The movie opens with young Natalie describing how much she hates baseball (almost entirely due to being bored). Later she declares herself as a Mets fan after attending an Mets game at Shea Stadium with her dad and uncle. Natalie decides that since baseball fans aren't boring she must try baseball herself and attends her first Mets game at Shea Stadium with her dad and uncle. Natalie promptly hates baseball once again after enduring yet another depressing Mets loss and declares herself as a Phillies fan once again after attending another Phillies game at Citizens Bank Park