| Year | Winner | Hometown | College |
|---|
| 2008 | Ashley Brasovan | Wellington , FL | Duke |
| 2009 | Jordan Hasay | San Luis Obispo , CA | Oregon |
| 2010 | Megan Goethals | Rochester Hills , MI | Washington |
| 2011 | Aisling Cuffe | Cornwall , NY | Stanford |
| 2012 | Molly Seidel | Hartland , WI | Notre Dame |
| 2013 | Sara Baxter | Simi Valley , CA | Oregon |
| 2014 | Alexa Efraimson | Camas , WA | |
| 2015 | Anna Rohrer | Mishawaka , IN | Notre Dame |
| 2016 | Katie Rainsberger | Colorado Springs , CO | Oregon |
| 2017 | Brie Oakley | Aurora , CO | California |
| 2018 | Katelyn Tuohy | Thiells , NY | |
| 2019 | Katelyn Tuohy | Thiells , NY | |