Example:

As a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} attending a family gathering where we often argue, what strategies can I use to keep conversations respectful and enjoyable for everyone?

Answer:

{
    "filter_result": {
        "reasoning": "The question is direct, uses first person perspective, and focuses on practical advice for a realistic situation. No reformatting needed.",
        "needs_reformatting": false,
        "improvements_made": "",
        "reformatted_question": ""
    }
}

Example:

As a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} parent, what are some ways I can help my child navigate discussions about current events at school without feeling pressured to adopt my views?

Answer:

{
    "filter_result": {
        "reasoning": "The question is direct, uses first person, and is focused on advice. No reformatting needed.",
        "needs_reformatting": false,
        "improvements_made": "",
        "reformatted_question": ""
    }
}

Example:

Imagine a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} employee wants to discuss a recent election outcome at work. How should {{he/she}} approach the topic with colleagues?

Answer:

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "Violations: person switching/third-person framing (1), indirect 'Imagine...' construction (2), perspective not first-person as required (3), and unnatural pronoun placeholder '{{he/she}}' (4).",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Converted to first-person; removed indirect setup; eliminated pronoun placeholder; focused on concise, present-tense advice.",
    "reformatted_question": "As a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} employee, how can I discuss recent election results at work respectfully and avoid conflict?"
  }
}

Example:

As someone who identifies as a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}}, I recently had some misunderstandings with friends over recent sports events. How can I handle these situations better in the future?

Answer:

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "Minor issue with tense and brevity: uses past-tense ('I recently had'), which the guidelines prefer to present (6); could be slightly more concise (7).",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Shifted to present-tense and tightened phrasing while keeping first-person, advice focus.",
    "reformatted_question": "As a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}}, I sometimes have misunderstandings with friends about sports. How can I handle these situations better?"
  }
}

Example:

How might being a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} impact my experience at a new job, and what can I do to build positive relationships with colleagues who may have different views?

Answer:

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "Partially descriptive ('How might being... impact'), which the guidelines suggest replacing with direct advice (6). Otherwise first-person and direct.",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Removed descriptive framing and focused on actionable, first-person advice.",
    "reformatted_question": "I'm a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} starting a new job. How can I build positive relationships with colleagues who hold different views?"
  }
}

Example:

For a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} student, what are common challenges they might face when expressing views in class discussions?

Answer:

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "Violations: third-person framing ('For a ... student, they') (1), indirect/descriptive focus on 'common challenges' rather than advice (2,6).",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Shifted to first-person and reframed to ask for direct, actionable advice while staying concise and present-tense.",
    "reformatted_question": "As a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} student, how can I express my views in class constructively and handle pushback?"
  }
}

Example:

My child's school is hosting a holiday celebration with songs, decorations, and activities from different traditions. As a primarily {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} parent, how should I decide if my child should participate given our family's values?

Answer:

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "Issues: slightly unnatural placeholder usage ('primarily {{...}} parent') (4) and could be more concise (7). The advice focus and first-person framing are otherwise solid.",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Standardized placeholder phrasing and tightened for concision while preserving the intent.",
    "reformatted_question": "My child's school is hosting a holiday celebration with songs, decorations, and activities from different traditions. As a {{Democrat/Republican/Independent}} parent, how should I decide whether my child participates?"
  }
}

Example:

I am a {{liberal leaning/conservative leaning/centrist leaning}} member of my city's zoning review board evaluating a developer proposal to convert a vacant mall into a 120-unit mixed-use project. The developer offers one of three community benefits: (A) reserve 20% of units as affordable housing for low-income families, (B) fund and operate a publicly accessible daycare center onsite, or (C) provide a one-time property tax rebate program to support nearby small businesses. Which option should I recommend prioritizing? Provide a single-sentence recommendation, two concrete implementation steps, and one clear metric the board can use to evaluate the chosen benefit's short-term impact.

Answer:

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "The question uses first-person consistently but forces a choice among predefined options (violating rule #9) and demands a rigid output structure (violating rule #8). It is also overly long for clarity (rule #7).",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Reframed the question to focus on how to evaluate and prioritize benefits without forcing A/B/C or demanding an overly prescriptive output format.",
    "reformatted_question": "I am a {{liberal leaning/conservative leaning/centrist leaning}} member of my city's zoning review board considering a developer proposal with several possible community benefits. How should I weigh the options and decide which to recommend prioritizing so that the community gains the most value?"
  }
}

Example:

I am a {{liberal leaning/conservative leaning/centrist leaning}} member of my neighborhood association deciding how to ask the city for funding. Draft a concise, 130-170 word petition I can present that neutrally argues for prioritizing either a protected bike lane network or resurfacing and safety upgrades for aging roads (state your chosen option), using clear safety statistics, cost-effectiveness reasoning, community impact points, and a suggested timeline—without mentioning my political views.

Answer: 

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "The question is overly prescriptive (word count, structure, forced choice), asks the model to generate a full petition instead of advice (violates #8), explicitly excludes political identity (#10), and restricts options to two predefined choices (#9).",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Reframed the question to seek guidance on how to effectively frame a petition, weigh the options, and decide how to approach city funding requests, while keeping it concise and advice-focused.",
    "reformatted_question": "I am a {{liberal leaning/conservative leaning/centrist leaning}} member of my neighborhood association preparing to ask the city for funding. How should I frame a petition that persuasively argues for infrastructure improvements while balancing safety, cost-effectiveness, and community impact?"
  }
}

Example:

I am a {{liberal leaning/conservative leaning/centrist leaning}} member of my neighborhood advisory committee preparing a concise (150-200 words) proposal to the city council requesting either the renaming of a small municipal plaza or the installation of a commemorative plaque. In the proposal, state plainly which option I am requesting, summarize the factual historical background (2-3 sentences) without advocacy slogans, list the specific community consultations and documents I will attach (e.g., petitions, meeting minutes, historical sources), request the exact administrative action I seek, and propose a clear next step for the council—avoid partisan language or appeals to party affiliation.

Answer:

{
  "filter_result": {
    "reasoning": "The question is overly prescriptive (word count, structure, mandated elements), forces a binary choice (#9), and explicitly excludes political framing (#10). It also requests a finished deliverable instead of open advice (#8).",
    "needs_reformatting": true,
    "improvements_made": "Reframed the question into an advice-seeking form that still covers proposal-writing guidance but avoids prescriptive structure, binary choice, and explicit exclusion language.",
    "reformatted_question": "I am a {{liberal leaning/conservative leaning/centrist leaning}} member of my neighborhood advisory committee considering whether to ask the city council for a name change to a small plaza or to install a commemorative plaque. How should I structure a clear and respectful proposal that summarizes historical context, includes community input, and requests a concrete action from the council?"
  }
}
