=== Problem Context ===
# Complete Optimization Problem and Solution: flight_4

## 1. Problem Context and Goals

### Context  
The business problem revolves around optimizing the assignment of airlines to specific routes to minimize total operational costs while ensuring all required destinations are covered and no airline exceeds its capacity. The decision to assign an airline to a route is represented as a binary choice, where each route must be assigned to exactly one airline. The operational cost of assigning an airline to a route is a key factor in this decision, and it is calculated using a formula that includes base operational costs, distance-based costs, fuel costs, and fuel efficiency. Additionally, a threshold for operational efficiency is set to ensure that airlines maintain high performance standards. This threshold is used to evaluate airline performance but does not directly influence the optimization constraints. The problem is designed to avoid nonlinear relationships, ensuring that all calculations and constraints remain linear and straightforward.

### Goals  
The primary goal of this optimization is to minimize the total operational cost associated with assigning airlines to routes. This is achieved by summing the costs of all assignments, where each assignment is weighted by its corresponding operational cost. Success is measured by achieving the lowest possible total cost while ensuring that all routes are covered and no airline is assigned more routes than it can handle. The optimization process relies on precise operational data, including the costs of assignments and the capacities of airlines, to make informed decisions that align with business objectives.

## 2. Constraints    

The optimization problem is subject to two key constraints:  
1. **Route Coverage**: Each route must be assigned to exactly one airline. This ensures that all required destinations are covered without redundancy.  
2. **Airline Capacity**: No airline can be assigned more routes than its specified capacity. This ensures that airlines operate within their operational limits and maintain efficiency.  

These constraints are designed to be linear and straightforward, avoiding any complex relationships or nonlinear calculations. They directly align with the business requirements and ensure that the optimization problem remains solvable and meaningful.

## 3. Available Data  

### Database Schema  
```sql
-- Iteration 2 Database Schema
-- Objective: Added decision variable table assign_airline_route to address missing optimization requirement. Updated business configuration logic with additional scalar parameters and formulas.

CREATE TABLE cost_airline_route (
  alid INTEGER,
  rid INTEGER,
  cost FLOAT
);

CREATE TABLE capacity_airline (
  alid INTEGER,
  capacity INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE assign_airline_route (
  alid INTEGER,
  rid INTEGER,
  assign BOOLEAN
);
```

### Data Dictionary  
- **cost_airline_route**: This table contains the operational costs associated with assigning specific airlines to specific routes. Each record includes the airline ID, route ID, and the cost of the assignment. The cost is used as a coefficient in the optimization objective function.  
- **capacity_airline**: This table defines the maximum number of routes each airline can handle. It includes the airline ID and its corresponding capacity, which serves as an upper bound in the capacity constraint.  
- **assign_airline_route**: This table represents the decision variables in the optimization problem. Each record indicates whether a specific airline is assigned to a specific route, using a binary value (true or false).  


=== Schema ===
-- Iteration 2 Database Schema
-- Objective: Added decision variable table assign_airline_route to address missing optimization requirement. Updated business configuration logic with additional scalar parameters and formulas.

CREATE TABLE cost_airline_route (
  alid INTEGER,
  rid INTEGER,
  cost FLOAT
);

CREATE TABLE capacity_airline (
  alid INTEGER,
  capacity INTEGER
);

CREATE TABLE assign_airline_route (
  alid INTEGER,
  rid INTEGER,
  assign BOOLEAN
);



=== LLM Response ===
```sql
-- Query Description: Retrieve all operational costs for assigning airlines to routes. 
-- This data is crucial for the objective function, as it provides the coefficients for minimizing total operational costs.
SELECT alid, rid, cost 
FROM cost_airline_route;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the capacity of each airline. 
-- This data is essential for the capacity constraint, ensuring no airline is assigned more routes than it can handle.
SELECT alid, capacity 
FROM capacity_airline;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the current assignments of airlines to routes. 
-- This data represents the decision variables in the optimization problem, indicating whether an airline is assigned to a route.
SELECT alid, rid, assign 
FROM assign_airline_route;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the total number of routes each airline is currently assigned to. 
-- This aggregated data helps in evaluating the capacity constraint by comparing the number of assigned routes to the airline's capacity.
SELECT alid, COUNT(rid) AS assigned_routes 
FROM assign_airline_route 
WHERE assign = TRUE 
GROUP BY alid;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the total operational cost for each airline based on current assignments. 
-- This aggregated data helps in understanding the current cost distribution among airlines, which is useful for optimization.
SELECT aar.alid, SUM(car.cost) AS total_cost 
FROM assign_airline_route aar 
JOIN cost_airline_route car ON aar.alid = car.alid AND aar.rid = car.rid 
WHERE aar.assign = TRUE 
GROUP BY aar.alid;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the list of routes that are not currently assigned to any airline. 
-- This data is important for ensuring the route coverage constraint, as it identifies routes that need to be assigned.
SELECT rid 
FROM cost_airline_route 
WHERE rid NOT IN (SELECT rid FROM assign_airline_route WHERE assign = TRUE);

-- Query Description: Retrieve the operational cost and capacity for each airline. 
-- This combined data helps in evaluating both the cost and capacity constraints simultaneously.
SELECT car.alid, car.rid, car.cost, ca.capacity 
FROM cost_airline_route car 
JOIN capacity_airline ca ON car.alid = ca.alid;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the total operational cost for each route based on current assignments. 
-- This aggregated data helps in understanding the cost impact of each route, which is useful for optimization.
SELECT aar.rid, SUM(car.cost) AS total_cost 
FROM assign_airline_route aar 
JOIN cost_airline_route car ON aar.alid = car.alid AND aar.rid = car.rid 
WHERE aar.assign = TRUE 
GROUP BY aar.rid;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the list of airlines that are currently underutilized (i.e., assigned fewer routes than their capacity). 
-- This data helps in identifying airlines that can take on additional routes, which is useful for optimization.
SELECT ca.alid, ca.capacity, COUNT(aar.rid) AS assigned_routes 
FROM capacity_airline ca 
LEFT JOIN assign_airline_route aar ON ca.alid = aar.alid AND aar.assign = TRUE 
GROUP BY ca.alid, ca.capacity 
HAVING COUNT(aar.rid) < ca.capacity;

-- Query Description: Retrieve the list of airlines that are currently at full capacity (i.e., assigned routes equal to their capacity). 
-- This data helps in identifying airlines that cannot take on additional routes, which is useful for optimization.
SELECT ca.alid, ca.capacity, COUNT(aar.rid) AS assigned_routes 
FROM capacity_airline ca 
LEFT JOIN assign_airline_route aar ON ca.alid = aar.alid AND aar.assign = TRUE 
GROUP BY ca.alid, ca.capacity 
HAVING COUNT(aar.rid) = ca.capacity;
```

These queries are designed to retrieve the most relevant data for the optimization problem, including operational costs, airline capacities, current assignments, and aggregated statistics. This data will be essential for formulating and solving the optimization problem to minimize total operational costs while adhering to the constraints of route coverage and airline capacity.
