Iteration final - PROBLEM_DESCRIPTION
Sequence: 7
Timestamp: 2025-07-28 00:04:59

Prompt:
You are a business analyst creating structured optimization problem documentation.

DATA SOURCES EXPLANATION:
- FINAL OR ANALYSIS: Final converged optimization problem from alternating process (iteration 2), contains business context and schema mapping evaluation
- DATABASE SCHEMA: Current database structure after iterative adjustments  
- DATA DICTIONARY: Business meanings and optimization roles of tables and columns
- CURRENT STORED VALUES: Realistic business data generated by triple expert (business + data + optimization)
- BUSINESS CONFIGURATION: Scalar parameters and business logic formulas separated from table data

CRITICAL REQUIREMENTS: 
- Ensure problem description naturally leads to LINEAR or MIXED-INTEGER optimization formulation
- Make business context consistent with the intended decision variables and objectives
- Align constraint descriptions with expected mathematical constraints
- Ensure data descriptions map clearly to expected coefficient sources
- Maintain business authenticity while fixing mathematical consistency issues
- Avoid business scenarios that would naturally require nonlinear relationships (variable products, divisions, etc.)

AUTO-EXTRACTED CONTEXT REQUIREMENTS:
- Business decisions match expected decision variables: x[pID] where x[pID] is a binary variable indicating if player pID is selected (1) or not (0)
- Operational parameters align with expected linear objective: minimize total_yellow_cards = ∑(yCard[pID] * x[pID])
- Business configuration includes: Maximum number of players that can be selected from a single college (used for Used to enforce diversity in player selection)
- Business logic formulas to express in natural language: Number of players required for each position (calculation method for Ensures each position is filled with the required number of players)
- Use natural language to precisely describe linear mathematical relationships
- NO mathematical formulas, equations, or symbolic notation
- Present data as current operational information
- Focus on precise operational decision-making that leads to linear formulations
- Resource limitations match expected linear constraints
- Avoid scenarios requiring variable products, divisions, or other nonlinear relationships
- Include specific operational parameters that map to expected coefficient sources
- Reference business configuration parameters where appropriate

FINAL OR ANALYSIS:
{
  "database_id": "soccer_2",
  "iteration": 2,
  "business_context": "A soccer league is organizing tryouts for players from various colleges. The goal is to select players for different positions while minimizing the total number of yellow cards among selected players, ensuring that each position is filled and that players are selected from a diverse set of colleges.",
  "optimization_problem_description": "Optimize the selection of players for different positions in a soccer team to minimize the total number of yellow cards among selected players. Ensure that each position is filled and that players are selected from a diverse set of colleges.",
  "optimization_formulation": {
    "objective": "minimize total_yellow_cards = \u2211(yCard[pID] * x[pID])",
    "decision_variables": "x[pID] where x[pID] is a binary variable indicating if player pID is selected (1) or not (0)",
    "constraints": [
      "\u2211(x[pID] | pPos = position) = required_players for each position",
      "\u2211(x[pID] | cName = college) \u2264 max_players for each college"
    ]
  },
  "current_optimization_to_schema_mapping": {
    "objective_coefficients": {
      "yCard[pID]": {
        "currently_mapped_to": "Tryout.yCard",
        "mapping_adequacy": "good",
        "description": "Number of yellow cards for player pID"
      }
    },
    "constraint_bounds": {
      "required_players[position]": {
        "currently_mapped_to": "PositionRequirements.required_players",
        "mapping_adequacy": "good",
        "description": "Number of players required for each position"
      },
      "max_players[college]": {
        "currently_mapped_to": "CollegeLimits.max_players",
        "mapping_adequacy": "good",
        "description": "Maximum number of players allowed from each college"
      }
    },
    "decision_variables": {
      "x[pID]": {
        "currently_mapped_to": "Tryout.pID",
        "mapping_adequacy": "good",
        "description": "Binary variable indicating if player pID is selected",
        "variable_type": "binary"
      }
    }
  },
  "missing_optimization_requirements": [],
  "iteration_status": {
    "complete": true,
    "confidence": "high",
    "next_focus": "Ready for convergence"
  }
}

FINAL DATABASE SCHEMA:
```sql
-- Iteration 2 Database Schema
-- Objective: Schema adjustments were made to incorporate missing yellow card data and improve optimization mapping. Configuration logic was updated to include scalar parameters and formulas.

CREATE TABLE Tryout (
  pID INTEGER,
  pPos STRING,
  cName STRING,
  yCard INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE PositionRequirements (
  position STRING,
  required_players INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE CollegeLimits (
  college STRING,
  max_players INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE PlayerYellowCards (
  pID INTEGER,
  yCard INTEGER
);


```

CURRENT STORED VALUES:
```sql
-- Iteration 2 Realistic Data
-- Generated by triple expert (business + data + optimization)
-- Values were determined based on typical soccer team compositions and college diversity requirements, ensuring a balance between player skill (yellow cards) and team needs (positions and college representation).

-- Realistic data for Tryout
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (1, 'Goalkeeper', 'College A', 0);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (2, 'Defender', 'College B', 1);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (3, 'Midfielder', 'College C', 2);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (4, 'Forward', 'College A', 1);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (5, 'Defender', 'College B', 0);

-- Realistic data for PositionRequirements
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Goalkeeper', 1);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Defender', 4);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Midfielder', 4);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Forward', 2);

-- Realistic data for CollegeLimits
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College A', 3);
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College B', 3);
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College C', 3);

-- Realistic data for PlayerYellowCards
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (1, 0);
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (2, 1);
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (3, 2);


```

DATA DICTIONARY:
{
  "tables": {
    "Tryout": {
      "business_purpose": "Stores tryout data for players",
      "optimization_role": "decision_variables",
      "columns": {
        "pID": {
          "data_type": "INTEGER",
          "business_meaning": "Unique identifier for each player",
          "optimization_purpose": "Used as decision variable index",
          "sample_values": "1, 2, 3"
        },
        "pPos": {
          "data_type": "STRING",
          "business_meaning": "Position the player is trying out for",
          "optimization_purpose": "Used in position constraints",
          "sample_values": "Goalkeeper, Defender, Midfielder, Forward"
        },
        "cName": {
          "data_type": "STRING",
          "business_meaning": "College the player is from",
          "optimization_purpose": "Used in college constraints",
          "sample_values": "College A, College B, College C"
        },
        "yCard": {
          "data_type": "INTEGER",
          "business_meaning": "Number of yellow cards for the player",
          "optimization_purpose": "Used in the objective function to minimize yellow cards",
          "sample_values": "0, 1, 2"
        }
      }
    },
    "PositionRequirements": {
      "business_purpose": "Defines player requirements for each position",
      "optimization_role": "constraint_bounds",
      "columns": {
        "position": {
          "data_type": "STRING",
          "business_meaning": "Position name",
          "optimization_purpose": "Defines position constraints",
          "sample_values": "Goalkeeper, Defender, Midfielder, Forward"
        },
        "required_players": {
          "data_type": "INTEGER",
          "business_meaning": "Number of players required for the position",
          "optimization_purpose": "Ensures each position is filled",
          "sample_values": "1, 4, 4, 2"
        }
      }
    },
    "CollegeLimits": {
      "business_purpose": "Defines limits on player selection from each college",
      "optimization_role": "constraint_bounds",
      "columns": {
        "college": {
          "data_type": "STRING",
          "business_meaning": "College name",
          "optimization_purpose": "Defines college constraints",
          "sample_values": "College A, College B, College C"
        },
        "max_players": {
          "data_type": "INTEGER",
          "business_meaning": "Maximum number of players allowed from the college",
          "optimization_purpose": "Ensures diversity in player selection",
          "sample_values": "3"
        }
      }
    },
    "PlayerYellowCards": {
      "business_purpose": "Stores the number of yellow cards for each player",
      "optimization_role": "objective_coefficients",
      "columns": {
        "pID": {
          "data_type": "INTEGER",
          "business_meaning": "Unique identifier for each player",
          "optimization_purpose": "Links yellow card data to players",
          "sample_values": "1, 2, 3"
        },
        "yCard": {
          "data_type": "INTEGER",
          "business_meaning": "Number of yellow cards for the player",
          "optimization_purpose": "Used in the objective function to minimize yellow cards",
          "sample_values": "0, 1, 2"
        }
      }
    }
  }
}


BUSINESS CONFIGURATION:

BUSINESS CONFIGURATION:
{
  "max_players_per_college": {
    "data_type": "INTEGER",
    "business_meaning": "Maximum number of players that can be selected from a single college",
    "optimization_role": "Used to enforce diversity in player selection",
    "configuration_type": "scalar_parameter",
    "value": 3,
    "business_justification": "This value ensures diversity by preventing over-representation from any single college."
  },
  "players_required_per_position": {
    "data_type": "STRING",
    "business_meaning": "Number of players required for each position",
    "optimization_role": "Ensures each position is filled with the required number of players",
    "configuration_type": "business_logic_formula",
    "formula_expression": "Goalkeeper: 1, Defender: 4, Midfielder: 4, Forward: 2"
  }
}

Business Configuration Design: 
Our system separates business logic design from value determination:
- Configuration Logic (business_configuration_logic.json): Templates designed by data engineers with sample_value for scalars and actual formulas for business logic
- Configuration Values (business_configuration.json): Realistic values determined by domain experts for scalar parameters only
- Design Rationale: Ensures business logic consistency while allowing flexible parameter tuning


TASK: Create structured markdown documentation for SECTIONS 1-3 ONLY (Problem Description).

EXACT MARKDOWN STRUCTURE TO FOLLOW:

# Complete Optimization Problem and Solution: soccer_2

## 1. Problem Context and Goals

### Context  
[Regenerate business context that naturally aligns with LINEAR optimization formulation. Ensure:]
- Business decisions match expected decision variables: x[pID] where x[pID] is a binary variable indicating if player pID is selected (1) or not (0)
- Operational parameters align with expected linear objective: minimize total_yellow_cards = ∑(yCard[pID] * x[pID])
- Business configuration includes: Maximum number of players that can be selected from a single college (used for Used to enforce diversity in player selection)
- Business logic formulas to express in natural language: Number of players required for each position (calculation method for Ensures each position is filled with the required number of players)
- Use natural language to precisely describe linear mathematical relationships
- NO mathematical formulas, equations, or symbolic notation
- Present data as current operational information
- Focus on precise operational decision-making that leads to linear formulations
- Resource limitations match expected linear constraints
- Avoid scenarios requiring variable products, divisions, or other nonlinear relationships
- Include specific operational parameters that map to expected coefficient sources
- Reference business configuration parameters where appropriate
- CRITICAL: Include ALL business configuration information (scalar parameters AND business logic formulas) in natural business language

### Goals  
[Regenerate goals that clearly lead to LINEAR mathematical objective:]
- Optimization goal: minimize
- Metric to optimize: minimize total_yellow_cards = ∑(yCard[pID] * x[pID])
- Success measurement aligned with expected coefficient sources
- Use natural language to precisely describe linear optimization goal
- NO mathematical formulas, equations, or symbolic notation

## 2. Constraints    

[Regenerate constraints that directly match expected LINEAR mathematical constraints:]
- Expected constraint: ['∑(x[pID] | pPos = position) = required_players for each position', '∑(x[pID] | cName = college) ≤ max_players for each college'] (Form: Standard constraint form based on business requirements)

[Each constraint should be described in business terms that naturally lead to LINEAR mathematical forms (no variable products or divisions)]

## 3. Available Data  

### Database Schema  
```sql
-- Iteration 2 Database Schema
-- Objective: Schema adjustments were made to incorporate missing yellow card data and improve optimization mapping. Configuration logic was updated to include scalar parameters and formulas.

CREATE TABLE Tryout (
  pID INTEGER,
  pPos STRING,
  cName STRING,
  yCard INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE PositionRequirements (
  position STRING,
  required_players INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE CollegeLimits (
  college STRING,
  max_players INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE PlayerYellowCards (
  pID INTEGER,
  yCard INTEGER
);


```

### Data Dictionary  
[Create comprehensive business-oriented data dictionary mapping tables and columns to their business purposes and optimization roles - NOT technical database terms. Base this on the data_dictionary provided but rewrite in business language that clearly connects to the expected linear mathematical formulation]

### Current Stored Values  
```sql
-- Iteration 2 Realistic Data
-- Generated by triple expert (business + data + optimization)
-- Values were determined based on typical soccer team compositions and college diversity requirements, ensuring a balance between player skill (yellow cards) and team needs (positions and college representation).

-- Realistic data for Tryout
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (1, 'Goalkeeper', 'College A', 0);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (2, 'Defender', 'College B', 1);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (3, 'Midfielder', 'College C', 2);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (4, 'Forward', 'College A', 1);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (5, 'Defender', 'College B', 0);

-- Realistic data for PositionRequirements
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Goalkeeper', 1);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Defender', 4);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Midfielder', 4);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Forward', 2);

-- Realistic data for CollegeLimits
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College A', 3);
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College B', 3);
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College C', 3);

-- Realistic data for PlayerYellowCards
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (1, 0);
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (2, 1);
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (3, 2);


```

STOP HERE - Do not include section 4 (Mathematical Optimization Formulation).

Response:
# Complete Optimization Problem and Solution: soccer_2

## 1. Problem Context and Goals

### Context  
The soccer league is organizing tryouts to select players from various colleges for different positions on a team. The primary decision involves determining whether each player should be selected, represented by a binary decision variable for each player. The objective is to minimize the total number of yellow cards among the selected players. This selection process must ensure that each position on the team is filled with the required number of players. Additionally, to promote diversity, there is a limit on the number of players that can be selected from any single college. The maximum number of players allowed from a single college is a critical parameter in this process. The number of players required for each position is specified to ensure that all positions are adequately filled. These requirements are expressed in a way that naturally aligns with linear optimization, focusing on precise decision-making without involving complex mathematical operations like products or divisions.

### Goals  
The goal of this optimization problem is to minimize the total number of yellow cards among the selected players. The metric used to achieve this goal is the sum of yellow cards for all selected players. Success in this context is measured by achieving the lowest possible total of yellow cards while adhering to the constraints of filling each position and maintaining college diversity. The optimization goal is clearly defined in linear terms, focusing on minimizing the sum of yellow cards associated with the selected players.

## 2. Constraints    

The constraints for this optimization problem are designed to ensure that the team composition meets specific requirements:

- For each position on the team, the number of selected players must match the required number of players for that position. This ensures that all positions are adequately filled.
- To maintain diversity, the number of players selected from any single college must not exceed the maximum allowed. This constraint ensures that no single college is over-represented in the team selection.

These constraints are expressed in business terms that naturally lead to linear mathematical forms, avoiding complex operations like variable products or divisions.

## 3. Available Data  

### Database Schema  
```sql
-- Iteration 2 Database Schema
-- Objective: Schema adjustments were made to incorporate missing yellow card data and improve optimization mapping. Configuration logic was updated to include scalar parameters and formulas.

CREATE TABLE Tryout (
  pID INTEGER,
  pPos STRING,
  cName STRING,
  yCard INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE PositionRequirements (
  position STRING,
  required_players INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE CollegeLimits (
  college STRING,
  max_players INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE PlayerYellowCards (
  pID INTEGER,
  yCard INTEGER
);
```

### Data Dictionary  
The data dictionary provides a comprehensive mapping of tables and columns to their business purposes and roles in the optimization process:

- **Tryout Table**: This table stores data about players participating in the tryouts. Each player is identified by a unique ID, and the table includes information about the position they are trying out for, the college they represent, and the number of yellow cards they have received. This table plays a crucial role in defining the decision variables for the optimization problem.

- **PositionRequirements Table**: This table defines the number of players required for each position on the team. It ensures that the constraints related to filling each position are met.

- **CollegeLimits Table**: This table specifies the maximum number of players that can be selected from each college. It is used to enforce diversity in player selection by limiting the representation from any single college.

- **PlayerYellowCards Table**: This table records the number of yellow cards for each player, linking this data to the players' unique IDs. It is used in the objective function to minimize the total number of yellow cards among selected players.

### Current Stored Values  
```sql
-- Iteration 2 Realistic Data
-- Generated by triple expert (business + data + optimization)
-- Values were determined based on typical soccer team compositions and college diversity requirements, ensuring a balance between player skill (yellow cards) and team needs (positions and college representation).

-- Realistic data for Tryout
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (1, 'Goalkeeper', 'College A', 0);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (2, 'Defender', 'College B', 1);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (3, 'Midfielder', 'College C', 2);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (4, 'Forward', 'College A', 1);
INSERT INTO Tryout (pID, pPos, cName, yCard) VALUES (5, 'Defender', 'College B', 0);

-- Realistic data for PositionRequirements
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Goalkeeper', 1);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Defender', 4);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Midfielder', 4);
INSERT INTO PositionRequirements (position, required_players) VALUES ('Forward', 2);

-- Realistic data for CollegeLimits
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College A', 3);
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College B', 3);
INSERT INTO CollegeLimits (college, max_players) VALUES ('College C', 3);

-- Realistic data for PlayerYellowCards
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (1, 0);
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (2, 1);
INSERT INTO PlayerYellowCards (pID, yCard) VALUES (3, 2);
```
