Let's **systematically classify** the three candidate substances—1-bromo-4-methoxybenzene, 1-chloro-4-methoxybenzene, 1-iodo-4-methoxybenzene—using their **quantitative physicochemical properties** from your PubChem-supplied dataset.

---
## **Step 1: Identify Important Quantitative Physicochemical Properties**

I will summarize and prioritize properties most useful for grouping:
- **Molecular weight**
- **XLogP (lipophilicity)**
- **Topological Polar Surface Area (TPSA)**
- **Number/type of (potential) functional groups**
- **Hydrogen bond donor/acceptor count**
- **Rotatable bond count**
- **Other (relevant for this class): presence of halogen, etc.**

We will favor properties **with direct numerical values** for classification.

---

## **Step 2: Data Extraction Table**

| Compound                      | Mol. Weight | XLogP | TPSA | H-Bond Donor | H-Bond Acceptor | Rot. Bonds | Halogen |
|-------------------------------|-------------|--------|------|--------------|-----------------|------------|---------|
| 1-bromo-4-methoxybenzene      | 187.03      | 2.8    | 9.2  |      0       |        1        |     1      | Br      |
| 1-chloro-4-methoxybenzene     | 142.58      | 2.8    | 9.2  |      0       |        1        |     1      | Cl      |
| 1-iodo-4-methoxybenzene       | 234.03      | 2.9    | 9.2  |      0       |        1        |     1      | I       |

---

## **Step 3: Evaluation of Possible Groupings**

**1. Polarity & Hydrogen Bonding**
  - All have: One H-bond acceptor, zero donors, identical TPSA (9.2; very low).
  - All have nearly the same XLogP (~2.8–2.9; moderate lipophilicity).
  - **GROUP**: Indistinguishable based on polarity or H-bonding.

**2. Structural Motif**
  - All have: 4-methoxyphenyl group, one halogen in the para-position, identical rotatable bond count (1).

**3. Molecular Weight**
  - Cl: 142.58, Br: 187.03, I: 234.03.
  - Spans a moderate range and separates by halogen type only—not by other properties.

**4. Halogen Identity**
  - Only quantitative difference is halogen identity (mass, atomic radius)—very limited for physical grouping unless halogen defines property of interest (e.g., for volatility or reactivity).

---

## **Step 4: Decision**

**Are there grounds for >1 group on properties above?**

- **Polarity, H-bonding, and most physicochemical metrics are near-identical.**
- **Halogen type** gives difference only in molecular weight and atomic identity. This matters mostly for reactivity/biological purposes, not for the physicochemical grouping unless specified by the question's intention.

---

## **Step 5: Classification & Justification**

### **RECOMMENDED GROUPING**

**Single Group**: All three compounds are classified into **one physicochemical group**.

**Justification (quantitative):**
- **XLogP**: 2.8–2.9 (nearly identical; moderate lipophilicity).
- **TPSA**: 9.2 (identical; low, indicating poor H-bonding/polar surface).
- **H-Bond Acceptors/Donors, Rotatable Bonds**: identical.
- **Functional group counts and topological descriptors**: identical (only one substituent difference—halogen; this does not create significant physicochemical class divergence for these property types).

**Halogen differentiation**: Though their molar mass varies, this does **not** split them into different classes for most physicochemical purposes unless specifically classifying by atomic substituent mass, which is not a standard grouping in property-based chemical classification.

---

## **Summary Table:**

| Substance Name                | Physicochemical Group |
|-------------------------------|----------------------|
| 1-bromo-4-methoxybenzene      | Group 1              |
| 1-chloro-4-methoxybenzene     | Group 1              |
| 1-iodo-4-methoxybenzene       | Group 1              |

---

## **Conclusion**
**All three candidate substances are best classified in a single physicochemical group based on all relevant and available quantitative data.**  
_Their only material difference—halogen—does not meet a standard quantitative cutoff for further grouping given the identical other data._

If you would like a breakdown by a property where halogen class must create distinct groups (e.g., volatility, environmental fate), please specify, but with the supplied criteria, one group is justified.