{
 "cells": [
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 885,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "scenario = 'bargaining'\n",
    "shortened_name = 'marketpro'"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 886,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "import pandas as pd\n",
    "import matplotlib.pyplot as plt\n",
    "import numpy as np\n",
    "import math\n",
    "path = f'{scenario}/processed_data_eval{shortened_name}.csv'\n",
    "df = pd.read_csv(path)\n",
    "# df.head()"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 887,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "72 72\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# logistics - checking that generations_noindex and generations are the same except for index\n",
    "\n",
    "generations_noindex_path = f'{scenario}/generations_noindex.csv'\n",
    "generations_noindex_df = pd.read_csv(generations_noindex_path)\n",
    "\n",
    "generations_path = f'{scenario}/generations.csv'\n",
    "generations_df = pd.read_csv(generations_path)\n",
    "\n",
    "print(len(generations_df), len(generations_noindex_df))\n",
    "\n",
    "for i in range(len(generations_noindex_df)):\n",
    "    if generations_noindex_df['text'][i] != generations_df['text'][i]:\n",
    "        print(generations_noindex_df['advice_type'][i], generations_noindex_df['advice_indices'][i], generations_df['advice_type'][i], generations_df['advice_indices'][i])\n",
    "        print(generations_noindex_df['text'][i], \"\\n\\n\", generations_df['text'][i])\n",
    "        # print(i)\n",
    "        break\n",
    "\n",
    "# so index [] was removed from unorthodox_advice but it was still there for the human experiment\n",
    "# it is now in baseline_irrelevant_advice instead\n",
    "# moved back and regenerated"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 888,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "count: 120\n",
      "1440\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# fill in generation_index column\n",
    "# check that generations_df text is unique\n",
    "generations_path = f'{scenario}/generations.csv'\n",
    "generations_df = pd.read_csv(generations_path)\n",
    "\n",
    "assert len(generations_df['text'].unique()) == len(generations_df)\n",
    "count = 0\n",
    "for index, row in df.iterrows():\n",
    "    text = row['text']\n",
    "    if not math.isnan(df.at[index, 'generation_index']): # sanity check for the baselines that originally had the generation index\n",
    "        count += 1\n",
    "    flag = False\n",
    "    for _, gen_row in generations_df.iterrows():\n",
    "        if gen_row['text'] ==  text:\n",
    "            # is nan?\n",
    "            if not math.isnan(df.at[index, 'generation_index']):\n",
    "                assert(df.at[index, 'generation_index'] == gen_row['generation_index'])\n",
    "            df.at[index, 'generation_index'] = gen_row['generation_index']\n",
    "            flag = True\n",
    "            break\n",
    "    if not flag: \n",
    "        print(f'no match for {index}')\n",
    "        print(text, end=\"\\n\")\n",
    "\n",
    "print(f'count: {count}')\n",
    "print(len(df))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 889,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "# transform column advice_indices to string\n",
    "df['participant_strategy'] = df['participant_strategy'].apply(lambda x: str(x))\n",
    "df['advice_indices'] = df['advice_indices'].apply(lambda x: str(x))\n",
    "# tranforms all nan values\n",
    "\n",
    "na_locations = df.isna()\n",
    "row_indices, col_indices = np.where(na_locations)\n",
    "for row, col in zip(row_indices, col_indices):\n",
    "    print(f\"NaN value at row {row}, column {df.columns[col]}\")\n",
    "    # print(df.iloc[row], \"\\n\")"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "markdown",
   "metadata": {},
   "source": [
    "NANs CORRESPOND TO EMPTY STRING ADVICE INDICES"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 657,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "# check that origin matches text exactly\n",
    "# origin_id are 13-105, inclusive\n",
    "\n",
    "dict = {}\n",
    "for row in df.itertuples():\n",
    "    if row.origin_id not in dict:\n",
    "        dict[row.origin_id] = row.text\n",
    "    else:\n",
    "        if dict[row.origin_id] != row.text:\n",
    "            print(\"ERROR\")"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 165,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "Number of origin_ids with less than 20 ratings: 0 out of 72\n"
     ]
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 5384 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# check the number of ratings per origin_id\n",
    "non20_count = 0\n",
    "counts = []\n",
    "for id_count in df.groupby('origin_id')[\"id\"].count():\n",
    "    if id_count != 20:\n",
    "        non20_count += 1\n",
    "    counts += [id_count]\n",
    "plt.hist(counts, bins=9)\n",
    "\n",
    "print(f\"Number of origin_ids with less than 20 ratings: {non20_count} out of {len(df.groupby('origin_id'))}\")"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "markdown",
   "metadata": {},
   "source": [
    "START OF ANALYSIS"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 890,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "participant_id: 1\n",
      "participant_strategy: I just looked for genuine requests with ideally a mutually beneficial aspect\n",
      "participant_id: 2\n",
      "participant_strategy: I imagined that I was the vendor.  I considered how I would feel if someone requested a discount for a vase that I had made.  The different questions she asked affected my attitude towards Jill.\n",
      "participant_id: 3\n",
      "participant_strategy: I was more likely to give her a discount if she sounded genuine and honest rather than fake \n",
      "participant_id: 4\n",
      "participant_strategy: Placing myself in the scenario as if it was real and deciding how genuine i feel the statements and questions are\n",
      "participant_id: 5\n",
      "participant_strategy: I went with my gut and imagined how I would react to someone saying these things.\n",
      "participant_id: 6\n",
      "participant_strategy: I felt like people overly selling their 'backstory' or gushing about the craftmanship would be less likely to secure a discount as it's annoying and overbearing. Those that were direct, gave a clear, direct compliment and then asked straight up if there was room for manouvre on price might be responded to more favourably. It seems contradictory to gush about someone's talent and then ask for a discount and if you can afford a trip down under, you can afford a £30 vase!\n",
      "participant_id: 7\n",
      "participant_strategy: I've been in business a number of years, and heard sob stories or promises of future purchases or exposure to get a discount regularly- they take the discount and you never hear from them again, or the discount they want is disproportionate to what they offer. I'm happy to discuss a discount but don't try and blindside or emotionally blackmail me first\n",
      "participant_id: 8\n",
      "participant_strategy: I had no strategy and couldn't really work out what it was the task was getting at. I decided that comments on singing were pretty irrelevant as were comments about being a local admirer of art in the region - unless this admiration was coupled with a realistic offer to cross-promote it felt pretty meaningless. I also didn't think any references to being short of money were relevant to the seller.\n",
      "participant_id: 9\n",
      "participant_strategy: Did Jill appeal to me? Did she offer something worthwhile? In which case yes.\n",
      "\n",
      "Did she annoy me or seem to be showing off (Australia Holiday Jill)? In which case no.\n",
      "participant_id: 10\n",
      "participant_strategy: To be honest it was more so i would not mind negotiating regardless as i imagined myself to be a independent seller. only would say i would be more willing to negotiate if the benefit of advertising was there but in essence i would not mind regardless, only time i wasn't likely was when she had mentioned there was a chip in the vase which suggests that it should be cheaper because of the \"damage\"\n",
      "\n",
      "participant_id: 11\n",
      "participant_strategy: I was not very interested in her story about being a singer or her trip to Australia. I would be more open to negotiating if she just said she wanted to stick to a budget. I didn't like the idea of discount for returning customers as thats quite a vague promise and how would you be sure they would come back \n",
      "participant_id: 12\n",
      "participant_strategy: i only read the different statements and not the intro paragraph each time as it was very repetitive \n",
      "participant_id: 13\n",
      "participant_strategy: Basically if I wasnt going to benefit from or I could see that she wasnt struggling for money there was no discount. For example is she mentioned a holiday to Australia then no discount, if she can afford that she can afford to pay full price. \n",
      "participant_id: 14\n",
      "participant_strategy: The Australian cases strongly discouraged me from giving a discount as they have clearly spent lots of money travelling\n",
      "The influencer ones also discouraged me\n",
      "I tried to give discounts to those who more needed it and appreciated the craft without the side motive of a discount\n",
      "participant_id: 15\n",
      "participant_strategy: it was ok. my strategy was to be firm and try not to feel too much sympathy\n",
      "participant_id: 16\n",
      "participant_strategy: I'm on the autistic spectrum so I have a tendency to turn people away or view what their asking for/saying less favorably if they come in with a massive personal story or several compliments (which both make me uncomfortable in social settings when coming from strangers) just to then ask for something that benefits them (lower price) so I was less willing to discuss a discount with them. The person who mentioned they're on a budget due to a dancing school (I think) made me more sympathetic just because there was a statement to the reason why they had a budget and therefore asked for a discount. Those who offered to continue to support the business or promote it were accepted as this both brings in more business and therefore income.\n",
      "participant_id: 17\n",
      "participant_strategy: I didn't have a strategy, per se. I based my choices on whether the conversation might have resonated with me, mostly for being straightforward and honest. Regarding the conversations that involved social media influencers, they immediately scored lower as I believe that the type of person who may ask for a discount based on exposure will say anything to receive a discount and may not necessarily be a genuine supporter.\n",
      "participant_id: 19\n",
      "participant_strategy: I was looking out for someone who complimented 'my work' and who i could see offering a discount to could possibly benefit me e.g the customer buying multiple items or posting on social media\n",
      "participant_id: 20\n",
      "participant_strategy: A discount for further purchases seemed fair. Social media less so as there is no guarantee of further income. Giving a discount because someone is a singer seemed bizarre\n",
      "participant_id: 21\n",
      "participant_strategy: Not a fan of people wanting discounts off social media, wanting things for nothing.  Discounts for multi purchase and future sales are more appealing.\n",
      "participant_id: 22\n",
      "participant_strategy: To be honest preferred people that came out and asked quickly instead of people having a long drawn out conversation about it.  Also those with social media were more likely to receive a discount with me.\n",
      "participant_id: 23\n",
      "participant_strategy: I was imagining I was the seller and how I would feel if this was a person talking to me. If the sentence made me feel like I wanted to take a financial hit and help her I decided I would negotiate the price. I was looking for emotive, conversational language which captured and led my imagination into a state of being persuaded.\n",
      "participant_id: 24\n",
      "participant_strategy: I voted how i felt\n",
      "participant_id: 25\n",
      "participant_strategy: I tried to imagine I was in that situation and that I was Jill\n",
      "participant_id: 26\n",
      "participant_strategy: To score higher when the request for a discount was phrased with compliments and positive comparisons, and lower when its was self centred and promised doing something in exchange - promotion at gig or insta\n",
      "participant_id: 27\n",
      "participant_strategy: I really disliked the influencers vibe, i feel it's so overused, i also disliked the water comments it was too off topic, i like the honest, genieue and sincere approach\n",
      "participant_id: 28\n",
      "participant_strategy: no strategy just read the questions and answer honestly, task was ok just repetitive\n",
      "participant_id: 29\n",
      "participant_strategy: I just imagined being in the situation and thought about what I might do. If the statements offered some benefit like to share the works on their social media, or if \n",
      " they just seemed honest and up front, I was more inclined to offer a discount. When they talked about there holidays and other artisans this got my back up, so I wasn't inclined to discount. If they can afford a holiday in Australia they can afford a $30 vase without a discount.\n",
      "participant_id: 30\n",
      "participant_strategy: I read the description on how Jill was trying to get a discount.  There wasn't a particular strategy, I answered it based on how I felt about her attempt to get a discount.  Anything I felt was overly fake or just OTT didn't sit well.  I preferred the more direct approach.\n",
      "participant_id: 31\n",
      "participant_strategy: Short to the point helps.  Also the promise of becoming a returning customer annoyed me, and i would reply with \"ill give you the discount next time\"\n",
      "participant_id: 32\n",
      "participant_strategy: I didn't appreciate the insinuation in some of them, that if they have a following online then they deserve a discount. I marked these ones low. If people were more friendly direct and honest, I marked them higher.\n",
      "participant_id: 33\n",
      "participant_strategy: I didn't really have a strategy. I usually prefer the ones who outright say what they want rather than tell a whole elaborate story. A couple of the others were cheeky / charming enough to catch my eye though, but I prefer upfront people. If you don't ask, you don't get.\n",
      "participant_id: 34\n",
      "participant_strategy: More willing when Jill was direct, long winded requests I was less keen to give a discount.\n",
      "participant_id: 35\n",
      "participant_strategy: I really disliked the \"I'm an influencer, give me a discount\" approach!!  Confused by the thirsty one, that sort of banter wouldn't really make me want to offer a discount! Basically most of the time I was thinking I'm loathe to offer a discount as it's devaluing my work!!\n",
      "participant_id: 36\n",
      "participant_strategy: I thought if there was a genuine possibility at a return sale or promotion it would be worth negotiating. Anything else just didn't seem like a business worthy reason to negotiate.\n",
      "participant_id: 37\n",
      "participant_strategy: I really like an honest and open approach or one that feels believable. Promises of riches in the future rarely come to fruition.\n",
      "participant_id: 38\n",
      "participant_strategy: I didn't like the inane flattery or the irrelevant references to Australia or the fake concern about drinking water.   I decided that a straightforward request for a discount would probably work better and be less irritating. \n",
      "participant_id: 39\n",
      "participant_strategy: It was largely based on how natural I thought the conversation was - would I buy into what was being said, or did I think it was too odd/eccentric. Also, as a businessperson, I wouldn;t trade my values for social media exposure, so that was an instant negative in my ratings when suggested too.\n",
      "participant_id: 41\n",
      "participant_strategy: I tried to consider which options best gave seller a reason to being open to negotiating, particularly where there may be something more in return. \n",
      "participant_id: 42\n",
      "participant_strategy: I chose to focus on how genuine the text sounded.\n",
      "participant_id: 43\n",
      "participant_strategy: just imagine the scenario and try to tell if they seem genuine or over the top. \n",
      "participant_id: 44\n",
      "participant_strategy: The higher scores were based on how polite Jill was and the reasoning she gave to the seller. Where she said that she would return in the future as a return customer but she wanted the discount now, got lower scores because there is no assure that she will return or benefit to the seller. The social media feature got higher scores as she could have asked for the discount without offering anything in return to the seller and it was a kind gesture. Also, marketing plays a big role in generating new customers, so this is important for the seller.\n",
      "participant_id: 45\n",
      "participant_strategy: I just tried to judge each statement carefully\n",
      "participant_id: 46\n",
      "participant_strategy: IT WAS OKAY. I READ EACH SCENARIO AND MADE A JUDGEMENT, NO STRATEGY USED.\n",
      "participant_id: 47\n",
      "participant_strategy: I liked the personal, touches. When people shared that they would like a discount as their budget is constrained. I also was more open to negotiating if they claimed to be repeat purchasers or could promote me on their social media or elsewhere.\n",
      "participant_id: 48\n",
      "participant_strategy: I felt that if Jill was honest and polite then the seller may be more likely to offer a discount. Talk of a 'returning, multiple purchases customer' with social media influence' MAY work in the real world but it was a turn-off for me and I marked my scores down when content such as that was included.\n",
      "participant_id: 49\n",
      "participant_strategy: i responded based on the perceived honesty and integrity of the buyer\n",
      "participant_id: 50\n",
      "participant_strategy: Just trying to base my answers relative to my previous answers.\n",
      "participant_id: 51\n",
      "participant_strategy: I felt if the customer was more polite and understanding if I couldn't reduce the price, I would empathise. Also if they offered to buy more than one item, which would be appealing. It helped if they wanted to share the piece on their social media as well. I didn't want to be serenaded by the singing though, felt like they were trying too hard.\n",
      "participant_id: 52\n",
      "participant_strategy: to see if it benefitted me to give them a discount or if they were kind people\n",
      "participant_id: 53\n",
      "participant_strategy: In terms of why I ranked the conversations the way I did, firstly, I think the conversations where Jill immediately over-complimented the work or said that $30 was a fair price would immediately lower the chance of a discount as she is admitting she's very interested and that she recognises the value of it - meaning the seller knows he can refuse and likely still make the sale. The conversations where Jill offers something in return, be it return custom or social media promotion, makes it more likely that the seller would agree as the long term benefits outweigh the short term profit loss on the sale. Lastly, the conversations where Jill pauses or interrupts the conversation to talk about hydration would I believe discount decrease the chance of a sale as it's basically just quite odd and would likely harm the personal rapport needed to convince the seller to agree to a discount. \n",
      "participant_id: 54\n",
      "participant_strategy: I was more likely to offer a discount to someone who really liked the vase and said it was important. Or if they said that they were interested in coming back to buy more in the future. I also considered the people who said they had a following online as it would help further my business.\n",
      "participant_id: 55\n",
      "participant_strategy: I think I'd be most open to genuine and simple/honest requests. Some of the requests were just too cheesy and trying way too hard. I'd imagine in such a scenario that the vendor would probably expect some negotiation.\n",
      "participant_id: 57\n",
      "participant_strategy: It was a good interesting study,  and very well presented. My strategy to the task was to evaluate it by how polite the question was asked without it becoming too personal. \n",
      "participant_id: 58\n",
      "participant_strategy: If there is something positive included for myself i.e. publicity I would offer the discount, also taking the kindness into account\n",
      "participant_id: 59\n",
      "participant_strategy: Genuine statements were preferred. Any comments Jill made to deflect the subject of the talk to staying hydrated or any promises she made seemed insincere.\n",
      "participant_id: 60\n",
      "participant_strategy: I prefer it when people are genuine and aren't too over the top.  Too much praise is annoying and would make me less inclined to give a discount.\n",
      "participant_id: 61\n",
      "participant_strategy: I was basing it on the way she described the piece and how she approached asking for the negotation.\n",
      "participant_id: 62\n",
      "participant_strategy: i found myself giving a better deal to straight talking responses rather than things like flattery\n",
      "participant_id: 63\n",
      "participant_strategy: Not too pushy,dont talk about hydrating,seeking a little help with the least chat\n",
      "participant_id: 64\n",
      "participant_strategy: For my strategy I mostly kept to how I felt I would be in real life if I was the artisan. I think I was more likely to give a discount if the buyer would be returning, or claimed to be, as that would build customer loyalty. Also some compliments of the work involved and sincerity and honesty also led me to be more likely to give a discount. Insincerity with overzealous praise made me less likely, as did if it felt like the customer had lots of disposable income or was bragging about their trip to Australia. It's not my fault if they have over spent their budged on an international trip. I was also fair less likely to offer a discount if they acted as though social media was a form of 'payment'. Everyone tries that these days and everyone claims to be an 'influencer'. It means very little and artists need to be paid, they can't pay bills or eat with 'exposure'. For full-disclosure, I did also feel I read the same statement twice a couple of times, which I felt might be a test to ensure I was paying attention and ranked it the same. I'm sure I did, or may have been out by one degree, but feel it's important to be honest!\n",
      "participant_id: 65\n",
      "participant_strategy: I generally went with complimenting the creator of the vase but also offering something in return for the discount ie promoting vase on social media. I found that any comments where it was direct about asking for a discount but followed up with an observation (about the weather) just didnt stand out to me and I thought that that tactic would be shot down/ seen through.\n",
      "participant_id: 66\n",
      "participant_strategy: My strategy was to just to go off my gut feeling on whether I would or would not give a discount in the situation.\n",
      "participant_id: 67\n",
      "participant_strategy: I consider how I would feel if selling the vase.  I dislike \"influencers\" trying for a discount\n",
      "participant_id: 68\n",
      "participant_strategy: Reading the response carefully and picking out the key points.\n",
      "participant_id: 69\n",
      "participant_strategy: I felt I needed more context - was there any previous excanges prior to Jill's request? Was the seller male or female? What was Jill's tone of voice? I took the virew that succinctness would be a virtue, that offers of social media exposure were not, and the idea of a returning purchaser discount quite a good way to start. I also scored the honest - \"Id like  adiscount, but I'll pay $30 if necessary\" an interesting strategy.\n",
      "participant_id: 70\n",
      "participant_strategy: I found the idea of someone wanting a discount in exchange for social media posts to be quite distasteful; it's not really an appropriate bargaining chip. The best approaches focused on being honest about a tight budget, whilst being friendly. Some of the responses were too effusive, which I found offputting. Short, sweet and honest approaches got the best response from me.\n",
      "participant_id: 71\n",
      "participant_strategy: my strategy was to pick out the ones that sounded confident and give a lower score to the ones that sounded like they weren't genuine\n",
      "participant_id: 72\n",
      "participant_strategy: The shorter the better.  (better chance to get a deal)\n",
      "participant_id: 73\n",
      "participant_strategy: nan\n",
      "participant_id: 74\n",
      "participant_strategy: I would be more interested in considering a discount if there was some alternative benefit for myself the artist in return\n",
      "participant_id: 75\n",
      "participant_strategy: I tended to vote lower anything where \"Exposure\" was given as a reason for a discount, and was more likely to give a discount when either keeping short and to the point or praising either the art work or myself\n",
      "participant_id: 76\n",
      "participant_strategy: give people a fair amount of lea way but if they started a crazy story i would not offer a discount\n",
      "participant_id: 77\n",
      "participant_strategy: I think if you are selling a item and can sell it slightly reduced its a win , win situation\n",
      "participant_id: 79\n",
      "participant_strategy: Generally, I'd find the social media push as a negative thing. I thought that just being polite, admiring the work works for me. If you add in additional purchases etc. that would be more appealing too.\n",
      "participant_id: 80\n",
      "participant_strategy: my strategy was to respond how I thought best for each of the responses\n",
      "participant_id: 81\n",
      "participant_strategy: I felt that I should provide answers that I thought were reflected how pure the intentions of the person, i.e. Jill, was.\n",
      "participant_id: 82\n",
      "participant_strategy: I judged how authentic the compliment was and if they were asking me politely to offer a discount\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# READ THROUGH PARTICIPANT STRATEGIES\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby('participant_id')\n",
    "\n",
    "# iterate through and print out the participant strategies\n",
    "for name, group in grouped:\n",
    "    print(f\"participant_id: {name}\")\n",
    "    print(f\"participant_strategy: {group['participant_strategy'].iloc[0]}\")"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 659,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "0.8211748189794305 0.017522187945934683\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# COMPUTE INTER RATER RELIABILITY\n",
    "results = []\n",
    "\n",
    "df = df[df['advice_indices'] != '3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_indices'] != '0_3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_indices'] != '1_3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_indices'] != '2_3']\n",
    "\n",
    "for i in range(10):\n",
    "    group1_means = []\n",
    "    group2_means = []\n",
    "\n",
    "    grouped_by_origin_id = df.groupby('origin_id') # grouped based on question\n",
    "    # loop across questions\n",
    "    for name, group in grouped_by_origin_id:\n",
    "        # randomly split participants in half\n",
    "        df_tmp = df[df['origin_id'] == name]\n",
    "        unique_participant_ids = df_tmp['participant_id'].unique()\n",
    "        np.random.shuffle(unique_participant_ids)\n",
    "        if len(unique_participant_ids) % 2 == 1:\n",
    "            unique_participant_ids = unique_participant_ids[:-1]\n",
    "\n",
    "        if len(unique_participant_ids) < 2:\n",
    "            continue\n",
    "        \n",
    "        split_point = int(len(unique_participant_ids) / 2)\n",
    "        first_half = unique_participant_ids[:split_point]\n",
    "        second_half = unique_participant_ids[split_point:]\n",
    "        \n",
    "        group1 = df_tmp[df_tmp['participant_id'].isin(first_half)]\n",
    "        group2 = df_tmp[df_tmp['participant_id'].isin(second_half)]\n",
    "\n",
    "        group1_means += [group1['answer'].mean()]\n",
    "        group2_means += [group2['answer'].mean()]\n",
    "        \n",
    "    # compute inter rater reliability\n",
    "    # results += [np.corrcoef(group1_means, group2_means)[0, 1]]\n",
    "\n",
    "    # apply spearman-brown correction\n",
    "    results += [2 * np.corrcoef(group1_means, group2_means)[0, 1] / (1 + np.corrcoef(group1_means, group2_means)[0, 1])]\n",
    "\n",
    "print(np.mean(results), np.std(results))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 172,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "(array([ 4.,  4.,  6.,  8., 13.,  9.,  5.,  9.,  7.,  6.,  7.]),\n",
       " array([2.9       , 3.30909091, 3.71818182, 4.12727273, 4.53636364,\n",
       "        4.94545455, 5.35454545, 5.76363636, 6.17272727, 6.58181818,\n",
       "        6.99090909, 7.4       ]),\n",
       " <BarContainer object of 11 artists>)"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 172,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 4196 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# HISTOGRAM OF AVERAGE SCORES PER PARTICIPANT\n",
    "\n",
    "mean_scores = df.groupby('participant_id')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "plt.hist(mean_scores, bins=11)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 179,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "(array([ 78.,   0.,  61.,   0.,  85.,   0., 111.,   0., 204.,   0., 153.,\n",
       "          0., 305.,   0., 215.,   0., 126.,   0.,  66.,   0.,  36.]),\n",
       " array([ 0.        ,  0.47619048,  0.95238095,  1.42857143,  1.9047619 ,\n",
       "         2.38095238,  2.85714286,  3.33333333,  3.80952381,  4.28571429,\n",
       "         4.76190476,  5.23809524,  5.71428571,  6.19047619,  6.66666667,\n",
       "         7.14285714,  7.61904762,  8.0952381 ,  8.57142857,  9.04761905,\n",
       "         9.52380952, 10.        ]),\n",
       " <BarContainer object of 21 artists>)"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 179,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 5328 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# HISTOGRAM OF SCORES\n",
    "\n",
    "plt.hist(df['answer'], bins=21)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 180,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "(array([ 1.,  1.,  2.,  1.,  4.,  3.,  4.,  2.,  3.,  3.,  3.,  2.,  6.,\n",
       "         7., 10., 10.,  4.,  3.,  2.,  1.]),\n",
       " array([2.35  , 2.5925, 2.835 , 3.0775, 3.32  , 3.5625, 3.805 , 4.0475,\n",
       "        4.29  , 4.5325, 4.775 , 5.0175, 5.26  , 5.5025, 5.745 , 5.9875,\n",
       "        6.23  , 6.4725, 6.715 , 6.9575, 7.2   ]),\n",
       " <BarContainer object of 20 artists>)"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 180,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "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",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# HISTOGRAM OF AVERAGE ANSWER SCORES FOR EACH GENERATION\n",
    "\n",
    "mean_scores = df.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "plt.hist(mean_scores, bins=20)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 844,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "# NORMALIZE PARTICIPANT SCORES FROM 0-1\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby('participant_id')\n",
    "df['answer'] = grouped['answer'].apply(lambda x: (x - x.min()) / (x.max() - x.min()))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 181,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "5.168055555555555\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "print(df['answer'].mean())"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 275,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "4.95 unorthodox_advice 1_3 2.0 Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "5.15 unorthodox_advice 2_3 0.0 Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "5.15 unorthodox_advice 3 1.0 \"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "5.3 unorthodox_advice 1_3 0.0 Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "5.3 unorthodox_advice 0_3 2.0 Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "5.35 unorthodox_advice 3 0.0 \"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "5.35 unorthodox_advice 3 2.0 Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "5.55 unorthodox_advice 0 2.0 \"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "5.65 unorthodox_advice 2 1.0 Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "5.7 unorthodox_advice 1 2.0 \"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "5.8 unorthodox_advice 0 1.0 \"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "best from framework: 5.85 unorthodox_advice 2_3 1.0 Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "5.9 unorthodox_advice 2_3 2.0 Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "5.9 unorthodox_advice 0_1 2.0 \"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "5.9 unorthodox_advice 1_2 2.0 \"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "6.0 unorthodox_advice 1 1.0 \"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "6.1 unorthodox_advice 0_3 0.0 \"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "6.1 unorthodox_advice 1 0.0 \"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "6.1 unorthodox_advice 2 2.0 \"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "6.15 unorthodox_advice 1_3 1.0 Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "6.2 unorthodox_advice 0_3 1.0 \"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "6.2 unorthodox_advice 0_2 0.0 \"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "6.2 unorthodox_advice 0 0.0 \"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "6.25 unorthodox_advice 0_1 1.0 \"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "6.3 unorthodox_advice 2 0.0 \"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "6.55 unorthodox_advice 0_2 2.0 \"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "6.6 unorthodox_advice 1_2 0.0 \"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "6.8 unorthodox_advice 0_2 1.0 \"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "6.85 unorthodox_advice 0_1 0.0 \"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "7.2 unorthodox_advice 1_2 1.0 \"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n"
     ]
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "(array([1., 2., 0., 4., 0., 1., 2., 2., 3., 1., 4., 5., 0., 0., 2., 0., 2.,\n",
       "        0., 0., 1.]),\n",
       " array([4.95  , 5.0625, 5.175 , 5.2875, 5.4   , 5.5125, 5.625 , 5.7375,\n",
       "        5.85  , 5.9625, 6.075 , 6.1875, 6.3   , 6.4125, 6.525 , 6.6375,\n",
       "        6.75  , 6.8625, 6.975 , 7.0875, 7.2   ]),\n",
       " <BarContainer object of 20 artists>)"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 275,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "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",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# SORTED AVERAGE SCORES FOR EACH GENERATION\n",
    "\n",
    "best_generation_advice = \"2_3\"\n",
    "best_generation_index = 1\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] != 'baseline_ask_with_reasoning']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_type'] != 'baseline_ask']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_type'] != 'baseline_neutral_advice']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_type'] != 'baseline_irrelevant_advice']\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "grouped.sort_values(inplace=True)\n",
    "items = []\n",
    "for text, score in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "    # get the advice_type for each text\n",
    "    advice_type = df_tmp[df_tmp['text'] == text]['advice_type'].unique()[0]\n",
    "    advice_indices = df_tmp[df_tmp['text'] == text]['advice_indices'].unique()[0]\n",
    "    generation = df_tmp[df_tmp['text'] == text]['generation_index'].unique()[0]\n",
    "    if advice_indices == best_generation_advice and generation == best_generation_index: \n",
    "        print('\\n\\nbest from framework: ', end = '')\n",
    "    print(score, advice_type, advice_indices, generation, text)\n",
    "    items.append(score)\n",
    "\n",
    "plt.hist(items, bins=20)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 260,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "3.5 baseline_neutral_advice 1_2\n",
      "\"Remember to hydrate!\"\n",
      "\"Be sure to appreciate the surrounding art.\"\n",
      "3.533333333333333 baseline_irrelevant_advice 0\n",
      "Remember to emphasize your interesting experiences from your recent trip to Australia while talking to the artisan.\n",
      "3.566666666666667 baseline_irrelevant_advice 0_2\n",
      "Remember to emphasize your interesting experiences from your recent trip to Australia while talking to the artisan.\n",
      "Practice your singing daily, it would be great for your goal to perform at the local concert.\n",
      "3.8333333333333335 baseline_irrelevant_advice 2\n",
      "Practice your singing daily, it would be great for your goal to perform at the local concert.\n",
      "4.166666666666667 baseline_irrelevant_advice 1_2\n",
      "Brush your hair and make sure your outfit complements your hair color before you approach the seller.\n",
      "Practice your singing daily, it would be great for your goal to perform at the local concert.\n",
      "4.333333333333333 baseline_irrelevant_advice 1\n",
      "Brush your hair and make sure your outfit complements your hair color before you approach the seller.\n",
      "4.366666666666666 baseline_neutral_advice 1\n",
      "\"Remember to hydrate!\"\n",
      "4.45 baseline_irrelevant_advice 0_1\n",
      "Remember to emphasize your interesting experiences from your recent trip to Australia while talking to the artisan.\n",
      "Brush your hair and make sure your outfit complements your hair color before you approach the seller.\n",
      "4.683333333333334 baseline_ask []\n",
      "baseline_ask\n",
      "4.866666666666666 baseline_neutral_advice 0_1\n",
      "\"Always wear a smile!\"\n",
      "\"Remember to hydrate!\"\n",
      "5.283333333333333 unorthodox_advice 3\n",
      "\"Jill, consider offering to promote the artisan's work on your social media in exchange for a discount on the vase.\"\n",
      "5.466666666666667 unorthodox_advice 1_3\n",
      "She should emphasize her interest in supporting local artisans but also give a hint that the price is a bit higher than what she can afford.\n",
      "\"Jill, consider offering to promote the artisan's work on your social media in exchange for a discount on the vase.\"\n",
      "5.55 baseline_neutral_advice 0\n",
      "\"Always wear a smile!\"\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "best from framework: 5.633333333333334 unorthodox_advice 2_3\n",
      "She should ask if there are any discounts available for purchasing multiple items or returning customers as she plans to come back to the market in the future.\n",
      "\"Jill, consider offering to promote the artisan's work on your social media in exchange for a discount on the vase.\"\n",
      "5.65 baseline_neutral_advice 2\n",
      "\"Be sure to appreciate the surrounding art.\"\n",
      "5.85 unorthodox_advice 0\n",
      "Jill should compliment the artisan's craftsmanship while gently asking if there is any room for bargaining.\n",
      "5.866666666666666 unorthodox_advice 0_3\n",
      "Jill should compliment the artisan's craftsmanship while gently asking if there is any room for bargaining.\n",
      "\"Jill, consider offering to promote the artisan's work on your social media in exchange for a discount on the vase.\"\n",
      "5.933333333333334 unorthodox_advice 1\n",
      "She should emphasize her interest in supporting local artisans but also give a hint that the price is a bit higher than what she can afford.\n",
      "5.983333333333333 baseline_ask_with_reasoning []\n",
      "baseline_ask_with_reasoning\n",
      "6.016666666666667 unorthodox_advice 2\n",
      "She should ask if there are any discounts available for purchasing multiple items or returning customers as she plans to come back to the market in the future.\n",
      "6.083333333333333 baseline_neutral_advice 0_2\n",
      "\"Always wear a smile!\"\n",
      "\"Be sure to appreciate the surrounding art.\"\n",
      "6.333333333333333 unorthodox_advice 0_1\n",
      "Jill should compliment the artisan's craftsmanship while gently asking if there is any room for bargaining.\n",
      "She should emphasize her interest in supporting local artisans but also give a hint that the price is a bit higher than what she can afford.\n",
      "6.516666666666667 unorthodox_advice 0_2\n",
      "Jill should compliment the artisan's craftsmanship while gently asking if there is any room for bargaining.\n",
      "She should ask if there are any discounts available for purchasing multiple items or returning customers as she plans to come back to the market in the future.\n",
      "6.566666666666666 unorthodox_advice 1_2\n",
      "She should emphasize her interest in supporting local artisans but also give a hint that the price is a bit higher than what she can afford.\n",
      "She should ask if there are any discounts available for purchasing multiple items or returning customers as she plans to come back to the market in the future.\n"
     ]
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "(array([3., 0., 1., 0., 1., 2., 1., 0., 1., 1., 0., 0., 1., 1., 3., 0., 3.,\n",
       "        3., 0., 1., 2.]),\n",
       " array([3.5       , 3.64603175, 3.79206349, 3.93809524, 4.08412698,\n",
       "        4.23015873, 4.37619048, 4.52222222, 4.66825397, 4.81428571,\n",
       "        4.96031746, 5.10634921, 5.25238095, 5.3984127 , 5.54444444,\n",
       "        5.69047619, 5.83650794, 5.98253968, 6.12857143, 6.27460317,\n",
       "        6.42063492, 6.56666667]),\n",
       " <BarContainer object of 21 artists>)"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 260,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 5284 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AVERAGE SCORES FOR EACH ADVICE COMBINATION (but not generation)\n",
    "import json\n",
    "\n",
    "best_advice_index = \"2_3\"\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby(['advice_type', 'advice_indices'])['answer'].mean()\n",
    "grouped.sort_values(inplace=True)\n",
    "scores = []\n",
    "for (advice_type, advice_indices), score in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "    if advice_type == \"unorthodox_advice\":\n",
    "        with open(f\"{scenario}/advice/normal_advice.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "            advice = json.load(f)\n",
    "        with open(f\"{scenario}/advice/unorthodox_advice.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "            advice += json.load(f)\n",
    "    elif advice_type != \"baseline_ask_with_reasoning\" and advice_type != \"baseline_ask\":\n",
    "        with open(f\"{scenario}/advice/{advice_type}.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "            advice = json.load(f)\n",
    "    \n",
    "    if advice_type == \"unorthodox_advice\" and advice_indices == best_advice_index:\n",
    "        print('\\n\\nbest from framework: ', end = '')\n",
    "    print(score, advice_type, advice_indices)\n",
    "    for index in advice_indices.split(\"_\"):\n",
    "        if index == \"nan\":\n",
    "            continue\n",
    "        elif advice_type == \"baseline_ask_with_reasoning\" or advice_type == \"baseline_ask\":\n",
    "            print(advice_type)\n",
    "        else: \n",
    "            print(advice[int(index)])\n",
    "    scores += [score]\n",
    "\n",
    "plt.hist(scores, bins=21)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 261,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "3.9805555555555556 baseline_irrelevant_advice\n",
      "4.683333333333334 baseline_ask\n",
      "5.002777777777778 baseline_neutral_advice\n",
      "5.946666666666666 unorthodox_advice\n",
      "5.983333333333333 baseline_ask_with_reasoning\n"
     ]
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "{'whiskers': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7cf25f880>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7cf25fb20>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3e1ca0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3f5a60>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce485730>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce485b20>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce513f70>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce4084f0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce65a7f0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce6562b0>],\n",
       " 'caps': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7cf25fdc0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7cf26e0a0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3fb370>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3fbd30>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce476f70>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce4a5610>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce481970>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce481610>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce656dc0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce650160>],\n",
       " 'boxes': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7cf25f5e0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3e1610>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce485340>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce53b0a0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce555760>],\n",
       " 'medians': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7e9c1c1c0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3e71f0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce48f100>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce54e730>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce650dc0>],\n",
       " 'fliers': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3eef70>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce3e7d00>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce53b760>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce5550a0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ce641f10>],\n",
       " 'means': []}"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 261,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 7348 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AVERAGE SCORES FOR EACH ADVICE TYPE\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby('advice_type')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "grouped.sort_values(inplace=True)\n",
    "for advice_type, score in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "    print(score, advice_type)\n",
    "\n",
    "\n",
    "# best_advice_from_framework = None\n",
    "# best_grouped_avg = df.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()[best_advice_from_framework]\n",
    "# print(f\"best advice from framework score: {best_grouped_avg}\")\n",
    "\n",
    "# best_generation = None\n",
    "\n",
    "\n",
    "# make a box and whisker plot of the scores for each advice type\n",
    "advice_types = [\"baseline_irrelevant_advice\", \"unorthodox_advice\", \"baseline_ask\", \"baseline_neutral_advice\", \"baseline_ask_with_reasoning\"]\n",
    "short_advice_types = [\"irrelevant\", \"our avg gen\", \"ask\", \"neutral\", \"reasoning\"]\n",
    "plt.boxplot([df[df['advice_type'] == advice_type]['answer'] for advice_type in advice_types], labels=short_advice_types)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 262,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "5.283333333333333 unorthodox_advice 3\n",
      "5.466666666666667 unorthodox_advice 1_3\n",
      "best advice from framework score:  5.633333333333334 unorthodox_advice 2_3\n",
      "5.85 unorthodox_advice 0\n",
      "5.866666666666666 unorthodox_advice 0_3\n",
      "5.933333333333334 unorthodox_advice 1\n",
      "6.016666666666667 unorthodox_advice 2\n",
      "6.333333333333333 unorthodox_advice 0_1\n",
      "6.516666666666667 unorthodox_advice 0_2\n",
      "6.566666666666666 unorthodox_advice 1_2\n"
     ]
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "(array([1., 0., 0., 1., 0., 1., 0., 0., 0., 2., 1., 0., 1., 0., 0., 0., 0.,\n",
       "        1., 0., 0., 2.]),\n",
       " array([5.28333333, 5.34444444, 5.40555556, 5.46666667, 5.52777778,\n",
       "        5.58888889, 5.65      , 5.71111111, 5.77222222, 5.83333333,\n",
       "        5.89444444, 5.95555556, 6.01666667, 6.07777778, 6.13888889,\n",
       "        6.2       , 6.26111111, 6.32222222, 6.38333333, 6.44444444,\n",
       "        6.50555556, 6.56666667]),\n",
       " <BarContainer object of 21 artists>)"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 262,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 6732 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AVERAGE SCORES FOR EACH ADVICE TYPE AND ADVICE INDEX\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] != 'baseline_ask_with_reasoning']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_type'] != 'baseline_ask']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_type'] != 'baseline_neutral_advice']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_type'] != 'baseline_irrelevant_advice']\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby(['advice_type', 'advice_indices'])['answer'].mean()\n",
    "grouped.sort_values(inplace=True)\n",
    "scores = []\n",
    "for (advice_type, advice_indices), score in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "    if advice_type == 'unorthodox_advice' and advice_indices == best_advice_index:\n",
    "        print(\"best advice from framework score: \", score, advice_type, advice_indices)\n",
    "    else: print(score, advice_type, advice_indices)\n",
    "    scores += [score]\n",
    "\n",
    "plt.hist(scores, bins=21)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 276,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "3.85 Remember to emphasize your interesting experiences from your recent trip to Australia while talking to the artisan.\n",
      "3.8555555555555556 Practice your singing daily, it would be great for your goal to perform at the local concert.\n",
      "4.2444444444444445 \"Remember to hydrate!\"\n",
      "4.316666666666666 Brush your hair and make sure your outfit complements your hair color before you approach the seller.\n",
      "5.0777777777777775 \"Be sure to appreciate the surrounding art.\"\n",
      "5.5 \"Always wear a smile!\"\n",
      "5.5625 \"Jill, consider offering to promote the artisan's work on your social media in exchange for a discount on the vase.\"\n",
      "6.075 She should emphasize her interest in supporting local artisans but also give a hint that the price is a bit higher than what she can afford.\n",
      "6.141666666666667 Jill should compliment the artisan's craftsmanship while gently asking if there is any room for bargaining.\n",
      "6.183333333333334 She should ask if there are any discounts available for purchasing multiple items or returning customers as she plans to come back to the market in the future.\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AVERAGE SCORES FOR ALL GENERATIONS CONTAINING A PARTICULAR PIECE OF ADVICE\n",
    "import json\n",
    "\n",
    "advice_texts = []\n",
    "advice_scores = []\n",
    "# for each advice type\n",
    "for advice_type in df['advice_type'].unique():\n",
    "    df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == advice_type]\n",
    "    \n",
    "    if advice_type == \"baseline_ask_with_reasoning\" or advice_type == \"baseline_ask\":\n",
    "        continue\n",
    "    \n",
    "    if advice_type == \"unorthodox_advice\":\n",
    "        with open(f\"{scenario}/advice/normal_advice.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "            advice = json.load(f)\n",
    "        with open(f\"{scenario}/advice/unorthodox_advice.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "            advice += json.load(f)\n",
    "    else:\n",
    "        with open(f\"{scenario}/advice/{advice_type}.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "            advice = json.load(f)\n",
    "\n",
    "    # for each set of indices containing advice 0\n",
    "    df_0 = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'].str.contains(\"0\")]\n",
    "    advice_texts += [advice[0]]\n",
    "    advice_scores += [df_0['answer'].mean()]\n",
    "\n",
    "    df_1 = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'].str.contains(\"1\")]\n",
    "    advice_texts += [advice[1]]\n",
    "    advice_scores += [df_1['answer'].mean()]\n",
    "\n",
    "    df_2 = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'].str.contains(\"2\")]\n",
    "    advice_texts += [advice[2]]\n",
    "    advice_scores += [df_2['answer'].mean()]\n",
    "\n",
    "    if advice_type == \"unorthodox_advice\":\n",
    "        df_3 = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'].str.contains(\"3\")]\n",
    "        advice_texts += [advice[3]]\n",
    "        advice_scores += [df_3['answer'].mean()]\n",
    "\n",
    "# argsort\n",
    "indices = np.argsort(advice_scores)\n",
    "for i in indices:\n",
    "    print(advice_scores[i], advice_texts[i])\n",
    "\n",
    "# note: each triplet is correlated. "
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 894,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "df_copy = df.copy()\n",
    "grouped = df_copy.groupby('participant_id')\n",
    "df_copy['answer'] = grouped['answer'].apply(lambda x: (x - x.min()) / (x.max() - x.min()))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 683,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "0.07183499288762463\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07183499288762463\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07183499288762463\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07627854430578362\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07649107394973809\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07649107394973809\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.0673924638408685\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07183499288762463\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07649107394973809\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07204852033880582\n",
      "435\n",
      "0.07325327218851707 0.0029060096064365973\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AGREEMENT BETWEEN HUMAN AND FRAMEWORK\n",
    "from sklearn.metrics import cohen_kappa_score\n",
    "import json\n",
    "import random\n",
    "import math\n",
    "import os\n",
    "\n",
    "path = f\"{scenario}/MWU_matrix_weighted.npy\"\n",
    "MWU_matrix = np.load(path)\n",
    "\n",
    "# get all the response generations\n",
    "unorthodox_path = f\"{scenario}/candidates/unorthodox_advice/\"\n",
    "for path in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators\"):\n",
    "    if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\"):\n",
    "        evaluator = f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\" # all mappings are the same\n",
    "        break\n",
    "\n",
    "with open(f\"{evaluator}/mappings.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    mapping = json.load(f)[0]\n",
    "\n",
    "kappas = []\n",
    "\n",
    "for iteration in range(10):\n",
    "    matching = 0\n",
    "    total = 0\n",
    "    gpt_tie_count = 0\n",
    "    human_tie_count = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "    gpt_judgements = []\n",
    "    human_judgements = []\n",
    "\n",
    "    for i in range(MWU_matrix.shape[0]):\n",
    "\n",
    "        # get the responses for the ith advice set\n",
    "        filename = mapping[str(i)]\n",
    "        if filename == \".json\": continue\n",
    "        with open(f\"{unorthodox_path}/{filename}\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "            responses1 = json.load(f)\n",
    "        \n",
    "        for k in range(MWU_matrix.shape[2]):\n",
    "\n",
    "            # get the specific generation text, corresponding df, and score\n",
    "            response1 = responses1[k]\n",
    "            df_tmp = df[df['text'] == response1]\n",
    "            if len(df_tmp) == 0: raise Exception(f\"no match with response1: {response1}\")\n",
    "            score1 = df_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "            for j in range(i, MWU_matrix.shape[1]):\n",
    "\n",
    "                # get the responses for the jth advice set\n",
    "                filename = mapping[str(j)]\n",
    "                if filename == \".json\": continue\n",
    "                with open(f\"{unorthodox_path}/{filename}\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "                    responses2 = json.load(f)\n",
    "\n",
    "                for l in range(MWU_matrix.shape[3]):\n",
    "\n",
    "                    # onlt need half of the MWU_matrix, self-compare is meaningless\n",
    "                    if i == j and k >= l:\n",
    "                        continue\n",
    "\n",
    "                    # get the specific generation text, corresponding df, and score\n",
    "                    response2 = responses2[l]\n",
    "                    df_tmp2 = df[df['text'] == response2]\n",
    "                    if len(df_tmp2) == 0: raise Exception(f\"no match with response2: {response2}\")\n",
    "                    score2 = df_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "                    # if score1 - score2 < 0.5 and score2 - score1 < 0.5:\n",
    "                    #     continue\n",
    "\n",
    "                    result = MWU_matrix[i][j][k][l]\n",
    "                    if math.isclose(result, 0.5): \n",
    "                        # print(f\"TIE FROM GPT: {i}, {j}, {k}, {l}, {result}\")\n",
    "                        gpt_tie_count += 1\n",
    "                        if random.random() > 0.5: result = 1\n",
    "                        else: result = 0\n",
    "                    \n",
    "                    if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                        # print(f\"TIE FROM HUMAN: {i}, {j}, {k}, {l}, {score1}, {score2}\")\n",
    "                        human_tie_count += 1\n",
    "                        df_copy_tmp = df_copy[df_copy['text'] == response1]\n",
    "                        df_copy_tmp2 = df_copy[df_copy['text'] == response2]\n",
    "                        score1 = df_copy_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "                        score2 = df_copy_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "                        \n",
    "                        if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                            print(\"STILL A TIE\")\n",
    "                            continue\n",
    "\n",
    "                    if score1 > score2:\n",
    "                        human_judgements.append(1)\n",
    "                    elif score1 < score2:\n",
    "                        human_judgements.append(0)\n",
    "                    else: \n",
    "                        print(\"tied?\")\n",
    "                    \n",
    "                    if result > 0.5:\n",
    "                        gpt_judgements.append(1)\n",
    "                    elif result < 0.5:\n",
    "                        gpt_judgements.append(0)\n",
    "                    else:\n",
    "                        print(\"tied?\")\n",
    "                    \n",
    "                    total += 1\n",
    "\n",
    "    kappa = cohen_kappa_score(human_judgements, gpt_judgements)\n",
    "    kappas.append(kappa)\n",
    "    print(kappa)\n",
    "    print(total)\n",
    "    # print(gpt_tie_count)\n",
    "    # print(human_tie_count)\n",
    "\n",
    "print(np.mean(kappas), np.std(kappas))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 682,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "0.4595238095238095\n",
      "840\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AGREEMENT BETWEEN HUMAN AND FRAMEWORK\n",
    "\n",
    "import json\n",
    "import random\n",
    "import os\n",
    "path = f\"{scenario}/MWU_matrix_weighted.npy\"\n",
    "MWU_matrix = np.load(path)\n",
    "\n",
    "# get all the response generations\n",
    "unorthodox_path = f\"{scenario}/candidates/unorthodox_advice/\"\n",
    "for path in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators\"):\n",
    "    if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\"):\n",
    "        evaluator = f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\" # all mappings are the same\n",
    "        break\n",
    "\n",
    "with open(f\"{evaluator}/mappings.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    mapping = json.load(f)[0]\n",
    "\n",
    "matching = 0\n",
    "total = 0\n",
    "comparison_points = []\n",
    "for i in range(MWU_matrix.shape[0]):\n",
    "    filename = mapping[str(i)]\n",
    "    if filename == \".json\": continue\n",
    "    with open(f\"{unorthodox_path}/{filename}\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "        responses1 = json.load(f)\n",
    "    \n",
    "    for k in range(MWU_matrix.shape[2]):\n",
    "        # get the specific generation text\n",
    "        response1 = responses1[k]\n",
    "\n",
    "        df_tmp = df[df['text'] == response1]\n",
    "        # if len(df_tmp) == 0: raise Exception(f\"no match with response1: {response1}\")\n",
    "        score1 = df_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "        # df_tmp_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['participant_id'].isin(competent_participants) | df_tmp['participant_id'].isin(maybe_competent_participants)]\n",
    "        # score1 = df_tmp_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "        for j in range(MWU_matrix.shape[1]):# i, MWU_matrix.shape[1]):\n",
    "            filename = mapping[str(j)]\n",
    "            if filename == \".json\": continue\n",
    "            with open(f\"{unorthodox_path}/{filename}\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "                responses2 = json.load(f)\n",
    "\n",
    "            for l in range(MWU_matrix.shape[3]):\n",
    "                if i == j and k >= l:\n",
    "                    continue\n",
    "\n",
    "                response2 = responses2[l]\n",
    "\n",
    "                df_tmp2 = df[df['text'] == response2]\n",
    "                # if len(df_tmp2) == 0: raise Exception(f\"no match with response2: {response2}\")\n",
    "                score2 = df_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "                # df_tmp_tmp2 = df_tmp2[df_tmp2['participant_id'].isin(competent_participants) | df_tmp2['participant_id'].isin(maybe_competent_participants)]\n",
    "                # score2 = df_tmp_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "                result = MWU_matrix[i][j][k][l]\n",
    "\n",
    "                if score1 > score2 and result > 0.5:\n",
    "                    match = 1\n",
    "                elif score1 < score2 and result < 0.5:\n",
    "                    match = 1\n",
    "                elif math.isclose(score1, score2) and math.isclose(result, 0.5):\n",
    "                    match = 1\n",
    "                elif math.isclose(result, 0.5):\n",
    "                    match = 0.5\n",
    "                elif math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                    match = 0.5\n",
    "                else: \n",
    "                    match = 0\n",
    "                    # print(response1, \"\\n\\n\", response2)\n",
    "                    # print(f\"{i} {j} {k} {l} {result} {score1} {score2}\")\n",
    "                    # if random.random() > 0.7: raise Exception(\"?\")\n",
    "\n",
    "                matching += match\n",
    "                total += 1\n",
    "                comparison_points.append((score1, score2, result, match))\n",
    "\n",
    "\n",
    "print(matching / total)\n",
    "print(total)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 907,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "0.43415637860082307\n",
      "243\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AGREEMENT BETWEEN HUMAN AND FRAMEWORK FOR LARGE DIFFERENCE CASES\n",
    "\n",
    "import json\n",
    "import random\n",
    "import math\n",
    "import os\n",
    "path = f\"{scenario}/MWU_matrix_weighted.npy\"\n",
    "MWU_matrix = np.load(path)\n",
    "\n",
    "# get all the response generations\n",
    "unorthodox_path = f\"{scenario}/candidates/unorthodox_advice/\"\n",
    "for path in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators\"):\n",
    "    if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\"):\n",
    "        evaluator = f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\" # all mappings are the same\n",
    "        break\n",
    "\n",
    "with open(f\"{evaluator}/mappings.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    mapping = json.load(f)[0]\n",
    "\n",
    "matching = 0\n",
    "total = 0\n",
    "comparison_points = []\n",
    "look_at_points = []\n",
    "\n",
    "for i in range(MWU_matrix.shape[0]):\n",
    "    filename = mapping[str(i)]\n",
    "    if filename == \".json\": continue\n",
    "    with open(f\"{unorthodox_path}/{filename}\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "        responses1 = json.load(f)\n",
    "    \n",
    "    for k in range(MWU_matrix.shape[2]):\n",
    "        # get the specific generation text\n",
    "        response1 = responses1[k]\n",
    "\n",
    "        df_tmp = df[df['text'] == response1]\n",
    "        df_tmp_tmp = df_tmp\n",
    "        if len(df_tmp_tmp) == 0:\n",
    "            continue\n",
    "        score1 = df_tmp_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "        for j in range(i, MWU_matrix.shape[1]):\n",
    "            filename = mapping[str(j)]\n",
    "            if filename == \".json\": continue\n",
    "            with open(f\"{unorthodox_path}/{filename}\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "                responses2 = json.load(f)\n",
    "\n",
    "            for l in range(MWU_matrix.shape[3]):\n",
    "                if i == j and k >= l:\n",
    "                    continue\n",
    "\n",
    "                response2 = responses2[l]\n",
    "\n",
    "                df_tmp2 = df[df['text'] == response2]\n",
    "                df_tmp_tmp2 = df_tmp2\n",
    "                if len(df_tmp_tmp2) == 0:\n",
    "                    continue\n",
    "                \n",
    "                score2 = df_tmp_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "                result = MWU_matrix[i][j][k][l]\n",
    "\n",
    "                if score1 - score2 < 0.5 and score2 - score1 < 0.5:\n",
    "                    continue\n",
    "\n",
    "                if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                    print(f\"TIE FROM HUMAN: {i}, {j}, {k}, {l}, {score1}, {score2}\")\n",
    "                    human_tie_count += 1\n",
    "                    df_copy_tmp = df_copy[df_copy['text'] == response1]\n",
    "                    df_copy_tmp2 = df_copy[df_copy['text'] == response2]\n",
    "                    if len(df_copy_tmp) == 0: raise Exception(f\"no match with response1: {response1}\")\n",
    "                    if len(df_copy_tmp2) == 0: raise Exception(f\"no match with response2: {response2}\")\n",
    "                    score1 = df_copy_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "                    score2 = df_copy_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "                    \n",
    "                    if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                        print(\"STILL A TIE\")\n",
    "                        raise Exception(\"STILL A TIE\")\n",
    "\n",
    "                if score1 > score2 and result > 0.5:\n",
    "                    match = 1\n",
    "                elif score1 < score2 and result < 0.5:\n",
    "                    match = 1\n",
    "                elif math.isclose(score1, score2) and math.isclose(result, 0.5):\n",
    "                    match = 1\n",
    "                elif math.isclose(result, 0.5):\n",
    "                    match = 0.5\n",
    "                elif math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                    match = 0.5\n",
    "                else: \n",
    "                    match = 0\n",
    "                    # print(response1, \"\\n\\n\", response2)\n",
    "                    # print(f\"{i} {j} {k} {l} {result} {score1} {score2}\")\n",
    "                    # if random.random() > 0.7: raise Exception(\"?\")\n",
    "\n",
    "                matching += match\n",
    "                total += 1\n",
    "                comparison_points.append((score1, score2, result, match))\n",
    "                look_at_points.append({\"response1\": response1, \"response2\": response2, \"score1\": score1, \"score2\": score2, \"result\": result, \"match\": match, \"i\": i, \"j\": j, \"k\": k, \"l\": l, \"advice1\": mapping[str(i)], \"advice2\": mapping[str(j)]})\n",
    "\n",
    "\n",
    "print(matching / total)\n",
    "print(total)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 905,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 0, 7, 0, 2, 6.2, 6.2\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 0, 3, 0, 0, 6.2, 6.2\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 4, 7, 0, 1, 6.1, 6.1\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 4, 9, 0, 2, 6.1, 6.1\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 1, 5, 2, 1, 5.9, 5.9\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 1, 8, 2, 1, 5.9, 5.9\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 7, 0, 2, 2, 6.1, 6.1\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 7, 9, 2, 2, 6.1, 6.1\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 7, 8, 2, 2, 6.2, 6.2\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 2, 3, 0, 0, 6.2, 6.2\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 5, 1, 2, 1, 5.9, 5.9\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 5, 8, 2, 1, 5.9, 5.9\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 9, 9, 0, 1, 5.35, 5.35\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 9, 6, 1, 2, 5.15, 5.15\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 9, 5, 2, 2, 5.35, 5.35\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 3, 0, 0, 2, 6.1, 6.1\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 3, 7, 0, 1, 6.1, 6.1\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 3, 8, 0, 2, 6.2, 6.2\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 3, 7, 1, 2, 6.2, 6.2\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 3, 3, 2, 1, 5.3, 5.3\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 6, 3, 0, 1, 5.3, 5.3\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 8, 9, 0, 0, 5.15, 5.15\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 8, 1, 2, 1, 5.9, 5.9\n",
      "TIE FROM HUMAN: 8, 5, 2, 1, 5.9, 5.9\n",
      "0.4632183908045977\n",
      "435\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AGREEMENT BETWEEN HUMAN AND FRAMEWORK, the other way but no kappa\n",
    "import json\n",
    "import random\n",
    "import math\n",
    "import os\n",
    "\n",
    "path = f\"{scenario}/MWU_matrix_weighted.npy\"\n",
    "MWU_matrix = np.load(path)\n",
    "\n",
    "# get all the response generations\n",
    "unorthodox_path = f\"{scenario}/responses/unorthodox_advice/\"\n",
    "for path in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators\"):\n",
    "    if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\"):\n",
    "        evaluator = f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\" # all mappings are the same\n",
    "        break\n",
    "\n",
    "with open(f\"{evaluator}/mappings_remapped.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    remap = json.load(f)[0]\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == 'unorthodox_advice']\n",
    "\n",
    "matching = 0\n",
    "total = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('origin_id')\n",
    "for name, group in grouped:\n",
    "    for name2, group2 in grouped: \n",
    "        if name == name2: continue\n",
    "        score1 = group['answer'].mean()\n",
    "        score2 = group2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "        # if score1 - score2 < 0.5 and score2 - score1 < 0.5:\n",
    "        #     continue\n",
    "\n",
    "        if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "            print(f\"TIE FROM HUMAN: {i}, {j}, {k}, {l}, {score1}, {score2}\")\n",
    "            df_copy_tmp = df_copy[df_copy['origin_id'] == name]\n",
    "            df_copy_tmp2 = df_copy[df_copy['origin_id'] == name2]\n",
    "            score1 = df_copy_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "            score2 = df_copy_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "            if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                print(\"STILL A TIE\")\n",
    "                continue\n",
    "\n",
    "        # look for it in the MWU matrix\n",
    "        advice_indices = group.iloc[0]['advice_indices']\n",
    "        advice_indices2 = group2.iloc[0]['advice_indices']\n",
    "        i = int(remap[advice_indices + \".json\"])\n",
    "        j = int(remap[advice_indices2 + \".json\"])\n",
    "        k = int(group.iloc[0]['generation_index'])\n",
    "        l = int(group2.iloc[0]['generation_index'])\n",
    "\n",
    "        # if \"3\" in advice_indices or \"3\" in advice_indices2:\n",
    "        #     continue\n",
    "\n",
    "        if i > j or (i == j and k >= l): \n",
    "            continue\n",
    "\n",
    "        result = MWU_matrix[i][j][k][l]\n",
    "\n",
    "        if score1 > score2 and result > 0.5:\n",
    "            match = 1\n",
    "        elif score1 < score2 and result < 0.5:\n",
    "            match = 1\n",
    "        elif math.isclose(result, 0.5):\n",
    "            match = 0.5\n",
    "        elif math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "            raise Exception(\"STILL A TIE\")\n",
    "        else:\n",
    "            match = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "        matching += match\n",
    "        total += 1\n",
    "\n",
    "print(matching/total)\n",
    "print(total)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 690,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "0.38961038961038963\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.37678207739307534\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.37678207739307534\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.38961038961038963\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.37678207739307534\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.3639602952405193\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.37678207739307534\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.38961038961038963\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.3639602952405193\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.38961038961038963\n",
      "153\n",
      "0.3793490458494898 0.009597735680630706\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AGREEMENT BETWEEN HUMAN AND FRAMEWORK, the other way\n",
    "from sklearn.metrics import cohen_kappa_score\n",
    "import json\n",
    "import random\n",
    "import math\n",
    "import os\n",
    "\n",
    "path = f\"{scenario}/MWU_matrix_weighted.npy\"\n",
    "MWU_matrix = np.load(path)\n",
    "\n",
    "# get all the response generations\n",
    "unorthodox_path = f\"{scenario}/responses/unorthodox_advice/\"\n",
    "for path in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators\"):\n",
    "    if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\"):\n",
    "        evaluator = f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{path}\" # all mappings are the same\n",
    "        break\n",
    "\n",
    "with open(f\"{evaluator}/mappings_remapped.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    remap = json.load(f)[0]\n",
    "\n",
    "kappas = []\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == 'unorthodox_advice']\n",
    "\n",
    "for iteration in range(10):\n",
    "    matching = 0\n",
    "    total = 0\n",
    "    gpt_tie_count = 0\n",
    "    human_tie_count = 0\n",
    "    gpt_judgements = []\n",
    "    human_judgements = []\n",
    "\n",
    "    grouped = df_tmp.groupby('origin_id')\n",
    "    for name, group in grouped:\n",
    "        for name2, group2 in grouped: \n",
    "            if name == name2: continue\n",
    "            score1 = group['answer'].mean()\n",
    "            score2 = group2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "            if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                # print(f\"TIE FROM HUMAN: {i}, {j}, {k}, {l}, {score1}, {score2}\")\n",
    "                human_tie_count += 1\n",
    "                df_copy_tmp = df_copy[df_copy['origin_id'] == name]\n",
    "                df_copy_tmp2 = df_copy[df_copy['origin_id'] == name2]\n",
    "                score1 = df_copy_tmp['answer'].mean()\n",
    "                score2 = df_copy_tmp2['answer'].mean()\n",
    "\n",
    "                if math.isclose(score1, score2):\n",
    "                    print(\"STILL A TIE\")\n",
    "                    continue\n",
    "\n",
    "            # if score1 - score2 <= 0.5 and score2 - score1 <= 0.5:\n",
    "            #     continue\n",
    "\n",
    "            # look for it in the MWU matrix\n",
    "            advice_indices = group.iloc[0]['advice_indices']\n",
    "            advice_indices2 = group2.iloc[0]['advice_indices']\n",
    "            i = int(remap[advice_indices + \".json\"])\n",
    "            j = int(remap[advice_indices2 + \".json\"])\n",
    "            k = int(group.iloc[0]['generation_index'])\n",
    "            l = int(group2.iloc[0]['generation_index'])\n",
    "\n",
    "            if \"3\" in advice_indices or \"3\" in advice_indices2:\n",
    "                continue\n",
    "\n",
    "            if i > j or i == j and k > l: \n",
    "                continue\n",
    "\n",
    "            result = MWU_matrix[i][j][k][l]\n",
    "            if math.isclose(result, 0.5): \n",
    "                # print(f\"TIE FROM GPT: {i}, {j}, {k}, {l}, {result}\")\n",
    "                gpt_tie_count += 1\n",
    "                if random.random() > 0.5: result = 1\n",
    "                else: result = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "            if score1 > score2:\n",
    "                human_judgements.append(1)\n",
    "            elif score1 < score2:\n",
    "                human_judgements.append(0)\n",
    "            else: \n",
    "                print(\"tied?\")\n",
    "                \n",
    "            if result > 0.5:\n",
    "                gpt_judgements.append(1)\n",
    "            elif result < 0.5:\n",
    "                gpt_judgements.append(0)\n",
    "            else:\n",
    "                print(\"tied?\")\n",
    "\n",
    "            total += 1\n",
    "\n",
    "    kappa = cohen_kappa_score(human_judgements, gpt_judgements)\n",
    "    kappas.append(kappa)\n",
    "    print(kappa)\n",
    "    print(total)\n",
    "\n",
    "print(np.mean(kappas), np.std(kappas))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 286,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "human scores: 6.2 5.55\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['As an artisan, my decision to negotiate wouldn\\'t solely rest on how Jill phrases her negotiation attempt, but rather on a broader range of factors such as her appreciation for the craft, the current market dynamics, my business needs, and my appraisal of her genuine interest in the product.\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill genuinely expressed her interest in purchasing the vase and appreciate the craftsmanship, which are positive signals for negotiation. However, she approached the potential price negotiation more directly and professionally in Scenario 2, by acknowledging the value of the work that has gone into the vase, and the interest she has in the product, which makes me lean towards this scenario.\\n\\nReasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill opens up indirectly about the possibility of a price negotiation. She uses terms like \"wondering\" and \"any room for bargaining,\" which feel slightly distant and less direct.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill clearly appreciates the craftsmanship and mentions that she\\'s deeply considering the purchase, showing her recognition of its value. Additionally, she clearly states her request for a potential discount or price negotiation, showing a more direct and open approach.\\n\\nI believe that by establishing both her appreciation and demand plainly, Jill in Scenario 2 is giving off more confident and serious buyer vibes than in Scenario 1, which could positively influence my decision.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nAs an artisan, the skill, effort, time and materials that go into creating each piece of craft are significant factors taken into account when determining its price. That said, negotiation is not uncommon in such settings and a degree of flexibility can be expected. However, I would take into consideration how the request for negotiation is presented and if the customer appreciates the value of the work put into creating the vase. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the craftsmanship and expresses a desire to bargain without offering a specific price she is willing to pay. However, in Scenario 2, Jill goes beyond recognizing the craftsmanship to stating her appreciation for the work that went into it, thus showing a deeper understanding, respect and value for the work involved. Her request for a discount or negotiation is then made from a position of appreciation, which comes across as more considerate and respectful.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 2 as she demonstrates a comprehensive appreciation of the work involved. Her respectful approach might make me more open to negotiation even if it's just subtle. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"Both scenarios present Jill as a polite and appreciative potential customer who seems to genuinely value the craftsmanship of the vase. However, the main difference between the two scenarios lies in the way Jill approaches the subject of the price negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly asks if there is any room for bargaining on the price. This might feel like a more confrontational approach to some, and it's a clear indication that she's interested in reducing the price as much as she can.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is more careful and respectful in how she brings up the topic of price negotiation. She first compliments the craftsmanship and emphasizes how much she values it. She then gently suggests the possibility of a discount, indicating that she's interested in making the purchase but might be limited by her budget. \\n\\nGiven these factors, I would likely be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 2. Jill's detailed compliments in this scenario show her deep appreciation for the work that has gone into creating the vase, which indicates that she values the craftsmanship just as highly as the artisan does. Her polite and thoughtful approach to asking for a discount also suggests that she would likely respect the value of the artisan's work during the negotiation process.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 6.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\nWhile both scenarios present Jill as genuinely interested in and appreciative of the vase, there is a slight difference in how she approaches the topic of negotiation. In Scenario 1, Jill immediately shows her interest in the vase, acknowledges its unique quality, and only after all of this does she bring up the concept of a discount. This could potentially give the impression that she values the craftsmanship and the time and effort that went into creating the vase.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 also does a good job in expressing Jill's admiration for the vase and local artisans, but she introduces the concept of a discount as a circumstantial necessity because of her current budget. It somewhat gives the impression that she might be more willing to pay the full price if it was within her budget.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses admiration for the vase and explains her interest in it. However, there are subtle differences which may influence our willingness to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the work and craftsmanship that has gone into the creation of the vase. This appreciation signifies her understanding of the vase's value, suggesting that she may be willing to meet halfway in terms of price. However, she doesn't present a personal or compelling reason for a price negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill shares a personal story stating her support for local artisans and desire to incorporate their work into her home. Moreover, she provides a specific, relatable reason for requesting a discount- the current price is beyond her present budget. This personal touch, combined with her love for artisan-made goods might make us more likely to empathize with her situation and negotiate a price that fits her budget, while also maintaining the value of our craftwork.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill makes it clear that she values the vase and appreciates the work that has gone into crafting it. However, in the second Scenario she also explains that she is a supporter of local artisans which could imply repeat business and free word of mouth advertising, enhancing future sales.\\n\\nFurthermore, she justifies her request for a discount by stating that the current price slightly exceeds her budget. So, it appears reasonable to offer a small discount to Jill in scenario 2 to secure her as a customer and potential repeat buyer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 6.8\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill are very flattering and respectful, but only one subtly reveals an aspect that would make me more likely to negotiate on the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase, but she also implies future purchases by asking if there are deals for repeat customers. This shows her intent to support my work regularly, which is a big encouragement for small businesses and local artisans like myself. A loyal customer might be worth a small discount on this sale, especially if it means fostering a relationship that results in multiple purchases over time.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill definitely admires the vase and expresses interest in buying it, she only talks about this single purchase. There's no firm indication of any further purchases or ongoing support.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price or offer a deal to Jill in the first scenario, because it suggests a potential for ongoing business, rather than simply a one-off purchase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[Reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present Jill as a well-mannered and genuinely interested customer, the first scenario has a stronger potential for negotiation. In Scenario 1, Jill demonstrates a high level of appreciation for the artisan's work, which may make them more amenable to negotiation. Also, the fact that she talks about being a repeat customer and keeping on supporting the artisan's work in the future could instigate a sense of trust and willingness to negotiate. The potential for future sales may tip the scales in favor of a one-time discount. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her willingness to purchase it, appealing subtly to both a negotiation on the price and the artistic value of the item. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill introduces the potential for future purchases by positioning herself as a repeat customer who would love to continue supporting your work when she comes back to the market. This consideration enhances your relationship with her, establishing loyalty and continuity which could lead to more consistent sales and potentially word of mouth advertising. \\n\\nFrom a business standpoint, fostering good relationships with loyal customers is a critical aspect. It's easier and more cost-effective to retain a good customer than to acquire a new one, and repeat customers often end up spending more in the long run. Even a small discount now could pay off in potential future sales and customer loyalty.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer that appreciates the craftsmanship and quality of the vase, but there are subtle differences between the two. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill does not only commend the quality of work but also sees its value, indicating she's willing to pay the full price. However, she also presents a mutually beneficial proposition. She offers to use her social media influence to promote the artisan's work in exchange for a small discount. This can serve as an opportunity for extended reach and potential new customers for the artisan, which may outweigh the loss from the small discount offered.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill praises the work but simply asks for a discount without offering any mutual benefit. The request seems to be leaning more towards personal interest as opposed to the mutual benefit presented in Scenario 1.\\n\\nGiven these differences, I'd be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. The potential gain of promotion and reaching new customers can exceed the minor loss from the discount. Additionally, this scenario shows a customer who understands and appreciates the value of handcrafted work and is not merely seeking a price reduction out of pure interest. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nBoth scenarios demonstrate a respectful and admiring approach from Jill towards the handcrafted vase. Jill acknowledges the time, effort, and skill required to design and create the vase in both scenarios. However, the main difference lies in the impetus for a potential discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers a form of value exchange for a discount. She proposes to promote the vase and my craftsmanship through social media where she has quite a following. This could lead to further exposure and possibly more clients for me. Although it's not guaranteed, the potential exposure could provide long-term benefits that outweigh the immediate benefit of selling the vase at the full price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill expresses interest and admiration, she doesn't propose a value exchange for a discount. She only expresses her willingness to negotiate the price, making it a one-sided request for a lower price. This doesn't provide additional benefits to me compared to the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer who appreciates the artistry behind the vase, which is encouraging for any artisan. However, what makes a significant difference between the two scenarios is Jill's offer in Scenario 1, where she is not just asking for a discount but is offering to expose my work to a potentially much larger audience through her social media. \\n\\nThis offer could mean more exposure and potentially more customers coming my way. So even if I might be taking a small hit by giving her a discount on the vase, the potential benefits from the increased exposure could more than compensate for it. \\n\\nBesides, in Scenario 2, the customer is only asking for a discount but doesn't offer anything in return. While it is a normal part of doing business in a marketplace to negotiate prices, without any added benefit, I would be less inclined to offer a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.7\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a willing buyer with a genuine appreciation for craftsmanship and local artisans, potentially indicating a long-term customer relationship. In scenario 1, Jill emphasizes not only her admiration for the vase but also the importance of supporting local artisans like myself. She openly discloses her budget constraints which shows honesty and a willingness to negotiate. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, though Jill praises the craftsmanship extensively, she doesn’t give much personal information or emphasize potential future purchases or support. She asks for a discount or negotiation directly making it a bit more transactional instead of relational. \\n\\nTherefore, based on the information from both scenarios, I am inclined to favor the former where Jill expresses a desire to support local artisans overall and illustrates a degree of budget transparency. This provides a strong foundation for not only a single purchase negotiation but potentially a long-term customer relation where she could purchase more items, tell friends and family about my products, or even become a regular supporter contributing to local crafts culture. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen deciding which scenario makes negotiation more likely, it's crucial to consider how the customer approaches the situation and the respect they show towards the artisan's work. While both scenarios are similar, there is a nuanced difference.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses her admiration for the vase and reveals her budget constraints, which could motivate the artisan to help her out by reducing the price. However, it's her explicit statement of supporting local artisans that might be most persuasive. This statement values the artisan's work and their contribution to the community, and might prompt a positive response from the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also shows admiration and acknowledges the exceptional craftsmanship in the vase, but there's less of an indication that she really understands or values the significance of local artisans. Her request for a discount, therefore, feels slightly more transactional and less personal.\\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios have their respective strengths, the key difference lies in Jill's framing of her request and the underlying respect for artisanal work she communicates.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios show Jill having a genuine interest in the craftsmanship and appreciating the value of the locally handcrafted vase, which is a good start for negotiating. It's always more likely to be open to price negotiation when a customer shows real appreciation for your work and genuinely wants to support you.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly states that she loves supporting local artisans and finds the work unique. She also is honest about needing to stretch her budget, implying she values the item but just cannot afford the listed price. This kind of straightforward honesty is often appreciated.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the craftsmanship and expresses interest in it. However, she only hints towards wanting a negotiation or discount without explicitly mentioning her budget constraints or that the current price is an issue for her. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\nWhile both instances might lead to a price negotiation because of Jill's appreciation for the work, in Scenario 1, Jill's directness about her budget constraints makes it more likely that she will be offered a price negotiation as it is clear there is both appreciation for the work and a want for the item, but a financial limitation in acquiring it.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Both scenarios present a customer who appreciates the value of the piece and expresses an interest in supporting your work. However, there are a few key differences that might influence your willingness to negotiate the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill explicitly asks for a discount or negotiation on the round flower vase. She appreciates the craftsmanship which shows that she values your work. However, she didn't commit to buying it yet or promised to come back for more.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only expresses her admiration for your work but also her intention to support local artisans in the future. The promise of her becoming a returning customer could potentially lead to more sales compared to Scenario 1, especially if she recommends your products to others.\\n\\nFinally, Jill also inquires if there is any discount for future purchases or for buying multiple items. This shows that she is possibly interested in buying more than just the round flower vase. \\n\\nFor these reasons, being interested in securing a potential long-term customer and potentially selling more than one item, you would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill's approach in both scenarios is courteous and respectful; she expresses admiration for the vase and acknowledges the value of the craftsmanship.\\n\\nYet, in Scenario 1, she directly asks for a price negotiation or discount. In Western bargaining cultures, this direct approach is common and typically initiates bargaining. However, this approach is generally less effective than Scenario 2, mainly because it's a one-shot deal without any promise of future engagement or business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill takes a more strategic stance. She not only compliments the product, but she also makes a point of noting her intention to support local artisans. Moreover, she floats the idea of buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. This scenario sweetens the negotiation deal for the artisan. Jill is expressing an interest in creating an ongoing customer relationship, potentially resulting in more net profit in the long run for the artisan.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential for repeat business and sale of more items, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 2 due to the possibility of a long-term, mutually beneficial business relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the work and effort put into crafting the vase and expresses her genuine interest in purchasing it. She is direct in discussing the idea of a price negotiation. The consideration here is if Jill's appreciation and possibility of negotiation would seem enticing enough to reduce the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill uses a more indirect approach to negotiate the vase's price. She praises the vase's craftsmanship and shows support for local artisans. Jill also suggests her intention to be a returning customer and her interest in buying multiple items. The resale potential and the idea of having a loyal customer could be motivating.\\n\\nBased on these scenarios, my decision would lean towards Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: In Scenario 2, Jill shows potential not just as a one-time customer, but possibly a recurring one, which can benefit the business in the long run. Also, she expresses interest in purchasing multiple items, which could lead to a higher total sale even if the items are priced slightly lower. The combination of long-term customer relationship building and higher total sales makes Jill's proposal in Scenario 2 more appealing.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as an appreciator of artisan work who sees value in the vase but is hoping for a discount. However, the key deciding factor between these two scenarios is the additional benefit the artisan could secure beyond the sale of the vase. In Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms, which could potentially attract more buyers and increase business in the long run. This kind of promotion can work as free advertising, reaching an audience that the artisan might not have access to. Therefore, the potential long term financial benefit is something to bear in mind.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the compliment from Jill acknowledges the work and craftsmanship that has gone into the vase, but she offers no additional benefit that would compensate for the reduction in price. Her statements only express readiness to negotiate, but she doesn't bring something extra on the table as Scenario 1 does.\\n\\nOn the basis of the above reasoning, I would be more likely to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI'm more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 and this is mainly due to a few reasons. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill is offering me something in return for the discount – publicity on her social media platforms. This can be a great way to reach a wider audience and potentially attract more customers. As an artisan, exposure can be crucial in expanding my customer base.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill flatters my workmanship generously, acknowledging my talent and the uniqueness of the locally made product. She also manifests appreciation for local artisans and the worth of supporting them. Her admiration builds up a rapport and creates a positive line of communication.\\n\\nAlthough this could potentially reduce my revenue initially, Scenario 1 proposes a specific exchange: some loss now, but potentially gain later with the advertisement. However, in Scenario 2, Jill only compliments the vase and asks for a price cut, without offering anything in return. While her interest and compliments are appreciated, they don’t clearly benefit my business outside of this one sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, it appears that Jill is truly interested in the vase in both situations. However, the key elements in both scenarios differ.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill commends the quality of the vase and expresses interest, but only asks for a discount without offering anything in return.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 1 not only has Jill appreciating the craftsmanship, but she also proposes an exchange of sorts. While she asks for a price reduction, she also offers to share the works on her social media profile, which could potentially mean more exposure and therefore, potential clients for me.\\n\\nThough I value my work and the listed price of the vase, the prospect of more visibility and potential customers might lead me to negotiate in this case. Therefore, Scenario 1 seems to present the best case for negotiation to happen.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nAlthough both offers from Jill are similar in that she is proposing a negotiation, the circumstances are different. In scenario 2, Jill simply appreciates the work and asks for a discount without any exchange of value. On the other hand, in scenario 1, Jill is offering something in return - the promotion of my work on her large social media platforms. Therefore, taking into consideration her proposition would mean the potential of my brand reaching a broader audience, thereby increasing visibility and potentially driving more business to me in the long run. As an artisan at a local market, this kind of exposure can be invaluable and could outweigh the slight discount provided to Jill.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom an artisan's perspective, both scenarios as proposed by Jill are compelling in their own ways. In Scenario 1, Jill offers a form of promotion in exchange for a discount on the vase. If she indeed has a large following on her social media platforms and posts regularly about her purchases and experiences, this could serve as valuable advertisement for the artisan's work and possibly bring in more customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses her admiration for the craftsmanship of the vase and the work that's gone into creating it. She acknowledges the value of the item while still proposing a discount. This shows respect for the artisan's craft and suggests that she would value the item and might even become a repeat customer in the future.\\n\\nHowever, it can be harder to quantify the value of potential exposure through a social media post as offered in Scenario 1, and there's no guarantee that it would lead to increased sales. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill presents a direct and straightforward request for a discount that acknowledges the value of the artisan's work. This gives a sense of respect and sincerity, which is very important in such negotiation situations.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios emphasize appreciation for the craft, which is a good starting point. However, there are a few distinct differences between the two approaches.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only shows interest in the vase but also provides a solution that could potentially benefit both parties. By offering to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms, she's suggesting a form of barter that may widen the artisan’s customer base in return for a discount. Considering the importance of social media in promoting businesses today, this can be a valuable offer besides mere appreciation on her part for the handcrafted item. \\n\\nScenario 2 also shows appreciation from Jill for the fine craftsmanship but just asks for a discount without giving a reasoning or offering a potential return value for the artisan. It is a straightforward, but less persuasive, negotiation tactic.\\n\\nTherefore, given the potential benefits outlined, an artisan might be more likely to negotiate based on the conditions set in scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nNegotiation is not just about the immediate sale but also building relationships for future sales and gaining loyal customers. In both scenarios, Jill demonstrates an appreciation for the vase and its craftsmanship, however, there are important differences between the two.\\n\\nScenario 1 offers two incentives for me to consider a discount: the potential for multiple item purchases, and a promise of future return business. By mentioning the possibility of buying other items, Jill is increasing the potential for a larger immediate sale, not just the $30 from the vase. Additionally, the prospect of a long-term relationship and repeat business from Jill could significantly increase my future revenue. Offering her a discount could be a strategic investment in customer loyalty in order to get a future return.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also shows her admiration for the vase and indicates her interest in a discount, she doesn't propose any additional incentives for the purchase. The potential future gain in scenario 2 isn't as profitable for me.\\n\\nSo even though a price negotiation could happen in either scenario, considering these factors, I'd be more likely to negotiate the price in the former case.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill appealing to my understanding and appreciation of the craftsmanship of the vase. However, the two scenarios actually differ in terms of their potential long-term results. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only interested in purchasing one item but also signals her intention to buy multiple items. This means more sales for me. Jill also mentions her intention of becoming a returning customer. This will result in future purchases and set a foundation for customer loyalty. Offering a discount to Jill in Scenario 1 could yield a higher long-term profit and build a loyal customer base.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, suggests Jill's singular interest in the vase with no mention of potential recurrent purchases or customer loyalty. \\n\\nTherefore, considering long-term profit and customer rapport, I would be more inclined to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 1, where Jill shows interest in multiple purchases and repeat business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons for considering a price negotiation. However, in Scenario 1, Jill mentions multiple factors that may influence the decision to negotiate the price, such as buying more than one item, which would immediately increase the total revenue from the sale. Additionally, Jill also indicates she plans to become a returning customer, which means potential future revenue and a strengthened customer relationship.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, includes compliments on the vase, expressing strong interest which might potentially lead to a purchase even without a discount. While Jill does ask for a discount or price negotiation, she does not provide any additional incentives for the vendor to lower the price such as in Scenario 1 with the promise of buying multiple items or becoming a returning customer.\\n\\nTherefore, from a business perspective and based on the information provided, negotiating on the price would be more justified in Scenario 1 where it could lead to increased immediate and future revenue alongside a strengthened customer relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFirstly, negotiation is essential in business, and as a local artisan, I may be more inclined to negotiate price based on certain advantageous factors or incentives. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill provides multiple potential benefits for giving her a discount. She mentions the possibility of being a returning customer, which means more potential sales in the future. She also offers to promote my work on her social media in exchange for a discount. This endorsement could help me reach a bigger audience and ultimately increase my customer base. Both of these factors make offer from Jill in Scenario 1 a profitable trade-off for a reduced price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses interest in buying it, she doesn't offer any specific reasons or incentives for a discount beyond simply asking if it's possible. Her negotiation does not extend beyond the immediate sale, which, while certainly not negative, doesn't bring the same potential long-term benefits as Jill's proposal in Scenario 1.\\n\\nHence, considering these points, negotiation would be more beneficial for me in Scenario 1 as it potentially gives me subsequent sales and a wider market reach.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"The likelihood of offering a negotiation strongly depends on the individual seller's perspective. However, in terms of potential benefits to the business, I would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1.\\n\\nReasoning:\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering several compelling reasons for a potential discount. Firstly, she expresses an intention to become a repeat customer which could mean consistent business in the future. Secondly, she shows interest in buying multiple items at once which often warrants a small reduction in price. Lastly, she offers to endorse the products on social media. As someone with a few thousand followers, this could provide some valuable marketing exposure, resulting in increased sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill does compliment the craftsmanship and indicates interest in purchasing the vase, she doesn't offer any extra incentive that would directly benefit your business in terms of future sales or marketing exposure.\\n\\nHowever, taking the negotiation decision should not only base on this single interaction, as Scenario 2 might lead to a stronger bond of trust with the customer, leading to potential word-of-mouth advertising and possibly returning business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nFrom a business standpoint, both scenarios provide incentives to consider a negotiation. However, they present different opportunities, and the best scenario depends on what I, as an artisan, value more. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows interest in being a repeat customer and speaks about the possibility of promoting my work on her social media. This could potentially provide some free marketing and bring in new customers. Continual business and broad exposure to a new customer base can be very beneficial, especially if Jill's followers are within my target demographic. The discount could be seen as a marketing cost.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the craftsmanship but doesn't necessarily offer any additional value, like the promise of repeat business or exposure in Scenario 1. Nonetheless, her appreciation for the product is genuine, and as an artisan, I may feel satisfied knowing my work is being valued. \\n\\nThe decision depends on crafting satisfaction vs. potential business growth. \\n\\nAnswer: Essentially, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 1 due to the potential long term benefits for my business.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn evaluating the two scenarios, we need to consider the motivation for negotiation and the potential returns.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and the value of the vase. She's shown understanding of the work that goes into each piece, indicating that she understands the price is not arbitrary. This could potentially mean that she's in a position of not being able to afford the vase at its current price but really wants to purchase it. If we negotiate with her, we might not only sell this vase but also earn a loyal customer who could make more purchases in the future.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill proposes a sort of partnership where she promotes the artisan's work on her social media page in exchange for a discount. The effectiveness of this strategy depends on a number of factors that aren't given in the scenario, including the number of followers Jill has, their interest in handcrafted items, and how engaging or influential Jill is as a personality on social media. If done effectively, this offer has the potential of increasing our visibility and attracting more customers, but it's a gamble.\\n\\nOverall, in the absence of further information about Jill's social media influence, Scenario 1 seems to be a safer option. It is a more direct transaction, we understand what we're gaining and losing, and there's less inherent risk.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[Reasoning Text]\\nWhile both scenarios present potential reasons to negotiate, the choice largely depends on the immediate goal and priorities as an artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill openly appreciates the craft and seems genuinely interested in the vase. However, she does not provide a concrete benefit for offering a discount outside of the immediate sale. The benefit to the artisan here is selling the vase and potentially building a relationship with a customer who shows appreciation for craft.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers a tangible benefit to the artisan beyond the immediate sale of the vase. By promising to promote the artisan's work on social media, she provides a potential opportunity for the artisan to reach a wider audience and potentially earn more sales in the future. If Jill indeed has a substantial number of followers who might be interested in artisan crafts, her promotion could significantly impact the artisan's business.\\n\\nHowever, it's also worth considering the risks here. There is no guarantee that Jill's promotion would lead to more sales, and the discount would mean an immediate smaller profit on the vase. The artisan would also need to trust Jill to follow through on her promise.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I would suggest the artisan would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2, assuming they value the potential exposure over the immediate return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: \\nIn both scenarios, the customer, Jill, is complimenting my work and expressing a genuine interest in the round flower vase, which is always appreciated. However, the scenarios differ in what they offer in return for a possible discount. In Scenario 1, Jill is only asking for a discount without providing a clear benefit for me beyond the sale of the vase itself. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is not just asking for a discount, she's also offering me something in return, which is the promotion of my work to her network of followers on social media. This means that if I were to give her a discount, there's a chance that it could lead to more potential customers who might be interested in my handcrafted items. This potential for future business makes Scenario 2 more attractive.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios show an appreciation for the craftsmanship of the vase, the first scenario offers a potential benefit to me, the artisan. Jill is proposing a trade of sorts where she receives a discount on the vase, in return, she will promote my works on her large social media platforms. This could potentially lead to increased sales and recognition of my craft which can be beneficial in the long term. \\n\\nOn the contrary, scenario 2 offers appreciation and interest in the product but does not present a value addition for me. Jill requests a discount, but offers nothing in return. Though this might be a more usual scenario in which price negotiations come up, it's less likely to engender a sense of a mutually beneficial exchange.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are strong and carry plausible arguments for negotiation. However, considering the value in return, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in the first scenario.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering something in return for a discount - exposure to a wider audience through her social media platforms. This exposure has the potential to attract more customers to my stall, and thereby increase my sales and revenue. It could also bring greater recognition for my work, thus increasing its value in the long run. It is a win-win situation - Jill gets her discount, and I get the advantage of marketing without any cost.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, although Jill is flattering and appreciative of my craft, she is not giving a concrete reason or offering anything in return for the discount. Thus, the probability of gaining something beneficial from the negotiation is lower compared to Scenario 1.\\n\\nTherefore, I will be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1, as it offers greater potential benefits for my craft and business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nGenerally, I would consider to negotiate on the price in both scenarios as Jill is expressing recognition for the craftwork and showing interest in purchasing the vase. However, I would be more interested in negotiating in Scenario 1.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only showing her interest and appreciation but also offering a unique way to help my business. She is offering to introduce my crafts to her social media following, which could potentially bring more customers. It's not just about selling one vase at a discounted price, it's also an investment to potentially increase the exposure of my craftwork and attract more customers. As an artisan, it would be beneficial to have my works shared and recognized by more people. \\n\\nWhereas in Scenario 2, Jill is simply asking for a discount without offering anything besides her appreciation in return. While I appreciate her kind words, it doesn't offer the same potential benefit to me as an artisan and business owner. \\n\\nOf course, the value of Jill's offer in Scenario 1 would largely depend on the size and engagement of her social media following. But without considering the specifics of her social media audience size and engagement, based on the two scenarios provided, I would likely be more willing to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: Each scenario has Jill expressing interest in the round flower vase and attempting to negotiate the price. In Scenario 2, Jill simply compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and asks for a possible discount. Although her appreciation is fairly evident, there's no significant benefit for the artisan if the price is reduced. On the other hand, in Scenario 1, Jill proposes a trade-off. She asks for a discount but offers promotion of my work on her social media platforms in exchange. This publicity could potentially bring in new customers and foster more sales. Therefore, this proposal has a clear advantage for me, as it provides an opportunity for my work to reach a larger audience. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile it's evident Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase in both scenarios, the situations present different opportunities. In Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media platforms. This can potentially bring in a larger customer base, increasing my sales in the long run. It's a form of barter trade, which could be mutually beneficial. Therefore, I am enticed by the added value, making me more willing to discuss a discount in return for the promotion. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill expresses her appreciation for the vase but doesn't offer anything beyond the purchase of the vase itself. While it's still a valid enquiry in a market setting, my interest in negotiation could be less, because there is less added value for me.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn this case, I would be more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 1. While both scenarios show interest and appreciation in the craft, it's Scenario 1 where Jill not only compliments the work but also offers value in exchange for a discount. The value mentioned here is free promotion on her social media, which can lead to more exposure and potential new customers for the business. This kind of trade-off is beneficial, especially for local artisans who may not have a lot of marketing resources. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 6.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios put forward by Jill are persuasive; however, there are distinctions in the way she communicates her interest in the vase that could influence my decision as the artisan. In scenario 1, she compliments my craftsmanship and gently implies that she would like a decrease in the price without revealing too much about her personal interest or constraints. It's a more direct and less invested approach, expecting a no-frills negotiation.\\n\\nOn the other hand, scenario 2 goes a step further by not only complimenting the craftsmanship but also explaining her personal attachment to, and support for, local artists' wares. This more emotionally charged approach shows that she feels a real connection with the vase, sees its unique value, and would truly cherish it. Moreover, she frames her request for a price drop around her own current budget constraints - which make her negotiating position more compelling without downgrading the work put into the vase.\\n\\nBoth are respectful requests, yet the plea in scenario 2 feels more compelling due to the personal connection she expresses toward the vase and the sentiment behind supporting local crafts.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nUnder both circumstances, Jill compliments the vase and hints at negotiating its price. But, in scenario 2, Jill does a few more things which might make me more open to price negotiation. \\n\\nFirst, she appreciates not just the product, but also me as an artisan, emphasizing that she values and supports local craftsmen. This recognition is encouraging and makes me feel more connected to her and more inclined to help her out. \\n\\nSecond, she explains why she is asking for a discount - the current price is slightly out of her budget. When customers openly explain their situation, it feels more validating for a seller and may sway them into providing some concession.\\n\\nTherefore, in scenario 2, Jill is not only flattering the work, but she is also building a rapport, showing respect for the craft, and providing a valid rationale for her request which in my opinion is a more compelling scenario to negotiate the price.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill seems genuinely interested and appreciative of the handcrafted vase which to a certain degree, makes one prone to be open to negotiation. However, there's a slight variation in how Jill communicates her interests and the possibility for a price negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and then lightly throws in the prospect of a price negotiation. She doesn't give reasons to warrant a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, aside from praising the vase, Jill goes an extra step to declare her support for local artisans and express her intent to add the vase to her collection. Additionally, she gives a valid reason - working on a tight budget at that particular moment, for asking for a discount.\\n\\nThe additional information provided in Scenario 2 would likely make it more compelling as the explanation provokes empathy, given everyone faces financial hiccups occasionally. Besides, knowing that the vase will be appreciated in a home (and not resold for profit) could also be a motivating factor towards negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 6.8\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: Both scenarios offer opportunities for negotiation, but they differ in key aspects. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows high interest and enthusiasm for the artisan's work and hints at potential future purchases, a business asset that artisans appreciate. The promise of a returning customer who not only appreciates high-quality craftsmanship but also shows willingness to sustain a relationship and directly promote the artisan's business in the future is a factor to consider. It's important to maintain a good relationship with repeat customers who, in the long run, can significantly contribute to the artisan's business growth. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, although Jill is complimentary of the vase and queries about price negotiation, she doesn't give indications of future purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe willingness to negotiate prices would largely depend on the artisan's principles or business model, but objectively, Scenario 1 might have a slightly higher chance of successful negotiation as Jill offers a future business proposal. She directly indicates her interest in becoming a repeat customer and providing continual support for the artisan's work. This is something that any business person would value immensely - the prospect of having loyal customers. Therefore, it could lead the artisan to consider giving a small discount on the vase as an investment in what could potentially become a long-term business relationship.\\nMoreover, Jill’s approach in Scenario 1 seems more polished, showing admiration for the vase and the artisan's skill, as well as showing interest in the future production, which may also influence the artisan’s decision to negotiate.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill also compliments the artisan's work but doesn't provide any concrete promise or proposal for future business. The slight edge Scenario 1 has is the mentioned potential of future transactions.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: In Scenario 1, Jill not only compliments the artisan's work, but also shows interest in becoming a repeat customer. This promise of future business could make the artisan more willing to negotiate on the price, as they may see it as an investment towards future sales. Jill also explicitly asks about deals for repeat customers, which could provide an opportunity for the artisan to create a customer loyalty program if they don't already have one. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill still compliments the work, she merely asks out of curiosity about price negotiation and does not indicate that she would be a returning customer.\\n\\nEven though both customers compliment the artisan and their work, Jill in Scenario 1 seems more forthcoming about her intent and genuinely interested in supporting the work further.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 6.55\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision will be based on the potential for future sales and the way the request for negotiation is presented. In Scenario 2, Jill not only praises the craftsmanship of the vase just like in the first scenario, but she also expresses her plan for future purchases and returning to the market. This information suggests that there is potential for future sales, which is beneficial for an artisan selling in the market. In addition, Jill asks about discounts for returning customers or multiple purchases, which shows her interest and potential commitment as a recurring customer. While negotiating the price of one item might lead to a temporary small loss, the profits from the potential future purchases could outweigh this loss. Therefore, it might be more beneficial in the long run to agree on a slight price negotiation for the vase in the second scenario. \\nHowever, it's important to note that artisan pieces are generally priced based on the time, effort, and materials put into them. Any discounts should still respect the worth and value of the work done. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a respective and appreciative customer, which already makes me more open to negotiation. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill directly compliments my work and casually inquires if there's any room for negotiation. This scenario shows Jill is genuinely interested in the vase and is likely willing to buy, even at a slightly reduced price. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, there is a similar approach, but what persuades me more is the potential future business Jill mentions. She not only expresses her admiration of my work but also indicates a plan to return to the market and possibly buy more. This means potential return business and the chance to cultivate a loyal customer. This makes me more likely to offer a small initial discount to establish a good relationship. Her potential for a bigger spend over time could offset the small loss I take on this vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, showing genuine interest in the product. However, in Scenario 2, she also indicates that she plans to return to the market, suggesting potential for future purchases. This provides incentive to offer a discount or negotiate a lower price on the current item as an investment in potential future sales.\\n\\nIf we do strike a deal and lower the price slightly for her, there is a chance she might become loyal to our store. Moreover, if she is happy and satisfied with our service, she could also spread the word and bring in more customers for us.\\n\\nAnother significant consideration is that Jill expresses possible interest in purchasing more items. This could mean moving more items at once and increasing our immediate sales. \\n\\nThe commitment Jill shows in Scenario 2 fits better with our goals of not just earning a profit from this vase, but of gaining a loyal customer who could potentially make repeat purchases and spread the word about our quality products and excellent customer service.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nBoth of Jill's approaches are polite and express admiration for the craftsmanship of the vase, which is a good start to negotiation. However, in Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the vase but also offers a form of non-monetary exchange -- exposure on her social media platform. This indicates that she wants to support the artisan and spread the word about their work. Offering to publicize the artisan's work in exchange for a discount is not only showing respect for the artisan's skill, but also recognizing the value of such unique, handcrafted items. On the other hand, Scenario 2 seems like a more straightforward approach of negotiating for a deal but offers nothing in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: I would be more likely to negotiate price in Scenario 1 due to several reasons. Firstly, Jill is showing genuine interest and admiration for my work which implies that she values it and wouldn't undermine its worth. Secondly, she is clear and upfront about her intention to negotiate, which breeds goodwill and trust. Finally, her offer to highlight my work on her social media in return for some discount is quite appealing. This could serve as a form of marketing for my work, accessing her following could potentially attract more customers in the future. Thus, the slight loss in the original price could be offset by future sales prompted by her highlight. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning text: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship and effort gone into creating the vase, she is also offering a form of advertisement or marketing for my work. Making my work known to a larger audience could benefit me in the long run and possibly increase my sales in the future. Although she is asking for a discount, the potential benefits I might receive from the exposure through her social media outweigh the slight reduction in price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is just appreciating the vase and then expressing an interest in a possible price reduction without proposing any form of value in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows appreciation for the handcrafted vase and interest in purchasing it. However, she presents different arguments for a possible price negotiation - an immediate sale versus an expected steady return on investment.\\n\\nScenario 1 paints a picture where Jill intends to be a recurring customer who will purchase multiple items in the future. Given this, it entails a longer term benefit for my business with the potential for consistent sales over time. Also, this scenario suggests Jill values my work and is willing to financially support it, which aligns with my goal as an artisan - to create and sell pieces that bring joy to others.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, suggests an immediate sale of the vase, rather than a potential series of purchases over time. Jill's negotiation in Scenario 2 seems to be solely based on this single purchase, making this situation a short-term gain.\\n\\nAs a result of these reasons, I would likely be more inclined to negotiate on the price in the first scenario, as Jill's proposal and commitment to purchase more items promise a potential consistent return for my business. This would help in its growth and sustenance in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the customer, Jill, exhibits more knowledge about the artisan’s craft, emphasizes the importance of supporting local artisans, and expresses interest in becoming a recurring customer. Moreover, Jill implies a potential increase in future sales since she mentions a possible discount for multiple item purchases. She positions her request for a discount in a way that is not only beneficial to her but to the artisan as well.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the artisan's work and subtly proposes a price negotiation. However, she does not offer any additional incentives like potential future purchases, which implies a one-time transaction with no guaranteed return.\\n\\nGiven the potential for future purchases and establish a long-term customer relationship, Scenario 1 offers more value to the artisan, even if a discount is applied to the item. Therefore, the artisan would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios pose potential situations for negotiating the price of the vase. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, the customer is expressing an interest in being a returning customer, buying multiple items, and supporting local crafts. This suggests a future investment and brand loyalty, which is valuable for any business. A small discount now could help build a worthwhile relationship with a consistent customer which could lead to more profit in the future.\\n\\nOn the other hand, scenario 2 presents a one-time negotiation, where the customer is hesitating due to the price of a single item. There is a potential for a sale, however, no promise of future purchases or brand loyalty has been expressed. While it could be beneficial to negotiate to make the immediate sale, the long-term gain isn't as prominent as in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenarios 1 and 2, both customers are polite and compliment your work, which is a good start in facilitating positive negotiations. However, in Scenario 2, Jill goes a step further. \\n\\nShe is not only interested in one item but also expresses her intent to purchase multiple items and is planning to be a returning customer. For an artisan, a returning customer is a valuable asset considering they can bring you steady income and possibly refer others to your store. Moreover, she is supportive of local artisans and wants to support your work. \\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios are viable for negotiating, Scenario 2 presents a more compelling case due to the prospect of more future sales, not just the current one.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill demonstrate her genuine interest and admiration for my craftsmanship. However, there are significant differences between the two scenarios which may affect my decision to negotiate the price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly asked for a price negotiation. While appreciating my art, she didn't mention any particular financial constraint or offer an explicit promise of future purchases. The fact that she directly asked for a discount without giving a reason makes her request seem less reasonable.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill provided a number of compelling reasons for a price negotiation. She not only mentioned her tight budget, which means she might not be able to afford the item at its current price, but also expressed clear intent to return for future purchases. Furthermore, she asked if there are discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers, meaning she's considering not only this purchase, but also future engagements with my services. This appeals to my interest as a seller longing for a stable customer base. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\nThe multiple reasons Jill presented make her a more promising customer, hence, I would be more willing to negotiate in Scenario 2. A small discount now might earn much more in the future if she becomes a loyal customer. Furthermore, supporting her in her current financial tightness may build a stronger relationship, lead to word-of-mouth recommendations, and ultimately benefit my business in the long run.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing great appreciation for the craftsmanship involved in the vase but there's a significant difference between the two. In the first scenario, Jill is directly negotiating the price of this specific vase. It's a somewhat regular exchange often expected in markets like these.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill is not only interested in one item but intends on buying multiple items and even becoming a returning customer. She's implying a more long-term relationship with the artisan, which could lead to numerous purchases over time. This could mean more overall profit in the long run, compared to the one-time sale of the vase.\\n\\nProviding a discount can also help in building customer loyalty, an important factor in any business - even for artisans in a local market.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill displays an appreciation for locally made items and the work that goes into making them, which is great. While she expresses financial restrictions in both cases, in scenario 2, there is no explicit benefit to the artisan beyond the potential sale of the vase.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 1, Jill offers a resourceful alternative to a traditional cash transaction by offering her social media influence as a form of payment. If she indeed has a significant following, this exposure could lead to more sales in the future, making it a strategic move beyond the immediate sale of the vase. Therefore, scenario 1 provides a more convincing reason for why I might opt for a price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning Text:\\nWhile both scenarios indicating Jill's interest in the vase appear respectful and appreciative, Scenario 1 stands out as more enticing to negotiate the price for a few reasons. Firstly, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship but also acknowledges the importance of supporting local artisans, directly implying her respect for the work. Additionally, Jill proposes a form of compensation in the form of exposure on her social media platforms. If her follower base is indeed large and tended towards a love for artisan works, this exposure could lead to further sales and increased brand recognition. \\n\\nScenario 2 is a more straightforward price negotiation without any additional benefits for the artisan aside from making the sale. Although it's a polite request, it might not have the same overall benefit as offered in scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses her appreciation for the vase and recognition of your craftsmanship, but also makes a persuasive case for a discount. She offers to promote your work on her social media platforms in return, potentially expanding your customer base and increasing future sales. While it's not a guaranteed benefit, it's certainly a possibility that could work in your favor, particularly if her followers align with your target market.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also acknowledges your talent and the quality of your work, but offers no reciprocal value in return for a possible discount, simply asking if negotiation is possible without further justification. \\n\\nConsidering these points, it seems more beneficial for you to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1 where she offers something in return, that could potentially increase your product visibility and future sales. If her social media influence is as impactful as she suggests, this could end up being more profitable in the long run despite the upfront discount. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0.5, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill is approaching the negotiation differently in both scenarios, and both are valid tactics depending on the seller's preferences and outlook. \\n\\nScenario 1 offers a barter system of promotion in exchange for a discount, which can be appealing to many artisans looking to grow their business and gain customer base. The offer to share the work on social media platforms might bring in more customers, thus potentially resulting in more sales. This can be considered as free advertising, which could be invaluable for a small business or local artisan. It also must be noted that Jill particularly praises the craftsmanship and expresses her support for local artisanship sincerely which is always a plus.\\n\\nScenario 2, meanwhile, is a straightforward request for a discount. It's a simple method, and more traditional, but lacks the potential bonus of increased visibility and customer reach that Scenario 1 offers.\\n\\nHowever, in the case of Scenario 2, if the vase is very popular and typically sells without the need for discounts or promotions, the artisan might be less inclined to offer a discounted price. The choice between the scenarios then really comes down to how established the business is and whether an increase in visibility or immediate sale is more beneficial.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 would be more applicable if the artisan is looking for more exposure or is still establishing their business. However, Scenario 2 would be better for an established business that does not need additional marketing and values immediate profits over exposure.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile scenario 2 by Jill seems respectful and she acknowledges my talent, she does not offer anything in return other than payment for the vase, implying a simple customer-vendor transaction. My talent is acknowledged, but this might not help me garner more customers.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 1, while Jill still acknowledges my talent, she adds value to her proposal. First, she mentions that she has a large following on social media, suggesting that she can provide valuable publicity to my work. This is a plus point, as it potentially promotes my work to a wider audience. Second, Jill proposes to post a photo of the vase on her platforms and share my name/brand, which again increases my visibility and could potentially attract more customers.\\n\\nGiven this, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price in scenario 1 because I see it as an investment that could help bring more customers in the future. So, scenario 1 seems far more appealing to me as an artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning Text:\\nWhile both scenarios offer potential benefits for me as an artisan, Scenario 1 offers a potentially greater long term benefit. In this scenario Jill offers not only to purchase the vase, but also to market my work to her large social media following. This could lead to future sales, and more important, spread my craftsmanship to a larger audience. \\n\\nFurthermore, Jill also exhibits a passion for supporting local artisans, which means she is likely to be a repeat customer. Therefore, while providing a discount might reduce the immediate profits from the sale, the overall benefit from increased exposure and potential future sales is likely to be greater.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, only involves negotiation on the price for one piece. Jill expresses admiration for the vase and the craft, but does not propose any additional benefit like future promotion or sustained support for my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"In both scenarios, Jill has shown great admiration for the work, making it clear that she values the item. However, her approach to asking for a discount is slightly different in each situation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship and talent before asking for a possible price negotiation. This strategy appreciates the work put into the item and could encourage the artisan to consider a discount. It may also indicate that she intends to buy this single piece, which doesn't add additional sales for the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses her intention of buying multiple items and becoming a repeat customer. Not only does this promise potential future sales, but it also proposes added immediate sales if she purchases more than one item. This could be a compelling reason for an artisan to offer a discount.\\n\\nReasoning: Artisans, especially local players, often bank on developing a loyal customer base. While scenario 1 could potentially land an immediate sale, Scenario 2 provides an opportunity for more sales in the future and possibly several items during the current transaction. Maintaining a good relationship with a potential returning customer often has long-term benefits, and a small discount could foster this relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is appreciative of the artisan's work and interested in purchasing the vase. However, the nature of her propositions differ quite significantly.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is directly asking for a price negotiation on the single item she's interested in. This puts the artisan in a position where he would have to decide whether to accept less profit on this current transaction with the hope of building a good customer relationship for future sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is inquiring about discounts for purchasing multiple items or for being a returning customer. This implies that she's not only interested in the vase, but potentially other items as well, or even future purchases. The artisan might view this as a potential to increase sales both in the short and long term as she has shown interest in being a repeat customer.\\n\\nWhile in Scenario 1 the artisan might be reducing profit on one item, in Scenario 2, the promise of multiple sales or future transactions could potentially make up for the lost profit due to any discount given.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\nWhen it comes to price negotiation, it will depend on the seller's perception of the situation and the benefit they can attain. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is complimenting the artisan's work and wants to negotiate the price specifically for the vase. Yet, she doesn't promise any future purchase or loyalty to the artist. Rather, she is expressing an interest in a one-time purchase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is not only showing an interest in the vase but also expressing her intention to purchase multiple items and to become a returning customer. This offers potential for future business and a meaningful and advantageous relationship for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios create an opportunity for negotiation, but there are some subtle differences between them.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is personable and complimentary about the vase and my craftsmanship, which can sometimes influence sellers to lower their price slightly. However, there's no concrete commitment from her about future purchases or promotion.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, she not only expresses admiration for my work but also mentions future visits and potential bulk buys. More interestingly, she brings up the power of social media marketing. If she does have thousands of followers as she claims, her posting about my items could bring a fair amount of visibility to my stall – perhaps far more value than a slight discount on one vase. This kind of bartering can be quite beneficial for small businesses trying to increase their footprint.\\n\\nTherefore, answering the discussion, based on the concrete future benefits promised in social media marketing and repeated purchases, I'd be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 2.  \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows an appreciation for the craftsmanship of the vase, indicating that she values your work. In scenario 1, Jill's approach is more traditional and direct; she compliments your talent, generates a warm rapport and then inquires about a possible discount. This is a pretty standard approach for a customer attempting to negotiate price at a local market.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill offers something additional which can serve as a value proposition for you as an artisan. She not only expresses her intent to become a regular customer (indicating potential ongoing business), but also offers to promote your work to her social media followers. The latter can be quite beneficial in terms of gaining more exposure and potentially new customers to your business.\\n\\nThere is a chance that Jill might not follow through on her promises, but with scenario 2, you're not only selling a vase, but also potentially investing in marketing your business. It's risky, but it's also an opportunity.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2.\\n  \\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and subtly brings up the topic of negotiation. While this might be effective to a point, it is a direct price negotiation scenario. A small discount might be given, but there is no potential for a longer-term relationship beyond that immediate transaction, which could limit the amount of flexibility in the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill brings up the prospect of becoming a regular customer and purchasing multiple items. This has the potential to provide continuous business and income, which is beneficial for a small local business. A small discount on this purchase might lead to more purchases in the future. Furthermore, she offers to promote the business on her social media, suggesting she has a significant number of followers. This could substantially enhance the visibility of the business, bringing in more customers and implicitly helping in the growth of the artisan's business.\\n\\nConsidering these factors in both the scenarios, the artisan in a local market essentially being a small business owner, would find Jill's proposal in the second scenario more interesting and advantageous. Therefore the artisan is more likely to negotiate on the price in the second scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.8 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is very complimentary about the vase, appreciating the craftsmanship and recognizing its quality. This shows respect for the work and time that went into making it. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the vase but also offers a value proposition by suggesting a mutual benefit, where she will promote the works to her followers on social media platforms if a discount is offered. This could potentially direct more customers to the stall, thereby expanding the market and increasing sales. If Jill's social media following tends to value and purchase handcrafted items like the vase, this could create a sustained increase in income that outweighs the one-time discount on the vase.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is just asking for a price negotiation without suggesting any value exchange. It would simply be a one-sided benefit to her if the price were reduced.\\n\\nBased on this analysis, it would be more beneficial to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 due to the potential for increased exposure and customer traffic.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only acknowledges my craftsmanship but also offers a way she could reciprocate the favour of a discount. By promoting my products, stall, and overall work on her social media platform to a wider audience, she is implying that I could potentially gain more exposure, followers, and customers. Therefore, her request isn't just for a simple discount — it's a trade of services of sorts, which might greatly benefit me in the long run if her following is significantly large and engaged.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments my work but simply asks for a price reduction out of curiosity, without offering anything in return. While it's not inappropriate to negotiate at a market, the offer isn't as enticing as the scenario 1.\\n\\nSo, considering all these factors, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1 since Jill has provided an exchange of value.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not just asking for a discount, but she is also offering to advertise my work on her social media platforms. This could potentially attract more customers to my store. Even if I sell the vase to her at a slightly lower price, the potential financial gain from the increased exposure could be notable. This exchange represents a bartering of services, which is often encouraged in artisan markets as it can create a strong sense of community and mutual support. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, however, Jill is simply asking for a discount without offering anything in return. While I, as an artisan, may be open to negotiation, I’m also aware that the price needs to cover the cost of materials and the time I’ve spent on creating the vase. Hence, I would be less likely to offer a discount unless she could offer a compelling reason otherwise.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer that appreciates the craftsmanship and is interested in buying the vase, but each one approaches the negotiation differently. In scenario 1, Jill takes a personal approach. She showers praises about the vase and its uniqueness, and she also expresses her support for local artisans. After establishing a connection, she only then mentions that the price is slightly beyond her budget, setting a stage for sympathy and understanding. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill still appreciates the work, her approach is direct and transactional. She immediately jumps to the question of negotiation without providing a reason of why the price might be out of her range. Given these differences, I may be more inclined to negotiate in scenario 1.\\n\\nThe emotional connection and context provided in scenario 1 is more likely to persuade me to negotiate the price. Such a response shows not just interest in the product but also appreciation of the craftsmanship and an understanding of the value of supporting local artisans. This means that the customer likely values the product more than someone who primarily wants to negotiate the price without much of a backstory.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning:\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present Jill as a potential buyer interested in the vase, the way she approaches the negotiation sets the two scenarios apart. In the first scenario, Jill takes the time to appreciate the craftwork, connecting it to her lifestyle, supporting local artists, and subtly hinting towards her budget constraints. This not only shows genuine interest but personalises the exchange, making it easier to empathize with her circumstance. \\n\\nOn the other hand, the second scenario, while expressing admiration for the craft, is comparatively more straightforward about the negotiation and lacks the personal element present in the first scenario.\\n\\nPersonalization plays a pivotal role in negotiations, especially when it comes to handmade craft items, it not only builds a connection between the buyer and seller but also makes the buyer more likely to value and cherish the item purchased.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn evaluating both scenarios, the focus rests on two major considerations: respect shown to the artisan and their work in addition to the testament of financial constraint. Both scenarios showcase a commendation of the artisan's craftsmanship, reinforcing the value of the vase and expressing the customer's genuine admiration for it.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the quality of the vase but also emphasizes her patronage of local artisans, communicating an encapsulated understanding of how valuable such work is to the community. Jill also explicitly mentions that the vase's current price point is slightly beyond her budget.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 still showcases admiration for the vase's craftsmanship. However, Jill doesn't signify that she supports local artisans nor does she mention financial constraints, making the request for a lower price feel more like regular bargaining without a solid reason.\\n\\nWith these factors in mind, Scenario 1 has stronger arguing points for a price negotiation as Jill manifests her consistent support to local craftsmen and clearly states the reason it's difficult for her to purchase the vase at the current price. Thus, as the artisan, I'm more likely to feel moved by her situation and appreciate her support, leading me to negotiate the price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.25\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenario 1 and 2 shows Jill's interest in the handcrafted vase, however, their approaches are quite distinct. In scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship, highlights the uniqueness of the vase, and expresses her support for local artisans like me. She also provides the context of her budget constraints which is an understandable reason for asking a discount. Therefore, I would feel more inclined to lower the price, as Jill not only appreciates the work that goes into it but also has a valid reason for her request.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, while Jill does commend the craftsmanship, she transitions quickly to bargaining without offering much of a reason or context. Though this is a typical approach seen in markets, it lacks the personal connection established in scenario 1. It doesn't make me feel as if Jill values the time and effort I've invested in my work.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the given scenarios, both customers have shown a strong interest in the vase and appreciation for my work. However, in Scenario 1, Jill has not only complimented my craftsmanship, but she's also shared a personal detail about her budgetary constraints and her wish to support local artisans. This induces a certain empathy and creates a personal connection with the customer. Furthermore, her compliments are more detailed, thereby showing a higher level of appreciation for my work. Therefore, my inclination towards negotiation would be more strong here, as I would prefer supporting someone who genuinely admires my work and has a sincere need.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill starts by complimenting your craftsmanship and acknowledges that the attention to detail is something that she can't find elsewhere, suggesting she appreciates the uniqueness and quality of your work. She expresses her desire to support local artisans, which shows that she values your work in the community. Her request for flexibility in pricing is based on her personal financial constraints, rather than a reflection of what she thinks the vase is worth.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, while Jill also compliments your work, her language is a little more direct when it comes to asking for a price negotiation.\\n\\nBoth scenarios are pretty similar and many would argue that it doesn't make a significant difference in whether you decide to negotiate or not. Some people might find Jill's approach in Scenario 1 more appealing because she seems to have a deeper appreciation for the value of handcrafted items and supports local artisans.\\n\\nHowever, others might prefer the more straightforward approach in Scenario 2, where Jill acknowledges the impressive craftsmanship but gets more quickly to the point of bargaining.\\n\\nAnswer: This could potentially divide opinion, but I personally lean towards Scenario [1]. The detail Jill provides about her appreciation of the artisanship, understanding its uniqueness, and expressing support for local artisans suggests that she values this craft. Furthermore, she is polite in asking for flexibility due to her financial constraints. This level of respect and admiration for the work done might sway an artisan to consider negotiating the price.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning: \\nJill taking the time to praise the quality of my work and show interest in my craft would have a positive influence on my willingness to negotiate. In addition, when comparing scenario 1 and scenario 2, Jill in the first situation displays a deeper interest not only in the vase but in my overall work, suggesting the potential for future purchases. This would make me more inclined to provide her with a discount as a way to both appreciate her admiration and to encourage her return. On the other hand, in scenario 2, while Jill does express similar admiration, her interactions are straightforward and solely targeted at a single purchase without any explicit indication of future purchases. So, while I might consider negotiating in scenario 2 as well, scenario 1 presents a more appealing case due to the potential for continued business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and shows admiration for my work, but she also expresses interest in purchasing multiple items and becoming a regular customer. This shows that engaging with Jill could not only lead to a higher sale today but could also build a fruitful relationship for the future. Building a customer relationship and loyalty can have a greater benefit in the long run.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also shows appreciation for the quality of the vase, she immediately turns to bargaining, which could suggest a more one-off purchase without the possibility of buying multiple items or returning as a habitual client.\\n\\nFor these reasons, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\nIn business, not only is it essential to make sales but equally essential is establishing long-term, profitable relationships with customers. This fosters customer loyalty, repeat patronage and potential for more revenue streams. \\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, Jill expresses a wish to negotiate the price in both, but the key distinction comes with Jill’s intent as expressed in Scenario 1. She not only shows interest in the vase but also indicates the possibility of purchasing multiple items and being a returning customer in the future. This provides the potential for a continuous business relationship rather than a one-time transaction. Apart from more sales, having a returning customer also enhances the market reputation of the business.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 is a more straightforward negotiation for discount on a single piece. The promise of further patronage or multiple purchases does not exist explicitly.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the long-term business prospects as a priority over a single transaction, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.8\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:  \\nA) Considering the approach of both scenarios, it’s easier to connect to the request in Scenario 1 rather than Scenario 2. Jill not only compliments the craftsmanship but also express an interest in continued support, which indirectly means more business in the future. This kind of loyalty is very valuable for small business owners and artisans. \\n\\nB) Scenario 2's approach is more direct and only emphasizes the craftsmanship. Jill is interested in a bargain but does not show the same interest in continuity or emotional connection to the work.\\n\\nC) The concept of being a 'repeat customer' takes Scenario 1 up a notch. Assuring repeat sales is definitely a pro for any artisan or seller at a market. While both are likely to work, the repeat business proposition in Scenario 1 makes it a bit more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning:\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is complimenting the vase and expressing her interest in purchasing it. However, in scenario 1, she not only shows interest in the present product but also promises future purchases by asking about deals for repeat customers. This indicates that she is interested in becoming a recurring customer. This future potential of ongoing business is a significant incentive for me to negotiate with her. Additionally, she is willing to promote my work among her circle which might bring more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nThis entirely depends on the individual artisan's business policies and negotiation style. However, generally speaking, Jill's approach in Scenario 1 is likely to yield more positive results. This is for the following reasons:\\n\\n1. Appreciation: In both scenarios, Jill begins by appreciating the artisan's work, which is a good start. However, in Scenario 1, she goes on to express interest in supporting the artisan's work on a continuous basis. This will undoubtedly appeal to the artisan, who, like any business person, values loyal repeat customers.\\n\\n2. Possible future purchases: Jill instigates a possibility of repeat purchases in Scenario 1, which might make the artisan more open to giving her a discount now to secure potential future sales.\\n\\n3. Politeness: Jill is politely inquiring about a discount, rather than demanding one, which could lead the artisan to feel more inclined to consider her request.\\n\\n4. Win-win situation: Offering a deal for repeat customers can create a win-win situation where Jill gets a discount and the artisan gets repeat business. In Scenario 2, she only asks for a discount without offering anything in return.\\n\\nGiven these points, if the artisan is open to negotiation at all, they might be more inclined to do so in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.55\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill begins by complimenting your craftsmanship, this acknowledgement may instantly foster a more receptive attitude toward her. Furthermore, she shows potential for future business, mentioning that she plans on coming back and making additional purchases from you. This promise of future transactions encourages you to potentially reduce the price somewhat as a means of building a long-term customer relation, stimulating repeated business. This would increase your overall sales in the long term.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also compliments your craftsmanship, she is more direct and only focuses on getting a reduced price on the vase. She does not express an interest in other items or future purchases, so there's less motivation to give her a discount since it may just be a one-off purchase.\\n\\nBased on this reasoning:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, Jill gave the reasons for a price reduction in the first scenario; she commended the quality of my work, and then presented her intentions to be a returning customer, possibly purchasing more items in the future. This creates a long-term customer-salesman relationship, initiating the potential for further sales in the future. Her polite and appreciative manner further encourages me to reconsider the asking price and offer a discount. \\n\\nIn contrast, the second scenario does not give as compelling a reason to reduce the price. Jill still expressed her admiration for my work, but she didn't make promises of future purchases or loyalty to my stand.\\n\\nAs a result, the first scenario would make me more inclined to negotiate the vase's price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill has shown interest in the vase in both scenarios, meaning that as an artisan, I would be open to negotiation in either case. However, scenario 1 presents a more persuasive argument for offering a discount. \\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill praises my work, which not only could make me more amenable to negotiation because it feels good to be complimented, but also shows that she appreciates the value of my craft. Furthermore, she mentions her intention to be a returning customer. This prospect of repeat business is a strong incentive to offer a discount, as acquiring new customers is typically more expensive than retaining existing ones. Lastly, her suggestion to make multiple purchases is also an appealing proposition, as this would potentially increase my overall sales. \\n\\nGiven these reasons, I'd be more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 1 as it makes more business sense to do so.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship but also offers a potential promotional opportunity for the artisan's work while asking for a discount. The trade-off of potential discount for potential advertisement and increased visibility could sway the artisan in favor of reducing the price a bit. \\n\\nIn contrast, scenario 2, while Jill does express interest and admiration for the work, she doesn't offer any additional benefit, other than her purchase, to the artisan in exchange for a discount. \\n\\nConsidering the beneficial trade-off offered in scenario 1 in comparison to scenario 2, the artisan might be more inclined to negotiate the price in the former case.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill expresses a genuine interest and appreciation in the craftsmanship of the vase, which may make the artisan more willing to negotiate the price. However, in Scenario 1, Jill not only displays her interest in the vase but also offers something extra in return for a possible discount: promotion on her social media. This kind of advertisement can potentially attract more customers to the artisan's work, possibly leading to an increase in sales. This additional incentive can make a compelling case for offering Jill a discount, compared to Scenario 2 where Jill simply asks for a price reduction.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the quality of the vase and compliments the craftsmanship, which shows respect and understanding of the value of the product. More importantly, she offers to promote the artisan and their shop on her social media platform. This could potentially lead to increased visibility and hence, customer reach. It is, indirectly, a promotional quid pro quo, where the artisan could gain, in the longer term, more than what a small discount would cost.\\n\\nWhereas in Scenario 2, Jill gives a general compliment and only suggests a bargain but does not provide any added value or reason for the artisan to consider the negotiation.\\n\\nTherefore, Scenario 1 would likely be more appealing for negotiation, as the artisan might see a potential marketing opportunity besides the immediate sale. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill not only compliments your craftsmanship but also shows a genuine interest in the vase and its aesthetic value. She visualizes the vase in her living room, revealing more personal attachment and appreciation for the product. Moreover, she is offering to promote your product and store on her social media, which could potentially bring new customers and create more awareness about your work. This could be a value exchange, where you give her a discount and in return, get free promotion to grow your business. Though you might make a lesser profit on this particular sale, the publicity could potentially lead to more sales in the future, which is a win for you.\\n\\nOn the other hand, the second scenario is a plain interest in buying with an attempt to negotiate, showing less emotional connection to the vase or/and your work. It's a more straightforward potential transaction without any additional value offered to you as the vendor.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the reasoning explained above, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only expressing her admiration for the craftsmanship, but also emphasizes the personal value that the vase would have for her, suggesting strong interest and potential long-term customer loyalty. Additionally, she offers to promote the vase and the store on social media, which is a form of free advertising that has the potential to attract new customers, further driving business. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill expresses appreciation for the craftsmanship, she does not make a compelling argument as to why a price reduction may yield mutual benefits. She simply asks for a bargaining on the price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning text: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing genuine interest in the vase and appreciating the craftsmanship involved, which inherently increases the possibilities for a negotiation. However, the key difference lies in the manner the price negotiation is being approached.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only shows her admiration and potential use for the vase but also proposes a different kind of value exchange - promoting my store on her social media. This is not just a simple monetary transaction. If Jill has a significant following, her sharing and tagging my store could help boost my business's visibility and reach, possibly attracting more customers. This is certainly a valuable offer beyond merely purchasing the vase.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill appreciates my work but the negotiation is purely on reducing the price without any additional offering to potentially increase the value of the transaction from her side.\\n\\nGiven these aspects, I would be more open to negotiation in the first scenario, where an additional advantage is possible to accrue.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning: \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill explains her genuine appreciation for the artisan’s work. She explicitly mentions that she is a significant supporter of local artisans, showing her respect for their work and her knowledge of the value of handmade work. She clearly expresses her love for the piece and her intention to cherish it, which might appeal to the artisan\\'s emotions and increase the likelihood of negotiation. Furthermore, by saying the price is a \"tiny bit over\" her budget, she is not undermining the value of the piece. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the craftsmanship but immediately inquiries about a possible price reduction, which might make the artisan feel as if she is undervaluing their work.\\n\\nTherefore, the artisan might feel more comfortable to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1 where she acknowledges the value of his work more.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill acknowledges the value of the artisan's work and expresses interest in supporting local craft. However, in Scenario 1, Jill gives a slightly more personalized rationale for asking for a discount - she expresses her love for the item and mentions that it's just above her budget. This justifies her request in a more compelling way and may encourage the artisan to empathize with her situation. Consequently, the artisan might be more lenient in offering a discount or negotiating the price to make the item affordable for her while maintaining a good relationship with a customer who values and supports local artisans.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: In scenario 1, Jill uses a complimentary approach to express her interest in the vase and my craftsmanship. She also emotionally appeals by mentioning her support for local artisans, which might make me feel more obliged to help her out. Her request for a small discount is also framed more politely, indicating she values my work.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is straightforward in expressing her interest in the vase and directly asking for a price negotiation, there's no particular reason given why she wants a discount, which makes it feel less personal. \\n\\nAlthough this could vary depending on personal preferences, it's usually preferable to negotiate with customers who show appreciation for the craft and the effort put into it, rather than those who just want a lower price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly asks if there's any chance for negotiation over the price. This could put the artisan in a situation where they might not necessarily want to offer a discount given the time, resources, and skill invested into handcrafting the vase. However, they may consider it if they believe losing the sale altogether would be a worse outcome. \\nIn Scenario 2, Jill pays compliments to the artisan and their craftsmanship. She shows interest in becoming a regular customer and supporting the artisan on a long-term basis. The hint about the return purchases and discounts for regulars also shows an interest in more products in the future. This scenario provides an opportunity for the artisan to build a relationship with Jill, consequently bringing in more business over time. Considering this, the artisan might be more willing to adjust the price or offer some discount to Jill as an investment into a future regular customer. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is interested in the vase and is directly asking for a discount on the current marked price. She is offering a straightforward one-time sale which is good for immediate business. However, this may only result in a one-off purchase with no assurance of a return customer.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill shows a high appreciation for the artisan's work and expresses her intention to regularly support the local crafts market, indicating potential future purchases and continuous support. She clearly wants to form a long term relationship with the artisan as a loyal customer. While she is asking for a discount, it is in the context of purchasing multiple items or for being a returning customer. This scenario presents an opportunity for a long-term customer relationship, which could lead to steady and recurring revenue, even if at a slightly discounted rate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her appreciation for the artisan's work, but scenario 2 shows a more profound appreciation for the artisan's labor and the local community. She not only highlights her liking for the vase and artisan's skills but also indicates potential for future multiple purchases and a continuity of business. Additionally, she is honest about her budget, which shows sincerity and thoughtfulness in her negotiation, rather than trying to devalue the work for a lower price. A sincere negotiation like this is more respectful to the artisan as it acknowledges the value of his work while also communicating the customer's limitations. Therefore, the artisan would be more willing to negotiate the price with Jill in this situation as it could mean a long-term customer who appreciates and supports local crafts, resulting in a win-win for both sides.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: In Scenario 1, Jill openly expresses interest in negotiating the price of the vase. As an artisan dealing with a customer at a local market, this is a fairly common situation, and negotiating could lead to a successful sale. However, Jill only compliments the craftsmanship and expresses interest in the item, but not my business as a whole. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only admires the craftsmanship but also shows interest in supporting local artisans, implying a deeper business relationship. She mentions her plans to come back for more shopping in the future, highlighting the potential of a returning customer, which can be very beneficial for a small business like mine. Also, she inquires about discounts for purchasing multiple items, indicating she might make more than one purchase right now. \\n\\nGiven these points, I'd be more tempted to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 2 due to her interest in other items, the potential of multiple sales immediately, and the possibility of her becoming a return customer. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: Both scenarios show that Jill is genuinely interested in buying the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship, which is always a good starting point for any negotiation. However, the difference lies in Jill's justification for a discount. In scenario 1, she just asks for a price that might be lower than the listed price without any further justification. This is a very common scenario for artisans and one that doesn't necessarily lead to a price negotiation. On the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill not only shows her interest in the item but also provides several reasons for a potential discount: she intends to purchase other items as well (increasing the total sale) and promises to return to the shop in future (to repeat business). She also mentions her tight budget. This overall engagement and loyalty toward's the artisan's work might make one more inclined to consider a negotiation as it might lead to a long term customer relationship. Giving a small discount today might mean getting a loyal customer for future. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill acknowledges the quality of the craftsmanship, which shows that she recognizes and appreciates the value of the product. This is a good start in both situations. However, there are differences in the reasons given for seeking a lower price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill simply asks if there's room for bargaining. This approach is straightforward in asking for a lower price but she doesn't provide any specific incentive for the artisan to accept a lower price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses her intent to support the artisan and other local makers, implying that this purchase might be the first of many. She also raises the possibility of buying multiple items. This approach provides reasons that might motivate the artisan to negotiate on the price, due to the potential for making more sales in the future or selling more items in one transaction.\\n\\nGiven these reasons, I would be more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 2. This scenario suggests a stronger potential for a longer-term, beneficial relationship with the customer in many aspects. The potential for future engagements and sales can ultimately contribute more to success and business growth.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0.5, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile the sentiment in both scenarios is quite similar, there are some differences in Jill's offers that would sway my decision. In Scenario 1, Jill is not only showing appreciation for the work but also providing an offer of value in return for a discount, which is promoting my art on her social media. This type of organic promotion is incredibly valuable because word of mouth and personal testimonials can represent a significant advantage for small artisans like myself. This can potentially lead to more clients and higher visibility, which can grow my business.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill is praising the work and expressing interest in purchasing the vase but is only asking for a lower price. She doesn't offer any extra value to balance out the reduction in price.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, I would be more willing to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 because of the additional value that Jill is promising in exchange for the discount. Her proposal could increase my market reach, which is a long-term benefit that surpasses the short-term profit from a single sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill in a positive and respectful way, expressing interest in the handcrafted vase, admiring the craftsmanship, and acknowledging the value of artisan work. The scenario where the artisan would likely negotiate the price, however, would depend on certain factors.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses an interest in purchasing the vase but also offers a potential form of long-term benefit in the way of promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This could mean reaching an audience that the artisan normally might not have access to, which could then lead to even more sales or business. If The artisan values this kind of exposure and believes it could drive more business, then this scenario might be more appealing. However, this would only work if the artisan trusts that Jill will keep her part of the agreement.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill simply expresses her interest in the vase and asks directly if there's any possibility for a price negotiation. While this is a more conventional approach and doesn't involve any potential long-term benefits, such as marketing, it might appeal to the artisan if they need to make a sale and are open to negotiating the price. As an artisan, I would evaluate how the sales are for the day and if the asking price can cover the costing price and still leave some margin then a decision can be made.\\n\\nNonetheless, the decision to negotiation and giving a discount would depend on the artisan's immediate need for a sale versus the potential for increased future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: It would depend on the individual artisan and his/her immediate versus long-term business goals. Both scenarios presented are appealing for different reasons and hence, it's not a clear cut Scenario 1 or Scenario 2.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is not only showing interest in buying the vase but also offering an additional value in the form of promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This would give additional exposure to the artisan and might result in future sales. This is a 'win-win' as the artisan gets to sell the vase and possibly gain more customers, while Jill gets the vase within her budget.\\n\\nWhile in scenario 2, Jill is only asking for a discount on the vase. Though it's a normal practice in local markets to negotiate the price, the artisan only stands to lose as there's no additional benefit offered. \\n\\nTherefore, taking these aspects into consideration, the artisan would get more value in scenario 1 as compared to scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and directly expresses her interest in bargaining for a better price. This straightforward ask gives an artisan an immediate option to reconsider the price and potentially make a sale. However, Jill doesn't provide any additional value or incentive for the artisan to lower the price, and it solely relies on the artisan's willingness to haggle.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill not only compliments the artisan's work but also proposes a form of collaboration. In exchange for a discount on the vase, Jill offers to use her social media platforms to promote the artisan's work. This provides the artisan with a potential opportunity to reach a larger audience, increase brand recognition, and possibly gain more customers. Therefore, Jill offers a more mutual benefit in the second scenario compared to the first one.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth situations present a compelling case for a price negotiation. In scenario 1, Jill offers basic praise and asks directly for a discount. This is straightforward and common with customers seeking a discount. However, it does not provide a clear additional benefit to me as a seller other than the immediate sale.\\n\\nOn the other hand, scenario 2 presents an interesting proposition. Jill not only appreciates the work but also offers to promote it in her social media platforms where she has a substantial following. This has a potential for more exposure and could attract more customers. The downside risk is that her followers may also expect discounts. \\n\\nTherefore, the decision to negotiate depends on the type of benefit I am seeking - immediate profit or a potential for more future business. Considering the nature of a local market where visibility and word of mouth can play a significant role, going with scenario 2 could provide more benefits in the long term thanks to the potential additional exposure and customers she could bring.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill demonstrate her interest in the vase and her admiration towards my craftsmanship. However, the approach differs significantly between the two.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill simply expresses her interest in purchasing the vase and opens up a direct negotiation for a lower price. This approach is straightforward and implies that Jill values the vase and wishes to make a deal for it.\\n\\nOn the other side, Scenario 2 is a more strategic approach. Here, Jill mentions the potential of advertising my work and enhancing my exposure through her social media platforms. The promise of free promotion adds considerable weight to her request for a discount. This could not only benefit my earnings from the sale of the current vase but also potentially drive future sales by increasing the awareness of my work among her follower base. However, it also depends on the authenticity of Jill's claims and whether her follower base aligns with my target market.\\n\\nFrom a business perspective, Scenario 2 would likely offer more benefits, as it can potentially lead to increased exposure and future sales. Nevertheless, it would still be imperative to assess the authenticity of Jill's offer before proceeding.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios present different reasons for Jill asking for a discount. In Scenario 1, Jill is admiring the craftsmanship and asking directly about bargaining on the price of a singular item. In Scenario 2, Jill is assuming a more long-term view with the potential of buying multiple items and the possibility of being a returning customer. \\n\\nFor an artisan at a local market, the latter might be more appealing. Repeat customers are valuable and if Jill buys more than one item at a time, it guarantee more immediate sales. Furthermore, offering a discount for buying multiple items may help to increase overall sales and can be beneficial for both the customer and the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', 'Reasoning: \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill explicitly asks for the possibility of bargaining. This directness could induce me more to discuss price alterations, especially if I perceive her as a potential buyer and get the sense she might buy the vase if the price is reduced. In Scenario 2, Jill asks about discounts without necessarily promising that she will buy the vase now, even if a discount is given or return to buy more later. Jill simply mentions her plans, and these plans could remain hypothetical. Therefore, Scenario 1 might push me more to negotiate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is being direct in expressing her interest in purchasing the vase, but also hints that she's hoping for a lower price. From a seller's perspective, it might not be preferable to lower the price of an individual item right away, especially if it's a handcrafted item which involves a lot of hard work. However, negotiating on the price could potentially lead to a sale, and depending on the profit margin, a seller might be willing to lower the price a little to secure the deal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is not only showing interest in the vase but also in purchasing multiple items. She's also hinting at potential future business as she plans to visit the market again. As a seller, offering a discount for multiple purchases or for returning customers is generally an easier pill to swallow as it promises more sales in the present and potential future business, leading to an overall increase in profit. Moreover, Jill's appreciation of the work may mean she's likely to promote it by word-of-mouth which will attract more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.55 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[Reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill demonstrates interest in the vase - as a single product in Scenario 2 and as part of a potentially larger future purchase in Scenario 1. In both cases, a seller might consider offering a discount. However, the implications of negotiating in each scenario differ.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill seems to be interested not just in the vase but in building a longer-term customer relationship. If she becomes a regular, you as the seller might benefit in the long term from her continued patronage even if you reduce prices or offer discounts now.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is focused on the vase alone and interested in negotiating the price for it. Bringing the price down might facilitate this single sell, but there might not be any subsequent benefits for you as the seller since a future relationship or purchases are not mentioned.\\n\\nWhile a seller might understandably be tempted to secure sales, longer-term relationships are in general more beneficial. So, if a choice has to be made, one might consider favoring the customer who promises more future benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Based on the scenarios provided, my likelihood to negotiate the price would be more affected by the potential value of the customer rather than just the immediate interest in one item. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses her intention to become a regular customer and is interested in buying more than one item. This kind of a customer brings more potential value over a long period, increasing the chance of more future sales. Offering her a discount might encourage her to stay true to her word and return to buy more of my products, which could possibly lead to a higher overall revenue and even potential referrals. It's an investment in customer loyalty. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, although Jill is appreciative of the craftsmanship of the vase, she only expresses interest in the one item and wants to negotiate its price. In this scenario, even though I could potentially sell the vase at a negotiated price, I cannot ensure she will be a returning customer or buy more than just one item.\\n\\nSo, while I would be open to negotiating in both scenarios, I would be more likely to do so in the first scenario because it could provide more future business and Jill has a potential to be a loyal customer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nScenario 1: In this situation, Jill demonstrates an interest in not just the flower vase but also potential future and multiple purchases. This promise of consistent patronage can inspire a deeper level of business connection and could possibly ensure a stable source of income. If Jill indeed becomes a regular, there might be some kind of loyalty or quantity discount offered.\\n\\nScenario 2: Here Jill is appreciating the craftsmanship, implying she values the work and effort put into it. She is interested in purchasing, yet opens the door to negotiation on the price. Many artisans strive to have their work appreciated and might be willing to negotiate based on that appreciation, however the value and effort of craftsmanship should be properly acknowledged.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios have compelling arguments, scenario 1 offers more benefits and a broader potential for continuous trade, making it more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.25\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: Both scenarios express appreciation for the craftsmanship of the vase and both make it clear that Jill supports local artisans. However, in the second scenario, Jill also emphasizes that she not only appreciates local artisans, but also actively seeks to include their work in her home, suggesting that selling the item to her might help to advertise my craftsmanship. Furthermore, whereas in the first scenario Jill only implies that she is on a budget, in the second scenario she explicitly states that 30 dollars is a stretch for her. Because of this, I might be more inclined to negotiate in the second scenario, reasoning that even if I make less money on this particular sale, Jill's appreciation and possible word-of-mouth advertising could indirectly lead to greater overall sales in the future. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: Both scenarios involve Jill expressing her admiration for the vase and acknowledging the local craftsmanship. This is an approach that is likely to appeal to an artisan's pride in their work. She does a good job at explaining her financial constraints, making it clear that the negotiation is not due to undervaluing the work, but rather because of her limited budget. However, in scenario 2, Jill explicitly expresses her support for local artists which indicates her respect for the work that goes into producing such crafts. This could inspire a particular level of goodwill from the artisan. Bravo to Jill for highlighting the potential place the vase will have in her home. Knowing the item will be cherished might actually sway the artisan towards being more likely to negotiate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios show a very polite and interested customer, which makes the decision a bit challenging. However, in both scenarios, Jill uses different approaches to request a price reduction. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only compliments the work but also acknowledges it as something unique which she is unable to find elsewhere. She emphasizes her support for the local artisans suggesting a possible future customer relationship. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill starts off with complimenting the vase and the craftsmanship but does not specifically state that the vase is unique or hard to find elsewhere. She talks about loving to add these types of items to her home, which shows her interest but does not necessarily promise future purchases. \\n\\nBased on these observations, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 where Jill appreciates the uniqueness of the work and clearly states her support for local artisans which indicates potential future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"In both scenarios, Jill compliments the artistry of the vase and mentions her desire to support artisans - these are strong empathetic reasons for considering a price reduction. However, there are slight nuances to consider.\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill explicitly says the current price is a stretch for her budget and asks if there is any wiggle room, suggesting she might be able to pay close to the marked price.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill mentions she's constrained by her budget but doesn't specify if the vase is outside her budget. She only asks for a small discount, indicating she might be fine with a minimal reduction.\\n\\nBased on these considerations, I'd be slightly more inclined to negotiate in scenario 1 due to Jill's openness about her budget constraints. Importantly, the expression 'wiggle room' suggests she's not necessarily looking for a massive discount. She seems like a customer who genuinely appreciates the value of the vase and is more likely to return or recommend my stall to others.\\n\\nMoreover, reducing prices for supportive customers who genuinely cannot afford the full price can be seen as a long-term investment in building customer relationships.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios involve a customer who is appreciative of the work it takes to handcraft items and is responsive to the design and quality of the vase. However, there are minor differences that might influence the decision on whether or not to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill starts by praising the design and the craftsmanship. This appreciation for the love, labor, and skills invested into the vase may make one feel valued and recognized as an artisan. She also indicates her continuous support for local crafts, suggesting she is likely to return as a customer in the future. Lastly, she specifically explains her budget constraint, justifying her request for a negotiation, and she asks if negotiation is possible in a polite way, showing respect for the value of the work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill makes similar compliments, also expressing her desire to support local artisans, and she mentions her budget restrictions, but she seems slightly less enthusiastic about the specific piece, focusing more on a general appreciation. \\n\\nGiven this analysis, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. Jill's respect for the artisanal work, her likely future support, and her appreciation for the specific piece at hand could make a slight price reduction more appealing for the promise of a good customer relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"In both scenarios, Jill approaches respectfully and praises the craftsmanship of the vase, expressing a real desire to support local artisans. She also indicates in both scenarios that she is budget-constrained.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, however, she expresses some emotional gravity towards the vase and the value it would add to her house. She also mentions that $30 is only slightly out of her budget, not extremely so.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the focus is more on the admiration for the craftsmanship and less on how the vase would enhance her home decor or personal connection. She might be genuinely constrained by her budget, but there's less emphasis on how close she is to affording the asking price.\\n\\nBoth scenarios increase the likeliness of a negotiation but Scenario 1 gives more reasons to do so, because Jill not only values the item and artisan but also sees a specific personal connection and has mentioned just slightly exceeding her budget.\\n\\nReasoning text:\\nGiven both scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. This is because she has shown appreciation for the uniqueness of the design and elaborated on the value the vase would bring to her home. The added personal connection makes her request for a lower price more compelling. Moreover, indicating that the vase is slightly out of her price range hints at the possibility that she would still be able to pay a price relatively close to the initial mark, which means that the potential discount wouldn't drastically affect my own earnings from the sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her appreciation for the artisan's work and shows interest in buying the vase. However, the situations differ significantly when it comes to their potential for future business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only wants to purchase the vase but also hints at buying multiple items and even becoming a recurring customer. This has potential to increase my revenue in the long run, even if I have to reduce the price somewhat for this initial purchase. She also shows sincere appreciation in my craft, which is a form of respect for what I do, setting quite a conducive environment for negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is also complimentary of my work, but mentions that the marked price is a stretch for her budget, implying that she might not purchase if there's no room for negotiation. While this scenario brings the sympathy factor into play, it may result in a one-time sale only without hinting at any future business or multiple item purchases.\\n\\nTherefore, based on potential for future business and considering this as a long term relationship, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn my evaluation, both scenarios have Jill expressing sincere admiration for the vase and for my craftsmanship. However, Jill's approach in Scenario 1 includes elements that make me more inclined to negotiate the price with her. Firstly, she expresses interest in buying multiple items, not just the vase. This represents a bigger sale for me, making me more likely to consider a discount on the vase. Secondly, Jill suggests she will be a returning customer. This means that offering her a discount now could lead to further sales in the future, establishing a loyal customer who appreciates my work. While Jill in Scenario 2 also appears genuine in her interest and praise, her approach simply focuses on a discount without offering a clear future benefit to me as the artisan. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Given the two scenarios, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the flower vase in Scenario 2. \\n\\nJill, in scenario 1, shows admiration and interest in my craft and proposes future purchases but doesn\\'t state any particular reason to really need a discount. Despite the fact that she implies she will be a returning customer, this isn\\'t a guarantee. However, a future discount for repeat business could potentially be negotiated as it fosters a returning customer relationship.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill gives a specific reason - \"30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment\". This shows an immediate need for a discount and she is clearly expressing her interest in the piece but showing restraint due to her current financial situation. This consideration and honesty are compelling reasons for a price negotiation, along with the fact that she also appreciates local artisans, means she may more likely recommend my products to others, indirectly helping me sell more.\\n\\nObviously, the implication of a repeat customer in scenario 1 is very enticing, but the immediate sale under sincere circumstances as expressed in scenario 2 is a safer bet.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\n\\nJudging both the scenarios, Scenario 1 seems more promising because firstly, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and recognizes the value. And secondly, she is offering something in return to the potential discount. She is offering to feature the vase and the shop on her social media, which might give the shop more exposure and can potentially bring more customers. Even though she is asking for a discount, this can be seen as an investment in marketing or advertising. In contrast, Jill in Scenario 2 is solely asking for a discount based on her personal budget, with no return for the shop.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Based on my understanding of the scenarios given, there are two main factors influencing the decision: the potential benefit I might get from the negotiation and the empathy I could potentially have towards Jill's situation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is interested in buying the vase at a discounted price, but in return, she offers to promote my work and shop on her social media, potentially leading to more customers. This introduces a potential for more sales and growing my brand, which is a significant appeal even under negotiation. Depending on her social media reach, this could result in a significant increase in sales and visibility for my art.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill really admires the vase stating that she supports local artisans and would love to have the vase in her home. However, she mentions that the price is slightly outside her budget. While showing empathy to her situation might be considered, it largely depends on the business situation of my art and how critical the price of this sale is to me, as she does not offer any additional tangible benefit in return to the price negotiation.\\n\\nReasoning Text:\\nAlthough I respect Jill's budget considerations in Scenario 2, as a business person, the prospect of increased visibility and potential new customers in Scenario 1 is more tempting. The promise of promoting my work could result in overall higher profit in the long run, even if I provide a discount for this specific item.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons for a discount, however, there are slight differences that can affect my decision as an artisan:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship but also offers mutually beneficial business direction. She offers to feature my vase and shop on her social media platform. Depending on the size of her following and the engagement rate, this could potentially bring a lot more business my way. It also expands the reach of my shop beyond the local market. It's worth noting, however, that this scenario requires some level of trust. There's no guarantee that Jill will follow through, but it is a promising proposition.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is emphasizing her support for local artisans and states that she's confronted with a budget issue. While supporting local artisans is laudable, it's based more on an emotional appeal and less on tangible benefits. Still, her enthusiasm for my work is appreciated and can be seen as supportive of my craft.\\n\\nAnswer: Considering all, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. The potential for wider exposure and increased business makes this proposition more appealing. The promise of additional advertising marks this as a more strategic business decision, rather than one solely based on goodwill.\\n\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[Reasoning Text]\\n\\nFrom my standpoint as an artisan and a local market seller, both scenarios present valid reasons to negotiate, but I lean more towards Scenario 1. Here's why:\\n\\n1. Value proposition: In Scenario 1, Jill offers to advertise the vase (and thereby my craftsmanship) on her social media, presumably to her circle of friends and acquaintances. This kind of word-of-mouth publicity could potentially lead to more customers or greater recognition for my work, which could be more valuable than a small price reduction.\\n\\n2. Willingness to pay: Although she suggests a price reduction, Jill in Scenario 1 starts by appreciating the vase and stating how she could use it, which demonstrates her strong interest and intent. To contrast, in Scenario 2, Jill compliments the vase but her main focus is on the price being beyond her current budget. \\n\\n3. Supporting Local Artisans: While supporting local artisans is highlighted in Scenario 2, it’s implicit in Scenario 1 as well - she likes the craftsmanship and wants to showcase the piece on her social media, which is a form of supporting local artisans.\\n\\nTherefore, taking these points into account, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAnalyzing both scenarios, we observe that Jill shows a strong interest in the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship in both cases. The difference, however, lies in how Jill presents her negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only asks for a price reduction but also offers to post pictures of my vase on her social media and tag my store. This could potentially bring additional exposure and possibly sales, assuming she has a decent number of followers or a social circle interested in handcrafted items. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses her love for my work and does also ask for a price negotiation because $30 is slightly beyond her current budget. However, she doesn't propose anything extra, unlike the first scenario. \\n\\nConsidering the potential benefits, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in the first scenario since it offers a win-win situation: Jill could get a slight discount, and I could gain extra exposure for my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: While both scenarios present a case for negotiation, Jill in scenario 1 offers an exchange of value that makes her proposition more enticing. In return for the discount, she offers to promote the business on her social media platform. This type of promotion can help attract more customers which can be more beneficial in the long run. However, in scenario 2, Jill simply asks for a discount solely because the vase is beyond her budget. As an artisan and a business person, while empathizing with her situation, this does not present a direct or immediate benefit to my business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill admires the craftsmanship and quality of the vase and recognizes the effort put into making it. She also offers to showcase the vase and highlight the artisan's work on her social media in exchange for a discount. This gesture could potentially help promote and gain more exposure for the artisan's products, which could lead to increased sales in the future. Therefore, the promise of future gain and the recognition of the value in the craft might encourage negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again expresses her admiration for the vase and the artisan's work. However, she merely mentions her budget constraints as her justification for a discount. While this could appeal to the artisan's sympathy, it doesn't offer the same potential benefit as Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present an interested customer who appreciates the craftsmanship and is willing to find common ground for a discount. However, there are notable differences in the cases laid out.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses her deep appreciation for your work, but she also presents a proposition that in a way, could greatly benefit your business beyond this one sale. She hints at having a quite following on social media which means if she purchases the vase and gives it a shoutout, your craftsmanship could be viewed by many of her followers. This exposure can potentially drive more customers your way and could even enhance your online presence if you haven't touched upon that yet.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill does express her admiration for the vase and the work that went into it, but the only reason she gives for asking for a discount is because of her budget. While it's reasonable, it doesn't bring additional value to the table the way Scenario 1 does.\\n\\nSo, based on the situation, the discount could be more justified in Scenario 1 because the exposure your work could gain from this customer's social media seems a worthwhile trade.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning:\\n\\nAs an artisan, I highly value the recognition and representation of my work. Both scenarios have their reasonings behind a possible price negotiation, but the concept of receiving promotional exposure for my handcrafts on a social media platform outweighs a personal budget concern. Promotion on social media could help me reach a wider audience, possibly resulting in more clientele and higher sales in the future. Also, the customer in scenario 1 values the craftsmanship and is ready to pay the full price but just sees an opportunity of mutual benefit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill complimented all aspects of your work from the craftsmanship to the unique design and exhibited her support for local artisans. However, there are slight differences in how she introduces her request for a price negotiation. In Scenario 1, Jill explicitly states that 30 dollars is a stretch for her budget at the moment. She then politely requests for a price negotiation. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill subtly mentions that the price is over her budget and asks for a small discount. \\n\\nConsidering these differences, it would be more likely to negotiate on price in Scenario 1. This is because, in the first scenario, Jill has been a bit more upfront about her financial constraints. This candor might make you, as an artisan, more empathetic toward her situation and encourage you to negotiate a lower cost. Additionally, a negotiation leaves room for a middle ground, which could potentially be more profitable for you than giving a straightforward discount, as mentioned in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'In both scenarios, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, expresses her support for local artisans and politely asks if the price is negotiable as it exceeds her current budget. However, there\\'s a slight distinction in her phrasing and approach that matters.\\n\\nReasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill pays more personalized compliments about the \"unique design\" of the vase and praises the \"incredible job\" done in crafting it. This shows that she truly appreciates its value and uniqueness. Also, she uses the phrase \"wiggle room,\" suggesting that she still acknowledges the marked price as fair but is modestly asking for a concession due to her constraints. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill\\'s compliments are also genuine, but she uses more general terms like \"exquisite craftsmanship.\" She asks for a \"small discount,\" which inherently suggests the marked price might be too high, even if that\\'s not her direct intention.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the artisan may feel that Jill more fully recognizes the value of the vase, and her personal budget constraints may motivate the artisan to make a slight adjustment in the price to support a consistent patron of local handcrafts.', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill commends the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her support for local artisans, which indicates that she appreciates the value of the product. However, the way she approaches the negotiation differs slightly. They are both polite and very complimentary, which makes it a hard choice. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly indicates that the price is a \"slight stretch for her budget,\" which suggests she has a budget constraint. She also mentions the possibility of negotiation, indicating her intention to discuss the price, but still leaves the room for me to make a decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses a similar interest, but she\\'s asking for a \\'small discount\\', which might be perceived as her trying to lower the value of my work. The \\'tiny bit over budget\\' comment could also be seen as a strategy to get a decrease in price, rather in Scenario 1 where it felt more like a genuine concern. \\n\\nTherefore, while it\\'s a close call, I am more likely to negotiate on Scenario 1 because it feels more genuine and less like a bargaining strategy. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.0\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios involve Jill appreciating the quality of the work and expressing her support for local artisans. However, scenario 2 seems to show a little more passion for the product. Jill expresses a personal interest with the unique design of the vase and its potential addition to her home. She seems more attached to the product and genuinely stricken by it, as opposed to scenario 1, where she simply admires the work. Furthermore, she opens up about being slightly financially strapped at the moment, proving authenticity and sincerity in her request to reduce the price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill recognizes the quality of the vase, expresses admiration for the craft, and also voices an interest in supporting local artisan work, which bodes well for her negotiation. However, it's her approach in each scenario that might sway the negotiation in her favor. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is quite direct with her intentions and immediately expresses her financial constraints. Even though she shows her appreciation for the vase and the craftsmanship involved, she is straightforward in asking for a discount. This can put the artisan on the spot and make the negotiation a bit difficult, as it might not allow room for discussion.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill express her admiration for the vase, commends the uniqueness of the design, complements the artisan on his work, and expresses her support for local artisans before suggesting a price reduction. This way of negotiating may feel more comfortable for the artisan, as Jill creates a friendlier atmosphere with her comments before discussing the price. It makes the negotiation seem less about the money and more about Jill's genuine appreciation for the vase but her inability to afford it at the moment.\\n\\nBased on these factors, I'd likely be more open to negotiation in Scenario 2 where Jill takes a more considerate approach in her negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios represent a situation where Jill is complimenting the artisan's work and showing deep interest in buying the vase while expressing her budget constraints. There seems to be no substantial difference in intents between the two scenarios for negotiating the price. However, in Scenario 2, Jill goes into more detail about her appreciation for local artisans and her commitment to adding these types of pieces to her home. This indicates that she might be a returning customer who values the artisan's work and could potentially make more purchases in the future. Therefore, giving her some discount could encourage customer loyalty and future business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.7\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both the scenarios, Jill shows her appreciation for the vase and also empathizes with your work as a local artisan, which positively influences your inclination to negotiate. However, in Scenario 2, she further adds a personal touch to her request by sharing how much she adores adding such pieces to her home, which could create a stronger emotional connection. This could make you more open to negotiation because she not only values the object but also appreciates the artistry behind it, and you might feel gratified knowing your work will be cherished in her home. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and indicates her support for local artisans, implying an appreciation for the work and time that goes into creating such items. She also expresses her desire to add such a piece to her home collection. However, there is a slight difference in the way she approaches the price issue.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill straight-up mentions she wants to discuss the price, making her intention to negotiate clear from the start. Her approach is friendly, but the mention of the budget stretching makes it sound as though purchasing the item would be a strain on her resources.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill goes a bit further to emphasize the value she sees in the vase, calling the design unique and complimenting the craftsmanship. After establishing her appreciation, she then brings up the price, suggesting there's 'wiggle room'. Her phrasing is softer, and she doesn't emphasize the financial constraint as much as in Scenario 1.\\n\\nGiven these distinctions, Jill in Scenario 2 demonstrates a greater appreciation for the vase and uses a softer approach in initiating a price negotiation; this approach can make the artisan feel their work is valuable and respected by prospective buyers. Therefore, negotiation in Scenario 2 would probably feel less like devaluing the artisan's work and more like accommodating a valued customer's needs within reason.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", 'Reasoning: Looking at both scenarios, Jill is lavishing praise on the craftsmanship and appreciating the effort that goes into making a handcrafted item in each case. This creates a positive atmosphere, and she is expressing her willingness to support local artisans. However, in Scenario 2, she further establishes her appreciation of such items and expresses explicitly that she loves adding these to her home, hinting that she is possibly a repeat customer. This directly implies her long-term support and fosters the idea of a future relationship. In addition, in both scenarios, she explains her budget concerns, but in Scenario 2, she does it without undercutting the perceived value of the vase. Overall, Scenario 2 creates a friendlier atmosphere which can lead to a more successful negotiation process. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the vase and expresses an interest in supporting local artisans. However, the two situations differ slightly in their approach. In Scenario 1, Jill directly asks for a possible negotiation on the vase's price stating her budget constraints, but in Scenario 2, she subtly asks about discounts for multiple items or future purchases indirectly hinting at negotiation. \\n\\nIn my opinion, Scenario 2 presents a better opportunity for negotiation as Jill not only expresses interest in the vase but also shows potential for future purchases. Offering a small discount to Jill could result in building a long-term customer relationship and demonstrate goodwill for future interactions. She's not just interested in a single item; she could also purchase more items now or be a repeat customer in the future. Hence, the potential profit from future purchases or multiple items may compensate for a small decrease in the price of the vase now.\\n\\nWith this in consideration, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"The best scenario to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill is scenario 1. \\n\\nReasoning:\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments your work genuinely admiring the uniqueness of the vase. Her admiration for your craftsmanship can indicate a deep appreciation for the value of the vase. Jill also mentions that she's negotiates asking for a 'wiggle room,' on the price, implying that the price is just slightly out of her range, giving an indication that she's close to the stealing point, and a slight reduction might secure the sale.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while it comes off as more business-like, the impression it gives is of a bargain hunter looking for a discount. Jill is looking for a deal, asking not only for a discount on this item but seeing if there are further discounts for buying multiple items, or for potential future purchases. There's no certainty here - she 'sees herself coming back', but it is in no way definite. She also suggests that she might buy more items, but again, it's just an implication, not a firm commitment. \\n\\nScenario 1 suggests a real appreciation for the art and a willingness to pay nearly the asking price. Jill seems more likely to value the vase at a price nearly its worth, whereas scenario 2 seems more keen on getting a deal than supporting the value of the artwork. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nThe decision to negotiate the price largely depends on the context that is painted by the customer and the potential for future business gains. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments my craftsmanship and shows enthusiasm and appreciation for the vase, which makes for a favorable initial impression. She also admits that $30 is slightly above her budget, which suggests that she might be more likely to buy the vase if the price is lowered a little. \\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill not only admires the vase but also indicates a clear intent to support local artisans and buy more items in the future. This scenario paints a picture of a potentially loyal customer who could bring in more business over time. She also asks about future discounts, suggesting a plan to purchase more items down the line.\\n\\nGiven both scenarios, I would lean towards offering a discount or negotiating a price in scenario 2. This decision is based on the potential longer-term value that this customer could bring, which could be more valuable over time, even if I take a small hit on the price of the vase today. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a well-spoken and appreciative customer, which is great for any artisan at a local market. In Scenario 1, customer Jill not only shows admiration for the vase but also offers reciprocal value. She proposes to share the work on her social media platforms, which can potentially give the artisan a reach to a larger audience - an effective form of free marketing. It is also a form of investment, which may yield higher returns in the future.\\n\\nScenario 2 is a straightforward appreciation and request for a discount due to personal budget constraints. While this scenario is still polite and respectful, it doesn't offer a form of reciprocal value beyond the purchase of one piece.\\n\\nThus, considering value exchange and potential future gains, scenario 1 carries a little more weight.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a situation where Jill, the customer, initiates a negotiation for the price of a handcrafted flower vase. Understanding the premise, however, offers insight into why or why not I might prefer and be more willing to consider one scenario over the other.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the artisan work but also provides an additional value proposition. She offers to promote the work on her social media, potentially driving more customers to the business. This suggests that the personalized craftsmanship is not only valued by her, but likely to be appreciated by a broader audience, validating the work. If her following is sizable and if such free promotion might attract more customers, then losing a small amount on an individual item could be advantageous over a broader scale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses admiration for the artisan craft and desire to support local businesses. However, she appears only to be seeking a discount based on her budget without offering any additional value for the business. It might be a simple, straightforward sale.\\n\\nWhile the genuine appreciation expressed in both scenarios is a positive, the added value in Scenario 1 offers a potentially greater business benefit. The promise of exposure to a wider customer base may more than offset a small discount provided to this individual customer and thus yield a long-term gain.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision between the two scenarios has to be made based on the perceived value of the proposed transactions and Jill's approach. In both cases, Jill is appreciative of the work and finds the vase appealing. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she doesn't directly mention about what kind of discount she wants, but she proposes to help advertise the product on her social media platform, which could lead to increased exposure and possibly more sales. This is a valuable proposition as it might help in growing the business.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, she only says she can't stretch her budget to the price but she doesn't give any specific reasons nor does she offer anything else in return, although she still shows appreciation for the work.\\n\\nGiven the additional potential value offered in Scenario 1, I'd be more likely to negotiate the vase's price with Jill in that context.\\n \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both situations presented by Jill promote sympathetic and friendly negotiation, there are a few key differences that make a stronger case for scenario 2. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill points out that the price is a little outside her budget. This is a valid reason and it's common for customers to ask for a discount. However, with the price set at $30, which is reasonable for a handcrafted item, lowering the price solely due to a customer's budget constraints could set a precedent that may not be sustainable in the long run. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill not only states her budgetary reasons, but also proposes a form of barter: promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This additional element can potentially grant exposure of the artisan's work to a wider audience, leading to more sales in the future. This indicates a long-term benefit for the artisan, as opposed to the one-time sale from scenario 1.\\n\\nThus, according to the given scenarios and understanding of the longer-term benefits, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen approached by a customer for possible negotiation, various factors come into play that could influence our decision. Some of the main ones include the customer's attitude, their appreciation of the craftsmanship and most importantly, the additional value they might bring. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her support for local artisans. She voices that the price is slightly beyond her current budget, but doesn't necessarily bring additional value to the table other than the potential purchase of the vase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill shows similar appreciation and support for local artisans. Besides expressing the financial constraints, she also offers economic plus non-monetary value as well, which she can do through promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This could possibly lead to higher visibility and more sales.\\n\\nWhile both are good scenarios, and it's important to support customers who appreciate craft, Scenario 2 provides an additional dimension that could potentially expand the customer base and increase total business volume. The offer to promote the items on social media provides a future value to the business that could lead to more sales. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show that Jill is interested in buying the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship involved in creating it. However, in Scenario 2, she's offering to promote the work on her social media, which could potentially attract more customers and increase sales. This not only demonstrates a deep level of personal interest but might also bring a longer-term benefit to me as an artisan. The potential for increased exposure and potentially more sales in the future provides an added incentive to consider her request for a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nTo decide which scenario is more likely to make me negotiate on the price of the vase, I'll consider both Jill's approach and potential benefits to my business.\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill is offering to exchange social media promotion for a discount. Depending on her social media follower count and engagement, this could potentially be a decent trade-off. If her followers are in the thousands or tens of thousands, featuring my product could expose my art to a much larger audience, leading to more customers in the future. However, the value of this promotion is uncertain and relies heavily on whether her followers are inclined to buy my products. \\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill is simply asking for a discount. She complimented my work, explained that she's an avid supporter of local artisans, and has honestly admitted that the price is slightly beyond her budget. However, there's no additional benefit for my business beyond the direct sale.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, I'm more likely to negotiate price in Scenario 1. The potential marketing value gained is a significant factor and could be more beneficial for my art business in the long term than a single sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her admiration and appreciation for the handmade vase, which is a good starting point for a negotiation. She's managed to communicate her interest very effectively, praising the craftsmanship and uniqueness of the piece.\\n\\nHowever, scenario 1 suggests an additional benefit for me as an artisan. Jill's proposal to promote my work on her social media platforms could potentially get my craft noticed by a wider audience, resulting in more customers in the future. This is significant because as a local artisan, the marketing channels available to me are limited, and this could be an effective way of reaching many people at once without incurring any additional marketing costs.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, while Jill did a good job expressing her interest and support for local entrepreneurs, she doesn't offer any extra value besides the purchase.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential long-term benefit,\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nThe decision to negotiate the price depends on what the artisan values more; immediate payment or potential future sales and exposure. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering something beyond mere monetary compensation. She is proposing a sort of symbiotic relationship where she helps expand the artisan's reach in exchange for a discount. If the artisan believes in the power of social media marketing and trusts Jill's promise to promote him properly, there's a possibility he may consider negotiating. However, Jill's proposal carries a risk as the promised promotion might not translate to increased sales. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 is a straightforward negotiation based on monetary terms. Jill is not stretching it too far as she only mentions a slight stretch on her budget, which might imply a small discount may make her purchase the vase. Here, the artisan doesn't have to gamble on future benefits as he would in scenario 1. \\n\\nHowever, definitely, there are pros and cons to each scenario, which include loss of income in Scenario 2 and loss of future visibility if Jill does not uphold her end of the deal in Scenario 1. \\n\\nGiven the risk involved in Scenario 1 and the potential for immediate money with minimal loss in Scenario 2, I'd lean towards the latter as it seems like the safer bet.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"The choice between the two scenarios would most probably depend on the seller's policies and personal business ethics. However, as an artisan, I would carefully consider both on a context basis. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows the intent of becoming a repeat customer as well as purchasing multiple items at the same time. As a business, I would favor this since it can lead to future sales and potentially more recommendations. Offering Jill a discount here could encourage her loyalty and create a regular customer, which could result in steady revenue in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill expresses earnest love for the craftsmanship and supports local artisans, she asks for a direct discount due to budget constraints. There is no clear indication of her becoming a frequent buyer, and as an artisan, this is a one-time sale. Giving a discount here doesn't necessarily guarantee a longer-term engagement with this customer compared to the first scenario.\\n\\nTherefore, taking these circumstances into account, I am more likely to negotiate price in scenario 1 since it can lead to a longer-term benefit and promote customer loyalty.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show an interest in the vase, but the approach is different. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is showing their intent to not only purchase multiple items on this occasion but also to be a recurring customer. They are expressing their overall interest in my craft and an intent to visit again, which means a possibility of future sales. Offering a discount could therefore serve as an investment in building a long-term customer relationship.\\n\\nScenario 2 is also promising in that Jill appreciates my work and wants to support local artisans. However, Jill's request for a price drop seems to be due to their limited budget. \\n\\nWhile both scenarios provide good reasons to negotiate, Scenario 1 seems more advantageous from a business standpoint because of Jill's expressed intent to make additional purchases and to potentially become a recurrent customer. A small discount now could lead to greater profits in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"In both scenarios, Jill shows a genuine appreciation for the work and a desire to continue supporting it. However, the reasoning behind her negotiation differs. \\n\\nScenario 1: Jill offers the potential of a future continued business and a multiple items purchase, which could potentially lead to larger revenue. However, a discount policy on multiple items or for returning customers might not be implemented. Providing a discount on this basis could set a precedent and expectation for future transactions, which might not be a sustainable business strategy, especially for artisan crafts where the profit margin can be narrow. \\n\\nScenario 2: Jill appreciates the craftsmanship but points out some budget constraints. It seems like a one-off event where negotiation on price won't risk creating an ongoing expectation of discounts. Moreover, helping a customer with limited budget might enhance the business reputation and she may recommend the craft to her circles.\\n\\nReasoning: The artisan would want to ensure sustainability of the business while supporting their customers. As one-off discounts might not affect the pricing dynamic as much as ongoing discounts, Scenario 2 seems to provide better grounds for a negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios invite negotiation, they come from different perspectives. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the customer, Jill, appreciates the craftsmanship and uniqueness of the vase but mentions that the price is slightly beyond her current budget. This approach makes me empathize with her financial situation, and considering the appreciation she has shown for the vase and my work, I would be inclined to negotiate the price to make it more affordable for her.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 leverages the potential for future sales. Jill hints at buying multiple items and frequently returning, which suggests a potential for long-term business. However, such promises are uncertain and there's no guarantee that she will indeed become a regular customer. Moreover, offering a discount on the vase based on the promise of future purchases could set a precedent for expected discounts, which may affect the perceived value of my products.\\n\\nTherefore, given the direct, honest approach in Scenario 1 vs. the more uncertain potential business in Scenario 2, I'm more likely to negotiate in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her interest and appreciation in the vase and my work as an artisan, indicating her willingness to support local artisans. However, there are key differences in the negotiations between both scenarios. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill directly mentions her constraints which is stretching her budget for the price of the vase. It's a direct and honest approach. However, in Scenario 2, Jill not only expresses her interest in one item but also her plan of purchasing multiple items from my stand, indicating a potentially larger purchase. She also states her intent of being a regular customer, indicating future sales and a lasting relationship. \\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling cases, but as a seller, ensuring repeat business is highly valuable and can often outweigh the benefit of a single sale. The possibility to sell more items to Jill over time, including today, would potentially provide more income even with some initial discount. Additionally, treating her well could lead her to spread positive word of mouth about my stand, thereby attracting more customers. \\n\\nTherefore, I would be more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 2 due to the promise of a continuous buyer relationship and potential for more sales, both today and in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nDeciding whether to offer a discount depends on the circumstance and considering the long-term profitability for the business. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appeals to the quality of the vase and compliments the craftsmanship, an emotional appeal that could make the seller more inclined to give a discount. She also explains that her budget is strained, essentially asking for a one-time discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, however, Jill is not only interested in buying the vase but is also hinting at buying multiple items and returning for future purchases. This indicates a potential for a more extensive, long-term business relationship, which might justify offering a discount now.\\n\\nMoreover, since Jill claims to be a big supporter of artisans and plans to be a returning customer, giving her a small discount today might incentivize her to buy even more items in the future, or recommend the shop to her friends and family, indirectly promoting the business.\\n\\nWith these factors in account, it appears that Scenario 2 would bring more benefits to the business in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning: Given the information provided in both scenarios, it would be more advantageous to negotiate in Scenario 1 for multiple reasons. Firstly, Jill has made her intentions clear that she will be a regular visitor and customer implying a consistent source of income in the future. Lowering the price might seem like a loss at first glance, but a returning customer would bring more profit over time, making it a good investment. Secondly, she has expressed interest in purchasing more than one item which increases the total sales, and offering a discount on bulk purchases is a common practice. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and supports local artisans, the main reason she gives for requesting a discount is her own budget constraint, not providing any incentive from a business perspective. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill has expressed interest in supporting the market stand in a long-term manner. If she does become a regular and buys multiple items each time, that could be a sustainable income for the stand and worth giving a discount. Jill also mentions an interest in purchasing more than one item right now and this could lead to an immediate increase in sales. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill commends the craftsmanship of the vase and seems genuinely interested in it. However, her request for a discount is based only on her current budget constraints. There's no guarantee of future patronage or increased sales. \\nSo while it's important to be understanding of customer's current budgets, it's also crucial as a seller to prioritize sustainable and increased sales for the business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:\\nJill's approach in both scenarios seems to encourage negotiation, but the contexts are slightly different. In Scenario 1, she is promising a potential return customer and multiple purchases which could mean more business in the future. The promise of a returning customer who might potentially buy more items is quite attractive to a seller. Customers who would willingly return to a store have the potential to advertise the store to their peers, increasing the scope of business. Moreover, if she is claiming to buy multiple items at once, even a small discount on each would still mean a significant total sum at the end of the day.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is showing appreciation for the craftsmanship of the product and claims supporting local artisans, displaying an emotional connection. However, the reason for her wanting a discount is due to budget constraints which might be a common claim among customers wanting a price reduction. \\n\\nSo, from a business perspective, the promise of potential continuous business seems more enticing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a negotiation standpoint, both scenarios present compelling cases for a price adjustment. However, several key factors lead me to favor one scenario over the other. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, showing her acknowledgment of the effort and time put into creating it. She also states her support for local artisans which implies she values the work involved. Jill then expresses her desire for the vase and notes that the price is a bit out of her current budget. Here, Jill is quite honest about her financial situation, which adds credibility to her request for a price adjustment. She is not asking for a considerable discount, just a 'little wiggle room', which suggests she respects the artisan's work and is not trying to undervalue their effort. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 involves Jill asking for potential discounts for multiple purchases or for returning customers. While these propositions may seem appealing, they put the artisan in a spot where they're committing to future discounts without any concrete commitment from Jill apart from her 'plan' of regular visits. The social media aspect she introduces could give the artisan exposure, but it's not guaranteed to translate into sales. It could also set a precedence for the artisan, where they might be expected to offer discounts to anyone promising to promote them on social media.\\n\\nTherefore, based on the above reasoning, I would be more inclined to negotiate with Jill in:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has approached the situation by complimenting the item and acknowledging the work that has gone into it, which is a good starting point for any negotiation. However, her methods of justifying her request for a discount vary quite significantly. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is open about the fact that the price is slightly out of her budget, hinting at the fact that she might not be able to buy the item unless the price is reduced. This may work in her favor as, being a local artisan, I may be more interested in selling my items to people who genuinely appreciate them and will give them a good home, rather than just making a profit.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers two reasons for a potential discount: the possibility of purchasing multiple items and her potential to promote the items on her social media platform. While the promise of future purchases might be appealing, it's not guaranteed. The social media promotion, however, could potentially reach a large audience and attract new customers to the stall, which could generate more sales in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nHaving considered both scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. Her suggestion of promoting my items on her social media platform could be more beneficial to me in the long term, despite being an undefined return. While Scenario 1 is more immediately sympathetic, as a business, potential brand exposure offers greater future opportunity.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere seems to be a greater willingness to compromise price in Scenario 2. Even though they both show interest, Jill from Scenario 2 is giving more reasons and bargaining chips for you to consider lowering your price. She is discussing not only just getting the vase, but also potential repeated business, as she plans to come back to the market often. Moreover, she could potentially help expand your customer base with her social media following, which is an aspect in favor of giving her a discount. In Scenario 1, while Jill shows admiration for your work, she only uses her current budget constraint as an argument, and she does not mention anything about promoting your work, repeat business, or buying multiple items. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present good opportunities for negotiation, but I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 2. This decision is based on a few factors.\\n\\nFirst, in Scenario 2, Jill not only shows interest in the vase, but also in other products, which hints at the possibility of her buying more items either presently or in the future. Offering a small discount or bundling deal on this occasion may lead to a bigger overall sale, or add to customer loyalty in the long term.\\n\\nSecond, Jill mentions about being a returning customer, indicating she is a regular at the market and has potential to become a repeat customer for my business. The value of retaining a loyal customer can often be more productive than aiming for maximum profit on single sales.\\n\\nLastly, Jill offers to promote my work on her substantial social media platforms. Effective advertising can often be costly and this allows me the opportunity of reaching a wider customer base for free. This potential marketing value can exceed the cost of giving a minor discount on a single item.\\n\\nSo, by considering the potential future sales and marketing benefits offered in Scenario 2, I'm open to negotiate the price with Jill even though in Scenario 1 she also shows sincere interest and admiration for the workmanship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows great interest in the vase and appreciates the craftmanship, which is a positive starting point for negotiation. However, they approach the issue of price negotiation differently.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly indicates that the vase is slightly above her current budget and asks for a possible price reduction. This is a standard technique in negotiation where she explains her financial constraint, even though the price tag is reasonable and fair. As the artisan, I understand people have different budgets and sometimes they can't afford what they like, so I might agree to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill has a more long-term perspective. She asks about discounts for multiple purchases or rewards as a returning customer, showing intention for future interactions. Even more importantly, Jill mentions she has a substantial following on social media and she's willing to promote my crafts. As a local artisan, exposure for my work is extremely beneficial, possibly attracting more customers and generating more revenue than the price drop for this one vase. \\n\\nTherefore, in terms of potential future benefits and continuous customer relationship, the offer from Scenario 2 is more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nThe first scenario is straightforward and upfront about Jill needing a price reduction due to budget constraints. While this is a common tactic for negotiation, it is centered around the benefit of the buyer, not the seller. However, it could potentially gain the seller a loyal customer if the discount is given. \\n\\nOn the other hand, the second scenario provides a more compelling case for a discount as it gives something back to the seller. Jill not only remarks on purchasing multiple items, indicating potential future purchases, but also offers to utilize her substantial social media following to promote the artisan's work. This exposure could potentially translate into new customers and increased sales. The offer of repeated patronage and promotion provides greater incentive for the seller to negotiate the price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['From a business perspective, Scenario 1 offers more advantages and potential return on investment for me as an artisan. \\n\\nReasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is advertising to be a repeat customer, meaning steady sales in the future. This advantage alone is a compelling reason to consider a discount. Regular customers build a stable income source and they can provide a degree of business security. \\n\\nFurthermore, by mentioning her significant social media following, Jill is offering a form of marketing and promotion — a type of compensation that isn’t strictly monetary but could lead to increased sales and visibility. Supporting and networking with influencers, even local ones, can be invaluable to a small business or individual artisan. \\n\\nAlthough in Scenario 2, Jill sincerely appreciates the craftsmanship and supports local artisans, there’s no explicit mention of future purchases or added value for the business. She simply asks for a discount because the item is slightly out of her budget. While sympathizing with her situation, in a business exchange, Scenario 1 proposes a clear, mutually beneficial arrangement. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[Reasoning text]\\nWhile both scenarios show Jill as a potential and interested customer, the bargaining chips she presents in each scenario carry different weight. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers two incentives for a discount far more compelling than those presented in scenario 2. Firstly, she talks about becoming a repeat customer, which is a lucrative prospect for any business. Repeat customers provide a stable base for continual revenue. Secondly, and even more enticing, Jill proposes to advertise the vase and my artisan shop on her social media channels that would potentially expose my work to a new, large, and interested audience. Given today's digital culture, this form of promotion is quite significant and invaluable. Therefore, the potential for increased sales and exposure outweighs the immediate profit loss from the discount.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill merely states her admiration for the work and insinuates a potential inability to meet the asking price. While sympathy could be invoked and there's an indirect hint of her support for local artisans, she doesn't present a strong enough case as to why a discount should be offered. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill presents interesting propositions. However, I would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1 due to a few reasons. Firstly, Jill shows a genuine interest in returning to the market and purchasing more items, which indicates a potential for repeat business. This customer loyalty is something that any business values. Second, she offers to promote my products and store on her social media channels. In the modern world, such publicity could prove to be a valuable marketing tool, especially if she indeed has a substantial following as she claims. This could bring in new customers and increase sales in the future. So, even though a discount now reduces my immediate profit on the vase, the potential long-term benefits make it a sound investment. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship but she is asking for a discount because the price of the vase is slightly beyond her budget. This is a less compelling reason for providing a discount because it offers less potential benefits in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present an intriguing proposition. However, I would consider additional factors before making a decision. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill shows appreciation for the effort that I have put into my craft and gives a valid reason for asking for a discount. She bares her personal circumstances; her budget does not permit her to purchase the item at the given price. As she is a devoted supporter of local artisans, I can anticipate that she would visit my stand again to purchase more items in the future. This might encourage me to offer a small discount on the vase this time, building a loyal customer relationship for future sales. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers to promote my work on social media, which can potentially provide broader market exposure. However, there are uncertainties. Will her promotional efforts actually translate into increased sales for my products? How effective will her promotion be, and does she have a following that is potentially interested in my kind of work? These are factors to consider before offering a discount.\\n\\nWeighting up both scenarios, I'm leaning towards Scenario 1. The tangible benefit of making a sale now and potentially developing a loyal customer with this discount outweighs the uncertainty of future sales that might (or might not) result from a promotion in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: Both scenarios present viable reasons for price negotiation. Jill delivers her argument in a respectful and complimentary manner, recognizing the artisan's skill and craftsmanship. Scenario 1 bespeaks a buyer appreciating the handmade craft and planning to add it to her home. Nevertheless, she's on a budget, giving her reason to negotiate. Scenario 2 proposes a barter exchange where the artisan might get advertising benefits. However, the effectiveness of her promotion efforts might depend on her followers' number and engagement rate, not easy to determine instantly.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 is more likely to motivate the artisan to negotiate the price because it doesn't involve speculation or uncertainty about the extent of the potential promotional benefit. The artisan is guaranteed a sale, and the small discount would probably be less than the cost and effort required to make use of equivalent advertising elsewhere, making this a good deal even with a small price reduction. The request also respects the artisan's work, and is asked for personal reasons rather than for mutual benefit, which may appeal to the artisan's empathy.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom an artisan's understanding, it's important to value both the financial aspect and the exposure that could come from a sale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is appreciating the craftsmanship and showing genuine love for the product without promising anything extra. Although rewarding, this does not necessarily signify any additional benefit for the future business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill proposes a transaction where she would promote the artisan's work on her social media to her follower base. Such publicity could result in increased visibility and potentially additional sales, which is very beneficial for an artisan's business.\\n\\nWhile I value both scenarios and would consider negotiating a discount for both, the extra advantage offered in Scenario 2 could be more beneficial in the longer term.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering a potential for advertising and marketing, which could potentially bring more customers and increase the overall sales. This is beneficial in the long term even if it means selling the vase at a slightly discounted price. Increased visibility and audience reach is crucial for any business, particularly for small-scale local artisans.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is merely expressing her financial limitations. However, while empathizing with her situation, selling an item below the fair value just because a customer can't afford it is not sound business. It may also set a precedent for other customers to expect similar discounts.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, although selling the vase at a lower price might cut into the immediate returns, the vase can be considered an investment in the form of marketing and promotion, which is essential for growth.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present good arguments for a discount, however, the potential benefits seem more immediate and tangible in Scenario 1. In Scenario 2, Jill mentions she loves supporting local artisans and implies that she might spread the word about your work, but there's no concrete promise. Also, while you want to help customers who are on a budget, you still need to make a living from the sale of your items.\\n\\nIn contrast, Jill's offer in Scenario 1 to promote your craftsmanship on her social media platforms to potentially thousands of people could greatly increase your exposure and attract more customers, which could lead to an increase in sales. This could potentially offset the discount given to her and even bring more profit in the long term.\\n\\nTherefore, taking into consideration the future benefits of increasing your visibility vs a one-time sale, Scenario 1 seems to be a more beneficial deal for you as an artisan in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows a keen interest in the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship involved in creating it. However, my aim as an artisan at a local market is not just to sell my current inventory but also to create long-term customers and expand my customer base.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my craftwork on her social media platforms. If she indeed has a sizeable following, this could bring a significant amount of exposure and potential new customers to my stall. This is essentially free marketing, which is invaluable. Scaling down the price a bit here would be a strategic investment in creating future business prospects, even if it means slight short-term monetary loss.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is looking for a price reduction due to budget constraints. While it's a reasonable request, and I might consider giving her a small discount because she appreciates the work involved and supports local artisans, the benefit for me here isn't as clear as in the first scenario. \\n\\nTherefore, based on the potential for longer-term benefits, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.85 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the artisan's work and expresses her interest in the vase, and seeks to negotiate on the price. However, there are key differences in her approach:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill focuses on her appreciation for artisans and their work, but ends on the note that $30 is beyond her present budget. In essence, she is asking for a discount because she can't afford the vase, but doesn't offer anything in return.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the artisan's work, indicates the price is fair, but still proposes a discount. Crucially, she offers something in return: promoting the artisan's work on her social media platforms with a potential audience of hundreds or thousands of people for the artisan's work. This amounts to free advertising and can potentially boost the artisan's sales significantly.\\n\\nTherefore, an artisan might be more willing to offer a discount if they believe their work will reach a wider audience and potentially gain more customers. This is, of course, considering the artisan values exposure and potential increase in future sales over an immediate full-priced sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\nThere are pros and cons to both scenarios. In Scenario 1, Jill shows genuine appreciation for the craftsmanship and quality of the vase and openly admits that the price is just slightly beyond her budget. This approach leans on the emotional appeal and might entice a more empathetic response from me as the artisan selling the handcrafted item.\\n \\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only shows her interest in the item but also offers a potential marketing opportunity for my craft via her active social media accounts. The promise of promotion and potential for word-of-mouth marketing has monetary value and expands my work's visibility. It can potentially lead to more customers in the future and can be seen as a trade-off on the reduced price for the vase.\\n\\nHowever, there is no guarantee that the exposure will lead to more sales. It's also possible that future customers will expect similar discounts in return for promotions, which isn't a sustainable business model. But it could kickstart an artisan's recognition in the broad market if they're only starting.\\n\\nOverall, it's a balance between definite income and potential future returns. If I were in a position where immediate income is crucial, I would choose Scenario 1. If a potentially broader customer base is more attractive, and I can afford to take a bit of risk, I would choose Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: This depends on my current needs but in this situation, I would lean more towards Scenario [2] due to the potential future gains.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling cases for a possible price negotiation with Jill. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and acknowledges the effort that has probably gone into creating such a unique piece. Jill expresses that she is a great supporter of local artisans, implying that she would truly appreciate the vase. Furthermore, she openly discloses her financial strain, suggesting that she may not have the means to buy the vase at the full price, which might inspire sympathy.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to use her social media influence to market and advertise the artisan's work. This could be seen as a form of trade or barter, which has potential value. If she has a substantial following that responds to her posts, it could lead to further exposure and possibly more sales for the artisan.\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their merits, but for long-term business success and reach, the additional exposure offered in Scenario 2 might have more value. While sympathy for a customer's financial situation is noble, sales are crucial for the survivability and growth of a small business. The free marketing that comes with a customer showing off their purchase on social media, particularly if they have a large or engaging following, can prove priceless.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 6.8\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"In the act of negotiation, the customer's acknowledgment of the artisan's craftsmanship, the uniqueness of the products, and the intention to support local businesses play a significant role in influencing the decision to adjust the price. Both Jill's approaches involve these elements, hence either of them could lead to a successful negotiation.\\n\\nHowever, Scenario 2 not only includes all these elements but also adds an additional factor - Jill's intent to become a repeat customer. The prospect of establishing a long-term relationship with a customer can be very persuasive to small business owners like artisans, and usually incentivizes them to offer higher discounts to such customers. Therefore, the mention of a potential for repeat business from Jill in Scenario 2 could possibly serve as a stronger motivating factor for the artisan to negotiate the price.\\n\\nBesides, in Scenario 2, Jill also proposes the idea of a discount for repeat customers, indirectly suggesting a sort of loyalty program. If the artisan is interested in building a customer base and encouraging repeat purchases, this could lead to broader negotiations about the structure of such a discount scheme, reinforcing Jill's commitment to come back and make more purchases in the future.\\n\\nThus, while both Scenarios 1 and 2 could potentially lead to successful negotiations, Scenario 2 leverages a greater number of persuasive elements that could tip the scales in Jill's favor.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"Both scenarios present key points for consideration in this case. However, I would lean towards scenario 2, and here's why:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill first compliments my craftsmanship and acknowledges the uniqueness of my work. She then discloses that she has budget constraints. While this might invoke a sense of understanding and sympathy, it does not provide a clear incentive for me to lower my price aside from benefiting Jill.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill uses the same compliments but also mentions her intention to become a repeat customer. As a business owner, the prospect of gaining a loyal customer who would not only buy more of my products in the future but potentially also refer other customers to me is rather enticing.\\n\\nRepeat customers are extremely valuable in any business because not only do they add to the sales revenue but they also increase word-of-mouth marketing, which is both free and highly credible. The promise of future sales might make the small discount worthwhile.\\n\\nSo, considering these points:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: Each scenario presents an example of Jill complimenting the artisan's work and signaling a strong interest in purchasing the round vase. However, the circumstances and Jill's approach are slightly different. In Scenario 1, Jill compliments the artisan's work, acknowledges their unique talent, and mentions a budget constraint. This is a common negotiation tactic to evoke seller's empathy and willingness to reconsider the price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only appreciates the artisan's craftsmanship, but also expresses an intent for future purchases and continued support. While she also tactfully asks for a price adjustment, she further sweetens her pitch by presenting herself as a potential repeat customer.\\n\\nFrom a business standpoint, retaining a customer is often more valuable than a single transaction. It not only ensures future sales, but also increases the potential for the customer to refer other buyers. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nScenario 1 presents Jill as someone with a keen appreciation for craftsmanship and an understanding of the time, effort, and skill it takes to create such a piece. She recognizes and values the good deal she is getting even at the full price, thus exhibiting a willingness to pay for quality and support an artisan’s work.\\n\\nMore importantly, she offers to highlight the artisan's work on her social media, presumably with a sizable following, which could certainly boost future sales, attract customers and spread awareness about the artisan's creation beyond the immediate community. She isn’t just asking for a discount, she is offering a service in return which has the potential to benefit my business in the long term.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the artisan's work but she only puts forward her financial limitation as a reason for requesting for a discount. She didn't provide some equivalent exchange like in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her admiration for the vase and the detailing of it, and is therefore interested in purchasing it. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering something in return for a discount. She mentions that she has a strong following on social media, which implies she might help in promoting your work to a larger audience. This could potentially bring more interested customers and increased sales. A slight discount on one vase could lead to greater overall profits from the exposure.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses her admiration for the vase and the work that went into it but offers nothing in return apart from payment at a discounted price. It's a very polite request, but at the end of the day, agreeing to her request only reduces your profits without any potential gain.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nScenario 1 is more compelling for me to consider negotiating the price of the vase. Jill not only shows her admiration and understands the effort put into creating it but also provides an additional value proposition to me as an artisan: she offers to promote my work on her social media. In the age of digital marketing, this type of promotion can greatly increase my visibility and possibly bring in more customers. The advert could actually translate into more sales in the future, which has a certain long-term value. \\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2, Jill acknowledges the value of the work, but she only mentions her budget constraints and does not offer an additional incentive for me to consider lowering the price. Any negotiation in this case would only contribute to a direct loss of possible income.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.7\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Both scenarios are almost similar as Jill appreciates the quality of the work and highlights her desire to support local artisans while subtly expressing her budget constraints. However, there are minor details which can affect the decision.\\n\\nScenario 1:\\nIn this scenario, Jill straightforwardly mentions her budget constraints and desires to discuss the price. She appreciates your work and explicitly acknowledges her love for supporting local artisans. This goodwill from her could make negotiating the price more appealing, as she shows respect for your craftsmanship and seems genuinely interested in buying the vase. \\n\\nScenario 2:\\nIn this scenario, Jill focuses more on complimenting your work and alluding to its uniqueness before mentioning her budget constraints. This admiration for your work might indicate that she understands its value and hence, might be willing to pay a higher price. Moreover, her acknowledgment of your craftsmanship might insinuate that she expects the price to be higher due to its superior quality.\\n\\n[reasoning text]\\n\\nAs an artisan, appreciation for the work and understanding of its value are paramount. Both scenarios entail that, but Scenario 1 is a bit more direct regarding Jill's intention to negotiate the price. Furthermore, it also doesn't undermine the fact that she appreciates your effort behind the handcrafted item- she appreciates the quality and the uniqueness of your work and is direct about her need to negotiate. Honesty is key in successful negotiation, hence her clear intentions to talk about the price could result in a smoother negotiation process with less risk of miscommunication or hard feelings.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is praising the artisan's work, demonstrating interest in the vase and hinting she would like to negotiate the price. Both scenarios show Jill as a potential customer, who is valuing and acknowledging creativity and workmanship involved in creating the vase. Scenario 2 has Jill going a bit more in detail with appreciating the work, which might make an artisan feel that Jill more genuinely admires their work and hence, they might be more encouraged to give her a discount. However, some could argue that both scenarios are equally persuasive.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios involve Jill complimenting your work as an artisan and expressing a desire to support local craftspeople. She mentions her budget constraints in each scenario and asks if there may be room for negotiating the cost of the vase. The primary distinction between the two lies in the language used; in scenario 2, Jill's tone is more complementary and enthusiastic regarding your skill and craftsmanship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nMy choice is based on how Jill has framed her request in the second scenario. The way she appreciates the intricacies of the vase and acknowledges that it cannot be found elsewhere suggests a deeper understanding and value for the vase and, by implication, your work in general. This not only flatters your artistry but it also indicates she is likely to value and care for your creation. Also, Jill's elaboration on her budget challenges in scenario 2 feels more sincere, making it easier to empathize with her situation and consider reducing the price.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"In both scenarios, Jill compliments the workmanship of the vase and acknowledges the value of supporting local artisans. However, in Scenario 2, Jill hints at potential future business by expressing her intent to return for more purchases. The promise of repeat customer loyalty is often worth a small immediate price cut. While budget constraints are a valid concern in Scenario 1, it isn't as effective as Scenario 2's approach in negotiating a discount or a deal, because the potential for future recurring business is not guaranteed. Therefore, from a seller's perspective, considering both immediate profitability and future ongoing business, Scenario 2 presents a stronger case for negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn assessing both scenarios, negotiating a price may be considered in both, but for different reasons.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the artwork and clearly values the work that goes into the vase, which may make the artisan feel appreciated, creating a positive emotional connection. She mentions being constrained by her budget, which could hint at a potential need for a price negotiation. However, she doesn't explicitly mention wanting a discount or ask for a specific lower price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only admires the work but also shows clear interest in purchasing additional items and becoming a returning customer. She explicitly asks if there are discounts for buying multiple items or for returning customers. Here, the artisan might see an opportunity to sell more items or to establish a long-term customer relationship, and might be willing to offer a discount as an incentive.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nThe approach in Scenario 2 suggests a potential for more sales either immediately or in the future, which could justify offering a discount. Moreover, the customer directly asks about a discount, making it clear that a negotiation is sought after. Scenario 1 presents a potential for negotiation too, but without a clear suggestion of further sales or explicit request for a discount, it leans slightly weaker in comparison to Scenario 2. The logic behind favoring Scenario 2 is based on maintaining customer loyalty and potentially increasing sales volume.\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is polite and appreciative, which makes it more likely for a negotiation to take place. However, the outcomes from both scenarios differ slightly.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the artisan's work and expresses a specific interest in the item, but only hints at a possible return to the market. In this case, giving a discount might ensure a sale but it does not guarantee future purchases.\\n\\nIn contrast, in Scenario 2, Jill not only shows appreciation for the work, but she also explicitly mentions her intent to buy multiple items and return to the shop in the future. This means offering a discount could potentially turn into multiple sales now and continued business later, making this a more promising situation for negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer compelling cases for offering a discount, but I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1. Here's why:\\n\\nFirstly, Jill not only acknowledges the craftsmanship in my work but also offers a form of reciprocation, something that isn't present in Scenario 2. She proposes to promote my work on her social media platforms, which has the potential to greatly increase the visibility of my products to a wider audience. This can be an effective way of acquiring new customers, especially if Jill indeed has a good number of followers.\\n\\nFurthermore, her proposition suggests she's interested in building a relationship beyond a simple transaction, which is beneficial from a customer loyalty perspective. It shows she values the work and is likely to come back for future purchases or refer others.\\n\\nWhile the customer in scenario 2 also praises the work and shows interest in supporting local artisans, she does not offer anything in return for the asking of a discount. Therefore, scenario 1 is more persuasive.\\n \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only recognizes the value of the item she wants to buy but also offers something in return for a discount. Aside from showing appreciation for the local crafts, she wants to help advertise my business on her social platforms. Not only will this bring more visibility to my work, it could potentially bring in new customers. This is a form of barter system where I would be trading a product for a service.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also values and appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase, she only asks for a lower price, without proposing a possible benefit for me in return. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1, because Jill both appreciates my work and offers a way to promote it, can be seen as a win-win situation, as I could gain more customers and visibility in addition to making a sale. This could be more beneficial for my business in the long run compared to Scenario 2.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer who appreciates the workmanship of the vase and is open about the budget constraints they currently face. Jill's proposed deal in Scenario 1, however, offers something more substantial than just praise for the work: the prospect of marketing and reaching a wider customer base through her social media platforms.\\n\\nSuch a prospect could potentially result in increased sales and exposure for the artisan's work, and that could prove to be more valuable in the long run compared to the loss of a few dollars on the vase. Moreover, Jill's approach of appreciating the art and offering something in return gives a fair ground for negotiation.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 provides a similar appreciation for the work but does not offer anything else other than the plea for a discount. While it's often respectful and polite to engage a customer in price negotiations, this approach may not be as compelling as the first scenario where Jill offered something in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning text:\\n\\nIn considering requests for discounts, it's crucial to balance the desire to make a sale with the need to maintain the value and perceived worth of my work. Both scenarios presented by Jill highlight her appreciation for local handmade materials and her desire to support local artisans. However, Scenario 2 offers something more substantial for me as an artisan - exposure to a broader audience. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, while Jill sounds appreciative and sincere, she mainly discusses the personal budget constraint as the reason for demanding a price reduction. On the other hand, while she also requests a reduction in Scenario 2, Jill proposes a more concrete trade-off. She offers to promote my work to her large online following in exchange for a discount. This exposure could potentially lead to more sales in the future, and more people that know about my work and my brand, can have a much more significant impact on my business than a one-time sale.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential long-term benefits, I would be more willing to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. By leveraging her social media platforms, it is a mutually beneficial arrangement, where she gets the vase at a discounted price, and I gain access to a wider customer base.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios pitch for a discount quite well. In the first scenario, Jill appreciates the work and supports local artisans but is limited by her budget. This is a direct and honest request for a discount based on financial constraints, which could be considered favorably.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill takes a different approach. She's not only complimenting the work but also offering something in return for the discount: social media promotion. This could potentially bring more customers to the artisan, expanding the value of the trade beyond just the sale of the vase.\\n\\nBoth scenarios come from genuine places, but the second one has the potential for value beyond the immediate transaction, potentially benefiting the artisan in the long term. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere are various factors to consider in both scenarios presented by Jill. Both emphasize the importance and respect for artisan work and simultaneously hint at their budget concerns. This reveals a genuine interest in art, not just looking for a less price.\\n\\nHowever, Scenario 1 sounds more concerted to the authenticity of the artisan's work, giving a point of value for the artisan’s craft.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill does appreciate the work but also brings in a kind of a barter system wherein she offers to give exposure via her social media platforms. While this could be enticing as it promises potentially larger exposure, it could also come with risks. For instance, there is no guarantee of business or potential income from her posts, or the quality of the exposure Jill can provide may not align with the artisan's brand or audience.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, the personal appreciation of craftsmanship seems to create a more relatable and definite value for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nLet's evaluate both scenarios. In scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the attention to detail in the vase and she mentions she wants to support local artisans, but she says she is constrained by her budget. This hints she might not be able to afford the marked price or other items and hence, might not contribute to future sales.\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2 Jill again appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase, she also indicates she’s thinking about buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. This suggests she values your work and is planning to be a recurrent source of income.\\nFrom a sales perspective, although both scenarios enlist admiration for the product and express a willingness to support local artisans, scenario 2 presents a possibility of creating a long term relationship with a loyal customer and more immediate profit from selling multiple items at a discounted price. Giving a discount may result in lower profit margins per item, but this could be balanced out by increased sales volume and customer loyalty.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the scenarios provided, both have their unique aspects and depending on the situation, negotiation could occur in either. However, the artisan might be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. Here's why:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, it's true that the customer appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and supports local artisans. However, the customer only mentions personal budget constraint as a reason for a price reduction, which may not be a strong enough argument in haggling, considering the artisan's time, creativity, and effort spent in making the vase. Additionally, there's no surefire promise for future interactions or purchases.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 has a customer that not only acknowledges the artisan's skill but also shows intentions to purchase multiple items. There's an increased potential for higher overall sales. Furthermore, Jill identifies herself as a returning customer that plans on providing sustained support to the artisan's trade. This implies future purchases and possibly, word-of-mouth promotion as well. In the long run, giving a loyal customer like Jill an occasional discount could promote loyalty and also establish a stronger customer relationship.\\n\\nSo, an artisan who's looking at the long-term benefits might be more willing to negotiate in the second scenario, knowing that future business is likely and they could potentially sell more items at the current market event.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is definitely expressing interest in the vase and acknowledges the craftsmanship and quality of the product, which is a good start for a negotiation. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill mentions that she would like a discount because she's on a budget. This is a decent reason but it doesn't promise any future interactions or transactions, thus could lead to a one-time discount at best.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill not only mentions buying multiple items but also states that she would be a returning customer. This suggests potential future sales, which would be more profitable for me in the long run. Also, providing discounts for buying in bulk or returning customers is a common marketing strategy that can maintain customer loyalty and stimulate repeat business. Therefore, the potential for higher total sales and future business makes scenario 2 a better option for a price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\nIn any negotiation, the key to making a deal is effectively communicating mutual benefits. Looking at the scenarios, Jill in Scenario 1 compliments the work and recognizes the value of supporting local artisans but mentions her budget constraints. A good negotiator might choose to impact her positively, encouraging her to keep supporting local artisans in the future by offering a discount. However, she only shows interest in one item and doesn't offer any concrete benefit or bargaining tool, instead, hints at her financial constraint as a need for lowering the price.\\n\\nMeanwhile, Jill in Scenario 2 offers a more compelling case for a discount. Not only does she express interest in the vase, but she also hints at the possibility of purchasing more than one item - which could mean more revenue. In addition, she offers to promote the artisan's items to a considerable following on social media, potentially driving more clients to the artisan's business. This sort of promotion could be very valuable, especially if her followers are locals and/or people likely to appreciate handmade crafts. Furthermore, she indicates that she is a returning customer, suggesting she will continue to support the business in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill complements the originality of the artisan's work, showing a deep appreciation for the uniqueness and attention to detail. This is flattering for the artisan and suggests that Jill understands the value of unique, handcrafted goods. She also mentions that she is budget-constrained, implying that she may not be able to buy more items in the future if she pays the full price now.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also shows appreciation for the vase and interest in buying other items from the same artisan, indicating the possibility of a long-term customer relationship. More importantly, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work on social media, offering potential exposure to thousands of people who might be interested in similar items. This could significantly boost the artisan's business.\\n\\nBased on these considerations, Jill appears to be offering more value to the artisan in Scenario 2. Therefore, the artisan might be more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"Reasoning Text\\n\\nIt's quite difficult to make a definitive choice - both scenarios present valid reasons for discount consideration. In Scenario 1, Jill compliments our work, which is always nice to hear as an artisan, and presents her issue with budget constraints. However, offering discounts based on a customer's budget could set a tricky precedent for future sales. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only expresses interest in the vase but indicates she plans on buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. She also proposes a promotional exchange: a discount in return for social media exposure. This could potentially result in new customer acquisition through her followers. Offering a discount to returning customers or those purchasing in bulk is a common business practice, and the prospect of gaining additional exposure through her social media influence is a worthwhile consideration.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide persuasive reasons for considering a price negotiation, but they emphasize different benefits. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill highlights her appreciation for unique, handcrafted work and respects the craftsmanship of the vase, showing a genuine interest in it. She also explains her situation, hinting at a tight budget, which may trigger empathy, potentially leading to a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers an additional value in the form of potential marketing and exposure to her large followers on social media. If Jill's follower base is indeed substantial and engaged, this kind of exposure could lead to future customers and profits, which is beneficial in the long-run. \\n\\nIt's important to note that while Scenario 1 involves an immediate, tangible sale (even if it's at a slight discount), Scenario 2 offers intangible, potential future benefits that are somewhat harder to measure and aren't guaranteed. My decision would also depend on my own circumstances as a vendor, such as how much I need the immediate money from the sale vs. how beneficial I believe the exposure could be for my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Given these considerations, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 2. This scenario provides me with an opportunity for potential growth and reaching a wider audience through Jill's social media promotion, making it a more strategic choice for the sustainability and expansion of my business.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios are compelling, the latter suggests a potential mutual benefit and a possible long-term relationship. Jill is not only interested in the round flower vase but also offers to promote the work to her extensive social media following. This could lead to increased exposure, possibly attracting more customers and consequently generating more sales.\\n\\nIn the first scenario, while Jill shows appreciation for the craft, she doesn't offer anything in return apart from the promise to support local artisans. Although her request for a discount might be plausible due to her budget constraints, there's no proposal of a direct immediate advantage for the artisan in this case. \\n\\nConsidering the artisan at the local market could evidently benefit from wider promotion, a small discount on the vase could be a rewarding investment in a potentially bigger market.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill brings forward compelling reasons for her request for a discount. However, in Scenario 1, Jill seems more sincere and genuine in her approach. She appreciates the craft, understands the value of the work and is eager to support local artisans. Although her budget constrains her, she doesn't make any promises in exchange for a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the craftsmanship and introduces the idea of promoting the works to her social media following. However, the success of this arrangement depends on a few variables like the nature of her followers, how she'd promote the work, whether her followers are interested in such items or whether they reside in the same locality or not. Therefore the impact wouldn't be as immediate or guaranteed as a direct purchase.\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide an opportunity to negotiate, but there's a greater likelihood and assurance of tangible support in Scenario 1. Also, the artisan's craft is recognized and appreciated, which could provide an emotional motivation to negotiate in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nNegotiating price is always a delicate balancing act between valuing one's work and accommodating the customer. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and uniqueness of the vase. However, she is requesting for flexibility due to budget constraints. As an artisan who values his work, giving a discount simply because a customer has a limited budget can set a precedent that might not be sustainable. It could also undervalue the time, effort, and artistic value inherent in each product. However, by giving a small discount, it can foster goodwill and encourage repeat business from a customer who clearly appreciates the artistry involved. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only appreciates the work but also offers a form of non-financial compensation which is her influence as a social media persona. Offering a discount in return for exposure through social media can potentially reach a wider audience, and is a common practice today. One must consider, however, the reach and engagement of Jill's social media. \\n\\nGiven these considerations, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 2, provided Jill's social media reach and engagement is substantial. This option strikes a balance between accommodating the customer and maintaining the value of the product. Additionally, it secures a potential avenue for free advertising, potentially attracting more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is expressing genuine interest in the flower vase and praises your work, acknowledging that the price is justified by the craftsmanship. However, she implies that her budget is tight, without providing any added value for a potential discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates your work, agreeing that the price is fair for the quality. Yet, her negotiation strategy involves offering value in return for a price reduction. By mentioning her willingness to promote your work on her social media platforms, she is proposing a mutual benefit scenario which might lead to increased visibility and possible sales in the future. Her offer could potentially help to increase your business and broaden your market.\\n\\nTherefore, taking into consideration the points made, Scenario 2 appears more favorable. While it's essential to help customers who appreciate the craftsmanship and are financially constrained, it's better for the longevity of the business to opt for a deal which also provides potential growth and increased sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios pose a potential benefit, however, the contexts are slightly different.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill clearly appreciates the artisan's work and appears to genuinely desire the vase for personal enjoyment. She implies that she has financial constraints, and this act of negotiation might be common in the local market scene. Therefore, offering a discount might secure her satisfaction and loyalty to return to the shop in the future, when she may have a looser budget. However, there is no explicit promise of future benefits for reducing the price, other than continued patronage.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers a different type of compensation – exposure for the artisan's products on her social media platform. Considering she has a 'considerable following', this could potentially bring new customers and increase overall sales. The artisan would face a temporary loss on the vase's sale, but the exposure could provide a long-term gain. Of course, the potential of this promise depends on the credibility of Jill's offer, and the demographics and buying power of her followers.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I am inclined to choose scenario 2, for its potential wider audience reach and long-term benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.25 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present plausible reasons for why Jill should get the vase at a lower price. However, the determining factors for negotiation would be based on the potential benefits you as an artisan would get out of the interaction.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is complimentary about your work and also expresses her constraint due to her budget. She is showing a genuine interest and appreciation of your work and this might potentially cause you to consider her plea. But, her offerings are not distinct or beneficial for you, beyond this single transaction.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill also shows appreciation for your work and asks for a discount, she additionally offers exposure of your work through her social media platform. If Jill has a substantial following on her social media, this could potentially lead to more sales or general awareness of your craft, which is beneficial in the long run.\\n\\nGiven these, while the first scenario may potentially tug at your sympathy, it is the second scenario which provides a more tangible benefit as an advertising and marketing opportunity. That is why you would be more likely to negotiate the price in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth of Jill's approaches are valid methods of negotiation, however, there are different factors to consider.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the work, shows respect for the craft, and ask for flexibility due to her budget constraints. This is a straightforward negotiation appeal that could result in a price reduction as a favor to a well-intentioned customer, possibly fostering a good relationship that might lead to future business.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, offers a potential for benefiting beyond just this one transaction. Here, Jill is proposing a form of barter where instead of paying the full price, she offers promotion of the artisan's work on her social media platforms. This could lead to increased exposure and potentially more customers in the future, which could prove valuable in the long-term.\\n\\nFrom a purely business standpoint, Scenario 2 may hold more appeal assuming Jill has a substantial following that could convert to future sales. This makes the assumption that the exposure gained will indeed result in more profit over time. It's a riskier route but might pay off more substantially.\\n\\nOn the other hand, a discount granted in Scenario 1 might encourage Jill to return for more purchases, or recommend others to the artisan, also potentially increasing future sales.\\n\\nSo my choice would depend largely on how much I value immediate returns versus potential future gains, and how much confidence I have in Jill's ability to influence her social media following.\\n\\nAnswer: This decision can be subjective based on one's approach to their business. However, from a strategic and long-term perspective, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI'll consider both scenarios separately:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is appealing on the basis of her admiration for local artisans and her current budgetary constraints. This shows her deep appreciation for the craft and at the same time, she is honest about her financial situation. However, she doesn't provide any direct benefit to me or my business, other than her patronage, in exchange for the discount she is asking for.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, not only does Jill show deep appreciation and interest in the vase, but she also offers something of value in return - promotion on social media. This could potentially reach many people, and it could be of great benefit especially if she has a considerable following. This could lead to more visibility for my work and potentially more sales.\\n\\nTherefore, my answer would be: \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nThe reason being, Jill is not only seeking a discount but also offering a valuable proposition that could potentially attract more customers. Besides, this can be a great opportunity for me to use her platform to expand my market visibility.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 6.8\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both statements, Jill shows a keen interest in supporting local art and buying the vase. Both cases present us with a customer who values the work of a local artisan and indicates she might become a regular buyer. However, in Scenario 2, Jill not only shows her interest but also mentions the possibility of her becoming a repeat customer. This opens up a chance for a long-term relationship with a customer, which can be more beneficial in the future.\\n\\nAlso, considering the negotiation part, in Scenario 2, Jill talks about a 'little wiggle room', not specifying any particular discount amount, giving us more flexibility to offer a small concession that would make her happy and inclined to come back. In Scenario 1, on the other hand, she's talking about a 'small discount' without defining what 'small' means to her, which might be different from what it means to us.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments your work and expresses a desire to support local artisans—key factors in conveying her genuine interest. However, the two scenarios differ in Jill's stance on the buying pattern and her negotiation tactics.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is fairly straightforward and mentions her financial constraint, soliciting a price reduction based on sympathy and her appreciative recognition of your work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, not only does Jill admire your work, but she also inquires about discounts for repeat customers—implying that she plans to make future purchases. Thus, she's introducing the potential for an ongoing business relationship rather than a one-time transaction.\\n\\nConsidering long-term business prospects and potential customer loyalty, Scenario 2 presents a more compelling case for offering a discount. It helps to foster a continuing relationship with the customer where the loss from a small discount now may be offset by the future purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present Jill as a potential customer genuinely interested in purchasing the vase and supporting local artisans, there are some differences in her approach that could influence the inclination to negotiate a discount.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments the work and directly recognizes the effort put into the crafting process. She comes across polite and respectful, acknowledging the price is fair based on the perceived quality and workmanship, yet she states a personal circumstance (a tight budget) as her reason for requesting a discount. This acknowledgement can foster empathy and could potentially evoke willingness to help her out by dropping the price a bit.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, introduces Jill as a potentially regular customer. She again praises the craftsmanship of the vase and shows interest in supporting the artisan's work on multiple occasions. However, while asking for a discount, she also introduces the possibility of a larger future relationship that not only involves immediate sales, but also potential recurring sales and possibly word-of-mouth advertisement among her acquaintances. This is a classic sales negotiation tactic that could hold a positive outcome for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nThe promise of repeat business and potential free advertising might make the temporary reduction in profit worthwhile, thereby making Jill's approach in scenario 2 potentially more attractive. However, the decision may vary based on the artisan's personal principles, values, need for immediate income versus long-term potential, and other personal and business factors.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 6.55\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn this case, it can be tough to choose between the two scenarios because both individuals express their admiration for the craft, show their interest in the vase, and are advocating for a discount. However, I would be more willing to negotiate in Scenario 1 for a few reasons.\\n\\nJill mentions an intent to come back to the market and possibly buy more in the future. This indicates the possibility of a repeat customer, which can provide long-term financial benefits compared to a one-time purchase. By offering this customer a small discount, I may be incentivizing future purchases. It could establish goodwill and create a lasting customer relationship.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while the customer appreciates the work, she only mentions her constrained budget.  While I sympathize with her financial constraints, offering her a discount won’t necessarily guarantee return business or the sale of other items; there's no indication of potential future purchases.\\n\\nConsidering all factors, while both customers appreciate the craft and quality of the vase, future business potential is also a significant consideration.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a polite customer who appreciates the quality of an artisan's work and shows potential to be a return purchaser. However, for an entrepreneur, it's essential to sell products at profitable prices and maintain long-term relationships with customers as well.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill explicitly mentions her plans for future purchases and suggests that she might buy multiple items. This could potentially lead to a regular stream of sales and indicate a higher lifetime value as a customer. Offering her a discount could encourage her to make additional purchases in the future and enhance customer loyalty. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is expressing a desire to support local artisans and implicitly hints at returning, but her budget constraints could limit the number and frequency of her purchases. While it's still beneficial to maintain a good relationship with her as a customer, it might not be as financially rewarding as Scenario 1 in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches the negotiation with a sincere and reasonable request. She compliments my work, recognizes the effort I put into my craft, and conveys her desire to remain a customer in the future. I am open to negotiating in both cases.\\n\\nHowever, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. In Scenario 1, Jill not only compliments my work but also expresses an interest in making multiple purchases in the future. This signals to me that if I make an exception and offer her a discount now, she is likely to be a recurring customer, hence creating future revenues.\\n\\nFurthermore, she offers two possible justifications for a discount - returning customer and multiple purchases. Both are common practices in retail and provide me with a reasonable excuse to offer a discount without devaluing my work. Therefore, it feels less like a one-time negotiation and more like an investment in a long-term customer relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen considering these two scenarios, both present appealing reasons to offer a discount. They both express admiration and understanding for the craftsmanship involved, which shows respect for my work as an artisan.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill offers something additional–an incentive towards a discount by offering to promote my work on her social media. If she indeed has a substantial following, that could potentially bring me many more customers. It's essentially a form of barter - she gets a discount on the vase, and I get advertising in return, which can be more valuable than the discount and even bring more profit in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is focusing more on her personal constraints, and though it's a commendable approach, there's not an equal exchange like in the first scenario.\\n\\nHence, considering the potential long-term benefit of the offer in Scenario 1, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price with Jill in this scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a customer who has a legitimate interest in the vase and also an appreciation for artisan-made goods. She communicates her appreciation for the craftsmanship and admits she is either willing to pay the full price or really wants to support local artisans — both good signs.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 1, she also offers added value through social media exposure, which could potentially bring more customers and increase my business. This is an exchange not just of goods, but also of services, which could have a long-term benefit for me. On the other hand, in scenario 2, she is hinting that the item might simply be out of her price range — a typical negotiation tactic, but one that doesn't offer an added bonus for me.\\n\\nThat's why even though the monetary compromise might be the same, the potential for additional gains through exposure swings the balance in favor of scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present favorable conditions to negotiate the price of the vase, Scenario 1 provides more compelling reasons on why a discount could be potentially beneficial for me. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the effort that went into making the vase and expresses her willingness to pay the full price, showing she values the work put into the piece. This shows a level of respect for artisan work that might make me more favorably inclined towards negotiation.\\n\\nMore significantly, Jill possibly offers additional value with her suggestion of promoting my work on her social media platform. Assuming she does indeed have a sizable and engaged following, this could lead to increased exposure and potentially, more customers. It's essentially a form of marketing or advertising, and the value generated from that could well offset the small discount given.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill again appreciates the craftsmanship, she appeals more to sympathy due to her budget constraints, but does not offer additional value like the first scenario.\\n\\nTherefore, I am more likely to negotiate on the price with Jill in Scenario 1 due to added value she can bring through her social media platform. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill uses flattery to compliment my work and asserts her interest in supporting local artisans. Moreover, she conveys her desire to make a purchase despite being financially constrained, which is a polite way to broach the subject of a potential discount.\\n\\nHowever, the deciding factor is in the future benefits that the customer is implying by their words.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill explicitly requests a discount but doesn't put forth the possibility of future purchases or a continuing buyer-artisan relationship. She seems to appreciate the work, wants the vase, but asks for a one-time discount due to her financial constraints. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill's approach is more promising for my business longevity. While she mentions that the price is slightly above what she came prepared to spend, she also suggests repeat purchases, insinuates bulk buying, and proposes herself as a returning customer. Although implicit, her expressed intent towards a longer-term relationship proposes a more substantial overall profit even if I provide an occasional discount.\\n\\nIn such negotiation scenarios, artists need to make a tough decision between single purchase and potential future earnings. While the discount may lessen the profit today, it may lead to a profitable long-term customer relationship.\\n\\nTherefore, considering such future prospects, I am more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios revealed that Jill appreciates the craft and is interested in supporting local artisans. However, the difference lies in the way she presents her need for a discount. In Scenario 1, Jill is making a direct appeal for a small discount whilst highlighting her budget constraints. She recognizes the quality of work, and she’s indicating that she wants to make a purchase now, but needs it to fit within her budget. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also compliments the work, yet her request for a discount is slightly more complicated. She seems just as interested, but she’s suggesting that she plans to be a regular customer in the future and is interested in discounts for multiple item purchases or for being a loyal customer. The assurance of future purchases is a positive, but it might create a precedent where she’ll be expecting discounts every time.\\n\\nFrom a business standpoint, the best thing to do would be to secure a sale in the present moment rather than relying on potential future sales. So, although Jill's offer in Scenario 2 to be a regular customer is tempting, there's no immediate guarantee that she'll follow through on that promise.\\n\\nTherefore, it would be more reasonable to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1, particularly if you feel she could become a regular customer anyway once she appreciates the quality of your items in her own home.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios depict Jill expressing her admiration and appreciation for the artisanal work and the passion that has been put into it. They both are empathetic towards the artisan's efforts and livelihood which can be a crucial content while negotiating. However, Jill's approach in the second scenario is more convincing to negotiate the price as she's not just asking for a discount for this one time but also showing a prospect of a long-term customer who is willing to buy more items in future. A businessperson would always prefer a customer who can buy repeatedly even at a slightly reduced profit margin than a one-time customer. Long term customers help to maintain a steady flow of income and are more valuable in long run. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have potential for garnering a discount, but there are a couple of distinct differences between the two scenarios that affect my decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill sincerely compliments my craft, acknowledges the passion and work that goes into it, and expresses that supporting local artisans is important to her. While she does mention a budget constraint, she doesn't quantify this or suggest a new price, she merely asks if a discount is possible. This could lead to a negotiation where we discuss a fair price that appreciates the value of the work and her budget.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again compliments my work and expresses a desire to support local artisans. This scenario even goes a step further by indicating Jill's intent to return and shop at my stall in the future. This signifies a potential for not just a one-time sale but multiple sales and perhaps even word-of-mouth promotion. She inquires about discounts for multiple items or returning customers. There is however no immediate promise or commitment of buying multiple items, it remains a vague proposition. \\n\\nLastly, giving discounts to returning customers may not be a good strategy for me as it might encourage customers to expect sales or discounts, devaluing my work or making future negotiations difficult. \\n\\nAnswer: Considering all these factors and since I don't want to set unrealistic expectations with any potential frequent customer, I'd be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. Jill's respect for my work and sincere request for a discount due to budget limitations seems to offer the best case for a negotiation that is fair to both of us.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom an artisan's perspective, both scenarios present strong arguments for a potential discount. In scenario 1, Jill expresses appreciation for the craftsmanship involved and emphasizes her support for local artisans. In scenario 2, Jill also expresses her admiration for the work and commits to future purchases from the stall.\\n\\nHowever, the key difference lies in the nature of concession Jill is asking for. In scenario 1, she is requesting a straightforward price discount on a current single item, potentially reducing the net profit on at least one item.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is hinting towards buying multiple items or promising future purchases. This scenario can potentially generate more sales or secure a future customer even if a discount is offered, indicating a potentially higher overall profit for the artisan despite a smaller profit margin.\\n\\nMoreover, while both scenarios indicate a tight budget, scenario 2 provides a promise of future business, leading to the creation of a loyal customer base, which is crucial for small, local businesses.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the long-term benefit and possibility of increased sales volume, I'd be more inclined to negotiate on the price in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision to negotiate the price takes in several aspects into account such as the customer's compliment about the product, their budget constraints, and their anticipated return for more purchases. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill shows an interest in the vase and appreciates the artisan's work. She also mentions her budget constraints, implicitly asking for a discount. Even though she promises to support local artists, there is no clear guarantee she would return for more purchases from you specifically. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only compliments the vase's craftsmanship but also brings up the topic of future purchases and return customer discounts. By expressing her plans to come back and shop more, she shows her potential as a repeat customer, which could mean more business in the future.\\n\\nIf a small negotiation makes Jill a satisfied and loyal customer, this could pay off in the long run. Therefore, it would be better to consider a small discount, or a deal for buying multiple items or for future returning customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning: Both scenarios provide compelling reasons for considering a discount, and Jill in both respects the workmanship of the vase and shows interest in supporting local businesses. However, the offer from Jill in scenario 1 is more beneficial in the long term. Sharing my work on her social media platforms, especially if she has a significant number of followers, can provide advertising for my business that could bring in more customers beyond this one sale. This potential long-term client increase will likely offset any loss from providing a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill appreciates the work and presents a good case for the discount. She not only acknowledges the workmanship but also proposes a form of indirect compensation by offering to share the work on her social media platforms to potentially gain more clients. This is a decent proposition because in today's world, marketing plays a very crucial role in expanding one's customer base. If Jill's follower base is interested in such artisan pieces, it could mean more potential sales. If I have trust in the quality of my pieces, this kind of promotion could make a significant difference.\\n\\nOn the other hand, scenario 2 is much more straightforward in asking for a discount due to budget constraints. While this is a valid request and she states her desire to support the local artisan, there is no tangible return on reducing the price for me as the vendor.\\n\\nTherefore, after considering both events, I find it more beneficial to negotiate on the price in scenario 1 because Jill is offering something in return even after getting a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a potential customer who expresses genuine interest and appreciation for the handcrafted vase and recognizes the effort and talent involved in its creation. They both also emphasize their desire and emphasis on supporting local artisans. However, their negotiation methods are slightly different. Scenario 1 proposes a barter deal of sorts, offering social media exposure in return for a discount which could potentially bring more customers. This might be an appealing offer especially if I'm looking to expand my customer base.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, appeals to empathy, underlining the budget constraint as a reason for the requested discount. Although this approach is direct and honest, there is less of a tangible, future benefit to me as the seller and my business. It's more relying on goodwill and the short-term gain of making a sale.\\n\\nConsidering these perspectives, the decision would depend on what is more important to me at this moment in time. In the long run, Scenario 1 could be more beneficial as it could bring exposure and potential new customers. If immediate sales and supporting local community regardless of the business outcome is more important, Scenario 2 might be a better choice. For this response, I will consider long term benefits as being of more importance. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill emphasizes her appreciation for the artisan's work and the importance she places on supporting local crafters. There are a few factors to consider before deciding.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, she directly requests for a discount, citing budget limitations. It is a fairly straightforward request, respectful, and there is an implied promise for future patronage since she has an interest in the craft. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill proposes a discount in exchange for social media promotion. This can be an attractive proposition if the artisan is looking for ways to expand their reach and attract more customers. However, its effectiveness depends entirely on Jill's influence, the quality of her followers, and if they are the target market. It can be a gamble, as there's no surety on returns, and it could potentially undervalue the artisan's work as it's being sold for less than its worth based on a promise.\\n\\nIt's something of a tricky decision, but given the information at hand, I would choose...\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nMy reasons are this: While promotion on social media can be a good way to increase visibility, it's not a guaranteed success and does not guarantee immediate return on investment, if at all. Moreover, I don't have a measure of Jill's social media influence. On the other hand, giving a concession on an item for a visibly interested customer who appreciates the effort and artistry could potentially build good rapport and result in future business, and there's no additional condition attached other than price reduction. It's a more conservative approach, but in this case, it seems like a safer play.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a respectful potential buyer who appreciates the artistry of the product. However, the situations vary in the form of compensation you would get in return for offering a discount on the vase. \\n\\nScenario 1: Jill directly requests a small discount, which indicates a willingness to purchase. Nonetheless, she doesn't offer any compensation for reducing the price.\\n\\nScenario 2: Here, Jill not only appreciates the vase, but she also offers a form of non-monetary compensation. If Jill indeed has a significant following on her social media platform, providing a discount in return for her promotion could lead to wider exposure of your work and potentially new customers. In the long run, this specific type of advertising may yield higher profits compared to direct sales.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I'd be more likely to negotiate the price in the second scenario because of the unique value Jill brings beyond the immediate sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appeals to empathy by acknowledging the quality of my work and my efforts as a local artisan, yet admits limitations due to her budget. This direct request for a discount is a straightforward form of negotiation which may incline me towards offering a small discount.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill flatters my skillset again and implies that she has a large following on social media -implying that a discount on my vase would lead to promotion for my other works within her network. This proposition seems quite tempting since it is poised to generate more sales and exposure for my work. The only issue I see here is that it's a promise and promises can be broken.\\n\\nThough both are compelling, I lean towards Scenario 2 due to the long-term benefits associated with increased exposure and possible additional sales. However, I might request her to make a post about the vase and tag me right then thereby eliminating the risk of her not following through.  If she's unable to do this, I would stick with Scenario 1, as the conditions are more certain.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill acknowledges the quality of the work and expresses interest in the vase. However, the two scenarios differentiate in the values they offer back to me, the artisan. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only interested in acquiring the vase, but also indicates that she is most likely to make multiple purchases and will become a returning customer. Additionally, she might also become a source of free promotion for my handcrafted items by sharing on her social platform and help me reach a wider audience, potentially driving more sales. This indicates that she values the art and craft market and would likely become a regular patron, which is very beneficial for me as a seller.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is definitely admiring the work and appreciates my effort, which is nice to hear. However, she only mentions a personal budget constraint and the wish to support local artisans. She doesn't offer any additional incentive like becoming a regular customer or publicizing the work on social media. \\n\\nThus, while both Jill's expressions of admiration are gratifying, Scenario 1 offers more potential long-term benefits to my business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons for the artisan to consider a discount, but for different reasons. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is suggesting a possible long-term relationship with the artisan. Not only does she mention that she’s a returning customer, but she also hints at possible future purchases and offers to promote the stall on her social media platform, which could bring in more customers in the future. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill provides a compliment to the artisan’s work, expressing her support for local craftsmen. She shows a good understanding and appreciation of the value of handcrafted items, which the artisan might appreciate. However, she also mentions that she has a limited budget.\\n\\nWhile scenario 2 definitely lends itself to a possible negotiation, the first scenario provides a potentially more beneficial situation for the artisan in the longer term, through repeated business and free advertising.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios raised by Jill involve making some concessions on the price of the vase. However, the proposals differ significantly.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill puts forward several valid points for a discount. She expresses interest in buying multiple items and becoming a regular customer, which are beneficial to any business. Beyond that, Jill offers to utilize her considerable social media following to provide free publicity for my work. This kind of advertising could potentially broaden my customer base and increase my sales. So even though I will be giving a discount, the benefits provided in return would likely outweigh the minor loss.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill doesn't offer anything beyond the potential for regular patronage. While I appreciate her compliments and willingness to support local artisans, these kind words don't provide a tangible benefit to my business. Furthermore, budget constraints are unfortunately a common occurrence and I cannot provide discounts to every customer who expresses such limitations, as doing so could harm my earnings.\\n\\nFor these reasons, Scenario 1 presents a more compelling case for a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAs an artisan, it's always rewarding when customers acknowledge the effort and passion put into the work. Each piece sold supports my livelihood and enables me to continue crafting. In such situations, deciding on whether to give a discount can be tricky and varies case-by-case.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill has complimented my work and simultaneously expressed her financial constraints. She has shown appreciation for the effort I've put into the vase and wants to support local artisans. This suggests that she values my work beyond mere transaction – she understands my motivation behind crafting such items. Given the sincerity in her approach, I might be inclined to give her a small discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also acknowledges my craftsmanship and offers to promote my work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. This offer is certainly tempting because it could potentially bring more customers to my stall in the future. However, it's not precisely clear how influential her network is or how effective her promotion will be. Additionally, it's worth considering whether such business-like bartering matches my values as an artisan who appreciates the non-financial aspect of her craft.\\n\\nConsequently, while both scenarios hold desirable outcomes, one carries a risk with an uncertain potential. Thus, my decision would largely depend on my belief in the authenticity of the customer's claim and situation.\\n\\nAnswer: Further inquiry would be needed for Scenario 2, for instance, finding out more about Jill’s influence, followers, and commitment to promote the work. As it stands presently, I would be more likely to negotiate the vase price in Scenario 1 due to the clear and genuine appreciation and acknowledgment of financial constraints without the need for potential uncertainties.\", \"The potential to negotiate on the price of the vase could be found in both scenarios. However, each scenario focuses on different aspects that might motivate a change in price.\\n\\nScenario 1 sees Jill highlighting her appreciation for the artisan craft and the effort put into the vase. She also discloses her financial situation. Assuming she genuinely cannot afford the marked price and isn't just haggling, empathy on our part might lead to a small discount. Indeed as an artisan, the appreciation of craftsmanship and the intent to support local artisans could be a powerful driving factor. By selling at a lower price, we not only make a sale but also establish a customer relationship that may lead to future purchases and word-of-mouth recommendations.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, offers a form of barter trade -- promotion of craftsmanship in exchange for a discount. Here, Jill is effectively offering a marketing service which could bring more attention, and potentially customers, to our work. Scenario 2 also signifies a business partnership of sorts, offering the potential for long-term mutual benefits. \\n\\nKeeping everything in mind, I would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. While the recognition of our craft in Scenario 1 is appreciated, the concrete addition of value (potential new customers and exposure) from Jill's promotion in Scenario 2 makes it more attractive. Therefore:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe goal of selling at a local market is not just to make profits but also to foster a strong relationship with the local customers and build your customer base. In both scenarios, the customer, Jill, has complimented my work which shows she values my craft. However, they differ in their approach to asking for a discount.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill emphasizes her budget constraint and her interest in supporting local artisans. Here, she is directly engaging with my work and shows a genuine appreciation for the craft. By her statement, she is likely to return again and purchase more pieces in the future.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also expresses her appreciation but offers to promote me to her followers on social media in exchange for a discount. While this can be valuable, it is also a bit riskier. There's no guarantee this exposure will translate into sales or that her followers will be interested in my work.\\n\\nConsidering these points, while the offer of promotion is tempting, I would be more likely to negotiate in scenario 1. This is because Jill is emphasizing a personal connection to my work and not just viewing it as a commodity. Even though she is asking for a discount now due to budget constraints, she seems more likely to make future purchases at the full price, leading to sustainable business growth.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning text:\\n\\nBoth scenarios put forward by Jill offer reasons for a potential price negotiation, but they offer different benefits.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media platforms to a large audience. Depending on the size and quality of her following, this could directly result in increased sales, more recognition of my brand, and potentially more opportunities down the line. It's essentially proposing a trade- a discount now for valuable promotion and advertisement which could prove potentially more profitable in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is not offering anything concrete in return for a discount other than her goodwill and patronage. While supporting customers who earnestly appreciate craft and are genuinely constrained by their budget is admirable, it doesn't necessarily helps the business in a tangible way like the first scenario. \\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios might warrant some sort of discount, from a business standpoint, Scenario 1 presents a concrete value proposition and provides a potential return on the price reduction.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill presents a value exchange. She doesn't simply ask for a discount, she offers to share a post about the artisan's works on her social media platforms, exposing the artisan to a potential new customer base. This is a form of barter trade where she uses her social influence as commodity for a supposed price reduction. This could be beneficial to the artisan especially if Jill does have a significant social media following. It could lead to a wider visibility and subsequently more sales. So, the artisan might see an overall benefit that outweighs the discount given.\\n\\nOn the other hand, the second scenario is a more typical negotiation where the buyer expresses their constraint and appeals to the seller's empathy, hoping they understand the budget constraint and offer a discount. It is great that Jill wants to support local artisans, but apart from her goodwill, there's no direct benefit to the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\nIn scenario 1, Jill brings a potential benefit to my business by offering to promote my work on her social media platforms. This kind of exposure can indeed help attract new customers and expand my audience, which can escalate my sales. On top of this, she acknowledges the value of the work, implying that she understands the effort and craftsmanship involved in creating the vase. A small discount here could yield a greater return on investment in the form of new customers in the long run.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill's appreciation for my work and her intention to support local artisans like myself is clear and admirable, her request for a discount is solely based on her personal financial constraints. There is no immediate or potential benefit to my business in this scenario.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present reasonable requests for a discount. However, each scenario has different incentives for me as an artisan. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appeals to the value of my work and recognizes the effort it took for me to produce the vase. Her appeal to my passion for craftsmanship might make me more open to giving her a discount. However, this discount would likely be a one-time occurrence and doesn't immediately offer anything in return aside from the satisfaction of knowing my work is appreciated and will be put to good use.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also compliments my work, but she adds in a potential form of barters. She offers to promote my work on her social media platforms in exchange for a discount on the vase. Depending on her follower count and engagement rates, this could result in increased visibility for my work and potentially more customers in the future. This offer presents a potentially tangible return on investment in terms of increased exposure and potential sales.\\n\\nTherefore, taking into consideration the potential long-term benefits, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling arguments, however, they differ in their manner of approach and the type of benefits they offer. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill immediately recognizes and appreciates the value of the artisan's work, appealing directly to the emotions and principles of the artisan. This appreciation and understanding of the craftsmanship involved is indeed a pleasant approach, however, it only offers emotional value and doesn't present a tangible return for discounting the vase.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, while Jill also expresses her admiration for the work, she further offers something of value - promotion on her active social media accounts. This can result in wider exposure for the artisan's work, potentially bringing in more customers in the future. This type of proposed deal can be seen as an even exchange and is more likely to be attractive to the artisan. \\n\\nThe artisan may recognize that exposure via social media accounts can be worth more than the few dollars they may take off the vase. The future business it might drive would more than compensate for the discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn any negotiation, emotive reasons and the perceived value exchange are integral determinants of the outcome. \\n\\nAnalyzing Scenario 1: Jill appreciates the value of the artisan's craft and acknowledges the effort put into it. She wants to support the local artisans, which indicates a possible long-term customer and a positive influence in her circle. However, she doesn't provide any added value in return for the discount she is asking. Her justification for the discount is purely based on her personal budget constraint. \\n\\nAnalyzing Scenario 2: Jill not only appreciates the work but also provides a possible value exchange. She is offering to promote the artisan's work on her social media, and it could help the artisan gain exposure to a larger audience. If Jill has decent followings on her social media platforms, this could translate into future sales for the artisan. Therefore, granting a small discount might be viewed as a small current investment for bigger future gains. \\n\\nWith this in mind, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 2 because I could gain potential promotional benefits from this trade-off, which may help in expanding my customer base and increasing future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 6.8\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, the customer Jill has expressed admiration for the craftwork and has shown interest in returning to purchase more crafts in the future. In each case, she politely inquires about price negotiation and potential discounts, possibly for multiple purchases or for repeat business. This indicates that she values the work, which is positive. Both inquiries would typically lead to a price negotiation depending on the seller's policy. \\n\\nHowever, in scenario 1, Jill pushed a little bit further in her negotiation plea. She mentioned the possibility of buying multiple items, which may benefit the seller in terms of sales volume. This proposition would usually incentivize a seller to consider a discount, making this scenario slightly more compelling for price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses appreciation for the artisan's work. However, Scenario 1 reads as more sincere and builds a foundation for long-term customer loyalty. Jill expresses interest in making multiple purchases and becoming a returning customer. These words give impression that Jill values the artisan's work and is not only interested in getting a discount, but also in supporting the artisan's craft in the long run. This mutual respect is likely to open the artisan to the idea of giving a discount. In Scenario 2, although Jill also mentions supporting the artisan's work in future, it is less specific than in Scenario 1. The lack of interest in buying multiple items also makes Scenario 2 less compelling.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: In scenario 1, Jill interprets the craftsmanship and gives praise to the artisan, indicating that she understands and appreciates the value of handcrafted work. She also engages in respectful negotiation, asking delicately about the possibility of a lower price or multiple purchase discounts. Plus, she intends on being a repeat customer, showing loyalty to your craftsmanship that might be rewarded with a small discount. In comparison, Scenario 2 is similar, but lacks the same level of appreciation and promise of repeat business. While she admires the craft, the language used is less engaging.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers not just to buy the vase, but also to advertise the vase and my work on her social media. Depending on her reach, this could potentially bring in a considerable number of new customers and boost my sales significantly. Because she's promising to help me increase my business, I would be more willing to negotiate the price with her. While she does mention a discount, she does say that she is willing to pay the full price, so any negotiation could still result in a decent profit.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is more focused on bargaining for the vase and doesn't offer anything in return. Plus, she's suggesting the possibility of discounts on future purchases, which I may not be able to afford, especially if she wants similar pieces to the vase. So, while I would certainly appreciate her patronage, I may not be able to negotiate as much on the price.\\n\\nGiven these reasons, I'm more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1 because Jill is offering potential future benefits to my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nWhile both scenarios presented by Jill are appealing, they offer different incentives for negotiation. \\n\\nScenario 1 is attractive because Jill offers free marketing for my products. In case she does have a substantial following on social media, posts about my vase could increase exposure to my products and could potentially drive even more sales. This type of in-kind bartering can be very advantageous for small-time artisans, especially those who don't have a large marketing budget. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 showcases Jill's interest not only in the vase but also in potentially purchasing more items in the future. This implies I could have a repeat customer, which is always beneficial for any business. Offering her a discount could incentivize her to come back to my stall and purchase more in the future; however, there's no guarantee that this would happen. \\n\\nIn conclusion, while Scenario 2 proposes an indirect way of boosting sales, Scenario 1 provides an immediate benefit, potentially reaching a large audience instantly. The effectiveness of Jill's social media advertising could potentially yield more sales and repeat business than a mere verbal commitment to return. However, the effectiveness of Jill's offer in Scenario 1 does depend on her credibility, follower count, and the level of engagement on her social media.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn this particular situation, there are several considerations to take into account when determining which scenario would be more likely to prompt negotiation on the price of the vase. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appeals to both the emotional and the financial side of running a small local business. She recognizes the artisan's hard work, which is always appreciated. Moreover, she offers an intriguing proposition in the form of advertising on her social media. This has the potential to be quite valuable if she indeed has a large following as she claims. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is also showing respect and admiration for the artisan's work. Her approach is more direct and solely financially oriented. She is asking for a discount on either this purchase or future ones if she becomes a returning customer. \\n\\nBoth scenarios are tempting, but there's an added value in the first scenario with Jill's proposal for social media advertisement. This could attract new customers and boost sales in the future. Therefore, I would be more likely to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1 as it provides the potential for both immediate and future benefits. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.7\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios presented by Jill are nearly similar, the main differentiating point is the latter part of Scenario 2.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she complements the artisan's craft and shows sincere interest. Throughout this scenario, the customer is very friendly and courteous and asks for a potential price discussion politely. But Jill limits her purchasing interest to the flower vase only.\\n\\nHowever, In Scenario 2, Jill not only complements the artisan's work and asks for a price reduction of the single item, but also introduces other factors that could lead to a higher total sale. She demonstrates the potential of becoming a regular customer by mentioning her plans of returning. Additionally, she also shows interest in purchasing multiple items, implying an increased sale quantity.\\n\\nThe artisan is a business person who wants to encourage more sales and acquiring loyal customers. Though providing a small discount might decrease the price of each item, equity from multiple sales and the potential for recurring customers is worth the price reduction.\\n\\nWith these factors in mind, the artisan is more likely to negotiate the price in the second scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth customers are expressing their admiration and interest for my artisan work which is quite encouraging. However, their inquiries about price negotiations are handled quite differently. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is being straightforward about her budget constraint and honestly conveys that she'd like to negotiate on the price. This approach feels authentic and as a seller, I feel more inclined to consider her proposal out of respect for her budget considerations.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also shows interest in the vase but she frames her price negotiation in terms of potential future benefits for me such as purchasing multiple items and being a returning customer. This could potentially be more profitable, but it also hinges on a promise for future engagement which is uncertain. There's a possibility that she might not return to buy more or even become a repeat customer.\\n\\nTherefore, based on these considerations, I would choose to negotiate with the customer in scenario 1 who openly expresses her constraint rather than assuming potential future transactions.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[Reasoning Text]\\n\\nThe decision on reducing the price would depend on a few factors. In both scenarios, Jill shows appreciation and interest in the vase, giving praise to the craftsmanship, which certainly has an emotional impact on the artisan. Both scenarios suggest that Jill may become a repeat customer, providing the possibility of future sales. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill openly talks about her budget constraints, making it clear that a reduced price would aid her decision. However, she doesn't commit to coming back or buying more than one item right away.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also asks for a discount but sweetens the deal by mentioning the possibility of buying multiple items at once, which would obviously bring more immediate income, and also she suggests that she plans on coming back, which infers future income as well. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2 \\n\\nBecause in Scenario 2 Jill suggests an immediate multiple item sale which signifies more income right away, and the assurance of coming back infers future income which could make up for the discount given. The artisan might be more likely to accommodate an engaged customer who is planning to make multiple purchases and be a potential recurring customer, offering more long-term gains.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Both scenarios presented by Jill are polite and respectful, showing admiration to the craftsmanship and expressing interest in supporting local artisans. They both also express Jill\\'s intention of being a repeat customer and purchasing multiple items. Here are some reasoning points, and how they may influence the decision on negotiating the price.\\n\\n1. Attitude and politeness: Both scenarios are friendly and polite, valuing the artisans\\' work. This is an important element when considering negotiating prices. There is no significant difference in this element between the two options.\\n\\n2. Appreciation for craftsmanship: Both scenarios show a great appreciation for craftsmanship, which will always be appreciated by the artisan. However, scenario 2 emphasizes a stronger emphasis on appreciating and valuing the work that goes into the item. \\n\\n3. Intention of purchase: Both scenarios express the intention of buying the vase. However, scenario 1 explicitly expresses the intention of buying multiple items at once, which could be a more enticing offer for the artisan.\\n\\n4. Intent of future business: Both scenarios express the intention of returning for future business. This is something that any vendor appreciates and could influence the decision for a discount. Regardless, scenario 1 seems to emphasize a certain commitment to future business, as Jill noted she is \"definitely planning to come back to shop in the future.\"\\n\\nConsidering all the above points, my decision would lean towards scenario 1 due to its explicit mention of buying multiple items at once and a stronger commitment to returning for future business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning Text:\\nWhile both scenarios exhibit respect for the craft and desire to support local artisans, the customer in Scenario 1 seems genuinely invested in the artisan's work, future visits, and purchasing other items as value added. She also acknowledges clue of an explicit financial constraint on her part, giving a solid reason to need a discount. In Scenario 2, Jill seems interested in buying the vase, mentions the potential of buying other items, and her intent to return, but doesn't quite give a direct reason to need a discount aside from asking if bargaining is possible. Therefore, considering the nature of a seller-buyer relationship, a scenario where the potential buyer not just values the products but also shows intent towards building a long-term relationship by acknowledging future visits may encourage the artisan to negotiate or offer a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: Both scenarios roughly follow the same negotiation pattern with Jill complimenting the piece and expressing her interest in supporting local artisans and becoming a returning customer. However, in Scenario 1, Jill discloses that her budget is tight at the moment and she is looking for discounts due to financial constraints. Scenario 2 contains a similar request for negotiation, but without direct reference to financial issues. Instead, Jill seems more focused on making a deal, rather than expressing financial need. As a seller, one might be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1 due to empathising with Jill's budget issue, while in Scenario 2 it seems like Jill is more interested in securing a deal regardless of her actual financial capabilities.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"In response to Scenario 1:\\nJill is offering something beyond more money as a part of her negotiation. Her offer to share the work on her social media platforms could result in increased exposure and potentially more customers in the future. This free advertising is valuable and could result in a greater increase in revenue over time than the immediate sale of the vase. \\n\\nIn response to Scenario 2:\\nIn this scenario, Jill is asking for a discount based on her intention to purchase multiple items or become a returning customer. While this does offer potential for additional sales in the future, it doesn't guarantee future purchases and doesn't offer any immediate, additional value as Scenario 1 does.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Although the benefits from both scenarios are theoretical, the guaranteed exposure from the social media promotion in Scenario 1 has a more direct and measurable potential for driving revenue in the short and medium term than a promise of future purchases in Scenario 2. This makes Scenario 1 a more desirable strategy from a business perspective.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Jill's proposition in Scenario 1 not only appeals to a short-term benefit (the immediate sale) but also to long-term advantages (potential increase in visibility, customer base, and future sales). If Jill has a sizable social media following that aligns with potential customer demographics, offering a discount could ultimately pay off more than the price cut. Additionally, from the description Jill provides, she seems genuinely enthusiastic, supportive, and appreciative of the artisan's work, highlighting a potential for a longer-term customer relationship and possible referrals. Also, Jill talks about promoting the artist's work, which could lead to a rise in business visibility.\\n\\nWhile the potential of selling more than one vase in Scenario 2 is also appealing, there seems to be less guarantee of continued benefit as compared to the prospect of more visibility for future customers generated from Jill's social media promotion in Scenario 1. The discount proposal in scenario 2 also seems to be mainly centered around the buyer's benefit rather than a mutual benefit, as compared to scenario 1.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill approaches me politely and appreciatively, showing interest and admiration for my craftsmanship. However, what makes scenario 1 more appealing, despite seemingly similar notions, is the mention of potential exposure through her social media platforms.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers not only a purchase but also an exchange where the value goes beyond just the sale of the vase. She's providing a form of compensation in addition to paying for the vase. Jill's offer to promote my work on her social media where she has a considerable following could potentially increase my customer base which could lead to greater sales in the long run. This form of advertisement is an added value and a bartering chip that makes me more likely to negotiate the price and offer a discount.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2 Jill asks for discounts on potential future purchases. While this might suggest a long-term customer relationship, it's much more speculative and uncertain compared to the immediate and definite offer of advertising present in Scenario 1. Also, offering a discount in anticipation of future purchases might set a precedent for discounted prices in the long run which may not be sustainable for my business.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present interesting propositions, however, as an artisan my goal would be to sell more of my merchandise while also building a loyal customer base. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses appreciation for my work. She also mentions she will be a returning customer, possibly even buying more than one item. This is attractive as having loyal, returning customers can be a great asset for a small business like mine. Furthermore, her intention to buy multiple items could result in a larger immediate sale, even if I do offer her a discount. These reasons make Scenario 1 attractive. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to promote my art on her social media platforms for a discount. While this could bring me exposure, there is no guarantee that her followers will be interested in or be able/willing to purchase my handcrafted items. The impact on my potential sales is uncertain, making the offer less attractive. \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill wishes to negotiate the price down, and even though exposure on social media is tempting, the promise of regular visits and the purchase of multiple items in Scenario 1 is much more appealing. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their own unique ways of trying to negotiate the price. In the first scenario, Jill expresses her admiration for the work and discusses her intention of becoming a returning customer. She further expresses interest in purchasing multiple items. This could mean a larger immediate sales for me and potential future sales which is appealing. This is a direct benefit for me as an artisan and a seller.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers to share my work on her large social media platform. Whilst this sounds intriguing, there are a few uncertainties. The effectiveness of this type of promotion isn't a guaranteed sale and there is no way of knowing how Jill's followers will react, if they will be interested in my work, and if they would actually purchase anything. While it could potentially generate more exposure and thus more business, it's also a substantial risk since there's no immediate tangible benefit.\\n\\nTherefore, taking these factors into account, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1. It seems to offer more immediate and assured benefits to me as a seller. The promise of additional purchases increases the value of the overall sale and the possibility of a return customer offers more long-term stability. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[Reasoning Text]\\nBoth scenarios are good examples of negotiation strategies where the customer upfront admires the artisan's work and politely communicates their desire for a better deal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the customer appears to be potentially a value customer who might buy more than one item and also could be a returning customer. This can result in higher future sales for the artisan while requiring one-time negotiation as a reward to the customer's loyalty. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the customer offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. However, without concrete numbers regarding the customer's following or reach, it's hard to evaluate what the artisan could actually benefit from this deal. It also introduces additional risk if the social media promotion does not consequently lead to more sales.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, the artisan may feel inclined to negotiate more in the first scenario as it provides a more immediate and quantifiable return. Also, having a large customer base that consistently buys your products gives a certain amount of stability and predictability to your business' revenue, while depending on the impact of a social media post can be quite uncertain.\\n  \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0.5, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as someone who genuinely appreciates artisanal handiwork and is looking to buy the vase. That being said, in Scenario 1, Jill directly expresses an interest in bargaining, and she compliments the craftsmanship, which shows she values the work, thus her attempt to reduce the price should be out of a need for a deal rather than devaluing the product. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill exhibits a similar appreciative stance toward the craftsmanship but frames her inquiry regarding discounts within the context of buying multiple items. This could potentially bring more sales, which is an enticing prospect. However, her request for future customer discounts is more strategic yet vague as she doesn't commit to a future purchase.\\n\\nSo, considering both pros and cons in each scenario, Scenario 1's direct bargaining approach and Scenario 2's potential multiple sale bargain position are taken into account.\\n\\nAnswer: Both scenarios provide valid reasons to negotiate, making it a tie between Scenario 1 and Scenario 2.\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill communicates with respect and shows a deep appreciation for the artisan's craft—a good starting point for a discussion. However, the way she phrases her intentions towards a possible discount and future transactions vary and could influence the artisan's response.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is more direct in asking for a possible discount right away and promptly refers to a prospective repeat patronage and bulk buying, which may feel more like a transactional interaction to the artisan. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill puts a more personal spin on her approach. She mentions her support for local artisans and paints a picture of a loyal customer relationship developing over time before asking about possible special deals. This resonates more closely with the practices of a small-scale craft market and the artisan's likely preference for long-term customer relationships.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2 could potentially be more persuasive for the artisan from a relational perspective. The artisan might feel more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill and consider special deals, as she has framed her interest not just as a single transaction, but as a longer-term relationship that could benefit the artisan both immediately and in future.\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is praising the craftsmanship of the vase, exhibiting interest in it, and hinting at the possibility of becoming a returning customer. However, the approach does differ slightly between the two scenarios. In Scenario 1, Jill openly brings up the possibility of bargaining and directly asks about discounts for multiple purchases and returning customers. In Scenario 2, Jill's approach seems more subtle, she 'wonders' about possible discounts rather than asking explicitly. However, she reinforces her admiration for the craftsmanship and support for local artisans. \\n\\nWhile both scenarios provide an opportunity for negotiating, Scenario 1 offers a more transparent and direct approach to negotiation, making it easier for the seller to gauge Jill's interest and respond to her request for discounts or bargains. Her direct question about bargaining and discounts also shows apparent intent to buy. In Scenario 2, although the admiration and support for local artisans are conveyed, the request for a discount is less direct and can be considered more of a subtle hint, which could leave a little uncertainty about her intent to purchase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn my opinion, Jill's approach in Scenario 2 is more persuasive for a negotiation. Firstly, she compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, similar to what she does in scenario 1, showing genuine appreciation for the artisan's work. However, beyond just expressing her interest, Jill presents two possible ways that she could provide value to the artisan in return for a discount. \\n\\nFirst, Jill mentions that she plans to be a repeat customer, suggesting that the artisan can expect future revenue from her. This is a strong negotiation tactic as it offers recurring business in exchange for a small favorable deal now. Secondly, Jill mentions that she has a few thousand followers on social media and offers to promote the artisan's work on her platforms. This implies that the artisan could gain additional exposure, potentially leading to more customers down the line. This form of unofficial 'influencer marketing' can be very valuable, especially for small, local artisans who may not have a large advertising budget. \\n\\nWhile scenario 1 also includes Jill expressing her admiration for the work and indicates she would return, it lacks the concrete offer she presents in Scenario 2. Therefore, as an artisan, I would be more interested in negotiating the price with Jill in Scenario 2 due to potential future benefits. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present different opportunities for negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows an interest in not only the round flower vase but potentially other items as well. She expresses a direct interest in becoming a returning customer, which could lead to more future sales. This makes considering a discount advantageous as it could foster a relationship and create a regular customer. The potential for repeat business gives me incentive to negotiate the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill proposes a discount in exchange for some social media attention to my works, even though she also shows interest in the vase itself and hints at potential future visits. This proposition could be beneficial by increasing the visibility of my work, potentially attracting more customers. \\n\\nHowever, there are uncertainties along with this. There is no guarantee that her posts will translate into more clients or sales. Also, committing to discounts based on vague future social media promotion sets a risky precedent if other customers were to find out. \\n\\nBased on these explanations, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. The prospect of securing a returning customer who might purchase multiple items in the future seems more certain and immediately beneficial than hoping for potential indirect business due to someone's social media posting.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expressed admiration for the handcrafted vase and a willingness to support the artisan's work, either by buying additional items or through return visits to the market. Positive customer experiences can easily translate into repeat business and word-of-mouth promotion, which might be tempting for the artisan to consider when negotiating the price.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers a straightforward proposal for a potential discount: buying multiple items and committing to returning in the future. This sort of bulk buying or loyalty discount is a common practice and can be a worthwhile investment for the artisan, as it guarantees more sales and a potential return customer.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill suggests a social media promotion in exchange for a discount. While this provides a different type of visibility, it's less predictable and harder to quantify its effect on future sales than the more traditional approach of buying more items or promising repeat business.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, Scenario 1 provides more surety for the artisan, both in terms of immediate sales (through additional purchases) and longer-term customer loyalty.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work in exchange for a discount. This sounds tempting and can be beneficial for my business, given how influencer marketing works these days. The promotion could potentially expand my customer network. However, depending on her actual following and the engagement rate, this might not translate into immediate sales or substantial growth.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates my work and is more than willing to purchase the vase. More importantly, she expresses interest in buying other items and becoming a potential long-term customer. This is compelling as it signifies not only an immediate sale but also possible future sales. She is also open to the concept of discounts on multiple items, which could lead to a larger overall sale at the current moment.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nEven though future sales are not as guaranteed as a one-time promotion in Scenario 1, recurring customers are usually more valuable for a small business like a local artisan. The potential of Jill purchasing other items today, along with the prospect of her being a repeat customer, could result in a more steady and reliable income. As an artisan, I would prefer a customer who genuinely values my work and wants to support my business long-term over a one-time promotion.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere are varied reasons to consider both scenarios. \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering to promote my work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. In essence, the discount could be viewed as payment for advertising services. The value of this depends on the size and demographics of her followers, and whether they're the kind of customers likely to purchase my items. If she has a large following of people that fit my target market, this could result in new customers and increased sales, which would more than offset the discount on the vase. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is interested in the vase, but also mentions buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. If I give her a discount, she might become a loyal customer and also buy more items both now and in the future. This would definitely lead to increased income in the long run.\\n\\nThat said, considering there's no certainty in either scenario, I would lean more towards Scenario 2. The simple fact that Jill mentioned a consideration to buy more items and return in the future seems like a more guaranteed option to increase my sales, compared to possible exposure on social media that may or may not translate to sales. Therefore, I'd be more willing to negotiate the price in that case.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"In considering both scenarios, I believe I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nReasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, although Jill is asking for a discount, she is offering something valuable in return. This value comes in the form of promotion to her social media followers, which has the potential to widen my customer base and multiply my sales substantially. This kind of word-of-mouth marketing is incredibly powerful, especially as it's coming from a trusted source (Jill). Furthermore, it's a more immediate offer that could have benefits right away, especially if Jill also leaves positive reviews online.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is definitely polite and shows interest in my work, but her request for a discount lacks the tangible return that Scenario 1 offers. While her intentions to return and buy more items are positive, it's more of a vague future promise compared to the immediate advertising value I gain from Scenario 1.\\n\\nTherefore, while bargains are not my usual business practice, the potential gain and exposure from Scenario 1 would make me more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen Jill approaches me to negotiate the price, as an artisan, I would have to consider various factors, including the profitability, goodwill, and potential exposure for my work. In both scenarios, Jill values my craft and shows direct interest in the vase. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media platforms, where she has a considerable following. If she has an audience that aligns with my target market, this could potentially be very beneficial for me. Exposure to a wider audience could increase my sales significantly and even open possibilities for potential collaborations or custom orders. The visibility and reach that social media provides can sometimes outweigh monetary benefits in the long-term growth of a small-scale business like mine.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill indicates continuous support by planning to be a returning customer and potentially buying multiple items. This is appealing, but the certainty of this happening is not as concrete as the exposure offered in scenario 1. \\n\\nIn conclusion, while both scenarios have their merits and chances for negotiation, the possibility to reach a broader audience with immediate effect gives scenario 1 an edge over scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios Jill is appreciative of the craftsmanship of the vase and shows interest in purchasing it, questioning the potential for a discount or agreement on price. \\n\\nScenario 1: Jill proposes a form of trade, with payment partially in exposure of my work to her social media following. The impact of this advertising would be indirectly beneficial and difficult to measure. Although it may potentially bring a new clientele, there's no guarantee that her followers would be interested in my work or would come to the market to purchase it.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill is asking for a discount and also opens up the discussion of multiple purchases as well as becoming a returning customer. This suggests a more immediate and guaranteed benefit to me: selling more items now, and potentially in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nWhile the advertising proposal in Scenario 1 is tempting and may be worth considering, Scenario 2 offers a more reliable benefit because Jill commits to purchasing multiple items and indicates that she will be a returning customer. These are tangible actions that can increase sales, while social media advertising is less predictable.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show Jill's appreciation for the craftsmanship and her interest in purchasing the vase. However, they offer different propositions for a potential discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote the products on her social media platforms, potentially increasing the visibility and reach of the products. This kind of promotion could potentially bring in many more customers, especially if Jill indeed has a sizable and engaged social media following. This type of exposure can be truly beneficial for a local artisan at a market, reaching customers who might not be local or aware of the market. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill implies a plan to buy other items or return to make more purchases in the future, which does promise more business for the artisan but does not provide any immediate or defined benefits.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios are appealing, the potential for wider reach and promotion offered in Scenario 1 could offer greater overall benefits. The promise of immediate promotion to a larger audience could have more impact than the potential future sales suggested in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth propositions from Jill are compelling. However, based on the provided information, I would consider giving a discount in Scenario 1. \\n\\nThis is primarily because she isn't just seeking a discount for personal gain, Jill is also offering something in return that has potential value for me as an artisan. The exposure on her social media could attract more customers to my craft business. Moreover, if her audience is interested in local arts and artisans, the posts may reach the exact demographic that would have a genuine interest in purchasing my products. Thus, this barter agreement can potentially increase my customer base. \\n\\nNevertheless, it would be wise to ask further questions to Jill - for example, how many followers she has and whether her posts about promotions have previously led to increased business for other artisans. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, though Jill suggests the possibility of future purchases and returning business, this is uncertain and contingent on her liking my products enough to return and buy more. While I appreciate her support and intention, a definitive promotion offer in scenario 1 seems more beneficial and immediate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAnalyzing both scenarios brings to light multiple factors that can influence my decision as an artisan to negotiate the price of the vase. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering to feature my work on her social media platforms in exchange for a discount. This could potentially include a significant audience reach and promotion for my art. However, there are also uncertainties in this deal since I cannot confirm the number of her followers or the influence she has over her audience. Therefore, the potential benefit may or may not materialize.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is suggesting the possibility of buying multiple items and returning to purchase more in the future, in exchange for a discount on the vase. This proposition offers a more immediate and tangible benefit: the sale of more items both at present and in the future.\\n\\nTherefore based on these considerations, and assuming both customers are equally trustworthy, I would be more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 2. In this case, there's a higher chance of immediate gain through multiple purchases, and the promise of a repeat customer is a valuable asset for my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer opportunities for negotiation, but they present different incentives. In the first scenario, Jill offers to promote the craftsman's work on her social media platforms in exchange for a discount. This kind of exposure could potentially attract a larger customer base, especially if Jill has a good number of followers or if her followers are people who would be interested in handmade items like those the craftsman sells.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill seems to be a repeat customer. She expresses her future interest to come back and make additional purchases. Offering a discount to such customers can be beneficial as it encourages customer loyalty, potentially leading to more sales in the future.\\n\\nWhile both negotiation offers are tempting, I would probably lean toward the first scenario. The reason for this is that, while repeat customers are highly valuable, reaching a broader audience through social media platforms can have a considerable impact on business growth. A larger audience can result in increased sales that can more than offset the discount provided to Jill on the vase.\\n\\nHowever, the decision would also depend on factors not presented in the scenarios like how many followers Jill has on social media and how often she is willing to promote the work, as well as how often the craftsman thinks Jill will return and how many items she might purchase on those returns.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill showed an interest in being a loyal customer implying additional future purchases which would lead to more profit in the long run. Thus, giving her a slight discount as a gesture of good faith might incentivize her to come back or recommend the shop to friends and family. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers to promote the shop on her social media, but it's not certain how much exposure this will actually give the shop or if this will result in any sales. There is no guarantee of direct returns and it might just result in a one-off purchase. Hence, providing a discount based on this proposition might not be as beneficial as establishing a relationship with a potential repeat customer. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning:\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and shows an interest in purchasing it, suggesting she values it quite highly. However, the two scenarios present different potential benefits for me. In Scenario 1, Jill suggests she could potentially be a repeat customer, which would be a steady stream of business. However, there isn’t a clear assertion that she will indeed become one. Furthermore, the frequency and volume of her future purchases are unknown, which makes the immediate benefit of the price reduction unclear.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 presents a more concrete benefit. Jill offers to actively promote my work, and her shop on her social media. If she has a large following, that could significantly increase the visibility of my products and potentially bring in a lot more customers. This provides not just a one-time benefit of a single sale but has potential long-term benefits that could be worth offering a discount for. Depending on the scale of her social media influence, I might be able to make back the amount I lose from the discount and potentially even more.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning text: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows enthusiasm for your work and alludes to the possibility of being a repeat customer. This presents an opportunity for a potential long-term relationship, which could result in more sales in the future. Moreover, offering discounts for repeat customers can provide added incentive for her to continue shopping from you. While immediate profit will be slightly less from a discounted sale, you may earn more in the long run from her recurring purchases.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to promote your work on her social media. This can be a tempting proposal depending on the scale and reach of her online presence. If she has a significant following, your work could gain more visibility, potentially attracting new customers. However, this scenario lacks any assurance – it poses more risks as compared to the first scenario. There's no certainty about the effectiveness of her social media promotion, or whether it will translate into additional sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 6.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn evaluating these two scenarios, both customers have shown a level of interest and appreciation for the craftsmanship of the vase. They also both offer promises of return business, though there is a slight variation in their propositions. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is more straightforward, offering consistent future business by becoming a repeat customer if there is a possibility of receiving deals. This promise of future purchases means potential steady income from this one customer even if I discount the current product. The fact she'd consider returning implies she values my work and might spread the word organically to others she knows.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the vase and suggests a trade-off where she gets a price reduction and I receive social media exposure. While social media exposure could potentially lead to increased business, it is significantly more unpredictable and out of my control. I would have to trust in Jill's social media following and her ability to present my product in a way that attracts other buyers.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill based on the proposal in Scenario 1, due to the more reliable promise of repeat sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill comes off as genuinely interested in the product and shows appreciation for the craftsmanship. However, the scenarios do differ slightly in terms of the incentives offered. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill asks for a discount upfront but provides a possible prospect for future business as she mentions being a repeat customer. It indicates that she values the vendor's work and would be interested in future purchases. This could be advantageous in the long term, providing an opportunity to foster a relationship with a repeat customer that could result in more sales. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill suggests that she would promote the product on her social media. This proposal depends on Jill's social media reach and influence, which are unknown in this context. If she has a considerable number of followers or has some influence, then this could be a promising way to market the products. But if her reach is limited, it won't significantly benefit the artisan. Therefore, this offer contains uncertainty.\\n\\nIn conclusion, I believe that a guaranteed prospect of future sales outweighs the potential, but uncertain, benefit of limited social media promotion. Thus I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches the situation respectfully and appreciates the high level of craftsmanship that goes into the making of the vase, which is a positive start to a negotiation. In Scenario 1, she introduces the prospect of becoming a repeat customer, suggesting that a potential discount might encourage her to support the business more consistently in the future. This could result in more income over a longer duration, even if at a slight discount to the asking price.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill leverages social media exposure through pictures and tagging. This approach could potentially help to bring in new customers who follow Jill on her social media channels. It's an offer that has potential, but at the same time, it's a bit unpredictable because it ultimately depends on her follower base's interest in the product and their propensity to buy.\\n\\nWhile both approaches have their merits, considering the potential long-term customer loyalty, Scenario 1 seems more compelling. Here, the prospect of Jill becoming a regular customer who, if satisfied, could recommend others to the business seems more direct and tangible compared to the potential exposure and uncertain outcome of the social media promotion proposed in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: \\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the work that has been put into the craft but also acknowledges it. Moreover, she suggests a promotion strategy that could potentially benefit my business. By Jill leveraging her social media following, it could pull in new customers, increasing sales, visibility, and potentially followers. This creates a win-win situation for both parties involved. Despite the price reduction on a single item, the long-term benefits that come from expanding my customer base could be invaluable.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill again appreciates the craftsmanship but simply asks for a discount without offering anything in return. There isn't a clear benefit for me besides making a sale. The mention of future purchases does offer potential, but it lacks the immediacy and potential reach of the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:  \\n\\nBoth scenarios present approaches that have a potential to warrant a price negotiation. However, the bargaining chips are slightly different. In the first scenario, Jill proposes a potentially beneficial advertising arrangement, using her social media following to promote my handcrafted items in exchange for a small discount on the vase. This could significantly increase the visibility of my artistry. A lot depends on the size and demographics of Jill's following. If her followers are likely to be interested in handcrafted items like those I make, such exposure could indeed be valuable. In the second scenario, Jill mentions the possibility of being a repeat customer. While this also holds potential value for building my business, it's somewhat more nebulous and less immediate than the social media promotion proposed in the first scenario. Repeat customers are valuable, but the promise of future purchases is less concrete than immediate advertising to an existing audience.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill are very persuasive, however, they appeal to different aspects.  \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the artisan work and offers exposure on social media which could potentially result in attracting more customers. This could be a chance to enhance further sales and publicity, although it is uncertain how much impact her social media post would truly make.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, Jill flatters the craftsmanship and also shows interest in becoming a repeat customer. This implies she’s planning to make future purchases. Giving her a discount now doesn't just potentially secure this sale, but also future sales if she's happy with my work and prices.\\n\\nSo, considering the potential consistent customer over uncertain exposure, I would lean slightly more towards the offer in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and is interested in a purchase, but her approach is slightly different in each case.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only expresses her interest in purchasing the vase, but she also mentions her intention of being a repeat customer. This shows that she is not only drawn to the single item, but she also admires and values your work overall. This potential repeat business can generate more revenue and help build a consistent customer base, which is incredibly valuable for a local artisan. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, while Jill compliments your work and shares how she loves to support local artisans, she only mentions her interest in buying the current item and doesn't hint at any future purchases or the likelihood of her becoming a repeat customer. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\n\\nWhy? Based on the given scenarios, scenario 1 is more appealing because Jill expresses her interest in continuing to support the business in the future as a repeat customer. A possibility of repeat business on top of the current sale is more advantageous, making a little negotiation on the price more acceptable.\", \"Reasoning: \\nThe first thing that stands out between the two scenarios is Jill's approach. In Scenario 1, Jill immediately acknowledges the artisan's work and expresses her real interest in the product. She doesn't directly ask for a discount but subtly asks for some price adjustments. But more importantly, she indicates that she's a repeat customer and she intends to keep supporting the artisan's work in the future. This will encourage the artisan to negotiate and make room on the price to keep good relations with a loyal customer who could provide repeated business.\\n\\nOn the other hand, although Jill gives compliments on the artisan's craftsmanship in Scenario 2, she directly asks for a discount. Her reasoning is that the item is over her budget. However, she doesn't mention anything about purchasing other items in the future or becoming a repeat customer.\\n\\nSo, considering these points and valuing the potential for future business, I would be more inclined to negotiate in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling arguments for a price negotiation. However, there are several key differences that make me more likely to negotiate in one situation over the other.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only shows appreciation for my work but also expresses interest in becoming a repeat customer. This has the potential for ensuring continuous patronage and support for my craft, which is very beneficial in the long run. While giving a discount on this item might result in a lower immediate profit, the promise of future sales may offset this. Also, promoting customer loyalty through a discount can be advantageous for maintaining a strong customer base.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 presents a customer who appreciates the product and the craftsmanship but does not give any indication of future purchases. Jill's mention of the vase being slightly over budget suggests that the cost is a significant factor in her purchasing decision, meaning she may hesitate more in the future to buy if prices remain the same.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nEven though both customers appreciate the product's craftsmanship, the intent of future purchases and continual support in Scenario 1 makes it more appealing and profitable to negotiate the price with Jill.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 6.0\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"In both scenarios, Jill approaches the negotiation politely, demonstrating admiration for the craftsmanship of the vase, which is certainly a good way for her to start.\\n\\nHowever, there is a slight difference in the approach between the two scenarios that could make a difference to the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill emphasizes the long-term benefits of giving her a discount. She not only mentions that she wants to buy the vase, but also expresses her intention of becoming a repeat customer. This potentially means more sales and, thus, more profit in the future. Given that, for many artisans, loyal customers are an invaluable asset, this could make Jill's proposal more appealing.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2, while also respectful and complimentary, comes across as a one-time transaction. Jill does mention that she supports local artisans, but doesn't specify whether she plans on coming back to this particular artisan in the future.\\n\\nGiven these factors, if we have to choose one scenario where a price negotiation is more likely to happen, it would be Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[Reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios present potential for negotiation, as Jill shows her interest in supporting local vendors and making future purchases. However, in scenario 1, Jill mentions being a repeat customer and the potential of continuing to support the artisan's work, which indicates future sales. Customer retention is important for artisans that sell at local markets, as it’s economically beneficial to maintain relations with existing customers rather than constantly seeking new ones. Thus, providing a discount here could ensure continued sales in the future, essentially paying itself back over time. \\n\\nFurthermore, customer loyalty and word-of-mouth promotion can have a substantial impact in small-scale, local market business, serving as free advertising and bringing even more customers over time.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"After careful consideration, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 2.\\n\\nReasoning: \\nIn both scenarios, Jill comes off as courteous, respectful, and appreciative of handcrafted art, which instantly builds a positive atmosphere for a potential negotiation. However, Scenario 2 would be my preferred choice for several reasons.\\n\\nFirstly, Jill begins by expressing her fondness and admiration for the vase and acknowledging the high quality. This genuine appreciation for the craftsmanship creates an emotional connection and makes me more open to her request. \\n\\nSecondly, she supports local artisans, indicating a broader interest in the economy and community, which makes her approach more virtuous and admirable. As a local artisan myself, I would feel supportive of her belief and be more likely to offer her a discount, not just to secure this sale, but to encourage her ongoing patronage.\\n\\nLastly, she states being on a budget. This gives me a concrete reason to lower the price, as it could mean the difference between her being able to afford it or not. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions being a repeat customer but doesn't specify if she has bought anything before. If she hasn't, this could just be a strategy to get a better deal now with no guarantee of future sales, making it a less compelling argument for discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.7\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[Reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is polite, appreciative of the craftsmanship, and stresses her intent to support local artisans, which can encourage negotiation. However, the circumstances are slightly different in each scenario.\\n\\nScenario 1 brings up the idea of Jill being a potential repeat customer, which is indicative of building a long-term business relationship. By conceding a bit on the price now, you could potentially secure more future sales, which could make up for the initial discount. Being a repeat customer, she would also be likely to recommend your work to others, bringing in potential new customers. \\n\\nOn the other hand, while scenario 2 stresses the admiration and intent to support local craft, it is more centered on her budget constraints rather than the potential of a long-term customer relationship where she might return to make more purchases. \\n\\nOverall, while both scenarios present strong cases, scenario 1 hints more towards a longer-term customer relationship which could be beneficial to the business in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning: One of the most important aspects in negotiating prices is building a rapport with the customer. A big part of that is communicating genuine interest and respect for the product and its maker. In both scenarios, Jill demonstrates this, but there is one key difference: in Scenario 1, Jill explicitly mentions her intention to be a repeat customer, suggesting that she is not only interested in buying a single item, but also potentially many more in the future. This would incentivize the seller to offer a discount, as it could establish a loyal customer and further purchases. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: Both scenarios exhibit Jill's appreciative approach towards the local artisans work. However, Scenario 1 inclines a bit more towards a win-win negotiation. This is primarily because Jill not only appreciates the work, but also expresses her intention to be a repeat customer, which indicates potential long term business. This makes it more appealing, as it's not just about a one-off transaction but also establishes a prospect of future purchases. Jill has also explicitly asked about discounts for repeat customers, which provides an additional reason to consider negotiating the price. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows an expressed interest in supporting local artisans and wanting to purchase more items in the future. She puts forth the concept of further supporting your work by coming back to the market for more in the future, showing a long-term commitment to your craft. This implies a relationship and loyalty that could potentially result in repeat business, and possibly her recommending you to others, which is good from a business standpoint.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also shows a love for the vase and intention of returning, her conversation implies that she may not want to spend much today, which could potentially be a negotiation not just on this vase, but on future items as well. The tone is more price-conscious and less about the appreciation of the craft involved.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision between scenario 1 and scenario 2 would greatly depend on how I perceive Jill's interest and how her negotiation appeal resonate with me as an artisan.\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill seems interested in my work, which is encouraging. She also hints at future purchases, which could mean more business for me later on.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 1, Jill specifically compliments my craftsmanship and expresses her desire to continue supporting my work. She also asks for a possible discount directly but respectfully, and I might be more inclined to reward such a dedicated customer.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also emphasizes her support for local artisans and her desire to come back for more purchases. However, she frames the pricing as more of an obstacle and debates on the value of the vase in terms of price rather than its artistry. This could make me feel slightly less appreciated as an artisan.\\n\\nFor these reasons, I am more likely to negotiate on the price with Jill in Scenario 1. While both scenarios show Jill as a potential repeat customer, scenario 1 places a greater emphasis on the value she sees in my craftsmanship, which is more appealing to me and could potentially motivate me to offer her a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios portray a customer who likes the vase, is appreciative of the artisanal work, and indicates a potential of returning to buy more in the future. However, the way in which Jill communicates her negotiation differs between each.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill begins by complimenting the vase and the craftsmanship, creating a warm and friendly air. She indicates her interest in purchasing the vase, but subtly introduces the idea of a discount. She goes a step further to express her intent of supporting the artisan's work in the future. This soft approach makes the artisan feel appreciated and valued, making it more likely that they would consider a negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill follows a similar approach, expressing her love for the vase and her support for local artisans. However, her negotiation tactic is more direct, questioning whether a discount could be offered if she buys multiple items or returns in the future. Her directness might come off as pushy and could potentially generate resistance.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the subtler approach and compliments given as part of negotiation in the first scenario, I would say it would be more likely to lead to price negotiation effectively.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Looking into both scenarios, they each offer different appeals. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only compliments the craftsmanship but also offers a form of advertisement through her social media and hints at potential future sales. This could be beneficial as it can provide exposure to a larger customer base, which could bring more business in the long run. To discount the vase to her would not simply be a loss of money or a one-off sale, but an investment in promoting the business to a wider audience. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appeals as a potential repeat customer. She is asking if there are any deals for those who come back to purchase again. This proposition is more based on a promise than a tangible offer like Scenario 1. The future profit is more uncertain, as her return to purchase again is not guaranteed.\\n\\nFor these reasons, my answer would lean more toward Scenario 1. The immediate benefit of social media exposure combined with the potential for future sales seems more advantageous. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.', \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide acceptable reasons to negotiate, however, there are key differences in the approach and benefits to consider.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only offering a direct purchase sale but also brings the potential for increased exposure and customer base through her willingness to promote the artisan work on her social media with a considerable number of followers. This means that there could be other potential customers who may be interested in buying similar products in the future. This will essentially serve as a free advertisement for the artisan's work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is inquiring about a discount for this purchase as well as future ones if there is an ongoing customer discount available. It implies that Jill may return for future purchases, but it does not directly promise advertisement or expanding the artisan's customer base.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, Scenario 1 offers potential expanded exposure and customer base in addition to the immediate sale, which has a greater long-term benefit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios intimidate the deep appreciation and willingness of the customer, Jill, to purchase the handcrafted vase, despite expressing concern about the cost. There is no doubt, each of Jill's propositions encase benefits that could be advantageous for a local artisan like me, but the unique specifics in each scenario could reflect on my decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appeals to a possible mutual benefit - a minor discount for her and some free advertisement for me on her social media, assuming she does have a notable number of followers who are fascinated with handcrafted artifacts. This could be potentially beneficial in long run, providing more exposure and possibly attracting new customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill conjectures on a future commitment of being a repeat customer. While this sounds appealing, it's a promise with variables that might or might not come true. Although her return to the market and continuous support could be potentially good, it is uncertain to completely rely on this promise.\\n\\nConsidering all factors, I would be more likely led to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 1. The potential growth and exposure my business could gain through the social media platform seem more immediate and confirmative than the promise of a possible return customer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 6.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0.5]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill communicates her admiration for the artisan's work and her interest in supporting local craftspeople. However, there are subtle differences that may influence the artisan's decision to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers an alternative type of compensation besides money - promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This is potentially a valuable offer, depending on the size and engagement of Jill's social media following. If she has a large, engaged audience that aligns well with the artisan's target demographic, this social media exposure could bring in new customers and grow the artisan's business. However, this arrangement also involves more uncertainty - the artisan doesn't know for sure how many sales this promotion will lead to, or whether Jill will follow through on her promise.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill simply asks for a discount and mentions the possibility of becoming a repeat customer. For the artisan, this would guarantee immediate revenue from the vase sale and potential future sales from Jill. However, it's also possible that Jill is bluffing about returning to the market, and even if she does return, there's no guarantee that she'll choose to buy the artisan's work again.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, an artisan who prioritizes immediate, guaranteed income might prefer Scenario 2, while an artisan who is willing to take a risk for the potential of greater exposure and business growth might prefer Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: This would vary based on the artisan's individual priorities and business strategy, but let's say Scenario 2 for an artisan who prioritizes guaranteed, immediate income.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. \\n\\nJill in this scenario not only expresses her admiration for the craftwork but also shows keen interest in its value as a locally handcrafted item. Many artisans highly value this kind of direct recognition and appreciation of their work. This encourages negotiation, as it doesn't frame the negotiation as just driven by the price.\\n\\nAdditionally, Jill proposes a mutually beneficial arrangement in Scenario 1. By offering to promote my work on her social media, Jill is going beyond simply asking for a discount. She's suggesting a way that she can contribute to my business, potentially increasing awareness and future sales. This could translate to added value for my business in the long run. The cooperation nature of this offer is more appealing, it's not only about the price cut, but also about the potential prospect to be advertised to a wider audience.\\n\\nScenario 2 is a more general request for a discount and does not provide a strong incentive or offer of value exchange for me to lower the price. Repeat customer discounts are certainly a valid promotional tactic, but they typically require establishing a purchase history first, and apply to future purchases, not the first one.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches with clear interest in the vase and compliments my work, showing appreciation for its craftsmanship. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes a barter-like situation where she hopes to leverage her social media influence to promote my products in exchange for a discount. Depending on her social media reach, this proposition could be beneficial as it might bring in more potential customers and therefore, sales in the future. I would need to assess if her social media following consists of people who would be interested in my artwork, and if she has enough reach to make a notable impact to my sales. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill inquires about a discount, she primarily bases this request on being a potential repeat customer. This promise could encourage me to give her a discount as I would get the reassurance of continued business, thus potential repeated sales. \\n\\nHowever, in weighing both scenarios, it will come down to whether Jill's social media influence surpasses the long-term value of her being a repeat customer. If I find more value in Scenario 1, then I would be more inclined to negotiate the price from that standpoint. Conversely, if I value a consistent returning customer even more and see a steady flow of sales, I'd be more likely to negotiate from Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: This answer ultimately depends on Jill's social media influence, so without further information, it's hard to determine definitively.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer some form of negotiation or barter system. Scenario 1 showcases Jill as a returning customer who is looking for a discount based on her loyalty and future purchases. This suggests a guaranteed future business which can be very valuable. Customer retention is of utmost importance in small businesses like a local market artisan.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers a potential for wider outreach and marketing exposure in exchange for a discount. This could potentially bring more customers in the long run. However, this involves a risk, as the impact of such promotion would be hard to measure. Additionally, it would be hard to validate the extent of Jill's social media reach and influence.\\n\\nOverall, while social media marketing can be attractive, the value of a loyal customer should not be underestimated, particularly for a small trader within a local setting. So, based on the information provided, a guaranteed future business versus a potential one, makes scenario 1 a more palpable choice.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows appreciation for the craft and expresses a genuine interest in buying the vase. However, there are key differences as well that vary the level of leverage the customer holds to negotiate. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions that she is a repeat customer and expresses an intention to keep supporting the work in the future. This possibility of a long-term business relationship presents a potential benefit to the seller in terms of sustained sales, not just one-time. Therefore, giving a discount to a repeat customer could secure more sales in the future uplifting the overall business. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers the benefit of free word-of-mouth marketing, which has the potential to bring in even more customers. Jill proposes to promote the work on her social media platforms, which could potentially be seen by hundreds or even thousands of people. Yet, this form of advertising is not guaranteed. While internet exposure can be beneficial and lead to increased sales and brand awareness, Jill's actual reach and influence are unknown. She could have a myriad of followers, few, or none who are interested in the purchases she makes. This makes her offered publicity a bit risky.\\n\\nTaking these points into consideration, although both scenarios bring their unique benefits, the promise of a loyal repeated customer provides an assured return on investment.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present plausible circumstances, however, they put forward different approaches and incentives for negotiating the vase's price. Scenario 1 exhibits a potential long-term customer, hinting at future purchases and continual support for my craft. This could suggest a steady revenue stream, making the price negotiation more appealing. \\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, seeks a more immediate, one-time discount based on social media promotion. Relying on this method for potential sales could be risky, as it is dependent on Jill's followers' interest in my work and their willingness to purchase. Yet, it might bring broader visibility to my creations to a potentially larger customer base.\\n\\nEven though Scenario 2 could potentially raise the profile of my work, as a local artisan who values repeat business and building relationships with customers, I would gravitate more towards Scenario 1. This scenario presents a more reliable, long-term engagement where I could predict and rely on future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is interested in the vase and subtly suggests she would like some reduction in price. However, the approach in Scenario 1 would likely inspire me to be more willing to negotiate the price. There are a few reasons for this. \\n\\nFirstly, she starts off by giving a compliment and recognition to my work. This not only makes me feel appreciated but also implies she genuinely values my creations, increasing the chance I might give her a discount. \\n\\nSecondly, she expresses her intention to be a repeat customer. The prospect of having a loyal customer who will regularly purchase my products and potentially spread positive word of mouth about my work is worth considering a price reduction on this initial purchase.\\n\\nFinally, while in scenario 2, Jill also suggests she could be a repeat customer, she does not express it as clearly and immediately as in scenario 1. The warmth and sincerity of Jill in Scenario 1 are more noticeable, and this might impact my willingness to negotiate more favorably for her compared to Jill in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing interest in the vase and seeking a possible discount. However, there are slight differences in her approach.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill starts by complimenting the craftsmanship, implying that she values the work, effort, and talent required to produce the vase. She asks if there is any wiggle room with the price but also expresses the desire to be a repeat customer, suggesting a potential long-term relationship which could benefit me as an artisan in the future.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill again expresses her interest in the vase, asking about discounts, especially for multiple items and returning customers. This scenario may imply immediate, larger sales, however, it doesn't have the same personal connection and appreciation for the workmanship as the first scenario does.\\n\\nAs an artisan, I would value clients who appreciate the craftsmanship that goes into my work and the time I put into creating each piece. While immediate larger sales are attractive, building customer relations with those who value my work for what it is, is more sustainable and rewarding in the long run. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer opportunities for negotiation, but under different considerations. In Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship, showing a deep appreciation for my work. She directly asks for flexibility with the price, suggesting she might be looking for a better deal on this one-off purchase. In addition to this, she introduces the prospect of being a repeat customer which could mean future business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is interested in buying the vase and perhaps additional items, implying a larger sale overall. She also hints at becoming a potential recurring customer.\\n\\nReviewing both scenarios, while Scenario 2 could result in a larger immediate sale, Scenario 1 presents a stronger case for negotiation. Jill's appreciation for my work in Scenario 1 is more explicit and personalized, showing she values the time and effort that has gone into the product. Additionally, her direct question about price flexibility opens up the negotiation door wider than the more general query about discounts in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill mentions buying multiple items and this means more sales for the hardware individual and also talks about her plans to be a consistent buyer. This can be seen as a basis for a long-term customer relationship which is great for any business. Giving her a discount could be a great way to establish that relationship and can lead to more sales in the future. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill only discusses about one item and although she hints at being a return customer, does not give a guarantee like in scenario 1. Therefore, from a business standpoint - while it's still a good gesture to offer a discount - it doesn't carry the same potential long-term benefit as scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Both scenarios represent valid approaches from Jillattempting to negotiate the price of a good. However, there are subtle differences in the way she communicates her intentions that would influence my decision as an artisan.\\n\\nScenario 1:\\nIn the first scenario, Jill acknowledges the vase\\'s impressive craftsmanship upfront, indicating she respects my work. She inquires about discounts for buying multiple items, implying that she\\'s not just interested in getting a cheaper price for this single item, but she\\'s also attracted to my other products. Furthermore, she announces her intention to be a returning customer, expressing long-term support, which could lead to more sales in the future.\\n\\nScenario 2:\\nJill shows her admiration for the vase, too, but her approach towards negotiation is somewhat direct, as she directly mentions \"wiggle room\" with the price. She also shows an interest in being a repeat customer, but unlike scenario 1, she doesn\\'t necessarily show interest in purchasing multiple items at once.\\n\\nIn both scenarios, the prospect of having a returning customer is appealing, but in Scenario 1, the prospect of selling multiple items in one transaction is significantly more attractive for immediate business. Immediate bulk sales can help with inventory turnover rate and general cash flow.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill demonstrate a strong interest in the vase and a willingness to come back to purchase more items in the future. In both scenarios, Jill expresses her appreciation for the artisan's work and the quality of the vase. \\n\\nHowever, the important difference in these two scenarios is how Jill implies the negotiation. In Scenario 1, Jill openly asks about discounts for purchasing multiple items and for returning customers, indicating she's willing to make a larger or frequent purchase. This could be potentially more profitable for your business in the future. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is asking for a lower price for that particular vase itself without necessarily guaranteeing further purchases. While she does mention potentially being a repeat customer, she doesn't implicitly link that to buying multiple items at once.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the immediate and future financial prospects, the likelihood of negotiating the price would be higher in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her appreciation for the craftsmanship of the vase, an interest in becoming a repeat customer, and a desire for a possible discount. However, there is a small, yet potentially significant difference in their wording. In Scenario 1, Jill states that she is \"really interested in making a purchase,\" which could suggest a more immediate intent to buy the vase. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill says she is \"planning on being a regular visitor,\" and \"interested in multiple purchases.\" While this is encouraging, it does not necessarily equate to a guaranteed sale, as in Scenario 1 where she expressly shows intent to purchase.\\n\\nMoreover, each scenario poses a different request regarding discounts. Scenario 1 inquires whether a discount might be available specifically for the vase Jill has shown interest in, as well as for future purchases. Scenario 2 simply asks if multiple purchases might warrant a discount. It leaves a bit more ambiguity about whether or not Jill would buy the vase now, without a discount.\\n\\nTherefore, considering these factors, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1, where there seems to be a higher likelihood of an immediate guaranteed sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, it is clear that despite having some similarities, there are some crucial differences as well. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and shows intentions of making a purchase. She also indicates that she wants to maintain a relationship by coming back for more work, which could potentially lead to repeat business. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2's Jill expresses her interest in the vase and also plans on being a regular visitor. However, instead of inquiring for flexibility in the price of just one vase, she asks for discounts for multiple purchases, indicating that she's more interested in buying more than one product.\\n\\nAs an artisan, the relationship and appreciation of the work can often be quite impactful. However, business-wise, Scenario 2 provides the possibility of multiple purchases which is a more immediate plus in terms of revenue generation. This also implies that Jill doesn't only admire one piece, but likes my work in general - which can be seen as a form of appreciation too.\\n\\nTherefore, taking into account both the urge of maintaining a good customer relationship, and business benefits, I'd be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 2 due to the immediate potential of multiple purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios seem feasible for negotiations, however, I'd lean slightly more towards Scenario 2. Let's break down the reasons:\\n\\n1. Quantity: In Scenario 2, Jill mentions that she is interested in making multiple purchases. This indicates that the total business value from Jill might be higher compared to Scenario 1, where she is only indicating interest in one item, the vase. As a vendor, this might make me more inclined to offer a discount to secure a larger sale or multiple sales.\\n\\n2. Return Customer: While both scenarios indicate that Jill intends to be a return customer, Scenario 2 seems slightly more compelling because she 's planning on being a regular, indicating more potential future business. \\n\\n3. Open Negotiation: Lastly, both scenarios have open negotiations, but the perspective of regular buying and multiple purchases from Scenario 2 makes it more appealing.\\n\\nTherefore, considering all these aspects, while both scenarios are somewhat equal, Scenario 2 would likely make me more apt to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses interest in supporting the artisan in the future, creating the potential for loyal customer base. However, the proposition varies in nature.\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill offers to advertise the artisan's work in social media to her followers. This could open up a new medium for the artisan to be recognized and could attract more customers. Allowing a minor discount for a potential boost in customers could result in higher sales and publicity. The downside, though, is that the artisan can't control the narrative Jill might portray in her social media and there is a risk that it may not actually lead to more customers, as the artisan has no information about the demographics or interests of Jill's followers.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill discusses future purchases and potential long-term support but doesn't offer any extra promotion beyond her own purchases. While the repeat customer is attractive, the potential for additional customers isn't clearly addressed.\\n\\nIn terms of long term benefits, scenario 1 carries more potential despite the associated risks. Thus, as an artisan, one might be more inclined to negotiate under the terms discussed in scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a business perspective, we want to create a sense of loyalty and ongoing relationships with our customers. Therefore, a customer who expresses interest in not only purchasing an item now but also returning in the future to make additional purchases is quite valuable. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions her interest in the flower vase and even brings up the idea of purchasing multiple items. She also shares her intention of becoming a repeated customer which is great for business. Furthermore, she offers to promote the artisan's work to her thousands of followers on social media. This proposition could lead to potential new customers and increased sales, which is a significant opportunity which won’t be found with every customer. Even though she is asking for a discount, the mutual benefit for the artisan makes this a more attractive proposal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also expresses her interest in the vase and mentions her potential return to the market which will again foster customer loyalty, she doesn’t offer any promotional benefits in exchange of the negotiation.\\n\\nTherefore, despite the fact that both scenarios show potential for customer loyalty, Scenario 1 provides an additional marketing advantage to the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[Reasoning text]\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers several good reasons for a discount and adds value to the transaction. Apart from buying multiple items and being a returning customer, she is willing to advertise your stall on her social media account, which has a few thousand followers. This could potentially bring more business in the future. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, while Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and shows interest in supporting your work in the future, she provides less tangible benefits in return for the discount. Therefore, the first scenario seems to offer a mutually beneficial prospect for both Jill and the artisan, making it a more favorable situation for a price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios frame interesting propositions for a possible negotiation, but I'm more inclined towards Scenario 2. Here, Jill not only presents a proposition for immediate business (purchasing multiple items) but also a long term prospect - her regular visits to the market and her enormous social media following, which can offer me great promotion. This dual benefit of direct sales and potential wider promotion for my work makes the offer in Scenario 2 more attractive than Scenario 1. Hence, I'm more likely to negotiate the price in this case.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill approaches me in a polite and appreciative manner, acknowledging the craftsmanship of the vase. She reveals her interest in making repeat purchases, meaning she is a potential loyal customer. This can lead to guaranteed sales in the future, which is definitely beneficial for a small business like mine.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill not only shows the intention of buying multiple items but also offers to promote my work on her social media platforms, potentially reaching a considerably broader audience. This kind of advertising could significantly increase my customer base and sales.\\n\\nHowever, reducing the price based on the promise of potential future promotions can be risky, as I don't have a guarantee that Jill will actually promote my business, nor that it will result in increased sales. \\n\\nTherefore, between these two scenarios, I would be more likely to consider negotiating the price of the vase in Scenario 1. This is because Jill promises repeat business, which could ensure a steady income without me having to worry about potential risks associated with influencer promotions of Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and opens up the conversation to negotiate the price subtly. She also suggests a potential future relationship by hinting at being a returning customer. While this is an enticing proposition, there's no immediate benefit for me as an artisan aside from the potential promise of a loyal customer. \\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill not only shows interest in the product but also offers something tangible in return - promoting my business on her social media platforms to her substantial following. This type of exposure could significantly benefit my business, and it's an immediate, quantifiable return on giving a discount. In addition, she also shows interest in buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer, just like in the first scenario. \\n\\nTherefore, both scenarios offer the possibility of a repeat customer, which is very beneficial. However, the second scenario has an additional benefit - immediate promotion of my business through Jill's social media platforms.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: This scenario is more likely to prompt a negotiation for various reasons. Jill not only expresses her interest in the vase but emphasises on potential future purchases, indicating the potential for a continued customer relationship and repeat business. Also, she offers to promote the artisan's products on her social media platforms, providing a potentially valuable publicity channel. This could potentially bring in new customers and increase overall sales, something most artisans would value greatly.\\n\\nThe elements of future profits, customer loyalty, and free advertisement make this scenario more appealing. It would incentivize the artisan to offer a discount in order to secure these benefits. This potential for larger, long-term gains makes scenario 2 more likely to prompt price negotiation than scenario 1, where Jill only mentions potential future purchases without offering any other incentives.\", \"Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill's approach is complimenting and polite. However, in scenario 2, Jill offers more to the artisan in return for a discount. Not only does she propose to be a repeat customer, which could guarantee future business, but she also plans to advertise the artisan's products on her social media channels. This offers a potential for direct exposure to a new customer base passionate about home décor and DIY. The opportunity of free marketing in return for a small discount on a single item could be very appealing to the artisan, especially if Jill's social media following is large. Therefore, while loyalty discounts as suggested in scenario 1 are a common practice, the additional marketing potential in scenario 2 makes it more likely for the artisan to negotiate the price of the vase.\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios present fairly compelling cases for offering a discount. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is complimenting the craftsmanship, showing an interest in being a repeat customer and implying that she values the work. This could potentially lead to future sales and a supportive relationship. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers not only the prospect of repeat business, but also the added value of promoting the work on her social media channels. This could have the potential to reach a larger audience and lead to increased sales. Jill is effectively offering a barter - promotion in exchange for a discount.\\n\\nAdditionally, in scenario 2, Jill initially acknowledges that the marked price is fair for the quality of the vase, which shows respect and understanding of the value of the item and the artisan's work. This demonstrates that she does not undervalue the work but is looking for a mutually beneficial arrangement.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nComparing both scenarios, the customer Jill is asking for a price negotiation for the vase in both of them. However, her approach is different in each.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she appreciates the artisan's work and implies she might be a repeat customer. This is appealing as the artisan could benefit from a loyal customer who appreciates their work and might buy again in the future. However, there are no guarantees that she will return or purchase more goods.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again offers appreciation and further proposes to advertise the artisan's work on her social media to her followers. This could potentially lead to more customers and greater exposure of the artisan's work for a one-time discount. This might be a win-win situation as the artisan will get advertisement without any extra charge, and in return, Jill gets a small discount on the vase.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential exposure and customer reach that could come from Scenario 2, the artisan might be more likely to negotiate in this case. The artisan may also see it as a small investment into marketing their work.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: Although both scenarios provide an interesting proposition to negotiate the price, I would lean more toward Scenario 2. Here's why: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill highly appreciates the craftsmanship and seems genuinely interested in the vase. She also proposes to be a potential repeat customer, which is always a positive influence on a small business. However, 'potential' repeat business is not always an ensured prospect, and can sometimes just be a method customers use to try and negotiate lower prices. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only shows interest in the vase but also proposes a form of collaboration wherein she would promote my work to her social network in exchange for a small discount. This can mean a lot for a small business, as it could potentially reach more customers and result in more sales. This type of promotion, especially if Jill has a significant following, can be more valuable than the small discount she's asking for. It's also a more tangible benefit compared to the potential of repeat business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nBetween these two scenarios, it would be more favorable to negotiate in Scenario 2. The main reason is that Jill is offering to promote the work to her social media followers. This can be beneficial in terms of reaching a wider audience and potentially getting more customers in the long run. It's a kind of indirect investment in marketing. In Scenario 1 she merely asks for a discount because she intends to become a repeat customer. While this is not a bad thing, her statement does not guarantee future purchases, and a promise to return for more purchases holds less weight in comparison to Scenario 2 where the benefit is more tangible. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nIn the first scenario, Jill is a repeat customer who promises to be supportive and continue purchasing from you, which means long-term business. But the assurance of those future sales is uncertain. Being a repeat customer doesn't necessarily ensure that they will purchase frequently or purchase other expensive items from your stall.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, however, Jill is willing to promote your work to her considerable follower base on social media. In today's digital age, social media exposure can be tremendously valuable - it's basically free advertising. Even if Jill's followers don't immediately turn into customers, they become aware of your work, potentially increasing your customer base in the long run. The one-time discount in return for the promotion could thus be of more pronounced benefit. \\n\\nHence, based on the potential long-term gain from scenario 2, I'd be more likely to negotiate on the price with Jill in that situation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present good reasons for offering a discount. However, my preference leans towards scenario 2. Here are my reasons:\\n\\n1. Potential Reach: In the second scenario, Jill offers to use her 'considerable' social media following, which provides an opportunity to advertise the craft to a much larger audience than that of the local market, potentially leading to more sales.\\n\\n2. Mutual Benefit: In this same scenario, Jill offers a form of payment beyond money by offering exposure. This benefits both parties. Jill gets her discount, and in return, the artisan gets the promotion and possibly an expanded customer base. Also, it gives the business an online presence if it doesn't have that already.\\n\\n3. An understanding of value: In scenario 2, Jill acknowledges the fairness of the pricing in relation to the work's quality before asking for a discount. This recognition is essential, reflecting her understanding and appreciation of the artisan labor involved, making it easier for the artisan to engage in negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses interest in the vase and admiration for the craftsmanship, indicating that she sees the value of the item. However, the context of their requests for a lower price differs.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill brings up the idea of possibly becoming a repeat customer and hence looks for a discount for her future purchases. While the prospect of a returning customer is appealing, there's no guarantee that her intentions will translate into actual future sales. Furthermore, if a discount were given to her now based on the future promise of buying more, it might set a precedent, and she could expect discounts on every purchase henceforth.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill mentions her substantial social media following and offers to advertise the artisan's work in exchange for a discount. Considering the potential reach to a wider audience, the artisan stands to gain increased visibility and sales. The potential exposure could be invaluable to the artisan, as it could attract new customers who might not have discovered his work otherwise. \\n\\nBased on this reasoning, the artisan might see more value and potential profit in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.8 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn selecting between these two scenarios, my decision would stem from the consideration of the direct and indirect benefits I could get from each transaction. Negotiation should generally benefit both parties and these two situations provide uniquely different prospects.\\n\\nScenario 1 offers not just a sale, but potential promotion of my craft to diverse audiences on social media. If Jill has a significant following and is influential, this could be more profitable in the long run as it can result in further sales from people who see her posts. This is not just a one-time discount, but a potential investment in marketing my work, which could be quite costly if done differently.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, carries a promise of repeated patronage which is also good for business, but the assurance level is quite lower compared to the first scenario. Customer loyalty is highly desired, but there is no concrete plan or quantifiable reach presented. Only a hope of return and likelihood of future sales which remains uncertain.\\n\\nConsidering both, I think I would lean more towards the potential of gaining a broader audience for my craft and increasing my market reach, as well as the immediacy of the benefit in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\nBetween these two scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 1. This is because there is an added value to her proposal. In addition to purchasing my product, she's offering advertising on her social media platforms, which could significantly increase my exposure and possibly increase future sales.\\nThough in Scenario 2, Jill promises future purchases, it's relatively less concrete than the immediate marketing offer presented in Scenario 1. Concession for repeat customers is quite substantial for businesses, but it's harder to track and ensure. Therefore, while both are potentially beneficial offers, Scenario 1 presents a more appealing immediate return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text:\\nBoth scenarios offer compelling reasons to consider negotiating the price, but I would be more inclined toward scenario 1. Here's why:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, while Jill asks for a potential discount, she also offers to give something in return - featuring my work on her social media platforms. This could result in greater visibility and potentially more customers, a sort of indirect future revenue. For a craftsman in a local market, this kind of promotion can be really valuable. It's not only about this one sale; it's about potential future sales too. \\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, while interesting, doesn't offer the same level of potential return. Repeat custom is valuable, but it doesn't carry the sales-driving potential of social promotion. Moreover, we also don't have a guarantee that she would return or when that would be. Hence, while taking care of returning customers is valuable in the long run, Scenario 1's benefits outweigh those in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill notes her appreciation for the craftsmanship and conveys a willingness to pay the full price but is interested in negotiating. Simultaneously, she offers a value-added proposition by highlighting her social media following and volunteering to promote my work, thereby potentially increasing my visibility and generating additional sales in the future. This exposure could lead to higher returns than the small discount she is requesting. \\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill also shows appreciation for the work, indicating she might be a potential return customer. Yet, she does not provide a value-added offer similar to scenario 1's viral marketing potential.\\n\\nTherefore, based on potential future benefits and considering both present and future sales, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[Reasoning Text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill are compelling, making the decision a tough one. In scenario 1, offering to promote the product and work on social media could offer invaluable exposure for the artisan, especially if Jill indeed has a sizeable following. This could potentially lead to more customers and even higher prices for the products due to increased demand. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers loyalty and promises to return for more purchases, also a valuable proposition. Recurring customers are important for business as they not only bring in steady income, but can also become advocates for the brand within their social circles, therefore attracting more buyers.\\n\\nHowever, considering all aspects, the artisan might lean more towards scenario 2. Here's why: Jill's promise to return offers an immediate financial benefit. While the social media promotion in scenario 1 is attractive, it's more of a long-term benefit and it also depends heavily on how influential Jill is on social media. In addition, purchasing multiple items or being a returning customer usually warrants a discount in many businesses, but a single-item purchase exchanged for a social media post may not.\\n\\nAnother point in favor of Scenario 2 is that it reduces the risk of future price expectations. If a discount is given in return for a social media post (Scenario 1), future customers might expect similar discounts without providing the same value (a sizeable social media following isn't that common). \\n\\nSo, while both scenarios offer valuable prospects, the artisan might find scenario 2 to be a safer and more immediate beneficial choice.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", 'Reasoning:\\n\\nAs an artisan, my interest lies not only in selling my creations but also in building connections with my customers and gaining visibility for my work. In both scenarios, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and design of the vase which is always pleasant to hear as a craftsman.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill expresses a willingness to pay the full price and offers a proposition that could benefit both parties:  she suggests promoting my work through her social media platform which can lead to increased visibility and potentially more customers. This is a value-added proposition for a slight price discount, making it a win-win situation for both me and Jill.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, while Jill does promise the possibility of coming back for more items and hints at becoming a repeat customer, this is more uncertain compared to the immediate and tangible benefit offered in Scenario 1. In both scenarios, Jill appreciates the work put into the vase, which does endear her, but Scenario 1 offers more immediate and tangible benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 6.0\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is interested in buying the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship. However, in Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the work but also shows interest in becoming a potential repeat customer who is possibly planning to make multiple purchases in the future. This condition significantly increases Jill's value as a customer. Selling the vase at a lowered price today has the potential to secure a loyal customer and more revenue in the future. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill mentions that she is on a budget. This could mean that even though she appreciates the artisans' work, her financial situation might prevent her from becoming a repeat customer. Therefore, in terms of long-term business profitability, Jill in Scenario 1 seems like a more beneficial customer. However, it is imperative to strike a balance between maintaining price integrity and welcoming a repeat customer with a small discount. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is appreciating the work and admiring the craftsmanship of the vase, which as an artisan, you would be glad to hear. She also states that she is planning to come back to the market again and possibly make more purchases in the future. This suggests that if you offer her a discount this time, she might become a regular customer, increasing your business in the long run.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill equally appreciates the vase and the craftsmanship, but unlike Scenario 1, she does not imply any future purchases. She merely states that she supports local artisans and that she is on a budget, which while sympathetic, does not offer the same potential for future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning text: \\nBoth scenarios put forward by Jill reflects her interest in the vase and my artisan work. However, there's a difference. In the first scenario, Jill is not only interested in the vase, but she's also indicating that she's planning on being a repeat customer, which means more business in the future. She also raised a valid point regarding discounts on multiple purchases. This could lead to more sales which would benefit my business. On the other hand, in the second scenario, Jill praises my work and empathises with the local community of artisans but doesn't promise any future transaction and is asking for a discount based on her current budget constraints. \\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios involve a potential negotiation, the first scenario seems more beneficial for my long-term business objectives. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.7\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer with genuine interest and admiration for the handcrafted item. Jill appears to be a responsible buyer who values the work of artisans. However, there are specific elements in each scenario that could influence the decision to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows an interest in becoming a repeat customer, implying there's a chance for more business in the future. She even mentions buying multiple items, which could result in an overall higher sale, even if a discount is given on the flower vase. This potential for ongoing engagement establishes trust and value in the relationship from a business perspective, fostering loyalty.\\n\\nScenario 2 also presents a respectful negotiation attempt. Jill expresses her desire to support local artists, showing appreciation for the work, and indicating why she's on a budget. However, she doesn't mention future purchases or any kind of ongoing business relationship.\\n\\nWhile both Jill's approaches are diplomatic and thoughtful, based on the value of potential future sales, more leeway for negotiation is presented in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: Both scenarios show Jill as a courteous and respectful customer, expressing interest not just in a single item, but also potentially more items in the future. However, Scenario 1 is more explicit about her intention to return and make more purchases – this not only hints at future business but also engenders good customer relations. Furthermore, in Scenario 1 she appreciates your work and acknowledges the uniqueness which implies that she understands the value of why your items may be priced as they are. In Scenario 2, she refers more to her budget constraints without indicating any potential for future business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows great interest in the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship, which is a positive sign. However, the reasons for choosing to negotiate in a particular scenario are quite different.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill implies that she might become a regular customer and make multiple purchases, which could potentially bring more revenue in the future. This consideration would motivate me to offer a discount to establish a strong relationship with Jill and encourage repeat business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses her support for local artisans and unique crafts such as my vase. Her willingness to negotiate pricing stems from stretching her budget, which suggests economic constraints. While it's clear that she respects my work, she is still asking for a price reduction based solely on her budget and not because she is planning on becoming a regular customer.\\n\\nConsidering future sales and the establishment of a potentially fruitful customer relationship, I would be more inclined to negotiate in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her desire to support local artisans. She makes it clear that she sees the value in the work and intends to return for future purchases. While she doesn't implicitly ask for a reduction on this vase, she asks about discounts generally – for those buying multiple items or returning customers. This creates a conversation where negotiation could naturally occur but doesn't put the artisan immediately on the defensive. Furthermore, the mention of returning and buying more items provides an incentive to offer her some sort of discount now to secure future sales.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill also compliments the work, she straightforwardly asks for a negotiation on this vase and then mentions the possibility of returning for more purchases. The immediate request for a discount can feel more aggressive and doesn't provide the same potential ongoing relationship incentive as in scenario 1.\\n\\nSo, based on the above reasoning, while both situations might lead to some negotiation, the conversation in scenario 1 feels more constructive and promises potential future sales, making it the more preferable scenario for price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios depict Jill's admiration for the flower vase's craftsmanship and her desire to support local artisans. Both also express her interest in coming back to make more purchases in the future. However, there is a slight difference in the approach of the potential negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill gently proposes the idea of a discount for multiple items or for being a potential returning customer, making it clear that she values your work but is also conscious of her budget. This doesn't put the artisan in a direct spot to lower the price of the showcased item specifically, but implies it indirectly.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill clearly asks for a negotiation on the given price. Although expressing intention to return, she doesn't make it clear from her words whether she is intending to purchase multiple items this time or in the future.\\n\\nThe decision on whether or not to negotiate depends on considering the buyer's transparency, clarity, and the potential for future sales. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the communication made by Jill seems more open and honest. This approach assumes less direct pressure on the artisan to lower the price immediately while still expressing her clear interest in supporting the business in the future. Additionally, the suggestion for a discount for multiple item purchasers may increase immediate sale volume. The appeal to a tighter budget could also lead to empathy and potentially willingness to negotiate the price a little. Therefore, I would be more likely to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a potential customer who is interested in making a purchase now and possibly in the future, increasing the likelihood that I might be willing to negotiate. However, in Scenario 1, Jill makes an emotional appeal, expressing her appreciation for the craft and her support for local artisans, which would resonate more with me as a craftsman. \\n\\nAdditionally, she brings up the idea of discounts for purchasing multiple items, implying she may buy more than just the vase, which would boost her appeal. Furthermore, she only mentions the problem of a tight budget instead of directly asking for a price reduction, so she is not essentially demanding a discount but proposing a win-win situation for both parties.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill too expresses admiration for the craft but goes straight into asking whether there's room for negotiation on the price of the vase. This direct approach seems more focused on getting a better deal rather than highlighting potential future business, which distinguishes it from Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present the essence of negotiation, however, there are subtle differences in approach and reasoning that make one scenario more favorable for negotiation than the other. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses her liking of the vase and appreciates the importance of supporting local artisans. She also indicates a possible long-term buying relationship by her intention to return to the market in the future. While she is considerate of the creator's work and the importance of supporting local artisans, her negotiation approach is more subtle but clear, she's inquiring about discounts on multiple items or future purchases. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also demonstrates a similar level of appreciation for the artisan's work and shows potential interest in becoming a recurring customer. She however directly asks for a price negotiation for the current item. \\n\\nWhile both customers show potential interest in becoming recurring customers, the first scenario portrays a customer willing to support the artisan's work by even buying more items and not directly asking for a discount on the vase she's interested in, but rather a future purchase or if she buys multiple items. Considering the likelihood of the artisan gaining not only from this purchase but from potential future purchases, the indirect negotiation tactic used here expresses a level of respect for the artisan's pricing and craftsmanship. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Both scenarios present a customer who appreciates artisanal work, expresses an interest to buy, and is eager to make a discount deal. However, there are slight differences in their approach to requesting a discount which makes one scenario more appealing than another from the seller's perspective.\\n\\nScenario 1:\\nIn Jill's first approach, she immediately shows her love for the vase and mentions her interest in supporting local artisans which is a good start to complement the seller's work. She's upfront about the price issue but justifies it by expressing her intent to buy multiple items and promising to be a returning customer. By providing the seller with the prospect of future sales, she's given more weight to her request for a discount.\\n\\nScenario 2: \\nHere, Jill compliments the seller's work and also expresses interest in the vase. But her approach to getting a discount is slightly less straightforward. She's unsure about the possibility of negotiating the price and ends by asking if the seller offers discounts for returning customers or for multiple purchases. This approach does invoke sympathy, but it seems slightly less certain than her first approach.\\n\\nReasoning: \\nBetween the two scenarios, Scenario 1 sounds more steady, clear, and assertive. Jill puts forth her request for a discount with the justification of making more purchases and being a returning customer in a confident tone. This approach might be more agreeable to the seller as she shows a genuine interest in the product and at the same time gives the prospect of a future sale which would impact the seller's decision to lower the price or not.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Both Scenarios 1 and 2 seem alike as Jill uses a similar approach to request a discount. However, her expressions and the way she presents her request are different in each case. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill uses phrases like \"I\\'m always looking to support local artisans,\" and \"add unique pieces like this to my collection,\" which makes it appear that she values the work and the effort put into it. She also enquires about discounts for future purchases or if buying multiple items. This shows she likes the pieces and is interested in buying more, potentially leading to future sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and uniqueness of the item, but her request for a discount is based mainly on price and her intention to return. Though she mentions coming back to purchase more, she doesn\\'t express the same level of interest in supporting the artists and collecting unique pieces as she does in Scenario 1. \\n\\nBased on these evaluations, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. The reasons are higher perceived value and respect for the work, plus the interest shown in further purchases could be beneficial for future business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is suggesting a collaboration of sorts - she's offering to promote our crafts through her social media platforms. This could be beneficial to us in the long run as it might attract new potential customers. However, it is difficult to measure the true potential of her proposal. She might have many followers, but will her sharing translate to actual sales for us?\\n\\nScenario 2 also mentions Jill's interest in making future purchases. This is more direct and something that could be immediately beneficial. While a discount may lower the profit for this particular sale, knowing that Jill is planning to return in the future for more purchases makes this an easier decision to make. \\n\\nSo, while both scenarios offer potential benefits, Scenario 2 is more within our control and offers a more immediate and tangible benefit. Therefore, it would more likely encourage us to negotiate on the price of the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2 \\n\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their merits and differences. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is offering to advertise my work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. This could potentially introduce my work to a broader range of customers who may not be currently aware of it. However, the reach and impact of the proposed advertisement isn't assured. I have no information on the demographic and buying habits of Jill's followers. Additionally, there's a risk in this scenario since I can't control the quality and veracity of the promotion.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill expresses interest in the vase but also hints at the possibility of future purchases. This signals that she might become a repeat customer, which is beneficial for a sustainable business. Even though there's no particular promise, there's still potential for more business down the line, which could be a more secure form of gaining profits. Finally, there isn't the uncertainty of social media exposure as in the first scenario. \\n\\nBased on these deliberations, I would, on balance, be more willing to negotiate in Scenario 2. The prospects of a returning, loyal customer and potential for future purchases provides a more tangible business prospect. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. In this situation, Jill not only expresses admiration for my work but also presents a potential opportunity for free advertisement and possibly more clients through her social media following of people who share her interest in handcrafted items. \\n\\nWhile it's true that offering the discount reduces the initial profit from selling the vase, the potential gain in terms of customer reach, increased visibility, and potential new clients outweighs this small loss. In addition, it builds good customer relations and encourages people to support local artisans. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill also shows interest in the product and suggests the potential of future purchases which is a good prospect. However, without any solid commitment of repeat business, it's a less appealing proposition compared to Scenario 1. Offering a discount based on a promise of future purchases which may or may not happen is riskier. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has complimented my work and shown genuine interest in the flower vase, which is a positive start. Both cases seem to offer certain mutual benefits, and therein lies the key: how beneficial will each proposition be for my business in the short and long run?\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering to promote my work via social media in exchange for a discount. This could potentially expose my work to a broader audience and attract more customers. The effectiveness of this strategy would largely depend on the reach and influence of her social media presence, which I don't have details on. However, the risk that her followers might not translate into my customers is too present and there wouldn't be any guarantee of sales increase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill suggests there's a possibility of her being a repeat customer and also buying multiple items. This could mean more guaranteed future earnings in comparison to a potential social media boost.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios have their merits, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 2 as it offers a more direct, tangible benefit to my business; Confirmed profit from future sales rather than speculating over uncertain exposure benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more inclined to negotiate on the vase price in Scenario 1. \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill complements my work and appears genuinely interested in supporting local artisans. However, it's Jill's offer in Scenario 1 that makes it more appealing for me to consider a discount. Her proposal of promoting my art to her large social media following does not only benefit her because she'll be getting the vase at a discounted price, but it also creates a possibility of attracting more customers for me. That's a beneficial trade-off, as her promotion could lead to increased brand awareness and potentially more sales for my business.\\n\\nWhile in Scenario 2, Jill indirectly states the possibility of returning or making multiple purchases, the key factor that makes it less appealing is the uncertainty it conveys. The word 'planning' and 'possibly' indicates that there's no guarantee she will make future purchases. Jill might return and buy more, but on the other hand, she might not.\\n\\nTherefore, considering these reasons, Jill’s offer in the first scenario stands out as a better option to negotiate the price of my vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a compelling argument for a price negotiation. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers to promote the work of the artisan on her social media platforms. If she has a significant following, this could potentially result in increased visibility and future sales. This scenario, however, is based on trust and the future potential benefit is not guaranteed.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill shows interest in becoming a returning customer and buying more items in future. This could suggest more guaranteed, immediate sales, especially if she decides to purchase other items.\\n\\nConsidering these points, I would be more likely to negotiate if Jill is a potential return and bulk customer, as the immediate benefit outweighs the potential and unpredictable future benefits presented in scenario 1.\\n\\nTherefore, I'd pick scenario 2 for negotiation. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, it appears that both of them have potential for a good sale. However, Scenario 1 seems more promising for a couple of reasons. \\n\\nFirstly, in Scenario 1, Jill compliments the uniqueness and quality of the artisan's work right from the beginning. This often sets a positive tone that can make the negotiation process smoother. \\n\\nSecondly, she's direct about her interest in the vase, and hints at an intention to buy more items in the future, which suggests she could become a loyal customer. This could encourage the artisan to offer a lower price now in the hopes of securing future profits from her. \\n\\nFinally, her questioning if there's room for negotiation on the price as well as the discounts for future purchases clearly indicates her interest not only in the product but also in establishing a ongoing relationship with the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also expresses her interest in the vase, and potential future purchases, she doesn't directly negotiate the price of the vase. This could slightly lessen the chances for a possible price negotiation.\\n\\nTherefore, owing to direct negotiation, positivity, and potential future profits, Scenario 1 seems to be the scenario where I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments my work openly and expresses her intent to return to the market, indicating a potential for future sales. She also clearly states her interest in negotiating the price of the vase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, although Jill also shows admiration for my work and mentions the possibility of being a returning customer, her approach to negotiation is more indirect.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present enticing opportunities for negotiation, Scenario 1 provides a more explicit opportunity. The customer directly asks for a negotiation and guarantees future visits and purchases, which could lead to more sales in the long term. This straightforward approach suggests that the customer is serious about purchasing the vase and potentially developing a long-term relationship with my business, which could be beneficial in growing and maintaining a strong customer base. That being said, it is also important to ensure these discounts are feasible for my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill demonstrates interest in the vase and hints at making multiple purchases in the future, which could lead to longer-term customer loyalty. However, there are slight differences that make one scenario more appealing for negotiation from the seller's perspective.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill upfrontly asks for a negotiation, acknowledging the craftsmanship. She clearly mentions her intention of returning to the market and possibly making more purchases in the future. This scenario suggests that offering a discount might not only secure the immediate sale but also encourage future purchases, exponentially increasing overall sales. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill does show an interest in buying multiple items but she is more focused on any discounts that could be available for loyal customers. She, however, does not explicitly ask for a negotiation unlike the first scenario. This scenario may not necessarily guarantee immediate sales as the purchase factor is highly dependent on the discounts being offered. \\n\\nConsidering the above factors, I'd say that the seller might more likely negotiate in scenario 1, as Jill more directly expresses her intention to make a buy and her willingness to negotiate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill demonstrates high interest in the hand-crafted flower vase and implies returning to the market in the future for more purchases, which are compelling reasons to consider a price negotiation. However, in scenario 1, Jill introduces an added value to the negotiation by offering to market the artisan's work on her own social media platforms. This offer provides a potential for increased exposure and a larger customer base for the artisan, which could result in even more sales and recognition.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill compliments the artisan's work and mentions potentially purchasing more items in the future. While these points are probably appreciated, they do not offer the same immediate and concrete benefit that the social media exposure offers in scenario 1.\\n\\nIn business, strong relationships and future promises are certainly valuable, but it is concrete actions and the understanding of immediate benefits that often clinch deals. Therefore, the artisan would likely be more inclined to negotiate in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill does a great job expressing her interest in the vase and my work, asks politely for a discount, and suggests the possibility of future purchases. However, in Scenario 1, she extends the value of her purchase beyond its immediate financial impact; she offers to promote my work on her social media platforms, potentially reaching thousands of prospective customers. This can not only help me sell other items in the current market but also attract more potential customers to my stall in future markets, thus increasing the value of her purchase even further. This marketing potential could make a small discount worthwhile for me. Therefore, while both scenarios are compelling, the added value Jill provides in Scenario 1 makes me more likely to negotiate the vase's price with her.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only shows intent to become a recurring customer but also proposes a form of partnership through advertising your work to her followers. This offers the potential for new customers and reaching a larger audience, which is a valuable offer for a local artisan. Remember, the goal for any business is not just to sell but to also build a customer base and to potentiate recurring sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill displays admiration for your work and indicates that she might return to make more purchases. However, they do not offer any additional value like Jill in Scenario 1. The potential for a returning customer is attractive, but the added value of promotion to her followers in Scenario 1 makes a stronger case.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their perks: In Scenario 1, Jill immediately acknowledges the exceptional craftsmanship, expresses a desire for future purchases and posits potential negotiation, while in Scenario 2, she presents a complimentary value exchange in the form of social media promotion.\\n\\nHowever, as a local artisan, I lean towards Scenario 2. This is because Jill demonstrates an understanding and respect for my work and the importance of local artisans. Her willingness to promote my work to her large following can potentially drive more customers my way and increase sales. Although both scenarios suggest future purchases, the social media exposure in Scenario 2 provides a longer-term benefit. Of course, this will require a review of her social media to assess how meaningful her promotion might be. But the potential win here could significantly outweigh a one-time purchase with a discount.\\n\\nNevertheless, it still depends on the reality: if she does have a sizable following and engagement rates that would result in a substantial boost in sales, it would be a worthwhile exchange; if not, Scenario 1 would be preferable.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and indicates her interest in supporting the artisan for future purchases, which shows commitment towards maintaining a long-term business relationship. This gives the artisan assurance of future business and potential earnings. However, Jill does not offer anything else that could benefit the artisan's business, aside from her potential future business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, in addition to expressing her appreciation for the artisan’s work and the intention to make future purchases, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work through her considerable social media following. As a result, the artisan not only gets the certainty of a current sale (which may be lesser due to the discount), but there's also the potential for future sales via Jill's market influence. This could significantly benefit the artisan's business in the long run, more so if Jill's social media audience aligns with the artisan's target market.\\n\\nGiving a discount to Jill in scenario 2 could prove to be a good investment for the artisan's future visibility and expansion of their customer base. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", 'Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill expresses a strong interest in the vase and potential future purchases, trying to negotiate a better price. However, Scenario 2 offers an added value that could be more beneficial in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is looking for a standard discount for returning or multiple purchases customers. While this could lead to future business, it doesn’t necessarily guarantee it, and you may be losing revenue on the discounted items.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to use her influence on social media to promote your work in exchange for a discount. This potential exposure to a much larger audience can help increase the visibility of your work, potentially attracting more buyers, therefore boosting sales in the long term. This offer has a stronger added value because apart from the promise of a potential return customer, Jill is offering a service in exchange that can directly contribute to future sales and visibility of your craftsmanship. So while you might negotiate a lower price for this vase, the potential exposure and new customer acquisition could make the price reduction worthwhile.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not just asking for a discount, but she’s also offering something in return, which is exposure on her large social media channel. An exposure like this could immensely help an independent artisan to increase their visibility, customer base, and ultimately, sales. Therefore, providing a discount in exchange for this kind of publicity may end up being beneficial in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, although Jill mentions that she's likely to return to buy more, there's no real tangible benefit for me at present. Many customers could make the same promise about future purchases in order to receive a discount. Additionally, she directly asks for negotiation but does not offer anything concrete in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nThere are several reasons that I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. Firstly, Jill displays an understanding of the value of the vase and the craftsmanship that went into it. This respect for my work indicates she isn't trying to devalue it but is looking for a mutually beneficial arrangement.\\n\\nSecondly, she provides a clear incentive for offering her a discount: she plans to become a repeat customer and will purchase more items in the future. This gives me an idea of potential future income that justifies the small loss I would take in giving her a discount.\\n\\nLastly and most importantly, offering to promote my shop and work on her social media platform with a large following can significantly boost my business by reaching potential customers I wouldn't have access to otherwise. This form of marketing is highly valuable and might make a significant impact for the exposure of my business. Therefore, the potential return on this offer is much more valuable than the small reduction in price.\\n\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nThe scenarios provided by the customer, Jill, both present opportunities for negotiating the price of the product. However, how the situations were set up and the potential future benefits vary greatly.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposed the idea of being an ongoing customer making regular purchases, which can lead to more accumulated profits over time. More importantly, she also offered exposure of my craftsmanship on her social media channels, which has a considerable following. Her influence in home décor circles offers potential for increasing awareness of my work and attracting more customers, extending the value beyond just a one-time purchase. This can be seen as a strategic partnership which can be highly beneficial for me, the artisan.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, also mentions Jill's intention of returning and buying more items in the future, but it lacks the added advantage of social media promotion. Although it opens the possibility of getting a loyal customer, it's nowhere as persuasive as the first scenario.\\n\\nThus, my decision is influenced by the long-term prospective advantages offered by the customer which can significantly benefit my business in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen choosing between Scenario 1 and Scenario 2, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 2. This decision is based on a few factors. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill states her interest in the vase and her plan to return to the market and potentially make more purchases. While this is thoughtful, it is only a potential future benefit, not a guaranteed one. Therefore, giving a discount based on this promise involves an inherent risk. She might not return, or she might not find other items she likes enough to buy.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, however, Jill presents a clear, immediate benefit for me: promotion to her social media followers, who could potentially become my customers. By offering this, she positions herself as a partnership rather than just a customer, and if she indeed has a considerable amount of followers, this could potentially provide a valuable source of new customers and greater visibility for my work. \\n\\nFor these reasons, Scenario 2 seems more compelling for negotiation. There are tangible benefits and the prospect of reaching a larger customer base through her promotion versus the promise of future purchases in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the quality of the artwork and is also making a potential commitment to become a returning customer. This implies there is a guarantee of future sales and profits, which is a deal any artisan would find hard to turn down. Even more, giving her a discount may encourage her to buy more handcrafted items, boosting sales for the day. \\n\\nAlthough in Scenario 2, Jill proposes to promote the artisan's work on her social media, there's no guarantee of a direct return on investment. The artist might not actually see a significant increase in customers or sales, or it might take a longer time to realize any benefits. Also, offering a discount in exchange for promotion can be a tricky proposition if there's no clear understanding about what constitutes adequate promotion or if Jill's followers are genuinely interested in handcrafted items.\\n\\nTherefore, taking all these factors into consideration, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented suggest that the vase is indeed valued by the customer, Jill. However, these scenarios differ in the customer's approach to asking for a discount. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill highlights her intention to become a recurring customer and her potential future purchases. This proposition is appealing as it implies a steady, possibly increasing, stream of income. Furthermore, this indicates that Jack may in future purchase other handcrafted items apart from the vase. Thus, offering a slight discount to her would not just encourage her to make this purchase but may also encourage future purchases, improving customer loyalty.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill offers a different kind of bargain. Her offer to promote the artisan's work on her social media isn't directly profitable, nonetheless, it can potentially result in a surge of followers and future customers, indirectly leading to increased sales. However, this largely depends on the size and demographic of Jill's following which is not clearly defined in this scenario.\\n\\nWhile both propositions have their appeals, as an artisan I would be more interested in securing a steady customer base, and knowing that my work is truly appreciated and sought after. Also, it is a safer bet as compared to banking on the promise of increased visibility through promotion by Jill.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nConsidering both scenarios, one has to consider the immediate and future gain that can be realized. In Scenario 1, Jill is suggesting a potentially repeat patronage and future multiple purchases which can guarantee a steady stream of revenue. This can also translate to recommendations to her friends or family. So, offering her a discount might attract more purchases from her in the future.\\n\\nScenario 2 involves more potential exposure through a larger audience via Jill's social media platforms. However, this is not a guaranteed return. The success of this depends heavily on Jill's influence, the reach of her posts, and how her followers act upon seeing them.\\n\\nGiven these points, the guarantee of continuous purchases in Scenario 1 seems more appealing and less risky than the potential exposure of Scenario 2. Social media exposure is great, but it doesn't guarantee a conversion into sales. A bird in hand (Scenario 1) might be worth more than two in the bush (Scenario 2) in this context.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAnalyzing both scenarios, we note two different strategies presented by the same customer, Jill. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses a recurring interest in the artisan's work. She also states a possible return to the market to make further purchases. This conveys a potential regular customer, which can guarantee steady business, not just a one-time buy. Offering a discount could strengthen the customer relationship and assure regular visits and purchases from Jill. Therefore, there would be a more direct, tangible, and immediate impact on the business's profits. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again recognizes the quality of the crafts, but she offers exposure through her social media following as incentive for a discount. While this method might bring the artisan's work to a wider audience, it is somewhat riskier because there's no guarantee it will convert into sales. It's dependent on Jill's followers' interests aligning with the artisan market items. There's also the matter of how influential Jill truly is on her social media platforms.\\n\\nThough both scenarios propose opportunities, the first scenario appears to offer a more concrete and direct benefit to the artisan's business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons for negotiation, but each targets different aspects of business value. In Scenario 1, Jill is appealing to the idea of potential future purchases and loyalty. If she feels valued and gets a fair price now, she will be likely to revisit in the future and provide more business. This can be profitable from a long term perspective.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, she's offering exposure to a larger audience by featuring the artisan's work on her social media. If her follower count is large and engage well with her posts, this could result in significant traffic and potential new customers, which will increase sales in the short term. However, we don't have an actual number or statistic of her followers, which might not ensure a successful marketing strategy.\\n\\nIn the marketplace setting where prospects and customer retention are important but not guaranteed, the immediate publicity and potential new business that could come from social media exposure might be more appealing to the average seller. Furthermore, accepting Scenario 2 does not prevent me from potential negotiations in the future, as presented in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.55 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has expressed a strong interest in the vase and has given me compelling reasons to consider negotiating the price. However, after comparing the two circumstances, I believe that Jill's proposition in Scenario 1 is more appealing to me as a small business owner. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to advertise my work on her social media profiles where she frequently posts about local art. Depending on her follower count and engagement rate, this could potentially expose my work to a larger audience, bring in new customers, and increase my sales in the long run. Although this scenario doesn't guarantee an immediate return like Scenario 2 might, the potential for increased visibility and long-term customer growth is an enticing offer. \\n\\nMeanwhile, in Scenario 2, Jill proposes a possible return to the market and the opportunity for future purchases. While this is tempting, there's less certainty compared to the first scenario. After all, Jill's future purchases depend on various factors, such as her continued interest in my items, her budget, and even whether she indeed returns to the market. \\n\\nTherefore, while both offers have merit, the added value of potential marketing through Jill's social media in Scenario 1 is more attractive to me as a business owner looking to expand my customer base.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nAs an artisan selling handcrafted items at a local market, the primary aim is not only to sell the product but to promote the art, spread the word, and build a customer base. Pricing for handcrafted items also takes into consideration several factors like the time, effort, skill, and the uniqueness of the item. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is offering to promote the art on her social media platform, which could increase visibility and possibly bring in more customers. This could be good exposure for the business. In return, a small discount would be a fair trade-off for the potential increase in customers.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is asking for a discount with the promise of potentially purchasing more later. This hinges on the promise of a future event that may or may not happen. Moreover, given the nature of handmade items where each piece is unique, she may or may not like other items enough to buy them in the future.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the immediate benefit and the prospect of promotion on social media, I am more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present worthy reasons for a discount, they need to be evaluated against the benefits gained from the discount offered.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers publicity on her social media in exchange for a discount. This can help gain visibility and possibly attract new customers. Therefore, if she has a considerable following, this strategy could pay more dividends than the initial loss on the discount. However, it is important to verify her engagement rate and followers amount. It's also worth noting that there's no guarantee that this promotion would translate into actual sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill alludes to the potential of her becoming a repeat customer and making future purchases. This would mean consistent sales over time. However, this is under the assumption that she will indeed return to buy more goods. Offering a discount here establishes a good customer relationship and secures possible future sales, but it's still based on an unconfirmed promise.\\n\\nThat said, it's with the understanding of these scenarios that a judgment can be made over which one to favor.\\n\\nAnswer: It truly depends on Jill's social media following and guarantee of a return. However, if we'd have to choose, Scenario 2 could potentially establish a more consistent revenue stream, assuming Jill does indeed become a recurring customer. This establishes a direct monetary benefit to us, unlike Scenario 1 where the benefits are indirect and based on unqualified promises. Therefore, Scenario 2 would be a safer bet.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFirst and foremost, Jill is demonstrating admiration for the flower vase and my craftsmanship, which is important. She's not just asking for a lower price; she's acknowledging the work and effort that went into creating this piece. She also recognizes the value of handmade art pieces, which stands out in both scenarios.\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media platform. This is a nice incentive considering the potential for new customers it might bring in. It's crucial here to consider how reliable this promise is, and while this cannot be determined wholly from these scenarios, we can consider the overall tone and credibility from the conversation so far.\\n\\nComparing the two scenarios, in Scenario 1, Jill is more upfront about her intentions about being an admirer of local artisans and her efforts to get good value. In Scenario 2, however, Jill's offer to promote my work on her social media appears to be linked more directly to getting a discount.\\n\\nFinally, we must consider the implications of price negotiation and the precedent that may set with other customers observing the transaction.\\n\\nAnswer: I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. Jill's tone is respectful and genuine, showcasing a sincere appreciation for the craft, not merely focused on getting a good deal. She also sets up her request for a discount with the affirmation that she's willing to pay full price, underpinning the value of the vase. This approach, coupled with offering to promote my work on her social media, results in a balanced negotiation rationale.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn deciding these two scenarios, it's crucial to consider how the customer approaches negotiation and how a discount might benefit me as an artisan. \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill acknowledged the quality and craftsmanship of my work. She didn't just try to bring down the price out of the blue; she showed respect for my work and established rapport by being pleasant and sincerely appreciative. \\n\\nHowever, there are a few subtle differences. In Scenario 1, Jill implied she is ready to pay the full price if necessary, which makes the negotiation process feel more like a collaboration than a competition. She introduced her social media following as a potential benefit for me, which means it's not a zero-sum game where she wins the discount, and I lose the full price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while she offers a similar bargain, her opening statement about the price seems a bit more forceful, less collaborative and is less explicit about her readiness to pay the full price if necessary. She still offers her social media promotion, but it feels a bit more like an afterthought rather than the collaborative proposition in the first scenario. \\n\\nWhile both approaches are quite fine, the way Jill carefully maneuvers the negotiation in Scenario 1 would make me feel more respected and valued as a craftsman, and it also opens up new possibilities for promoting my work. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere are a few factors that I\\'m considering here between the two scenarios.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill seems a lot more genuine in her appreciation for the craftsmanship and design of the vase. She also talks about how she is an admirer of local artisans. The exchange feels more personal and appreciative of my work. Additionally, she mentions her willingness to pay the full price. Also, the fact that she suggests a form of trade, specifically promoting my work on her social media, makes her proposal more interesting.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, though Jill is complimentary, her approach seems more business-oriented. Her statement \"I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price,\" somehow gives me a feeling as if she\\'s not fully on board with the cost considering the effort put in the work, even though this might not be the truth.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, I feel more receptive to the proposition made in scenario 1. It comes off as more of a win-win situation, she gets a slightly lower price, but in return, I get some free advertisement and reach a potentially larger audience through her social media platform. Also, the way she respects the value of the vase and the work of local artisans makes me more willing to negotiate, as it feels like a respectful reciprocation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0.5, 0.5, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: Each scenario presents a different case. In Scenario 1, Jill proposes a potentially long-term customer relationship whereby she would regularly purchase items, thereby possibly earning in the long run, even with a discount. It is an appealing offer for a small business that thrives on regular clientele and word-of-mouth marketing. However, there is no guarantee that Jill will return and fulfill her word of being a regular customer.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers immediate value by providing publicity for the artisan's work via her social media platform. While the extent of her influence could not be verified from the conversation, her offer provides the potential for business growth from exposure to her followers. This could bring significant gains in terms of increased awareness and potential sales that might outweigh the discount given on this purchase. It should be noted, however, that this too is not assured and depends on her actual social media reach and its influence on her followers.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios involve an element of risk, the decision might rest on the artisan's current needs. If the artisan requires immediate growth in customers and publicity, Scenario 2 may be more desirable. If the artisan is more interested in nurturing long-term customer relationships, Scenario 1 might be a better choice.\\n\\nAnswer: The answer would really be dependent on the artisan's needs, but both scenarios allow for negotiation and establish a meaningful relationship with the customer. Both options have merit and could be beneficial in a variety of ways.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios put forth by Jill are persuasive, making it somewhat challenging to pick one over the other. Still, they offer different angles of negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the artisan's work and expresses her desire to be a regular customer, indicating future purchases. She is subtly suggesting a form of loyalty discount for multiple purchases or return purchases. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill tries to negotiate the price by proposing a symbiotic relationship of sorts. She intends to leverage her social media platform to promote the artisan's work in exchange for a discount on the vase. \\n\\nThe choice between the two scenarios largely depends on what would be more beneficial to the artisan in the long run. If the artisan values a steady customer more, who consistently purchases items over time, as suggested in Scenario 1, that would be the preferred option. It would provide a more predictable income stream.\\n\\nHowever, if the artisan believes that the promotion and potential reach of a wider audience from Jill's social media influence, as proposed in Scenario 2, would bring in more business, that may be the better choice. \\n\\nIn this case, if the artisan believes in the power of social media, and feels Jill could truly bring them more potential customers, the artisan might choose Scenario 2. However, if Jill's social media influence isn't considered as beneficial, and the artisan prefers to secure Jill as a regular customer, Scenario 1 would be the better choice. As an artisan in a local market, a regular customer may prove more valuable as Jill's consistent support and word of mouth within the local community could bring in more business than a one-off social media promotion.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario depends on the artisan's perceived value in Jill's proposals.\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is appreciative of the work and is clearly interested in the vase. Moreover, she is not just interested in a one-time purchase but in buying multiple items in the future. As an artisan, having her as a regular customer would definitely be beneficial in a long term scenario given she plans to spend more overall despite asking for a discount in the present case. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is offering to promote the craft on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. This could be potentially beneficial but there are uncertainties such as the reach of her social media platform and the actual conversion rate from her shout-outs. It's harder to measure the value of this sort of promotion.\\n\\nA customer returning and buying multiple items over time as mentioned in scenario 1 is a more tangible and reliable form of repeat business as compared to the potential, but uncertain exposure from scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is approaching the negotiation process respectfully, acknowledging the artistry and craftsmanship that went into the creation of the vase. However, the approaches used in each scenario vary slightly, potentially affecting the artisan's inclination to negotiate on the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill emphasizes her support for local artisans and uses this as the foundation for her request for a discount. She makes no immediate promises of further benefits to the artisan beyond suggesting her likelihood of returning to make more purchases in the future. On one hand, the artisan might appreciate Jill's pledge of support, but on the other hand, it is speculative with no guaranteed benefits in return for a price reduction.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the craftsmanship but additionally offers a direct benefit to the artisan—a promotion of the artisan's work on her social media. If Jill has a considerable following, this could mean significant exposure for the artisan's products, possibly leading to increased sales and business growth.\\n\\nThus, even though both approaches are considered polite and respectful, in Scenario 2, Jill provides immediate value and a potential return on investment for the artisan. Therefore, the artisan might be more willing to negotiate and offer a discount under this scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons to consider negotiating the price of the vase with Jill, as each offers potential benefits to me as the artisan. However, the situations differ in the type of future benefits they present; the first scenario consists of the promise of future patronage and possibly more immediate sales, while the second scenario offers exposure through Jill's social media.\\n\\nMy decision would largely depend on my immediate financial needs and the current state of my business. If I am in immediate need of making sales to sustain my business, scenario 1 provides a more reliable and immediate return by confirming future purchases and potentially other items.\\n\\nOn the other hand, if I am interested in growing my brand or want to market my products to a wider audience, the proposal in scenario 2 about featuring my vase and my shop on her social media may be very attractive, especially if Jill has a significant amount of followers or influence on social media platforms.\\n\\nHowever, bear in mind that scenario 2 presents a higher risk since there is no guarantee that featuring my products on her social media will result in increased sales, as it all depends on Jill's followers' interest in my products and their purchasing power.\\n\\nBased on all these considerations, if I were to choose one scenario over the other, I might be more inclined towards scenario 1 because the promise of future purchases seems like a safer bet than an uncertain increase in exposure.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present an interesting argument for a discount; however, the negotiation strategies differ significantly. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is implying loyalty, she may be a returning customer and is considering purchasing more than one item. This is good as a business owner, knowing that my product appeals to customers to the point they would return. However, loyalty cannot be guaranteed. At this point, Jill has expressed an intention, not a committed action.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill is offering something concrete in return for a discount: marketing. If Jill truly has a robust social media following, her promotion could bring new clients to my stand and provide additional sales. This is an immediate value. \\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential reach and business growth, I would be more inclined to offer a discount given the marketing exchange Jill is proposing. This could be more beneficial in the long run, particularly if she has a large or local following who could turn into potential customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is offering a similar proposition, however, the tone and approach of the negotiation differ slightly. In Scenario 2, Jill straightforwardly asks for a discount and offers to promote my work on her social media. This is clear and to the point, but it might come across as impersonal or business-like.\\n\\nContrarily, in Scenario 1, Jill takes the effort to compliment my work sincerely and recognize the local artisan community. She presents her financial constraints and her offer to promote my work as part of the same narrative, giving a more personal and sympathetic touch to her negotiation.\\n\\nJill also subtly anticipates a concern I might have about the potential impact of a discount, by promising that her promotion might attract more customers in the future. This suggests that she is thoughtful and understands the implications of her request, making her proposal seem more like a win-win.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill showcase her interest in the vase and add an incentive for giving a discount in the form of social media promotion. This can be a compelling reason to negotiate the price since it provides a form of advertisement that could attract more customers. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the talent of the artisan and expresses her interest in supporting local craftsmen, which could foster a sense of community, appreciation, and rapport. Moreover, she sets up a context with her financial restrictions, allowing for a more personal approach to the negotiation process.\\n\\nWhile Jill in Scenario 2 also compliments the artisan, the way she casually links the discount to social media exposure might come across as transactional. The way the proposal is framed does not emphasize her support for the local artisans or personal financial considerations as much as in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAlthough the potential social media exposure offered in both scenarios is beneficial, the manner of negotiation in Scenario 1 feels more personalized and empathetic, which might make the artisan more inclined towards giving a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer similar propositions. They both compliment the work, show respect for it, and present the same offer for a discount in return for social media exposure. They effectively communicate Jill's intentions in a respectful manner. \\n\\nHowever, the approach in scenario 1 is a bit more heartfelt and appeals more to an emotional perspective. Jill is not only acknowledging your talent as an artisan but also showing genuine interest in supporting local crafts and artisans. This appeals to the sense of community and shared support among local artisans.\\n\\nFurthermore, in the first scenario, Jill does a better job explaining how exactly she will be able to return the favor (promoting your work on her social media, providing access to a new audience). The more detailed explanation could potentially be more convincing. \\n\\nFor these reasons, a more likely scenario to negotiate the price would be the first one.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"As an artisan, both scenarios are appealing because they offer not just a sale, but also a potential promotion of my work. However, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nReasoning: Jill explicitly acknowledges the value of supporting local artisans in Scenario 1, which shows a deeper understanding and appreciation for the work I do. In addition, by expressing how she has been searching for a unique, locally made piece and is eager to own my piece of art, it not only validates its worth but also signifies that she values my work for its intrinsic value and not just sees it as a commodity. Also, the mention of sharing my name and brand on her social media as part of the deal shows she’s not just looking for a one-time discount but could help me reach a wider audience. Consequently, while I could possibly negotiate a discount, I would also get promotion and recognition from this transaction. This feels like a more balanced exchange.\\n\\nJill's approach in Scenario 2 has a more direct emphasis on the flexibility of the price and the offer of promotion feels more like an afterthought. Although this also involves promotion, it might not be as beneficial for me, because the equal emphasis on the value of my work and its promotion is not there.\\n\\nSo, my decision is: \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nScenario 1 presents a flattery and a clear offer of wanting to promote your work to a large following on her social media platforms. This would be like a barter system, with her promotion services being exchanged for a discount. The exposure that could come from Jill's promotion of your work could potentially bring in future customers and sales. \\n\\nScenario 2 also complements your work and offers promotion via social media for a discount, however, it doesn't emphasize on a clear action plan as Scenario 1 does. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"In both scenarios, Jill effectively discusses the vase's appeal to her and brings up the concept of promoting the artisan’s work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. However, there are slight differences in the way she puts forth her proposal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill goes into more detail about her appreciation for the artisan's work, and emphasizes the importance of supporting local artisans. Her approach feels more personal and appreciative, which may resonate positively with the artisan. She also undersells the vase, saying the price is too high and suggests trading promotion for a discount. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill compliments the artisan's talent, she doesn't delve as much into the importance of supporting local artists or the beauty of the vase. Her proposal to promote the artisan's work in exchange for a discount is more straightforward without other adornments.\\n\\nMy reasoning and preference lean toward Scenario 1. As an artisan who probably values the recognition and appreciation of the work put into each creation, Response 1's approach, which shows a deep understanding of the local artists' craftsmanship, could potentially be more influential. The mix of strong compliments, underselling, and the promise to advertise feels like a more balanced negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill uses similar strategies to negotiate the price: appreciating the craftsmanship, showing ongoing interest, and giving a valuable offer i.e. promoting my work through her social media platform. However, there are subtle differences that make a bigger impact on the negotiation outcome. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only talks about promoting my work, but also creates additional value by expressing her intention of becoming a repeat customer and potentially buying multiple items, which can significantly increase my overall sales and customer loyalty. This tactic is more likely to make me interested in negotiating the price, as I perceive greater future gains, not just a one-off transaction. \\n\\nFurthermore, Jill's tone in Scenario 2 is more pleasant and less demanding, which can help in price negotiation as it promotes a more positive dialogue and relationship between us. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is leveraging the possibility of promoting the artisan's work on her social media, which could potentially bring more business. The offer for repeated business and the potential for bulk purchasing is raised in Scenario 2, which may make it slightly more appealing. However, the compliment on the craftsman's talent in Scenario 1 stands out and could have an emotional impact on the artisan, potentially swaying them towards reducing the price. Negotiation often involves not just logical reasoning, but also emotional persuasion. Furthermore, Jill in Scenario 1 directly discusses the potential for a discount in exchange for social media promotion, making her proposition clearer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill attempts to negotiate the price with the promise of giving my work exposure through her social media channels. However, the strategies differ slightly. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill starts by complimenting my work and acknowledging the value of the price set. Rather than suggesting a specific discount, she leaves it open-ended, perhaps allowing me to propose a reduction I'd be comfortable with. Her offer to feature my work on her social media page also feels somewhat more genuine and less conditional, suggesting she truly does appreciate the vase and my craft.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill immediately questions whether there are any discounts available, possibly hinting that she thinks the price is too high. Her additional offer to promote my work on social media comes off as more transactional, and she ties it directly to a potential discount. While she does mention being a returning customer, there's no immediate benefit to me, as she's only just now showing interest in my products.\\n\\nConsidering the tone and approach in each scenario, I'm more inclined to negotiate based on Scenario 1 due to Jill's direct appreciation of my work and less obvious assumption of a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has very diplomatically expressed her interest in purchasing the vase and proposed a trade-off by promoting the artisan\\'s work on social media. But there are a few variances between the two scenarios that might make one more effective than the other. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill starts the conversation by complimenting the artisan\\'s talent and acknowledging the value of the vase. She then promptly indicates that she understands the pricing and appreciates the work. However, it\\'s only after suggesting a bartered discount that she reveals her offer to promote the artist\\'s work on her social media. This puts the artisan in a position where he/she is now less \"selling\" to the customer, but more as if they are \"collaborating\" together. This can be a compelling move as it puts the artisan\\'s work at the forefront and at the same time indicates an opportunity of promotion and exposure. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also initiates the conversation by appreciating the work but directly jumps into the promotional arrangement without acknowledging the set price of the vase explicitly. While the offer to promote the work is certainly valuable, not addressing the current price might put the artisan in an awkward position, particularly if their pricing is non-negotiable.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, the customers are applying a similar approach to negotiate the price of the vase and offering to promote the work on their social platforms in return, which is a great opportunity for any artist. However, Scenario 1 seems a bit more direct and respectful. Jill appreciates the talent and acknowledges the reasonable price of the vase even before suggesting a discount. On the other hand, in Scenario 2 she jumps directly to the negotiation part. Also, in Scenario 1, Jill's offer is more persuasive as she intends to promote the entire shop and not just the vase. This could potentially bring more customers to the artisan and might generate additional business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present an opportunity for a new customer, possible price negotiation, and additional advertising via social media. However, there are some differences that could influence the decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill complements the artisan’s craft and shows clear interest in the vase. She also suggests a trade-off in which she would promote the shop on her social media in exchange for a discount on the vase. However, there's no factual evidence about the reach or impact such a promotion would have.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill presents a similar proposition but makes it more tangible by stating that she has a decent number of followers. Depending on the artisan’s current advertising strategy, this might be a very attractive proposition. If the artisan is not very well known and needs the promotion, the assurance of a decent follower base could be a deciding factor.\\n\\nBased on these points, my reasoning tends towards Scenario 2, because it provides more specific information about the potential benefit for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning text: The two scenarios are quite similar in the way Jill is trying to negotiate for a discount on the vase, but each scenario holds a slightly different approach. In both scenarios, Jill attempts to use the possible promotion of your artistry on her social media platform as a bargaining chip. That being said, scenario 1 appears to offer a more assertive and compelling request. Jill not only complimented your craftmanship but also stated her intent right at the beginning. She states that she finds the original price fair, implying that she recognizes the value in your work. She, then, offers a quid pro quo deal, which would not only directly bring your craft to a larger audience but also increase the likelihood of more sales, hence the greater long-term benefit. On the other hand, scenario 2 presents a more passive request and focuses more on the discount than the promotion. She says \"feature the vase and entire shop\" but it sounds less direct and organized than the more specified post of scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning: Amongst the two scenarios, both offer a similar proposal, where Jill is proposing a discount in exchange for advertising the products on her social media platform. Both scenarios reflect a similar tone of appreciation for the work and craft, offering genuine compliment before starting the negotiation.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 1, Jill offers a more detailed approach by complimenting specifically the uniqueness of the work, acknowledging the fair price considering the quality, and providing an assurance that she would not only post about the vase but also about other works. This specific and thorough approach adds more credibility to her proposal and gives the impression that she values the work genuinely.\\n\\nOn the other hand, scenario 2, while similar to scenario 1, lacks directly acknowledging the fairness of the price, and the proposal of promotion comes more as a condition attached with the discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe potential decision on whether to negotiate the price with Jill would depend on the perceived value of her offer. In both scenarios, Jill is offering to use her social media presence to promote your craftsmanship and store, but the emphasis and detail differs between them.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is quite flattering about your skills and the quality of the vase. She considers the price \"fair\", indicating respect for your work. She is also upfront with what she’s willing to do in exchange for a discount and confidently mentions her \"considerable following on social media\", which suggests she has a significant audience that could bring you increased business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is equally complimentary, however, her wording slightly undermines the price you\\'ve set -- \"while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price\", which feels subtly less respectful. Plus, she is not as clear about the size of her social media following.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present more or less the same proposition, Scenario 1 comes across as more respectful of your work and offers a potentially more valuable trade-off.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, they both seem very similar in how they are approaching the negotiation. Jill is complimenting the workmanship, acknowledging the current price as fair and offering to promote the artisan\\'s work on social media in exchange for a discount. \\n\\nThe key differentiation between the two scenarios seems to be Jill\\'s level of enthusiasm and commitment to promote the artist\\'s work. In scenario 1, Jill specifically mentions that she posts often about local art and artisans, implying a track record of consistent posts and perhaps a dedicated audience who have an interest in this kind of content. This makes her offer of promotion more valuable and identifiable as opposed to in scenario 2 where she simply states she\\'d \"love to\" promote the work without specifying any exact platform or the regularity of her posts, making her offer seem vague.\\n\\nWith all these elements in mind, even though both scenarios are plausible angles for negotiation, the artisan has a slightly better incentive to consider a discount in regards of Jill\\'s offer in scenario 1 due to the potential of reaching a dedicated audience interested in local craftsmanship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches the situation with positivity and appreciation for the artisan's craft. She doesn't just talk about wanting a discount; she offers an exchange – promoting the artisan's work on her social media platforms.\\n\\nBut upon careful analysis, I find Scenario 1 more appealing for negotiation. Here are the reasons:\\n\\n- Jill starts by acknowledging the fairness of the price based on its quality. This shows she values the artisan's work and does not undervalue it.\\n- She makes her offer to promote the artisan's work before asking for a discount. This makes it seem like an afterthought or a favor she's asking.\\n- Her tone is less commanding; she seems to be suggesting and asking rather than insisting. \\n\\nHaving said this, the artisan could still consider Scenario 2 depending on the level of Jill's influence on social media. If she is a well-known influencer, her assertive approach might not be a problem. But in a general situation, Scenario 1 is more likely to motivate negotiation, as it respects the artisan's pricing and offers something in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: Both scenarios express appreciation for the craft and keep the interaction respectful while showing interest in purchasing the vase. In both scenarios, Jill also offers to promote the artisan\\'s work on her social media, which could potentially bring more customers and increase sales. However, while Scenario 2 is polite and straightforward, Scenario 1 seems more personalized. Jill compliments the artisan\\'s work, and by saying \"this beautiful vase has particularly caught my eye\", she specifically points out the item of her interest rather than generally referring to it as a \"piece\". Additionally, it seems like Jill is more familiar with the value of handcrafted work and considers the original price of the vase fair for its quality, which suggests that she is more likely to appreciate the effort that went into creating it.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill respectfully acknowledges the time and effort that went into creating the vase, which indicates her appreciation for the craftsmanship behind the product. This is likely to be appreciated by any artisan.\\n\\nMoreover, Jill proposes a quid pro quo arrangement whereby she offers to promote the artisan’s work on social media in exchange for a discount. Since artisans typically rely on word of mouth and publicity to boost sales, this could be an appealing trade-off. \\n\\nAlthough Jill offers the same in Scenario 1, what distinguishes Scenario 2 is that she mentions having quite a following, implying wider reach and greater potential exposure for the artisan's work, which adds more value to her proposition. \\n\\nOverall, Scenario 2 offers a more persuasive case for a discount, since it not only compliments the artisan's work, but also proposes a beneficial exchange which could lead to future sales.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill are compelling in their own ways. She openly admires the craftsmanship, which psyched me as an artisan and showed me that she genuinely appreciates my work, not just seeking to lower the price. However, there are subtle differences that make Scenario 2 slightly more appealing. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes \"a slight reduction\" in price but it\\'s not mentioned how much of a discount she\\'s expecting. This could potentially leave me, as the artisan, at a disadvantage because we don\\'t have a starting point for our negotiation. She did offer to share some pictures on her social media and tag my store, which is a great offer, but again, it\\'s not specified how many followers she has or if her followers would be interested in my vases.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill uses similar language but presents her request in a slightly different manner. She states that she\\'s \"willing to pay the full price,\" meaning she likely understands the value of the vase and the work that went into it. She also mentions that she has \"quite a following on social media\" which signifies that she can expose my work to a larger audience. The potential for attracting new customers is a big plus in this situation.\\n\\nBecause of the concise request and the potential for increased exposure, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe details between the two scenarios are very similar; Jill compliments the craftsmanship, says she can see it fitting in her home, and offers to share the piece on social media. However, there are some minor differences that can influence an artisan's decision to negotiate. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions she's willing to tag the store in her social media posts. This suggests that she might have a connection with an audience who could potentially become customers. It's beneficial for word of mouth marketing, and it would cost nothing for the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill mentions that she has a 'quite a following' on social media. This phrase does not provide any objective measure of her follower count, it could mean almost anything. She does offer a social media post, but without knowing her influence or reach, it's difficult to judge if her offer would be beneficial in the same way it would be in Scenario 1.\\n\\nThus, considering the potential marketing value and the assertiveness of Jill in the first scenario, I would be more likely to negotiate in that case.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.7\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and visualizes how it would fit into her home decor. This scenario also includes an additional value proposition - she offers to share pictures on her social media and tag the store, giving the store potential free advertising. This social proofing could potentially attract other customers to the store, depending on the size and engagement of Jill's social media following. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the vase and acknowledges the value of supporting work of local artisans. However, she only mentions that she's hoping to stretch her budget a bit without specifying what amount she'd be comfortable with or offering any additional benefit to the store in exchange for a price reduction.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nMy decision is based on the added value Jill's offer brings in Scenario 1. The promise of social media promotion could potentially expand the customer base and thus outweigh the minor loss from discounting the vase. Additionally, Jill leads with a strong emotional appeal and connection with the product in both scenarios, but the added value proposition in scenario 1 gives her a stronger bargaining position.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill showing appreciation for the piece and expressing interest in purchasing, which is a good start. However, their approach to the negotiation is a bit different.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase, but also offers to promote the vase and the store on her social media. This could potentially bring more customers and increase the store visibility, which could boost future sales.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill relies solely on the fact that she wants to support local artisans and is budget constrained. It's a compassionate angle, but there's no clear additional benefit.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I would be more likely to negotiate in the circumstances described in Scenario 1 where there is a chance for additional promotion which could lead to more business opportunities.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, I would tend to lean more towards negotiating the price in Scenario 1. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship but also discusses her intention to promote my craft via her social media, which can potentially bring in more customers, thus increasing sales and awareness about my store. Furthermore, she is willing to give credit, enhancing the value proposition on her side considerably.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill expresses her appreciation and talks about the budget, but no additional value is offered in return for a potential discount. \\n\\nNevertheless, the final decision would depend on my profit margin and general pricing strategy, but under equal conditions, Scenario 1 provides more added value than Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide valid reasons for a price negotiation. However, Scenario 2 shows a bit more incentive for me as an artisan to be inclined towards negotiation. In this scenario, Jill not only expresses her appreciation for the vase but also suggests a beneficial compromise, which is promoting my handcrafted items on her social media. This could potentially capture the attention of new customers and subsequently increase my sales. Furthermore, her intent to place it in her living room suggests that she values the product and it's not just an impulse buy.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 1 also presents a compelling case with the promise of future patronage and purchasing multiple items. But the effect of these promises is somewhat uncertain and relies on the customers' long-term commitment, which may or may not materialize.\\n\\nFor these reasons, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 2, as the potential direct and immediate benefits outweigh the potential long-term profits of Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill does an excellent job of complimenting the vase and showing her sincere interest. However, each scenario presents different potential benefits for me as the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions the possibility of buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. Her loyalty could lead to more sales in the future, which would be a positive outcome. \\n\\nHowever, I'd need to ensure that the discounts on multiple items don't significantly cut my profit margins. Additionally, future sales are not guaranteed, and Jill may or may not come back even after given the discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill highlights not just a single purchase, but also a potential marketing opportunity. By posting photos of the vase on her social media and tagging my store, she could expose my handcrafted items to a larger audience. This could generate more sales and increase my customer base. \\n\\nSo, after evaluating both scenarios, I would lean towards a negotiation in Scenario 2 as it presents an immediate return investment in the form of a third-party promotion, which might bring more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses an intention to become a returning customer and supports local artisans like yourself. Also, she suggests a basis for negotiation that can potentially benefit your artisan business in the long run - discounting prices for multiple items or for future returning customers. This approach may encourage customer loyalty, repeat business, and can be a good promotion technique attracting more customers willing to buy multiple items. So as an artisan who likely values sustainable customer relations and community support, you might feel positively inclined towards this proposal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, although Jill also shows appreciation for the vase’s craftsmanship and even offers to promote your work on her social media, she directly jumps into price reduction without much concrete or mutually beneficial proposition unlike Scenario 1. Yes, promotion through social media can be beneficial but factors such as Jill's online reach, engagement rate, and followers' propensity to actually buy also come into play, making the return on this aspect a bit uncertain.\\n\\nOverall, while both propositions have their potential merits, my inclination as an artisan trying to build a local loyal customer base would lead me towards Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAssessing the two scenarios, there isn't a massive difference in Jill's approach. However, subtler elements alter the impression Jill gives in each scenario.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill begins by expressing her admiration for the vase and acknowledging the local craftsmanship. She upfrontly discusses her budget issues and proceeds to offer a form of barter trade - a discount in exchange for promoting the artisan's work on her social media. The beneficial point here is that she mentions her significant following, leading to potential benefit to the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses her admiration for the vase and compliments the craftsmanship. But her approach to negotiating the price is less direct. She merely hints at a desire for a discount without explicitly stating that. Moreover, she suggests sharing photographs on her social media but doesn’t mention anything about a significant number of followers or potential benefit to the artisan.\\n\\nTaking everything into account, I believe Scenario 1 portrays a more advantageous interaction for the artisan. Jill’s direct approach, honest expression about her budget constraints, combined with her offer of potentially beneficial visibility for the artisan makes her case more compelling, thereby increasing her chances of obtaining a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth users are making persuasive arguments for a price reduction. In Scenario 1, Jill explicitly recognizes the effort and talent that has gone into creating the flower vase. She shows appreciation for local craftsmanship and indicates her intent to support it. In addition to asking for a discount, she offers to promote the artisan work on her social media platforms, potentially attracting more customers. She lays down the benefits of her offer quite convincingly.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill also communicates her admiration for the vase and its craftsmanship. She visualizes how the vase will enhance the beauty of her living room, signaling that she values the vase not just as an object, but as an aesthetic addition to her space. However, her promise to tag the store and share photos on social media seems more as an afterthought rather than a well-considered way to compensate for the discount she is asking for.\\n\\nGiven these details, Scenario 1 comes off as a better deal for the artisan. Jill's proposition to promote the work potentially stands to benefit the artisan beyond just this single sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill make a good case for a price negotiation. However, there are subtle differences between the two that sway my decision towards one more than the other. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill takes time to appreciate the craftsmanship of the vase and acknowledges the talent present on the local market, which is heartwarming and displays her understanding of the effort put into my work. Her offer to share my work on her social media platform also presents a potentially valuable opportunity for my business. The fact that she ensures to express gratitude regardless of the outcome also evokes a feeling of good intentions and openness.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the vase and its craftsmanship. However, when she proposes a possible discount, she does not justify her request with any financial constraints. Nonetheless, she suggests spreading the word about my work on her social media, which, again, could be of benefit for my business.\\n\\nTaking into account these aspects, my inclination is towards scenario 1. Jill has taken an in-depth look at and provided appropriate appreciation for the vase, as well as given a reasonable explanation for her request. Additionally, she offered to help promote my business on her social media platform as a show of gratitude, potentially expanding my work's exposure to a wider audience.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: While both scenarios involve Jill using similar tactics of negotiation (i.e., offering to promote the artisan's work on social media in exchange for a discount), the first scenario feels more personal and persuasive. She appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase in each scenario, but in the first, she expressly mentions her support for local artisans and her desire to own genuinely unique art pieces. This suggests a deeper connection with the work and shows that she understands and values the time and effort that goes into each piece. In addition, Jill seems more sincere about promoting the vase and the artisan's brand on social media in Scenario 1, presenting it as a credible form of payment rather than just an additional favor. Her approach might resonate more with the artisan, increasing the likelihood of earning a discount.\\n\\nAdditionally, in Scenario 1, Jill's proposal comes across as a potential business partnership, which might be an attractive prospect for an artisan trying to reach a larger audience. This could lend more weight to her argument and appeal to the artisan's business interests.\\n\\nIn contrast, in Scenario 2, the request for a price reduction seems more akin to a standard customer bargaining tactic. Although she offers to promote the artisan's work on social media, it reads more like an afterthought rather than a genuine offer of partnership. The line 'Maybe there's some room for slight reduction?' comes across less persuasive than the more assertive negotiation/suggestion of a deal in Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios demonstrate the customer's appreciation for the artisan's work and their intention to endorse it on their social media platforms, I would lean more towards negotiating a discount in Scenario 1. \\n\\nThe customer, Jill, in the first scenario, takes the time to commend the artisan's work, express her keenness in supporting local artisans, and shows an earnest desire to own the vase. Further, she leverages her social media following, implying the potential for a greater outreach for the artisan's work, which could lead to more sales. It builds a picture of a mutually beneficial arrangement, which may persuade the artisan to negotiate the price.\\n\\nIn contrast, Jill in Scenario 2 expresses her admiration for the artwork, but her emphasis is more on the potential placement of the vase in her living room and less about the potential social media promotion. Thus, the potential benefits for the artisan aren't as evident.\\n\\nHowever, the decision to negotiate would also greatly depend on how crucial the extra sales might be to the artisan, or if they are more concerned with maintaining the perceived value of their artwork by refraining from discounts. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill makes appealing offers, proposing to publicize one's craftsmanship on her social media platforms – an influential tool that can attract more customers and boost potential sales. However, the approach differs in each.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges your craftsmanship and emphasizes how much she values local artisans. This respect for your work is always good to hear as an artisan. Then she proceeded to propose a deal that could also benefit you indirectly. Her suggestion makes economic sense, as this could potentially lead to more customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is more straightforward. She compliments the vase, visualizes her use of it, and then asks directly for a price negotiation. Offering to tag the store on social media, she directly offers the possibility of promotion which might help in gaining more visibility.\\n\\nAlthough both approaches are constructive, I would favor Scenario 1 as Jill communicates her appreciation more thoroughly. She not only admires the product, but it seems she understands your efforts as an artisan, which makes her proposal feel more sincere. The stress on supporting local artisans indicates that she possesses some sense of community, making her more reliable. Offering to leverage her sizable social media followers gives an indication she's confident about her influence and this provides some reassurance about her offer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2 for a few reasons:\\n\\n1) Emotional Appeal: In Scenario 2, Jill emphasizes how much she admires the vase and how it would fit perfectly into her home. There's a circumstantial connection, as the vase will be placed in her living room. This creates a visual and emotional appeal to negotiate the price.\\n\\n2) Advertising exposure: She also offers to promote the vase, and thereby my stall, on her social media account. This could potentially expose my work to a broader audience, which in the long run may lead to more profit and new customers.\\n\\n3) Price Negotiation: While Jill also suggests price negotiation in Scenario 1, scenario 2's potential for advertising and demonstration of strong emotional connection to the vase offers more incentives for me as an artisan to negotiate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is not only showing interest in one item but she also expresses the intent to buy multiple items. This indicates a potential for a larger total sale. Furthermore, she mentions her intention to be a returning customer, which could mean a sustained income source for me as an artisan. Offering a discount now could result in long-term gains by securing a loyal customer. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill's offer to share pictures on her social media could potentially provide some promotion, it's uncertain how many potential buyers this could reach, or whether this would translate to direct sales. It would be more beneficial for me to have a guaranteed sale of multiple items and a returning customer, than a potential one-time sale and uncertain promotional value.\\n\\nConsidering these points, I'd be more likely to negotiate the price in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen comparing the two scenarios, we need to consider both the potential immediate benefits and future gains for the business. In scenario 1, Jill promises to be a returning customer and implies the purchase of multiple items, which can result in a significant business boost over time. However, this potential advantage relies upon trust and future commitment. In scenario 2, Jill proposes a trade-off where she could help the store gain more visibility on social media in exchange for a discount. \\n\\nConsidering the immediate advantage and the potential reach of Jill's social media, this proposal could result in attracting more customers to the store, therefore increasing revenue in a shorter time span. Furthermore, scenario 2 offers a form of immediate return (free advertising) which makes the discount transaction more balanced. \\n\\nSo, while scenario 1 is promising in terms of future business, it lacks the immediate return proposed by scenario 2. In essence, the impact of social media advertising, if Jill does have a good following, could potentially lead to more sales. Consequently, this could be more profitable than relying on one customer's return and their potential multiple purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: While both scenarios presented by Jill are similar in nature, there are some subtle differences that might influence the decision. In Scenario 1, Jill highlights her intentions of becoming a returning customer and hints she might purchase multiple items. This being an investment in future sales, Jill's situation might be appealing. The offering of promoting the artisan's products on her social media adds to the attraction as this could potentially bring more customers. \\nIn Scenario 2, Jill focuses more on the admiration for the vase itself and the artisan's craftsmanship. Her offer of a price reduction is paired with a promise of social media promotion, similar to Scenario 1, yet without implying future purchases. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\n\\nThe aspect of potentially more future sales from Jill herself and her followers on social media makes Scenario 1 more favorable for negotiation. It is especially preferable for a small, local business to gain loyal customers and possibly reach a larger audience through social media promotion.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill seems truly interested in the round flower vase and provides compelling reasons for asking for a discount, demonstrating her appreciation for the craftsmanship and suggesting she will promote the item and my stall on her social media.\\n\\nHowever, I am slightly more inclined towards Scenario 1. In Scenario 1, Jill communicates her intentions for future purchases and regularly returning to the market, implying she could end up a loyal customer, creating potential for long-term profit. She also proposes a form of partnership, offering promotion on her social media. Given that she has a few thousand followers, this could provide considerable exposure and lead to increased market visibility and potentially more sales.\\n\\nAlthough Jill also offers social media exposure in Scenario 2, she does not mention returning to the market, meaning there is no promise of future purchases. Furthermore, in Scenario 2 she only talks about a reduction of price without proposing a direct benefit to me as the vendor.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1, as it appears to offer more potential for future benefits and sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill communicates more incentives for me as the seller to consider a discount. In addition to expressing her interest in the vase, she offers to multiply her purchases, implies the likelihood of future purchases as a returning customer, and promises promotional activity on social media.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while she expresses a strong interest in the vase as well, Jill only offers the possibility of a social media promotional assistance, making her incentives less attractive than in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning text: \\n\\nFirstly, both scenarios presented by Jill offer a proposition of promoting my work on her social media, leading to potential indirect benefits to my business through increased exposure and potentially more customers. However, in Scenario 1, Jill directly states her intentions of asking for a discount upfront. Promoting the business is attractive, but it implies a certainty of return, which cannot be guaranteed in the world of social media promotion. This can feel like a risk to discount the item.\\n\\nBy contrast, in Scenario 2, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and mentions how she envisions using it in her home, showing a genuine appreciation for the item and indicating a personal connection to it. Additionally, her offer to negotiate the price feels like a suggestion rather than a demand, opening a conversation rather than presenting a business transaction.\\n\\nFrom an artisan's perspective, it can be a pleasure to know that someone genuinely appreciates your work, and these emotional connections can influence decision making. The customer's appreciation implied in scenario 2 can therefore motivate the artisan to offer a small discount, taking it as a compliment rather than an attempt to devalue their work.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen considering these two scenarios, the main factors to evaluate are the customer's approach in each, and the potential future benefits that may come from the sale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the work and mentions that she wants to support the artisan by promoting their talent to her network on social media. This offer may benefit the artisan in the long run by potentially attracting more customers to their market stall or online store. Therefore, it would be in the artisan's best interest to negotiate a small discount on the vase to encourage Jill to make the purchase and promote their work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the work again and talks of her use for the vase, which might encourage the artisan, but her offer to share pictures on her social media and tag the store is much vaguer than in Scenario 1. From the wording, it is not clear whether Jill has a substantial following or influence on social media that would genuinely benefit the artisan.\\n\\nBased on these points, the first scenario seems more likely to persuade the artisan to negotiate the price of the vase, because Jill clearly states her intent to promote the artisan's work to her follower base. A small discount on this vase could result in far greater profits in the future, providing a clear business advantage.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media which could potentially attract more customers. However, there's a slight difference between the two scenarios. In the first scenario, Jill is explicitly proposing a barter exchange where she asks for a discount on the vase in return for promoting my work. There isn't a definite promise of actual sales from her promotions. While it is true that promotion could bring exposure, there is no absolute certainty in sales conversion. \\n\\nIn contrast, the second scenario gives more emphasis on how Jill admires my work, appreciates its aesthetic value, and visualizes how it could fit into her own space. She merely suggests a potential discount, and offers to promote on her social media as a bonus. She didn't demand or suggest an exchange outrightly. The true appreciation and potential user satisfaction coming from Jill in scenario 2 could contribute to word-of-mouth marketing which could be more sincere and impactful in the long term.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning: Both scenarios project Jill as an interested buyer with a potential to provide free advertising through her social media platforms. However, scenario 2 presents a more compelling case for negotiation. Jill in this scenario understands and appreciates the value of the vase, considering her words \"which I think is fair considering the quality.\" Also, the fact that she offers to direct people to my stall does resonate with me as an artisan because it implies she wants to support my work on a broader scale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning text: \\n\\nBoth scenarios present similar propositions, which involve Jill appreciating the craftsmanship of the vase and offering to promote the artisan's business on her social media platform in exchange for a price reduction. However, in Scenario 2, Jill not only praises the vase but also acknowledges that the initial price set is fair given the quality, demonstrating an understanding and respect for the value of handcrafted items. Additionally, she specifies the benefit to the artisan is not just a single post, but potentially directing people to the artisan's stall, suggesting an ongoing relationship. Jill also mentions she has a 'considerable following', indicating the potential for a larger audience. Hence, Scenario 2 demonstrates a fair trade-off and portrays Jill as someone genuinely interested in supporting local artisans which increases her bargaining power. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", 'Reasoning: Both scenarios have nearly identical premises; Jill appreciates the vase\\'s craftsmanship and wants to negotiate the price down, offering to endorse the vase on her social media platform in exchange. However, in Scenario 1, Jill brings up the negotiation more casually as a slight reduction and immediate appreciation for the vase. Meanwhile, in Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the vase but clearly states she finds the price fair yet wants a discount. She offers social media promotion as a kind of payment for the discount, clearly trading services for a lower price. Despite her high praise for the craftsmanship, her approach is more transactional.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nBy only implying she wants a \"slight reduction\" Jill makes it seems less like she\\'s requesting a favor and more like she\\'s engaging in a friendly discussion. While the offer to promote the vase on social media is there, it\\'s less a bargaining tool and more an enthusiastic customer looking to share a beautiful product with her friends. This gives the impression that Jill really values the artisan\\'s work and appreciates the value of the handcraft, a compliment that a craftsman might find more agreeable to negotiation.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Although both scenarios are quite similar with Jill asking for a discount while offering to promote the artisan's work on her social media, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2.\\n\\nReasoning: In Scenario 2, Jill acknowledges the quality of the craft right away by specifically commenting on the 'outstanding craftsmanship', and expresses her personal appreciation for the vase by sharing where she would place it in her home. Her comments suggest a deeper appreciation for the work and thought that has gone into the product. This implies that she values the work and the skills of the crafts person. This emotional connection surpasses the transactional nature of purchasing and reveals a more personal engagement with the vase. \\n\\nMoreover, she doesn't just propose a transactional deal where she'll promote the artist's creations in return for a discount, but also promises to actually use the vase and take pictures of it in her home, giving it a personal touch and potentially attracting more genuine interest to my products. \\n\\nIn contrast, scenario 1 feels slightly more transactional where Jill asks for a discount immediately after the compliment, and also the way she offers to promote the vase feels more like a business deal. Even though promoting on social media is mentioned in both scenarios, scenario 2 feels more personal and genuine.\\n\\nHence, I'd chose Scenario 2 for negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios contain almost similar lines of negotiation, there are certain key differences that make one more appealing than the other when it comes to a prospective discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill presents in an apparent way a value exchange proposal. She notes a specific commitment to feature the artisan\\'s work on her social media platforms, mentioning Instagram and Facebook by name. Moreover, she alludes to posting \"often\" about local art and artists, which suggests she has an audience interested in this. \\n\\nIn comparison, Scenario 2 has Jill expressing her admiration and how she envisions the vase enhancing her living room’s beauty. While this is emotionally compelling, the offer for potential exposure is relegated to a secondary clause and comes off weaker in comparison.\\n\\nFrom an artisan\\'s perspective, while the compliment is appreciated, Scenario 1 seems more business-oriented and has the potential for more tangible rewards i.e., increased exposure and possibly more sales. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill's request for a discount is directly tied to a valuable return service. She offers a promotion of the artisan's work on her social media platforms, which can definitely help in drawing more customers and increasing sales. This way, a small discount could be seen as an investment in marketing and could easily pay off in the long term.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also mentions she could share pictures and tag the store on her social media, however, her offer is less straightforward and direct compared to the first scenario. In addition, she doesn't provide any details about her social media influence or followers which could potentially mean her offer has less or uncertain value.\\n\\nTaking into account the above, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1 since she presents the offer of helping with promotion and marketing more clearly and assertively, which could be beneficial for my business growth.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows appreciation for the craftsmanship and expresses interest in supporting local artists, which is a positive approach. Nevertheless, there are differences in how she proposes a discount which might sway the decision. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, not only does Jill praise the work but she also offers a form of barter system by promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This might be of significant value if she indeed has a large following. This can help increase visibility and possibly bring in more customers for the artisan. It's a win-win situation where both parties are benefiting, making this scenario more appealing.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is simply asking for a discount without offering anything in return. Although supporting her desire to own the artisan's work is good, when you consider the time, effort, and skill it takes to create the vase, simply reducing the price without gaining anything might be less appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is clearly expressing a genuine interest to buy the vase, and she is also appreciating the artisan effort. However, my decision would lean more towards Scenario 1. \\n\\nIn this first scenario, Jill not only appreciates the effort that went into creating the vase but she also offers a form of exchange: promoting the artisan and product on her social media platform which potentially exposes the product to a larger audience. This proposed exposure and marketing for the product and artisan skills provides an added benefit that is not present in Scenario 2. Jill in Scenario 1 suggests a mutually beneficial relationship, unlike Scenario 2 where only the price is being considered with no additional benefits to the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning Text:\\nBoth scenarios had Jill approach with compliments about the vase, showing genuine interest and admiration for the craftsmanship. These positive comments make Jill a potential customer that the artisan will likely want to accommodate. However, there are differences in the negotiation approaches of the two scenarios that may lead to different outcomes.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only conveys her interest but also proposes a value-add proposition in the form of social media exposure. This offer could potentially bring more customers and expand the artisan's reach, which could be a beneficial trade-off for a small discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also shows appreciation for the artisan's work, but she only mentions that the price goes slightly beyond her budget. While this showcases her desire to own the vase, her negotiation is based solely on a discount, which may not immediately benefit the artisan other than making a sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nThe proposition of additional value in the form of social media exposure in Scenario 1 could potentially benefit the artisan in the long run despite the short-term discount. This makes Scenario 1 more likely to result in a successful negotiation for Jill.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.0\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0.5, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a case where Jill exhibits a keen interest in the artisan's work and appreciates the effort that goes into making such hand-crafted items. However, there's a difference in the way Jill approaches the negotiation in both scenarios. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill positions herself as an appreciator and supporter of local artisans, thereby creating an emotional connection. She is honest about being on a budget and conveys her willingness to contribute to the community. In a way, her negotiation is not just about receiving a discount but contributing to the sustenance of local artisans. The artisan, being a part of the local community, might feel compelled on a personal level to accommodate her request and also build goodwill with a potential repeat customer.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill acknowledges the artisan's craftsmanship and proposes an alternative form of payment – promoting the artisan's work on her social media platform. This proposal presents a potential benefit to the artisan by widening their reach to a broader audience. However, the efficacy of this strategy relies on the influence and reputation of Jill's social media presence.\\n\\nFrom solely a business perspective, Scenario 2 could give more value to the artisan in the long term if Jill's social media promotion leads to increased sales and visibility for the artisan's work. On the other hand, Scenario 1 relies more on sustaining the local community and building a stronger network of supporters. It depends on what the artisan values more: wider exposure and reach (Scenario 2) or strong community ties and goodwill (Scenario 1).\\n\\nBased on this, my answer would be:\\n\\nAnswer: This would entirely depend on the artisan's value system and long-term goals. If the artisan primarily values community, Scenario 1 would likely be more appealing. If the artisan is more focused on wider visibility and exposure, Scenario 2 could be more enticing. Nevertheless, both cases offer different advantages to the artisan, making both scenarios potential winners.\", 'Reasoning Text:\\nWhile both scenarios have elements that encourage negotiation, Scenario 2 presents a more appealing case.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill uses emotional appeal, expressing her admiration for local artisans and implying that her budget constraints might prevent her from buying. This emotional appeal might effectively invoke the compassion of some artisans, and they may offer a discount based on this. However, without any concrete benefits presented, a financial-minded artisan might not find this reasoning persuasive.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 involves both an emotional appeal and a more practical offer. Jill still admires the craftsmanship and expresses a desire to get good value, but she also brings a new element – her social media following. This suggests that reducing the price might also come with advertising benefits, which could potentially draw in more customers in the future. This win-win proposal might make the artisan more willing to negotiate the price as it presents a clear benefit to the business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill shows interest in the vase in both scenarios, acknowledging and praising the quality of craftsmanship, with a desire for a price reduction. However, in Scenario 2, Jill offers additional value beyond cash; she proposes to promote the vase and my work on her social media, which has a considerable following. This kind of exposure can expand my customer base, resulting in potentially more future clients, which equates to future sales and profits.\\n\\nTherefore, without devaluing the vase, a small discount in exchange for free marketing exposure and potential future sales would outweigh the immediate benefit of the full price sale in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nDespite both scenarios offering compelling arguments for a discounted price, I'd lean towards Jill's proposal in Scenario 1, for a few reasons.\\n\\nFirstly, Jill not only appreciates the design and craftsmanship of the vase, indicating that she values the work put into it, but she also mentioned she could promote the vase on social media. This could potentially lead to increased exposure and sales, which could more than make up for the slight loss from the discount. Word-of-mouth is a powerful marketing tool, and leveraging an already existing follower base can give a significant boost.\\n\\nSecondly, in Scenario 2, Jill mentions returning in the future and buying more items as a reason for discount. However, this promise is neither immediate nor guaranteed and it might put me on the spot each time regarding whether to grant her discounts.\\n\\nConsidering these points, I'd feel more inclined to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nNegotiations are just as much about building relationships as they are about coming to an agreement. Both scenarios offer potential for customer loyalty, but they each present the opportunity in different ways. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill proposes indirect marketing in exchange for a discount, mentioning her social media following. If Jill truly has a significant following, this could potentially attract new customers and boost sales. This is something that can be harder to quantify, though, and it's based largely on trust. \\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, implies a chance for continued business from Jill herself. She shows intentions to make additional purchases in the future and wishes to maintain a long-term customer-artisan relationship. However, a discount now doesn't necessarily guarantee future sales.\\n\\nBoth scenarios have merits, but given the immediate monetary benefit and potential future business, as well as the appreciation Jill shows for local artisans, scenario 2 seems slightly more appealing. The potential of a returning customer who also values and understands the hard work that goes into handmade items feels more secure, compared to the slightly unknown outcome of the social media promotion in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill shows appreciation for the craft and highlights her interest in promoting the work on her social media platform, which could potentially bring more customers. However, she doesn't indicate any likelihood of becoming a returning customer or buying multiple items. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill not only expresses her admiration but also commits to return in the future for more purchases. She hints at becoming a regular customer and supporting my business further. Even though she doesn't have a platform for publicity, retaining a loyal customer often proves more beneficial in the long run. Apart from this, the potential of selling more items to her in the future gives a clear incentive for offering her a discount at the current moment.\\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios present valid cases for a price negotiation, the likelihood of future business in scenario 2 makes it more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"While both scenarios are thoughtful and respectful, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill acknowledges the time, effort, and craftsmanship that went into creating the vase, which shows her understanding and valuing of handcrafted work. This already creates goodwill between us.\\n\\nSecondly, her proposition of promoting my work on her social media platform can potentially bring new customers to my market stall or online store which increases the business' visibility and could lead to increased sales in the future. This has a value beyond the immediate sale of the vase and could be a fair trade-off for a small discount at the moment. In fact, that sort of advertising can often cost more than the discount she is likely asking for.\\n\\nIn comparison, while Jill in Scenario 2 also compliments my work and states her intention to buy in the future, without a specific proposal or immediate benefit to my business, I have less incentive to discount the vase for her. There is less guaranteed benefit for providing a discount in this case.\\n\\nHowever, Jill's strategy in Scenario 2 of asking if there are discounts for future returning customers or multiple items is still a good one and I would consider implementing such programs if I haven't done so already.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn this particular case, I would be more prone to negotiate in Scenario 1 for a number of reasons:\\n\\n1. Exposure: Jill mentions that she has a considerable following on social media, and she’s proposing to feature the vase and highlight my work there. This could potentially lead to increased visibility and reach, opening up a whole new audience for my work.\\n\\n2. Value exchange: Even though she's asking for a discount, she's also offering something in return (promotion), which in the long run could benefit my artisanal business. This makes her negotiation proposition less of a simple discount request and more of an exchange of values.\\n\\n3. Positive approach: Jill's approach is respectful and complimentary, acknowledging the time and effort put into the craft. She expresses more of an interest in the product itself, and less in the price markdown. This suggests that she genuinely values the work, making me more inclined to work out a discount for her.\\n\\nMeanwhile, while in Scenario 2 Jill still shows interest and compliments the product, she doesn't offer the same concrete value exchange as in Scenario 1.\\n\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In comparison, Scenario 1 seems to present me as the artisan with more potential benefits and reasons to negotiate the price of the vase. Jill is not only appreciating the vase and the craftsmanship that goes into my work but also offers something of substantial value in return. \\n\\nJill's offer to promote my crafts on her social media platform has the potential to provide exposure to a wider audience. This might result in more customers, boosting my business's overall sales and revenue. Additionally, the fact that she states she is willing to pay the full price indicates that she understands the value of the product and isn't just looking for a bargain. \\n\\nWhereas in Scenario 2, Jill amplifies her praise for my work and expresses a desire to get a discount for multiple items or for being a returning customer, but neither of these promises is certain and the potential impact on business isn't as clear or immediate. While it's beneficial to incentivize customers to return, in this particular situation, the benefits of scenario 1 are more enticing and sound for the business.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing an appreciation for my work as an artisan and is presenting me with possible alternatives to a straight-out discount. While her shopping in the future and bringing in potential customers are beneficial strategies offered in Scenario 1, they are not as immediate or guaranteed as the proposal offered in Scenario 2. In Scenario 2, Jill is still willing to pay the full price but suggests a smaller discount in exchange for promoting my brand on her social media, which is a direct form of marketing for my crafts, providing tangible and immediate returns.\\n\\nAdditionally, her appreciation for the time and effort that go into creating each piece indicates that she values my work and is not simply looking for cheap deals. This shows a level of respect that makes me more likely to negotiate with her. \\n\\nTherefore, based on the potential for immediate impact and respect for craftsmanship, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn my opinion, Scenario 2 is more compelling for negotiation, for several reasons:\\n\\n1. Appreciation: Jill opens with a compliment on the design and acknowledges the hard work that has gone into the piece. This is not only flattering but also shows she values the artisan's work - a good start to negotiations.\\n\\n2. Direct negotiation: Jill is very straightforward about wanting a discount, while remaining polite and respectful. Instead of suggesting that the artisan's work might not be worth the asking price, she makes it clear that she's looking for value.\\n\\n3. Social exposure: Jill offers something valuable in return for the discount, i.e., exposure on her social media. This could reach more potential customers and increase the overall sales, offering long-term benefits which makes the discount seem a worthwhile investment.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 1 involves Jill vaguely suggesting she might purchase multiple items or may become a returning customer in the future. While these could be beneficial, Jill doesn't explicitly commit to either, making these offers less enticing as negotiation points. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer interesting negotiation proposals from Jill, but there's some difference in approach and potential benefit for me.\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill shows her interest in returning to the shop for future purchases. It implies that a discount could not only result in the immediate sale but also potentially lead to future revenue. Offering a small discount in return for repeat business might be worth considering. \\n\\nHowever, the second scenario offers immediate potential benefits like publicity and advertising which could reach out to a new audience, provided if Jill's social media following is large and engaged. Not only does Jill compliment my work, but she's also willing to pay the full price, she just prefers to pay less, if possible.\\n\\nIt's important to note that social media exposure could be more valuable in long-term if she has an engaged, relevant audience who would be interested in handcrafted items like mine. The reach of an influential social media personality could potentially result in high visibility and possibly new customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons to negotiate the price with Jill, as she could potentially help spread word-of-mouth for my business in exchange for a discount. However, there are subtle but significant differences between the two scenarios to consider before making a decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is clearly an enthusiastic potential customer who has a strong appreciation for the craftsmanship and design of the vase. She's supportive of local artisans and even offers a direct exchange - the promotion of my business through her social media platform, in return for a small discount. This implies she has a substantial number of followers who may be interested in my work, giving me exposure to a wider audience.\\n\\nScenario 2 also presents a customer who appreciates the work of local artisans, wants to support local businesses and proposes a similar offer to promote my business. However, she mentions being on a tight budget. This might mean that even after receiving a discount, she might not follow through on her end of the bargain.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I find Jill's offer in Scenario 1 appears more beneficial to my business in the long run. I see a potential for wider exposure to an appreciative audience capable of driving more sales, meaning I can earn more, too, despite providing a discount on this piece.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nI appreciate both scenarios as Jill comes across as respectful and appreciative of the effort that goes into creating handcrafted pieces like the flower vase. In both scenarios, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media, which could potentially attract more customers. \\n\\nHowever, I\\'m more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. The reason being, in Scenario 1, although Jill admires the work, she states that she \"always tries to get good value whenever possible,\" which may imply that she isn\\'t necessarily in need of a discount. Conversely, in Scenario 2, Jill shows a genuine interest in supporting local artisans and makes it clear that her budget is tight which indicates that a discount would truly be of help to her. She also offers to barter services in return for a discount, showing a commitment to forging a fair and mutually beneficial exchange.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill hold compelling reasons for negotiation. In both, she appreciates the artisan's work and displays a genuine interest in supporting local artisans. Also, in each case, she proposes to use her social media influence to promote the artisan's work, which could help bring in new customers.\\n\\nHowever, the key difference is found in the way she presents her budget situation. In Scenario 1, she says that she's willing to pay full price, suggesting that she isn't in dire need of a discount. Contrarily, in Scenario 2, she discloses that she is on a tighter budget than she had initially hoped.\\n\\nWith these considerations in mind, I would lean more towards negotiating with Jill in Scenario 2. Her honesty about needing the discount due to budgetary restrictions may resonate more and creates a sense of urgency and necessity. Additionally, her offer to promote the artisan's work still stands, making her proposal a fair exchange.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill presents a good case for potential negotiation. That being said, Scenario 1 seems slightly more appealing due to a number of factors. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase, which itself is a good incentive for me as an artisan to consider facilitating her request. Secondly, her proposition of promoting my work on her social media could benefit my business by expanding my client base. This potential trade-off between a small discount and increased visibility is a strategy that could pay off in the long run, depending on the size and engagement level of her following.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 makes the negotiations more about getting a deal rather than appreciating the value and effort put into creating the piece — even though it does suggest potential for future purchases.\\n\\nHowever, in a real-life scenario, I might take the liberty to inquire about the number of followers Jill has on social media to ensure the benefit of the trade-off.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nFrom a business perspective, both scenarios propose an enticing offer, but they serve different purposes. Let's break it down:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is offering what effectively amounts to free advertising through her social media platform. If Jill indeed has a sizable following, this could potentially bring in new customers that you wouldn't have access to otherwise, leading to increased sales in the long run.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is offering a more immediate and certain option - buying multiple items now or promising to be a loyal customer who will make repeat purchases. This can also increase sales and build customer loyalty, and the effect is easier to measure and more predictable compared to scenario 1.  \\n\\nThus, my approach to negotiation would depend on the current business needs. If I want to expand my reach and am willing to consider long term benefits, I might be more encouraged by Jill's offer in scenario 1. But if I need an immediate increase in sales, scenario 2 could be more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: This really depends on the business needs at the time, but in a general perspective where both immediate sales and long term benefits are considered, I would be more inclined towards Scenario 1. Jill's offer to promote the work on her social media platform can not only boost the product's visibility but may also help build a wider customer base.\", \"Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill has presented considerable reasons for a discount, but their emphasis differs. In scenario 1, she proposes a barter system of sorts - visibility for my work in exchange for a discount which is a potential avenue for new customers, however, there's no guarantee on the return of investment. This visibility is based on the uncertain premise of her post translating to sales. Whereas, in scenario 2, she expresses her intent to be a returning customer and possibly buy multiple items which solidifies her as not only a potential source of multiple sales but also a possibly loyal customer. So, as the artisan, while both prospects offer value, I will more likely lean towards an immediate concrete benefit as opposed to a potential long-term, uncertain one.\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is proposing a potential benefit to me, the artisan. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she claims to be a future regular buyer. However, this is uncertain and I am potentially losing profit on the first item with no guarantee of future purchases, not knowing if Jill will actually follow through.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and proposes advertising my work on social media, which would potentially expose my crafts to a wider audience.\\n\\nBetween the two, Scenario 2 provides a more immediate and concrete benefit (improved exposure and potential direct customer increase through her social media followers) and validates my hard work on the vase. Also, the fact that she is willing to pay the full price without the discount, but is just looking for a good deal, gives me more confidence in her purchase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning text: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions being a potential regular customer in the future and also having an interest in purchasing multiple items. This is beneficial from a business perspective as repeat customers are valuable, and often more profitable, with the prospect for future sales. If Jill gets a slight discount, she will be more likely to return and make more purchases. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill's offer of providing exposure through her social media might seem appealing, it's more uncertain and harder to quantify. There are no guarantees that Jill's followers will become customers or even be interested in your product. Offering a discount in exchange for social media exposure might work if she's a well-known influencer or has a large number of active followers who engage with her content, but otherwise it's a riskier proposition.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios propose a different kind of bargain - future purchases versus immediate exposure. The decision will come down to potential value and personal preference. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill pledges allegiance as a regular customer and seems to be in for long term association. This could positively impact sales in the future. Moreover, she mentions interest in \"multiple purchases,\" this could mean instant revenue from more than one item. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to augment the artisan\\'s publicity by showcasing his work on social media. While this does sound tempting as it could potentially boost prominence and attract more customers, it doesn\\'t guarantee immediate sales - it\\'s a prospective gain.\\n\\nWhile both offers have potential benefits, Scenario 1 delivers the promise of immediate and future revenue which may offer more assurance than just promotional exposure.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios propose a potentially beneficial arrangement for me as an artisan; however, there are certain aspects that make Scenario 2 more appealing. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is appreciating the craftsmanship of the vase and offering to promote my work on social media in exchange for a discount. This is a positive proposal as social media promotion can be incredibly helpful for a local artisan. However, Jill doesn't specify anything about purchasing other pieces or becoming a regular customer.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again shows interest in the vase, but also indicates a desire to become a returning customer. This aspect is essential as it indicates a steady and potentially longer-term source of income. Moreover, she proposes buying multiple items, which could result in more immediate profit even if sold at a discount. The offer of social media promotion is an added bonus. \\n\\nFor me, building a regular customer base can be more valuable in the long run than a one-time social media shoutout, since pleased recurring customers can provide a more consistent source of income and potentially generate more word-of-mouth referrals. Thus, forming a relationship with customers like Jill in Scenario 2 could be more beneficial for my business growth. \\n\\nQuick note, however, in both scenarios or any negotiation, I would need to ensure the agreed-upon discounted price still covers my material costs and adequately compensates the time, effort, and skill that goes into creating each handcrafted item. This is essential in maintaining a sustainable business as a local artisan. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Both scenarios have their own merits, but I am slightly more inclined towards Scenario 2.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and suggests value addition in terms of promoting the work on her social media. However, the negotiation is centered around the single vase and her active role in the negotiation feels a bit insistent.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only shows interest in the vase, but also in other items. This implies potential future patronage - every seller appreciates a returning customer. Additionally, her offer to promote the business on her social media platforms is a substantial additional value, possibly bringing in new customers. The possibility of a bulk purchase or frequent buying is an appealing prospect. She's not only negotiating for the vase but demonstrating her interest and support for my work as a whole which feels more genuine and less transactional.\\n\\nSelling isn't just about a single transaction, it's about building relationships. In the second scenario, Jill seems more interested in fostering a long-term relationship which could be beneficial for my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nWhile both scenarios demonstrate respect and recognition of the craftsmanship, Scenario 2 gives a slightly more persuasive negotiation.\\n\\n1. In Scenario 1, Jill offers to advertise my work on her social media in exchange for a small discount. However, the value of this exchange is uncertain. There's no guarantee that her social media posts will result in sales or increased traffic. \\n\\n2. In Scenario 2, Jill expresses a clear intention of purchasing multiple items and becoming a returning customer, which is a solid incentive for me to offer her a discount. Her consistent patronage guarantees ongoing revenue.\\n\\n3. Additionally, in Scenario 2, Jill again offers to advertise on her social media platforms, but this time it's more as a goodwill gesture rather than a direct trade-off for a discount. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill uses similar strategies to try and negotiate the price of the vase. She compliments the craftsmanship and mentions a potential promotional opportunity via her social media channels. However, there are subtle differences in the tone and the offers she makes.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill speaks about the likelihood of being a repeat customer and implicitly suggests that she could help increase the artisan's business visibility, thereby potentially attracting more customers. In this scenario, she not only outlines her own benefits, but also features the mutual benefits the artisan could obtain, in both short-term and long-term. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 is more focused on a one-off purchase. Jill does suggest promoting the artisan's work on her social media, which is beneficial, but she does not emphasize the likelihood of future purchases like in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\nGiven the potential of generating repeat business and also the potential of gaining more visibility through Jill's social media channels, Scenario 1 presents a better case for offering a discount.\", \"Reasoning:\\nBoth scenarios present a strong case for the negotiation, however, Scenario 1 edges out slightly due to a few key reasons. First, Jill presents herself not only as a buyer but also as a potential recurring customer. This establishes the possibility of a long-term relationship, which can bring consistent revenue in the future. Second, Jill introduces her substantial social media presence through which she could provide free advertising for the artisan's work. This is highly beneficial to the artisan, since it could lead to increased visibility and sales without any costs to them. \\n\\nThe introduction of these two reasons makes the proposition for a discount an appealing prospect that could benefit the artisan with both short term and long term value. While the second scenario does present the social media aspect, it lacks the promise of the recurring purchase, thereby offering less perceived value to the artisan. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Based on both scenarios, both customers have shown great interest and expressed their appreciation for the flower vase's craftsmanship. They also understand the value of the piece and its pricing. However, certain factors make one proposition more appealing to consider for a price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In Scenario 1, Jill not only shows interest in the product, but she also demonstrates the potential to become a repeat customer, which could mean more future sales. \\n\\nMoreover, she proposes an offer which provides more than just a one-time monetary exchange. Jill's willingness to promote the artisan's work on her social media—especially if she truly does have a considerable following—can definitely be translated as a valuable marketing opportunity, which can potentially bring in a broader audience interested in handcrafted items. \\n\\nThe combination of potential future sales and free publicity makes the offer in Scenario 1 much more attractive, which encourages the possibility of negotiating the price more than in Scenario 2. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill proposes a similar offer of promoting the artisan's work on social media, but minus the promise of being a repeat customer. They do mention that they are an admirer of local artisans which may imply they would return, but it's less explicit than in Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: \\n\\nConsidering the two scenarios, both are quite appealing as Jill demonstrates appreciation for the craftsmanship and admiration for the vase; she is also interested in supporting local artisans. \\n\\nHowever, there is a slight twist in the way she presents her case in each scenario. In Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses interest in the vase, but also mentions her intention to support the artisan as a regular customer in the future. In Scenario 2, Jill only requests a discount for the current item due, stating budget constraints. \\n\\nAs an artisan, immediate sales are important, but cultivating relationships with regular customers is more advantageous in the long term due to continuous support and sale predictability, which makes Scenario 1 appear more attractive as a business opportunity. Hence, Jill's statement in Scenario 1 could potentially hold more influence in negotiating a sale price because it offers the prospect of a long-term, beneficial relationship. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only stating her appreciation for the artisan's work but also expressing her interest in becoming a consistent supporter of the artisan in the future. She talks openly about her financial constraints and respectfully asks if the artisan has any discount structures for returning customers or multiple purchases. This shows Jill's intent to buy not just the vase now, but potentially more items in the future. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, though Jill expresses her love for the vase and the artisan's work, her negotiation is based on a single transaction. She doesn't talk about future purchases or an ongoing relationship with the artisan. \\n\\nBased on these reasons, it would be more beneficial in the long run for the artisan to negotiate in Scenario 1, where there is potential for more sales and a developing business relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her admiration for the artisan's work and is interested in purchasing the vase. However, she is hinting at a discount due to the price being slightly higher than her budget. \\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill not only shows her interest in the vase but also assures the artisan of future business by her mention of being a regular patron. She's proposing a long-term relationship, which would likely be beneficial for the artisan. Giving a discount here could be an investment toward retaining a loyal customer. \\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill also appreciates the work but primarily requests a discount due to budget issues. While Jill might return in the future, she doesn't explicitly state it, making it less certain if she will become a regular customer.\\n\\nWith these points in mind, the artisan would probably be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 due to the added assurance of continued business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill appreciates your work, shows an interest in supporting local artisans and indicates a desire to negotiate the price of the vase. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, she additionally mentions making future purchases and a possibility of becoming a returning customer. This can lead to a more long-term relationship, beneficial for your business. \\n\\nIf you give her a small discount now, it may ensure Jill's loyalty and her spreading good word about your stall to others. Furthermore, Jill mentioned that she may buy multiple items. If she indeed does so, you might end up making more profit even after giving her a discount.\\n\\nTherefore, considering Jill’s indication of ongoing support to your business, and likelihood of buying multiple items or becoming a repeat customer, you might be more inclined to negotiate the price in the second scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill approaches with genuine interest and appreciation for the work and even emphasizes her support for local artisans but subtly mentions her budget constraints. Jill doesn't try to offset the value of the vase, but instead acknowledges that it is worthwhile. She just expresses that she can't afford it and politely requests a discount. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill's approach is similar, expressing her appreciation for the craftsmanship and support for local artisans. However, her bargaining strategy focuses on future purchases and returning as a customer to seek a discount. This scenario is more uncertain because there's no guarantee she will come back to purchase again and can even be seen as trying to negotiate better terms for future potential sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\nEven though both customers have expressed their admiration for the artistry involved and their support for local artisans, the immediate sale to Jill in scenario 1 seems more favorable and realistic. The potential future sales in scenario 2 can't be guaranteed and shouldn't dramatically affect the pricing of the present sale.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision to negotiate the price is based on several factors: the customer's genuine interest in the craftsmanship, the appreciation for local artisans, a promise to return for more purchases, and the honest admission of budget constraints. Both scenarios present these elements, but the circumstances are subtly different, affecting the willingness to negotiate. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the customer acknowledges the craftsmanship and expresses a desire to support local artisans, which is similar to Scenario 2. However, her request for a discount is more direct and singular in nature, focused solely on the single purchase of the vase that slightly exceeds her budget. Here, she does not necessarily guarantee future purchases, but there is implied potential for her to become a returning customer out of her appreciation for artisan crafts. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, in addition to appreciating the vase and stating budget constraints like in Scenario 1, the customer goes a step further and enquires about discounts for multiple items and returning customers. This does not just imply potential for future purchases but makes a more explicit promise of return business. For a local artisan, having guaranteed customers proves beneficial in the long run and can justify offering an initial discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile it's appealing to have someone praise your work as a craftsman, it doesn't change the cost of materials or the time and effort put into creating the vase. Therefore, mere words of praise should not be the single factor in deciding to give a discount in scenario 1.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, although Jill is still asking for a discount, she is offering something in return - publicity. By sharing the craftsman's work on her social media, she could potentially attract more buyers in the future. This is a form of bartering, and could benefit the artisan's business in the long run.\\n\\nIt's important to note that any decision to lower the price should also take into account the potential effect on one’s profit margins. But in this specific scenario, considering the future potential customers, the better option would be to give a discount in return for the publicity.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both of Jill's offers are compelling, each offering their own incentives, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in scenario 2. In this case, Jill isn't just asking for a discount because of her limited budget; she's also offering a value in return: promotion of my products on her social media channels. \\n\\nAs an artisan selling my handcrafted items, gaining exposure to a wider audience could potentially drive more business my way, making it a beneficial trade-off. While I would be selling the vase for less than the marked price, the potential benefits outweigh the immediate loss. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling arguments for a discount. In Scenario 1, Jill expresses her appreciation for local artisans and the craftsmanship involved in making the vase but mentions her budget constraint as a reason for a potential discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only complements the craftsmanship but also offers value in terms of a potential future sales through her social media followers, which is a form of barter trade that has the potential to benefit my business in the long run. This gives a promising viable way to increase recognition and sales which is advantageous.\\n\\nWith these points in mind, although Scenario 1 is more straightforward, Scenario 2 is more compelling due to a more advantageous returned favor, and hence a discount would be justified.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a compelling argument for considering a price negotiation. In both instances, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and expresses her desire to support local artisans. However, the approach varies slightly in each situation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is straight to the point and honest about her budget constraints. On the other hand, Scenario 2 involves the promise of providing exposure on social media platforms. This latter scenario could potentially lead to greater awareness and increased sales in the future.\\n\\nNevertheless, relying on potential exposure and promise of promotion is riskier compared to a direct sale that scenario 1 presents. While the potential benefits from Scenario 2 could be significant, it's also possible the expected exposure might not translate to substantial sales or it might not reach the right target audience.\\n\\nMoreover, it would also depend on whether I as an artisan am trying to increase exposure or simply make a sale on the spot. However, given that this is a local market setup, immediate sales would likely be the priority, making the sure sale in Scenario 1 more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nEach scenario presents a different form of negotiation and they both have their potential benefits. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is straightforward, candid, and directly asks for a discount due to budgetary constraints. Her recognition of the artisan's craftsmanship and her support for local artisans can be appreciable. By asking directly, Jill might motivate a sympathy response and depending on the seller's nature and if they can afford to, they might give the discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill's approach is not just to ask for a discount but to offer something in return - promotion on her social media platforms, which has the potential to reach new customers and therefore more sales in the future. This barter-style trade-off could be a very appealing proposition for the artisan, depending on how established their business is, how much they value social media marketing, and their evaluation of Jill's social media influence.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios have valid negotiation points, in a temporary local market setting, an artisan might lean more towards immediate sale and cash flow, especially if they aren't heavily reliant on or interested in social media marketing. Thus, while both offers are good, the first scenario could potentially provide more immediate results in comparison to the long-term, prospective gains of the second offer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAs an artisan, the value of the product works on multiple levels including the time and effort invested to create it, the originality of each item due to its handmade nature, and it being a source of income. Price negotiations can be a sensitive matter, and each of the two scenarios provides a different angle for negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and shows sincerity in supporting local artisans. Her request for a discount is based on personal budget constraints rather than devaluing the item. Showing genuine admiration for the work and expressing a wish to own it, Jill makes her negotiation easier to consider, as it is honest and direct, notwithstanding plainly financial.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill uses a different tactic: promotion through her social media following. This approach has two sides: on the one hand, it could potentially introduce my work to a larger audience, benefitting my business in the long run. On the other hand, it lacks directness and it doesn't guarantee immediate results or returns, since the impact of her promotion is based on the interest of her followers and their purchasing intent. It also devalues my work in the sense that it trades the worth of my craft for a promotion.\\n\\nGiven these factors, I would likely find the first scenario more appealing for negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill shows a lot of interest in the vase and also suggests she could return to buy more. The real key point here is the fact that she also offers to promote your stall from her social media account which has a few thousand followers. This can potentially generate more sales, so it's beneficial to you on a business level.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill also appreciates your work and she's interested in the vase, but the basis of her request for a discount is just because the price is higher than she anticipated. There is no additional benefit offered to you.\\n\\nGiven these points, I would consider it more worth my while, as an artisan running a business, to offer the discount in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nBoth scenarios have presented potential for negotiation, however, the specific details provided by Jill in each scenario influence the likelihood and level of negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill provides a strategic bargaining tool in promise of repeat business and social media promotion. The prospect of return business boosts the potential for a long-term customer relationship, which could result in future income stability. Besides, the implied advertising to her few thousand social media followers presents a significant opportunity to the artisan to extend his market reach, potentially leading to more customers and more sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the craftwork, showing genuine interest in supporting local artisans, which is a positive quality for customers. However, the reason for request of a discount is specifically mentioned to be because the price is slightly over her budget. This does not provide additional benefits to the artisan as it is limited only to the purchase of this single item.\\n\\nHence, considering the longer term benefit and potential for indirect market expansion via social media exposure, the artisan is more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill demonstrates that she is truly interested in the vase, evidenced by her attention to detail. She also provides a plan for future purchases and shows willingness to commit to returning. This is beneficial for a local artisan running small business, as customer retention is crucial for success. Her proposition of being a brand advocate by sharing on social media suggests a potential boost in marketing without the business incurring advertising costs. An individual with a social media following also has the power to influence purchases, drawing in possible new customers. Although it requires a discount, it's an exchange of benefits and minimal risk. \\n\\nScenario 2 also deserves consideration. Jill commends the craftsmanship involved and expresses her commitment to supporting local artisans. The fact that she mentions the price being slightly over her budget suggests negotiation, but she doesn't offer much of a rationale or incentive for providing a discount, other than her liking for the craft.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn assessing both scenarios, it is crucial to gauge potential benefits and long-term implications of each negotiation. \\n\\nScenario 1 presents an opportunity for advertisement and audience outreach, because Jill proposes to promote the artisan's work across her social media platforms. While the artisan would lose some immediate revenue through the discount, an increase in customers drawn by Jill's promotion could potentially result in higher overall profits in the future. However, it also comes with uncertainty - the artisan cannot be sure of the effectiveness of Jill's promotion and whether it will actually result in more sales.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, only involves a one-time transaction. It has an immediate effect of slight loss from discounting the vase, with no promise of future benefit aside from Jill's personal appreciation and potential word-of-mouth promotion in her circle. However, this can also possibly create a precedent where customers expect discounts, depreciating the perceived value of the artisan's work and reducing overall profits.\\n\\nConsidering both scenarios, the artisan might opt for the potential long-term benefits that Scenario 1 presents. Providing Jill a discount in exchange for promotion could be beneficial for the artisan's business in the long run. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nChoosing between the two scenarios is a matter of understanding and weighing the potential benefits. In scenario 1, Jill proposes an interesting exchange where she promotes the artisan's work on her social media platform in return for a discount. This type of promotion, if indeed she has a decent number of followers, could potentially attract more customers, thereby boosting sales. Providing a discount here can be seen as an investment in marketing.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill simply asks for a discount because the vase is slightly out of her budget. While this holds the potential for goodwill and building customer loyalty, it doesn't offer an immediate tangible benefit for the artisan like scenario 1 does.\\n\\nIn both scenarios, the artisan would have to consider their personal business strategies and principles. If the artisan's strategy is to encourage word-of-mouth promotion or if they are keen on investing in social media marketing, they might lean towards the proposal in scenario 1. However, if the artisan believes more in maintaining set prices or if they prefer traditional sales methods, they might consider the straightforward request in scenario 2 more favorably.\\n\\nAnswer: This will vary greatly depending on the artisan's personal business strategy. However, based on the potential benefits alone, scenario 1 provides a possible ongoing return on a small investment in the form of a discount, while scenario 2 only provides a speculative potential for customer loyalty, so I would lean towards scenario 1.\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering a form of promotion for my work. This can greatly benefit me as an artisan if she indeed has a wide network and an appreciable number of followers interested in handcrafted items. This way, in exchange for a little discount, I'm getting potential access to a larger customer base through Jill's promotion which can lead to even more sales.\\n\\nScenario 2 is a common situation where a customer shows interest but tries to negotiate citing the price is over their budget. While, as an artisan, I might empathize with Jill's budget constraints, giving a discount merely because it's over someone's budget could set a precedent for other customers and I could end up losing my profit margin.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her support for the local artisans, but mentions that the price is slightly over her budget. While her appreciation and support is acknowledged, she doesn't offer any additional value in return for the discount she's asking for other than her purchase.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill not only praises the craftsmanship of the vase but also proposes value in return for a discount. Offering to showcase the flower vase and speak about the other works on her social media platforms, which could potentially direct a wider audience to the stall and possibly increase business in the future, is very valuable to a local artisan who could benefit from the promotion.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios highlight an interested customer aiming to maximize their purchasing power through a negotiation. In scenario 1, Jill readily appreciates the artisan's craftsmanship and shows genuine interest in supporting local artistry. She requests a small discount, framing it as a minor adjustment to fit within her budget, which could evoke sympathy and lead to a positive outcome. In this situation, a discount could be seen as encouraging a love for local craftsmanship.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is also highly appreciative of the artisan's work. However, she couples her request for a discount with an offer to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms. This could bring potential exposure and direct more customers to the artisan's stall. However, its success depends on whether Jill actually has a sizable following capable of influencing sales, whether her audience appreciates handcrafted items, and whether she would truly follow through on her promise. There is an inherent risk and unpredictability in this method, as the artisan cannot guarantee any actual increase in sales or traffic to his stall.\\n\\nNegotiating implies finding a mutually beneficial agreement. Therefore, the artisan would be more likely to negotiate in the scenario where there is a guaranteed immediate benefit as well as the possibility of fostering a relationship with a local who genuinely appreciates their work and may return for future purchases. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present interesting situations as a local artisan. However, when contemplating any discounts, it's important to consider the potential benefits.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill simply expresses her admiration for the work and requests a discount because the price is slightly beyond her budget. As much as sympathizing with her financial situation is human nature, it might not provide a long-term benefit for the business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill again compliments the work and asks for a discount. This time, she's offering something in return: promotion on her social media platforms. If she indeed has a substantial following, this proposal could potentially expose the artisan's work to a larger audience leading to more sales in the future.\\n\\nSo, in terms of overall benefit to the artisan, discounting while getting something valuable in return would be more beneficial.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning text:\\n\\nComparing the two scenarios, the context in both is that the customer, Jill, is fond of the vase and is hoping for a discount. However, the appeals made differ in both scenarios. In scenario 1, the appeal is purely emotional. Jill appreciates the art, supports local artisans, and wants the piece in her home, but cites budget constraints. These are certainly valid points, but they don't offer any concrete benefits to us as the seller. On the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill not only shows her enthusiastic interests in the vase, but also proposes a win-win situation for both. She offers to promote the work on her social media platforms. If she does have a notable presence and following on social media, the exposure could potentially introduce more customers to our products. This can mean more business and outweighs the reduction in price for one vase. That's a solid business proposition, which can be advantageous for both parties involved.\\n\\nAnswer: Given these considerations, we would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios suggest the possibility of a good intention from Jill, in terms of business sustainability and promotional benefit, Scenario 2 presents a more compelling argument for a price negotiation. In this situation, Jill not only expresses her admiration for the vase, but she also offers something in return for a discount - free advertisement on her social media platforms. This can potentially increase awareness of my work and reach a wider audience, thus possibly increasing sales in the future.\\n\\nEven though Jill's appreciation for our work in Scenario 1 is quite genuine, she does not explicitly offer anything in return for the discount. This could potentially harm the business if we get into the habit of offering discounts simply because customers ask. If it's known that prices are easily negotiated down, this could devalue our work in the eyes of future potential customers. \\n\\nFor these reasons, the offer of promotion in Scenario 2 is more appealing as a form of barter - reduced price for potential exposure.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios put forth requests for a discount, they offer different value in exchange. In Scenario 1, Jill compliments the artisan's work and states her support for local artisans, however, the value she provides in exchange for a discount is a little abstract. While a potential return customer is always good, it doesn't provide an immediate return on investment for the artisan. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only expresses her love for the vase but also offers a tangible return - promoting the artisan’s work on her social media channels. With this free advertising, the artisan potentially gets their work in front of a larger audience, which could result in increased sales. The discount given could be seen as an investment in marketing, which ultimately could lead to more income.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at the two scenarios, Jill presents a valid case for a discount in both; however, the dynamics are slightly different.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill appreciates the work, the craftsmanship, and even plans on supporting you as a local artisan multiple times in the future. She not only wishes to buy the vase but also shows willingness to be a regular patron. This suggests potential regular business and might even lend a word-of-mouth marketing advantage, which will be very beneficial in the long run. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also admires your work and wants to support local artisans. She is interested in the vase, though she is on a budget and requests a price reduction.\\n\\nBoth scenarios are pretty close, with Jill showing great admiration for your work. Nevertheless, the promise of potential regular business in scenario 1 tends to sound a bit more convincing and beneficial for you. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning text:\\nBoth scenarios offer compelling reasons for a potential discount. In Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase but also indicates her interest in becoming a regular customer, meaning that a discount may lead to greater profits in the long run through repeat purchases. In Scenario 2, Jill also acknowledges the quality of the work and her desire to support local artisans, which can be seen as a personal compliment to the artisan. However, the promise of future patronage and the willingness to buy multiple items in Scenario 1 provides more concrete assurances of future sales, whereas Scenario 2 focuses more on immediate needs.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a persuasion standpoint, Jill presents a stronger case for a discount in Scenario 1. In this scene, Jill not only expresses admiration for the craft but also suggests future purchases and repeated patronage. A discount on this one object could translate into a long-term and loyal customer, potentially leading to more sales and word-of-mouth recommendations to other customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is complimentary and expresses a desire to support local artisans, but does not explicitly indicate she will make additional purchases in the future. She only mentions her personal budget constraint which doesn't benefit the seller as much as Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning text:\\nChoosing between the two scenarios depends on the context of each situation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1: Jill has expressed her admiration for the handcrafted vase and noticeably shows interest in supporting local artisans. She poses the idea of buying multiple items and suggests the possibility of being a returning customer in the future. This indicates that although she may be asking for a discount on the current piece, she is likely to generate greater sales revenue in the long run. Agreeing to negotiate the price or offering a modest discount as a token of appreciation for her support might incentivize her to make more purchases both immediately and in the future.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2: Jill has also shown an appreciation for the craft, but her request for a price reduction seems to be more focused on the current item rather than future purchases or multiple items. While she identifies herself as a \"supporter of local artisans\", there isn\\'t a direct indication of ongoing or future patronage. This scenario presents less potential for future return as compared to the first.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill in a good light as a customer who is supportive of local artisans and appreciates the craft. However, in both instances, she alludes to the possibility of a price reduction or discount. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions a future plan of shopping with you, indicating a desire to create a lasting relationship. She also suggests that she might be purchasing multiple items which could lead to higher overall income for you even if you give a discount on this particular item.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill only asks for a price reduction due to her budget constraints. She does not suggest the possibility of buying other items or becoming a repeat customer.\\n\\nTherefore, establishing a relationship with a potential repeat customer and increasing immediate sale volume could be a more attractive scenario for you as an artisan. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is genuinely interested in the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship involved. However, the first scenario indicates that Jill is planning on buying multiple items or coming back to shop in the future, thus increasing her potential value to me as a repeat customer.\\n\\nWhile Scenario 2 also shows Jill's admiration for the work and a willingness to support local artisans, it does not offer the additional potential of future sales. Therefore, I see more potential benefit in giving a discount in the first scenario, as the promise of repeat business could potentially offset the reduction in income from the vase and result in greater long-term profit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: In Scenario 1, Jill is expressing her admiration for the vase and is hinting at her tight budget. This appeals to my sympathy as an artisan and could make me consider reducing the price. However, she is not offering any additional value in return for a discount.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill again praises my work and admits to financial restrictions, but she also proposes to promote my work on her social media. This could potentially lead to more exposure and new customers for my business. In this scenario, Jill is not only asking for a discount due to her budget constraints but also offering a value-added proposition, making the request more balanced and appealing. Therefore, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 2.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present appealing cases, Scenario 2 would probably make me more inclined to negotiate on the price for a few reasons. \\n\\nFirstly, this customer not only expresses appreciation for the artistry involved, but they also offer a form of mutually beneficial transaction - advertising my work on their social media. This is a potential method of attracting new customers, and that could increase my revenue over the long term. It's an investment of sorts.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill expresses clear willingness to negotiate and doesn't demand or expect a discount. Her tone is respectful and courteous, which makes it more likely I'd be willing to compromise on the price, as it feels like a respectful interaction rather than a one-sided demand. \\n\\nTherefore, in this situation, considering both the upfront respect and potential for future business, Scenario 2 makes me more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill are quite compelling. The willingness to support local artisans is encouraging in both situations. However, there are differences in Jill's approach which could influence my decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is straightforward about her budget constraints and genuinely appreciates the craftsmanship, which is heartening. However, she does not provide any added value that could compensate the price reduction.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers additional value by promoting my wares to Jill's social media following. Providing a discount with the advantage of potentially gaining more exposure and customers seems a very plausible trade-off.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, I would lean more towards a negotiation in Scenario 2, thanks to the additional value proposition Jill offers. Although there's no guarantee that her social media sharing might result in more sales, the potential for extra marketing and exposure could outweigh the reduced earnings of a single sale. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer unique points of negotiation. In the first scenario, Jill is offering a promotion deal where she would expose my work to her social media following. This could potentially obtain more customers for me depending on how many followers she has and their interest in artisan crafts. \\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill is appealing more to emotion, promoting her interest in supporting local artisans, and expressing concern about her budget. This scenario doesn't necessarily provide a direct gain for me like the first scenario, but it does build goodwill and community rapport.\\n\\nIf I take Jill's word in scenario one and she indeed has a big following, it might be more profitable in the long run as potentially more buyers will learn about my works. This situation is like investing in promotion. \\n\\nHowever, if Jill only has a limited following and they are not interested in my works, then reducing the price of the vase doesn't offer me any real advantages. It isn't easy to predict social media influence outcomes and it's risky without any solid guarantees. \\n\\nIn contrast, the second scenario provides a guaranteed outcome: the vase is sold. Also, providing a discount to a local buyer who appreciates handmade crafts could contribute to loyal, returning customers. \\n\\nAccounting for these factors, I understand that both scenarios have implications for immediate sales and potential future profits.\\n\\nAnswer: Depending on the long-term viewpoint, I would lean more towards Scenario 1 if Jill has proved her substantial social media influence, which could bring more future business. However, if such an influence isn't present or guaranteed, I might prefer Scenario 2. In this case, I would appreciate Jill's honest approach and willingness to directly purchase my product.\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nBoth scenarios present compelling arguments for a price reduction, but they approach it from different angles. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the price is relatively high but shows her appreciation for handmade crafts and local artisans. She proposes a unique exchange - providing meaningful promotion and publicity for your work on her social media platforms in return for a discount on the vase. This could potentially open up new avenues for customer acquisition, leading to increased sales, which might offset the discount given to Jill. However, this option also includes a level of risk involved as the effectiveness of her promotion is not guaranteed.\\n\\nScenario 2 is more straightforward. Jill expresses her admiration for the vase and your craftmanship, highlights her support for local artisans and simply asks for a slight price reduction, citing budgetary constraints. However, this approach doesn't offer you any additional benefits beyond the sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\n\\nThe first scenario holds more potential for a wider range of benefits, making it a more appealing option overall despite the potential risks.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, Jill is expressing her appreciation for my craftsmanship and her desire to support local artisans. This appreciation is vital because it shows that she places value on my work. However, the approach she takes in each scenario is slightly different.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes to trade some promotion in return for a discount. This could potentially bring me more customers in the future, expanding my business and letting more people know about my handcrafted items. If Jill's social media following is sizable and relevant to my target audience, this deal could be beneficial for me. Yet, it might be hard to evaluate the real value of this promotion, and it's worth noting that her followers might expect discounts too, which could lower the perceived value of my work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill simply asks for a slight discount, citing her budget as the reason. This scenario is more straightforward but neither indicates the continuance of an ongoing relationship nor suggests any direct benefits for me.\\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios demonstrate Jill's desire to purchase the vase and her value of my craftsmanship, Scenario 1 provides an additional advantage of potentially promoting my business. However, the final decision would depend on the 'reach' of Jill's social media followers and the relevancy to my brand.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill indicates she values the vase and appreciates local craftsmen, which is a great start to bargaining. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appeals to the artisan's passion for their work and the local community, empathizing with them and suggesting she would be supportive of them even after the purchase. However, she doesn’t provide a tangible benefit to the artisan for reducing the price; she only indicates she can't afford to pay full price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again appreciates the vase and the artisan's work. But, she takes it a step further by offering to buy more items - a real, tangible benefit to the artisan - and also mentions that she is likely to be a repeat customer. Not only that, but she offers additional free publicity through her social media if a discount can be arranged. This provides potential of driving more customers to the artisan’s stall.\\n\\nThe addition of a potential bulk purchase, repeat business, and free advertising provide solid reasons for an artisan to consider reducing the price of the item. Hence, promising tangible benefits to the artisan is preferable to asking for a reduction due to a tight budget.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide compelling reasons for providing a discount. However, upon analyzing the factors presented in each scenario, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 2.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the customer essentially admits that they admire the quality of work and that they are a supporter of local artisans which is a positive. They also acknowledge that they are on a budget, signaling that they may be more price-sensitive. Offering a discount here might make them more inclined to make this purchase and possible future ones, which can enhance customer loyalty and increase sales in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, however, the customer also expresses admiration for the craftsmanship and offers a concrete proposition for a longer term relationship - that they intend to be a regular customer, and that they are interested in purchasing multiple items. These are both good for increasing overall sales. Further, marketing through word-of-mouth is traditionally considered to be an effective tool, and the offer to use their social media presence to promote the shop, potentially reaching thousands of others, is a substantial additional benefit that might even generate new customers. Although it's harder to quantify, this potential for growth and increased visibility can be a huge advantage for a small local business.\\n\\nBoth are good scenarios, but Scenario 2 provides more reasons for giving a discount, not only in the form of immediate sales and customer loyalty, but also potential marketing value.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill has clearly mentioned that she is interested in buying multiple items, which would result in increased sales for me. The prospect of a sale of multiple items presents a good opportunity for me to offer a discount on the price of the vase as part of a package deal.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill has mentioned that she is a returning customer and plans on shopping at my stall regularly, indicating her willingness to support my business long-term. This is appealing as a business owner because it means steadier income and a possible word-of-mouth promotion if she becomes a satisfied regular customer.\\n\\nThirdly, she’s offered to promote my work on social media which is a form of free advertising and could attract new customers or more business for me. The potential exposure from Jill’s promotion on social media could be beneficial, especially if Jill's followers align with my target audience demographic. \\n\\nConsidering all these reasons, Jill's proposition in Scenario 2 creates more opportunities for mutual benefit and so I would be more likely to negotiate with her.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is offering to promote my work to her network on social media. While this could potentially reach more customers and open up greater opportunities in the future, there is no guarantee. It's difficult to put a value on such a promise without knowing the size and demographics of Jill's audience, and the reach and quality of her promotion.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill is appealing to our shared values of supporting local artisans. She's admirative of my work and is directly expressing her will to contribute to the community. Plus, she's also expressing that she's on a budget. \\n\\nWhile there's more of an immediate certainty to the financial transaction in scenario 2, it is important to maintain goodwill with customers who may become repeat buyers or refer others. Also, acknowledging and respecting customers' budget limitations can foster a positive reputation for your business in the local community. It's also possible for a price reduction to encourage additional purchases, both in the immediate and in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers the promise of promotional considerations along with the purchase of the vase. There is potential value in having my work seen and praised by a wider audience, particularly if Jill indeed has a following that appreciates artisan crafts. This could potentially bring in more customers and boost my overall sales in the future. It's sort of an investment that could reap further rewards.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill simply asks for a price reduction based on budgetary constraints. While it is wonderful to see customers who support local artisans, there's no additional potential value to be gained from the transaction beyond the actual sale. Moreover, if I negotiate prices for customers who claim to be on a budget, others might expect the same, and it might undervalue my work. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1. \\n\\nThe opportunity to reach a larger audience through Jill's promotion is of bigger potential value here. Moreover, in this case, the discount can be justified as a business expense for marketing purposes.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn evaluating both scenarios, the two main differences are Jill's potential bargaining chips: her social media influence in Scenario 1, and her limited budget in Scenario 2. Based on the eventual benefits to my business, it leads me to favor Scenario 1.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work to her network of followers on social media. This can potentially bring more attention to my items and potentially result in an increase in sales. Therefore, it has a direct and tangible benefit to my business in terms of marketing and increased visibility. This is a powerful bargaining chip if she indeed has a large following that aligns with the target market for my handcrafted items.\\n\\nOn the other hand in Scenario 2, Jill appeals to her limited budget and admiration for my work. Although this appeal to empathy is compelling, it does not provide a concrete benefit to my business.\\n\\nTherefore, my long-term business interests would guide me to prefer a bargain that has the potential to boost my brand visibility and sales over a one-time sales discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill lauds the craftsmanship of the vase and acknowledges its value, mentioning that she's a supporter of local artisans. However, she simply asks for a discount based on her current budget constraints.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill not only appreciates the vase and the quality of the craftsmanship, but she also provides a value proposition in return for a discount: promoting the artisan and his work on her social media platforms, potentially leading to more customers.\\n\\nIdeally, negotiation should not be a zero-sum game but rather an interaction where both parties gain something. Therefore, despite understanding the potential budget constraints of a customer, as a business owner, I must ensure that my business also benefits from any discounts offered. \\n\\nSelling crafts at a local market doesn't just require material costs, it also encompasses time, skills, artistic efforts, and underlying expenses—so each sale's margin matters. If Jill can help bring additional customers to me, that means more potential sales—not just for this vase, but for other items as well. In the long run, this can outweigh the one-time discount given to Jill. Hence, offering a discount in scenario 2 would seem a reasonable business decision.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing interest in the vase and is asking for a discount politely. However, the contexts provide different potential benefits. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is just asking for a discount because she is on a budget. While it's sympathetic and vendors at a local market are often willing to negotiate prices, there isn't a direct benefit for me other than her immediate purchase. If I negotiate the price for Jill, I might have to do the same with other customers, which could reduce my overall revenue.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers an interesting proposal. Apart from buying the vase, she proposes to promote my products on her social media platforms, potentially directing more customers to my stall. If she has a good following, this could be a great opportunity to reach a larger audience without any extra marketing effort or cost from my side. Bigger customer flow could mean more sales, and more sales could outweigh the discount given to Jill.\\n\\nSo, taking into consideration the added benefit of a potential publicity, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present their own unique proposals, in terms of potential return on investment, I myself as an artisan, would likely be more enticed by Jill's offer in Scenario 2. Here's my reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the customer, Jill, is appreciative of the craftsmanship and wants to support the local artisan community, but is looking for a reduction in price due to her budget. While this scenario can certainly appeal to the empathetic side of a seller, especially if the customer is a regular or intends to make future purchases, it also poses a risk given the lack of concrete incentive for offering a discount.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 provides a clearer and potentially more beneficial exchange. Jill still expresses admiration for the artisan's work but in this case, she offers something tangible in return - publicity and advertisement. In today's digital age, social media promotion can be incredibly beneficial for small artisans. If Jill has a substantial following, her post could effectively advertise the artisan's work to a significantly larger audience than the local market, potentially bringing in more customers and therefore more revenue in the future.\\n\\nWhile there's no guarantee that this will result in an immediate or considerable uptick in sales, the increased visibility and potential long-term benefits make Scenario 2 a more attractive option for negotiating the price of the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.0 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer valid reasons as to why Jill would like to negotiate the price of the vase. In Scenario 1, Jill makes her admiration for the work clear, expresses her support for local artisans and mentions her budget constraints. This approach relies on the goodwill of the artisan and their potential desire to make their products more accessible to those who appreciate craft.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers more of a value deal for the artisan. In this scenario, Jill again compliments the work and acknowledges the fairness of the price. However, she then proposes a trade-off – a discount in exchange for promotion on her active social media accounts. This could potentially expose the artisan's work to a whole new audience that could generate future sales.\\n\\nBased on these considerations, the artisan might be more swayed by the offer in Scenario 2. The potential high-impact visibility and promotional value Jill offers can be seen as a form of bartering, where both Jill and the artisan gain something valuable. Furthermore, this approach implies a longer-term investment in the artisan's work, as opposed to a one-off purchase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill's appeal is based solely on the assertion that she's on a budget, and while she admires the work, she doesn't offer any additional incentive for me to reduce the price. However, she does show an appreciation for the community and the work, which is encouraging, but she isn't giving a clear or substantial benefit to me as a seller to offer a reduced price. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in the second scenario, Jill not only appreciates the work, but she's also offering something in return to offset the discount she's asking for. She promises to promote the work on her social media profiles, potentially increasing local interest in my craft and possibly drawing in more customers in the future. This added visibility and potential increase in sales can make up for the reduction in price she's asking for. Even if she's asking for just as much of a discount as in the first scenario, she's offering something in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill appreciates the work and displays a genuine interest in the vase. However, in Scenario 2, Jill offers an additional value wherein she proposes to promote the artisan's work on her social media accounts. This could mean increased visibility and possibly more customers for the artisan's work in the future. A discount on the price of the vase could therefore turn out to be a small investment in marketing. Thus, the artisan might see this as an opportunity not just to sell a piece, but also to expand their customer base and even earn more in the future. Hence, the artisan could probably be more willing to negotiate in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.7 6.6\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[Reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios indicate Jill's interest in the vase and her intention to negotiate the price. However, while both present a certain charm and respect for artisan work, Scenario 1 offers something in return for the price negotiation. Jill mentions returning to the market in the future, potentially buying multiple items, and becoming a regular patron. This could mean more sales for me in the future, suggesting a good business relationship. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill only mentions her admiration and need to stretch her budget, offering no additional incentive for me to lower the vase's price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen considering these two scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1. There are a few reasons for my choice. Firstly, Jill has appreciated my work, which reflects her genuine interest, and it helps in building rapport. Secondly, she has expressed her intention of becoming a regular customer and also purchasing multiple items in future visits. By showing this interest in ongoing business, Jill is sharing her willingness not only to engage with my work in the short term, but also potentially comprise a steady stream of income in the long term. This presents an opportunity for me to build a loyal customer base that all businesses desire and require, especially local artisans.\\n\\nThe fact that she asked about discounts for multiple items or returning customers suggests she is interested in multiple items and thus a larger sale or future repeated sales, which is always a good sign. She has also shown respect for my craft and understanding of value, yet explaining her situation in a very polite way.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill does express her love for the vase and appreciation of my work as well as her intention to stretch her budget, she does not express the same level of ongoing commitment as in scenario 1. There's no mention of her becoming a regular patron or making future purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill is trying to build a long-term relationship with the artisan. She has mentioned that she is planning to come back to the market in the future and is interested in being a regular customer. This potentially means more sales and more business in the future, which is beneficial for the artisan. Also, she is recognizing and appreciating the artisan's work, which not just shows respect but also validates the artisan's efforts. This naturally makes the artisan more inclined to offer a discount. \\n\\nThe second scenario too presents a sincere customer, but Jill's negotiation seems more one-sided, concerning just one purchase. While she too is appreciating the artisan's work, she is not suggesting a future relationship or repeat business.\\n\\nTherefore, one would be more likely to negotiate with someone who is offering long-term business and understanding the effort put into the work.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.7 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: Both scenarios present a negotiation opportunity, but the discerning factor lies in Jill's approach and comportment. In scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the vase and craftsmanship but also expresses her interest in returning for future purchases and buying multiple items. This suggests a likely repeat customer who values the work and is potentially beneficial in the long run. In scenario 2, Jill also displays appreciation for the vase and local craftsmanship but doesn't exhibit the same promise for future interactions or purchasing multiple items. Her approach solely centers on getting a discount on a single item.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'In both scenarios, Jill expresses interest in the vase and the desire to support local artisans. However, her approach is slightly different in each situation. \\n\\nScenario 1: Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her intent to return in the future to shop more. Furthermore, she mentions the possibility of buying multiple items at once which will increase my sales for that specific instance, and her suggestion for future returning customers might attract more business. However, she has not explicitly asked for a discount on this specific vase but rather proposed a discount scheme for multiple items or returning customers.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill aligns her kindness with her intent to negotiate the price of the vase. She openly mentions her budget constraint and directly proposes a discussion concerning a price reduction, equating her respect and admiration for the artisanal work with the price negotiation.\\n\\nWhen considering the negotiation process, honesty and transparency play a crucial role. Although the approach in the first scenario is more general and adding a long-term perspective, it lacks a direct appeal for a negotiation on the current item of interest, i.e., the vase. Jill in the second scenario goes straight to the point by openly discussing her budget constraint and interest in negotiating the price of the vase. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\nThis is because it encourages a more immediate interaction between the customer and the seller. It promotes a straightforward negotiation process for the vase, and as a seller, I might be more inclined to negotiate since she showed her honest interest and appreciation for the artisanal work, which is a positive reinforcement for me as an artisan.', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nJill's approach in both scenarios shows her appreciation for local craftsmanship and an intent to support it. However, in scenario 1, she introduces the possibility of purchasing multiple items now or in the future. This promise of potential additional sales now or the likelihood of her becoming a returning customer in the future makes scenario 1 more appealing. Offering a discount here can establish a good relationship with the customer, ensuring not just a single sale, but potentially multiple sales over time. This would ultimately result in more overall profit even if a small discount is offered.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill's approach mainly discusses her budget constraints and a desire for a negotiation on the price of a single item. This only promises a one-time sale as opposed to the assurance of potential multiple sales or future business in scenario 1. Therefore, the incentive to give a discount in scenario 2 is less appealing as it doesn't promise additional future profit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.7 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile it's true that both scenarios Jill presents are compelling reasons to negotiate the price of the vase, they offer starkly different propositions in terms of value proposition and immediate profitability. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appeals to the common practice of bargaining at local markets and highlights her appreciation for local artisans, which is definitely flattering and persuasive. This approach would often be effective in market settings where haggling is commonplace and mutual understanding and appreciation can lead to a discount.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill puts forth a more enticing offer. She goes beyond haggling for a lower price and proposes a strategic partnership where she can leverage her social media following to promote the artisan's work. This could lead to increased visibility, impact future sales positively and create potential new customers for the artisan. The idea of this wider exposure can be appealing, especially for an artisan who wants to promote their work, and could be seen as an investment for future gain.\\n\\nHence, while immediately monetary gain may be less, the overall benefit is more in Scenario 2. Therefore,\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present a potentially beneficial situation for me as an artisan, scenario 2 provides an additional opportunity beyond the immediate sale. Jill not only shows interest in supporting local work, similar to scenario 1, but she also offers a possibility of promoting my work on her social media platforms. This kind of marketing is valuable given the reach and influence of social media today. Even though she's asking for a discount, she's presenting a way she could provide value back to me and my business. This doesn't mean I would give her a large discount, but discussing a smaller one in exchange for promotion could ultimately lead to more business exposure and potentially more sales in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill appeals to an emotional aspect by stating her desire to support local artists, which makes this scenario a strong contender for negotiation. She is open about her budget constraints, which could potentially resonate with a small business artisan who might sympathize with her circumstances. However, she does not offer anything concrete in return for a potential price reduction.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill not only values the artist's work and acknowledges its uniqueness, but she also offers a tangible incentive for the artisan to negotiate the price. Her proposal to promote the artwork to her large social media following could expose the artisan to a wider audience, potentially bringing in new customers and boosting sales. This kind of publicity is particularly valuable for local markets where the power of word-of-mouth recommendations can significantly influence business success.\\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios represent a desire for negotiation, the second scenario provides an immediate value proposition for the artisan beyond the immediate sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.7 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is showing interest in supporting your business in the long-term by planning to return and buy more items in the future. Also, she expressed the wish to buy more than one item at the moment, which could boost your immediate sales. Given these factors, it might be beneficial to provide a discount as it may cultivate a long-term relationship and prompt her to purchase more items, perhaps spending beyond the original $30 she may have intended to spend. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is indicating that she is price-sensitive at the moment due to her budget. Nevertheless, she communicates her admiration for your work and respects that it should be compensated. While it's kind of her to express these feelings, this scenario presents a situation where she might only be willing or able to pay less than the asked price for the vase, likely resulting in less revenue compared to the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is expressing interest in purchasing multiple items and also indicating her potential return as a customer. This earns her goodwill and makes a price negotiation more appealing to an artisan like me, given that she could potentially provide continuous support to my local business and contribute to more sales in the future.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is also supportive of my work and appreciates the uniqueness but, her interest primarily seems to be centered around the vase. Her negotiation on price seems to be a one-time request based solely on budget constraints rather than an ongoing relationship or potentially bigger sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has shown genuine interest in purchasing and has acknowledged the craft and artistry included in creating the item. However, the key factor would be her future loyalty and potential for continued business as shown in Scenario 1. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions the possibility of buying more items in that instance itself and also hints on being a repeat customer in future. This likely means that over time, she'll buy more items, bringing consistent business and also increasing the chance of word-of-mouth advertising which is a crucial aspect of running a local business. Offering a discount in this scenario creates potential not only for a single sale, but to foster a client relationship that could yield more in the long run.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill compliments the work and mentions her interest in supporting local artisans, her expression about stretching her budget indicates she might not be a frequent customer or buy other items, and the assurance of further business from her is relatively low.\\n\\nTherefore, though both scenarios present grounds for a possible negotiation, as a local artisan whose income might depend significantly on repeat customers and referred customers, I would be more persuaded by the potential for future business presented in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.7 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nEvery customer values sincerity and a relatable stance. Both scenarios have Jill expressing appreciation for the craftsmanship, which in itself can predispose an artisan to be more open to negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill presents a reason for asking for a discount that is very common and relatable - stretching her own personal budget. This can resonate with the artisan as it is a situation we all find ourselves in from time to time. Jill also flatters the artisan's work and supports local craft which might appeal to the artisan's desire for recognition and support.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is also positive about the work but offers an alternative form of payment in the form of exposure. The willingness to bargain with multiple purchases is a good tactic, however, promising exposure for a discount is not as direct as paying less money - results could vary greatly and it's a bit riskier for the artisan. Not all artisans may be convinced by the promise of social media promotion, especially without concrete numbers and potential reach.\\n\\nGiven these situations, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1 due to its more relatable and sincere approach. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision to negotiate would depend on several factors. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is being honest about her budget constraints and she clearly expresses an appreciation for the handcrafted items which creates a personal connection. However, she does not offer anything in return except for a potential implication of goodwill and future patronage. This type of negotiation relies only on sympathy and the goodwill of the artisan.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill does not only compliment the craftsmanship of the vase but also offers something in return: Publicity for the artisan's business through her social media followers and the idea of purchasing more items, which means more business in the future. These elements add value to the negotiation that transcends beyond the present transaction making it a win-win situation for both parties. The artisan can attract more business in the future and Jill gets the vase at a possibly discounted price. \\n\\nSo, whilst both scenarios have their own merits, scenario 2 offers more potential long-term benefits for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios could comfortably open a negotiation dialog regarding the price of the vase, but I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in scenario 2. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill already expresses her admiration and willingness to support local artisans. This indicates that she understands the value of unique, handcrafted items and appears flexible in discussing the price. However, Jill's approach is simply based on her personal effort to stretch her budget.\\n\\nIn contrast, scenario 2 presents me with a more tangible value proposition. Jill plans to be a returning customer and expresses interest in multiple items, which could immediately increase my sales. Furthermore, Jill offers to promote my crafts to her sizable social media following. If she follows through, this can potentially bring other customers to my stall and influence them to purchase my crafts, expanding overall sales overtime more than the price reduction on one item. \\n\\nFor these reasons, Jill's negotiation in scenario 2 offers a more reciprocally beneficial arrangement, making it more appealing for me as a seller.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.7 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present good opportunities for negotiation, but they appeal to different incentives. In Scenario 1, Jill is appealing to my empathy and willingness to support a customer who acknowledges and appreciates the uniqueness of my work. In Scenario 2, Jill is essentially offering a business deal where she offers to promote my work to her large social media following in exchange for a discount. \\n\\nHowever, there are uncertainties in Scenario 2. For instance, there's no guarantee that Jill's followers would convert into sales, or that the exposure she offers on her social media platform would reach my target audience. Additionally, her offer does not have immediate benefit for me, while a sale does.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 1, while Jill is negotiating, she acknowledges the worth of the product and communicates that she values it. This scenario seems to have less downside for me and I can immediately benefit from selling an item, which is my primary goal at the market. Moreover, having satisfied customers may also lead to good word-of-mouth promotion, more sustainable and trusted than a social media shout-out.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nConsidering the two scenarios, both of them show interest from Jill in purchasing the flower vase, however, there are different conditions tied to the price negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill simply asks for a price reduction due to her budget. While empathetic to her budget concerns, there doesn't appear to be any additional value being brought by offering this discount, other than the immediate sale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is offering to promote the work on her social media platforms, which could potentially bring in more customers to buy products, thus potentially increasing revenue in the long run. Not only would an immediate sale be made, but it might result in multiple future sales driven by the social media promotion. This cross-promotion could be especially beneficial if Jill indeed has a significant social media following. This may bring in far more revenue even with a discounted sale to her now. \\n\\nDue to this consideration, it would seem more advantageous to negotiate in the second scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", 'Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing appreciation for the handcrafted flower vase, which establishes an initial emotional and mental connection. This is important for both a potential sale and any price negotiations. \\n\\nScenario 1 is where Jill is straightforward in asking for a price reduction due to her budget. This scenario doesn\\'t offer any immediate benefits to me as the seller, except for a potential sale if we agree on a price reduction. \\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, not only shows Jill\\'s interest but also presents a direct proposal for a mutual benefit. She proposes to advertise my craft on her social media account, which she says has a \"considerable following\". If this is true, then the exposure could potentially bring more customers to my stall, increasing the visibility and sales of my handcrafted items. Even if the discount will reduce the immediate income from this sale, the overall gain from the increased exposure and potential new customers could outweigh this loss.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 7.2\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a sales perspective, both scenarios have their strengths. Jill compliments my work and expresses her interest in the vase in both cases. However, the decision to negotiate the price can be argued differently depending on what kind of customer I want to attract and which aspects I prioritize more.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only conveys her admiration of my craftsmanship but also her support toward local artisans. She also speaks about making consistent future purchases, which could guarantee a regular income and support for my business. Her approach is more personal and implies a long-term customer relationship which could bring more value beyond a single sale. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also compliments my work and expresses an interest in supporting local businesses. She also mentions the possibility of returning to shop in the future. Her language is less personalized, and apart from mentioning her budget constraints, she doesn't elaborate on her potential future support as convincingly as in Scenario 1. However, providing her a discount could certainly improve the chances of her returning.\\n\\nGiven these factors, I'd be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. The potential assurance of a longer-term customer relationship and Jill's expressed interest in supporting local artisans consistently holds more value to me than a single transaction and gives me a stronger reason to make a compromise on the marked price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show Jill appreciating the artisan's work and expressing her intent to support local craftsmanship. However, the emphasis varies in both accounts. In Scenario 1, Jill communicates her keen interest in the vase more eloquently. She goes ahead to affirm her future patronage and her inclination toward supporting the artisan's endeavors. She tactfully presents her budgetary constraint and justifies her request for a discount by propping up the prospect of future purchases and her likelihood to be a regular customer.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses similar sentiments, but her request for a discount seems more rooted in her current budget constraint rather than a guaranteed future patronage. She doesn't sound as convincing about her return to the market for more items in the future. \\n\\nGiven this, it is in the artisan's best interest to negotiate more favorably with a potential regular customer who shows a deep appreciation for the craftsmanship and promises future purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text: \\nBoth scenarios are similar in nature, appealing towards an artist's desire for appreciation of their work and a promise of potential returning customers. However, considering the nuances, I would lean more towards negotiating in Scenario 1. This is mainly because Jill not only praised my craftsmanship but also expressed her willingness to be a regular patron and support my work. It suggests a sincere interest in the continuation of my craft and implies a long-term customer relationship, which is beneficial for sustaining my business. This would outweigh the initial compromise I might make in the sale of the flower vase. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0.5, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Both scenarios almost communicate the same thing as both state the customer\\'s interest in the item, their willingness to support local crafts, their intent to purchase more in the future, and their concern about the price. They indicate that Jill is likely to come back and buy more products. Both are sound and respectful negotiation tactics where the customer is not merely haggling, but proposing further business prospects.\\n\\nHowever, I would lean a bit towards Scenario 1 for the following reasons:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the artisan work directly, calling it \"remarkable,\" and showing a deeper appreciation and recognition for the work, which builds a cordial and receptive atmosphere for negotiation. Moreover, Jill\\'s commitment to supporting local artisans feels more genuine and sincere here, which might motivate the artisan to take a bit off the price to maintain good business relations with a potential regular customer.\\n\\nFurther, the tone used by Jill in Scenario 1 feels more casual and personal, suggesting a longer-term and more thorough engagement with the artisan\\'s work, which might tip the artisan to negotiate the price as a gesture of good faith and building a good customer relationship. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill offers a compelling argument for obtaining a discount. She expresses clear interest in the vase and the potential for further purchases in the future. However, the selection between Scenario 1 and 2 would largely depend on the artisan's perspectives towards sales and customer relationships.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill uses a more personal approach. She compliments the artisan's work, shows understanding and appreciates the value of handmade items. She also mentions supporting local artisans which could resonate on an emotional level with the artisan. The artisan may feel more valued and genuinely appreciated for their hard work and efforts in this case.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill takes a more transactional approach. While she still compliments the artisan's work, it feels more like a business negotiation than a personal connection. Her tone is more of a regular shopper aiming at getting a deal.\\n\\nIn conclusion, if the artisan values personal connections and encouraging supportive customers, he or she might be more inclined to offer a discount in Scenario 1. However, if the artisan views the interaction as a conventional business transaction and values negotiation techniques, he or she might prefer Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: It's subjective and would depend on the artisan's perspective.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a customer who is considerate and thoughtful about her purchases, as well as responsible and cautious with money. Despite there being a slight price objection, Jill is expressing it in a respectful and polite manner, and she is not pressing for a discount straightforwardly. She supplicates for a potential future favorable arrangement, which implies her interest to make regular purchases and support my work as a local artisan. This can indeed be beneficial for a business like mine.\\n\\nHowever, the risk of future promises isn't always secure. It's possible she might not stick around as a regular customer, and even if she does, it might not compensate for the initial discounted purchase. Therefore, I'd have to be careful about reducing the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly acknowledges the craftsmanship of my work and the importance of supporting local artisans, specifically stating her intent to be a regular customer and support my craft. This admiration for the artisan's work and encouragement of local support seems earnest and may be even more encouraging for the artisan (me in this case) to negotiate on the vase's price.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 also presents Jill as a prospective loyal customer, but she uses the term 'unique pieces' to describe the vase and doesn't acknowledge the craftsmanship or the work that goes into these as much as Jill in Scenario 1 does. This could potentially mean she's just interested in the aesthetic rather than the underlying craftsmanship that makes each piece special.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn conclusion, I'd possibly give more consideration to negotiating the price or offering a discount in Scenario 1. A customer's recognition and understanding of my hard work, paired with the intention of long-term support, would make me lean towards Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text] \\n\\nBoth scenarios present valuable proposals, however, my inclination would be towards scenario 1. My reasoning is as follows:\\n\\n1. Long Term Benefit: Jill has mentioned her intention of becoming a regular customer. While a purchase today might result in less profit, her frequent purchases over time could make up for the initial loss.\\n\\n2. Multiple Purchases: Jill has also proposed a discount for multiple purchases in the future. This instantaneously increases the potential sales quantity; therefore, it would be in one's best business interest to negotiate.\\n\\n3. Sustainable Customer Relationship: By giving a concession to a regular customer, an artisan can build a strong and sustainable relationship. This is much more beneficial as compared to an unpredictable stream of strangers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nWhile discounts in exchange for promotion can indeed be a beneficial trade, there are aspects in Scenario 2 that could create potential concerns. Jill's promises of promotion could bring more awareness to the crafts, but there's also a degree of uncertainty as to the actual benefits they may or may not bring.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 1, Jill seems genuinely interested in supporting local arts and crafts. She appeals to the potential of becoming a regular customer and shows intent on buying other products in the future. This could increase the likelihood of creating a loyal customer who might provide steady business. This consistent support could bring in more revenue over time, making the concession of a small discount a potentially advantageous investment. \\n\\nMoreover, offering discounts for multiple item purchases may not even significantly reduce the overall price of an individual item, given that the total purchase is likely to be greater.\\n\\nSo, although both scenarios have merits, Scenario 1 involves a more tangible offer compared to uncertainty of the social media promotion in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: Considerations here include Jill's appreciation of the work, her willingness to support the artisans in the long run, how well she can attract new customers, and her specific proposal for a discount. In both scenarios, Jill is respectful and acknowledges the effort and craftsmanship behind the product. In scenario 1, she expresses a clear intention to return to the market and support the artisan as a regular customer, proposing a discount for multiple purchases or returning customers. In scenario 2, she doesn't guarantee future purchases but offers to promote the crafts on her social media platforms for a discount.\\n\\nDue to the following reasons, I'd be more likely to accommodate Jill's request in scenario 2: First, the artisan's work could gain exposure to a large number of potential customers through Jill's social media platforms, which could significantly benefit their business in the long run. Second, while Jill's two proposals in scenario 1 do express her intention to return and support the business, they lack the immediacy and concreteness of her offer in scenario 2. Lastly, even though scenario 2 doesn't ensure future purchases from Jill, the potential increase in sales from her promotion might outweigh the risk.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, the customer, Jill, appreciates the craftsman's work and shows a willingness to support local artists.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill offers value in the form of exposure through her large social media following. The artisan might see this as an opportunity to market their work to a broader audience, which could potentially result in more customers and sales. This sort of mutual benefit could make this offer more appealing.\\n\\nScenario 2 has Jill promising to become a repeat customer and inquiring about discounts for future multiple purchases. While this scenario does involve potentially consistent future revenue, there is uncertainty involved. Jill's future purchases depend on whether she decides to return and whether she would choose to buy anything if she does.\\n\\nTherefore, from my perspective as an artisan looking to grow my customer base and increase my brand visibility, I would choose Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill is offering to promote the artisan's craft on her social media platform, which could benefit the artisan by reaching a wider audience or potential customers that they may not have previously reached. While Jill's reach is not quantified explicitly, her proposal could result in more sales for the artisan.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill is suggesting the possibility of being a returning customer. However, this is uncertain as Jill is not committing to any future purchase. It only suggests a possible discount on this purchase in hopes for future purchases.\\n\\nBoth scenarios have its own strengths, but considering immediate benefits and certain future potential benefits, the first scenario could be more beneficial to the artisan. Jill's promotion of the artisan's work on her social media platforms could result in a higher overall profit in the long run if it leads to more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nWhile both scenarios offer the prospect of a further relationship with Jill, they are based on different conditions. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to use her relatively unknown social media influence to advertise the artisan's work. Without a track record or upfront proof, it's risky to bet on this having a significant impact on the artisan's business.\\n\\nScenario 2 is more enticing to negotiate the price as Jill is suggesting the possibility of herself becoming a returning customer who will make multiple purchases. This introduces a steady income stream and a higher lifetime value compared to a one-time purchase. Furthermore, offering a small discount now could lead to larger profits down the road, making scenario 2 more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present desirable situations for a local artisan like myself, as they not only involve immediate potential sales but also the opportunity to cultivate a loyal customer relationship. However, there are some notable differences between the two customers' approaches which might influence my willingness to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill communicates a precise appreciation for my craftsmanship, suggesting she understands the value and effort that goes into each piece and is therefore more inclined to pay a fair price. She also expresses a genuine interest in supporting local artisans and hints at future purchases. She presents her budget issue empathetically and professionally, not asking directly for a discount on the vase but inquiring about possible discounts on future purchases. She makes it clear that her interest lies in creating an on-going relationship and supporting my business in the long-term, reinforcing her value as a repeat customer. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses appreciation for my work and an interest in supporting local artisans. Yet unlike the first scenario, she directly asks for a discount on her potential current purchase, which may indicate more of a focus on saving money than on appreciating the product or forming an ongoing relationship.\\n\\nBoth customers could bring value to my business and it's understandable that people want to get the best possible deal. However, the prospect of a loyal, appreciative customer who understands the value of my work and has intentions for potential future purchases seems slightly more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and expresses interest in the vase as well as possibly buying multiple items in the future. This implies she would be a supportive and repeat customer. However, in Scenario 1, besides expressing her interest and appreciation, she also empathetically explains her financial situation and associates this purchase with her upcoming visit, giving me the impression of a guaranteed future sale. \\n\\nScenario 2 seems a little less personal, still appreciative but without the additional insight into Jill's situation. The promise of returning isn't as concrete as in the first scenario. So, while I would entertain negotiation in both scenarios, in the first one, I feel Jill has made a better case. \\n\\nTherefore, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn choosing between both scenarios, I'd be more willing to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. Jill addresses the issue with a lot of diplomacy and compliments, highlighting not only her admiration for my work but also her commitment to supporting local artisans. She posits her request in the form of an inquiry about discounts for multiple item purchases and for returning customers, which indicates her desire for a long-term relationship beyond a one-time purchase. Furthermore, her approach is respectful, and it sounds as though she truly values the craftsmanship behind my work, which would make me more inclined to consider her request. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill's approach in both scenarios suggests a potential long-term customer who is interested in supporting the local craft. However, the difference emerges in the manner they convey their intention.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill starts with complimenting the work, acknowledging the craftsmanship, and expresses her belief in supporting local artisans. This appreciation and recognition of my work set a positive tone. It shows sincerity and respect for my effort, implying that she values the items beyond simply their physical attributes. She further strikes a balance between her desire to purchase and her budget constraints delicately.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill shows interest in the vase and suggests she may return for more purchases, her approach is more direct and less personal. She dives straight into seeking a discount, without the prior dialogue and backdrop that scenario 1 provides.\\n\\nConsidering this, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1. Jill's approach in this scenario not only reflects a genuine appreciation for my effort but also a potential repeat customer who is considerate of the artisan's perspective.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 for several reasons. \\n\\nFirst, Jill begins by acknowledging and appreciating the craftsmanship that goes into the making of the vase, showing her support for the artisan's work. This appreciation increases the chances of a negotiation as it taps into the pride and recognition of the artisan's hard work. \\n\\nSecond, Jill presents herself as a potential regular customer who is planning on making multiple purchases in the future. The prospect of a long-term customer can be more beneficial financially for the artisan, even if it means reducing the price a little in the short-term. As a vendor, it's usually advantageous to have returning customers who also act as word-of-mouth advertisers for the business.\\n\\nThird, Jill makes it clear that she has budget constraints, but she presents it in a very respectful manner by not devaluing the item, hence not offending the artisan. Her sincerity may encourage the artisan to offer her a discount.\\n\\nOn the other hand, while Scenario 2 also presents a similar situation, the customer doesn't show as much appreciation or make a connection on a personal level with the artisan. It seems more transactional and less personable than Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is subtly requesting for a discount on the vase she admires. However, she presents her request differently in both contexts. In scenario 1, Jill not only conveyed her admiration for the vase but also for the entire body of work showcased by the artisan. She complimented the artisan's work and expressed her interest in becoming a regular customer. By indicating her support for local crafts, she presented herself as someone who understands the value and effort put into the work. She also hints that while she finds the vase a bit pricey, she's considering future purchases and essentially asking for a long-term relationship with a potential for more profitable interactions. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill does mention she will be a regular customer and will make multiple purchases in the future, she directly asks for a discount in a more impersonal way. There is less warmth or connection in her words when compared to scenario 1. \\n\\nBased on the approach used in each scenario, Scenario 1 is more likely to make the artisan feel truly appreciated, hence they may be more willing to negotiate the price. This is because in this scenario, Jill is not just asking for a discount but also establishing a relationship by expressing her future plans to continue supporting the artisan. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the process of negotiation, Jill's attitudes, words, and potential influence matter. Both scenarios have their appeal but come up with different approaches. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses appreciation for the artisan’s work and the value of supporting local artisans. She introduces her plan to be a regular customer which implies future purchases. This is appealing for a seller as it suggests a potential long-term relationship with the customer. The indication of future sales can also assure the value of offering a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the craftsmanship but offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media account, proposing that this could help the artisan reach a wider audience. Though this publicity could potentially boost clientele, it also depends on the followers Jill possesses, their demographics, and if they align with the target consumer base.\\n\\nConsidering all aspects, Scenario 1 seems more reliable as Scenario 2 comes with variables (the effectiveness of social media promotion also depends on many factors). But it should be noted that Scenario 2 could also be beneficial with the condition that the social media promotion is aligned with the artisan's clientele. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill makes it clear that she enjoys my work and is likely to become a returning customer. However, there are key differences between the two situations that impact my decision on whether or not to negotiate the pricing.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill presents a sincere appreciation for local artisans and crafts. She also conveys that she genuinely plans to purchase more handcrafted items in the future, which assures me of potential regular sales. The likelihood of sustained, recurring business is a strong motivating factor in considering a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill offers a potential marketing opportunity through her social media following, it can be risky. The reach and impact of her social media posts are uncertain. There's also no guarantee that her followers will be interested in my products or whether they're even local to the area. Not to mention that one viral post about a discount could potentially lead to unplanned price expectations from other customers.\\n\\nIn conclusion, while both scenarios offer some form of value proposition, I would likely be more inclined to negotiate based upon the promise of repeat business, as it offers a more tangibly beneficial return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn these scenarios, both Jill's present strong reasons for asking for a discount on the vase; however, taking each one into account, the argument made by Jill in Scenario 2 seems more beneficial to me as a seller.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill appeals on emotional grounds, stating her intent of being a regular customer along with appreciation for my craftsmanship. However, while I do value loyal customers, the promise of future patronage is uncertain and doesn't guarantee any immediate benefit.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers an immediate and tangible benefit. Not only does Jill show intent to make multiple purchases, she also offers to promote my products on her social media which could potentially increase my exposure to new customers, thereby providing additional sales apart from the sale being negotiated. \\n\\nWhile both Jill's offer value in their own ways, I would be more likely to negotiate with Jill from Scenario 2 due to the added bonus of potential social media exposure, which can lead to an increase in sales and business growth. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nWith scenario 1, Jill directly puts forth a possible equivalent exchange, which could potentially increase my sales by accessing her sizable following on social media. While she's asking for a discount, the value that I might obtain from this social media promotion could far exceed the cost of reducing the price of the flower vase. It's essentially a trade-off between short-term profit and possible long-term gains based on the publicity she could provide.\\n\\nIn contrast, scenario 2 has Jill simply asking for a discount with the promise of being a returning customer. While I appreciate her compliments on my work, the promise of repeat business doesn't quite match the tangibility of social media promotion, particularly if she chooses not to return or doesn't buy as frequently as she suggests.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere are a few factors to consider in these two scenarios. In both, Jill expresses her appreciation of my work and has an intention to return, which is promising for future sales and engagement. However, there are differences in the two scenarios that could potentially impact my decision. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes to promote my work on her substantial social media platforms in return for a discount. This could potentially lead to increased sales or visibility, and could therefore be seen as a form of indirect payment or advertising. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses the same willingness to return, but without the added boost of a social media shoutout. However, her honesty about her budget limitations may also provide room for negotiation. \\n\\nOverall, I would align more with Scenario 1 as it offers the potential for increased exposure and sales through her social media promotion. This could reach many more potential customers and could provide a more substantial return on the potential investment of a discount on the vase. It's always good to expand my customer base and Jill is not just buying a vase, but giving me the opportunity to reach more customers through her promotion.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text: \\n\\nWhile both scenarios present compelling arguments for a possible discount, Scenario 1 offers a potential benefit to me beyond the immediate transaction with Jill. Yes, in Scenario 2, she mentions becoming a regular customer, which is excellent for a basis for loyal customer base. The benefit though, in this case, isn't as immediate. The customer might or might not come back, or buy multiple items next time. It is a bit more uncertain.\\n\\nIn contrast, in Scenario 1, Jill offers to use her substantial social media influence to promote my products and business. This could potentially bring in many new customers as a form of effective free marketing, amplifying sales in the long run. Therefore, offering a discount as a consideration for Jill's promotional assistance could actually yield a net gain for my business if her influence is as substantial as she implies. \\n\\nHowever, I would need to verify her social media presence and influence before negotiating the price based on this claim.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe reasoning here involves two aspects: financial feasibility and potential value to the business. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows respect for my craftsmanship and a willingness to become a regular customer. Regular customers provide steady business, which ensures income for the future. Additionally, offering a small discount to her now could incentivize future purchases from her, generating more overall income. This would make Scenario 1 slightly favorable.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill mentions using her large social media following to provide free marketing for my shop, besides her intention of being a regular customer. This could potentially lead to major business growth, giving me exposure to a new audience and potential future customers without me having to invest in marketing. While I have to offer a discount initially, the long-term advantage of reaching this new customer base could be significant.\\n\\nConsidering the potential long-term gain, and the growing importance of social media as a marketing tool, I would see more value in offering a discount to Jill in Scenario 2. However, it would be contingent on her verifying her social media influence and agreeing to the promotion of my pieces as part of the deal.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present an interesting possibility for a negotiation. However, they appeal on very different grounds. In Scenario 1, Jill is appealing to the business-oriented side, with the feasibility of future purchases and repeat customer rewards playing a key role. In Scenario 2, Jill appeals more to the marketing and exposure potential, along with potential future purchases.\\n\\nFrom an artisan's point of view, both scenarios give room for negotiation. In Scenario 1, the prospect of repeat purchases and a dedicated customer provides a stable and reliable opportunity for sales, which is always beneficial for a small business. In Scenario 2, the idea of getting the brand name out there through influencers can be appealing as it involves potential wider reach and this might lead to attracting more customers.\\n\\nHowever, the potential risk involved with scenario 2 is that the promised exposure might not translate into actual sales or more customers. If her social media following does not result in further business, the artisan would lose out on the initial discount given to Jill without gaining the expected exposure in return. The return-on-investment is more uncertain and might not be instantaneous.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 1 offers potentially a more immediate tangible benefit: repeat business from Jill herself. It also builds a personal relationship with a customer who appreciates and supports craftwork - which is less risky and potentially more valuable in the long run.\\n\\nIn terms of relationship building, stability, and lower risk, Scenario 1 seems more appealing. However, the final decision would depend on the artisan's immediate needs and long-term business goals.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios given, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. Here's why:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses a genuine appreciation for the artisan craft which is very encouraging. She also mentions her intention of becoming a regular and purchasing multiple items in the future. However, she simply asks for a discount based on her good intentions, without providing any immediate or tangible benefits for me, the artisan, in trade for a lower price. While her intentions to support local artisans are good, they don't provide me with immediate value beyond this single sale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, however, Jill not only shows an interest in coming back to purchase more items (like in Scenario 1), but she also provides an immediate additional value proposition. Specifically, she offers to feature the bought items on her social media platform, which could potentially bring me, the artisan, more customers and recognition. This is a tangible benefit that might compensate me for agreeing a lower price on the vase. Additionally, the promise of recurrent business coupled with the potential social media exposure would be a strategic investment into the future growth of my craft business.\\n\\nThus, while both scenarios seem enticing, Scenario 2 provides a more immediate tangible value on top of her purchase and thus would be more inclined to negotiate the price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill proposes value exchange where she offers to promote my work to her followers on social media. Depending on her follower count and influence, this could potentially lead to increased exposure and sales. However, it's impossible to definitively quantify or guarantee that this exposure will translate into financial gain or increased sales. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill engages with genuineness and compliments my work, but also expresses a financial constraint. She does not demand an immediate discount but instead proposes consideration for discounts for future purchases, thus expressing an intent to become a regular customer. This opportunity could cement an ongoing business relationship that ensures more consistent income in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nIt seems to be a more reliable and fruitful engagement. A repeat customer not only could assure steady revenue but they might also spread the word about my services to their friends and family, leading to potential new customers. As opposed to scenario 1, where the perceived value of a social media shout-out can be unpredictable and can't guarantee tangible benefits.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a compelling case for a discount. In scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work through her social media network in exchange for a small discount. This could potentially expand my own customer base and drive more sales in the future. In scenario 2, Jill expresses interest in becoming a regular customer and asks about discounts for multi-item purchases or returning customers. This could ensure steady business in the future.\\n\\nHowever, without knowing the size of Jill's social media following in scenario 1 or the frequency of her planned future purchases in scenario 2, it's a bit risky to make a decision solely based on these factors. \\n\\nPromotion through social media is a powerful tool, and depending on Jill's influence, it could offer substantial benefits for my business on a broad scale. Moreover, she is offering a service (promotion) in addition to her purchase, rather than just asking for a discount. \\n\\nOn the other hand, regular patrons form the backbone of any business, ensuring steady income and growth over time. Jill has not committed to buying multiple items at this point, but she is indicating her intent of being a repeat customer.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, my decision would rely less on the potential financial gain and more on what I want for my business. If I want to expand my reach and possibly sell more items outside of the local market, scenario 1 would be compelling. But if I value stable, consistent support from local customers, scenario 2 would be more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: This would largely depend on the specifics of both scenarios and my own business priorities, but without specific numbers at hand, I would lean slightly more towards Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present reasons as to why I should negotiate the price of the vase with Jill. In scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media in exchange for a discount, providing potential for new customers and greater sales in the future. Scenario 2 provides an opportunity for Jill to become a returning customer, offering the potential for future sales even if a discount is offered in the short-term.\\n\\nHowever, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 2. Here's why:\\n\\n1. In Scenario 1, while the social media promotion is tantalizing, it's not guaranteed to convert into sales. The value received is also less tangible and immediate compared to a purchase. It is difficult to assess the effective reach of Jill's network and the potential for gaining new customers through her promotion. \\n\\n2. Scenario 2, on the other hand, promises me a potentially loyal customer who has shown a genuine appreciation for my craft. Offering a discount could nurture this relationship and increase profits in the long run. It is more direct and a definite opportunity for future sales from Jill herself. \\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios are helpful, Scenario 2 presents an option with an easier to measure, more reliable potential benefit from offering a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nScenario 1 offers the potential for expanding my customer base through marketing on Jill's social media. Considering the price of a traditional advertisement, this could be a good deal if Jill truly has a considerable following. This could potentially expose my craftsmanship to a wider audience, which in turn may increase my future sales and revenues. On the other hand, the discount given to Jill at this moment doesn't guarantee a steady stream of income as in scenario 2.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill presents herself as a potentially loyal customer who would likely make multiple purchases over time. This scenario provides the possibility of steady, consistent income. However, it restricts the possibility of gaining new customers as in scenario 1. \\n\\nSince both scenarios have their own advantages, the decision would ideally be based on my current business needs. If my business is new and I’m trying to build my customer base, I might want to go for the first scenario. If I already have a steady stream of customers and am looking for consistent income, the second scenario could be more beneficial. \\n\\nWithout having this specific information, it would be slightly more beneficial to choose Scenario 1, considering the wider reach and advertisement value Jill could bring to my handcrafted items.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning Text:\\nIn both scenarios, the customer Jill shows admiration for the artisan\\'s work and expresses a genuine interest in purchasing the vase. However, the propositions she makes in these scenarios are significantly different. \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering a trade-off by proposing to promote the artisan\\'s work to her social media audience. If Jill truly has a considerable following, this could lead to increased visibility and potentially more sales for the artisan. This is a form of bartering, where Jill exchanges her influence for a discount on the vase. The artisan would need to consider the potential value and reach of Jill\\'s social media influence to determine if the trade is worth it.\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is appealing to the artisan\\'s likely interest in having recurring customers. She did not specifically mention a price she would like the vase to be, she just mentioned her budget was low. The artisan would need to decide if the promise of a repeat customer is worth lowering the price. However, Jill doesn\\'t guarantee a future purchase - she only states that she \"plans\" to come back to the market.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers a potentially immediate and verifiable benefit to the artisan, that is, the opportunity to reach a broader audience through her social media platforms. This form of advertisement could lead to more sales, and the artisan could verify Jill\\'s social media influence on the spot. This scenario offers a tangible trade-off that could benefit the artisan beyond this single sale, making it a more attractive proposition for a price negotiation.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons for Jill to receive a discount. However, they each offer a different type of value in return to me, the artisan. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering a potential promotion for my works. This could indeed benefit me, especially if Jill has a large and engaged social media following. However, the effectiveness of her promotion cannot be guaranteed, and perhaps her followers are not my target market. Additionally, granting her a discount based on her promise to post about the vase entails a level of risk, as she might forget or change her mind.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, though, Jill is proposing a more tangible return that directly impacts my sales. She is interested in becoming a regular customer who would consistently spend money on my crafts, indicating that she values my products and wants to invest in them. The cost of discounting one vase could be offset by the multiple purchases she would likely make in the future. Furthermore, retaining a loyal customer will be beneficial for the sustainability of the business.\\n\\nAlso, the fact that she respects the work of local artisans and it seemed killing her to ask for the discount because it's more than she budgeted, this indicates Jill is not trying to undervalue my work but genuinely has budget constraints.\\n\\nSo, in careful consideration of these factors, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.6 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nScenario 1 presents a healthy conversation that shows the customer is not only interested in buying one item but promises to be a returning customer, potentially buying more items in the future. A loyal customer is much more valuable than a one-time purchase. In addition to that, this customer seems to genuinely appreciate the art, which brings better brand image and word-of-mouth marketing. \\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, also presents an interesting proposition where the customer offers visibility on social media in return for a discount. While it is also a fair offer, the impact on actual sales or conversion from the visibility gained from this type of promotion is often uncertain.  \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 is the more enticing option for a price negotiation due to the promise of a recurring customer and potential word-of-mouth marketing to other interested buyers.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer compelling reasons for providing a discount and each presents a distinct type of value to me as an artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers repeat business and proposes a connection where she becomes a regular patron. This offer presents a longer-term value to me because it means there will be a steady stream of purchase from Jill. The patronage she proposes is a welcome one and could potentially help stabilize sales, especially during slow business periods. However, she does not mention anything that would draw new customers to my business.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, offers an immediate exposure to a potentially larger audience. If Jill's social media presence is sizeable and her followers share the same interest and have the purchasing power, this could mean a large influx of new customers. It’s a form of free advertising, which if done well, could significantly boost my business. While she is not promising repeat business like in the first scenario, the potential to reach more customers is quite tempting.\\n\\nGiven the potential to reach a wider market and possibly attract more customers through Scenario 2, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in this scenario, assuming she has a substantial number of followers who may become potential customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are compelling in their own way, as they both offer value propositions that can be beneficial to me as an artisan. In Scenario 1, Jill is promising repeat business, which could be great for a continued relationship and steady income. However, this comes with a risk because there are no guarantees that she would follow through with her promise.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is offering instant value by exposing my work to a larger audience through her social media platforms. This not only has the potential to produce immediate direct sales but it also helps with indirect sales through word-of-mouth and increased brand recognition.\\n\\nI would prefer that the customer pays the asking price since it demonstrates value and respect for my craft, which are important to maintain as an artisan, and bargain may also give out the image that my work is overpriced. That said, I am also aware of the benefits of marketing and brand exposure, especially considering the sizeable audience on social media. Therefore, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 2, if Jill provides enough proof of her follower base and her influence, thus offering a fair trade-off for the discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0.5, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth Jill's in scenario 1 and scenario 2 show interest in supporting local artisans and mention the potential of being a returning customer. However, the main difference lies in their approach to the negotiation. \\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and implies that she values the work put into it. She addresses the pricing indirectly, expressing her interest in discounts without necessarily asking for a reduction in the price of the vase. \\n\\nIn contrast, Jill in the second scenario explicitly states that the price of the vase is more than she was hoping to spend. From a negotiation standpoint, this could potentially be seen as undervaluing the work of the artisan, as she indicates right away that she doesn't see the vase worth the original marked price.\\n\\nConsidering both scenarios, as an artisan who appreciates customers who value the work put into my handcrafted items, I would be more inclined to negotiate with Jill from scenario 1. In the first scenario, Jill shows a more respectful approach to the negotiation by acknowledging the work put into the item and by expressing her interest in potential deals or discounts, rather than directly asking for a lower price on the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"In both scenarios, Jill expresses her admiration for the vase and craft, indicates the intention to become a returning customer, and tactfully insinuates her budget constraints. However, the situations have slight differences that could influence the decision to negotiate.\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill states her intent to support local artisans and her likelihood to return consistently for shopping, setting a future prospect for your business. \\n\\nScenario 2: Jill expresses her love for the vase, implicitly indicating that she is a collector. Here, she also promises to return, which creates future business. But her emphasis also seems more focused on immediate sales.\\n\\nMy reasoning for choosing a scenario comes down to whether I'm focused more on immediate sales and revenue or building a lasting customer relationship, which could yield more profits in the long run.\\n\\nIf I prioritize immediate events, I might be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. Jill's words imply that she is after a transaction today and presents a real-time situation where giving a discount could lead to greater immediate sales. \\n\\nIf I am taking a long-term perspective, Scenario 1 might be more attractive because while Jill does express budget constraints, she highlights her intent to support local businesses - which could hint at consistent patronage and allow me to earn more overall revenue in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: It depends on my specific business goals at the moment. If I desire immediate sales, Scenario 2 has a slight edge. However, for the purpose of building a lasting customer relationship, Scenario 1 appears stronger.\", \"Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill compliments your craftsmanship and shows interest in supporting local artisans. She also mentions the possibility of shopping here in the future which could lead to more sales opportunities. However, in Scenario 2, Jill refers to adding unique pieces to her collection, suggesting that she might appreciate and value the items more than an average customer. The specific mention of a collection may also mean she is more likely to become a repeat customer, as collectors often purchase multiple pieces over time to build their collection. As she'd spend more in the future, reducing the price by a little can foster customer loyalty and lead to more sales in the future. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning Text:\\n\\nLooking at Scenario 1, Jill is willing to share my work on her social media platform which is of great benefit to me as a local artisan. Exposure from someone with a large follower base who is passionate about handcrafted works can effectively boost my reach and potentially draw in more clients.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2, where Jill offers the potential of buying multiple items or returning to make future purchases, does present a promise of continuous support, yet without any immediate and assured form of exposure or monetary benefit for me as a craftsperson.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios can incentive one to engage in a price negotiation, the offer in Scenario 1 presents a more immediate reward and potential future benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1. The reasoning behind this choice revolves around several factors.\\n\\nFirstly, Jill demonstrates a deep appreciation for local craftsmanship, not just verbally but also through her proposed action of promoting the works on social media. This reflects her willingness to provide value beyond the purchase itself, which promises greater visibility for the products and potential customers drawn to the stall.\\n\\nSecondly, she stated her plan clearly. It\\'s not a vague promise to bring \"potential customers\"; instead, she plans to share it right on her social media, which most likely has followers with similar interests. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while she does express the intention to return and purchase again in the future, such a promise is not as tangible as the social media exposure Jill offers in Scenario 1. It is a promise that depends on several uncertain factors like whether she would have enough budget next time or if she would really come back. We don\\'t have a definite way of measuring that.\\n\\nTherefore, the assuredness of potential future benefits seems stronger in Scenario 1, making it a better option to negotiate prices provided that Jill can demonstrate her significant social media following.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her appreciation for the work and the importance of supporting local artisans. However, her negotiation tactics differ between the two, with the first focusing more on a partnership or collaboration whereas the second leans more towards an immediate sale or possible future sales. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, she offers to publicize and expose your business to a broader audience via her social media platforms. Although this kind of exposure could potentially bring in new business, there's no guarantee it would. She leverages her social media influence, which is not quantifiable nor certain to result in new customers.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, she inquires about discounts for multiple items or future purchases. This approach not only shows her interest in purchasing more items but also indicates her intent to return for future purchases. This could provide the guarantee of more immediate income and also the potential for a loyal customer in the long run. \\n\\nTherefore, taking into account the certainty of immediate sales and the promise of return business, I would be more inclined to negotiate in the second scenario. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 6.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their own allure when it comes to negotiating the price of the vase. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers a service exchange - promoting my work on her social media. Depending on her follower count and engagement rate, this could be an excellent opportunity for me to reach a wider audience, leading to potentially more sales. This could be beneficial in the long term, provided she has a substantial audience that aligns with my target demographic.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill mentions the possibility of becoming a returning customer and buying multiple items in the future, but there is ambiguity and isn't a confirmed order. Yes, the prospects of a loyal customer or multiple purchases could be tempting, but there is a high level of uncertainty involved in banking on future sales. Also, there's no direct trade-off proposed.\\n\\nGiven these two scenarios, I am more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1, as Jill offers a tangible value for the discount - promotion of my work. This kind of bartering could be more profitable in the long run, even if it means giving a discount presently. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is not only showing an interest in purchasing the product, but also offering something in return, which is promoting the artist's business on her social media. As a small business, this offer of free advertising can be invaluable, as it can potentially bring in more customers and enable further sales. Additionally, her initial approach of expressing admiration for the work and a desire to support local craftsmanship helps to establish a rapport and opens the door to negotiation. \\n\\nOn the other hand, while Jill in scenario 2 also shows clear interest and expresses a desire to support the artist's work, she is only asking for a discount without offering anything in return. The promise of returning to shop in future is valid but there's no concrete benefit to the artist unless Jill actually does return to purchase more items. As such, in comparison, scenario 1 provides more compelling reasons for the artist to provide a discount.\", \"[reasoning text]\\nFrom a business perspective, both scenarios provide a compelling case for offering Jill a discount on the vase. However, in Scenario 1, Jill proposes to bring value to me as an artisan in return for a discount by offering to advertise my work on her social media. Provided she has a decent following, this could lead to a significant increase in visibility and potentially more customers for me, which could be far more valuable than the few dollars I would lose from the discount. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill shows intention of being a returning customer promising future purchases, there is no immediate value or guarantee that she will actually return. Although it's appreciated that she plans to support my work in the future, it can be risky for my business to offer a discount based on promises of future transactions. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\nAnalyzing both scenarios, Jill has utilized various tactics to negotiate the price of the vase. In scenario 1, she compliments the craftsmanship and expresses her support for local artisans. She also hints at future purchases and asks about discounts for multiple items or return customers. The persuasion hinges on loyalty and volume of purchase. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, she combines the appreciation of the craft, similar to Scenario 1, but approaches the negotiation from a marketing perspective. She offers to use her social media influence to promote the artisan’s work in exchange for a discount. Even though this sounds promising, it presents a less tangible immediate benefit, with the potential yield depending on her true social media influence and its effectiveness.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the potential promise of future interactions is more tangible and certain. The risk of discounting the vase could be mitigated by the potential for future purchases. Scenario 2 puts the artisan at more risk depending on whether the social media promotion effectively brings in new customers.', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling lines of reasoning from Jill for a possible discount. However, my preference as an artisan would be for scenario 2. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers the prospect of being a returning customer and possibly buying more items. While this is appealing, it is not a guaranteed benefit for me as the artisan. The promise of future purchases is uncertain and therefore less tangible.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 proposes a more immediate form of compensation. If Jill has a significant social media presence as she claims, she could potentially bring substantial exposure and direct traffic to my business. This kind of promotion could reach a wide and diverse audience that I might not have access to otherwise. Since Jill is willing to showcase my work to her following, this could result in not only one-time sales but also the potential of repeat customers.\\n\\nTherefore, my decision would be swayed more towards scenario 2 as I stand the chance of not just selling an item at a discounted price, but also gaining more visibility and potentially attracting more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill uses a really good approach to ask for a discount. In the first scenario, she praises the craftsmanship of the vase and shows eagerness to support local artisans. She also ensures the seller of future business and purchases. This can certainly be a tempting proposition for the seller to attract a potential regular customer.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill not only appreciates the artistry but also emphasizes her intention to promote the artist's work on her social media platforms which would potentially reach a wider audience, leading to an increase in sales. This does not only make her purchase at a discounted price, it essentially makes her a promoter of the artist's brand, thereby making it a mutually beneficial business proposition.\\n\\nTherefore, the seller is more likely to negotiate on the vase's price in scenario 2, considering the wider exposure and potential clientele expansion that could result from Jill's social media post.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as an appreciative and recurring customer, interested in purchasing more than one item and supporting local artisans. However, in Scenario 2, Jill also mentions that her budget is tight, implying that she might not be able to afford the original price. Her mention of tight budget portrays her genuine interest accompanied by her financial constraints, which can elicit empathy and instigate a greater need for negotiation. In both scenarios, Jill mains a respectful approach, but Scenario 2 has a more personal appeal, invoking a financial hardship which is more likely to lead to a price discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', 'Reasoning text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has expressed a strong interest in the vase and also in supporting local artisans. She has raised the possibility of purchasing multiple items and returning in the future. However, in Scenario 2, Jill\\'s language and tone are more persuasive. She takes the time to compliment the craftsmanship and confirms that she wants to support local artisans. Additionally, she mentions that her budget is \"a bit tight at the moment,\" which positions her as someone who might need a bit of extra financial consideration. Both scenarios show a potential customer who is not only interested in purchasing the vase, but also possibly other items in the future. Nevertheless, Scenario 2 suggests a greater sense of urgency and need from the customer. Therefore, as a seller, I would be more likely to negotiate the vase price in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows interest in the flower vase and the potential of becoming a loyal customer who buys multiple items. However, the main difference lies in the details of her approach. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly inquires about discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers. She presents her interest as a business proposition. If a discount is offered, she plans on being a returning customer and purchasing more items from you in the future. This is quite a straightforward approach that doesn't appeal too much to the artisan's emotions but more to the logical aspect of a potential long-term customer's relationship.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is more personal in her approach. She compliments your craftsmanship, expresses her desire to support local artisans, and subtly appeals to your empathy by mentioning that her budget is tight at the moment. This approach can lead the artisan to feel more appreciated for their work and recognised on a personal level. The artisan might want to support someone who is not only genuinely interested in their work but also needs a bit of help financially. This personal connection might be just what is needed to bring the price down.\\n\\nSo, considering general human nature and the value of being recognised and appreciated for your work, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 2. Jill's approach in Scenario 2 combines both a business proposition and an appeal to a human connection/empathy which could increase the chances of getting a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill uses a similar approach to start the negotiation, introducing herself as a potential future customer who appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and is keen on supporting local artisans. However, there is a slight difference in context when considering these two scenarios. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentioned her budget constraints along with her desire to support local artisans and her plan to shop in the future. In contrast, Scenario 2 only mentions her interest in the product and the support of local artisans without citing any budget concerns.\\n\\nConsidering these slight differences, this means that Jill is more likely to really need a negotiation in Scenario 1 due to her mentioned budget constraints. Besides, she retains her loyalty by stating her intention to be a returning customer, which is a potential benefit for the artisan. Knowing her budget concern, as an artisan, I could empathize with her situation and offer her a deal. \\n\\nThis is not to say that in Scenario 2, negotiation wouldn't occur but in Scenario 1, the reasoning is stronger and more personal for Jill, making it more likely for a negotiation to happen.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a potential customer exhibiting a real interest in the round flower vase and expressing her willingness to support local artisans by repeatedly buying their products. This is a positive sign for me as it denotes a potential for long-term purchasing. However, comparing both situations, there are slight differences that might influence my decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill points out her budget limitations directly, indicating that she might not be able to afford the vase at the current price and may need a markdown to make the purchase possible. Her budget constraints suggest that she might not have the capability to buy multiple items now or in the future, even if she has expressed her support for local artisans and her willingness to return.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 presents a Jill who seems to have more purchasing power. Although she asks for a discount, her emphasis is more on multiple purchases, and she doesn't mention budget restrictions. This suggests a more promising potential for future sales, which appeals to the sustainable growth of my artisan craft business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\nThis potential for consistent returns and larger purchases makes me more inclined to negotiate on price with Jill in Scenario 2, even if it means reducing the cost of the vase in this one instance. The chance of securing a repeat customer and increasing overall profit in the long run gives Scenario 2 an edge. The initial discount could be seen as an investment to cultivate this relationship.\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing strong interest in the product and also indicates plans on being a frequent customer. In the first scenario, she appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and explicitly mentions her plan to support your work in the future. However, she honestly talks about her budget restrictions at the moment. In the second scenario, she also appreciates the quality and craftsmanship of the vase and inquires about volume and returning customer discounts, indicating potential frequent purchases. However, she doesn't clarify her budget limitations compared to the first scenario.\\nThough both scenarios depict a potentially good customer, there is a slight difference between them in terms of their approach. The first scenario shows a more personal connection and honest expression of their financial constraints, while the second scenario seems more about looking for a deal or discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nThe sense of potential loyalty and honesty shown by Jill in Scenario 1 would make you more likely to negotiate the price of the vase. Her understanding and value for your work is evident, and her openly stated budget constraints might make you feel empathetic towards her situation. Since she expressed her future commitment to your work, supporting her now could pay off in the long run by securing a loyal customer.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios do present an opportunity for negotiation. However, the more compelling case for negotiation happens to be in Scenario 1. Here's why:\\n\\n1. In Scenario 1, Jill not only highlights her interest in the vase but also compliments the craftsmanship. This compliment shows genuine appreciation, which could incentivise the artisan to offer a discount. \\n\\n2. Jill also mentions her intent to support local artisans and to return to shop in the future. This presents the potential of a recurring customer who could profit the artisan in the long term.\\n\\n3. The economic aspect is empathetically presented by Jill as well. When she mentions her tight budget, it could appeal to the artisan's empathy and thus more likely to lead to negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill expresses intent of being a regular and buying multiple items, there's a lack of personal connection or appreciation displayed towards the craft, compared to Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has expressed her interest in the vase and her intent to be a returning customer, both of which are positive signs for future sales. She also hints at purchasing multiple items, indicating a potential to boost overall sales.\\n\\nHowever, there are some subtle differences in the way Jill proposes her negotiation in each scenario. In Scenario 1, she personalizes her request by explicitly praising the craftsmanship of the product and expressing her commitment to support local artisans, making an emotional connection. This emotional appeal might make the artisan more likely to empathize with her budget constraints and consider a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the product and hints at future visits and potential multiple purchases but misses out on making an emotional connection which was present in scenario 1. \\n\\nTaking these factors into consideration, the artisan might be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1 due to Jill's emotional appeal and explicit commitment to supporting local craftsmanship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn analyzing these two scenarios, we notice that Jill communicates the same message - she admires the work, plans to return for future purchases, and inquires about discounts. Although the wording differs, the intent remains consistent.\\n\\nEven so, there are subtle elements that may influence a decision to negotiate. In Scenario 1, Jill gives specific praise about the craftsmanship of the vase and explicitly mentions her desire to support local artisans. When she states that her budget is limited, it's perceived as an honest difficulty, which could trigger empathy. Scenario 2 also expresses Jill's positivity towards the vase and artisan, but lacks the personal touch and budget concern that could inspire a negotiation.\\n\\nGiven these considerations:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nThis decision is based on the authenticity and personal connection Jill makes in Scenario 1, which could potentially make the artisan more amenable to price negotiation. Her expressed appreciation for the craft and explicit intention to support local businesses, coupled with the candid admission of budget constraints, paints a relatable picture that might prompt a discount.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nBoth scenarios present strong cases for a discount, but the second one has a slight edge. In Scenario 2, Jill explicitly mentions a potential benefit for the artisan in terms of free publicity and a long-term investment of a regular customer. By spreading the word among her \"few thousand followers on social media\", she provides a value proposition that could easily outweigh the short-term loss from a small discount. This could possibly lead to an increase in sales or recognition for the artisan\\'s work. This sort of word-of-mouth advertisement is valuable, especially for local artisans depending mainly on foot traffic for their sales. Scenario 1, while also emphasizing the aspect of return sales, does not mention such a valuable benefit for the seller.', 'Reasoning Text: Both scenarios offer promising reasons for negotiation. Jill expressed admiration for the craftsmanship in both situations, acknowledging the value of the product. In Scenario 1, Jill\\'s negotiation tactic includes expressing plans to purchase multiple items and become a return customer. This implies future business, which could potentially offset the discount she\\'s requesting for the vase. It also encourages a good relationship between customer and seller. In Scenario 2, Jill also talks about making repeat purchases but additionally suggests she may provide free advertising on her social media platform, which could bring in more customers. However, the implications of \"a few thousand followers\" on social media is hard to quantify – not all followers might be interested in local crafts or even located conveniently to purchase them.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 is a better option as Jill promises more immediate and certain benefits - purchase of multiple items and potentially more future business. In Scenario 2, the potential benefits are more intangible and uncertain.', 'Reasoning: It\\'s quite challenging as both scenarios are close in their approach. However, in Scenario 2, Jill not only shows interest in purchasing multiple items and becoming a returning customer, but she also proposes a form of free advertising for my work through her social media platform. This could potentially bring me more customers, which is of great value. Nevertheless, her actual audience and influence cannot be verified here and let\\'s not forget that a \"small discount\" for her might be a \"big\" one for me, depending on her expectations. Thus, the promise of free advertising is somewhat speculative. In Scenario 1, Jill also expresses interest in purchasing multiple items and becoming a returning customer but she does not put forward any conditions. Jill clearly appreciates my work and her forthcoming honesty about her budget restrictions is refreshing. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\nAlthough both scenarios present Jill as a legitimate and interested customer, Scenario 1 seems to offer more benefits for me as the artisan. In Scenario 1, Jill expresses interest in multiple items and explicitly mentions that she will be returning to purchase more products in the future which signals more sales for me. She also wants to contribute to the promotion of my business on her social media platforms. While the discount initially impacts the profit on the first purchase, the long-term gain through additional purchases and promotion outweighs the short-term loss. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill only mentions the possibility of future purchases and returning without any concrete commitment. She also mentions her budget constraints, which appears as if she is more interested in a discount rather than in supporting local artisans. This makes me inclined to think that the discount might not turn into future sales, in contrast to Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing genuine interest in the flower vase and is clearly valuing artisanal products. However, scenario 1 offers an additional advantage where Jill proposes to promote the products on her social media channels. If she has a substantial following, it could effectively serve as an advertisement for the products, possibly bringing in more customers in the future. Moreover, she also expresses her willingness to return and purchase more items in the future, which shows commitment and loyalty to the artisan's work.\\n\\nWhile in scenario 2, Jill also expresses her intent to support and return for more purchases in the future. However, she mentions her budget being tight at the moment, which may raise a question about her ability to buy more products in the future. Therefore, scenario 1 provides a greater potential of future income and more immediate benefits like advertisement through social media in addition to the sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nWhile both scenarios present a positive view of the customer and their interest in supporting local artisans, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers an appealing proposition, which could potentially give my business more exposure through her social media platform. A well-curated social media post can be a significant marketing boost for my products, which can lead to more sales in the future. This could be worth more than the small discount I would give to her now. Additionally, the possibility of her becoming a returning customer who purchases multiple items in the future is another factor that encourages negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also indicates her interest in returning and buying more in the future, but it falls short in comparison to the first scenario where she offers additional value through advertising my products on her social media. While it's unfortunate that her budget is tight, from a business perspective, Scenario 1 ultimately provides more potential benefits. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: Both scenarios presented by Jill indicates a keen interest in the vase, willingness to return to shop in future, and a touch of price negotiation. However, what sets Scenario 2 apart is Jill's proposition to leverage her large social media following to promote your business. \\n\\nThis deal not only benefits Jill by providing an initial discount, but it also could mean boosted sales for you in the long term. Exposure through social media, especially when targeted to a group that is interested in home decor, can be a powerful marketing tool. Therefore, Jill's proposition in Scenario 2 provides more potential value to you as the artisan, making it more likely that you would be willing to negotiate on the price of the vase in this situation. \\n\\nEven though Scenario 1 also mentions a possibility of Jill's return to shop and buying in bulk, it's more based on future promise and doesn't bring any immediate benefits comparing it to Scenario 2. Also, the proposition in Scenario 2 is more centric to marketing and reaching out to potential new customers. Therefore, Scenario 2 gives more appealing prospects.\", \"Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: Jill is not only showing immediate interest in buying the vase, but is also offering ways to support and promote my business in the long term and provide valuable advertising, which she points out in scenario 2. Her suggestion to promote my business on her social media to a large number of followers, where she shares about home decors and DIY, could potentially attract more customers, which is a huge advantage for me. \\n\\nAlthough in scenario 1, Jill was promising to return and buy more items in the future, she didn't offer any immediate benefits to my business. Given that future purchases are not guaranteed, and I have more concrete offers in scenario 2, it would make more sense to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in that scenario. \\n\\nWhen running a small local business, word-of-mouth advertising and exposure on social media can greatly contribute to business growth. Therefore, the exposure proposed by Jill in the second scenario is more tempting and offers greater potential benefits, convincing me to negotiate the price of the vase.\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill presents compelling arguments for a possible discounted price. However, Scenario 2 seems to provide more fruitful prospects for the artisan in the long run.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, it appears that Jill is specifically interested in the vase and expresses willingness to return and become a regular customer. This commitment to future purchases is certainly appealing, thus making this scenario a solid contender for a discount scenario.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill not only declares her intention to buy additional items and become a recurring customer, but also expresses her willingness to promote the artisan's work through her social media platforms, where she has a large following interested in home décor. This aspect introduces a potentially significant marketing opportunity for the artisan's business, making the prospect of a discount more beneficial in the long-term perspective. It implies not just a one-off sale or just a continuing customer, but a potential influencer who can significantly boost the artisan's reach and sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"In both scenarios, Jill provides compelling reasons for asking for a discount. However, my decision would be based on the immediate and potential future benefits offered by each scenario.\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill offers to promote my work on her social media platform to her followers. This could potentially increase my visibility and lead to higher sales. However, the actual impact isn't guaranteed and depends heavily on whether her followers have interest in my kind of work and are willing to buy. For instance, if her follower base is mainly youth who might not be interested handcrafted vases, the promotion might not yield much.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill expresses the intention to become a regular customer and the desire to support local artisans. These are notable points, as loyal customers are highly valued. Furthermore, her interest in buying multiple items could provide an immediate revenue boost. However, her promise could also fall through and there's no binding reason for her to follow through on her claim.\\n\\nBy comparing both scenarios, it seems that Scenario 2 offers more guaranteed immediate benefits (user purchasing multiple items), though potentially lesser future benefits. However, given the potential unreliability in benefits presented by Scenario 1 and the guarantee of an immediate sale in Scenario 2, I would be more inclined towards Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches respectfully, praising the work, and shows interest in supporting local artisans. In Scenario 1, she offers to promote the artisan's work to her followers on social media, which could potentially lead to more sales and increased exposure for the artisan's work. This potential for future business and the wider promotional opportunity may make a discount feel more justified. However, the actual benefit or reach of this promotion will highly depend on the size and engagement rate of Jill's following.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only shows appreciation for the work but also promises to be a returning customer, which guarantees future business. If she is to buy multiple items at once, this could also increase the current sales. Yet there might be a little risk; there is no guarantee she will indeed return for more purchases.\\n\\nOn balance, while both offers have their pros and cons, in reality, a sure sale (even a small one) today is typically more valuable than a potential sale in the future. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nWhile slight risk is associated with both scenarios, Scenario 1 may provide a more immediate and potentially broader benefit by increasing visibility and attracting new customers. The opportunity to get promoted on her social media network could bring in more business considering that social media has become a very powerful tool for marketing and promotion.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill appreciates the vase's craftsmanship and wants to support local artisans. However, the proposals are different.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill suggests promoting my work to her social media followers in exchange for a discount. This arrangement could boost my exposure and potentially attract more customers, which is valuable. However, this would largely depend on the size and engagement of Jill's social media following. If she has a small or less-engaged audience, the promotion might not bring enough customers to offset the discount. This would be a gamble unless I can verify Jill's following and their interest in my work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill mentions buying multiple items and returning for future purchases. While only a promise at this point, this suggestion indicates a longer-term investment and commitment, increasing my chances of generating consistent income. Although she's asking for a discount, it's not just for one item but possibly several, and she hints at being a regular customer. That speaks to potential consistent sales, even at a slightly lower price.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, the second scenario seems less risky and potentially more beneficial in the long run. It creates the chance for immediate multiple sales and encourages long-term loyalty, which is crucial for a local artisan like myself.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have valid points for negotiation, however, Scenario 2 offers a more tangible return on investment. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill makes a very emotional appeal, expressing her love for the vase and her inclination towards supporting local artisans. However, her only tangible promise is the prospect of becoming a returning customer, which is difficult to quantify - even though repeat business is incredibly valuable. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 also has an emotional appeal, with Jill complimenting on the uniqueness of the craftsmanship. Beyond that, this scenario offers the prospect of free marketing and visibility to a presumably large audience. If Jill indeed has a considerable following on her social media platforms, this exposure could result in a significantly increased customer traffic that not only covers the discount given but could also boost overall earnings due to increased sales. This type of barter deal could be beneficial for a local artisan who might not have a big marketing budget.\\n\\nTherefore, based on this analysis, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is offering a certain benefit in return for a discount. In Scenario 1, she promises to be a repeat customer and potentially buy multiple items, which would ensure continued business. In Scenario 2, she offers to use her considerable social media following to advertise the artisan's works and attract potential customers.\\n\\nIf we think about the long-term benefits, Scenario 2 can potentially yield more, provided that Jill indeed has a significant social media following and her posts translate into more customers for you. The exposure could lead to an increase in sales that might outweigh the difference of selling the vase at a discounted price. However, it entails risk as there's no guarantee that Jill's social media promotion would in fact bring in new customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the promise of Jill being a recurring customer is more certain, as she is showing a keen interest in supporting local artisans and buying more in the future. Even though the immediate financial gain may not be as much as in Scenario 2, it's a safer and more guaranteed option.\\n\\nHowever, to make a final decision, we'd need to evaluate Jill's credibility in both scenarios. If the artisan recognises Jill as a regular returning customer or knows her reasonable reputation around the market (in Scenario 1), or if she has a verifiable and relevant social media presence (in Scenario 2), this would increase the likelihood of choosing each respective scenario.\\n\\nFor now, with the information provided, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 because of the promised repeat business and lower risk.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Choosing between these two scenarios is a tough decision because both options come with their own advantages, but there are also potential disadvantages inherent in each one.\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill indicates an interest in supporting local artisans and says she plans to return for future purchases. This implies the possibility of long-term loyalty, which is invaluable for a small business, and she's also expressing an interest in buying multiple items, which could lead to a higher total sale today. However, she doesn't specify how many items she would purchase today or commit to a precise timeline for future purchases, so the guaranteed financial gain from this discount is somewhat uncertain.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill offers to promote your craft on her social media platforms in exchange for a discount. This could gain you exposure to a large audience and potentially drive more customers to your business. However, the effectiveness of her promotion is uncertain. You can't assess how many potential customers would see Jill's post, how many of them may be interested in your craft, or how many would make a purchase.\\n\\nProvided both Jills are equally sincere, from a business perspective, you would need information about Jill's follower count and engagement rate in scenario 2 to make a fully analyzed decision. However, considering only the given information, I would lean towards scenario 2 because getting exposure to a potentially broad audience might bring me more business in the long run, given the increasingly digital nature of retail shopping.\\n\\nSo,\\n\\nReasoning: While scenario 1 offers potential long-term loyalty and immediate multiple sales, the potential reach and customer base expansion offered by scenario 2's deal on promoting the art on her social media trump it. However, this assumes that Jill in scenario 2 has a good amount of followers or engagement on her social platform.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 7.2 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, while Jill does express interest in supporting local artisans and willingness to make purchases in the future, there isn't an immediate or concrete benefit for me. Moreover, the promise of being a returning customer is not guaranteed.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill not only appreciates the art but offers to promote my work on her social media platforms. This implies she has a substantial following that could potentially bring more customers my way. This offer provides a concrete and immediate reciprocal benefit. Considering Jill is asking for a 'little' discount and not an outrageous price decrease, this negotiation is more favorable to my business interest. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both situations, Jill presents herself as a potential advocate for my handcrafted items, which is beneficial for any artisan. However, the situations offer different reward structures.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill hints on buying multiple items and returning for more purchases in the future, giving a long-term benefit, but it is based on an assumption, not a certain promise since she might not buy multiple items, and future purchases are in the realm of uncertainty.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill proposes a more immediate reward — promotion on her social media. This can potentially expose my products to a wider audience and indeed increase my sales. Considering modern age marketing, social media exposure can be impactful, and since she considers the vase to be of quality, we can assume she sees value in my product and her review can be genuine and positive.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill have positive aspects but ultimately it would depend on my personal business objectives and perspective. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill promises future business and the purchase of multiple items. In theory, this could lead to more sales in the long term. However, this also entails an element of risk and trust, as we cannot guarantee that Jill will follow through on her promise to return and make future purchases.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers immediate value exchange - a discounted product for promotion on her social media platforms. This could potentially increase my market reach and attract more customers. The value gained could exceed the discount given especially if Jill has a significant number of followers who value her opinion.\\n\\nMy assessment will be on the immediate value exchange and potential for market reach and so my preference would lean towards Scenario 2. However, one needs to respect and acknowledge the promise of future business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are quite compelling, but I would be more inclined to negotiate in the first scenario. Here's why:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill not only shows appreciation for the craftsmanship but also offers a means to potentially increase the visibility of my business and attract new clientele. Given the importance of social media marketing, an endorsement from someone with a good number of followers who share a passion for artisan pieces could help me grow.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill suggests the idea of a discount for multiple buys or repeat purchases, but it does not necessarily guarantee an increase in sales as there is nothing concrete about her promises. While it would be great to have Jill as a repeat customer, the benefit to the business is uncertain compared to the first scenario where potential exposure to new customers is in the offing.\\n\\nSo, the first scenario has the potential of both immediate and future gains through sale to Jill and possible visibility to new clients.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios presented by Jill offer attractive selling points, I believe that Scenario 1 provides a better incentive for negotiations. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my products on her social media channels to a potentially large audience of like-minded individuals. In today's digital age, the power of social media in influencing consumer behavior cannot be underestimated. If her followers do share a passion for artisan products, this bargain could lead to a significant increase in awareness of my brand and ideally an influx of new customers. This could have a long-term beneficial impact on my business far beyond the value of a small discount on a single vase.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 involves a more traditional approach of offering a discount for buying multiple items or promising to return for future purchases. While this, too, is an appealing offer, it lacks the immediate impact and potential reach of a social media promotion. Therefore, while I might be potentially incentivized to offer a discount in both cases, I would lean more towards negotiating in Scenario 1 due to the potentially larger return on investment.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn choosing between the two scenarios, I would lean towards Jill's proposition in scenario 1. There are a number of reasons for this:\\n\\nFirstly, Jill is not only showing an interest in my products, but also acknowledging and complimenting the craftsmanship and quality of my work. This shows she appreciates the value behind my products, which builds a good rapport and understanding.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill has mentioned that she has a large following on social media platforms who also have an interest in local artisan pieces. Offering her this discount could potentially increase the exposure of my work and attract additional customers, which would not only cover the cost of the discount I offer her but also potentially increase my profits. This can be seen as a form of indirect marketing and promotion.\\n\\nFinally, while scenario 2 also offers interest and potential for future purchases, Jill's proposition in scenario 1 offers immediate potential benefits and returns, suggesting it as a better deal for me.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing admiration for the artisan's work and expressing interest in supporting local artisans which is appreciable. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill is offering to promote the artisan's work on her significant social media platform. This could potentially provide the artisan with a larger audience and more customers in the future. There's a great deal of worth in such promotion since increasing visibility can potentially lead to future sales. So, even though Jill is asking for a discount, she's offering something of value in return.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill is mentioning the possibility of future purchases and visits, there isn't necessarily a tangible immediate return value offered for the artisan as in Scenario 1. \\n\\nConsidering the potential for added promotion and possible increased sales in the future, scenario 1 provides a more compelling reason to negotiate the price. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill approaches the situation with interest, admiration, and respect, showcasing her appreciation for the artist's work and indicating an intent to support local artisans. However, the key difference comes in what the customer is offering in exchange for a decreased price.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is proposing a potential future purchase as a reason for a discount. While this can be seen as an intriguing prospect, it remains speculative and uncertain. She simply intimates she is more likely to be a returning customer rather than promising to make another purchase.\\n\\nBy contrast, in scenario 1, Jill proposes a more concrete and immediate exchange. She is offering an opportunity for increased publicity for the artisan's work by sharing it on her social media platforms, where she claims to have a large following. This is potentially more valuable for the artisan because it could reach more potential customers and raises brand awareness, which might ultimately result in more sales than just one customer returning in the future.\\n\\nTherefore, from a business perspective, the artisan would likely be more willing to negotiate price in scenario 1 due to the immediate and potentially wider-reaching benefits offered by the customer's proposal.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill's approach in both scenarios is commendable as she not only admires your work but also expresses her genuine interest in supporting local artisans. However, in terms of negotiation, Scenario 1 would be a more enticing proposition from a business perspective for a couple of reasons:\\n\\nFirstly, in Scenario 1, Jill is proposing a form of barter trade; she's offering promotion on her social media platforms in exchange for a discount. If Jill indeed has a large following, this could act as free advertisement for your business reaching potentially thousands of people, which normally could cost a significant sum.\\n\\nSecondly, Scenario 1 promises immediate returns in the form of increased visibility. While having a returning paying customer as offered in Scenario 2 would be valuable, it is more of a long-term, less certain benefit compared to the immediate exposure from a social media post.\\n\\nMoreover, while a discount would reduce the immediate profit from one transaction, the potential increase in future sales resulting from this exposure can lead to greater overall profitability. Plus, there's a chance Jill will promote your work in the future again without expecting a discount each time, since she genuinely appreciates your work.\\n\\nSo, considering all factors mentioned, I'd be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, Jill comes across as passionate about the vase and willing to support local artisans. However, there is a distinct difference in terms of the benefits these scenarios can offer me as an artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers the possibility of returning to the market and shopping from my stall again. This is good, as repeat customers are valuable, but it's a promise of future potential benefit with no concrete incentive upfront.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 1, Jill not only shows interest in buying multiple items and returning to shop again but also offers to promote my work on social media. This could potentially lead to more visibility and sales, since she claims to have thousands of followers.\\n\\nTherefore, in my opinion, the social media exposure in Scenario 1 provides more immediate and potentially significant benefits than the promises of possible future purchases in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses clear admiration for the flower vase and indicates an intention to return and make future purchases. However, the scenarios also contain distinct elements that can weigh into the decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill takes an additional step that could be considerably beneficial to the business. By offering to leverage her own following on social media to promote the artisan's work, Jill is suggesting an informal partnership that could attract more customers to the stall in the future. Additionally, she also hints at a social media following that potentially consists of a few thousand more individuals who could become aware of and be drawn to the artisan's work. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses an intention to support local artisans and makes it clear she likes unique items, implying she may appreciate handcrafted items more than the average market-goer. However, she doesn't provide any additional value proposition like Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nConsidering these points, I would lean towards Scenario 1. While both scenarios suggest Jill might become a repeat customer, her offer to promote the artisan's work to her social media following in Scenario 1 could bring more benefits to the business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show a customer who is intending to make a purchase, which is always a good start. However, the two scenarios heavily differ in their negotiating tactics.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill tries to leverage her social media presence and promises to provide free marketing. The potential exposure, depending on the nature of her followers, could lead to more sales in the future and is something not easily measurable in terms of immediate monetary value.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appeals to the fact that she is a local supporter and states that she might become a repeat customer. This promise though sounds good, lacks enforceability. There's no guarantee she will come back, and future sales could be uncertain.\\n\\nAs an artisan at a local market, one would ideally want to try and broaden their customer base. A single returning customer is an excellent asset, but exposure to a broader audience could potentially draw in several repeat customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[Reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision to offer a discount depends on several factors such as the customer's approach, potential return value to the business, and the chance for future interactions. Here is an analysis of both scenarios:\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill is proposing to use her social media following as a way to promote my work and help the business reach a wider audience. This could substantially increase my brand awareness and generate more sales in the future. The concern here lies in the credibility and reach of her social media accounts, which may need verification before accepting such an arrangement. \\n\\nScenario 2: Jill expresses her love for local artisans' work and mentions her intent to shop more in the future. Although she seems like a repeat customer, there are no tangibles that ensure future sales. Her proposition about discounts for buying multiple items suggests that she would be buying more today, which could generate more immediate income. \\n\\nWhile both scenarios have potential, Scenario 1 holds more promise of benefiting my brand and business in the long term, given that the social media proposal is legitimate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers a trade-off that benefits the artisan beyond the immediate sale. Jill's social media followers could drive additional sales and exposure for the artisan's work, potentially sustaining a steady income source in the longer term. This marketing advantage could outweigh the small discount Jill is asking for on the vase.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill indicates her intent to return and purchase again which is valuable for business sustainability. Offering discounts for return customers or multiple purchases is common in retail and could foster a loyal customer relationship. However, the promise is a bit vague and doesn't have the immediate potential benefit that scenario 1 presents.\\n\\nTherefore, evaluating both alternatives, the artisan would likely prefer the trade-off that brings broader exposure to their work, which could potentially attract more new customers. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes a collaboration to promote my handcrafted items to her network on social media. If her following is significant and relevant, this could potentially bring in sufficient business to compensate for the discount, or even increase my profits overall. In exchange for the benefit of promotion, a price adjustment could be rationalized. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill declares that she appreciates my work and intends to be a repeat customer, there is no concrete benefit offered in exchange for the discount. The promise of future purchases is uncertain, unlike the tangible benefit of promotion in the first scenario.\\n\\nTherefore, based on the potential return on investment and the immediate benefit to my business,\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering an exchange of services. She is not only interested in the vase but also commends the artisan's craftsmanship. By offering to share a post on her social media platforms, she is offering publicity to the artisan which might reach potential customers that the artisan may not have been able to access on his/her own. This does not only promote the one vase but the entirety of the artisan's works. This could result in more marketplace visibility and potentially higher sales, a benefit that could outweigh the loss from the discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the vase and states she would likely return for future purchases. However, future purchases are not a guarantee and the artisan would primarily be banking on this promise to offer a discount. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nScenario 1: In this situation, Jill is using a bartering system by offering her social media presence as payment. If I, as an artisan, believed her offer will genuinely bring more customers to my stall, it could be beneficial for me. Free advertising, especially to a wide, relevant audience, can be substantially valuable. However, the value of this cannot be guaranteed or measured immediately. \\n\\nScenario 2: In this scenario, Jill isn't offering anything in exchange for a discount, but she is suggesting a potential for future purchases and patronage. While this might sound promising, there is no guarantee that she will return or buy again in the future. \\n\\nGiven these considerations, and depending on the reach and influence of Jill's social media, I would be inclined more towards accepting the offer in the first scenario. Allowing for a discount in exchange for publicity could be beneficial in attracting more customers to my stall in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text: Analyzing both scenarios, Jill seems genuinely interested in the vase and appreciates the craft. In the first scenario, she's offering an exchange of services; promotion via her social media platforms in return for the vase at a discounted price. This is an enticing offer as it can potentially drive more traffic to my business, but there would also be a little risk involved since I would have no control over the outcome of the promotion. On the contrary, in the second scenario, Jill hints at the potential of becoming a frequent customer herself, indicating interest in purchasing more items in the future. This makes scenario 2 more appealing as it offers immediate sales and the potential for a longer-term customer relationship, which is great for business continuity.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn my opinion, Jill's negotiation approach in Scenario 2 would be more effective. This is because she not only shows appreciation for my work but also provides a value-in-return for the discount. She offers to promote my craftsmanship to her community through her social media accounts, which can help increasing the visibility of my work to a wider audience, potentially resulting in more customers and sales. This value proposition of advertising in return for a financial concession is a win-win situation, providing both an immediate financial benefit to Jill and a long-term potential benefit to me.\\n\\nMeanwhile, Scenario 1 also provides the potential for future purchases and repeat business, but it's not as tangible or immediate of a return on investment as the social media promotion offered in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer compelling reasons for giving a discount: the promise of future patronage in scenario 1 and a small promotion on social media in scenario 2. Deciding between the two would largely depend on the artisan's immediate goals and financial situation. \\n\\nIf the artisan is looking more to build a loyal customer base and doesn't mind accepting a little less money now for the possibility of more consistent returns in the future, they might lean towards scenario 1. Regular customers can be a valuable resource, especially in a local market environment where the number of potential patrons is typically smaller and word-of-mouth has a strong impact. \\n\\nOn the other hand, if the artisan wants to broaden their reach and attract a larger audience, they might see more value in scenario 2. Social media promotion can be a powerful tool for artisan businesses and might bring in more new customers than scenario 1. However, it's a bit more of a gamble: while a shout-out could bring in many new customers, it could also garner little to no attention. \\n\\nIt also depends on how busy the artisan typically is. If they're swamped with orders and struggling to keep up, expanding their customer base might not be as big a priority as maintaining their existing one.\\n\\nTaking all considerations into account, I would ultimately choose:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nThe potential rewards seem greater in this situation, especially for a small, local business. Even if the direct impact of the social media promotion ends up being minimal, having photos of their work spread by satisfied customers is always good publicity. The customer also recognizes the quality of the product and agrees the price is fair, indicating they value the artisan's work.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nStarting with Scenario 1, Jill mentions her interest in supporting local artisans and her plan to be a repeat customer at the market. This intent for future purchases is promising, however, only if she purchases more items during that interaction would a discount seem reasonable.\\n\\nLooking at Scenario 2, Jill compliments the quality of the work, which could reflect a better recognition of the value and effort put in the item. In addition, she proposes a trade-off for the discount - promoting the artisan's work on her social media platforms. If she has a sizable and active following, this could potentially bring new customers. Such an arrangement can act as a kind of barter trade: a discount in exchange for marketing, which can benefit the business in the longer run.\\n\\nGiven the above, my inclination would be towards Scenario 2 due to the additional value the artisan could gain from the offered social media promotion. It's almost like an investment that could attract more customers without any upfront costs.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\\n\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios involve Jill approaching me with compliments to my work, expressing her support for local creatives, and looking for a discount due to a tight budget. Jill also offers to promote my work on her social media platform in both situations. However, despite the commonalities, there are subtle differences between each scenario that could potentially sway my decision. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill seems sincere and thoughtful in her compliment about the craftsmanship on the round vase and her support towards local artisans. Her proposal to promote my work on her social media platform emphasises that her followers share in her interests, showing they could potentially become clients of mine. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also speaks highly of my work, but her compliments seem a bit more general and less specific compared to the first scenario. She does propose the same social media promotion deal, offering to promote my work in exchange for a discount.\\n\\nBased on the specific compliments of my work and the assurance that her followers have similar interests, I'm slightly more inclined towards Jill's proposal in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present pretty similar situations with Jill expressing her admiration towards local artisans and showing desire to support, which certainly creates a favorable environment for a negotiation. She also presents a similar offer in both scenarios, which is promoting my work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount.\\n\\nHowever, there are slight differences that makes one scenario more favorable over the other.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill specifically mentions that she is absolutely enchanted by the vase and then proceeds to detail how she could benefit my business. She expresses her gratitude beforehand and communicates the level of influence she has. This suggests that she recognizes the value of the vase, making it easier for me to negotiate on the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, though Jill expresses her admiration for the vase and the value she sees in local craftsmanship, she doesn't specifically mention her plans to show her gratitude or the influence she possesses. She mentions her intention of helping my business, but it comes across as vague and less concrete. Based on these observations,\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\n\\nis more likely to lead to a successful price negotiation with Jill.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios bring forward similar propositions where Jill is willing to promote the artisan's work on her social media in exchange for a discount. So, there's similarity in the value addition Jill promises to bring.\\n\\nFrom the perspective of Jill's engagement with the artisan, Scenario 1 feels more likely to bring about a price negotiation. Jill starts by complimenting the artisan's craftsmanship and the local talent, thereby acknowledging the artisan's skills. This contributes to establishing an emotional connection, which might incline the artisan towards considering her request. \\n\\nMoreover, Jill appears more solution-oriented in Scenario 1 by not just stating her budget constraint but also offering a potential solution to increase the artisan's business visibility. This proactive approach may hold more sway with the artisan.\\n\\nOn other hand, Scenario 2 is somewhat less personal. While Jill does express her admiration for the work, it lacks the personalized compliment about the craftsmanship that's present in Scenario 1. Hence, the artisan might be more receptive to negotiation in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning text:\\n\\nBoth scenarios present strong reasons, but there is a slight difference in the approach and potential outcomes which impact my decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes to market my work on her social media platform, where she has several followers who may be interested in my products. This could potentially increase my visibility and sales in the future. It's a form of trade-off; I give her a discount on the flower vase and in return get free marketing from her. This kind of bargain can be beneficial, especially if her followers indeed have a great interest in local arts.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill seems to be a loyal customer or someone who is likely to become one. She's suggesting the possibility of purchasing more items right now and in the future. While this is also very appealing, there is no absolute guarantee that she will return and buy more. Sometimes customers ask for discounts on the grounds of becoming regular customers but do not follow through.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present opportunities, the promising exposure from Scenario 1 is more beneficial here. Especially if Jill’s followers also value local craftsmanship, this can help in establishing a solid customer base, yielding greater long-term benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both the scenarios, Jill appears to be interested in the vase I have crafted and sincerely praises my work, which I appreciate. However, the way she approaches the negotiation differs.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill tries to negotiate the price by offering to promote my work on her social media platforms. Although this may sound initially appealing, considering her number of followers might love my work and be interested in buying, it's still a risky bet. It can potentially increase the visibility of my work, but it may not necessarily result in direct sales or profit for me. It largely depends on the kind of followers she has and whether they are genuinely interested in buying handmade crafts. So, while her proposal is tempting, it doesn't promise a sure-shot return.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only shows interest in my vase but also hints at her intention of buying multiple items and becoming a regular customer. This seems like a more concrete proposal, where I can calculate the profit I'd be making from her repeated purchases, even if I offer her a small discount now. Also, it's always great to have returning, loyal customers for any business. Therefore, her proposal to possibly become a regular customer holds more weight in my perspective because it seems to offer a more dependable revenue stream.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is showing interest in the vase and implying the wish for negotiation but there are a few differences. In scenario 1, she isn't only asking for a discount because of limited funds, she's also providing a potential gain for the artisan - exposure on her social media platform. This could generate more business for the artisan in the future, something that would benefit the artisan greatly. While she hasn't provided exact figures, her promise to share the work and draw more clients could prompt the artisan to think long-term.\\n\\nOn the other hand in Scenario 2, Jill is asking for discounts on potential future purchases and for returning customers. However, this promises less immediate return for the artisan as it's based on hypothetical future purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nThe immediate potential gain from social media exposure seems to be a more persuasive argument in Scenario 1 given it could result in a larger customer base, therefore, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in this scenario.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill brings up good points. In Scenario 1, she offers publicity for my business on her social media, which could potentially bring in new customers. This is an appealing offer because it could lead to increased sales in the long term. However, this largely depends on her influence and reach on social media, which isn't explicitly mentioned.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill suggests she will not only be a regular customer but is also interested in buying multiple items. This directly means more sales volume which is guaranteed, as opposed to the potential sales from Scenario 1. Frequent customers are valuable as they will likely provide steady income and potentially recommend the business to their friends and family over time.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2 \\n\\nThe guaranteed benefits of repeated sales and increased volume presented in Scenario 2 would make me more likely to negotiate on the price compared to the promised publicity and potential customers of Scenario 1. The latter is less predictable and depends on many factors that are not completely under control, while the benefits of a loyal customer are both immediate and long-term. Furthermore, discounts on multiple items or for returning customers are common practices that can motivate customers to buy more.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn assessing both scenarios presented by Jill, she uses different tactics to negotiate a lower price for the vase. In Scenario 1, Jill is leveraging her social media following as a form of advertisement for my handcraft work. She's insinuating that more business could come my way if she showcases my work on her platform, this is helpful especially if she does indeed have high engagement and her followers demonstrate an interest in artisanal crafts. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is promising to be a repeat customer and even suggesting purchase of multiple items. This too offers potential future business which could offset any initial discount on the vase. However, these offers are made on assumptions, while more immediate, tangible benefits are offered in Scenario 1 with the promise of social media exposure that could reach new customers.\\n\\nTherefore, given the immediate benefit of potential marketing through social media in Scenario 1 as compared to the speculative promise of future business in Scenario 2, I would lean more towards Jill's first proposal.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are tempting as a business owner because they reflect good future prospects for my business. However, evaluating each offer critically, I would likely lean more towards Scenario 1.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering not only to purchase the vase but to also promote my work on her social media platform. This could be a valuable form of advertisement, particularly if she does have a substantial following as she claims. This could bring me more customers, increasing the exposure and reach of my work. While this might not yield immediate financial return, the long-term benefit could be substantial.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 does hold promise as the customer is interested in buying multiple items and being a regular visitor. But the guarantee in this case is somewhat nebulous as there's no firm commitment beyond a statement of intent.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses a genuine admiration for the artisan's work and a desire not only to purchase a product but also to assist in raising awareness about the artisan's business. She does this by promising to share information about the artisan's work on her social media accounts. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1 Jill also shows interest in purchasing multiple items and becoming a returning customer. This implies potential for more future business with her. As an artisan trying to sell my products, I would be more attracted by the prospect of a regular customer who could provide stable future income, rather than a one-time buyer. Jill in Scenario 1 is indirectly suggesting a long-term customer-artisan relationship while Jill in Scenario 2 is just asking for a discount for a sole product.\\n\\nMoreover, Jill in Scenario 1 is very thoughtful in framing her request for a discount. She first complements the quality and diverse range of products and then subtly suggests a discount. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text: \\n\\nBoth scenarios are persuasive in their own rights as Jill is not only showing interest in purchasing the product but also in promoting the artisan's business in return for a discount. However, there are subtle differences. Either way, Jill isn't just asking for the discount, she's also offering a value exchange which is beneficial for the artisan business. \\n\\nThe most notable difference between the two scenarios is the reason provided for asking for the discount. This will certainly have an impact on the decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appears to be more interested in becoming a regular customer and she also promises to promote the artisan's work among her social media followers. Providing a discount in this context could be seen as an investment in a loyal customer and potential free advertisement.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, despite Jill's professed admiration for the artisan's work and her offer to promote the business on her social media, her main reason for requesting a discount appears to be a tight budget. While a sympathetic seller might grant the discount, there's less promise of return on this scenario compared to the first one. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nBoth scenarios provide a compelling case for Jill to be offered a discount. In both scenarios, Jill praises the craftsmanship of the vase, acknowledges the importance of supporting local art, offers to promote the business on her social platform, and requests for a discount due to budget constraints or in relation to an increased purchase.\\n\\nHowever, Scenario 1 offers an additional incentive of promising to be a recurring customer and discussing the prospect of purchasing multiple items along with the vase. This hints at an immediate increase in sales as well as potential future sales, establishing a relationship that could be profitable for the artisan over time. \\n\\nOn the other hand, while Scenario 2 does offer the possibility of promotion on Jill's social media, it doesn't provide a direct indication of future purchases or immediate multiple purchases. \\n\\nGiven these considerations, it would seem that Jill in Scenario 1 provides a more appealing negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.3 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: Although both scenarios essentially offer the same deal - a discount in exchange for promotion on social media, Jill's approach in scenario 2 is more appealing for a couple of reasons. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill not only appreciates the vase for its look but also for the quality of craftsmanship and quotes it as a fair price initially, validating the asking price rather than making it seem as if it's overpriced from the get-go. \\n\\nSecondly, in the second scenario, Jill introduces the idea of becoming a potential regular customer. This could mean more revenue in the long term and this added incentive might increase the likelihood of the seller negotiating the price. \\n\\nThe concept of getting a customer discount for future purchases would also give me, as an artisan, motivation to build a customer relationship with Jill. Feature in social media is a bonus which could potentially attract more clients. This strategy seems more beneficial and respectful compared to scenario 1.\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer a similar bargain, with Jill promising to purchase more items in the future and promoting the artisan shop on her social media in exchange for a discount. However, there are subtle differences that could sway an artisan's decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is immediately complimentary about the craftsmanship of the vase, indicating she can appreciate its value and the work that went into it. This could be very appealing to an artisan who values recognition for their work. She also comes across as sincere and friendly in her approach, and that she values supporting local artisans could also resonate with the artisan. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 presents Jill as a bit more transactional. She begins by acknowledging the fair price of the vase, and her promise of future purchases comes across as more of a bargaining chip than a genuine interest in the artisan's work. While her offer of social media promotion is the same, it feels a bit more detached and business-like.\\n\\nOverall, the artisan might feel more understood and appreciated in Scenario 1, rather than just a means to an end as they could in Scenario 2. Thus, they might be more likely to be moved by Jill's sincerity and evident respect for the artisan's craft.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Overall, both scenarios present strong reasons for giving a discount, but between the two, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1.\\n\\nReasoning: \\n\\nWhile both scenarios promise some form of repeat business and promotion, Jill in Scenario 1 seems more personal and genuine due to her compliments about the local craftsmanship and her intentions to support local artisans. Her request for a small discount due to a tight budget makes it feel like she truly values the vase and isn't merely trying to haggle for the sake of getting a cheaper price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill is also complimentary and expresses a future desire to buy more items, her query about discounts gives the impression that she might be more focused on looking for a better deal, rather than truly valuing the artistry of the piece like Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nPromoting my work on social media is a great bonus in both scenarios but it's the authenticity of Jill in Scenario 1 that makes a stronger impression on me as an artisan. Her appreciation for my work feels sincere and I would, therefore, be more willing to negotiate the price for her.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.15 4.95\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is very complimentary about my work and acknowledges the value of supporting local artisans, which is really appreciated. Both scenarios also involve some kind of trade-off - help promoting my work on social media in return for a discount. \\n\\nHowever, Scenario 1 is probably more persuasive to me. Firstly, Jill specifically mentions that she has a large following on her social media platforms which potentially means a lot of exposure for my work. This can be a powerful incentive for a small artisan business, as word-of-mouth and positive reviews can significantly drive up business. Although Jill does not specifically mention the number of followers she has in Scenario 2, it's a minor detail that could make a big difference.\\n\\nFurthermore, in Scenario 1, Jill is also more explicit about her intentions to purchase the vase and share my name/brand on her platform; in Scenario 2, she just vaguely mentions promoting my work which could involve less effort or exposure on her part.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"Both scenarios are quite similar with Jill expressing her admiration for the artisan work and proposing a form of barter system whereby she will promote the artisan's work in exchange for a discount. However, scenario 1 seems to be more detailed and persuasive than 2. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses her interest in the vase but also lays emphasis on supporting local artisans, the uniqueness of the piece, and her desire to own it despite it being beyond her budget. Her proposal to promote the artisan's work through her social media platform is also laid out more persuasively, indicating her large following. This implies that her promotion could potentially reach more people which would be beneficial for the artisan.\\n\\nScenario 2 on the other hand is more straightforward with Jill directly asking for a discount while offering to help promote the artisan's work. While it's clear and direct, it lacks the persuasive element seen in Scenario 1.\\n\\nFor these reasons, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. It feels like a more mutually beneficial arrangement where both parties get something of value – Jill gets a beautiful vase at a reduced price and the artisan gets some valuable promotion.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth customers are interested in the vase and both are proposing a potential barter transaction: a discount for social media promotion. However, there are subtle differences in how Jill approaches the negotiation in each scenario.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is much more explicit about the base value of the vase and the workmanship that goes into it. She shows a detailed appreciation for handcrafted, unique items and underscores her interest in supporting local artisans. She also isn’t shy about the reach of her social media following, implying a significant potential customer base.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill focuses more on her budget constraints and less on the value of the vase itself. Offering to help promote does not necessarily guarantee a solid return, especially as there is no mention of a substantial social media following.\\n\\nTherefore, considering these aspects, I'd be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. This is because her appreciation of my work seems more genuine, she presents a potentially greater benefit with the promise of a large social media following, and she understands and values the effort it takes to craft a unique item like the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.15 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present attractive negotiations, but I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in scenario 2. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is proposing a potential discount on multiple items and a special rate for being a returning customer, which could lead to a loss for me as an artisan if the same agreement were made with all customers. As a small business, I can't afford to constantly give discounts, as I'm selling handcrafted items that take time and effort to produce. However, I should see the potential benefits of a loyal customer and consider offering some form of a loyalty reward system in the future.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill is not only asking for a discount but also offering something valuable in return: promotion of my work on her social media. This is an opportunity for free advertising and could potentially bring more business my way, thereby possibly offsetting the discount given to her.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nScenario 1 presents an opportunity for bigger sales and repeated business. Jill has expressed the possibility of not only buying multiple items, which will increase the overall sales for the day, but also returning for more purchases in the future. In the long run, this means a steady stream of sales, which is beneficial for any business.\\n\\nScenario 2, while also having a persuasive argument, involves more intangible benefits such as social media promotion. Here, the effectiveness of Jill's promotion cannot be quantified or guaranteed. Plus, the benefits are more long term and indirect, whereas the direct benefit of making sales is more immediate and guaranteed in Scenario 1. \\n\\nHowever, scenario 2 might be more advantageous if Jill has a large social media following and can provide significant exposure for the artisan's work within his typical target audience. This kind of organic promotion could lead to increased sales and visibility over time, making a one-time discount worth it.\\n\\nGiven these reasons, without further information about Jill's social media influence, I would likely lean towards Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a purposeful willingness towards supporting local artisans, hence they are balanced in terms of emotional appeal. Nevertheless, Jill introduced different negotiation tactics respectively.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is essentially trying to give reasons as to why she might be granted a discount - for potential bulk buying and future recurring purchases.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, aside from budget constraints, Jill suggests a barter concept in which she would promote the artisan's work through her social media platforms to compensate for potential price reductions.\\n\\nWeighing the pros and cons, Scenario 1 provides more concrete and straightforward business benefits. A bulk purchase assures immediate income, and the promise of a returning customer guarantees future patronage which is essential for small businesses like a local artisan. On the other hand, Scenario 2’s proposed barter system is rather vague. The reach and influence of Jill's social media is unknown and there's no surefire way to gauge the impact of such promotion.\\n\\nTherefore, based on these points, I would be more inclined to negotiate the vase price with Jill in Scenario 1 where the benefits are more solid and definite.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.15 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide compelling reasons and potential benefits to offering a discount, but they differ slightly in the value they bring.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only mentions potential repeat business but also mentions buying multiple items at once. This potentially increases the value of the sale and could justify a discount. Further, she offers to promote your work on her social media with a following of thousands, providing potential exposure.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill shows a strong appreciation for your work and commitment to local artisans. However, her offer is based predominantly on her budget restrictions. While she offers to promote your work on her social media, she does not indicate a large following as in scenario 1.\\n\\nBased on the potential immediate increase in sales (multiple items, repeat business), and the substantial promotional value of exposure to Jill's thousands of social media followers, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill offers to promote my work on social media, which could potentially bring in new business. However, in Scenario 1, Jill mentions the possibility of multiple purchases and returning frequently to the market. This suggests potential for repeat business, which is generally more valuable than a one-time sale. In addition, since Jill stated that she has several thousand social media followers, any promotion she does could potentially reach a large audience. Therefore, while both scenarios offer some value to me as a vendor, Scenario 1 provides a more tangible and immediate benefit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe artisan, representing a local market, will look at a few aspects to decide whether or not to negotiate the price of the vase.\\n\\nFirstly, an artisan will consider whether the customer appreciates the value of the work, as expressed by respect for the craftsmanship and an understanding that this is not a mass-produced item.\\n\\nSecondly, the buyer's willingness to help promote the craftsman's work, especially in this digital age where social media marketing is influential, can be an attractive proposition for the artisan. This can not only boost sales in the short term but can also bring benefits in the long run.\\n\\nThirdly, a customer's intention to be a repeat purchaser will also make the artisan more inclined to offer a discount.\\n\\nEven though both scenarios express some or all of these points, in Scenario 1, Jill makes it clear that she is interested in purchasing multiple items as well as that she intends to become a returning customer. This certainly brings an appealing prospect to the artisan. The willingness of using her social media platform is also a solid leverage since she already has thousands of followers.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill focuses more on her love for local craftsmanship and her tight budget. The idea of promoting the artisan's work on her social media appears to be suggested more as an alternative way to strike a deal given her limited budget rather than her willingly wanting to support the artisan using her social media influence.\\n\\nTherefore, as a seller, I would more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 1 - due to her clear intention of being a returning customer, her interest in multiple items, and her upfront offer of using her social media leverage as a part of the negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.15 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, Jill's approach is different yet her objective is the same - to negotiate a lower price for the vase while offering to promote my work on her social media. In both scenarios, Jill uses a relatable and persuasive strategy to achieve this. \\n\\nHowever, Jill's approach in Scenario 2 is more appealing because she aligns herself with the artisan culture - she signals that she's passionate about supporting local artisans and prefers handcrafted items over factory-made goods. Scenario 2 portrays her as someone who values the hard work and time that goes into crafting such unique pieces. Her interest to support independent businesses and the local economy is touching and persuasive.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she does mention that she loves my work and would like to promote it - this is quite flattering as it's always nice to hear that someone appreciates our work. However, her offer is linked directly to her proposition for a discount which makes her intention seem more transactional and less from the heart.\\n\\nThus, Jill's approach in scenario 2 seems more genuine, personal and it reflects her passion for handcrafted items. I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in this scenario. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill offers to promote my craftsmanship on her social media, which means additional exposure and potential customers. However, Scenario 1 sounds more promising as Jill asserts she has a 'decent amount of followers' which insinuates an existing influence, complimented by her eagerness to support local artisans.\\n\\nWhile in Scenario 2, Jill also sounds interested and supportive towards local artistry, her financial limitations is her primary reason for seeking a discount. This could set a less favourable precedent for future customers who might also cite personal financial constraints to demand discounts, consequently devaluing my work over time.\\n\\nOn basis of this reasoning, I am more inclined to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1. Jill's approach in this scenario suggests a promising potential for mutual benefit - getting exposure to a substantial audience via her social media in exchange for a discount on the vase. Therefore, I consider Scenario 1 to be more beneficial to both my business and the customer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nGenerally, both scenarios are similar - Jill is offering to promote my handcrafted items on her social media account in exchange for a discount on the vase she likes. However, there are a couple of differences which makes one scenario slightly more appealing than the other. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments my work and specifically mentions she would love to support me by promoting my talent to her network. She's upfront about her desire for a quid pro quo type of deal - advertising in exchange for a discount. It's clear, professional and to the point.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill takes a different approach. She begins by complimenting my work, and then proceeds to share a bit about her passion for supporting local artisans. She humanizes her situation by revealing she's on a tighter budget than she hoped for. Then, instead of outright asking for a discount, she suggests a trade - promotion in exchange for a discount. It's a softer approach, and her story is more relatable and personal.\\n\\nGiven these nuances, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 2. Even though Jill is asking for a discount, she connects on a personal level about her passion for supporting local artisans. This is not only convincing but also strikes a chord as I'm a local artisan too. Her willingness to share more about her circumstances and offer to help promote my work makes her seem genuine - it feels like a collaborative process rather than a transactional one.\\n\\nI would certainly appreciate Jill's intent of promoting my work in both scenarios, but the additional personal connection in the second makes me more open to negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.15 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nLooking at both scenarios, Jill's interest in the vase is clear and she is appreciative of the workmanship. However, the way she communicates her request for a lower price varies between the two scenarios. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she compliments the work and proposes a barter-like arrangement. She offers a clear value addition: promoting the artisan's business to potentially a wider audience through her social media platforms provided she receives a discount. This promotion could potentially bring in more business, and this is a win-win situation: Jill gets her desired discount, and the artisan benefits from increased social media exposure.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill remains appreciative, her reasons for asking for a price cut seem rooted in her personal budget constraints. Her offer to promote the crafts on her social media is not as confidently presented and seems more like an afterthought rather than an organized proposal. \\n\\nHence, considering the better framed proposition and potential benefit to the business in the long run, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe choice between the two scenarios is largely dependent on the potential benefits gleaned from each of Jill's proposals. In both situations, Jill offers to utilize her social media reaches to promote my work, which could potentially increase my customer base and sales, a very welcome idea for any entrepreneur. \\n\\nHowever, the choice boils down to how each proposition was introduced. In Scenario 1, Jill not only admires the vase and acknowledges the unique craftsmanship presented in the piece but also recognises and appreciates the value tied to it. She seems to understand and respect the effort put into creating the piece, which potentially makes her a credible promoter of my work. Furthermore, she confidently implies she has a 'considerable following' on her social platforms, which gives credibility to her claim of possibly being able to bring my craft to a wider audience. This is an attractive attribute and might sway the decision in her favour. The possibility of reaching a wider audience through her might justify giving her the discount she asks for.\\n\\nOn the contrary, Jill in Scenario 2 is seen lamenting about her financial constraints, implying she loves the vase but can't afford it at the marked price. She offers to promote my work on her social media, but unlike Jill in scenario 1, she doesn't provide much detail about her potential reach or influence. We get the sense that the offer to promote my work could simply be a convenient excuse to ask for a discount which puts her credibility in question.\\n\\nSo, looking at both scenarios and considering the potential benefits and risks, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. She comes across as sincere and cognisant of the fact that she's buying an artisanal object and not just an everyday item. Her offer to share my work with her social media following is also presented convincingly and seems like a beneficial trade.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are quite similar and very compelling, as Jill clearly appreciates the value of artisanal work and offers fair reasons for seeking a price negotiation. However, I am more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. Here, Jill explicitly states that she deems the price of the vase to be fair for the quality offered, which shows an understanding and respect for my work and its value, indicating that she won't undervalue my other products either. \\n\\nHer offer to promote my work to her considerable social media following could also be hugely beneficial for me. It would not only expose my craftsmanship to a wider audience, potentially leading to more future sales, but it's also a validation of my work coming from a customer, which can have greater impact on potential customers. \\n\\nAlthough her offer in Scenario 2 is similar, here she doesn't explicitly state that she respects or compares my pricing to quality, so it's less appealing compared to Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.15 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a negotiation perspective, both scenarios are quite similar as Jill is offering something in return for a discount: promotion on social media. However, the minor difference lies in Jill's presentation which can subtly affect the outcome of the negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly mentions her intention of asking for a discount from the beginning but quickly adds value to her request by offering to promote the work on her active social media. She positively appreciates the price, agreeing that it is fair for the quality, which presents a respectful acknowledgement of the artisan's work and pricing.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the work, but mentions being on a tighter budget than she hoped for before suggesting a trade. This could potentially come across as though she is attempting to appeal emotionally to get a reduced price.\\n\\nConsidering the above reasons, and as an artisan who values craft recognition and respect for the pricing, I would likely be more inclined to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1. It appears to create a more balanced exchange where the artisan benefits from Jill's promotion, while Jill gets the vase she admires at a slightly reduced cost. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer essentially the same proposition for a lower price: a promise to share the artisan's work on Jill's social media. However, in scenario 1, Jill proactively mentions that she loves the work and acknowledges that the current price is reasonable for the quality. It shows her respect for the artisan's work and the price put on it. In addition, she details her marketing proposal further, mentioning her active status on social media and willingness to feature the vase and the artisan's work on her platforms to help in promoting the craft.\\n\\nWhereas in scenario 2, Jill focuses mainly on her tight budget and although she expresses her passion for supporting the local artisans, she seems more requesting and less offering in this scenario.\\n\\nGiven these subtleties, the artisan might feel more appreciated and recognized in Scenario 1 where Jill not only compliments the work but also provides a mutual benefit proposal without focusing on her financial constraints. The artisan might therefore be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios show Jill trying to appeal to the benefits the artisan could reap from her social media promotion, the key difference lies in each approach. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is more assertive and confident. She opens the conversation by complimenting the work and the fair price, showing her appreciation for the craftsmanship. She offers the promotion on her social media as a more definitive barter, adding to her argument with the potential benefit to the artisan's business. This makes her offer seem more professional and potentially fruitful.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 prepares the artisan for a request for a discount by explaining Jill's tight budget situation. While this could potentially engage sympathy from the artisan, it also could make it seem like Jill is primarily interested in a discount, rather than genuinely valuing the artisan's work.\\n\\nFurthermore, Jill's offer to advertise on her social media feels more like an afterthought in Scenario 2, rather than a compelling reason for a discount.\\n\\nWith these considerations in mind, the artisan might be more likely to negotiate the price in the first scenario, since the benefits to the business are more clearly and confidently communicated. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 4.95 6.3\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\nWhile both scenarios present valid reasons for Jill to ask for a discount, they approach the situation from different angles. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is suggesting that she might be a more valuable future customer by buying multiple items and making additional purchases down the line. As an artisan, building a rapport with repeat customers is important. Discounting the price would provide an incentive for her to return, which can benefit the seller in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is offering to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms in exchange for a sale at a reduced price. This approach can be effective, but it relies on the quality and reach of Jill's social media following for the marketing to prove beneficial to the seller. However, as a person who values the work of local artisans and considering the size of her following is unknown, this option is potentially more risky. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present interesting cases, each with its own set of positives. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is showing interest in not just the vase but also in potentially more items, which can lead to a larger sale today. Jill also indicates that she is a returning customer, suggesting the possibility of a consistent income stream from her in the future. Retailers often offer discounts for bulk purchases as these lead to increased overall sales. The prospect of a repeat customer is equally valuable as customer retention costs less than acquiring new customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is trying to use her social media influence in exchange for a discount. Depending on the reach and audience of Jill's social media platforms, this could yield quite a significant value for the artisan. However, this could be risky as it is hard to quantify the return on investment, and not every follower may convert into a sale.\\n\\nGiven these points, it would be less risky to go with Scenario 1. It offers more guaranteed sales up-front as well as the potential for future income through a repeat customer, as opposed to the uncertain benefits of social media exposure in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate with Jill in scenario 2. Here are my reasons:\\n\\n1. Jill expresses appreciation for the vase and the artisan's work, which showcases her genuine interest in owning the piece. This demonstrates that she respects the artistic value of the vase and is not just seeking to buy it because it's affordable.\\n2. She presents a win-win proposal of promoting the artisan's work on her social media platforms in exchange for a discount. This might result in increased visibility and potentially more sales for the artisan.\\n3. Even though she mentions that the price is higher than she had budgeted, Jill's approach doesn't sound like she is belittling the value of the work or implying that it's overpriced. She's simply stating her perspective, and offering a solution that may be beneficial to the artisan.\\n\\nWhile in scenario 1, Jill is asking for a discount based on future promises of buying more items or returning as a customer, these are not guaranteed outcomes. In this scenario, the artisan may risk losing value on the first transaction without assurance of future purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 4.95 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0.5, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Both scenarios presented by Jill provide compelling reasons to negotiate the price of the vase. However, scenario 1 offers a more immediate and potentially longer-term benefit to my business as an artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill suggests promoting my work on her social media platforms. Given that she has a 'large following', her promotion could potentially bring in more customers in the future. This kind of exposure and marketing can be invaluable for a local artisan like me, especially if I don't have a substantial marketing budget. Offering a small discount to Jill in exchange for this promotion is therefore an investment that could potentially have greater returns.\\n\\nScenario 2 is also promising. Jill's suggestion that she could become a returning customer and willingness to buy multiple items shows trust in my product. However, the promise of future purchases is more uncertain than the immediate promotion offered in Scenario 1.\\n\\nOf course, in practice, I could consider offering a small discount to Jill in both scenarios, rewarding her for both her potential loyalty and willingness to promote my work. However, based solely on the information given in each scenario, I would be more likely to negotiate the vase's price in Scenario 1 due to its potential marketing benefits and exposure.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill offers persuasive reasons for asking for a discount. However, the events presented in the scenarios offer different potential benefits for me, as the artisan. \\n\\nScenario 1 could potentially increase my visibility and reach a wider audience. The value of such an advertisement, though, would largely depend on the specifics of Jill's reach on social media. Nevertheless, it could potentially drive more customers and increase sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the promise of loyalty and the possibility of selling multiple items at once is presented. This could lead to consistent sales over time. Since businesses thrive with returning, loyal customers, this scenario also holds considerable appeal.\\n\\nI would need to weigh the potential immediate benefits of social media exposure against the long-term benefits of a loyal customer. This decision could also be influenced by other factors, such as current business needs and goals. \\n\\nIf I currently lack exposure and need to promote my work quickly, Scenario 1 might be more appealing. On the other hand, if I am more interested in developing long-term relationships with customers and have enough existing visibility, I might be more drawn to Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: I would likely consider both scenarios, with a slight preference for Scenario [2] if I am more focused on long-term stability through loyal customers, or Scenario [1] if I need immediate promotion and higher visibility.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill is displaying her interest and appreciation for local artisans. However, in scenario 1, she's presenting a trade-off that could potentially benefit me as an artisan in a much larger way.\\n\\nShe is proposing to advertise my artwork, and her large following on her social platforms means my work could reach a larger audience, potentially increasing future business. If she has a significant number of followers and engagement, this could be an opportunity for a significant increase in sales and popularity for my brand. This possibility is more alluring and beneficial for me in the long run, as compared to offering a discount for multiple purchases or continued patronage as in scenario 2.\\n\\nWhile scenario 2 does propose the promise of repeat business, it is less concrete compared to the immediate and broader exposure offered in scenario 1. Also, the marketing potential of social media exposure can yield long-term returns. Therefore, I am more likely to negotiate on the price for scenario 1 than in scenario 2.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 4.95 6.1\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, although Jill is expressing interest in a future relationship and potentially multiple purchases in the future, there are no guarantees up front. Furthermore, she hasn't committed to a purchase yet and it's possible that after the initial purchase, she might not return as planned. Therefore, the future returns are still uncertain.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill is expressing a strong interest in the vase, and she is also offering immediate added value by promoting my work on her social media platforms. As she mentions, she has a large following, which could translate into exposure and potential sales. This proposition seems more beneficial in the immediate term as it can boost my brand recognition and attract more new customers.\\n\\nTherefore, I'm more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 2 because it offers immediate value and potential future benefits as well. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe key factor in my decision-making is the potential for return business, future sales, and increased exposure. Both scenarios offer these opportunities, albeit in different ways. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions that she is planning on being a regular visitor and also intends to make multiple purchases. This signals a consistent avenue for future sales. She also asks directly if there are discounts for returning customers and for purchasing more than one item, therefore, there is room for negotiation and the development of a customer relationship. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the work and expresses her desire to support local artisans. She suggests a type of barter system where she'd promote the work on her social media platforms with a large following in exchange for a discount. This could result in increased exposure and possibly more customers. However, the effectiveness of this proposal relies on her influence and reach on social media, which is not guaranteed.\\n\\nThus, considering the potential surety of regular business in the future versus potential exposure that may or may not lead to sales, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text] \\n\\nFrom a business perspective, both scenarios offer potential benefits. Scenario 1 suggests the prospect of repeat business and also the sale of more than one item at once. This is an appealing prospect because repeat customers are valuable, they could potentially buy more items in the future and even bring in new customers through word-of-mouth. \\n\\nOn the other hand, scenario 2 offers a different kind of potential benefit via exposure on social media. In the modern age, social media can play a key role in marketing and getting the word out about your products. If Jill has a large following and is willing to showcase the vase and mention your name/brand, this could potentially attract new customers and help expand your brand's visibility. \\n\\nHowever, scenario 2 has a level of uncertainty as the amount of potential exposure is unknown and not guaranteed to result in immediate or future sales. This is a riskier negotiation for the discount since it's based on a potential future gain that may or may not occur.\\n\\nIn contrast, scenario 1 presents a more immediate gain by promising more purchases on that very day and the promise of future purchases. This scenario is thus somewhat safer and more beneficial from a short-term perspective.\\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios offer potential benefits, I would be more inclined to negotiate in scenario 1, as it provides a more immediate return and seems to be a safer bet.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 4.95 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe key factors that affect my willingness to negotiate the price are how the customer presents their request and what benefits I could potentially gain from the adjustment.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill seems to be a regular visitor to the market, indicates that she is planning to buy multiple items, and also promises to be a returning customer. This establishes not only her credibility but also the possibility of proportionally higher sales in the future. Furthermore, she offers to promote my work through her substantial social media following. This is a great opportunity for free marketing and could lead to increased recognition and sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments my work and expresses her desire to support local artisans which is encouraging. She suggests the idea of advertising my brand on social media due to her large following, a gesture that can bring attention to my work. However, she does not indicate the intention to buy multiple items or to return for future purchases. Her negotiation is based primarily on getting a discount due to her budget constraints rather than offering a mutually beneficial deal.\\n\\nComparatively, Scenario 1 seems to offer a more enticing deal for me as an artisan. On top of the social media promotion, she indicates her intention to buy multiple items and return as a customer in the future. These factors could potentially improve the sustainability of my business in the long term.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is using a similar approach to appeal to the artisan and negotiate the price. She is emphasizing her interest in the product, her admiration for local handiwork, and her intent to promote the artisan on her own social media platform.\\n\\nConsiderations include Jill's proposed discount for buying multiple items or as a returning customer, her potential social media promotion, and her declared admiration for the artisan's work. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill's strategy feels more comprehensive, suggesting ongoing support for the artisan, potential frequent purchases, and could possibly bring recurring income if she becomes a regular customer. Additionally, her offer to promote the products to her online following implies she can help enhance the reach and visibility of the artisan's work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the focus is more on the immediate transaction. Jill does state her love for the work and the artisan, and also offers to promote the work through her social media. Yet, her proposal lacks the explicit promise of future patronage or buying more than one item.\\n\\nTherefore, based on the considerations of potential future business and social media advertising potential, Scenario 1 would be the preferable choice.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\", \"[Reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth of the scenarios present Jill as an enthusiastic customer who appreciates the unique value of handcrafted items. However, the way she proposes a potential discount differs, which can impact the artisan's decision to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions the possibility of becoming a returning customer and buying multiple items, which has the potential for a greater total profit. Moreover, she presents the social media promotion as an offer rather than a trade-off, implying that she would share the artisan's work regardless of the discount. This creates a win-win situation and depicts Jill as genuinely supportive of local businesses. All of these factors could lead to a greater willingness to negotiate the price for the vase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill mainly relies on promoting the artisan's work on her social media in exchange for a discount. While this could potentially expand the audience for the artisan's work, it presents the promotion as a contingency plan and offers no solid benefits (like a promise of future purchases). Moreover, Jill's statement to looking for a unique local piece and the vase exceeding her planned spending limit might give the artisan an impression that she also values the piece highly and would anyway be willing to purchase it even without the discount.\\n\\nTherefore, comparing these two scenarios, while both have potential benefits for the artisan, Scenario 1 offers a more tangible future benefit and presents the customer as more genuine and less transactional.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 4.95 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has provided a compelling argument for a discount on the vase. In Scenario 1, she merely values local handmade arts, appreciates the unique vase and offers to promote my work on her social media. While in Scenario 2, in addition to the social media promotion, she also promises to be a returning customer, which may introduce potential for future monetary benefit. \\n\\nHaving a customer who plans on making more purchases in the future can provide more certainty and continued profit, and this could help me establish a strong customer base. Sharing my works on her social media platforms also seems like a valuable trade-off for a discount on the price. \\n\\nTherefore, while Jill's appreciation for the vase and offer of social media promotion is appealing in Scenario 1, the added promise of her being a repeat customer makes Scenario 2 slightly more compelling.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Answer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning Text: \\n\\nWhile both scenarios seem worthy of potential negotiation thanks to Jill's compliments and offers to promote the artisan work on her social media, Scenario 2 provides clearer, tangible benefits for the artisan and thus is more likely to cause negotiation of the price. \\n\\nFirstly, in Scenario 2, Jill plans on being a repeat customer, meaning she would bring in more business in the future. This kind of customer loyalty is valuable for any business or artisan. On top of that, she offers to share the artisan's work with her followers which is a clear benefit. \\n\\nIn comparison, Scenario 1 also has aspects of promotion through social media, but Jill does not mention repeated purchases which makes her less of a guaranteed future customer. Without the promise of repeat business, the artisan might lean more towards Scenario 2. \\n\\nBoth scenarios are beneficial, but Scenario 2, with its dual promise of future patronage and promotion, edges out as the more attractive proposition for the artisan.\", \"Answer: Scenario 2 \\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill communicates respectfully and displays genuine appreciation for your craftsmanship which is very persuasive. However, Scenario 2 seems a bit more enticing for a couple of reasons. Firstly, Jill is overt about her intent to return and make future purchases. This promise of repeated business holds a lot of value especially in a local market context where building relationships with customers is crucial. A small discount today could pay off in the long term with consistent business from Jill in the future.\\n\\nSecondly, her offer to promote your work on her social media channels is presented as additional value in Scenario 2, rather than a substitutive value in Scenario 1. While both approaches could informally be seen as a form of bartering (exposure for a discount), the way it is presented in Scenario 2 suggests a win-win situation, trading immediate revenue for potential future gains. As an artisan, this amplifies your chances to increase the visibility of your work, bring in new customers, and boost your overall sales. Although Scenario 1 similarly offers this, it comes across more as a negotiation chip directly for the price of the vase, while in Scenario 2 it's seen as a 'bonus' to her promise of future purchases. All this would make it feel like a more favorable deal, encouraging price negotiation.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.3 5.65\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill displaying an interest in supporting local artisans by making a purchase and planning to return in the future. While this similar aspect is evident in both scenarios, it's important to note key differences in Jill's approach in each scenario.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only compliments the craftsmanship of the vase but also clearly implies her support for local artisans. She subtly presents herself as a potential loyal customer who plans to visit again, which could mean more business in the future. She's strategic in her approach, bargaining for a discount by offering the possibility of buying multiple items and giving the impression of a long-term business relationship. This approach touches the artisan both at a business level, by hinting towards future sales, and on a personal level, by appreciating his craftsmanship.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill does express her will to return in the future and possibly make some more purchases, there is an absence of a compliment or recognition of the artisan's work. She bases her request for a discount on solely her potential future visits, omitting an immediate promise of purchasing multiple items.\\n\\nGiven these facts, I'd be more likely to negotiate a discount in Scenario 1. The prospect of immediate multiple sales and a potential long-term customer, coupled with the compliment, makes this customer's negotiation more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn my decision between these two scenarios, I am more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 1. Here's why:\\n\\nFirstly, in Scenario 1, Jill shows a high degree of appreciation for my craftsmanship. This can lead to personal satisfaction and pride in my work, fostering a more positive interaction which may result in me wanting to reciprocate her kindness and offer her a better deal.\\n\\nSecondly, not only does Jill express interest in buying multiple items, but she also indicates her intention to become a loyal customer. This intention, if materialized, can lead to consistent sales and a long-term customer relationship which is beneficial for me. Offering a discount now may entice her to follow through with these intentions, thus securing future sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill voices a similar query about discounts, her overall request feels less personal and does not specify her appreciation of my work nor indicate the intent to buy several items. \\n\\nIn summary, Scenario 1 provides more compelling reasons - the appreciation of craftsmanship, buying multiple items, and the promise of future patronage - which makes me more likely to negotiate the vase's price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses interest in the vase and implies a desire for a discount. However, the level of engagement is different.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, indicating she values the product and understands its worth. Her interest in purchasing multiple items suggests an immediate increase in sales, which can be profitable, even if discounts are granted. Besides, she expresses an intention to be a returning customer, thus offering the prospect of future sales. Her deliberate support for local artisans indicates she is not just looking for cheap items but is interested in fostering relationships with vendors and supporting the local economy. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill also shows interest in the vase, raises the question of a discount and suggests she may return in future. However, this scenario lacks the compliments on craftsmanship and active support for local artisans which are present in scenario 1.\\n\\nTherefore, the willingness to negotiate would likely be based not just on the potential for immediate and future sales but also an appreciation for the work and the craft. This makes Jill from scenario 1 more attractive from a negotiation standpoint.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.3 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning Text: \\n\\nBoth scenarios set forth by Jill are persuasive to an extent, but Scenario 1 presents a more compelling reason to consider offering a discount. First, Jill expresses her in-depth appreciation for the vase which as an artisan, is encouraging. Second, she not only promises to return, thereby giving repeat business but also pitches the idea of buying multiple items; this implies even more business. Providing a small discount for a larger sale is much more profitable than selling a single item at full price. Lastly, and perhaps crucially, Jill offers free marketing through her social media account, which could have thousands of prospective customers. Although the success of this is not guaranteed, if only a fraction of her followers are interested in handmade crafts or your work specifically, it could result in a significant increase in earnings. On the other hand, while Scenario 2 also offers the promise of future business and the suggestion of multiple purchases, it lacks the extra element of free marketing to a large audience that Scenario 1 offers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill shows her strong interest in the flower vase and signals intent to purchase multiple items and return as a loyal customer in the future. She also offers additional value in the form of promoting your work to her many followers on social media. This could potentially lead to additional traffic and purchases at your stall. Based on these factors, the likelihood of considering a price negotiation is higher in this scenario because it may provide more long-term benefits for you as the seller.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, while Jill again expresses intentions of purchasing more items and becoming a regular customer, she does not offer any additional incentives like advertising your work. Her approach is more focused on receiving a discount rather than providing you with potential future benefits.\\n\\nTherefore, based on these considerations, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in the first scenario where she not only shows intent to buy and return but also offers potential marketing value.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has expressed potential interest in regularly buying from your market stall and becoming a returning customer. This is a factor that may indeed justify a discount. However, the differences lie in the other points raised by Jill in each scenario.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentioned her large following on social media and her willingness to promote your art on her channels. This can be seen as added value because it has the potential to increase your visibility, reach a wider audience, and bring new customers to your stall. Therefore, giving her a discount on the vase could be seen as a win-win transaction, as you'd be gaining something valuable in return—free exposure and advertisement.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill does express her enjoyment of your work, she doesn't provide any additional value nor reason that justifies a discount other than her interest in your products and possible intention to return.\\n\\nFrom a business point of view, Scenario 1 provides more incentives for a price negotiation or a discount due to the added value and potential return on investment that Jill could give to your business, making it the more attractive situation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.3 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['[Reasoning Text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill takes a complimentary and supportive approach to making her proposition, showing genuine interest in the product and the potential of a continuing relationship. \\nHowever, Scenario 1 presents a win-win negotiation strategy, offering a practical and continuous benefit to me as the artisan. Jill may be able to increase my potential customer base by promoting my work to her social media followers, which could result in increased sales in the long run, not just a one-time sale. This strategy seems more advantageous in the long term, even if it would require reducing the immediate price.\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 involves promising future purchases for a discount. Even though this is appealing, there are uncertainties associated with this kind of arrangement. There is the potential the customer may not return, despite her good intentions, so the immediate gain is less clear.\\nTherefore, I would be more inclined to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions that she has a decent amount of followers on social media and she could promote my work in exchange for a small discount. This could potentially increase my visibility and customer base. On the other hand, this kind of promotion is intangible and there's no guarantee that it will result in direct sales. Also, it's difficult to quantify the actual value of her promotion.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is interested in buying multiple items and also becoming a returning customer. This is a more tangible and direct benefit for my business. By giving a small discount in this case, I would not only make more sales now, but also encourage Jill to revisit and purchase more in the future. Therefore, the potential for this customer's loyalty and repeat business seems a more promising and direct way of boosting my sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\", \"[Reasoning Text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering to promote my work on social media, which could increase my recognition and lead to higher sales. This is a form of bartering, where Jill is providing me with a service (marketing) in return for a lower price on the vase. Moreover, Jill emphasized her appreciation and support for artists, which suggests that she has a certain level of respect and understanding of the value of handcrafted work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is asking for a general discount for buying multiple items or returning in the future. While this is a common business practice, there's no immediate and specific benefit to me besides the potential for her to come back and buy more. In this situation, I'm risking reducing the price without any guarantee that Jill will follow through with her intentions to purchase more or return.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, the most compelling reason for me to negotiate would be the potential for wider exposure and increased sales, as offered in the first scenario. It's a more immediate benefit compared to a prospective and unpredictable future sale, as well as a form of advertisement that wouldn't require out-of-pocket expenses on my part.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.3 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer unique opportunities for making a deal. In scenario 1, Jill is showing interest in potentially purchasing more items and becoming a returning customer. This means an immediate boost in sales and the promise of future business, which might justify a discount. \\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill mentions a significant following on her social media platforms and offers to promote your work to her audience. This could potentially bring new customers to your stall beyond the market, and it could substantially expand your business. It's essentially free advertising, which can be more valuable than a one-time returning customer. The only thing to consider is whether or not Jill intentions are genuine and she truly has a large enough following to make a difference.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\nThis scenario will give an opportunity to reach new potential customers through social media promotion which could outweigh the potential loss from a single discount. However, the decision should be made contingent on verification of Jill's social media reach.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIt's important to note that both scenarios present some level of negotiation, however the context and manner of negotiation are different. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is expressing interest in purchasing not just the vase, but potentially more items from your stall — either at this moment or during her future visits. This could increase your sales in the long run. Offering a discount on multiple items is commonly practiced, and would incentivize her to buy more now.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is looking for a discount primarily on one item. However, she's offering to promote your work on her social media platforms for free, which could potentially bring a wider audience and increase your sales.\\n\\nWhile both situations offer potential benefits, they do have their risks or uncertainties. There's no guarantee that the followers of Jill would purchase from your stall in Scenario 2, whereas in Scenario 1, if she's impressed by your work and decides to become a returning customer, you could see consistent sales.\\n\\nAnswer: I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. While Scenario 2 could potentially bring more customers, it's uncertain. Furthermore, it seems more ethical to provide discounts based on volume or loyalty, rather than for promotion. \", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill has shown appreciation for the work and has mentioned returning to the market to possibly buy additional items in the future. However, there is no specific detail or guarantees about these future purchases, she is leveraging potential future purchases in exchange of a discount today.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill is not only showing appreciation for the work, but she's also providing a direct value proposition - advertising to her social media followers could bring increased visibility and potential business. She is offering a clear return, wider audience reach for a negotiated price.\\n\\nTherefore, the second scenario seems more appealing. The collaboration and advertisement potential could lead to increase in sales and is easier to quantify versus the somewhat vague promise of future purchases in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.3 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is offering something in return for a discount - future patronage versus promotion of work on social media, respectively. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill has expressed her interest in purchasing multiple items and has also promised to be a returning customer. The amount of potential sales here could exceed that of a single discounted item and there is also a chance for a stable source of income if she truly becomes a regular customer. This can be beneficial in the long run for an artisan who sells products at a local market.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is offering to promote the product and the work on her social media in return for a discount. This can definitely bring about visibility and potential more sales. However, it's not guaranteed that this promotion would directly turn into sales as not all social media exposure converts to customers. Additionally, the reach and influence of Jill's social media aren't clear from her statement.\\n\\nBecause of the reasons above where scenario 1 offers potentially more long-term profitability, I would be more open to negotiate the vase's price in that situation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have Jill trying to negotiate the price, albeit through different methods. \\n\\nScenario 1: Jill is suggesting a form of loyalty discount. This approach indicates that she intends to be a recurring customer and support your work continually. On a long-term basis, this could result in more sales, which would benefit you. Furthermore, she also asks about discounts when buying multiple items. If she decided to buy more, it would be beneficial for you in terms of selling more products.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill offers exposure in exchange for a discount. The effectiveness however depends on her social media following and how engaged they are. While social media exposure can be beneficial, it can also be very unreliable. It relies on Jill's followers being interested in the vase or the other products that you sell, and also them being willing and capable of visiting the market to make a purchase.\\n\\nGiven this, I would lean towards Scenario 1. The promise of repeat business and the potential of selling multiple items at once seems a more reliable and immediate gain to me.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nBoth scenarios offer potential benefits for the artisan. In scenario 1, Jill expresses interest in becoming a return customer and purchasing more products in the future. This can provide consistent income and establish a faithful client base which is beneficial for business.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers a chance for exposure of the artisan's work on her social media which could result in more clients attracted by Jill's promotion. While this does offer potential benefits, it's hard to guarantee if Jill's promotion would result in direct sales or just exposure to her followers. She could be a micro-influencer or just a regular customer with a modest number of followers.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios offer potential benefits, scenario 1 has a more immediate and direct promise of increased sales. As for scenario 2, it might seem more attractive to someone who focuses on large-scale business or who is new to the business and desperately needs exposure. But considering that the artisan is a local market participant, who auctions his items right at the spot, I would assume the artisan would lean towards a more guaranteed return. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.65 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nWhen deciding which scenario encourages more negotiation, it's vital to look at the potential benefits offered by the customer - not just for the immediate sale, but for possible future transactions as well.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote your stall to her social media followers, who number in the thousands. This kind of promotion could potentially provide a significant boost to your business, especially if Jill's followers are interested in the kind of products you offer. Moreover, Jill also expresses her intent to be a repeat customer and implies interest in purchasing more than just the vase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill similarly shows interest in buying multiple items and being a loyal customer. This could result in regular income from future purchases. While this scenario lacks the social media promotion offered in Scenario 1, It still provides a valuable opportunity to foster a new business relationship.\\n\\nGiven the potential reach of Jill's social media promotion as well as her promise to be a repeat customer, Scenario 1 offers more enticing incentives for negotiation. Social media has the potential to widen your customer base and boost your sales in the long run, making it a powerful bargaining tool. The additional possibility of multiple purchases and a return customer adds further incentive.\\n\\nSo, my answer would be:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present strong cases for a negotiation on the price of the vase. Either way, Jill shows genuine interest in supporting the artisan's business not just as a one-time buyer but as a return customer. This consistent business would certainly be worth a discount. However, there are a few details that lead me to select one scenario over the other.\\n\\nScenario 1 has Jill mentioning that she has a few thousand followers on social media, and she would happily share and promote the artisan's work. This serves as a form of free advertising and could potentially attract more customers and increase sales. This added benefit justifies a small discount on the vase as it could increase the visibility of the artisan's work beyond the scope of the local market.\\n\\nIn contrast, while Scenario 2 does present Jill as being supportive of local artisans and potentially a loyal customer, it doesn't offer any additional benefit beyond her personal purchases. Still beneficial, but not as enticing as the potential widespread exposure through social media in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill is showing interest in not only buying multiple items, but also being a returning customer for the market. This implies that Jill is more likely to contribute to a steady revenue stream over time, which is profitable for the business. However, Jill offers an additional benefit in Scenario 1 that is not available in Scenario 2. In Scenario 1, Jill mentions that she has a few thousand followers on social media and is willing to broadcast her love for the items from my stall to her followers. This direct marketing advertises the business to potentially thousands of people and could significantly boost sales and awareness of my stall. This level of exposure often requires considerable investment, so getting it in return for a small discount is worthwhile and could attract more customers. Therefore, the offer in Scenario 1 is more attractive and would make me more open to negotiating the price of the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.65 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0.5, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios posed by Jill are tempting offers for negotiation, however, as an artisan, I would be more inclined towards Scenario 2.\\n\\nScenario 1 offers the prospect of Jill becoming a returning customer. This gives me the benefit of a dedicated customer, which is always a blessing for small businesses. However, depending on the number and the frequency of her purchases, the immediate financial benefit might not be substantial. Additionally, concessions offered to one customer could set a precedent for other customers, who might also start expecting deals.\\n\\nScenario 2 holds the potential of wider audience visibility through Jill's considerable social media following. This form of word-of-mouth advertising can have far-reaching impacts on my stall's visibility and could possibly bring in a higher number of customers and sales, not just now but also in the long term. It's like the saying goes, 'Give someone a fish, they eat for a day; teach someone to fish, they eat for life.' The advertising provided by Jill creates a lasting impact that potentially benefits my business much more than a single customer's repeat purchases.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, my choice is influenced by the potential for broader customer reach and long-standing impacts on my business more than immediate gains.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nNegotiation often requires weighing up the immediate benefits and long-term gains. Both scenarios offer compelling arguments but vary in their approach.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill suggests buying multiple items and frequent business in the future. This could lead to steady income and sustainability for my artisan business. Offering her a discount could indeed help build a loyal customer base. However, the buying of multiple items isn't guaranteed, and future purchases are also uncertain.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill puts forth the proposal of promoting my works on her social media platforms. Depending on the reach and engagement of her platforms, this could potentially expose my craft to a significantly larger audience, leading to substantial immediate and long-term benefits.\\n\\nHowever, again, the effectiveness of this social media promotion cannot be verified instantly. There also lies the risk that Jill's followers might not be interested in my work. But if she has a large following that resonates with the kind of craft I sell, there is significant potential for increased sales.\\n\\nGiven that either scenario poses some level of risk, I'd base my decision on additional factors such as Jill's sincerity, her passion for supporting local artisans, the authenticity of her social media proposal, and our rapport.\\n\\nAnswer: Based on the scenarios provided, it is challenging to pick one over the other without additional context. I would be more inclined to offer a discount if Jill could assure future purchases (Scenario 1) or provide more information about her social media influence (Scenario 2). So, it's a tie between Scenario 1 and Scenario 2.\", \"Both scenarios have their merits and provide mutually beneficial solutions that could offer incentives for negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is indicating she is willing to make larger or multiple purchases and indicates she will be a regular customer. This can provide consistent support and potentially recurring income in the future. Customers like Jill, who value handcrafted items enough to make regular purchases and commit to supporting the artisanal industry locally, are valuable. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 provides a different kind of opportunity. Jill offers to advertise the products to her considerably large social media following. This could bring exposure to a vast virtual market and increase opportunities for both local and possibly non-local sales if shipping is an option. The cost of such advertising could be well worth the price reduction given for the vase.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, I would be more likely to negotiate in:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nMy reasoning leans towards the potential vast market exposure and immediate impacts of social media advertising. While recurring local support is valuable, the chance to capture a larger audience's attention might yield more benefits, particularly if all works are of similar quality and appeal to the vase Jill likes. As long as Jill follows through with her promise, it could result in increased revenue and brand awareness. Hence, giving a discount to Jill under these conditions may prove a more far-reaching investment.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: ['Reasoning:\\nBoth scenarios are appealing in different ways. In Scenario 1, Jill recognizes the craftsmanship and beauty of the vase and mentions that she is planning to be a regular customer and may buy more than one item. This offers potential for repeat business, which is always beneficial for an artisan. However, in Scenario 2, Jill not only recognizes the quality of the vase and mentions future visits and potential multiple purchases, but she also offers free marketing by saying that she will promote the items on her social media. This could potentially bring in additional customers and increase sales overall. Furthermore, that Jill is willing to negotiate with non-monetary benefits demonstrates that she appreciates the value of the vase and is eager to work out a deal that benefits both parties. Therefore, the second scenario has more potential benefits for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is offering similar scenarios with value propositions to persuade me to consider giving her a discount. However, each offers a different advantage.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions she would be a regular visitor and is interested in multiple purchases. Regular customers are crucial for any business as they provide a stable source of income. Moreover, her interest in buying multiple items can also boost my sales. If the items purchased the items were of high value, this could potentially compensate for the discount offered.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is suggesting a form of partnership where she could influence her few thousand followers on social media to buy from my store. The potential reach of her post about my products could greatly surpass the profit from one or two discounted items.\\n\\nThe crucial factor in my decision would be the reliability and potential impact of both scenarios. \\n\\nIn the case of being a returning customer, there's a level of uncertainty, as I can't guarantee she will come back regularly or how many items she would buy in the future, only relying on her words.\\n\\nIn regards to social media followers, whilst there can be a lot of potential customers, it's uncertain how many people can be converted into actual buyers. However, her online mention of my products can be beneficial not only as a one-time thing, but it could give lasting exposure to my business. This can be a low cost marketing opportunity for my handcrafted items.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential return on my decision, I would lean towards scenario 2 to capitalize on the potential marketing opportunity and long term benefits. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nJill's negotiation attempt is more appealing in Scenario 2. Here, she expresses her admiration for the craftmanship and notes how it specifically meets her needs. She shows that she has keen interest in the artisan's work which could be flattering and make the artisan more open to negotiation. Furthermore, she offers to promote the artisan's products on her social media platform in return for a discount, which could be seen as a valuable branding opportunity for the artisan, potentially attracting more customers. This additional incentive could make the artisan willing to reduce the price considering the prospective gains.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 1 presents a weak argument. Simply planning to be a regular customer in the future and entertaining thoughts of multiple purchases is not much of an assurance, nor does it provide a unique incentive for the artisan to consider a price reduction. The customer may not keep their word and even if they do, they are only promising to act like many other customers.\\n\\nWhile Jills's interest in buying multiple items in both scenarios might attract a discount, the promise of advertising and specific compliment about the craftsmanship makes Scenario 2 a stronger argument.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill presents an opportunity for future consistent business, mentioning that she plans to be a regular customer and may potentially purchase multiple items. This may lead to more revenue in the future and establishing a positive relationship with a consistent customer could be beneficial for the business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers a discount in exchange for promoting the artisan's work on her social media network. This is uncertain value, as it rests on the assumption that her followers will see, appreciate, and follow through to purchase items. It hinges on her followers' tastes aligning with the artisan's work and their willingness to make a purchase. Additionally, the size of her followers matters; if it's not substantial or the engagement rate is poor, the return might not be much.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nWhile both scenarios offer possible advantages, the guaranteed benefits in Scenario 1 of a returning customer and potential for consistent revenue weigh heavier than the less guaranteed benefits of promotion on social media in Scenario 2. Word of mouth marketing can be productive, but it doesn't necessarily promise immediate or significant return. It's better to secure a loyal customer who's guaranteed to come back and make more purchases.\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nWhile both scenarios present potential benefits for the business in terms of returning customers and exposure, Scenario 2 arguably offers a more immediate advantage. Jill is not only interested in making a purchase, but she also offers to promote the work through her social media. This type of promotion can represent important growth for a small artisan as it can bring a considerable amount of new customers that might not have been reached otherwise. Even though the offer of a discount is in place, the potential increasing of the customer base can justify it.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 1 relies on a promise that Jill will return in the future and make more purchases. While this could be beneficial, the certainty of this happening is less concrete than the immediate social media promotion on Scenario 2. Moreover, the contingent of returning customers is something innate to running a business, it does not necessarily warrant a discount or special treatment, and it's a riskier bet to take as it's reliant on future promises.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill is presenting a valid argument for a discount. However, the value proposition she's offering differs in each case. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill promises to be a regular customer and possibly buy more items. This presents value in terms of potential for future business and revenue. She hasn't made any specific commitment or provided concrete evidence of her intent yet, but developing a repeat customer base is integral for any business so this is a compelling argument.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill presents something more tangible. She offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media platform. If she has a good number of followers and engagement, this could potentially boost the market reach and visibility of the artisan's products, which could lead to more sales and recognition.\\n\\nHowever, the certainty in Scenario 2 is dependent on the size and quality of Jill's social media following, as well as her ability to influence them in favor of the artisan's work. This information is not provided here. \\n\\nAlthough Scenario 2 sounds more enticing due to immediate return in terms of promotion and advertising, without knowing the specifics of her social media reach, it would be a gamble. On the other hand, establishing a good relation with a guaranteed repeat customer in Scenario 1 might be more beneficial in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nNegotiating a discount based on promise of future purchases or exchange for exposure can be a tricky business. While it can be beneficial, it also depends on a host of factors.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill indicates she plans to be a regular visitor and is interested in purchasing multiple items. This would seem to promise steady income in the long-term, but it's also based on trust that she would indeed return and make the purchases she says she will.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill proposes a form of advertising exchange. She offers to promote the vase and my craft in general to her social media following. This has the potential to engage a wider audience and bring my stall increased visibility, possibly resulting in new customers and increased sales. However, this depends on factors such as the size and demographics of her following.\\n\\nTherefore, both scenarios have their pros and cons. However, the choice might lean towards scenario 2 since it offers more immediate potential benefits. Advertising to a possibly wide and diverse audience can help hike up sales among people who were not aware of my products. It can also promote my brand visibility in the longer term. Though there is a risk in assuming Jill's social media following will convert to actual sales, the immediate benefit of advertising is more attractive than a promise of future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both the scenarios, here are some thought processes:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill talks about being a regular visitor in the future, indicating possibilities for repeat purchases. This is promising as repeat customers are valuable assets to a business, and it could mean more profit in the long term. Also, she mentions she is interested in buying more than one item. So apart from the vase, there could be immediate sales of other items involved as well. This could mean higher sales for the day.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to promote the product on social media platforms due to her considerable following. This is a good way to reach broader audiences and may lead to increased visibility and sales in the long term. However, there is no guarantee that her followers will become paying customers. And it doesn't promise an immediate increase in sales or surety of repeat purchases.\\n\\nGiven the factors above, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill uses different strategies to negotiate the price of the vase. However, the tactics used in scenario 1 and scenario 2 hinge on different potential benefits for the seller. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is promising potential future benefits where she will be a return customer and buy multiple items. This will guarantee a higher income for the artisan in the future. Additionally, regular customers are valuable to a business due to the predictability of their orders, repeat business, and potential positive word of mouth marketing to their neighbours and friends. This said, this premise is based on trust and there is no guarantee that Jill will indeed be a regular customer.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill proposes a tangible immediate benefit in the form of social media promotion to her considerable audience, which could increase the artisan's business visibility significantly. This proposition offers solid value exchange as the artisan gets marketing value that is likely to pull in more customers for a possibly small discount on a single item.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, Scenario 2 offers a more immediate benefit and a tangible potential increase in business visibility and thus seems to be the more promising option for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 6.1 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill have their potential benefits. In Scenario 1, Jill promises to be a repeat customer and plans to buy multiple items, which could obviously lead to an increased profit in the long run. However, it's also a somewhat uncertain proposition. Repeat business and multiple purchases promise future sales, but there is no immediate guarantee. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers immediate benefits. Jill promises not only to buy the vase but also to advertise the artisan’s work on her social media platforms, representing a form of free advertising that could really help spread the word and attract new clients. This could potentially lead to immediate sales from her followers, which is more tangible.\\n\\nGiven the potential for immediate returns and the prospect of widening the customer base through free advertising, the second scenario seems to offer more concrete benefits to the artisan right now. Therefore, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios presented by Jill offer benefits, substantial differences exist in the provided considerations. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill promises potential future purchases and regular visits. However, those are not guaranteed and it would take time to reap the benefits of this proposed arrangement. Furthermore, her interest in multiple purchases does not necessarily mean she will buy multiple items on this visit, it could be a possible strategy simply to get a discount.\\n\\nScenario 2 offers immediate value to my business. Having Jill featuring the vase on her social media platforms could potentially attract a variety of new customers right away, making it a direct form of advertising. It's similar to a barter trade, offering exposure in exchange for a discount. This kind of influencer promotion is quite effective in today's digital age, and could catalyze business growth swiftly and significantly.\\n\\nTherefore, bearing in mind the potential immediate benefits as well as the long term growth, my answer would be:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios put forward compelling reasons for a discount. However, on weighing both offers, Scenario 2 seems more attractive and beneficial in the long term. Here, Jill proposes a way in which she could provide free advertising through her social media platforms. This not only helps in promoting my work but also could attract new buyers. The probability of reaching new clients via her social media and getting future sales surpasses the one-time discount for a regular customer purchasing multiple items in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.15 5.85\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI'd be more drawn to negotiating in Scenario 2. Both scenarios do showcase Jill's interest and potential value as a customer, even offering to advertise my work on her social media platforms. \\n\\nHowever, Scenario 1 tends to link the request for a discount directly with the promise of future purchases and potential advertisements, making it seem more like a business transaction than a support for artisan work.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 initially separates the interest in the vase and the interest in offering support for local artisans, giving the impression that Jill genuinely values the art and the artisans behind the work. She also expresses her interest in my other items, suggesting she might buy more than just the vase.\\n\\nMoreover, when she offers to advertise my work, she sounds enthusiastic, suggesting she genuinely wants to help support my business, not just looking for a price cut. Therefore, her approach feels more genuine and appealing, making me more willing to negotiate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth the scenarios laid out are very similar in terms of Jill's negotiating strategy. However, there are slight nuances in the approach that could influence the decision to negotiate the price of the vase. Throughout both scenarios, Jill is not only showing interest in a single item, but also commitment to future purchases and promotion of your work through her social media, which could potentially bring more customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill straightforwardly offers herself as a regular customer and social media promoter for a potentially lower price. She efficiently communicates her intentions and adds value to her purchase by stating that she would return for more products and will promote your work on her social media, given that she has a strong follower base.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill's approach is a bit more delicate. Here, she compliments your skill and craftsmanship first. Then she uses her regular presence at the market and potential for future purchases as a bargaining chip, similar to Scenario 1. However, the way she gently introduces her social media influence to promote your work seems more considerate and respectful toward your craft.\\n\\nAlthough both scenarios would theoretically result in a similar outcome, Scenario 2 presents a more empathetic and less transactional approach. This suggests that Jill values your work beyond just the product, recognizing the effort and time that it takes to craft these items. This approach might build a stronger connection with you as an artisan, making it easier to negotiate the price of the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a probability of negotiation of the vase's price. However, my preferred choice would be Scenario 2. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill insinuates that she is open to negotiate the price, but the mention of her few thousand followers feels a bit presumptuous and may not necessarily translate into sales or increased visibility. There is an overemphasis on the potential influencer aspect which doesn't naturally translate into a benefit for my business. It's not guaranteed that her followers will translate into clientele for me.\\n\\nWhile similar, Scenario 2 hits closer to home. Jill not only compliments the vase but shows an understanding and appreciation for the value of the craftsmanship, which is encouraging and respectful. While she still offers to use her social media influence for advertising, it isn't the main focus of the negotiation. The customer shows clear, continual support and assures future purchases. This makes her proposal for a discount more genuine and persuasive.\\n\\nTherefore, as an artisan who would also appreciate the importance of recurrent customer relations and word-of-mouth promotion despite the size of the audience, I would be more willing to negotiate the price with Jill under the conditions presented in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.15 5.9\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches in a respectful and appreciative manner, pointing out the fine craftsmanship of the vase which shows she understands the value of the product. That already is a good start for a potential haggle.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, she clearly states her intention of being a frequent customer and her willingness to use her social media platform to promote the artisan's work. She also presents a clear plan to support the artisan's business in the long term which adds value beyond the immediate sale. This is an enticing offer because it suggests potential for future purchases and also provides free advertising.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also mentions returning to the market regularly and purchasing multiple items. She also offers to share her purchase on her social media. However, she is slightly less explicit about her intentions to be a regular customer and to promote the business, and makes the social media promotion seem conditional on receiving a discount.\\n\\nBased on these considerations, I am more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. She seems more sincere in her intentions to support the business in the long run and provides a clearer idea of how she can support the business beyond this one purchase. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In the first scenario, Jill provides a more detailed case and sets the baseline for understanding the quality of the vase and its fair price. This indicates a serious buyer who appreciates the craft and the effort that goes into creating the vase. She exhibits a long-term benefit for you by promising regular purchases from your store. Additionally, she offers another advantage of promoting your work across her social media platforms with a considerable following. This kind of indirect marketing could potentially bring more customers to your stall.\\n\\nContrarily, in the second scenario, while Jill also suggests potential discounts for returning customers or bulk buying and promises to promote your stall on her social media, the language is less assertive and slightly less structured. Thus, it may come across as a passing remark rather than a serious proposal.\\n\\nTherefore, Scenario 1 offers a more compelling argument for a discount on the vase due to its stronger presentation and the specification of long-term benefits, offering a better chance from the seller's point of view to negotiate the price.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons for me to consider negotiating my price, but I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill clearly recognizes and appreciates the quality of my craftsmanship and is open to making consistent purchases from my stall in the future. Her likely return as a customer presents a potential steady stream of income which is attractive.\\n\\nShe also offers to use her large social media following to share my work and bring more attention to my shop. While she offers the same in Scenario 2, in Scenario 1 she frames it not as a bargaining chip, but as an added benefit to our potential \"relationship\" as artist and buyer. She views my work within the contextual field she operates in i.e. home décor and DIY and also plans on featuring my products there. This creates the potential for increasing my customer base through her followers who have similar interests, which assures me of her influence translating into tangible benefits for my business.\\n\\nTherefore, the long-term benefits that Scenario 1 presents for the survival and growth of my shop would make me more likely to negotiate with Jill.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.85 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more inclined toward negotiating in Scenario 1. There are a couple of reasons for this:\\n\\n1. Building Rapport: Jill starts the conversation by appreciating the quality of the work and mentioning how the vase fits her home, which creates a positive dialogue. Also, she comes across as appreciative of the artisan's work, which is a good demonstration of rapport building. \\n\\n2. Supporting Local Artisans: She speaks about her willingness to support local artisans, which means she values the work involved and is not just looking for price savings.\\n\\n3. Potential for More Business: Jill is contemplating purchasing multiple items, which may lead to a larger immediate sale. Additionally, she is stating that she is a regular at the market and may purchase more items in the future. This potential for consistent repeat business is attractive.\\n\\n4. Social Media Promotion: Jill is offering to promote the work to her sizable online audience, which has inherent value in itself.\\n\\nCompared with scenario 2, Jill in scenario 1 offers more reasons that make her a valuable customer, and hence, I would be more inclined to give her a discount. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, the first one is more appealing for a few reasons. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill not only expresses genuine interest in the round flower vase but also compliments the quality of other items that are being sold and shows intention of purchasing multiple items. Offering a discount for multiple purchases or for returning customers is a common practice that can foster customer loyalty, so it would make business sense to negotiate in this context.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill’s proposal of social media promotion in the first scenario seems more genuine and considerate as she acknowledges the exchange as an offer rather than a demand. She also mentions having a substantial following, which could potentially lead to more customers and sales in the future.\\n\\nLastly, Jill’s polite and respectful tone in the first scenario – appreciating the work of the artisan, showing an interest in supporting local businesses and stating her willingness to continue supporting in the future – makes the conversation feel more like a collaboration than a transaction. This frames the discount as a mutual benefit rather than a loss.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have Jill offering to support and promote the artisan's work, which is a positive sign of interest and potential future benefits. However, there are slight variations that make one scenario more appealing for negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only offers promotion through her sizable social media following but she also expresses an interest in purchasing multiple items from the artisan now and in the future, indicating potential repeat business. This shows that the artisan stands to benefit not only from a single sale, but also from multiple possible sales influenced by Jill's social media promotion and her recurring purchases. Additionally, her genuine appreciation for the artisan's work is explicit, which can be flattering and encouraging for the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also offers to promote the artisan's work to her network and appreciates the quality of work. However, she asks for a small discount without indicating a commitment to purchasing multiple items or returning as a regular customer. This makes Scenario 2 less appealing, as the artisan stands to gain less compared to Scenario 1, even if Jill shares the artisan's work on social media.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.85 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: True\n",
      "parsed_answers: [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill presents compelling arguments for a discounted price on the vase, but the scenarios differ in a few key ways which make Scenario 2 a more attractive proposition for me as a seller.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill's offer is limited to promoting my craft to her social media followers, in exchange for a discounted price on the vase. While this offer has the potential to significantly increase my marketing reach and sales, it is contingent on the size and purchasing power of Jill's audience, as well as her influence over them.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only offers to promote my work on her social media platforms but also indicates her willingness to buy multiple items and return as a regular customer. This promise of future business is a solid incentive to me as a seller, increasing my likely profit from this relationship, as compared to Scenario 1. Furthermore, Jill's commitment to supporting local artisans further tells me that she values my work and my livelihood, establishing common values between us that can lead to a positive and profitable long-term customer relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: Both scenarios place the artisan in a powerful negotiating position as Jill showcases a clear interest in purchasing and proposes valuable trade-offs. However, the differences lie in the scope of the proposed deals. In Scenario 1, Jill speaks mainly of making a single purchase and offering promotion on her social media platforms. In Scenario 2, she not only talks about promoting the artisan's work but also mentions her regular visits to the market and shows interest in committing to making further purchases. The idea of her being a returning customer could potentially turn into a long-term beneficial relationship for the artisan, which gives this scenario an edge over the first one. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAs an artisan selling handcrafted items, I'll be considering several factors when deciding on whether to negotiate on the price of the vase that Jill is interested in.\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill offers to use her social media influence to promote my work, which is a compelling proposition. Additionally, Jill shows an appreciation towards my work and the value it represents, which is always good to hear as a creator of unique work. However, there's a slight difference in the proposals that makes one scenario more appealing than the other. \\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill emphasizes her interest in becoming a returning customer and buying multiple items, which offers a potential for ongoing sales and consistent support, alongside the promotion of my work. Given the nature of selling handcrafted items, having repeated customers is a valuable asset, since it contributes to regular income and builds a devoted customer base. She's also expressing her interest in more than just one item, and if she were to buy additional products, it provides immediate sales value and justifies offering her a discount.\\n\\nSo, given these factors, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.85 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are quite persuasive in their approach as Jill uses effective negotiation strategies such as praise for the artisan's work, showing her support for local business, and offering something in return for a possible discount (promotion on social media). \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill uses a bit more tact in her bargaining. She not only commits to being a returning customer but also shows interest in buying multiple items. This implies that the artisan can get more value in the long run. Additionally, she mentions her social media influence and hints at a possible collaboration that could increase the artisan's reach, which could ultimately result in more customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the work too but focuses primarily on the specific vase she's interested in. Her offer to promote the artisan's work on her social media handles is more direct and it entirely focuses on this single transaction. Although this is also a good approach, it doesn't necessarily imply the artist will benefit outside of this specific instance.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nJill's negotiation in Scenario 1 is just a bit more favorable because it suggests a larger investment and potential for repeated business, which would most likely be more attractive to a local artisan attempting to sell their work and sustain their business.\", \"Reasoning: \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill has not only shown interest in purchasing the round flower vase but has also communicated her intention to continue coming back to purchase more items in the future. This implies that granting her a discount could foster a long-term customer relationship that could be beneficial for my business in the long run. Additionally, Jill offers promotion for my products on her social media platforms. This is not trivial, as it could significantly broaden my customer base, depending on her following and engagement rate. Knowing this, I would be more willing to reduce the price for her, as she could bring me additional revenue through her network and continuous patronage.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill makes a similar proposition for a discount in exchange for social media promotion. Despite expressing admiration for the vase, Jill doesn't express the same ongoing commitment to purchasing further products as in Scenario 1. Thus, while social media promotion would still be beneficial, the potential for a long-term customer relationship - and therefore consistent profit - is not as clear.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning Text:\\n\\nJill used similar tactics in both scenarios. However, there are a few differences between the methods she used that might make one more appealing than the other. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill first appreciates the quality of the artisan\\'s work and then introduces the idea of becoming a regular customer. She makes it clear that she\\'s a frequent shopper at the market and her interest in supporting local artisans is emphasized. The possibility of returning purchases, whether it be for personal use or for gifts, indicates potential future income. Further, she proposes an exchange of promotion for a discount, in what she calls an \"equivalent exchange\". This proposal has immediate and potential benefits: a sale now and an increase in the artisan\\'s exposure, leading to possibly more sales in the future.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill takes a more direct route. She immediately compliments the piece she\\'s interested in and then dives into negotiating with an offer of promoting the artisan\\'s work on her social media platforms. This could certainly also bring future sales, but without the promise of her return business, the appeal is slightly less than that in the first scenario. \\n\\nOverall, while both scenarios have their merits, the first one is more appealing because it offers a broader range of benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill presents a more compelling argument in favor of a discount. Firstly, she intends to become a regular customer which provides an additional source of stable income for me as the artisan. The promise of future purchases offsets the discount on the current purchase and incentivises me to keep her as a satisfied customer. \\n\\nSecondly, Jill's offer to promote my work on her social media further adds to the value she brings as a customer. This isn't just about selling a single vase, but potentially attracting more customers to my stall, thereby increasing the income in the long run. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill's proposition is similar but less detailed. She offers promoting my work on her social media as her only negotiating point and does not mention the prospect of becoming a returning customer.\\n\\nConsidering the future implications of both scenarios, I'd say Scenario 1 provides more added value to my business in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision on whether to negotiate the price or not would largely depend on a variety of factors including the cost incurred in making the vase, the existing profit margin, the perceived value of the vase, among others. However, looking at the two scenarios, I would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering more than just a social media shout-out. She's planning on being a repeat customer, which means steady business in the long run, and she's also willing to advertise my work to potentially thousands of people. It's not just about the sale of a single item, but the potential for future sales as well, possibly at full price. Plus, her followers might visit not just for the vase alone but also for other items leading to a broader customer base. \\n\\nMoreover, she's respectful, acknowledging the fair price of the vase and the quality of the work that went into it. She's treating the negotiation as a collaboration, not a haggling contest, which makes her a pleasant customer to deal with.\\n\\nThe social media following, while similar in both scenarios, is presented as an additional possible source of customers in the first scenario, rather than the sole incentive for a discount as in the second scenario. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill appeals to potentially promote the business through her large social media following, which is a beneficial proposition. However, in Scenario 1, Jill shows a deeper understanding, appreciation of the artisan's work and also mentions her intention to return in the future. The commitment to be a returning customer appeals to a long term benefit for the business, making scenario 1 more appealing.\\n\\nMoreover, in Scenario 1, Jill recognizes the price as fair for its quality before asking for a discount. This shows respect for the artisan's work, which helps in building a good rapport, unlike in Scenario 2 where she directly asks for a discount.\\n\\nThus, considering the future business prospects, respect for the work, understanding of craftsmanship, and potential promotion through social media, the artisan would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.15\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are compelling as they offer perceived value beyond the immediate sale, but effectively, both scenarios are very similar - Jill is offering to promote the artisan's work on social media in exchange for a discount. \\n\\nHowever, I would lean more towards Scenario 1, primarily because Jill mentions the intention of becoming a repeat customer. This signals potential for future sales which could lead to a sustained relationship and long-term value, and therefore would make me more willing to negotiate the price. The proposal of her featuring the vase (and possibly future purchases) on her social media page adds value, as it's essentially free advertising for my work and can help attract new customers.\\n\\nTherefore, my answer is Scenario 1.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide Jill with a strong bargaining position, as she plans to promote your work on social media and become a loyal customer. However, there are slight differences in her approach in each scenario, which could potentially affect decision making.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill explicitly mentions her intentions as a repeat customer and plans to buy more items in the future. This commitment not only provides immediate sales but a promise for future ones. Furthermore, she lays out her plans about promoting your work on her social media, giving concrete ideas about how she can provide value back to your business. These factors add a layer of assurance and potential benefits for you as an artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill does mention social media promotion, she does not outline any intention of becoming a loyal customer buying multiple items overtime. In spite of her generous offer of promotion, the absence of a pledge for continued patronage might make her offer slightly less appealing compared to the first scenario.\\n\\nTherefore, my decision would depend on what I value more as an artisan – immediate and future sales (potential repeat business) or one-time boosted social media exposure.\\n\\nAnswer: If both short-term gains and long-term relationships with customers are a priority, then Scenario 1 would be preferred when it comes to negotiating a price for the vase.', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nUpon reading Scenario 1 and Scenario 2, both scenarios make compelling arguments for a potential discount. Jill promises future patronage in both cases and also promises to promote the product and the artisan shop to her large social media following. \\n\\nHowever, the promise of future purchasing and potential advertising through her social media is more explicit in Scenario 1. In this scenario, Jill clearly states her plans for future visits and the likely purchases she will make. Additionally, she also underscores her intent to give exposure to my work by featuring the vase and sharing my shop\\'s information with her followers, outlining a more detailed intent. \\n\\nAlthough Scenario 2 also floats the idea of social media promotions and potential for future patronage, it seems less direct in its assertions compared to Scenario 1. There are promises made, but they are hedged in softer language (\"would be more than happy to share a post\" and \"could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience\") and lacks details compared to Scenario 1.\\n\\nOverall, I am more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1, because it offers more explicit commitments. Even though Scenario 2 is roughly similar, it lacks certain details present in the first scenario, making it less appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "human scores: 5.9 5.35\n",
      "evaluator: artisan\n",
      "MWU result: 0.3333333333333333\n",
      "flipped: False\n",
      "parsed_answers: [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "user_prompt: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? Please think step by step and explain your reasoning. \n",
      "Put your response in the following format:\n",
      "[reasoning text]\n",
      "\n",
      "Answer: Scenario [1 or 2]\n",
      "\n",
      "reasoning: [\"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Both scenarios offer similar negotiations for a potential discount - recurring patronage and social media promotion. However, Scenario 1 provides more detailed information and expresses stronger commitment.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill presumes a regular return to purchase more items, which signals a promising future business and prospective repeat customer. This would encourage me as an artisan to develop a loyal customer relationship, which might translate into more sales. Offering a discount on the vase might be the start of a potentially profitable business relationship.\\n\\nAlso, Jill offers me a clear proposition about posting her purchase on her social media, stating that she has a large following interested in home décor and DIY. If her audience is inclined towards home decoration, it increases the likelihood of interested prospects for my work, which could lead to higher visibility and wider customer reach.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 also proposes a social media post and potential future purchases, but it appears less specific and doesn't make a definite commitment about being a repeat customer. The proposition is comparatively weaker.\\n\\nTherefore, from a business perspective, I am more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1 than in Scenario 2.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In both the scenarios, Jill is offering almost the same propositions: potential future business and social media exposure to negotiate the price of the vase. While the offers are similar, the presentation and the approach in scenario 1 seem more professional and are more detailed. Here, Jill straightforwardly mentions the possibility of recurring purchases, which can lead to a steady source of income for your business. While scenario 2 has a similar proposition, it lacks this clear specification. \\n\\nFurthermore, in scenario 1, Jill also puts across her intention of promoting your work on her social media more concretely, claiming that she has 'quite a large following,' which implies that your brand can benefit from this visibility significantly. While scenario 2 is somewhat similar, it again lacks this assurance. The manner of presentation and the detailed proposing found in scenario 1 gives an impression that Jill is serious about her offers, making it more likely for you to negotiate the price of the vase with her.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is approaching the negotiation with similar strategies, mainly, offering free exposure and promotion on her social media channels as well as the potential of continuing business through repeat purchases. However, when it comes to negotiating, a clear intention, respectful tone, and a well-structured argument often work more in favor.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship of the piece but also acknowledges the fair pricing given the quality. This shows respect and understanding towards the artist's work. Additionally, Jill provides a clear incentive in her negotiation by stating her intention of being a repeat customer, which ensures future business. Adding to this, she offers to promote the artisan shop among her social media followers, which could potentially lead to more customers.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2, while quite similar, lacks the element of committing to repeat business, instead, focusing more on the social media promotion aspect.\\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios have compelling arguments, Scenario 1, where Jill presents a more comprehensive proposition including ongoing business relationship and promotion, would be more appealing and hence, we could be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# print out the reasonings for items in look_at_points\n",
    "\n",
    "for item in look_at_points:\n",
    "    i, j, k, l = item[\"i\"], item[\"j\"], item[\"k\"], item[\"l\"]\n",
    "\n",
    "    for evaluator in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators\"):\n",
    "        if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}\"):\n",
    "            with open(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}/compare_results/{i}_{j}_{k}_{l}.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "                comparison = json.load(f)\n",
    "    \n",
    "            print(f\"human scores: {item['score1']} {item['score2']}\")\n",
    "            print(f\"evaluator: {evaluator}\")\n",
    "            print(f\"MWU result: {result}\")\n",
    "            print(f\"flipped: {comparison['flipped']}\")\n",
    "            print(f\"parsed_answers: {comparison['parsed_answers']}\")\n",
    "            if type(comparison['user_prompt']) == type([]):\n",
    "                user_prompt = comparison['user_prompt'][0]['content']\n",
    "            else: user_prompt = comparison['user_prompt']['content']\n",
    "            print(f\"user_prompt: {user_prompt}\\n\")\n",
    "            print(f\"reasoning: {comparison['responses']}\\n\\n\")\n"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 287,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "# check that the weighted MWU matrix is correct\n",
    "\n",
    "# get the weighted MWU matrix\n",
    "path = f\"{scenario}/MWU_matrix_weighted.npy\"\n",
    "weighted_MWU_matrix = np.load(path)\n",
    "\n",
    "# get the weights\n",
    "with open(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/weights.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    weights = json.load(f)\n",
    "\n",
    "MWU_constructed_matrix = np.zeros(weighted_MWU_matrix.shape)\n",
    "\n",
    "# get each MWU matrix and the weights\n",
    "for evaluator in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/\"):\n",
    "    if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}\"):\n",
    "        MWU_matrix = np.load(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}/MWU_matrix.npy\")\n",
    "\n",
    "        for d in weights:\n",
    "            if d[\"evaluator\"] == evaluator:\n",
    "                weight = d[\"weight\"]\n",
    "                break\n",
    "        \n",
    "        MWU_constructed_matrix += MWU_matrix * int(weight)/100\n",
    "\n",
    "assert np.allclose(weighted_MWU_matrix, MWU_constructed_matrix)\n"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 223,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "<matplotlib.collections.PathCollection at 0x7fc7ceed15b0>"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 223,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 19944 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# PLOT MATCHES\n",
    "data = comparison_points\n",
    "\n",
    "import matplotlib.pyplot as plt\n",
    "# Separate the data based on the 'match' values\n",
    "x_match_0 = [x for x, y, result, match in data if match == 0]\n",
    "y_match_0 = [y for x, y, result, match in data if match == 0]\n",
    "\n",
    "x_match_0_5 = [x for x, y, result, match in data if match == 0.5]\n",
    "y_match_0_5 = [y for x, y, result, match in data if match == 0.5]\n",
    "\n",
    "x_match_1 = [x for x, y, result, match in data if match == 1]\n",
    "y_match_1 = [y for x, y, result, match in data if match == 1]\n",
    "\n",
    "# Create the scatter plot with different colors\n",
    "plt.scatter(x_match_0, y_match_0, color='red', label='match=0')\n",
    "plt.scatter(x_match_0_5, y_match_0_5, color='yellow', label='match=0.5')\n",
    "plt.scatter(x_match_1, y_match_1, color='green', label='match=1')"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 103,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "Text(0.5, 0, 'Result')"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 103,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 6116 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "result_match_0 = [result for x, y, result, match in data if match == 0]\n",
    "result_match_0_5 = [result for x, y, result, match in data if match == 0.5]\n",
    "result_match_1 = [result for x, y, result, match in data if match == 1]\n",
    "\n",
    "# Create the scatter plot with different colors\n",
    "plt.scatter(result_match_0, [0] * len(result_match_0), color='red', label='match=0')\n",
    "plt.scatter(result_match_0_5, [0.5] * len(result_match_0_5), color='yellow', label='match=0.5')\n",
    "plt.scatter(result_match_1, [1] * len(result_match_1), color='green', label='match=1')\n",
    "\n",
    "# Set labels and legend\n",
    "plt.xlabel('Result')"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 104,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "0.5266343825665859\n"
     ]
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 5284 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# get any remapping\n",
    "evaluator = \"artisan\"\n",
    "with open(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}/mappings_remapped.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    remapping = json.load(f)[0]\n",
    "\n",
    "# get the weighted MWU matrix\n",
    "path = f\"{scenario}/MWU_matrix_weighted.npy\"\n",
    "MWU_matrix = np.load(path)\n",
    "\n",
    "# unorthodox entries grouped by participant\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == 'unorthodox_advice']\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby('participant_id')[['advice_type', 'advice_indices', 'generation_index', 'answer']]\n",
    "\n",
    "participant_ids = []\n",
    "totals = []\n",
    "participant_matches = []\n",
    "total_matches = 0\n",
    "total_total = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "for name, group in grouped: # for each participant\n",
    "\n",
    "    if name not in competent_participants and name not in maybe_competent_participants:\n",
    "        continue\n",
    "\n",
    "    participant_match = 0\n",
    "    total = 0\n",
    "    \n",
    "    for i in range(len(group)):\n",
    "        for j in range(i+1, len(group)): # for each pair of ratings from the participant\n",
    "\n",
    "            # get the MWU index\n",
    "            advice_indices_i = group.iloc[i]['advice_indices']\n",
    "            if (advice_indices_i == \"[]\" or advice_indices_i == \"nan\"): continue\n",
    "            advice_MWU_index_i = int(remapping[str(advice_indices_i) + \".json\"])\n",
    "\n",
    "            advice_indices_j = group.iloc[j]['advice_indices']\n",
    "            if (advice_indices_j == \"[]\" or advice_indices_j == \"nan\"): continue\n",
    "            advice_MWU_index_j = int(remapping[str(advice_indices_j) + \".json\"])\n",
    "\n",
    "            # find the comparison in the MWU matrix\n",
    "            generation_index_i = int(group.iloc[i]['generation_index'])\n",
    "            generation_index_j = int(group.iloc[j]['generation_index'])\n",
    "\n",
    "            gpt_result = MWU_matrix[advice_MWU_index_i][advice_MWU_index_j][generation_index_i][generation_index_j]\n",
    "            \n",
    "            # human scores\n",
    "            score_i = group.iloc[i]['answer']\n",
    "            score_j = group.iloc[j]['answer']\n",
    "\n",
    "            if (score_i > score_j and gpt_result > 0.5) or \\\n",
    "               (score_i < score_j and gpt_result < 0.5) or \\\n",
    "               (math.isclose(score_i, score_j) and math.isclose(gpt_result, 0.5)):\n",
    "                participant_match += 1\n",
    "            elif math.isclose(gpt_result, 0.5) or \\\n",
    "                 math.isclose(score_i, score_j):\n",
    "                participant_match += 0.5\n",
    "\n",
    "            total += 1\n",
    "\n",
    "    participant_ids.append(name)\n",
    "    totals.append(total)\n",
    "    participant_matches.append(participant_match / total)\n",
    "    total_matches += participant_match\n",
    "    total_total += total\n",
    "\n",
    "plt.hist(participant_matches, bins=21)\n",
    "print(total_matches / total_total)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 288,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "# correct = 0\n",
    "# total_competent = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "# for i in range(len(participant_ids)):\n",
    "#     if participant_ids[i] in competent_participants:\n",
    "#         correct += participant_matches[i] * totals[i]\n",
    "#         total_competent += totals[i]\n",
    "\n",
    "# print(correct / total_competent)\n",
    "\n",
    "# for i in range(len(participant_ids)):\n",
    "#     if participant_ids[i] in maybe_competent_participants:\n",
    "#         correct += participant_matches[i] * totals[i]\n",
    "#         total_competent += totals[i]\n",
    "\n",
    "# print(correct / total_competent)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 78,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "participant 18 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 2, score 4\n",
      "2_3, generation 1, score 9\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present strong cases, but for different reasons. In Scenario 1, Jill is proposing a trade-off that isn't just financial. She offers to use her significant social media following to promote my business in exchange for a discount. If her following is indeed substantial and engaged, this could lead to a much larger return on investment in the long run, potentially bringing in new customers that far outweigh the discount I would be providing. Moreover, Jill also indicates her intent to be a returning customer and possibly buy multiple items, which again points towards potential future earnings.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill loves the vase but is asking for a price negotiation purely based on her budget constraints. While this is a common practice, especially in a market setting, it doesn't offer as much potential benefit as Scenario 1.\\n\\nBefore making the decision, I would need to consider the potential value of the free promotion and likelihood of repeat purchases from Jill in the future. It's also important to consider my current financial situation and whether I can afford to offer a discount. If the promises of Scenario 1 seem tangible after discussion with Jill, I might lean towards that.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 is more likely.\", \"In both scenarios, Jill is expressing a deep interest in the round flower vase and seems keen to support local artisan work. She's also hinting at the possibility of negotiating the price in both situations.\\n\\nHowever, Scenario 1 provides more motivation for a potential price twist. Here, Jill is not only interested in the flower vase, but also is suggesting buying more items as a repeated customer, which would mean future business. Moreover, she is willing to use her significant social media platform to promote the products, thus providing free advertisement, which could lead to increased sales, more market visibility and brand awareness.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 seems more about Jill trying to stretch her budget. While it's a legitimate concern, it doesn't promise future business or provide the artisan with an added benefit such as free advertising. Jill simply mentions an appreciation of unique work and wanting to support local artisans but doesn't offer much beyond that.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the long-term benefits and the potential of securing a returning customer with marketing benefits, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\nJill's negotiation method varies between the two scenarios, with distinct approaches in each. In the first scenario, she not only mentions a potential future business by becoming a returning customer but also introduces the prospect of promoting the business on her sizeable social media following. This suggestion of a broader audience for my products through social media could mean more visibility and potentially higher sales. It sounds like an equivalent exchange and also builds upon a potentially beneficial relationship going forward.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill is asking for a price reduction based on her budget constraints, which could be just a one-time transaction. It doesn't promise any continued support or additional marketing for my product line. While her appreciation for my work is sincere, it lacks the potential benefits present in the first scenario.\\n\\nTherefore, considering these factors, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in the first scenario where there are additional perks beyond the immediate sale. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 18 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "1, generation 2, score 4\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[Reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is polite, appreciative of the craftsmanship, and stresses her intent to support local artisans, which can encourage negotiation. However, the circumstances are slightly different in each scenario.\\n\\nScenario 1 brings up the idea of Jill being a potential repeat customer, which is indicative of building a long-term business relationship. By conceding a bit on the price now, you could potentially secure more future sales, which could make up for the initial discount. Being a repeat customer, she would also be likely to recommend your work to others, bringing in potential new customers. \\n\\nOn the other hand, while scenario 2 stresses the admiration and intent to support local craft, it is more centered on her budget constraints rather than the potential of a long-term customer relationship where she might return to make more purchases. \\n\\nOverall, while both scenarios present strong cases, scenario 1 hints more towards a longer-term customer relationship which could be beneficial to the business in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning: One of the most important aspects in negotiating prices is building a rapport with the customer. A big part of that is communicating genuine interest and respect for the product and its maker. In both scenarios, Jill demonstrates this, but there is one key difference: in Scenario 1, Jill explicitly mentions her intention to be a repeat customer, suggesting that she is not only interested in buying a single item, but also potentially many more in the future. This would incentivize the seller to offer a discount, as it could establish a loyal customer and further purchases. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: Both scenarios exhibit Jill's appreciative approach towards the local artisans work. However, Scenario 1 inclines a bit more towards a win-win negotiation. This is primarily because Jill not only appreciates the work, but also expresses her intention to be a repeat customer, which indicates potential long term business. This makes it more appealing, as it's not just about a one-off transaction but also establishes a prospect of future purchases. Jill has also explicitly asked about discounts for repeat customers, which provides an additional reason to consider negotiating the price. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 18 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer some form of negotiation or barter system. Scenario 1 showcases Jill as a returning customer who is looking for a discount based on her loyalty and future purchases. This suggests a guaranteed future business which can be very valuable. Customer retention is of utmost importance in small businesses like a local market artisan.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers a potential for wider outreach and marketing exposure in exchange for a discount. This could potentially bring more customers in the long run. However, this involves a risk, as the impact of such promotion would be hard to measure. Additionally, it would be hard to validate the extent of Jill's social media reach and influence.\\n\\nOverall, while social media marketing can be attractive, the value of a loyal customer should not be underestimated, particularly for a small trader within a local setting. So, based on the information provided, a guaranteed future business versus a potential one, makes scenario 1 a more palpable choice.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows appreciation for the craft and expresses a genuine interest in buying the vase. However, there are key differences as well that vary the level of leverage the customer holds to negotiate. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions that she is a repeat customer and expresses an intention to keep supporting the work in the future. This possibility of a long-term business relationship presents a potential benefit to the seller in terms of sustained sales, not just one-time. Therefore, giving a discount to a repeat customer could secure more sales in the future uplifting the overall business. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 offers the benefit of free word-of-mouth marketing, which has the potential to bring in even more customers. Jill proposes to promote the work on her social media platforms, which could potentially be seen by hundreds or even thousands of people. Yet, this form of advertising is not guaranteed. While internet exposure can be beneficial and lead to increased sales and brand awareness, Jill's actual reach and influence are unknown. She could have a myriad of followers, few, or none who are interested in the purchases she makes. This makes her offered publicity a bit risky.\\n\\nTaking these points into consideration, although both scenarios bring their unique benefits, the promise of a loyal repeated customer provides an assured return on investment.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present plausible circumstances, however, they put forward different approaches and incentives for negotiating the vase's price. Scenario 1 exhibits a potential long-term customer, hinting at future purchases and continual support for my craft. This could suggest a steady revenue stream, making the price negotiation more appealing. \\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, seeks a more immediate, one-time discount based on social media promotion. Relying on this method for potential sales could be risky, as it is dependent on Jill's followers' interest in my work and their willingness to purchase. Yet, it might bring broader visibility to my creations to a potentially larger customer base.\\n\\nEven though Scenario 2 could potentially raise the profile of my work, as a local artisan who values repeat business and building relationships with customers, I would gravitate more towards Scenario 1. This scenario presents a more reliable, long-term engagement where I could predict and rely on future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 2, score 7\n",
      "3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAs an artisan, it's always rewarding when customers acknowledge the effort and passion put into the work. Each piece sold supports my livelihood and enables me to continue crafting. In such situations, deciding on whether to give a discount can be tricky and varies case-by-case.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill has complimented my work and simultaneously expressed her financial constraints. She has shown appreciation for the effort I've put into the vase and wants to support local artisans. This suggests that she values my work beyond mere transaction – she understands my motivation behind crafting such items. Given the sincerity in her approach, I might be inclined to give her a small discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also acknowledges my craftsmanship and offers to promote my work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. This offer is certainly tempting because it could potentially bring more customers to my stall in the future. However, it's not precisely clear how influential her network is or how effective her promotion will be. Additionally, it's worth considering whether such business-like bartering matches my values as an artisan who appreciates the non-financial aspect of her craft.\\n\\nConsequently, while both scenarios hold desirable outcomes, one carries a risk with an uncertain potential. Thus, my decision would largely depend on my belief in the authenticity of the customer's claim and situation.\\n\\nAnswer: Further inquiry would be needed for Scenario 2, for instance, finding out more about Jill’s influence, followers, and commitment to promote the work. As it stands presently, I would be more likely to negotiate the vase price in Scenario 1 due to the clear and genuine appreciation and acknowledgment of financial constraints without the need for potential uncertainties.\", \"The potential to negotiate on the price of the vase could be found in both scenarios. However, each scenario focuses on different aspects that might motivate a change in price.\\n\\nScenario 1 sees Jill highlighting her appreciation for the artisan craft and the effort put into the vase. She also discloses her financial situation. Assuming she genuinely cannot afford the marked price and isn't just haggling, empathy on our part might lead to a small discount. Indeed as an artisan, the appreciation of craftsmanship and the intent to support local artisans could be a powerful driving factor. By selling at a lower price, we not only make a sale but also establish a customer relationship that may lead to future purchases and word-of-mouth recommendations.\\n\\nScenario 2, on the other hand, offers a form of barter trade -- promotion of craftsmanship in exchange for a discount. Here, Jill is effectively offering a marketing service which could bring more attention, and potentially customers, to our work. Scenario 2 also signifies a business partnership of sorts, offering the potential for long-term mutual benefits. \\n\\nKeeping everything in mind, I would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. While the recognition of our craft in Scenario 1 is appreciated, the concrete addition of value (potential new customers and exposure) from Jill's promotion in Scenario 2 makes it more attractive. Therefore:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe goal of selling at a local market is not just to make profits but also to foster a strong relationship with the local customers and build your customer base. In both scenarios, the customer, Jill, has complimented my work which shows she values my craft. However, they differ in their approach to asking for a discount.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill emphasizes her budget constraint and her interest in supporting local artisans. Here, she is directly engaging with my work and shows a genuine appreciation for the craft. By her statement, she is likely to return again and purchase more pieces in the future.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also expresses her appreciation but offers to promote me to her followers on social media in exchange for a discount. While this can be valuable, it is also a bit riskier. There's no guarantee this exposure will translate into sales or that her followers will be interested in my work.\\n\\nConsidering these points, while the offer of promotion is tempting, I would be more likely to negotiate in scenario 1. This is because Jill is emphasizing a personal connection to my work and not just viewing it as a commodity. Even though she is asking for a discount now due to budget constraints, she seems more likely to make future purchases at the full price, leading to sustainable business growth.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 2, score 7\n",
      "3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning text:\\n\\nBoth scenarios put forward by Jill offer reasons for a potential price negotiation, but they offer different benefits.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media platforms to a large audience. Depending on the size and quality of her following, this could directly result in increased sales, more recognition of my brand, and potentially more opportunities down the line. It's essentially proposing a trade- a discount now for valuable promotion and advertisement which could prove potentially more profitable in the long run. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is not offering anything concrete in return for a discount other than her goodwill and patronage. While supporting customers who earnestly appreciate craft and are genuinely constrained by their budget is admirable, it doesn't necessarily helps the business in a tangible way like the first scenario. \\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios might warrant some sort of discount, from a business standpoint, Scenario 1 presents a concrete value proposition and provides a potential return on the price reduction.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill presents a value exchange. She doesn't simply ask for a discount, she offers to share a post about the artisan's works on her social media platforms, exposing the artisan to a potential new customer base. This is a form of barter trade where she uses her social influence as commodity for a supposed price reduction. This could be beneficial to the artisan especially if Jill does have a significant social media following. It could lead to a wider visibility and subsequently more sales. So, the artisan might see an overall benefit that outweighs the discount given.\\n\\nOn the other hand, the second scenario is a more typical negotiation where the buyer expresses their constraint and appeals to the seller's empathy, hoping they understand the budget constraint and offer a discount. It is great that Jill wants to support local artisans, but apart from her goodwill, there's no direct benefit to the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\nIn scenario 1, Jill brings a potential benefit to my business by offering to promote my work on her social media platforms. This kind of exposure can indeed help attract new customers and expand my audience, which can escalate my sales. On top of this, she acknowledges the value of the work, implying that she understands the effort and craftsmanship involved in creating the vase. A small discount here could yield a greater return on investment in the form of new customers in the long run.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill's appreciation for my work and her intention to support local artisans like myself is clear and admirable, her request for a discount is solely based on her personal financial constraints. There is no immediate or potential benefit to my business in this scenario.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 2, score 7\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a sensitive and considerate buyer who appreciates the value of handcrafting. However, she raises the question of price negotiation differently in each case. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she not only shows interest in purchasing several items but also expresses her intention of becoming a regular customer. She proffers reasons relating to potential frequent patronage and bulk purchase, which can present valid grounds for a price negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, her compliment about the vase and the passion put into it garners sympathy. Nevertheless, she only mentions wanting to purchase this single item and merely asks for a possible small discount based on her budget constraints, rather than presenting a condition or a promise of further business that could benefit you as an artisan in the long run. \\n\\nGiven these considerations, the preference would tend towards a scenario where there is potential for repeated business and a higher purchase volume. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her admiration and interest in the handcrafted piece while also making it clear that she wants to financially support local artists. However, their approaches to asking for a discount vary slightly.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill mentions a potential interest in buying multiple items and also indicates she will be a returning customer. This can be advantageous for an artisan, as it means not only immediate sales but possibly future ones as well. It offers the opportunity to build a relationship with the customer and provides more assurance that the discount is not simply a one-off deal but rather might lead to future business. Here, negotiation on the vase's price can also open the conversation about the pricing of other items, potentially leading to a larger sale.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while Jill expresses her interest and admiration, she only talks about her budget constraint and asks for a discount on the single item she has chosen. While a discount might lead to a sale, it doesn't necessarily offer the prospects of further business or the potential sale of multiple items presented in scenario 1.\\n\\nBased on these comparisons, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in...\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios portray a customer who is willing to support local artisans, appreciates the skill involved in handcrafting the vase, and is interested in buying. But they differ in their proposals for a price reduction.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, the customer suggests possibilities for future purchases, either of multiple items in one go or repeated visits to the market. This implies the development of a potentially long-term customer relationship, which could include upselling or cross-selling opportunities. Jill is offering a potential promise of giving regular business and thus, might seem more open to giving a concession.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, the customer does appreciate the work but only requests a discount on the basis of budget constraints. Their message of support is clear, but there is no future commitment or possibility for further purchases stated.\\n\\nFrom a business perspective, although a sale is a sale, a customer that brings potential repeat business is more valuable in the long run. Thus, if forced to choose, I would lean towards negotiating in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 2, score 7\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill acknowledges the quality of the work and expresses interest in the vase. However, the two scenarios differentiate in the values they offer back to me, the artisan. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only interested in acquiring the vase, but also indicates that she is most likely to make multiple purchases and will become a returning customer. Additionally, she might also become a source of free promotion for my handcrafted items by sharing on her social platform and help me reach a wider audience, potentially driving more sales. This indicates that she values the art and craft market and would likely become a regular patron, which is very beneficial for me as a seller.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill is definitely admiring the work and appreciates my effort, which is nice to hear. However, she only mentions a personal budget constraint and the wish to support local artisans. She doesn't offer any additional incentive like becoming a regular customer or publicizing the work on social media. \\n\\nThus, while both Jill's expressions of admiration are gratifying, Scenario 1 offers more potential long-term benefits to my business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons for the artisan to consider a discount, but for different reasons. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is suggesting a possible long-term relationship with the artisan. Not only does she mention that she’s a returning customer, but she also hints at possible future purchases and offers to promote the stall on her social media platform, which could bring in more customers in the future. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill provides a compliment to the artisan’s work, expressing her support for local craftsmen. She shows a good understanding and appreciation of the value of handcrafted items, which the artisan might appreciate. However, she also mentions that she has a limited budget.\\n\\nWhile scenario 2 definitely lends itself to a possible negotiation, the first scenario provides a potentially more beneficial situation for the artisan in the longer term, through repeated business and free advertising.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios raised by Jill involve making some concessions on the price of the vase. However, the proposals differ significantly.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill puts forward several valid points for a discount. She expresses interest in buying multiple items and becoming a regular customer, which are beneficial to any business. Beyond that, Jill offers to utilize her considerable social media following to provide free publicity for my work. This kind of advertising could potentially broaden my customer base and increase my sales. So even though I will be giving a discount, the benefits provided in return would likely outweigh the minor loss.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill doesn't offer anything beyond the potential for regular patronage. While I appreciate her compliments and willingness to support local artisans, these kind words don't provide a tangible benefit to my business. Furthermore, budget constraints are unfortunately a common occurrence and I cannot provide discounts to every customer who expresses such limitations, as doing so could harm my earnings.\\n\\nFor these reasons, Scenario 1 presents a more compelling case for a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 2, score 7\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is making an emotional appeal by not only complimenting your work but also by expressing her desire to support local artisans. She acknowledges the value of your craft and is suggesting a partnership where she promotes your work on her social media. This may not bring an immediate return on the discount you give but it can certainly help in the long run by increasing your visibility and customer base.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill is also appreciative of the work, she only requests for a small discount without offering anything in return. \\n\\nTherefore, considering Jill's compliment towards the artisan's work, her willingness to support local artisans, and the proposed exchange of services, Scenario 1 gives a better chance of initiating a negotiation for a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are rather persuasive, however, Jill's approach in Scenario 1 is a bit more compelling. This is because, not only does she state her case in a manner that feels personal and appreciative of your craft, but she also offers an opportunity for a beneficial trade-off, proposing to promote your business on her social media platform.\\n\\nThis type of exposure can help not only in immediate terms, eventually leading to more sales, but also in the longer term, as it boosts your business's visibility and potentially allows it to reach a much wider audience than you might normally have access to. In essence, by accepting her offer for a slight discount, you're gaining an opportunity to market your product beyond your current reach.\\n\\nPlus, there's also a psychological element at play here: by offering to help out your business in some way, Jill portrays herself as more of an ally rather than just another customer looking for a discount. This sense of mutual benefit and reciprocity makes it more appealing to negotiate with her.\\n\\nSo, in weighing both scenarios, the first scenario seems more inviting for negotiation, not only because it can bear additional fruit for your business, but also because it enhances a sense of community and mutual support, which can be especially valuable in a local market set-up where personal connections matter quite a bit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show a genuine interest in the product and an understanding of the value of handcrafted items, which is already a good start for a negotiation. However, in Scenario 1 Jill provides an additional value proposition. She offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media which might have potential to reach more customers and hence could potentially bring in more sales. This way, the artisan might not only be recouping the potential loss from the discount given but also gain in another form. This tactic is effective because it not only appeals to the artisan's need to make sales, but also suggests a potential for future business.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 is a straight-forward financial negotiation based on Jill's budget constraints which is a valid reason but doesn't provide an immediate benefit to the artisan in exchange for the discount.\\n\\nTherefore, Jill's proposal in Scenario 1 not only acknowledges the value of handmade goods, but also provides a solution that might be mutually beneficial.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present an intriguing proposition. However, I would consider additional factors before making a decision. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill shows appreciation for the effort that I have put into my craft and gives a valid reason for asking for a discount. She bares her personal circumstances; her budget does not permit her to purchase the item at the given price. As she is a devoted supporter of local artisans, I can anticipate that she would visit my stand again to purchase more items in the future. This might encourage me to offer a small discount on the vase this time, building a loyal customer relationship for future sales. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers to promote my work on social media, which can potentially provide broader market exposure. However, there are uncertainties. Will her promotional efforts actually translate into increased sales for my products? How effective will her promotion be, and does she have a following that is potentially interested in my kind of work? These are factors to consider before offering a discount.\\n\\nWeighting up both scenarios, I'm leaning towards Scenario 1. The tangible benefit of making a sale now and potentially developing a loyal customer with this discount outweighs the uncertainty of future sales that might (or might not) result from a promotion in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: Both scenarios present viable reasons for price negotiation. Jill delivers her argument in a respectful and complimentary manner, recognizing the artisan's skill and craftsmanship. Scenario 1 bespeaks a buyer appreciating the handmade craft and planning to add it to her home. Nevertheless, she's on a budget, giving her reason to negotiate. Scenario 2 proposes a barter exchange where the artisan might get advertising benefits. However, the effectiveness of her promotion efforts might depend on her followers' number and engagement rate, not easy to determine instantly.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 is more likely to motivate the artisan to negotiate the price because it doesn't involve speculation or uncertainty about the extent of the potential promotional benefit. The artisan is guaranteed a sale, and the small discount would probably be less than the cost and effort required to make use of equivalent advertising elsewhere, making this a good deal even with a small price reduction. The request also respects the artisan's work, and is asked for personal reasons rather than for mutual benefit, which may appeal to the artisan's empathy.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom an artisan's understanding, it's important to value both the financial aspect and the exposure that could come from a sale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is appreciating the craftsmanship and showing genuine love for the product without promising anything extra. Although rewarding, this does not necessarily signify any additional benefit for the future business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill proposes a transaction where she would promote the artisan's work on her social media to her follower base. Such publicity could result in increased visibility and potentially additional sales, which is very beneficial for an artisan's business.\\n\\nWhile I value both scenarios and would consider negotiating a discount for both, the extra advantage offered in Scenario 2 could be more beneficial in the longer term.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering a potential for advertising and marketing, which could potentially bring more customers and increase the overall sales. This is beneficial in the long term even if it means selling the vase at a slightly discounted price. Increased visibility and audience reach is crucial for any business, particularly for small-scale local artisans.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is merely expressing her financial limitations. However, while empathizing with her situation, selling an item below the fair value just because a customer can't afford it is not sound business. It may also set a precedent for other customers to expect similar discounts.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, although selling the vase at a lower price might cut into the immediate returns, the vase can be considered an investment in the form of marketing and promotion, which is essential for growth.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present good arguments for a discount, however, the potential benefits seem more immediate and tangible in Scenario 1. In Scenario 2, Jill mentions she loves supporting local artisans and implies that she might spread the word about your work, but there's no concrete promise. Also, while you want to help customers who are on a budget, you still need to make a living from the sale of your items.\\n\\nIn contrast, Jill's offer in Scenario 1 to promote your craftsmanship on her social media platforms to potentially thousands of people could greatly increase your exposure and attract more customers, which could lead to an increase in sales. This could potentially offset the discount given to her and even bring more profit in the long term.\\n\\nTherefore, taking into consideration the future benefits of increasing your visibility vs a one-time sale, Scenario 1 seems to be a more beneficial deal for you as an artisan in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows a keen interest in the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship involved in creating it. However, my aim as an artisan at a local market is not just to sell my current inventory but also to create long-term customers and expand my customer base.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my craftwork on her social media platforms. If she indeed has a sizeable following, this could bring a significant amount of exposure and potential new customers to my stall. This is essentially free marketing, which is invaluable. Scaling down the price a bit here would be a strategic investment in creating future business prospects, even if it means slight short-term monetary loss.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is looking for a price reduction due to budget constraints. While it's a reasonable request, and I might consider giving her a small discount because she appreciates the work involved and supports local artisans, the benefit for me here isn't as clear as in the first scenario. \\n\\nTherefore, based on the potential for longer-term benefits, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the vase and expresses an interest in supporting local artisans. However, the two situations differ slightly in their approach. In Scenario 1, Jill directly asks for a possible negotiation on the vase's price stating her budget constraints, but in Scenario 2, she subtly asks about discounts for multiple items or future purchases indirectly hinting at negotiation. \\n\\nIn my opinion, Scenario 2 presents a better opportunity for negotiation as Jill not only expresses interest in the vase but also shows potential for future purchases. Offering a small discount to Jill could result in building a long-term customer relationship and demonstrate goodwill for future interactions. She's not just interested in a single item; she could also purchase more items now or be a repeat customer in the future. Hence, the potential profit from future purchases or multiple items may compensate for a small decrease in the price of the vase now.\\n\\nWith this in consideration, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"The best scenario to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill is scenario 1. \\n\\nReasoning:\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments your work genuinely admiring the uniqueness of the vase. Her admiration for your craftsmanship can indicate a deep appreciation for the value of the vase. Jill also mentions that she's negotiates asking for a 'wiggle room,' on the price, implying that the price is just slightly out of her range, giving an indication that she's close to the stealing point, and a slight reduction might secure the sale.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while it comes off as more business-like, the impression it gives is of a bargain hunter looking for a discount. Jill is looking for a deal, asking not only for a discount on this item but seeing if there are further discounts for buying multiple items, or for potential future purchases. There's no certainty here - she 'sees herself coming back', but it is in no way definite. She also suggests that she might buy more items, but again, it's just an implication, not a firm commitment. \\n\\nScenario 1 suggests a real appreciation for the art and a willingness to pay nearly the asking price. Jill seems more likely to value the vase at a price nearly its worth, whereas scenario 2 seems more keen on getting a deal than supporting the value of the artwork. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nThe decision to negotiate the price largely depends on the context that is painted by the customer and the potential for future business gains. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments my craftsmanship and shows enthusiasm and appreciation for the vase, which makes for a favorable initial impression. She also admits that $30 is slightly above her budget, which suggests that she might be more likely to buy the vase if the price is lowered a little. \\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill not only admires the vase but also indicates a clear intent to support local artisans and buy more items in the future. This scenario paints a picture of a potentially loyal customer who could bring in more business over time. She also asks about future discounts, suggesting a plan to purchase more items down the line.\\n\\nGiven both scenarios, I would lean towards offering a discount or negotiating a price in scenario 2. This decision is based on the potential longer-term value that this customer could bring, which could be more valuable over time, even if I take a small hit on the price of the vase today. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a negotiation standpoint, both scenarios present compelling cases for a price adjustment. However, several key factors lead me to favor one scenario over the other. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, showing her acknowledgment of the effort and time put into creating it. She also states her support for local artisans which implies she values the work involved. Jill then expresses her desire for the vase and notes that the price is a bit out of her current budget. Here, Jill is quite honest about her financial situation, which adds credibility to her request for a price adjustment. She is not asking for a considerable discount, just a 'little wiggle room', which suggests she respects the artisan's work and is not trying to undervalue their effort. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 involves Jill asking for potential discounts for multiple purchases or for returning customers. While these propositions may seem appealing, they put the artisan in a spot where they're committing to future discounts without any concrete commitment from Jill apart from her 'plan' of regular visits. The social media aspect she introduces could give the artisan exposure, but it's not guaranteed to translate into sales. It could also set a precedence for the artisan, where they might be expected to offer discounts to anyone promising to promote them on social media.\\n\\nTherefore, based on the above reasoning, I would be more inclined to negotiate with Jill in:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has approached the situation by complimenting the item and acknowledging the work that has gone into it, which is a good starting point for any negotiation. However, her methods of justifying her request for a discount vary quite significantly. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is open about the fact that the price is slightly out of her budget, hinting at the fact that she might not be able to buy the item unless the price is reduced. This may work in her favor as, being a local artisan, I may be more interested in selling my items to people who genuinely appreciate them and will give them a good home, rather than just making a profit.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers two reasons for a potential discount: the possibility of purchasing multiple items and her potential to promote the items on her social media platform. While the promise of future purchases might be appealing, it's not guaranteed. The social media promotion, however, could potentially reach a large audience and attract new customers to the stall, which could generate more sales in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nHaving considered both scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. Her suggestion of promoting my items on her social media platform could be more beneficial to me in the long term, despite being an undefined return. While Scenario 1 is more immediately sympathetic, as a business, potential brand exposure offers greater future opportunity.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere seems to be a greater willingness to compromise price in Scenario 2. Even though they both show interest, Jill from Scenario 2 is giving more reasons and bargaining chips for you to consider lowering your price. She is discussing not only just getting the vase, but also potential repeated business, as she plans to come back to the market often. Moreover, she could potentially help expand your customer base with her social media following, which is an aspect in favor of giving her a discount. In Scenario 1, while Jill shows admiration for your work, she only uses her current budget constraint as an argument, and she does not mention anything about promoting your work, repeat business, or buying multiple items. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both situations presented by Jill promote sympathetic and friendly negotiation, there are a few key differences that make a stronger case for scenario 2. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill points out that the price is a little outside her budget. This is a valid reason and it's common for customers to ask for a discount. However, with the price set at $30, which is reasonable for a handcrafted item, lowering the price solely due to a customer's budget constraints could set a precedent that may not be sustainable in the long run. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill not only states her budgetary reasons, but also proposes a form of barter: promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This additional element can potentially grant exposure of the artisan's work to a wider audience, leading to more sales in the future. This indicates a long-term benefit for the artisan, as opposed to the one-time sale from scenario 1.\\n\\nThus, according to the given scenarios and understanding of the longer-term benefits, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhen approached by a customer for possible negotiation, various factors come into play that could influence our decision. Some of the main ones include the customer's attitude, their appreciation of the craftsmanship and most importantly, the additional value they might bring. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her support for local artisans. She voices that the price is slightly beyond her current budget, but doesn't necessarily bring additional value to the table other than the potential purchase of the vase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill shows similar appreciation and support for local artisans. Besides expressing the financial constraints, she also offers economic plus non-monetary value as well, which she can do through promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This could possibly lead to higher visibility and more sales.\\n\\nWhile both are good scenarios, and it's important to support customers who appreciate craft, Scenario 2 provides an additional dimension that could potentially expand the customer base and increase total business volume. The offer to promote the items on social media provides a future value to the business that could lead to more sales. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show that Jill is interested in buying the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship involved in creating it. However, in Scenario 2, she's offering to promote the work on her social media, which could potentially attract more customers and increase sales. This not only demonstrates a deep level of personal interest but might also bring a longer-term benefit to me as an artisan. The potential for increased exposure and potentially more sales in the future provides an added incentive to consider her request for a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 6\n",
      "3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nComparing both scenarios, the customer Jill is asking for a price negotiation for the vase in both of them. However, her approach is different in each.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she appreciates the artisan's work and implies she might be a repeat customer. This is appealing as the artisan could benefit from a loyal customer who appreciates their work and might buy again in the future. However, there are no guarantees that she will return or purchase more goods.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again offers appreciation and further proposes to advertise the artisan's work on her social media to her followers. This could potentially lead to more customers and greater exposure of the artisan's work for a one-time discount. This might be a win-win situation as the artisan will get advertisement without any extra charge, and in return, Jill gets a small discount on the vase.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential exposure and customer reach that could come from Scenario 2, the artisan might be more likely to negotiate in this case. The artisan may also see it as a small investment into marketing their work.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning: Although both scenarios provide an interesting proposition to negotiate the price, I would lean more toward Scenario 2. Here's why: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill highly appreciates the craftsmanship and seems genuinely interested in the vase. She also proposes to be a potential repeat customer, which is always a positive influence on a small business. However, 'potential' repeat business is not always an ensured prospect, and can sometimes just be a method customers use to try and negotiate lower prices. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only shows interest in the vase but also proposes a form of collaboration wherein she would promote my work to her social network in exchange for a small discount. This can mean a lot for a small business, as it could potentially reach more customers and result in more sales. This type of promotion, especially if Jill has a significant following, can be more valuable than the small discount she's asking for. It's also a more tangible benefit compared to the potential of repeat business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nBetween these two scenarios, it would be more favorable to negotiate in Scenario 2. The main reason is that Jill is offering to promote the work to her social media followers. This can be beneficial in terms of reaching a wider audience and potentially getting more customers in the long run. It's a kind of indirect investment in marketing. In Scenario 1 she merely asks for a discount because she intends to become a repeat customer. While this is not a bad thing, her statement does not guarantee future purchases, and a promise to return for more purchases holds less weight in comparison to Scenario 2 where the benefit is more tangible. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a similar proposition wherein Jill offers promoting the artisan's craftwork on her social media following as a concession for a discount on the vase. However, there are a few distinct differences in the presentation of each scenario that makes one scenario more appealing over the other.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill immediately expresses her interest in buying the vase and directly compliments the artisan's talent, which establishes a positive connection. She proposes her offer straightaway without beating around the bush, giving the artisan the flexibility to consider and negotiate the terms. Her deal is explicit, with a fixed objective - a discount in exchange for a promotion to her network.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, even though Jill compliments the quality and price fairness of the vase, her request for a discount comes across as a bit less genuine due to the lengthy introduction. Additionally, while she does provide an offer to promote the work on her social medias, it's not explicitly mentioned as an exchange for a discount but rather subtly implied, making the purpose of the proposition slightly ambiguous. \\n\\nWhile both scenarios hold merit, the directness and explicitness of Jill's proposal in Scenario 1 may make it more appealing for the artisan when considering to negotiate prices.\\n \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is offering a form of promotion in exchange for a discount on the vase. Here is the breakdown:\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill makes a direct appeal, mentioning the quality of your work and her intention to promote it. However, she does not provide specific details about her follower count, giving more of a general suggestion that it\\'s \"decent.\"\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill is equally appreciative of your work and proposes a similar exchange. However, she specifies that her following on social media is \"considerable,\" implying a larger audience might see her promotion.\\n\\nBased off the amount of potential promotion, you might lean towards scenario 2. However, both scenarios don\\'t provide specific metrics about Jill\\'s social media reach, therefore your decision should also consider factors such as how she communicates, the respect she shows for your work, and the likelihood that she\\'ll follow through with her proposal.\\n\\nNeither scenario guarantees a major increase in sales - a social media shout out may or may not convert into more customers. It\\'s essentially an uncertain form of payment. However, creating good relations with customers who appreciate your work does have value.\\n\\nGiven the above, both scenarios could be seen as potentially benefiting your business, but with some uncertainty and factors to weigh.\\n\\nAnswer: Either scenarios could work depending upon your specific priorities and judgement, but Scenario 2 might be slightly more preferable due to the implication of a larger audience.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer a quid pro quo that ultimately benefits us both. Nevertheless, there are some key differences that will influence my decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is direct, sincere, and communicates her intent clearly. She states her willingness to promote my products to her network, which is definitely a valuable proposition, given the importance of social media in today's marketing landscape. A promotion like that could potentially expand my consumer base. In addition, she also adds a personal note complimenting my artistic skills, showing she appreciates the labor and skills that goes into my work.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is more formal and elaborate but her proposition is pretty much the same as in Scenario 1, with the promise to promote my work on her social media profiles. The tone is more professional, and some artisans might find this approach more appealing. However, it can also come off as more transactional and less personal than Jill's approach in Scenario 1.\\n\\nIn my case preference, I appreciate directness layered with personal touch. Therefore, I would be more inclined towards negotiating the price of the vase in Scenario 1. Jill's upfrontness and appreciation of my work hits the right note, making me feel valued as an artisan, and her promise to promote my work to her network feels like a good trade-off for offering a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[Reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision to offer a discount depends on several factors such as the customer's approach, potential return value to the business, and the chance for future interactions. Here is an analysis of both scenarios:\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill is proposing to use her social media following as a way to promote my work and help the business reach a wider audience. This could substantially increase my brand awareness and generate more sales in the future. The concern here lies in the credibility and reach of her social media accounts, which may need verification before accepting such an arrangement. \\n\\nScenario 2: Jill expresses her love for local artisans' work and mentions her intent to shop more in the future. Although she seems like a repeat customer, there are no tangibles that ensure future sales. Her proposition about discounts for buying multiple items suggests that she would be buying more today, which could generate more immediate income. \\n\\nWhile both scenarios have potential, Scenario 1 holds more promise of benefiting my brand and business in the long term, given that the social media proposal is legitimate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers a trade-off that benefits the artisan beyond the immediate sale. Jill's social media followers could drive additional sales and exposure for the artisan's work, potentially sustaining a steady income source in the longer term. This marketing advantage could outweigh the small discount Jill is asking for on the vase.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill indicates her intent to return and purchase again which is valuable for business sustainability. Offering discounts for return customers or multiple purchases is common in retail and could foster a loyal customer relationship. However, the promise is a bit vague and doesn't have the immediate potential benefit that scenario 1 presents.\\n\\nTherefore, evaluating both alternatives, the artisan would likely prefer the trade-off that brings broader exposure to their work, which could potentially attract more new customers. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes a collaboration to promote my handcrafted items to her network on social media. If her following is significant and relevant, this could potentially bring in sufficient business to compensate for the discount, or even increase my profits overall. In exchange for the benefit of promotion, a price adjustment could be rationalized. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill declares that she appreciates my work and intends to be a repeat customer, there is no concrete benefit offered in exchange for the discount. The promise of future purchases is uncertain, unlike the tangible benefit of promotion in the first scenario.\\n\\nTherefore, based on the potential return on investment and the immediate benefit to my business,\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 6\n",
      "3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\nIn the first scenario, Jill is a repeat customer who promises to be supportive and continue purchasing from you, which means long-term business. But the assurance of those future sales is uncertain. Being a repeat customer doesn't necessarily ensure that they will purchase frequently or purchase other expensive items from your stall.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, however, Jill is willing to promote your work to her considerable follower base on social media. In today's digital age, social media exposure can be tremendously valuable - it's basically free advertising. Even if Jill's followers don't immediately turn into customers, they become aware of your work, potentially increasing your customer base in the long run. The one-time discount in return for the promotion could thus be of more pronounced benefit. \\n\\nHence, based on the potential long-term gain from scenario 2, I'd be more likely to negotiate on the price with Jill in that situation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present good reasons for offering a discount. However, my preference leans towards scenario 2. Here are my reasons:\\n\\n1. Potential Reach: In the second scenario, Jill offers to use her 'considerable' social media following, which provides an opportunity to advertise the craft to a much larger audience than that of the local market, potentially leading to more sales.\\n\\n2. Mutual Benefit: In this same scenario, Jill offers a form of payment beyond money by offering exposure. This benefits both parties. Jill gets her discount, and in return, the artisan gets the promotion and possibly an expanded customer base. Also, it gives the business an online presence if it doesn't have that already.\\n\\n3. An understanding of value: In scenario 2, Jill acknowledges the fairness of the pricing in relation to the work's quality before asking for a discount. This recognition is essential, reflecting her understanding and appreciation of the artisan labor involved, making it easier for the artisan to engage in negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses interest in the vase and admiration for the craftsmanship, indicating that she sees the value of the item. However, the context of their requests for a lower price differs.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill brings up the idea of possibly becoming a repeat customer and hence looks for a discount for her future purchases. While the prospect of a returning customer is appealing, there's no guarantee that her intentions will translate into actual future sales. Furthermore, if a discount were given to her now based on the future promise of buying more, it might set a precedent, and she could expect discounts on every purchase henceforth.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill mentions her substantial social media following and offers to advertise the artisan's work in exchange for a discount. Considering the potential reach to a wider audience, the artisan stands to gain increased visibility and sales. The potential exposure could be invaluable to the artisan, as it could attract new customers who might not have discovered his work otherwise. \\n\\nBased on this reasoning, the artisan might see more value and potential profit in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 6\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows an expressed interest in supporting local artisans and wanting to purchase more items in the future. She puts forth the concept of further supporting your work by coming back to the market for more in the future, showing a long-term commitment to your craft. This implies a relationship and loyalty that could potentially result in repeat business, and possibly her recommending you to others, which is good from a business standpoint.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also shows a love for the vase and intention of returning, her conversation implies that she may not want to spend much today, which could potentially be a negotiation not just on this vase, but on future items as well. The tone is more price-conscious and less about the appreciation of the craft involved.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision between scenario 1 and scenario 2 would greatly depend on how I perceive Jill's interest and how her negotiation appeal resonate with me as an artisan.\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill seems interested in my work, which is encouraging. She also hints at future purchases, which could mean more business for me later on.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 1, Jill specifically compliments my craftsmanship and expresses her desire to continue supporting my work. She also asks for a possible discount directly but respectfully, and I might be more inclined to reward such a dedicated customer.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also emphasizes her support for local artisans and her desire to come back for more purchases. However, she frames the pricing as more of an obstacle and debates on the value of the vase in terms of price rather than its artistry. This could make me feel slightly less appreciated as an artisan.\\n\\nFor these reasons, I am more likely to negotiate on the price with Jill in Scenario 1. While both scenarios show Jill as a potential repeat customer, scenario 1 places a greater emphasis on the value she sees in my craftsmanship, which is more appealing to me and could potentially motivate me to offer her a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios portray a customer who likes the vase, is appreciative of the artisanal work, and indicates a potential of returning to buy more in the future. However, the way in which Jill communicates her negotiation differs between each.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill begins by complimenting the vase and the craftsmanship, creating a warm and friendly air. She indicates her interest in purchasing the vase, but subtly introduces the idea of a discount. She goes a step further to express her intent of supporting the artisan's work in the future. This soft approach makes the artisan feel appreciated and valued, making it more likely that they would consider a negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill follows a similar approach, expressing her love for the vase and her support for local artisans. However, her negotiation tactic is more direct, questioning whether a discount could be offered if she buys multiple items or returns in the future. Her directness might come off as pushy and could potentially generate resistance.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the subtler approach and compliments given as part of negotiation in the first scenario, I would say it would be more likely to lead to price negotiation effectively.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 6\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses interest in supporting the artisan in the future, creating the potential for loyal customer base. However, the proposition varies in nature.\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill offers to advertise the artisan's work in social media to her followers. This could open up a new medium for the artisan to be recognized and could attract more customers. Allowing a minor discount for a potential boost in customers could result in higher sales and publicity. The downside, though, is that the artisan can't control the narrative Jill might portray in her social media and there is a risk that it may not actually lead to more customers, as the artisan has no information about the demographics or interests of Jill's followers.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill discusses future purchases and potential long-term support but doesn't offer any extra promotion beyond her own purchases. While the repeat customer is attractive, the potential for additional customers isn't clearly addressed.\\n\\nIn terms of long term benefits, scenario 1 carries more potential despite the associated risks. Thus, as an artisan, one might be more inclined to negotiate under the terms discussed in scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a business perspective, we want to create a sense of loyalty and ongoing relationships with our customers. Therefore, a customer who expresses interest in not only purchasing an item now but also returning in the future to make additional purchases is quite valuable. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions her interest in the flower vase and even brings up the idea of purchasing multiple items. She also shares her intention of becoming a repeated customer which is great for business. Furthermore, she offers to promote the artisan's work to her thousands of followers on social media. This proposition could lead to potential new customers and increased sales, which is a significant opportunity which won’t be found with every customer. Even though she is asking for a discount, the mutual benefit for the artisan makes this a more attractive proposal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also expresses her interest in the vase and mentions her potential return to the market which will again foster customer loyalty, she doesn’t offer any promotional benefits in exchange of the negotiation.\\n\\nTherefore, despite the fact that both scenarios show potential for customer loyalty, Scenario 1 provides an additional marketing advantage to the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[Reasoning text]\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers several good reasons for a discount and adds value to the transaction. Apart from buying multiple items and being a returning customer, she is willing to advertise your stall on her social media account, which has a few thousand followers. This could potentially bring more business in the future. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, while Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and shows interest in supporting your work in the future, she provides less tangible benefits in return for the discount. Therefore, the first scenario seems to offer a mutually beneficial prospect for both Jill and the artisan, making it a more favorable situation for a price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 6\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 1, 0.5]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill communicates her admiration for the artisan's work and her interest in supporting local craftspeople. However, there are subtle differences that may influence the artisan's decision to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers an alternative type of compensation besides money - promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This is potentially a valuable offer, depending on the size and engagement of Jill's social media following. If she has a large, engaged audience that aligns well with the artisan's target demographic, this social media exposure could bring in new customers and grow the artisan's business. However, this arrangement also involves more uncertainty - the artisan doesn't know for sure how many sales this promotion will lead to, or whether Jill will follow through on her promise.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill simply asks for a discount and mentions the possibility of becoming a repeat customer. For the artisan, this would guarantee immediate revenue from the vase sale and potential future sales from Jill. However, it's also possible that Jill is bluffing about returning to the market, and even if she does return, there's no guarantee that she'll choose to buy the artisan's work again.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, an artisan who prioritizes immediate, guaranteed income might prefer Scenario 2, while an artisan who is willing to take a risk for the potential of greater exposure and business growth might prefer Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: This would vary based on the artisan's individual priorities and business strategy, but let's say Scenario 2 for an artisan who prioritizes guaranteed, immediate income.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 1. \\n\\nJill in this scenario not only expresses her admiration for the craftwork but also shows keen interest in its value as a locally handcrafted item. Many artisans highly value this kind of direct recognition and appreciation of their work. This encourages negotiation, as it doesn't frame the negotiation as just driven by the price.\\n\\nAdditionally, Jill proposes a mutually beneficial arrangement in Scenario 1. By offering to promote my work on her social media, Jill is going beyond simply asking for a discount. She's suggesting a way that she can contribute to my business, potentially increasing awareness and future sales. This could translate to added value for my business in the long run. The cooperation nature of this offer is more appealing, it's not only about the price cut, but also about the potential prospect to be advertised to a wider audience.\\n\\nScenario 2 is a more general request for a discount and does not provide a strong incentive or offer of value exchange for me to lower the price. Repeat customer discounts are certainly a valid promotional tactic, but they typically require establishing a purchase history first, and apply to future purchases, not the first one.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches with clear interest in the vase and compliments my work, showing appreciation for its craftsmanship. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill proposes a barter-like situation where she hopes to leverage her social media influence to promote my products in exchange for a discount. Depending on her social media reach, this proposition could be beneficial as it might bring in more potential customers and therefore, sales in the future. I would need to assess if her social media following consists of people who would be interested in my artwork, and if she has enough reach to make a notable impact to my sales. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill inquires about a discount, she primarily bases this request on being a potential repeat customer. This promise could encourage me to give her a discount as I would get the reassurance of continued business, thus potential repeated sales. \\n\\nHowever, in weighing both scenarios, it will come down to whether Jill's social media influence surpasses the long-term value of her being a repeat customer. If I find more value in Scenario 1, then I would be more inclined to negotiate the price from that standpoint. Conversely, if I value a consistent returning customer even more and see a steady flow of sales, I'd be more likely to negotiate from Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: This answer ultimately depends on Jill's social media influence, so without further information, it's hard to determine definitively.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is very complimentary about the vase, appreciating the craftsmanship and recognizing its quality. This shows respect for the work and time that went into making it. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the vase but also offers a value proposition by suggesting a mutual benefit, where she will promote the works to her followers on social media platforms if a discount is offered. This could potentially direct more customers to the stall, thereby expanding the market and increasing sales. If Jill's social media following tends to value and purchase handcrafted items like the vase, this could create a sustained increase in income that outweighs the one-time discount on the vase.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is just asking for a price negotiation without suggesting any value exchange. It would simply be a one-sided benefit to her if the price were reduced.\\n\\nBased on this analysis, it would be more beneficial to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 due to the potential for increased exposure and customer traffic.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only acknowledges my craftsmanship but also offers a way she could reciprocate the favour of a discount. By promoting my products, stall, and overall work on her social media platform to a wider audience, she is implying that I could potentially gain more exposure, followers, and customers. Therefore, her request isn't just for a simple discount — it's a trade of services of sorts, which might greatly benefit me in the long run if her following is significantly large and engaged.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments my work but simply asks for a price reduction out of curiosity, without offering anything in return. While it's not inappropriate to negotiate at a market, the offer isn't as enticing as the scenario 1.\\n\\nSo, considering all these factors, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1 since Jill has provided an exchange of value.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not just asking for a discount, but she is also offering to advertise my work on her social media platforms. This could potentially attract more customers to my store. Even if I sell the vase to her at a slightly lower price, the potential financial gain from the increased exposure could be notable. This exchange represents a bartering of services, which is often encouraged in artisan markets as it can create a strong sense of community and mutual support. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, however, Jill is simply asking for a discount without offering anything in return. While I, as an artisan, may be open to negotiation, I’m also aware that the price needs to cover the cost of materials and the time I’ve spent on creating the vase. Hence, I would be less likely to offer a discount unless she could offer a compelling reason otherwise.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses sincere interest and admiration for the flower vase which could potentially open up possibilities for negotiation. However, the particular context of the conversation in each scenario varies and thus influences the likelihood of price negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship on an aesthetic level and subtly inquires about the possibility of price negotiation. While Jill's appreciation is clear, her interest in buying is somewhat implied rather than explicitly stated. This somewhat vague stance might make a price negotiation less likely, as we are unsure about her immediate commitment to buy.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only praises the beauty of the vase but also signifies her interest to support local artisans – she acknowledges the overall value of the vase in terms of uniqueness and craftsmanship. Furthermore, she expresses an intention to buy multiple items and become a returning customer. This builds a potentially longer-term relationship, bringing more business in the future. In this case, a price adjustment seems more reasonable as an investment. It helps to secure a sale now, and also establishes customer loyalty for future transactions.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios demonstrate a keen interest in the handcrafted flower vase and a clear admiration for the craft. In Scenario 1, Jill directly asks for a price negotiation, whereas, in Scenario 2, she indirectly mentions that the price is a bit out of her budget and suggests the possibility of discounts for multiple purchases and future visits. In both cases, Jill could be a repeat customer. However, Scenario 2 provides two opportunities for selling more items, either now or in the future. Encouraging multiple purchases or encouraging a customer to return, fosters a stronger business-customer relationship. Also, Jill's appreciation for local crafts and dedication to support artisans indicates that she may spread the word about your work to others.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision to negotiate the price depends on how the query is presented and how the customer interacts with the seller. In both scenarios, Jill compliments on the craftsmanship and expresses her interest in the vase.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the beauty of the vase and artist's talent - however, she simply asks if there's room for negotiation on the price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, not only does Jill express her liking for the vase, she also mentions her intent to support local artisans, implies that she may want to purchase multiple items, and promises that she's likely to be a frequent customer in the future. This gives the artisan multiple reasons to potentially reduce the price: promoting larger sales, encouraging customer loyalty, and supporting the local artisan community.\\n\\nTherefore, the artisan would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2 due to the greater potential for future business and the larger immediate transaction. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios create an opportunity for negotiation, but there are some subtle differences between them.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is personable and complimentary about the vase and my craftsmanship, which can sometimes influence sellers to lower their price slightly. However, there's no concrete commitment from her about future purchases or promotion.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, she not only expresses admiration for my work but also mentions future visits and potential bulk buys. More interestingly, she brings up the power of social media marketing. If she does have thousands of followers as she claims, her posting about my items could bring a fair amount of visibility to my stall – perhaps far more value than a slight discount on one vase. This kind of bartering can be quite beneficial for small businesses trying to increase their footprint.\\n\\nTherefore, answering the discussion, based on the concrete future benefits promised in social media marketing and repeated purchases, I'd be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 2.  \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows an appreciation for the craftsmanship of the vase, indicating that she values your work. In scenario 1, Jill's approach is more traditional and direct; she compliments your talent, generates a warm rapport and then inquires about a possible discount. This is a pretty standard approach for a customer attempting to negotiate price at a local market.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill offers something additional which can serve as a value proposition for you as an artisan. She not only expresses her intent to become a regular customer (indicating potential ongoing business), but also offers to promote your work to her social media followers. The latter can be quite beneficial in terms of gaining more exposure and potentially new customers to your business.\\n\\nThere is a chance that Jill might not follow through on her promises, but with scenario 2, you're not only selling a vase, but also potentially investing in marketing your business. It's risky, but it's also an opportunity.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2.\\n  \\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and subtly brings up the topic of negotiation. While this might be effective to a point, it is a direct price negotiation scenario. A small discount might be given, but there is no potential for a longer-term relationship beyond that immediate transaction, which could limit the amount of flexibility in the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill brings up the prospect of becoming a regular customer and purchasing multiple items. This has the potential to provide continuous business and income, which is beneficial for a small local business. A small discount on this purchase might lead to more purchases in the future. Furthermore, she offers to promote the business on her social media, suggesting she has a significant number of followers. This could substantially enhance the visibility of the business, bringing in more customers and implicitly helping in the growth of the artisan's business.\\n\\nConsidering these factors in both the scenarios, the artisan in a local market essentially being a small business owner, would find Jill's proposal in the second scenario more interesting and advantageous. Therefore the artisan is more likely to negotiate on the price in the second scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 32 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show Jill's appreciation for handcrafted work, which is a good starting point for a negotiation. However, in Scenario 2, Jill not only acknowledges the value of supporting local artisans, she also offers something in return for a discount, while in Scenario 1 she simply asks for a price reduction.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to promote the art on her social media. This is an exchange that could have a long-term benefit. If she has a decent following, this could potentially bring in more customers, raise awareness about my work and potentially increase sales overall.\\n\\nMoreover, when customers understand the true cost and work that goes into handcrafted pieces and express their respect for it, as Jill did in Scenario 2, it makes me more willing to negotiate. She also shows empathy towards the business needs of an artisan, which is quite rare to come across.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn general, a pricing negotiation would depend on various factors including the cost of the materials, how long the piece took to make, the uniqueness of the item, and how attached I am to it. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the workmanship and quality of the vase, asserting her curiosity if there's a room for negotiation. However, she doesn't specify any special reason justifying why I should bring down the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses admiration for the vase and shows empathy for locally made, handcrafted items. She provides further significant information that she's on a tighter budget which may prevent her from affordably purchasing my products. Jill also proposes a trade-off, offering to promote my work on her social media platform, putting my products before potentially larger audience, which could be valuable for my business. \\n\\nHence, in terms of empathetic appeals, potential marketing exposure, and providing a solid reason, Scenario 2 motivates me more in favor of a negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom my perspective as the artisan, both scenarios offer interesting perspectives. In the first scenario, Jill expresses admiration for my work and suggests she values it highly, indirectly suggesting that she would be a satisfied buyer and possibly a repeat customer. \\n\\nHowever, in the second scenario, she not only compliments my work, but also offers value beyond the payment itself. Jill proposes assisting with promoting my work on her social media, which could potentially help expand my business and reach more customers.\\n\\nTherefore, for strategic and long-term perspectives, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in the second scenario as I see it as an investment in marketing and potential increase in the customer base. Her proposal implies that she may become a 'brand ambassador', telling her friends about my work and potentially influencing them to visit my local market stand.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0.5, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile the sentiment in both scenarios is quite similar, there are some differences in Jill's offers that would sway my decision. In Scenario 1, Jill is not only showing appreciation for the work but also providing an offer of value in return for a discount, which is promoting my art on her social media. This type of organic promotion is incredibly valuable because word of mouth and personal testimonials can represent a significant advantage for small artisans like myself. This can potentially lead to more clients and higher visibility, which can grow my business.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill is praising the work and expressing interest in purchasing the vase but is only asking for a lower price. She doesn't offer any extra value to balance out the reduction in price.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, I would be more willing to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 because of the additional value that Jill is promising in exchange for the discount. Her proposal could increase my market reach, which is a long-term benefit that surpasses the short-term profit from a single sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill in a positive and respectful way, expressing interest in the handcrafted vase, admiring the craftsmanship, and acknowledging the value of artisan work. The scenario where the artisan would likely negotiate the price, however, would depend on certain factors.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses an interest in purchasing the vase but also offers a potential form of long-term benefit in the way of promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This could mean reaching an audience that the artisan normally might not have access to, which could then lead to even more sales or business. If The artisan values this kind of exposure and believes it could drive more business, then this scenario might be more appealing. However, this would only work if the artisan trusts that Jill will keep her part of the agreement.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill simply expresses her interest in the vase and asks directly if there's any possibility for a price negotiation. While this is a more conventional approach and doesn't involve any potential long-term benefits, such as marketing, it might appeal to the artisan if they need to make a sale and are open to negotiating the price. As an artisan, I would evaluate how the sales are for the day and if the asking price can cover the costing price and still leave some margin then a decision can be made.\\n\\nNonetheless, the decision to negotiation and giving a discount would depend on the artisan's immediate need for a sale versus the potential for increased future sales.\\n\\nAnswer: It would depend on the individual artisan and his/her immediate versus long-term business goals. Both scenarios presented are appealing for different reasons and hence, it's not a clear cut Scenario 1 or Scenario 2.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is not only showing interest in buying the vase but also offering an additional value in the form of promoting the artisan's work on her social media. This would give additional exposure to the artisan and might result in future sales. This is a 'win-win' as the artisan gets to sell the vase and possibly gain more customers, while Jill gets the vase within her budget.\\n\\nWhile in scenario 2, Jill is only asking for a discount on the vase. Though it's a normal practice in local markets to negotiate the price, the artisan only stands to lose as there's no additional benefit offered. \\n\\nTherefore, taking these aspects into consideration, the artisan would get more value in scenario 1 as compared to scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "2, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide convincing reasons for a potential discount; however, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 2. Here's why:\\n\\nScenario 1: In this situation, Jill seems to be a repeat customer or indicates the potential to become one. She also hints at buying more than one item, which could justify a small discount. While repeat customers are valuable, unless she's purchasing multiple items on the spot, I wouldn't necessarily provide a discount straight away. Her future purchases aren't guaranteed; moreover, the vase is already handcrafted and reasonably priced.\\n\\nScenario 2: Jill's proposal in Scenario 2 is far more appealing. She is actively offering something in return rather than just the potential of future purchases. Her suggestion to promote my work on her social media could drive more business my way, creating more potential sales and customers, an exchange worth more than just a minor price reduction on a single vase. \\n\\nEvery artisan aims to gain more visibility, and if giving a small discount on a vase in exchange for promotion could do that, it would be a deal worth considering. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn a negotiation, concessions are usually granted in return for some perceived benefit. In Scenario 1, while Jill hints at the possibility of future purchases, there is no immediate benefit for me to lower the price. Her return business is not a guaranteed benefit and the potential future benefit is nebulous at best. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only expresses her interest in the vase but also proposes a beneficial arrangement for me - promotion of my work on her social media. This offer of immediate and evident value would increase visibility and potentially bring in more customers, thereby accelerating my business growth. \\n\\nTherefore, based on the potential immediate and tangible benefits, I'd be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is interested in supporting a small-scale artisan and buying a handcrafted vase. Jill is polite, respectful, and genuine in her words. However, there are major differences in the approaches she takes for bargaining.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is concerned with more than just this single purchase. She is suggesting a potentially long-term customer relationship, which can be beneficial for an artisan operating in a local market. She inquires about discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers, implying her intention of buying more items presently and in the future. By offering future purchases, Jill is indirectly proposing a trade - a discount now for guaranteed future sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill asks for a discount based on her financial constraints while also offering to promote the artisan’s work on her social media. While this is a noble offer, the artisan can't be certain of any tangible results coming from such promotion.\\n\\nConsidering all these factors, the certainty of more sales in Scenario 1 is a slightly more attractive proposition than the uncertainty of potential social media promotion benefits in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\nIn the art market, especially for handcrafted items, the conversation around the value of a piece is often nuanced. It includes not just the price in dollars but also the value the buyer places on the craftsmanship and the support they offer to the artisan's work and livelihood. In Scenario 1, Jill clearly appreciates the artisan's craftsmanship and expresses her support for local artisans while also acknowledging her budget constraints. This candid approach may appeal to the artisan's understanding and sense of community, and inclination to support a person who shares his passion to support local.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill goes beyond expressing her appreciation and support. She offers a practical and potentially valuable prospect in addition to her purchase: promoting the artisan's work on her social media. For a local artisan selling in a market, this could be a significant opportunity to broaden their customer base and raise their profile, which might even lead to an increase in their income over time. \\n\\nSo, despite Jill asking for a discount in both scenarios, the second one brings an extra benefit for the artisan that the first scenario does not have. This added value of promotion could more than compensate for the potential financial loss from the discount and therefore seems like a fair trade-off.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer compelling reasons to consider negotiating the vase's price with Jill. However, the inheritance of negotiation scenarios is that there should be some exchange. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill simply acknowledges the uniqueness of the vase and the artisan's craftsmanship. She then proceeds to express her budgetary constraints, appealing to possible leniency to reduce the price. Although this shows appreciation, there isn't any offered advantage for the artisan that prompts a discount.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only compliments the artisan's craftsmanship, but she also proposes a possibility of promotion on her social media channels. This indicates that she can offer something beneficial in return for a decreased price. As an artisan having a stand at a local market, any form of promotion could be highly beneficial for business growth. This bid can be much more attractive to the artisan as Jill is not just requesting a discount, but offering something tangible in return.\\n\\nFor this reason, I would lean more towards negotiating in Scenario 2 because it potentially provides a return of investment through publicity and reach to a new audience.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling propositions for a negotiation as Jill expresses appreciation for my work and highlights her desire to support local artisans, which is a heartwarming gesture.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill suggests a reduction in price due to her budget constraints without offering any advantages for me as the seller apart from the sale. Although I appreciate Jill's admiration of my artwork, reducing the price without any identifiable advantages may be an issue, especially because this vase is a handcrafted piece that required time, effort, and creativity.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2, not only does Jill express her financial constraints but she also proposes a means of compensation for the reduction in price. By offering to promote my work on her social media, Jill is bringing a sort of barter system into play which could potentially help expand the reach of my business and bring in more customers. This alternative offers me longer-term benefits and the possibility of increasing my customer base, which is great for business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 0, score 8\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill conveys her interest in the vase and appreciation for my craftsmanship while also gently laying groundwork for a price negotiation. However, there are subtle differences in the two that would impact my inclination to negotiate. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is committing to repeat transactions, i.e., buying more items as a returning, regular customer. This assures me of potential future sales which could be very lucrative. This suggestion of multiple purchases also shows that she values my work and is not just looking for a one-time, cheap deal.\\n\\nContrarily, in Scenario 2, while Jill offers to promote my work on her social media, it is a subjective value. It's dependent on her influence- the reach and engagement of her followers. If she isn't influential on these platforms, this promotion may not drive substantial additional sales. \\n\\nNegotiations, as such, always involve finding a mutually beneficial arrangement. The promise of repeat business in Scenario 1 seems like a safer and more direct benefit, rather than the uncertain prospects of social media promotion in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill shows a clear interest in long-term support for the business. She doesn't ask directly for a discount on the current item; instead, she proposes a kind of loyalty program, where she can receive discounts on future purchases when she buys more or comes back. This implies that the artisan will likely have more income in the future. \\n\\nIn contrast, in the second scenario, Jill asks directly for a discount and offers promotion in return. This might sound beneficial in the short term, but it can also be risky - sometimes these “promotions” don't bring the expected benefits and customers may not come back after getting a discount. However, it does still have potential for spreading the product to a wider audience.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present their own advantages and disadvantages, Scenario 1 is less risky and suggests more profitable long-term perspectives with a regular customer buying more items over time.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses a genuine interest in supporting local artisans and appreciates the quality of my craft. However, the nature of her proposition is different in each.\\n\\nScenario 1 involves potential future business, where she suggests becoming a regular customer and buying multiple items over time. This is a great proposal as it does show potential for more profits down the line. However, her commitment is not guaranteed, and it might turn out that she doesn't return or buys less than expected.\\n\\nScenario 2 is interesting, as Jill offers to promote my work on her social media. This could expose my items to a new audience, potentially increasing my customer base and sales. There's no guarantee on the effectiveness of her promotion, but it offers immediate value beyond the sale of the vase.\\n\\nConsidering both the scenarios, it's a tough decision but I would lean slightly towards Scenario 2. The exposure that comes from potential social media promotion is immediate and could attract new customers given today's digital days. Also, possibly she would tag my business and it might help in promoting my work to a larger audience than today's market visitors.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 2, score 8\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling reasons to negotiate the price with Jill, as she could potentially help spread word-of-mouth for my business in exchange for a discount. However, there are subtle but significant differences between the two scenarios to consider before making a decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is clearly an enthusiastic potential customer who has a strong appreciation for the craftsmanship and design of the vase. She's supportive of local artisans and even offers a direct exchange - the promotion of my business through her social media platform, in return for a small discount. This implies she has a substantial number of followers who may be interested in my work, giving me exposure to a wider audience.\\n\\nScenario 2 also presents a customer who appreciates the work of local artisans, wants to support local businesses and proposes a similar offer to promote my business. However, she mentions being on a tight budget. This might mean that even after receiving a discount, she might not follow through on her end of the bargain.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I find Jill's offer in Scenario 1 appears more beneficial to my business in the long run. I see a potential for wider exposure to an appreciative audience capable of driving more sales, meaning I can earn more, too, despite providing a discount on this piece.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nI appreciate both scenarios as Jill comes across as respectful and appreciative of the effort that goes into creating handcrafted pieces like the flower vase. In both scenarios, Jill offers to promote my work on her social media, which could potentially attract more customers. \\n\\nHowever, I\\'m more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. The reason being, in Scenario 1, although Jill admires the work, she states that she \"always tries to get good value whenever possible,\" which may imply that she isn\\'t necessarily in need of a discount. Conversely, in Scenario 2, Jill shows a genuine interest in supporting local artisans and makes it clear that her budget is tight which indicates that a discount would truly be of help to her. She also offers to barter services in return for a discount, showing a commitment to forging a fair and mutually beneficial exchange.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill hold compelling reasons for negotiation. In both, she appreciates the artisan's work and displays a genuine interest in supporting local artisans. Also, in each case, she proposes to use her social media influence to promote the artisan's work, which could help bring in new customers.\\n\\nHowever, the key difference is found in the way she presents her budget situation. In Scenario 1, she says that she's willing to pay full price, suggesting that she isn't in dire need of a discount. Contrarily, in Scenario 2, she discloses that she is on a tighter budget than she had initially hoped.\\n\\nWith these considerations in mind, I would lean more towards negotiating with Jill in Scenario 2. Her honesty about needing the discount due to budgetary restrictions may resonate more and creates a sense of urgency and necessity. Additionally, her offer to promote the artisan's work still stands, making her proposal a fair exchange.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 1, score 8\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show Jill's appreciation for handcrafted work, which is a good starting point for a negotiation. However, in Scenario 2, Jill not only acknowledges the value of supporting local artisans, she also offers something in return for a discount, while in Scenario 1 she simply asks for a price reduction.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to promote the art on her social media. This is an exchange that could have a long-term benefit. If she has a decent following, this could potentially bring in more customers, raise awareness about my work and potentially increase sales overall.\\n\\nMoreover, when customers understand the true cost and work that goes into handcrafted pieces and express their respect for it, as Jill did in Scenario 2, it makes me more willing to negotiate. She also shows empathy towards the business needs of an artisan, which is quite rare to come across.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn general, a pricing negotiation would depend on various factors including the cost of the materials, how long the piece took to make, the uniqueness of the item, and how attached I am to it. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the workmanship and quality of the vase, asserting her curiosity if there's a room for negotiation. However, she doesn't specify any special reason justifying why I should bring down the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses admiration for the vase and shows empathy for locally made, handcrafted items. She provides further significant information that she's on a tighter budget which may prevent her from affordably purchasing my products. Jill also proposes a trade-off, offering to promote my work on her social media platform, putting my products before potentially larger audience, which could be valuable for my business. \\n\\nHence, in terms of empathetic appeals, potential marketing exposure, and providing a solid reason, Scenario 2 motivates me more in favor of a negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom my perspective as the artisan, both scenarios offer interesting perspectives. In the first scenario, Jill expresses admiration for my work and suggests she values it highly, indirectly suggesting that she would be a satisfied buyer and possibly a repeat customer. \\n\\nHowever, in the second scenario, she not only compliments my work, but also offers value beyond the payment itself. Jill proposes assisting with promoting my work on her social media, which could potentially help expand my business and reach more customers.\\n\\nTherefore, for strategic and long-term perspectives, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in the second scenario as I see it as an investment in marketing and potential increase in the customer base. Her proposal implies that she may become a 'brand ambassador', telling her friends about my work and potentially influencing them to visit my local market stand.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 8\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision to negotiate the price could depend on several factors, such as the artisan's business model, necessity, and Jill's overall approach.\\n\\nHere are some considerations:\\n\\n1. **Customer's attitude:** Both scenarios display a positive attitude from Jill. However, Jill seems more genuine in Scenario 1, expressing appreciation for the artisan's work and showing her passion for supporting local businesses.\\n  \\n2. **The offer to promote the artisan's work:** In both scenarios, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work on social media. This is attractive, especially for a local business that could benefit from additional exposure.\\n\\n3. **Directness and clarity:** Jill is forthright in Scenario 2. She appreciates the artisan's work, visualizes where she could place the vase, and directly suggests a price discussion, which could be seen as a more upfront negotiation.\\n\\nIn this case, it could go either way, but considering these factors, I would be slightly more inclined to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1. Her genuine passion for supporting local artisans, combined with the potential for promotion of the work on social media, could provide long-term benefits that outweigh the short-term loss from a slight discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text: \\n\\nBoth scenarios handle the intent of negotiation in a respectful and complimentary manner to the artisan, focusing on the craftsmanship of the vase and expressing a desire to support local artisans. However, there are some subtle differences which might influence the final decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill establishes an emotional connection by expressing her passion for supporting local artisans and the value she sees in handmade items which may create an empathetic response. Furthermore, she offers tangible help by suggesting to promote the artisan’s work on social media. Creating more visibility can potentially lead to increased sales. Such an offer could be highly beneficial for small local craft businesses.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also complements the artisan's work and offers to share the art piece on her social media which can give the artisan some exposure. However, she doesn't explicitly express her support for local artisans and the importance of handmade work.\\n\\nThough in both cases the artisan might be inclined to negotiate due to the respectful approach and the promised promotion, Scenario 1 might have a slight advantage due to Jill’s expressed passion and support for local and handmade work.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is polite and compliments my work. This is always appreciated and creates a positive rapport to start with. Also, in both situations, she proposes to share my work on her social media, which could increase visibility and potentially attract more customers. \\n\\nNonetheless, there are still some slight differences between the two scenarios that can affect my decision. In scenario 1, Jill mentions her financial difficulties and that she\\'s a supporter of local artisans. This makes her seemingly more sympathetic and can evoke an emotional response. In addition, her offer seems more personalised as she not only proposes to share photos on her social media but also to do \"anything else that might be beneficial for my business\". \\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill is more direct and simply asks for a discount. She does refer to the vase\\'s potential placement in her house, creating a personal connection with the piece, but this seems less compelling than the reasons given in the first scenario.\\n\\nIn conclusion, based on these considerations, I would lean more towards negotiating with Jill in scenario 1 as she appears to be more passionate about my work, sympathetic, and her offer seems more sincere and personalised.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 42 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is making an emotional appeal by not only complimenting your work but also by expressing her desire to support local artisans. She acknowledges the value of your craft and is suggesting a partnership where she promotes your work on her social media. This may not bring an immediate return on the discount you give but it can certainly help in the long run by increasing your visibility and customer base.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill is also appreciative of the work, she only requests for a small discount without offering anything in return. \\n\\nTherefore, considering Jill's compliment towards the artisan's work, her willingness to support local artisans, and the proposed exchange of services, Scenario 1 gives a better chance of initiating a negotiation for a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are rather persuasive, however, Jill's approach in Scenario 1 is a bit more compelling. This is because, not only does she state her case in a manner that feels personal and appreciative of your craft, but she also offers an opportunity for a beneficial trade-off, proposing to promote your business on her social media platform.\\n\\nThis type of exposure can help not only in immediate terms, eventually leading to more sales, but also in the longer term, as it boosts your business's visibility and potentially allows it to reach a much wider audience than you might normally have access to. In essence, by accepting her offer for a slight discount, you're gaining an opportunity to market your product beyond your current reach.\\n\\nPlus, there's also a psychological element at play here: by offering to help out your business in some way, Jill portrays herself as more of an ally rather than just another customer looking for a discount. This sense of mutual benefit and reciprocity makes it more appealing to negotiate with her.\\n\\nSo, in weighing both scenarios, the first scenario seems more inviting for negotiation, not only because it can bear additional fruit for your business, but also because it enhances a sense of community and mutual support, which can be especially valuable in a local market set-up where personal connections matter quite a bit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show a genuine interest in the product and an understanding of the value of handcrafted items, which is already a good start for a negotiation. However, in Scenario 1 Jill provides an additional value proposition. She offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media which might have potential to reach more customers and hence could potentially bring in more sales. This way, the artisan might not only be recouping the potential loss from the discount given but also gain in another form. This tactic is effective because it not only appeals to the artisan's need to make sales, but also suggests a potential for future business.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 is a straight-forward financial negotiation based on Jill's budget constraints which is a valid reason but doesn't provide an immediate benefit to the artisan in exchange for the discount.\\n\\nTherefore, Jill's proposal in Scenario 1 not only acknowledges the value of handmade goods, but also provides a solution that might be mutually beneficial.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 53 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 2\n",
      "2_3, generation 1, score 8\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios present viable options for price negotiations, I'm more inclined towards scenario 2. Jill, in the second scenario, not only expressed interest in purchasing multiple items in the future but also offered to market my work on her social media platforms, which could potentially increase the audience and customer base for my craft. This could lead to more sales and exposure in the long run, so it's a win-win situation even if I cut some cost in the short term.\\n\\nIn contrast, the argument put forth in scenario 1, while acknowledging the quality and craftsmanship of my work, doesn't offer a tangible benefit in return for a price reduction, making it a less appealing prospect. It's more of a one-sided transaction favouring the customer.\\n\\nHence, considering the above reasons, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in scenario 2 as it offers a beneficial trade-off.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\nNegotiation is an art form guidelines of which change from situation to situation but there are a few fundamental principles that one must abide by. For one, negotiation should always provide value to both counterparts. It's not just about pushing for the lowest price but also about understanding the value of the craft, the effort that has gone into making the product and the worth of the artisan's time. \\n\\nIn both scenarios mentioned above, Jill is offering value in return but in different ways. In Scenario 1, she is only asking for a discount and hints at being a potential repeat customer without offering anything specific in return. While it's never a bad strategy to ask for a discount, her negotiation tactic is not as compelling as in Scenario 2.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only talks about buying multiple products but also shares her willingness to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms. This could potentially lead to an increase in the artisan's consumer base. Therefore, even if a discount is given to Jill, it may prove to be a fruitful investment in the long run if she is able to influence more people to buy the artisan's products. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAccording to the scenario, as an artisan at a local market, I'd put more value into Scenario 2 for several reasons.\\n\\nFirstly, in Scenario 2, Jill demonstrates her willingness to make more than one purchase which should, theoretically, generate more income for me as opposed to a one-off sale. She's signaling her intent to become a repeat customer. Offering her a discount might be initially less profitable, but in the long run, it could mean steady business which is beneficial.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill mentions the prospect of promoting my craftsmanship on her social media platforms, which could potentially attract more customers to my stand in future. In the era of technology, word of mouth can be incredibly influential, and if she has a significant following, her endorsement could significantly boost my visibility.\\n\\nTherefore, considering all these aspects, it's worth negotiating a discount on the vase in Scenario 2, mainly due to potential long-term benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 53 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 2\n",
      "0_1, generation 2, score 9\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe effectiveness of negotiation usually hinges on the strategy employed by the interested party. In this case, both scenarios involving Jill apply a considerate approach, with compliments on the craft and some form of flattery directed towards the artisan. However, they differ slightly in their tone and their reasons for seeking a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the labor and passion that the craftsman has put into making the vase. She gives the craft a high valuation, expressing that it's exactly what she's been searching for. Adding to this, she makes her discussion more humane by stating she wants to support local artisans and is only asking for a discount due to her limited budget. This strategy uses empathy to connect with the artisan personally, which could make him more inclined to offer a discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also compliments the craftsmanship but doesn't provide a personal touch or solid reasoning why she is seeking a discount. The scenario is somehow more business-like and less personal.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\n\\nThe reason for choosing Scenario 1 over 2 is due to the personal touch and the justification provided by Jill. Explaining that she is budget-tied but still wants to support local artisans might encourage the artisan to give a discount or negotiate the price. On the other hand, complimenting the product and expressing desire to own it without justifying the need for a discount, as done in Scenario 2, might not motivate the seller to reduce the price.\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill conveys her appreciation for the workmanship. However, the reasoning behind asking for a discount differs. In Scenario 1, Jill is asking for a discount due to budget constraints, while in Scenario 2, she is asking for a discount without providing a reason, instead only expressing interest. As an artisan, while appreciating the admiration for craftsmanship, the likeliness to support a client's budget constraint might be higher prompting more empathy. The financial burden is a more compelling reason compared to a simple expression of interest. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAnalyzing both scenarios, scenario 1 provides a stronger case for a possible price negotiation. Here is the breakdown:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill compliments not only the vase itself, but also acknowledges the passion and effort that went into crafting the vase. She also shows an understanding of the importance of supporting local artisans, but openly admits her budget constraints. This emotional appeal indicates a deeper appreciation for the value of the item and the work of the artisan, which might make an artisan inclined toward some discount as a way to reward the understanding and support a potential loyal customer who seems to have a genuine interest in locally handcrafted items.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill again acknowledges the workmanship of the vase and expresses her interest in it. She asks for a possible discount or negotiation, but does not offer any reason as to why she may require such a concession. While she does express appreciation for the work that's gone into it, there's less of a personal touch to her request.\\n\\nTherefore, in Scenario 1, there is a higher likelihood of negotiating a discount due to Jill's sincere approach, recognition of the work involved in the piece and clear appreciation of local craftsmanship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 53 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 2\n",
      "0_3, generation 2, score 8\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer that appreciates the craftsmanship and quality of the vase, but there are subtle differences between the two. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill does not only commend the quality of work but also sees its value, indicating she's willing to pay the full price. However, she also presents a mutually beneficial proposition. She offers to use her social media influence to promote the artisan's work in exchange for a small discount. This can serve as an opportunity for extended reach and potential new customers for the artisan, which may outweigh the loss from the small discount offered.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill praises the work but simply asks for a discount without offering any mutual benefit. The request seems to be leaning more towards personal interest as opposed to the mutual benefit presented in Scenario 1.\\n\\nGiven these differences, I'd be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. The potential gain of promotion and reaching new customers can exceed the minor loss from the discount. Additionally, this scenario shows a customer who understands and appreciates the value of handcrafted work and is not merely seeking a price reduction out of pure interest. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nBoth scenarios demonstrate a respectful and admiring approach from Jill towards the handcrafted vase. Jill acknowledges the time, effort, and skill required to design and create the vase in both scenarios. However, the main difference lies in the impetus for a potential discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers a form of value exchange for a discount. She proposes to promote the vase and my craftsmanship through social media where she has quite a following. This could lead to further exposure and possibly more clients for me. Although it's not guaranteed, the potential exposure could provide long-term benefits that outweigh the immediate benefit of selling the vase at the full price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill expresses interest and admiration, she doesn't propose a value exchange for a discount. She only expresses her willingness to negotiate the price, making it a one-sided request for a lower price. This doesn't provide additional benefits to me compared to the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer who appreciates the artistry behind the vase, which is encouraging for any artisan. However, what makes a significant difference between the two scenarios is Jill's offer in Scenario 1, where she is not just asking for a discount but is offering to expose my work to a potentially much larger audience through her social media. \\n\\nThis offer could mean more exposure and potentially more customers coming my way. So even if I might be taking a small hit by giving her a discount on the vase, the potential benefits from the increased exposure could more than compensate for it. \\n\\nBesides, in Scenario 2, the customer is only asking for a discount but doesn't offer anything in return. While it is a normal part of doing business in a marketplace to negotiate prices, without any added benefit, I would be less inclined to offer a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a well-spoken and appreciative customer, which is great for any artisan at a local market. In Scenario 1, customer Jill not only shows admiration for the vase but also offers reciprocal value. She proposes to share the work on her social media platforms, which can potentially give the artisan a reach to a larger audience - an effective form of free marketing. It is also a form of investment, which may yield higher returns in the future.\\n\\nScenario 2 is a straightforward appreciation and request for a discount due to personal budget constraints. While this scenario is still polite and respectful, it doesn't offer a form of reciprocal value beyond the purchase of one piece.\\n\\nThus, considering value exchange and potential future gains, scenario 1 carries a little more weight.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a situation where Jill, the customer, initiates a negotiation for the price of a handcrafted flower vase. Understanding the premise, however, offers insight into why or why not I might prefer and be more willing to consider one scenario over the other.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the artisan work but also provides an additional value proposition. She offers to promote the work on her social media, potentially driving more customers to the business. This suggests that the personalized craftsmanship is not only valued by her, but likely to be appreciated by a broader audience, validating the work. If her following is sizable and if such free promotion might attract more customers, then losing a small amount on an individual item could be advantageous over a broader scale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses admiration for the artisan craft and desire to support local businesses. However, she appears only to be seeking a discount based on her budget without offering any additional value for the business. It might be a simple, straightforward sale.\\n\\nWhile the genuine appreciation expressed in both scenarios is a positive, the added value in Scenario 1 offers a potentially greater business benefit. The promise of exposure to a wider customer base may more than offset a small discount provided to this individual customer and thus yield a long-term gain.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision between the two scenarios has to be made based on the perceived value of the proposed transactions and Jill's approach. In both cases, Jill is appreciative of the work and finds the vase appealing. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she doesn't directly mention about what kind of discount she wants, but she proposes to help advertise the product on her social media platform, which could lead to increased exposure and possibly more sales. This is a valuable proposition as it might help in growing the business.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, she only says she can't stretch her budget to the price but she doesn't give any specific reasons nor does she offer anything else in return, although she still shows appreciation for the work.\\n\\nGiven the additional potential value offered in Scenario 1, I'd be more likely to negotiate the vase's price with Jill in that context.\\n \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nTo decide which scenario is more likely to make me negotiate on the price of the vase, I'll consider both Jill's approach and potential benefits to my business.\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill is offering to exchange social media promotion for a discount. Depending on her social media follower count and engagement, this could potentially be a decent trade-off. If her followers are in the thousands or tens of thousands, featuring my product could expose my art to a much larger audience, leading to more customers in the future. However, the value of this promotion is uncertain and relies heavily on whether her followers are inclined to buy my products. \\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill is simply asking for a discount. She complimented my work, explained that she's an avid supporter of local artisans, and has honestly admitted that the price is slightly beyond her budget. However, there's no additional benefit for my business beyond the direct sale.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, I'm more likely to negotiate price in Scenario 1. The potential marketing value gained is a significant factor and could be more beneficial for my art business in the long term than a single sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her admiration and appreciation for the handmade vase, which is a good starting point for a negotiation. She's managed to communicate her interest very effectively, praising the craftsmanship and uniqueness of the piece.\\n\\nHowever, scenario 1 suggests an additional benefit for me as an artisan. Jill's proposal to promote my work on her social media platforms could potentially get my craft noticed by a wider audience, resulting in more customers in the future. This is significant because as a local artisan, the marketing channels available to me are limited, and this could be an effective way of reaching many people at once without incurring any additional marketing costs.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, while Jill did a good job expressing her interest and support for local entrepreneurs, she doesn't offer any extra value besides the purchase.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential long-term benefit,\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nThe decision to negotiate the price depends on what the artisan values more; immediate payment or potential future sales and exposure. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering something beyond mere monetary compensation. She is proposing a sort of symbiotic relationship where she helps expand the artisan's reach in exchange for a discount. If the artisan believes in the power of social media marketing and trusts Jill's promise to promote him properly, there's a possibility he may consider negotiating. However, Jill's proposal carries a risk as the promised promotion might not translate to increased sales. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 is a straightforward negotiation based on monetary terms. Jill is not stretching it too far as she only mentions a slight stretch on her budget, which might imply a small discount may make her purchase the vase. Here, the artisan doesn't have to gamble on future benefits as he would in scenario 1. \\n\\nHowever, definitely, there are pros and cons to each scenario, which include loss of income in Scenario 2 and loss of future visibility if Jill does not uphold her end of the deal in Scenario 1. \\n\\nGiven the risk involved in Scenario 1 and the potential for immediate money with minimal loss in Scenario 2, I'd lean towards the latter as it seems like the safer bet.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios involve Jill appreciating the quality of the work and expressing her support for local artisans. However, scenario 2 seems to show a little more passion for the product. Jill expresses a personal interest with the unique design of the vase and its potential addition to her home. She seems more attached to the product and genuinely stricken by it, as opposed to scenario 1, where she simply admires the work. Furthermore, she opens up about being slightly financially strapped at the moment, proving authenticity and sincerity in her request to reduce the price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill recognizes the quality of the vase, expresses admiration for the craft, and also voices an interest in supporting local artisan work, which bodes well for her negotiation. However, it's her approach in each scenario that might sway the negotiation in her favor. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is quite direct with her intentions and immediately expresses her financial constraints. Even though she shows her appreciation for the vase and the craftsmanship involved, she is straightforward in asking for a discount. This can put the artisan on the spot and make the negotiation a bit difficult, as it might not allow room for discussion.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill express her admiration for the vase, commends the uniqueness of the design, complements the artisan on his work, and expresses her support for local artisans before suggesting a price reduction. This way of negotiating may feel more comfortable for the artisan, as Jill creates a friendlier atmosphere with her comments before discussing the price. It makes the negotiation seem less about the money and more about Jill's genuine appreciation for the vase but her inability to afford it at the moment.\\n\\nBased on these factors, I'd likely be more open to negotiation in Scenario 2 where Jill takes a more considerate approach in her negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nBoth scenarios represent a situation where Jill is complimenting the artisan's work and showing deep interest in buying the vase while expressing her budget constraints. There seems to be no substantial difference in intents between the two scenarios for negotiating the price. However, in Scenario 2, Jill goes into more detail about her appreciation for local artisans and her commitment to adding these types of pieces to her home. This indicates that she might be a returning customer who values the artisan's work and could potentially make more purchases in the future. Therefore, giving her some discount could encourage customer loyalty and future business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "1_2, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios clearly show Jill's admiration for the work and her genuine intention to support the craftsmanship. \\n\\nI would be more inclined to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1. This is because Jill demonstrates that she is interested in becoming a regular customer, showing interest in a potential long-term relationship that could benefit my business in the future. The prospect of selling multiple items in the future outweighs the immediate marginal loss of giving a discount on the vase now. She also outlines the potential of future market visits where she might purchase more items, which implies continual support and repeat sales. This scenario appears to offer more prospective value to the business.\\n\\nTherefore in this case, offering a discount can be considered an investment in customer loyalty, as opposed to Scenario 2, where the customer's intention is to only negotiate the price of one item right now.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a customer drawn to quality craftsmanship and committed to supporting local artisans—qualities which inherently make a customer desirable. However, there are significant differences in their communication strategies which may influence my willingness to negotiate the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses her intentions of future purchases and becoming a regular customer. This indicates potential long-term benefits—potentially consistent income in the future and word-of-mouth marketing benefits if she talks positively about my products to her circle. The promise of the future purchase could cover any potential losses in profit from offering a discount on the current object. Jill is also asking about multiple item purchase discounts, meaning she is thinking about buying more items, which could make up for the discount given.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 simply presents Jill asking for a discount on the current object without promising any future purchases, or multiple purchases today.\\n\\nConsidering the long-term benefits that Scenario 1 presents, I’d be more likely to negotiate the price in this case.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[Reasoning text]\\n\\nIn comparing both scenarios, Jill is seen to appreciate handmade craft from local artisans like me. She also expresses her financial concern over the marked price and her passion to support the craft. However, taking a careful look at the statements made by Jill in both scenarios, Scenario 1 strongly suggests a future continuing patronage, which gives an incentive for me to compromise on the price to retain her as a customer and also possibly sell more items in the future. In Scenario 2, Jill only indicates her love for local art pieces but mentions no intention of possible future purchases. Therefore, although it is not an easy decision, ensuring a regular customer by negotiating the price might be more beneficial in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a negotiation standpoint, both scenarios present compelling cases for a price adjustment. However, several key factors lead me to favor one scenario over the other. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, showing her acknowledgment of the effort and time put into creating it. She also states her support for local artisans which implies she values the work involved. Jill then expresses her desire for the vase and notes that the price is a bit out of her current budget. Here, Jill is quite honest about her financial situation, which adds credibility to her request for a price adjustment. She is not asking for a considerable discount, just a 'little wiggle room', which suggests she respects the artisan's work and is not trying to undervalue their effort. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 involves Jill asking for potential discounts for multiple purchases or for returning customers. While these propositions may seem appealing, they put the artisan in a spot where they're committing to future discounts without any concrete commitment from Jill apart from her 'plan' of regular visits. The social media aspect she introduces could give the artisan exposure, but it's not guaranteed to translate into sales. It could also set a precedence for the artisan, where they might be expected to offer discounts to anyone promising to promote them on social media.\\n\\nTherefore, based on the above reasoning, I would be more inclined to negotiate with Jill in:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has approached the situation by complimenting the item and acknowledging the work that has gone into it, which is a good starting point for any negotiation. However, her methods of justifying her request for a discount vary quite significantly. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is open about the fact that the price is slightly out of her budget, hinting at the fact that she might not be able to buy the item unless the price is reduced. This may work in her favor as, being a local artisan, I may be more interested in selling my items to people who genuinely appreciate them and will give them a good home, rather than just making a profit.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers two reasons for a potential discount: the possibility of purchasing multiple items and her potential to promote the items on her social media platform. While the promise of future purchases might be appealing, it's not guaranteed. The social media promotion, however, could potentially reach a large audience and attract new customers to the stall, which could generate more sales in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nHaving considered both scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. Her suggestion of promoting my items on her social media platform could be more beneficial to me in the long term, despite being an undefined return. While Scenario 1 is more immediately sympathetic, as a business, potential brand exposure offers greater future opportunity.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere seems to be a greater willingness to compromise price in Scenario 2. Even though they both show interest, Jill from Scenario 2 is giving more reasons and bargaining chips for you to consider lowering your price. She is discussing not only just getting the vase, but also potential repeated business, as she plans to come back to the market often. Moreover, she could potentially help expand your customer base with her social media following, which is an aspect in favor of giving her a discount. In Scenario 1, while Jill shows admiration for your work, she only uses her current budget constraint as an argument, and she does not mention anything about promoting your work, repeat business, or buying multiple items. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 7\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning:\\nWhile both scenarios present Jill as genuinely interested in and appreciative of the vase, there is a slight difference in how she approaches the topic of negotiation. In Scenario 1, Jill immediately shows her interest in the vase, acknowledges its unique quality, and only after all of this does she bring up the concept of a discount. This could potentially give the impression that she values the craftsmanship and the time and effort that went into creating the vase.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 also does a good job in expressing Jill's admiration for the vase and local artisans, but she introduces the concept of a discount as a circumstantial necessity because of her current budget. It somewhat gives the impression that she might be more willing to pay the full price if it was within her budget.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses admiration for the vase and explains her interest in it. However, there are subtle differences which may influence our willingness to negotiate.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the work and craftsmanship that has gone into the creation of the vase. This appreciation signifies her understanding of the vase's value, suggesting that she may be willing to meet halfway in terms of price. However, she doesn't present a personal or compelling reason for a price negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, on the other hand, Jill shares a personal story stating her support for local artisans and desire to incorporate their work into her home. Moreover, she provides a specific, relatable reason for requesting a discount- the current price is beyond her present budget. This personal touch, combined with her love for artisan-made goods might make us more likely to empathize with her situation and negotiate a price that fits her budget, while also maintaining the value of our craftwork.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill makes it clear that she values the vase and appreciates the work that has gone into crafting it. However, in the second Scenario she also explains that she is a supporter of local artisans which could imply repeat business and free word of mouth advertising, enhancing future sales.\\n\\nFurthermore, she justifies her request for a discount by stating that the current price slightly exceeds her budget. So, it appears reasonable to offer a small discount to Jill in scenario 2 to secure her as a customer and potential repeat buyer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "1_2, generation 1, score 4\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Both scenarios presented by Jill are polite and respectful, showing admiration to the craftsmanship and expressing interest in supporting local artisans. They both also express Jill\\'s intention of being a repeat customer and purchasing multiple items. Here are some reasoning points, and how they may influence the decision on negotiating the price.\\n\\n1. Attitude and politeness: Both scenarios are friendly and polite, valuing the artisans\\' work. This is an important element when considering negotiating prices. There is no significant difference in this element between the two options.\\n\\n2. Appreciation for craftsmanship: Both scenarios show a great appreciation for craftsmanship, which will always be appreciated by the artisan. However, scenario 2 emphasizes a stronger emphasis on appreciating and valuing the work that goes into the item. \\n\\n3. Intention of purchase: Both scenarios express the intention of buying the vase. However, scenario 1 explicitly expresses the intention of buying multiple items at once, which could be a more enticing offer for the artisan.\\n\\n4. Intent of future business: Both scenarios express the intention of returning for future business. This is something that any vendor appreciates and could influence the decision for a discount. Regardless, scenario 1 seems to emphasize a certain commitment to future business, as Jill noted she is \"definitely planning to come back to shop in the future.\"\\n\\nConsidering all the above points, my decision would lean towards scenario 1 due to its explicit mention of buying multiple items at once and a stronger commitment to returning for future business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning Text:\\nWhile both scenarios exhibit respect for the craft and desire to support local artisans, the customer in Scenario 1 seems genuinely invested in the artisan's work, future visits, and purchasing other items as value added. She also acknowledges clue of an explicit financial constraint on her part, giving a solid reason to need a discount. In Scenario 2, Jill seems interested in buying the vase, mentions the potential of buying other items, and her intent to return, but doesn't quite give a direct reason to need a discount aside from asking if bargaining is possible. Therefore, considering the nature of a seller-buyer relationship, a scenario where the potential buyer not just values the products but also shows intent towards building a long-term relationship by acknowledging future visits may encourage the artisan to negotiate or offer a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: Both scenarios roughly follow the same negotiation pattern with Jill complimenting the piece and expressing her interest in supporting local artisans and becoming a returning customer. However, in Scenario 1, Jill discloses that her budget is tight at the moment and she is looking for discounts due to financial constraints. Scenario 2 contains a similar request for negotiation, but without direct reference to financial issues. Instead, Jill seems more focused on making a deal, rather than expressing financial need. As a seller, one might be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1 due to empathising with Jill's budget issue, while in Scenario 2 it seems like Jill is more interested in securing a deal regardless of her actual financial capabilities.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Reasoning Text:\\n\\nLooking at Scenario 1, Jill is willing to share my work on her social media platform which is of great benefit to me as a local artisan. Exposure from someone with a large follower base who is passionate about handcrafted works can effectively boost my reach and potentially draw in more clients.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2, where Jill offers the potential of buying multiple items or returning to make future purchases, does present a promise of continuous support, yet without any immediate and assured form of exposure or monetary benefit for me as a craftsperson.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios can incentive one to engage in a price negotiation, the offer in Scenario 1 presents a more immediate reward and potential future benefits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1. The reasoning behind this choice revolves around several factors.\\n\\nFirstly, Jill demonstrates a deep appreciation for local craftsmanship, not just verbally but also through her proposed action of promoting the works on social media. This reflects her willingness to provide value beyond the purchase itself, which promises greater visibility for the products and potential customers drawn to the stall.\\n\\nSecondly, she stated her plan clearly. It\\'s not a vague promise to bring \"potential customers\"; instead, she plans to share it right on her social media, which most likely has followers with similar interests. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while she does express the intention to return and purchase again in the future, such a promise is not as tangible as the social media exposure Jill offers in Scenario 1. It is a promise that depends on several uncertain factors like whether she would have enough budget next time or if she would really come back. We don\\'t have a definite way of measuring that.\\n\\nTherefore, the assuredness of potential future benefits seems stronger in Scenario 1, making it a better option to negotiate prices provided that Jill can demonstrate her significant social media following.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her appreciation for the work and the importance of supporting local artisans. However, her negotiation tactics differ between the two, with the first focusing more on a partnership or collaboration whereas the second leans more towards an immediate sale or possible future sales. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, she offers to publicize and expose your business to a broader audience via her social media platforms. Although this kind of exposure could potentially bring in new business, there's no guarantee it would. She leverages her social media influence, which is not quantifiable nor certain to result in new customers.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, she inquires about discounts for multiple items or future purchases. This approach not only shows her interest in purchasing more items but also indicates her intent to return for future purchases. This could provide the guarantee of more immediate income and also the potential for a loyal customer in the long run. \\n\\nTherefore, taking into account the certainty of immediate sales and the promise of return business, I would be more inclined to negotiate in the second scenario. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Reasoning:\\nAnalyzing both scenarios, Jill has utilized various tactics to negotiate the price of the vase. In scenario 1, she compliments the craftsmanship and expresses her support for local artisans. She also hints at future purchases and asks about discounts for multiple items or return customers. The persuasion hinges on loyalty and volume of purchase. \\n\\nIn scenario 2, she combines the appreciation of the craft, similar to Scenario 1, but approaches the negotiation from a marketing perspective. She offers to use her social media influence to promote the artisan’s work in exchange for a discount. Even though this sounds promising, it presents a less tangible immediate benefit, with the potential yield depending on her true social media influence and its effectiveness.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the potential promise of future interactions is more tangible and certain. The risk of discounting the vase could be mitigated by the potential for future purchases. Scenario 2 puts the artisan at more risk depending on whether the social media promotion effectively brings in new customers.', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling lines of reasoning from Jill for a possible discount. However, my preference as an artisan would be for scenario 2. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers the prospect of being a returning customer and possibly buying more items. While this is appealing, it is not a guaranteed benefit for me as the artisan. The promise of future purchases is uncertain and therefore less tangible.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 proposes a more immediate form of compensation. If Jill has a significant social media presence as she claims, she could potentially bring substantial exposure and direct traffic to my business. This kind of promotion could reach a wide and diverse audience that I might not have access to otherwise. Since Jill is willing to showcase my work to her following, this could result in not only one-time sales but also the potential of repeat customers.\\n\\nTherefore, my decision would be swayed more towards scenario 2 as I stand the chance of not just selling an item at a discounted price, but also gaining more visibility and potentially attracting more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill uses a really good approach to ask for a discount. In the first scenario, she praises the craftsmanship of the vase and shows eagerness to support local artisans. She also ensures the seller of future business and purchases. This can certainly be a tempting proposition for the seller to attract a potential regular customer.\\n\\nHowever, in scenario 2, Jill not only appreciates the artistry but also emphasizes her intention to promote the artist's work on her social media platforms which would potentially reach a wider audience, leading to an increase in sales. This does not only make her purchase at a discounted price, it essentially makes her a promoter of the artist's brand, thereby making it a mutually beneficial business proposition.\\n\\nTherefore, the seller is more likely to negotiate on the vase's price in scenario 2, considering the wider exposure and potential clientele expansion that could result from Jill's social media post.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "1_2, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Reasoning text:\\nChoosing between the two scenarios depends on the context of each situation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1: Jill has expressed her admiration for the handcrafted vase and noticeably shows interest in supporting local artisans. She poses the idea of buying multiple items and suggests the possibility of being a returning customer in the future. This indicates that although she may be asking for a discount on the current piece, she is likely to generate greater sales revenue in the long run. Agreeing to negotiate the price or offering a modest discount as a token of appreciation for her support might incentivize her to make more purchases both immediately and in the future.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2: Jill has also shown an appreciation for the craft, but her request for a price reduction seems to be more focused on the current item rather than future purchases or multiple items. While she identifies herself as a \"supporter of local artisans\", there isn\\'t a direct indication of ongoing or future patronage. This scenario presents less potential for future return as compared to the first.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill in a good light as a customer who is supportive of local artisans and appreciates the craft. However, in both instances, she alludes to the possibility of a price reduction or discount. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions a future plan of shopping with you, indicating a desire to create a lasting relationship. She also suggests that she might be purchasing multiple items which could lead to higher overall income for you even if you give a discount on this particular item.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill only asks for a price reduction due to her budget constraints. She does not suggest the possibility of buying other items or becoming a repeat customer.\\n\\nTherefore, establishing a relationship with a potential repeat customer and increasing immediate sale volume could be a more attractive scenario for you as an artisan. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is genuinely interested in the vase and appreciates the craftsmanship involved. However, the first scenario indicates that Jill is planning on buying multiple items or coming back to shop in the future, thus increasing her potential value to me as a repeat customer.\\n\\nWhile Scenario 2 also shows Jill's admiration for the work and a willingness to support local artisans, it does not offer the additional potential of future sales. Therefore, I see more potential benefit in giving a discount in the first scenario, as the promise of repeat business could potentially offset the reduction in income from the vase and result in greater long-term profit.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0.5, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth Jill's in scenario 1 and scenario 2 show interest in supporting local artisans and mention the potential of being a returning customer. However, the main difference lies in their approach to the negotiation. \\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and implies that she values the work put into it. She addresses the pricing indirectly, expressing her interest in discounts without necessarily asking for a reduction in the price of the vase. \\n\\nIn contrast, Jill in the second scenario explicitly states that the price of the vase is more than she was hoping to spend. From a negotiation standpoint, this could potentially be seen as undervaluing the work of the artisan, as she indicates right away that she doesn't see the vase worth the original marked price.\\n\\nConsidering both scenarios, as an artisan who appreciates customers who value the work put into my handcrafted items, I would be more inclined to negotiate with Jill from scenario 1. In the first scenario, Jill shows a more respectful approach to the negotiation by acknowledging the work put into the item and by expressing her interest in potential deals or discounts, rather than directly asking for a lower price on the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"In both scenarios, Jill expresses her admiration for the vase and craft, indicates the intention to become a returning customer, and tactfully insinuates her budget constraints. However, the situations have slight differences that could influence the decision to negotiate.\\n\\nScenario 1: Jill states her intent to support local artisans and her likelihood to return consistently for shopping, setting a future prospect for your business. \\n\\nScenario 2: Jill expresses her love for the vase, implicitly indicating that she is a collector. Here, she also promises to return, which creates future business. But her emphasis also seems more focused on immediate sales.\\n\\nMy reasoning for choosing a scenario comes down to whether I'm focused more on immediate sales and revenue or building a lasting customer relationship, which could yield more profits in the long run.\\n\\nIf I prioritize immediate events, I might be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. Jill's words imply that she is after a transaction today and presents a real-time situation where giving a discount could lead to greater immediate sales. \\n\\nIf I am taking a long-term perspective, Scenario 1 might be more attractive because while Jill does express budget constraints, she highlights her intent to support local businesses - which could hint at consistent patronage and allow me to earn more overall revenue in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: It depends on my specific business goals at the moment. If I desire immediate sales, Scenario 2 has a slight edge. However, for the purpose of building a lasting customer relationship, Scenario 1 appears stronger.\", \"Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill compliments your craftsmanship and shows interest in supporting local artisans. She also mentions the possibility of shopping here in the future which could lead to more sales opportunities. However, in Scenario 2, Jill refers to adding unique pieces to her collection, suggesting that she might appreciate and value the items more than an average customer. The specific mention of a collection may also mean she is more likely to become a repeat customer, as collectors often purchase multiple pieces over time to build their collection. As she'd spend more in the future, reducing the price by a little can foster customer loyalty and lead to more sales in the future. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "1_2, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide valid reasons for a price negotiation. However, Scenario 2 shows a bit more incentive for me as an artisan to be inclined towards negotiation. In this scenario, Jill not only expresses her appreciation for the vase but also suggests a beneficial compromise, which is promoting my handcrafted items on her social media. This could potentially capture the attention of new customers and subsequently increase my sales. Furthermore, her intent to place it in her living room suggests that she values the product and it's not just an impulse buy.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 1 also presents a compelling case with the promise of future patronage and purchasing multiple items. But the effect of these promises is somewhat uncertain and relies on the customers' long-term commitment, which may or may not materialize.\\n\\nFor these reasons, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 2, as the potential direct and immediate benefits outweigh the potential long-term profits of Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill does an excellent job of complimenting the vase and showing her sincere interest. However, each scenario presents different potential benefits for me as the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill mentions the possibility of buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. Her loyalty could lead to more sales in the future, which would be a positive outcome. \\n\\nHowever, I'd need to ensure that the discounts on multiple items don't significantly cut my profit margins. Additionally, future sales are not guaranteed, and Jill may or may not come back even after given the discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill highlights not just a single purchase, but also a potential marketing opportunity. By posting photos of the vase on her social media and tagging my store, she could expose my handcrafted items to a larger audience. This could generate more sales and increase my customer base. \\n\\nSo, after evaluating both scenarios, I would lean towards a negotiation in Scenario 2 as it presents an immediate return investment in the form of a third-party promotion, which might bring more customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses an intention to become a returning customer and supports local artisans like yourself. Also, she suggests a basis for negotiation that can potentially benefit your artisan business in the long run - discounting prices for multiple items or for future returning customers. This approach may encourage customer loyalty, repeat business, and can be a good promotion technique attracting more customers willing to buy multiple items. So as an artisan who likely values sustainable customer relations and community support, you might feel positively inclined towards this proposal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, although Jill also shows appreciation for the vase’s craftsmanship and even offers to promote your work on her social media, she directly jumps into price reduction without much concrete or mutually beneficial proposition unlike Scenario 1. Yes, promotion through social media can be beneficial but factors such as Jill's online reach, engagement rate, and followers' propensity to actually buy also come into play, making the return on this aspect a bit uncertain.\\n\\nOverall, while both propositions have their potential merits, my inclination as an artisan trying to build a local loyal customer base would lead me towards Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_2, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Both scenarios present a customer who appreciates the value of the piece and expresses an interest in supporting your work. However, there are a few key differences that might influence your willingness to negotiate the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill explicitly asks for a discount or negotiation on the round flower vase. She appreciates the craftsmanship which shows that she values your work. However, she didn't commit to buying it yet or promised to come back for more.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill not only expresses her admiration for your work but also her intention to support local artisans in the future. The promise of her becoming a returning customer could potentially lead to more sales compared to Scenario 1, especially if she recommends your products to others.\\n\\nFinally, Jill also inquires if there is any discount for future purchases or for buying multiple items. This shows that she is possibly interested in buying more than just the round flower vase. \\n\\nFor these reasons, being interested in securing a potential long-term customer and potentially selling more than one item, you would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill's approach in both scenarios is courteous and respectful; she expresses admiration for the vase and acknowledges the value of the craftsmanship.\\n\\nYet, in Scenario 1, she directly asks for a price negotiation or discount. In Western bargaining cultures, this direct approach is common and typically initiates bargaining. However, this approach is generally less effective than Scenario 2, mainly because it's a one-shot deal without any promise of future engagement or business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill takes a more strategic stance. She not only compliments the product, but she also makes a point of noting her intention to support local artisans. Moreover, she floats the idea of buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. This scenario sweetens the negotiation deal for the artisan. Jill is expressing an interest in creating an ongoing customer relationship, potentially resulting in more net profit in the long run for the artisan.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential for repeat business and sale of more items, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 2 due to the possibility of a long-term, mutually beneficial business relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges the work and effort put into crafting the vase and expresses her genuine interest in purchasing it. She is direct in discussing the idea of a price negotiation. The consideration here is if Jill's appreciation and possibility of negotiation would seem enticing enough to reduce the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill uses a more indirect approach to negotiate the vase's price. She praises the vase's craftsmanship and shows support for local artisans. Jill also suggests her intention to be a returning customer and her interest in buying multiple items. The resale potential and the idea of having a loyal customer could be motivating.\\n\\nBased on these scenarios, my decision would lean towards Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nReasoning: In Scenario 2, Jill shows potential not just as a one-time customer, but possibly a recurring one, which can benefit the business in the long run. Also, she expresses interest in purchasing multiple items, which could lead to a higher total sale even if the items are priced slightly lower. The combination of long-term customer relationship building and higher total sales makes Jill's proposal in Scenario 2 more appealing.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"In response to Scenario 1:\\nJill is offering something beyond more money as a part of her negotiation. Her offer to share the work on her social media platforms could result in increased exposure and potentially more customers in the future. This free advertising is valuable and could result in a greater increase in revenue over time than the immediate sale of the vase. \\n\\nIn response to Scenario 2:\\nIn this scenario, Jill is asking for a discount based on her intention to purchase multiple items or become a returning customer. While this does offer potential for additional sales in the future, it doesn't guarantee future purchases and doesn't offer any immediate, additional value as Scenario 1 does.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Although the benefits from both scenarios are theoretical, the guaranteed exposure from the social media promotion in Scenario 1 has a more direct and measurable potential for driving revenue in the short and medium term than a promise of future purchases in Scenario 2. This makes Scenario 1 a more desirable strategy from a business perspective.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Jill's proposition in Scenario 1 not only appeals to a short-term benefit (the immediate sale) but also to long-term advantages (potential increase in visibility, customer base, and future sales). If Jill has a sizable social media following that aligns with potential customer demographics, offering a discount could ultimately pay off more than the price cut. Additionally, from the description Jill provides, she seems genuinely enthusiastic, supportive, and appreciative of the artisan's work, highlighting a potential for a longer-term customer relationship and possible referrals. Also, Jill talks about promoting the artist's work, which could lead to a rise in business visibility.\\n\\nWhile the potential of selling more than one vase in Scenario 2 is also appealing, there seems to be less guarantee of continued benefit as compared to the prospect of more visibility for future customers generated from Jill's social media promotion in Scenario 1. The discount proposal in scenario 2 also seems to be mainly centered around the buyer's benefit rather than a mutual benefit, as compared to scenario 1.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill approaches me politely and appreciatively, showing interest and admiration for my craftsmanship. However, what makes scenario 1 more appealing, despite seemingly similar notions, is the mention of potential exposure through her social media platforms.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers not only a purchase but also an exchange where the value goes beyond just the sale of the vase. She's providing a form of compensation in addition to paying for the vase. Jill's offer to promote my work on her social media where she has a considerable following could potentially increase my customer base which could lead to greater sales in the long run. This form of advertisement is an added value and a bartering chip that makes me more likely to negotiate the price and offer a discount.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2 Jill asks for discounts on potential future purchases. While this might suggest a long-term customer relationship, it's much more speculative and uncertain compared to the immediate and definite offer of advertising present in Scenario 1. Also, offering a discount in anticipation of future purchases might set a precedent for discounted prices in the long run which may not be sustainable for my business.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present interesting propositions, however, as an artisan my goal would be to sell more of my merchandise while also building a loyal customer base. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses appreciation for my work. She also mentions she will be a returning customer, possibly even buying more than one item. This is attractive as having loyal, returning customers can be a great asset for a small business like mine. Furthermore, her intention to buy multiple items could result in a larger immediate sale, even if I do offer her a discount. These reasons make Scenario 1 attractive. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers to promote my art on her social media platforms for a discount. While this could bring me exposure, there is no guarantee that her followers will be interested in or be able/willing to purchase my handcrafted items. The impact on my potential sales is uncertain, making the offer less attractive. \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill wishes to negotiate the price down, and even though exposure on social media is tempting, the promise of regular visits and the purchase of multiple items in Scenario 1 is much more appealing. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their own unique ways of trying to negotiate the price. In the first scenario, Jill expresses her admiration for the work and discusses her intention of becoming a returning customer. She further expresses interest in purchasing multiple items. This could mean a larger immediate sales for me and potential future sales which is appealing. This is a direct benefit for me as an artisan and a seller.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill offers to share my work on her large social media platform. Whilst this sounds intriguing, there are a few uncertainties. The effectiveness of this type of promotion isn't a guaranteed sale and there is no way of knowing how Jill's followers will react, if they will be interested in my work, and if they would actually purchase anything. While it could potentially generate more exposure and thus more business, it's also a substantial risk since there's no immediate tangible benefit.\\n\\nTherefore, taking these factors into account, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1. It seems to offer more immediate and assured benefits to me as a seller. The promise of additional purchases increases the value of the overall sale and the possibility of a return customer offers more long-term stability. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[Reasoning Text]\\nBoth scenarios are good examples of negotiation strategies where the customer upfront admires the artisan's work and politely communicates their desire for a better deal.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, the customer appears to be potentially a value customer who might buy more than one item and also could be a returning customer. This can result in higher future sales for the artisan while requiring one-time negotiation as a reward to the customer's loyalty. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the customer offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. However, without concrete numbers regarding the customer's following or reach, it's hard to evaluate what the artisan could actually benefit from this deal. It also introduces additional risk if the social media promotion does not consequently lead to more sales.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, the artisan may feel inclined to negotiate more in the first scenario as it provides a more immediate and quantifiable return. Also, having a large customer base that consistently buys your products gives a certain amount of stability and predictability to your business' revenue, while depending on the impact of a social media post can be quite uncertain.\\n  \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her admiration for the craftsmanship and the quality of work, showing genuine appreciation for the items. However, it is in Scenario 1 when she not only shows interest in reducing the price of one item but also in potentially purchasing several items and becoming a repeat customer. Thus, giving her a discount in this case could serve as an investment, potentially leading to several successful transactions in the long run. Moreover, there is a chance that she could become a regular and loyal customer, spreading a good word about the products and inviting others to the shop. That said, I would be more prone to negotiate a discount in Scenario 1, because providing a small initial discount could be beneficial in the long term. Here, I see not only a customer but a potential patron and promoter of my craftsmanship, contributing more significantly to my business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has approached very politely and appreciatively, showing admiration for the artisan's work. This is a good starting point for negotiation. However, the scenarios differ on a few points:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses her interest in negotiating the price for the vase, but also mentions the possibility of purchasing multiple items. This potentially increases the purchase amount from her. In addition, she talks about coming back in the future, indicating she could be a returning customer. This could lead to more business opportunities for the artisan in the future.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill does show recognition for the artisan’s work and shows her support for local artisans. However, she only discusses the possibility of a discount on the single item due to her budget constraint. There is no mention of purchasing additional items or becoming a returning customer.\\n\\nGiven these points, I would be more likely to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1. It seems like a potentially larger immediate sale and the prospect of retaining a loyal customer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as an appreciator of artisanal crafts. However, Jill shows a deeper interest and commitment in scenario 1 than in scenario 2. In the first scenario, Jill specifically mentions her plans to return to the market in the future and her intent on purchasing multiple items. This indicates a potential for repetitive business and not just a one-time purchase. She sounds like a valuable customer who appreciates the craft and is likely to spread positive word of mouth and bring in more business. This contrasts with scenario 2 where Jill expresses her love for the vase but focuses heavily on her budget constraint. It seems like a one-time transaction and there's no explicit mention of her returning for more purchases.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "1_2, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios provide compelling reasons for a price negotiation. However, they present a slightly different approach from Jill. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill directly appreciates the round flower vase and acknowledges the craftsmanship involved in creating the decorative piece. She is upfront about her interest in purchasing the vase, and actively inquires about the possibilities of bargaining and discounts, given she plans on being a returning customer. Her query balances respect for the artisan's work with the practical consideration of price.\\n\\nOn the other hand, scenario 2 has Jill appreciating the artisan's work as well, but she hints at monetary constraints after expressing her interest in the vase. Despite her confession about the price being slightly above her budget, she shows intent to support the local artisan community by being a repeat customer in the future, which is an indirect suggestion for a discount or deal. \\n\\nIn both cases, the customer signals a future purchase, which could be good for the business. \\n\\nFrom a negotiation perspective, scenario 1 seems, however, more forthright. Jill explicitly requests a discount or a deal, while in scenario 2, she hinting at these things. In terms of sales, clear communication may often lead to quicker decisions and satisfied customers. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth Scenario 1 and Scenario 2 present compelling arguments for a discount. However, there is a notable difference in the approach of the customer in each situation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill opens up about her admiration for the craftsmanship of the vase, even before discussing the pricing or potential discounts. She expresses interest in buying multiple items and also indicates that she would be a returning customer, both suggesting potential future sale opportunities.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill does praise the work, nevertheless, her main focus is on the price being more than she had budgeted for. She does mention returning to the market in the future and the possibility of purchasing multiple items, but her primary interest seems to be on getting a deal due to her budget limitations.\\n\\nBased on these analyses, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. Here, not only does she convey a greater appreciations for the craftsmanship, which denotes she values the work, but also appears genuinely interested in making multiple purchases and returning in the future. This signals that she might become a loyal customer, thus justifying the discount which could lead to higher overall profits in the long term.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios Jill approached with compliments about the craft work and showed intention of not only buying the vase but also of purchasing multiple items in the future. This surely indicates her genuine interest towards supporting local talents and this attitude is definitely appreciable. However, if we investigate a little more into the subtle nuances of the conversations, we might be able to draw some hints about the possibility of a more immediate and sure sale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly asked for the possibility of price negotiation on the vase and mentioned her future market visits. It can be interpreted that she is indeed interested in buying now but at a lower price, and also indicated of possible future purchases. Her question about discount for returning customers denotes that she plans to come back but her immediate purchase intent seems more guaranteed here.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill confessed the price was more than what she had in mind indicating that she might not buy right now unless a substantial discount is given. Her question about multi-item discount or discount for returning customers is more of a backup plan that she is considering for future purchases.\\n\\nTherefore, I would take Scenario 1 as a more immediate opportunity for making a sale and would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill.\\n \\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn my opinion, Jill's approach in Scenario 2 is more persuasive for a negotiation. Firstly, she compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, similar to what she does in scenario 1, showing genuine appreciation for the artisan's work. However, beyond just expressing her interest, Jill presents two possible ways that she could provide value to the artisan in return for a discount. \\n\\nFirst, Jill mentions that she plans to be a repeat customer, suggesting that the artisan can expect future revenue from her. This is a strong negotiation tactic as it offers recurring business in exchange for a small favorable deal now. Secondly, Jill mentions that she has a few thousand followers on social media and offers to promote the artisan's work on her platforms. This implies that the artisan could gain additional exposure, potentially leading to more customers down the line. This form of unofficial 'influencer marketing' can be very valuable, especially for small, local artisans who may not have a large advertising budget. \\n\\nWhile scenario 1 also includes Jill expressing her admiration for the work and indicates she would return, it lacks the concrete offer she presents in Scenario 2. Therefore, as an artisan, I would be more interested in negotiating the price with Jill in Scenario 2 due to potential future benefits. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present different opportunities for negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows an interest in not only the round flower vase but potentially other items as well. She expresses a direct interest in becoming a returning customer, which could lead to more future sales. This makes considering a discount advantageous as it could foster a relationship and create a regular customer. The potential for repeat business gives me incentive to negotiate the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill proposes a discount in exchange for some social media attention to my works, even though she also shows interest in the vase itself and hints at potential future visits. This proposition could be beneficial by increasing the visibility of my work, potentially attracting more customers. \\n\\nHowever, there are uncertainties along with this. There is no guarantee that her posts will translate into more clients or sales. Also, committing to discounts based on vague future social media promotion sets a risky precedent if other customers were to find out. \\n\\nBased on these explanations, \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. The prospect of securing a returning customer who might purchase multiple items in the future seems more certain and immediately beneficial than hoping for potential indirect business due to someone's social media posting.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expressed admiration for the handcrafted vase and a willingness to support the artisan's work, either by buying additional items or through return visits to the market. Positive customer experiences can easily translate into repeat business and word-of-mouth promotion, which might be tempting for the artisan to consider when negotiating the price.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers a straightforward proposal for a potential discount: buying multiple items and committing to returning in the future. This sort of bulk buying or loyalty discount is a common practice and can be a worthwhile investment for the artisan, as it guarantees more sales and a potential return customer.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill suggests a social media promotion in exchange for a discount. While this provides a different type of visibility, it's less predictable and harder to quantify its effect on future sales than the more traditional approach of buying more items or promising repeat business.\\n\\nConsidering these factors, Scenario 1 provides more surety for the artisan, both in terms of immediate sales (through additional purchases) and longer-term customer loyalty.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\nBoth scenarios present valid reasons for considering a price negotiation. However, the deciding factor lies in the potential long-term benefits for your artisan business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill promises to actively promote your business on her social media if a price reduction is facilitated. This could increase public awareness of your products and potentially bring in more customers. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill hints at a possibility of becoming a regular customer, meaning a steady income for the business over time. Yet, this is not a concrete proposal from her, as she uses phrases like \"planning on\" which are subjective to changes. \\n\\nFor small businesses, marketing is often a part of the budget that requires a tremendous investment. In the digital age, social media exposure can greatly affect the success of a business, especially a local, craft-based enterprise like yours. \\n\\nTherefore, while both scenarios offer interesting pros, Scenario 1 seems to offer more immediate benefits as well as potential for future growth. The possibility of advertising through Jill\\'s social media is a form of payment itself. Additionally, the language Jill uses in Scenario 1 shows more urgency to buy the product, which could potentially mean an immediate sell.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nFor both scenarios, Jill shows a deep appreciation for the vase's craftsmanship and expresses a desire to buy, which is a good start for a negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she not only seeks a reduction in price, but also offers something in return - advertising the item and the store on her social media. This can possibly attract more customers to the shop, providing more value in the long run than the potential short-term loss from the price reduction.\\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill also hints at the prospect of buying multiple items or becoming a returning customer, which might offer a more immediate ROI from the price reduction compared to the potential exposure from social media advertising in Scenario 1. However, there is less certainty here as there's no affirmative statement that Jill will definitely purchase more items.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\n\\nIn this situation, the mutual benefit is clearer and more certain: Jill gets a discount, while the shop gains valuable marketing through her social media. The potential to draw more customers and make more sales may outweigh the initial drop in price for the vase. It's important for an artisan in local markets like this to build a wider customer base for sustainability.\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn Jill's first scenario, she is trying to bargain in exchange for promoting the product on her social media, but there is no way to measure the effectiveness of her effort. There isn't a guarantee that her posting would result in increased sales or how many people will actually see her post. Hence, this method of price reduction seems less reliable.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, while Jill is requesting for a negotiation on price, she is willing to buy multiple items — which means more sales for the artisan — or return as a customer. Both of these options create a more direct and substantial advantage for the artisan, both in the short and long term respectively. Greater customer loyalty is beneficial for sustaining the business, while selling more items in one transaction helps increase immediate profits.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a respectful and appreciative customer who values the work and craftsmanship that has gone into the flower vase. However, some differences could potentially impact my decision to negotiate.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill's approach is more straightforward. She admires the vase and directly expresses her interest in a possible discount or negotiation. While this approach is clear and might lead to a negotiation, it doesn't provide additional benefits to me as the seller. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill not only admires my craftsmanship but also mentions her intention of purchasing multiple items and becoming a returning customer. This implies potential for more sales now and in future, which may make offering her a small discount on the vase more advantageous in the long run.\\n\\nAs a seller, while I want to value my work appropriately, customer loyalty and the opportunity for repeat business is a significant factor to consider. Therefore, while both scenarios could lead to negotiation, Jill’s long-term customer potential in scenario 2 might make me more likely to negotiate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", 'Reasoning: The decision to negotiate the price of the vase would certainly depend on several factors, but based on the given scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 2. Although both individuals are expressing their interest in the item, the customer in Scenario 2 is not only expressing a strong interest in that one item but also hinting at the potential for future purchases. Offering a discount to this customer could not only secure the immediate sale but also garner a repeat customer who may make additional purchases. Moreover, she also expressed interest in buying multiple items which could potentially lead to a bigger sale. Therefore, it would make more sense to negotiate with the customer in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning: The customer in both scenarios is polite and shows genuine appreciation for the artisan's work, which can make the artisan more disposed to negotiate. However, in scenario 2, Jill proposes buying multiple items, not just the vase, which could potentially be a more profitable transaction. Moreover, she mentions being a returning customer, suggesting a potentially long-term relationship which might be valuable for the artisan. Therefore, the artisan may be more inclined to consider negotiation in scenario 2 in the hopes of securing a higher total sale and possibly a regular customer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 0, score 8\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile it's appealing to have someone praise your work as a craftsman, it doesn't change the cost of materials or the time and effort put into creating the vase. Therefore, mere words of praise should not be the single factor in deciding to give a discount in scenario 1.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, although Jill is still asking for a discount, she is offering something in return - publicity. By sharing the craftsman's work on her social media, she could potentially attract more buyers in the future. This is a form of bartering, and could benefit the artisan's business in the long run.\\n\\nIt's important to note that any decision to lower the price should also take into account the potential effect on one’s profit margins. But in this specific scenario, considering the future potential customers, the better option would be to give a discount in return for the publicity.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both of Jill's offers are compelling, each offering their own incentives, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in scenario 2. In this case, Jill isn't just asking for a discount because of her limited budget; she's also offering a value in return: promotion of my products on her social media channels. \\n\\nAs an artisan selling my handcrafted items, gaining exposure to a wider audience could potentially drive more business my way, making it a beneficial trade-off. While I would be selling the vase for less than the marked price, the potential benefits outweigh the immediate loss. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present compelling arguments for a discount. In Scenario 1, Jill expresses her appreciation for local artisans and the craftsmanship involved in making the vase but mentions her budget constraint as a reason for a potential discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only complements the craftsmanship but also offers value in terms of a potential future sales through her social media followers, which is a form of barter trade that has the potential to benefit my business in the long run. This gives a promising viable way to increase recognition and sales which is advantageous.\\n\\nWith these points in mind, although Scenario 1 is more straightforward, Scenario 2 is more compelling due to a more advantageous returned favor, and hence a discount would be justified.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 0, score 8\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a compelling argument for considering a price negotiation. In both instances, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and expresses her desire to support local artisans. However, the approach varies slightly in each situation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is straight to the point and honest about her budget constraints. On the other hand, Scenario 2 involves the promise of providing exposure on social media platforms. This latter scenario could potentially lead to greater awareness and increased sales in the future.\\n\\nNevertheless, relying on potential exposure and promise of promotion is riskier compared to a direct sale that scenario 1 presents. While the potential benefits from Scenario 2 could be significant, it's also possible the expected exposure might not translate to substantial sales or it might not reach the right target audience.\\n\\nMoreover, it would also depend on whether I as an artisan am trying to increase exposure or simply make a sale on the spot. However, given that this is a local market setup, immediate sales would likely be the priority, making the sure sale in Scenario 1 more appealing.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nEach scenario presents a different form of negotiation and they both have their potential benefits. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is straightforward, candid, and directly asks for a discount due to budgetary constraints. Her recognition of the artisan's craftsmanship and her support for local artisans can be appreciable. By asking directly, Jill might motivate a sympathy response and depending on the seller's nature and if they can afford to, they might give the discount.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill's approach is not just to ask for a discount but to offer something in return - promotion on her social media platforms, which has the potential to reach new customers and therefore more sales in the future. This barter-style trade-off could be a very appealing proposition for the artisan, depending on how established their business is, how much they value social media marketing, and their evaluation of Jill's social media influence.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios have valid negotiation points, in a temporary local market setting, an artisan might lean more towards immediate sale and cash flow, especially if they aren't heavily reliant on or interested in social media marketing. Thus, while both offers are good, the first scenario could potentially provide more immediate results in comparison to the long-term, prospective gains of the second offer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAs an artisan, the value of the product works on multiple levels including the time and effort invested to create it, the originality of each item due to its handmade nature, and it being a source of income. Price negotiations can be a sensitive matter, and each of the two scenarios provides a different angle for negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and shows sincerity in supporting local artisans. Her request for a discount is based on personal budget constraints rather than devaluing the item. Showing genuine admiration for the work and expressing a wish to own it, Jill makes her negotiation easier to consider, as it is honest and direct, notwithstanding plainly financial.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill uses a different tactic: promotion through her social media following. This approach has two sides: on the one hand, it could potentially introduce my work to a larger audience, benefitting my business in the long run. On the other hand, it lacks directness and it doesn't guarantee immediate results or returns, since the impact of her promotion is based on the interest of her followers and their purchasing intent. It also devalues my work in the sense that it trades the worth of my craft for a promotion.\\n\\nGiven these factors, I would likely find the first scenario more appealing for negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 0, score 8\n",
      "1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Reasoning: In both scenarios, Jill demonstrates a deep appreciation for the vase and the level of craftsmanship involved in making it. She also positions herself as a staunch supporter of local artisans, subtly signaling that there may be potential for repeat business and recommendations to other potential buyers. However, scenario 2 is more compelling because of how she adds on that the purchase supports the local community where you are an artisan. Jill brings not just an appreciation of the craftsmanship, but also shows a humanitarian side that appreciates the hard labor of local artisans and wants to support them, making her plea seem a bit more heartfelt and sincere.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning: While both scenarios involve Jill expressing admiration for the vase and a desire to support local artisans, there is a subtle difference in the manner of approach. In Scenario 1, Jill insists on her love for locally made items, commends the artisan's skills, and expresses a need for the vase in her home, but ends her conversation with a soft hint on her constrained budget. She does not directly ask for a lower price, giving the artisan room to offer a discount if they choose. In Scenario 2, Jill more explicitly mentions her budget constraints and directly asks for a reduction in price. While both strategies are valid, the direct request may put the artisan in a spot where they feel obliged to agree, which could compromise their earning and undermine the perceived value of their work.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'In both scenarios, Jill is courteous, recognizes the value of the handcrafted vase, and conveys a genuine interest in supporting local artisans. However, slight differences in the way she frames her request could potentially influence the willingness to negotiate a discount.\\n\\nScenario 1 stands out because Jill opens by articulating her admiration for the craftsmanship and specifically mentions how such items add value to her home. By highlighting the personal value she assigns to such products, she makes the interaction feel more relational than transactional. Her request for a \"small discount,\" while appreciating the artisan\\'s work, could potentially make the artisan more inclined to return the kindness.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 essentially contains the same elements as Scenario 1 but the request is slightly more formal and less personal. Additionally, her request for a \"slight reduction in price\" feels a bit less specific and more open-ended, potentially suggesting a higher discount.\\n\\nGiven these observations:\\n\\nReasoning: The artisan might be more likely to negotiate under Scenario 1 because Jill\\'s communication style is personal and appreciative, and her requested discount appears modest.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 0, score 8\n",
      "1_2, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning: \\n\\nConsidering the two scenarios, both are quite appealing as Jill demonstrates appreciation for the craftsmanship and admiration for the vase; she is also interested in supporting local artisans. \\n\\nHowever, there is a slight twist in the way she presents her case in each scenario. In Scenario 1, Jill not only expresses interest in the vase, but also mentions her intention to support the artisan as a regular customer in the future. In Scenario 2, Jill only requests a discount for the current item due, stating budget constraints. \\n\\nAs an artisan, immediate sales are important, but cultivating relationships with regular customers is more advantageous in the long term due to continuous support and sale predictability, which makes Scenario 1 appear more attractive as a business opportunity. Hence, Jill's statement in Scenario 1 could potentially hold more influence in negotiating a sale price because it offers the prospect of a long-term, beneficial relationship. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning text:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only stating her appreciation for the artisan's work but also expressing her interest in becoming a consistent supporter of the artisan in the future. She talks openly about her financial constraints and respectfully asks if the artisan has any discount structures for returning customers or multiple purchases. This shows Jill's intent to buy not just the vase now, but potentially more items in the future. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, though Jill expresses her love for the vase and the artisan's work, her negotiation is based on a single transaction. She doesn't talk about future purchases or an ongoing relationship with the artisan. \\n\\nBased on these reasons, it would be more beneficial in the long run for the artisan to negotiate in Scenario 1, where there is potential for more sales and a developing business relationship.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her admiration for the artisan's work and is interested in purchasing the vase. However, she is hinting at a discount due to the price being slightly higher than her budget. \\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill not only shows her interest in the vase but also assures the artisan of future business by her mention of being a regular patron. She's proposing a long-term relationship, which would likely be beneficial for the artisan. Giving a discount here could be an investment toward retaining a loyal customer. \\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill also appreciates the work but primarily requests a discount due to budget issues. While Jill might return in the future, she doesn't explicitly state it, making it less certain if she will become a regular customer.\\n\\nWith these points in mind, the artisan would probably be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 due to the added assurance of continued business. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 0, score 8\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill shows a lot of interest in the vase and also suggests she could return to buy more. The real key point here is the fact that she also offers to promote your stall from her social media account which has a few thousand followers. This can potentially generate more sales, so it's beneficial to you on a business level.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill also appreciates your work and she's interested in the vase, but the basis of her request for a discount is just because the price is higher than she anticipated. There is no additional benefit offered to you.\\n\\nGiven these points, I would consider it more worth my while, as an artisan running a business, to offer the discount in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nBoth scenarios have presented potential for negotiation, however, the specific details provided by Jill in each scenario influence the likelihood and level of negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill provides a strategic bargaining tool in promise of repeat business and social media promotion. The prospect of return business boosts the potential for a long-term customer relationship, which could result in future income stability. Besides, the implied advertising to her few thousand social media followers presents a significant opportunity to the artisan to extend his market reach, potentially leading to more customers and more sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the craftwork, showing genuine interest in supporting local artisans, which is a positive quality for customers. However, the reason for request of a discount is specifically mentioned to be because the price is slightly over her budget. This does not provide additional benefits to the artisan as it is limited only to the purchase of this single item.\\n\\nHence, considering the longer term benefit and potential for indirect market expansion via social media exposure, the artisan is more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill demonstrates that she is truly interested in the vase, evidenced by her attention to detail. She also provides a plan for future purchases and shows willingness to commit to returning. This is beneficial for a local artisan running small business, as customer retention is crucial for success. Her proposition of being a brand advocate by sharing on social media suggests a potential boost in marketing without the business incurring advertising costs. An individual with a social media following also has the power to influence purchases, drawing in possible new customers. Although it requires a discount, it's an exchange of benefits and minimal risk. \\n\\nScenario 2 also deserves consideration. Jill commends the craftsmanship involved and expresses her commitment to supporting local artisans. The fact that she mentions the price being slightly over her budget suggests negotiation, but she doesn't offer much of a rationale or incentive for providing a discount, other than her liking for the craft.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1, generation 0, score 8\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Reasoning: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the work and expresses her appreciation for local crafts. However, in Scenario 1, not only does Jill praises the work but also expresses her support towards local artisans and her habit of decorating her home with such pieces. Besides, she also indicates that the price of the vase is slightly beyond her budget. This could imply that while she is interested in the vase, a small discount might ensure she buys the item. As an artisan, it might create a long-term relationship with Jill if she continues to come back and support the local market. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the vase and shows her interest but she looks more into negotiating the price without mentioning why she might be asking for a discount, which can seem more like haggling rather than a genuine concern about the price.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning Text: \\nIn both scenarios, Jill compliments the craftsmanship, expressing her appreciation for the artistry involved and showing genuine interest in acquiring the vase. However, Scenario 1 would potentially prompt a more favorable response because Jill takes a more personal approach. Instead of just asking for a discount, she positions herself as a supporter of local artisans and implies that the vase would find a loving home with her. Jill also mentions that the price is slightly over her budget, which feels more sincere compared to simply asking for a price negotiation in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill emphasizes her appreciation for handmade items and local craftsmanship. However, in Scenario 1, she states explicitly that the price is over her budget, hinting at a potential financial constraint. She also verbally appreciates and acknowledges the artistry that went into creating the vase, supporting local artisans. This might induce some empathy in the seller.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is more vague about why she is asking for a discount. She seems interested in negotiating the price, but she does not provide a specific reason why she needs the discount, other than she's considering the vase. Her request is more exploratory and less concrete compared to Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are quite compelling, but I would be more inclined to negotiate in the first scenario. Here's why:\\n\\nIn the first scenario, Jill not only shows appreciation for the craftsmanship but also offers a means to potentially increase the visibility of my business and attract new clientele. Given the importance of social media marketing, an endorsement from someone with a good number of followers who share a passion for artisan pieces could help me grow.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill suggests the idea of a discount for multiple buys or repeat purchases, but it does not necessarily guarantee an increase in sales as there is nothing concrete about her promises. While it would be great to have Jill as a repeat customer, the benefit to the business is uncertain compared to the first scenario where potential exposure to new customers is in the offing.\\n\\nSo, the first scenario has the potential of both immediate and future gains through sale to Jill and possible visibility to new clients.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios presented by Jill offer attractive selling points, I believe that Scenario 1 provides a better incentive for negotiations. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote my products on her social media channels to a potentially large audience of like-minded individuals. In today's digital age, the power of social media in influencing consumer behavior cannot be underestimated. If her followers do share a passion for artisan products, this bargain could lead to a significant increase in awareness of my brand and ideally an influx of new customers. This could have a long-term beneficial impact on my business far beyond the value of a small discount on a single vase.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 involves a more traditional approach of offering a discount for buying multiple items or promising to return for future purchases. While this, too, is an appealing offer, it lacks the immediate impact and potential reach of a social media promotion. Therefore, while I might be potentially incentivized to offer a discount in both cases, I would lean more towards negotiating in Scenario 1 due to the potentially larger return on investment.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn choosing between the two scenarios, I would lean towards Jill's proposition in scenario 1. There are a number of reasons for this:\\n\\nFirstly, Jill is not only showing an interest in my products, but also acknowledging and complimenting the craftsmanship and quality of my work. This shows she appreciates the value behind my products, which builds a good rapport and understanding.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill has mentioned that she has a large following on social media platforms who also have an interest in local artisan pieces. Offering her this discount could potentially increase the exposure of my work and attract additional customers, which would not only cover the cost of the discount I offer her but also potentially increase my profits. This can be seen as a form of indirect marketing and promotion.\\n\\nFinally, while scenario 2 also offers interest and potential for future purchases, Jill's proposition in scenario 1 offers immediate potential benefits and returns, suggesting it as a better deal for me.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nAssessing the two scenarios, there isn't a massive difference in Jill's approach. However, subtler elements alter the impression Jill gives in each scenario.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill begins by expressing her admiration for the vase and acknowledging the local craftsmanship. She upfrontly discusses her budget issues and proceeds to offer a form of barter trade - a discount in exchange for promoting the artisan's work on her social media. The beneficial point here is that she mentions her significant following, leading to potential benefit to the artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses her admiration for the vase and compliments the craftsmanship. But her approach to negotiating the price is less direct. She merely hints at a desire for a discount without explicitly stating that. Moreover, she suggests sharing photographs on her social media but doesn’t mention anything about a significant number of followers or potential benefit to the artisan.\\n\\nTaking everything into account, I believe Scenario 1 portrays a more advantageous interaction for the artisan. Jill’s direct approach, honest expression about her budget constraints, combined with her offer of potentially beneficial visibility for the artisan makes her case more compelling, thereby increasing her chances of obtaining a discount.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth users are making persuasive arguments for a price reduction. In Scenario 1, Jill explicitly recognizes the effort and talent that has gone into creating the flower vase. She shows appreciation for local craftsmanship and indicates her intent to support it. In addition to asking for a discount, she offers to promote the artisan work on her social media platforms, potentially attracting more customers. She lays down the benefits of her offer quite convincingly.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill also communicates her admiration for the vase and its craftsmanship. She visualizes how the vase will enhance the beauty of her living room, signaling that she values the vase not just as an object, but as an aesthetic addition to her space. However, her promise to tag the store and share photos on social media seems more as an afterthought rather than a well-considered way to compensate for the discount she is asking for.\\n\\nGiven these details, Scenario 1 comes off as a better deal for the artisan. Jill's proposition to promote the work potentially stands to benefit the artisan beyond just this single sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by Jill make a good case for a price negotiation. However, there are subtle differences between the two that sway my decision towards one more than the other. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill takes time to appreciate the craftsmanship of the vase and acknowledges the talent present on the local market, which is heartwarming and displays her understanding of the effort put into my work. Her offer to share my work on her social media platform also presents a potentially valuable opportunity for my business. The fact that she ensures to express gratitude regardless of the outcome also evokes a feeling of good intentions and openness.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the vase and its craftsmanship. However, when she proposes a possible discount, she does not justify her request with any financial constraints. Nonetheless, she suggests spreading the word about my work on her social media, which, again, could be of benefit for my business.\\n\\nTaking into account these aspects, my inclination is towards scenario 1. Jill has taken an in-depth look at and provided appropriate appreciation for the vase, as well as given a reasonable explanation for her request. Additionally, she offered to help promote my business on her social media platform as a show of gratitude, potentially expanding my work's exposure to a wider audience.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as an appreciator of artisan work who sees value in the vase but is hoping for a discount. However, the key deciding factor between these two scenarios is the additional benefit the artisan could secure beyond the sale of the vase. In Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms, which could potentially attract more buyers and increase business in the long run. This kind of promotion can work as free advertising, reaching an audience that the artisan might not have access to. Therefore, the potential long term financial benefit is something to bear in mind.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the compliment from Jill acknowledges the work and craftsmanship that has gone into the vase, but she offers no additional benefit that would compensate for the reduction in price. Her statements only express readiness to negotiate, but she doesn't bring something extra on the table as Scenario 1 does.\\n\\nOn the basis of the above reasoning, I would be more likely to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI'm more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 and this is mainly due to a few reasons. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill is offering me something in return for the discount – publicity on her social media platforms. This can be a great way to reach a wider audience and potentially attract more customers. As an artisan, exposure can be crucial in expanding my customer base.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill flatters my workmanship generously, acknowledging my talent and the uniqueness of the locally made product. She also manifests appreciation for local artisans and the worth of supporting them. Her admiration builds up a rapport and creates a positive line of communication.\\n\\nAlthough this could potentially reduce my revenue initially, Scenario 1 proposes a specific exchange: some loss now, but potentially gain later with the advertisement. However, in Scenario 2, Jill only compliments the vase and asks for a price cut, without offering anything in return. While her interest and compliments are appreciated, they don’t clearly benefit my business outside of this one sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, it appears that Jill is truly interested in the vase in both situations. However, the key elements in both scenarios differ.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill commends the quality of the vase and expresses interest, but only asks for a discount without offering anything in return.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 1 not only has Jill appreciating the craftsmanship, but she also proposes an exchange of sorts. While she asks for a price reduction, she also offers to share the works on her social media profile, which could potentially mean more exposure and therefore, potential clients for me.\\n\\nThough I value my work and the listed price of the vase, the prospect of more visibility and potential customers might lead me to negotiate in this case. Therefore, Scenario 1 seems to present the best case for negotiation to happen.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing admiration for the artisan's work and expressing interest in supporting local artisans which is appreciable. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 1, Jill is offering to promote the artisan's work on her significant social media platform. This could potentially provide the artisan with a larger audience and more customers in the future. There's a great deal of worth in such promotion since increasing visibility can potentially lead to future sales. So, even though Jill is asking for a discount, she's offering something of value in return.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill is mentioning the possibility of future purchases and visits, there isn't necessarily a tangible immediate return value offered for the artisan as in Scenario 1. \\n\\nConsidering the potential for added promotion and possible increased sales in the future, scenario 1 provides a more compelling reason to negotiate the price. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill approaches the situation with interest, admiration, and respect, showcasing her appreciation for the artist's work and indicating an intent to support local artisans. However, the key difference comes in what the customer is offering in exchange for a decreased price.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill is proposing a potential future purchase as a reason for a discount. While this can be seen as an intriguing prospect, it remains speculative and uncertain. She simply intimates she is more likely to be a returning customer rather than promising to make another purchase.\\n\\nBy contrast, in scenario 1, Jill proposes a more concrete and immediate exchange. She is offering an opportunity for increased publicity for the artisan's work by sharing it on her social media platforms, where she claims to have a large following. This is potentially more valuable for the artisan because it could reach more potential customers and raises brand awareness, which might ultimately result in more sales than just one customer returning in the future.\\n\\nTherefore, from a business perspective, the artisan would likely be more willing to negotiate price in scenario 1 due to the immediate and potentially wider-reaching benefits offered by the customer's proposal.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nJill's approach in both scenarios is commendable as she not only admires your work but also expresses her genuine interest in supporting local artisans. However, in terms of negotiation, Scenario 1 would be a more enticing proposition from a business perspective for a couple of reasons:\\n\\nFirstly, in Scenario 1, Jill is proposing a form of barter trade; she's offering promotion on her social media platforms in exchange for a discount. If Jill indeed has a large following, this could act as free advertisement for your business reaching potentially thousands of people, which normally could cost a significant sum.\\n\\nSecondly, Scenario 1 promises immediate returns in the form of increased visibility. While having a returning paying customer as offered in Scenario 2 would be valuable, it is more of a long-term, less certain benefit compared to the immediate exposure from a social media post.\\n\\nMoreover, while a discount would reduce the immediate profit from one transaction, the potential increase in future sales resulting from this exposure can lead to greater overall profitability. Plus, there's a chance Jill will promote your work in the future again without expecting a discount each time, since she genuinely appreciates your work.\\n\\nSo, considering all factors mentioned, I'd be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: While both scenarios involve Jill using similar tactics of negotiation (i.e., offering to promote the artisan's work on social media in exchange for a discount), the first scenario feels more personal and persuasive. She appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase in each scenario, but in the first, she expressly mentions her support for local artisans and her desire to own genuinely unique art pieces. This suggests a deeper connection with the work and shows that she understands and values the time and effort that goes into each piece. In addition, Jill seems more sincere about promoting the vase and the artisan's brand on social media in Scenario 1, presenting it as a credible form of payment rather than just an additional favor. Her approach might resonate more with the artisan, increasing the likelihood of earning a discount.\\n\\nAdditionally, in Scenario 1, Jill's proposal comes across as a potential business partnership, which might be an attractive prospect for an artisan trying to reach a larger audience. This could lend more weight to her argument and appeal to the artisan's business interests.\\n\\nIn contrast, in Scenario 2, the request for a price reduction seems more akin to a standard customer bargaining tactic. Although she offers to promote the artisan's work on social media, it reads more like an afterthought rather than a genuine offer of partnership. The line 'Maybe there's some room for slight reduction?' comes across less persuasive than the more assertive negotiation/suggestion of a deal in Scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios demonstrate the customer's appreciation for the artisan's work and their intention to endorse it on their social media platforms, I would lean more towards negotiating a discount in Scenario 1. \\n\\nThe customer, Jill, in the first scenario, takes the time to commend the artisan's work, express her keenness in supporting local artisans, and shows an earnest desire to own the vase. Further, she leverages her social media following, implying the potential for a greater outreach for the artisan's work, which could lead to more sales. It builds a picture of a mutually beneficial arrangement, which may persuade the artisan to negotiate the price.\\n\\nIn contrast, Jill in Scenario 2 expresses her admiration for the artwork, but her emphasis is more on the potential placement of the vase in her living room and less about the potential social media promotion. Thus, the potential benefits for the artisan aren't as evident.\\n\\nHowever, the decision to negotiate would also greatly depend on how crucial the extra sales might be to the artisan, or if they are more concerned with maintaining the perceived value of their artwork by refraining from discounts. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill makes appealing offers, proposing to publicize one's craftsmanship on her social media platforms – an influential tool that can attract more customers and boost potential sales. However, the approach differs in each.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill acknowledges your craftsmanship and emphasizes how much she values local artisans. This respect for your work is always good to hear as an artisan. Then she proceeded to propose a deal that could also benefit you indirectly. Her suggestion makes economic sense, as this could potentially lead to more customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is more straightforward. She compliments the vase, visualizes her use of it, and then asks directly for a price negotiation. Offering to tag the store on social media, she directly offers the possibility of promotion which might help in gaining more visibility.\\n\\nAlthough both approaches are constructive, I would favor Scenario 1 as Jill communicates her appreciation more thoroughly. She not only admires the product, but it seems she understands your efforts as an artisan, which makes her proposal feel more sincere. The stress on supporting local artisans indicates that she possesses some sense of community, making her more reliable. Offering to leverage her sizable social media followers gives an indication she's confident about her influence and this provides some reassurance about her offer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_3, generation 2, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\n\\nAlthough both offers from Jill are similar in that she is proposing a negotiation, the circumstances are different. In scenario 2, Jill simply appreciates the work and asks for a discount without any exchange of value. On the other hand, in scenario 1, Jill is offering something in return - the promotion of my work on her large social media platforms. Therefore, taking into consideration her proposition would mean the potential of my brand reaching a broader audience, thereby increasing visibility and potentially driving more business to me in the long run. As an artisan at a local market, this kind of exposure can be invaluable and could outweigh the slight discount provided to Jill.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom an artisan's perspective, both scenarios as proposed by Jill are compelling in their own ways. In Scenario 1, Jill offers a form of promotion in exchange for a discount on the vase. If she indeed has a large following on her social media platforms and posts regularly about her purchases and experiences, this could serve as valuable advertisement for the artisan's work and possibly bring in more customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses her admiration for the craftsmanship of the vase and the work that's gone into creating it. She acknowledges the value of the item while still proposing a discount. This shows respect for the artisan's craft and suggests that she would value the item and might even become a repeat customer in the future.\\n\\nHowever, it can be harder to quantify the value of potential exposure through a social media post as offered in Scenario 1, and there's no guarantee that it would lead to increased sales. On the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill presents a direct and straightforward request for a discount that acknowledges the value of the artisan's work. This gives a sense of respect and sincerity, which is very important in such negotiation situations.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios emphasize appreciation for the craft, which is a good starting point. However, there are a few distinct differences between the two approaches.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only shows interest in the vase but also provides a solution that could potentially benefit both parties. By offering to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms, she's suggesting a form of barter that may widen the artisan’s customer base in return for a discount. Considering the importance of social media in promoting businesses today, this can be a valuable offer besides mere appreciation on her part for the handcrafted item. \\n\\nScenario 2 also shows appreciation from Jill for the fine craftsmanship but just asks for a discount without giving a reasoning or offering a potential return value for the artisan. It is a straightforward, but less persuasive, negotiation tactic.\\n\\nTherefore, given the potential benefits outlined, an artisan might be more likely to negotiate based on the conditions set in scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[Reasoning Text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches the artisan respectfully, complimenting the craftsmanship of the vase and expressing her approval of local artisans. There is no obligation to reduce the price for her, but it is good for customer relations to show flexibility where feasible.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only demonstrates a love for the handcrafted item but also hints at potentially buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. By suggesting the notion of discounts for multiple purchases, she makes it known that she is interested in more than just one item, therefore promising a greater income even with a discount applied. Her clear intention of becoming a repeat customer is also beneficial since repeat customers are valuable assets to artisans and small business owners.\\n\\nScenario 2 also presents a respectful, interested customer – but lacks the potential for larger purchase or repeat business. While Jill voices her admiration for the local artisan handcrafted vase, she mainly pleads for a price reduction due to her budget. While there's nothing wrong with negotiating based on budget constraints, her argument does not have the same business appeal as in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses admiration for the vase and acknowledges the value of supporting local artisans. However, the key difference lies in future sale potential. In Scenario 1, Jill mentions not only the prospect of buying multiple items on the spot but also makes a clear intention of returning to shop at our booth again in the future. This hints at a sustained business relationship which is indeed beneficial in the long run. Even if we give her a slight discount now, the overall profit from her repeat business could, in theory, be more than the immediate sale. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill only asks for a discount for one item, expressing budget constraints, and does not express any clear intention of being a repeat customer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer who appreciates the quality of the vase and supports local artisans. However, Jill’s approach in Scenario 1 may be more effective in encouraging a negotiation. She not only admires the work, but also sees herself as a returning customer, which could potentially mean more future sales. Additionally, she proposes a discount on the condition of buying multiple items, outlining another potential for an immediate increase in sales. \\n\\nWhile Scenario 2 presents a similar appreciation for the work, it mainly focuses on the customer's budget constraint. There's no indication of future purchases or buying multiple items. Although this isn't to say that a discount wouldn't be given in Scenario 2, Scenario 1 provides more incentive for the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios are compelling arguments from Jill, scenario 1 is more conducive to negotiation. Jill’s offer to promote the store on social media could potentially increase traffic and, subsequently, sales. This is valuable especially for local artisans, who may not have as much exposure as larger retailers. Additionally, strong customer reviews and word-of-mouth referrals could result in other customers who are more than willing to purchase items at full price. Scenario 2, while understandable, only benefits Jill and does not offer any compensatory benefits to the artisan. Although helping community members is certainly a noble cause, for an artisan to maintain business, it's usually necessary to approach each transaction with an eye for profit or potential growth opportunities. In this regard, scenario 1 offers more.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text: \\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only showing admiration for the vase and the work put into it but also offering to give something in return in the form of social media promotion, which could potentially bring in more customers and increase sales in the long run. This is an attractive proposition for a small business or craftsman who relies on word of mouth and social media to promote their goods, as it's essentially free advertising. \\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 just highlights Jill's budget constraints and provides only her goodwill as a contribution in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere are several factors that make the scenarios distinct, leading to potentially different decisions - \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill highlights not only her interest in the vase but also her willingness to help promote your business on social media. This kind of organic promotion through customer reviews and sharing can be very beneficial for small local businesses. This provides a type of value exchange beyond the direct purchase of the vase itself.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill emphasizes her admiration for the work and desire to support local artisans, yet mentions she's on a budget. This appeals on an emotional level and gives a contextual understanding of her financial situation.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios contain legitimate reasons for negotiation, the added value of potential online promotion in Scenario 1 sways the decision into its favor. Therefore, I would personally be more inclined to negotiate the price in Scenario 1, aiming for a beneficial arrangement both in terms of an immediate sale, and potential future business steered by Jill's social media exposure.  \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the work put into the vase and shows interest in buying it, and she directly asks for a negotiation or discount. Here, the customer recognizes the value and effort put into the product, and this acknowledgment can influence a seller to think about a possible concession in price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also acknowledges the quality and beauty of the vase, and the fact that she's a supporter of local artisans. However, she mentions she's on a budget, which suggests her ability to spend may be limited. While she is asking for a reduction, she doesn't mention a willingness to negotiate (potentially offering something in exchange for a price reduction like buying multiple items or future purchases) like in scenario 1. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nBeing an artisan, I understand and appreciate that my customers respect and value my work. In scenario 1, Jill is not only acknowledging the effort I have put into the work but also showing a willingness to negotiate, which directly communicates an intention to find a mutually agreeable solution to buy the vase. This approach is more favourable to me as a seller than just asking for a price reduction because of a buyer's limited budget, as in scenario 2. Therefore, I might be more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in scenario 1.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses admiration for the work and indicates interest in buying. However, the scenarios differ in the reasons Jill gives for asking for a discount. In Scenario 1, she simply asks for a reduction without specifying any particular reason. In Scenario 2, she mentions being a supporter of local artisans and being on a budget, which appeals to the artisan's sense of community and understanding. Also, this could imply that she is a returning customer or a potential consistent customer, which could be more beneficial to the artisan in the long term. So, this puts Scenario 2 in a stronger position.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios presented by the customer are compelling and make a fair case for a negotiation. However, my decision would lean slightly towards Scenario 2. Here's why:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship but her primary approach to negotiation is an ask for a discount. She does not specify why she needs it, leaving more room for the artisan to decline as the need is not clear.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, however, Jill not only appreciates the craftsmanship but also expresses her support for local artisans and the community. Along with that, she shares her personal context about being on a budget. This provides a more empathetic reason for a potential markdown, making it more compelling from a seller's perspective. In this scenario, her request for negotiation seems as less about just wanting a bargain and more about her real need to manage her financial situation without compromising her support for local art. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0.5, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Both scenarios almost communicate the same thing as both state the customer\\'s interest in the item, their willingness to support local crafts, their intent to purchase more in the future, and their concern about the price. They indicate that Jill is likely to come back and buy more products. Both are sound and respectful negotiation tactics where the customer is not merely haggling, but proposing further business prospects.\\n\\nHowever, I would lean a bit towards Scenario 1 for the following reasons:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the artisan work directly, calling it \"remarkable,\" and showing a deeper appreciation and recognition for the work, which builds a cordial and receptive atmosphere for negotiation. Moreover, Jill\\'s commitment to supporting local artisans feels more genuine and sincere here, which might motivate the artisan to take a bit off the price to maintain good business relations with a potential regular customer.\\n\\nFurther, the tone used by Jill in Scenario 1 feels more casual and personal, suggesting a longer-term and more thorough engagement with the artisan\\'s work, which might tip the artisan to negotiate the price as a gesture of good faith and building a good customer relationship. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill offers a compelling argument for obtaining a discount. She expresses clear interest in the vase and the potential for further purchases in the future. However, the selection between Scenario 1 and 2 would largely depend on the artisan's perspectives towards sales and customer relationships.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill uses a more personal approach. She compliments the artisan's work, shows understanding and appreciates the value of handmade items. She also mentions supporting local artisans which could resonate on an emotional level with the artisan. The artisan may feel more valued and genuinely appreciated for their hard work and efforts in this case.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill takes a more transactional approach. While she still compliments the artisan's work, it feels more like a business negotiation than a personal connection. Her tone is more of a regular shopper aiming at getting a deal.\\n\\nIn conclusion, if the artisan values personal connections and encouraging supportive customers, he or she might be more inclined to offer a discount in Scenario 1. However, if the artisan views the interaction as a conventional business transaction and values negotiation techniques, he or she might prefer Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: It's subjective and would depend on the artisan's perspective.\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a customer who is considerate and thoughtful about her purchases, as well as responsible and cautious with money. Despite there being a slight price objection, Jill is expressing it in a respectful and polite manner, and she is not pressing for a discount straightforwardly. She supplicates for a potential future favorable arrangement, which implies her interest to make regular purchases and support my work as a local artisan. This can indeed be beneficial for a business like mine.\\n\\nHowever, the risk of future promises isn't always secure. It's possible she might not stick around as a regular customer, and even if she does, it might not compensate for the initial discounted purchase. Therefore, I'd have to be careful about reducing the price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill directly acknowledges the craftsmanship of my work and the importance of supporting local artisans, specifically stating her intent to be a regular customer and support my craft. This admiration for the artisan's work and encouragement of local support seems earnest and may be even more encouraging for the artisan (me in this case) to negotiate on the vase's price.\\n\\nIn contrast, Scenario 2 also presents Jill as a prospective loyal customer, but she uses the term 'unique pieces' to describe the vase and doesn't acknowledge the craftsmanship or the work that goes into these as much as Jill in Scenario 1 does. This could potentially mean she's just interested in the aesthetic rather than the underlying craftsmanship that makes each piece special.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nIn conclusion, I'd possibly give more consideration to negotiating the price or offering a discount in Scenario 1. A customer's recognition and understanding of my hard work, paired with the intention of long-term support, would make me lean towards Scenario 1.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "1_2, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios paint different pictures. In the first, Jill offers potential advertising value while admiring the quality of the vase, which could lead to increased visibility and potentially further sales, an added advantage. In the second scenario, Jill shows a keen interest in your craft and the potential for future purchases. While both are compelling, they inspire different reactions. \\n\\nHowever, as a local artisan, the power of word of mouth and personal recommendations can be quite significant. Therefore, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1. Jill offering to share the vase on her social media and tag the store could introduce the concept of a 'social currency' here. This would expose my work to a new, potentially vast audience, including friends, family and followers of Jill who might be interested in handcrafted items. It's worth bearing in mind that often, people who follow or are friends with someone are likely to share similar interests, thus the potential for any of these people to become future customers is a valuable prospect to consider. \\n\\nIn the short term, I might be making less profit on the vase by reducing its price, but in the long term, the additional exposure could potentially bring in more customers and boost my sales, providing more benefit than the potential of a repeat customer in Scenario 2. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere are a few factors that come into play while determining the best scenario for negotiation. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, a discount is being requested by Jill, but she offers something in return: free advertisement on social media. This could potentially lead to more customers and increased sales in the future. The bench-marking basis here is largely goodwill related, hence there's a bigger risk of the discount not being fully offset by increased future sales. However, the positive here is that we get immediate advertisement and potential indirect referrals. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill mentions that she plans on returning and not only buying this vase but also perhaps other items. While Jill herself does not guarantee any advertisement as in Scenario 1, the potential of selling more products to a repeat customer could be enough to justify a slight discount. Here, though, we have to trust that Jill will indeed return and make further purchases. The positive in this scenario is direct future business and the potential for a loyal customer.\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their advantages, but value can be subjective. Depending on which advantage is more important to you as an artisan, you might choose different scenarios. However, from an objective stance considering risk versus reward, it might make more sense to go with Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present appealing proposals that could potentially influence my decision to negotiate the price of the vase. However, the perspective scenarios offer different outcomes for myself as an artisan. \\n\\nScenario 1: Jill's suggestion of sharing photos of my work on her social media could provide exposure for my craft that might reach new customers. This word-of-mouth marketing can be very valuable, especially if she has a significant follower base. \\n\\nScenario 2: Jill is indicating a plan to become a repeat customer. This gives me a chance of regular income from her in the future. Her question about discounts for returning customers or multiple purchases suggests that she might buy more items right now or in subsequent visits. \\n\\nConsidering these factors, it could be more beneficial to negotiate a deal with a potential repeat customer who may also buy more items, due to the fact that steady revenue is more valuable for my business in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_2, generation 0, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present effective ways that Jill is trying to negotiate the price, however, Jill's approach in Scenario 1 stands out more favorably. Here are some reasons:\\n\\n1) Persuasion: In Scenario 1, Jill begins by complimenting the craftsmanship, and mentioning she believes in supporting local artisans. This forms an emotional connection that appeals to the values of the artisan. \\n\\n2) Future patronage: Jill also mentions the idea of becoming a regular customer and purchasing multiple items. This implies that there could be much more profit in the future from this customer compared to a one-time purchase. This long-term view can be more beneficial for the business.\\n\\n3) Budget consideration: Mentioning that the current price is more than she had budgeted signals a willingness to buy if the price is right. It makes it clear she values the vase enough to consider stretching her budget, but also gives a sense that the artisan might lose the sale if he doesn't compromise a bit.\\n\\n4) Win-Win situation: Offering a discount to a returning customer is a common strategy to retain customers. This could benefit both parties as Jill gets her discount and the artisan retains a potentially loyal customer.\\n\\nSo, considering the above reasoning, the artisan is more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI would be more likely to negotiate price in Scenario 1 for several reasons.\\n\\nFirstly, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and emphasizes her belief in supporting local artisans, showing respect for our work. This not only reflects a positive attitude towards locally crafted products but also a conscious decision to sustain the local artisan community. \\n\\nSecondly, Jill also shows her interest to become a regular patron and has the intention of buying multiple items over time. This promises potential future business. A small initial discount may thus be seen as an investment towards building a strong customer relationship, which may yield higher returns in the long run. \\n\\nThirdly, Jill states clearly her concern about the budget yet shows high interest towards our products and a willingness to become a repeat customer. That delicately conveys the idea that she is serious about negotiating the price down for a reasonable purpose, rather than just trying to game some extra advantage or haggle down the price for the sake of it.\\n\\nLastly, Jill poses her query in a manner that still leaves it open for us to offer other forms of discounts. These could be in the form of discounts on multiple purchases or for returning customers, which can be implemented effectively without affecting the inherent value of individual products.\\n\\nOn the other hand, the request in Scenario 2 is more straightforward and focuses solely on a one-time purchase. Jill doesn't mention any future potential deals or make a commitment of becoming a regular customer. This restricts the room for negotiation or agreement to a mutually beneficial outcome.\\n\\nGiven all these reasons, Scenario 1 would make more sense to me for price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile in both scenarios Jill has expressed her admiration for the craftsmanship of the vase, the key differences lie in her proposed future involvement. In Scenario 1, Jill not only commends the artisan's work, but also establishes that she is interested in becoming a loyal, repeat customer. She acknowledges the price with respect for the artisan's work and proposes potential ways of giving patronage without stretching her budget. She suggests purchasing multiple items in the future and expresses her interest in receiving discounts for returning customers.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also shows admiration for the craftsmanship. However, she only mentions the possibility of this one-time purchase and asks for a price reduction without suggesting any significant future involvement or long-term buying commitment.\\n\\nConsidering these aspects, an artisan who is aiming to build a regular customer base might prefer the first scenario. It hints at a more substantial advantage in the long run, which includes several future purchases and word-of-mouth promotion which may be beneficial for the artisan's business. This strategic foresight could lead the artisan to consider a price negotiation, building good rapport with a likely return customer who will potentially make more purchases in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, Jill comes across as passionate about the vase and willing to support local artisans. However, there is a distinct difference in terms of the benefits these scenarios can offer me as an artisan.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers the possibility of returning to the market and shopping from my stall again. This is good, as repeat customers are valuable, but it's a promise of future potential benefit with no concrete incentive upfront.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 1, Jill not only shows interest in buying multiple items and returning to shop again but also offers to promote my work on social media. This could potentially lead to more visibility and sales, since she claims to have thousands of followers.\\n\\nTherefore, in my opinion, the social media exposure in Scenario 1 provides more immediate and potentially significant benefits than the promises of possible future purchases in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses clear admiration for the flower vase and indicates an intention to return and make future purchases. However, the scenarios also contain distinct elements that can weigh into the decision.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill takes an additional step that could be considerably beneficial to the business. By offering to leverage her own following on social media to promote the artisan's work, Jill is suggesting an informal partnership that could attract more customers to the stall in the future. Additionally, she also hints at a social media following that potentially consists of a few thousand more individuals who could become aware of and be drawn to the artisan's work. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill expresses an intention to support local artisans and makes it clear she likes unique items, implying she may appreciate handcrafted items more than the average market-goer. However, she doesn't provide any additional value proposition like Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nConsidering these points, I would lean towards Scenario 1. While both scenarios suggest Jill might become a repeat customer, her offer to promote the artisan's work to her social media following in Scenario 1 could bring more benefits to the business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios show a customer who is intending to make a purchase, which is always a good start. However, the two scenarios heavily differ in their negotiating tactics.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill tries to leverage her social media presence and promises to provide free marketing. The potential exposure, depending on the nature of her followers, could lead to more sales in the future and is something not easily measurable in terms of immediate monetary value.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appeals to the fact that she is a local supporter and states that she might become a repeat customer. This promise though sounds good, lacks enforceability. There's no guarantee she will come back, and future sales could be uncertain.\\n\\nAs an artisan at a local market, one would ideally want to try and broaden their customer base. A single returning customer is an excellent asset, but exposure to a broader audience could potentially draw in several repeat customers.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning: While both scenarios presented by Jill are similar in nature, there are some subtle differences that might influence the decision. In Scenario 1, Jill highlights her intentions of becoming a returning customer and hints she might purchase multiple items. This being an investment in future sales, Jill's situation might be appealing. The offering of promoting the artisan's products on her social media adds to the attraction as this could potentially bring more customers. \\nIn Scenario 2, Jill focuses more on the admiration for the vase itself and the artisan's craftsmanship. Her offer of a price reduction is paired with a promise of social media promotion, similar to Scenario 1, yet without implying future purchases. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1 \\n\\nThe aspect of potentially more future sales from Jill herself and her followers on social media makes Scenario 1 more favorable for negotiation. It is especially preferable for a small, local business to gain loyal customers and possibly reach a larger audience through social media promotion.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill seems truly interested in the round flower vase and provides compelling reasons for asking for a discount, demonstrating her appreciation for the craftsmanship and suggesting she will promote the item and my stall on her social media.\\n\\nHowever, I am slightly more inclined towards Scenario 1. In Scenario 1, Jill communicates her intentions for future purchases and regularly returning to the market, implying she could end up a loyal customer, creating potential for long-term profit. She also proposes a form of partnership, offering promotion on her social media. Given that she has a few thousand followers, this could provide considerable exposure and lead to increased market visibility and potentially more sales.\\n\\nAlthough Jill also offers social media exposure in Scenario 2, she does not mention returning to the market, meaning there is no promise of future purchases. Furthermore, in Scenario 2 she only talks about a reduction of price without proposing a direct benefit to me as the vendor.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1, as it appears to offer more potential for future benefits and sales.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', 'Reasoning:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill communicates more incentives for me as the seller to consider a discount. In addition to expressing her interest in the vase, she offers to multiply her purchases, implies the likelihood of future purchases as a returning customer, and promises promotional activity on social media.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, while she expresses a strong interest in the vase as well, Jill only offers the possibility of a social media promotional assistance, making her incentives less attractive than in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFirstly, negotiation is essential in business, and as a local artisan, I may be more inclined to negotiate price based on certain advantageous factors or incentives. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill provides multiple potential benefits for giving her a discount. She mentions the possibility of being a returning customer, which means more potential sales in the future. She also offers to promote my work on her social media in exchange for a discount. This endorsement could help me reach a bigger audience and ultimately increase my customer base. Both of these factors make offer from Jill in Scenario 1 a profitable trade-off for a reduced price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses interest in buying it, she doesn't offer any specific reasons or incentives for a discount beyond simply asking if it's possible. Her negotiation does not extend beyond the immediate sale, which, while certainly not negative, doesn't bring the same potential long-term benefits as Jill's proposal in Scenario 1.\\n\\nHence, considering these points, negotiation would be more beneficial for me in Scenario 1 as it potentially gives me subsequent sales and a wider market reach.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"The likelihood of offering a negotiation strongly depends on the individual seller's perspective. However, in terms of potential benefits to the business, I would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1.\\n\\nReasoning:\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering several compelling reasons for a potential discount. Firstly, she expresses an intention to become a repeat customer which could mean consistent business in the future. Secondly, she shows interest in buying multiple items at once which often warrants a small reduction in price. Lastly, she offers to endorse the products on social media. As someone with a few thousand followers, this could provide some valuable marketing exposure, resulting in increased sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill does compliment the craftsmanship and indicates interest in purchasing the vase, she doesn't offer any extra incentive that would directly benefit your business in terms of future sales or marketing exposure.\\n\\nHowever, taking the negotiation decision should not only base on this single interaction, as Scenario 2 might lead to a stronger bond of trust with the customer, leading to potential word-of-mouth advertising and possibly returning business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nFrom a business standpoint, both scenarios provide incentives to consider a negotiation. However, they present different opportunities, and the best scenario depends on what I, as an artisan, value more. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows interest in being a repeat customer and speaks about the possibility of promoting my work on her social media. This could potentially provide some free marketing and bring in new customers. Continual business and broad exposure to a new customer base can be very beneficial, especially if Jill's followers are within my target demographic. The discount could be seen as a marketing cost.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the craftsmanship but doesn't necessarily offer any additional value, like the promise of repeat business or exposure in Scenario 1. Nonetheless, her appreciation for the product is genuine, and as an artisan, I may feel satisfied knowing my work is being valued. \\n\\nThe decision depends on crafting satisfaction vs. potential business growth. \\n\\nAnswer: Essentially, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 1 due to the potential long term benefits for my business.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning Text: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is presenting good reasons for a negotiation. However, the tactics used in each scenario are slightly different. In scenario 1, Jill is proposing the possibility of becoming a return customer who buys multiple items, which could turn into more sales in the future and making her a valuable customer. On the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill is suggesting negotiating the price while offering some sort of social media promotion which could potentially bring more customers. \\n\\nThis said, there are a few reasons why I would most likely consider scenario 1. Firstly, although social media promotion is attractive, it's hard to measure its actual impact and whether it will indeed result in more sales. Moreover, since it is a one-time act, it may not provide consistent benefit over time. Secondly, the guarantee of a customer coming back and buying more is much more promising. This indicates the probably ongoing relationship with a customer who appreciates the craftsmanship. This customer can bring more business in the future guaranteeing continual revenue. This continual income can provide a stable financial flow, whereas there is no such guarantee with a social media promotion. Lastly, according to ‘Costumer Lifetime Value’ concept, which is a prediction of the net profit attributed to the entire future relationship with a customer, the customer from scenario 1 seems more valuable.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nAnalyzing both scenarios, both customers show a significant interest in the vase, appreciate its craftsmanship, and express potential additional benefits to the artisan. In scenario 1, Jill suggests she could become a repeat customer and potentially buy multiple items in one day, which can enhance the customer lifetime value. In scenario 2, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work on social media, which could potentially attract new customers.\\n\\nWhile both scenarios have their own benefits, I would be more inclined to negotiate in scenario 1. Repeat customers are a valuable asset to any business. If Jill buys multiple items regularly, not only the vase sales, but overall sales could raise over time. Moreover, a loyal customer can spread word-of-mouth referrals, bolstering even more the potential customer base.\\n\\nOn the other hand, the influence of scenario 2's Jill isn't quantifiable. The promise of social media promotion is intriguing, but we do not know Jill's reach, or whether her followers are within the target market. Therefore, the potential impact is uncertain.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present strong cases for a price negotiation, however, they differ in certain aspects and incentives.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill highlights her intent to support local artisans as well as her interest in potentially purchasing multiple items and becoming a returning customer. This hints at future purchases, providing a long-term incentive for a slight discount now.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and offers to promote the store on her social media platforms. This offers only a short-term benefit of potentially attracting other customers if Jill has a large, interested following. However, the potential advantage here is less certain as there are no guarantees of her posts having the desired effect.\\n\\nConsidering these aspects, the prospect of future, repeat business from Scenario 1 would likely be more appealing to the artisan considering the sustainability of the business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_2, generation 2, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['Reasoning:\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill praised your craftsmanship and expressed her interest in supporting local artisans. Moreover, she not only showed interest in purchasing the round flower vase but also hinted at buying other items and possibly returning to the market in the future. By potentially buying more items or becoming a loyal customer, she increases her value to you as a seller. As a businessperson, it would make sense to encourage repeat business and larger volume sales by offering a slight discount.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill acknowledges the work that has gone into creating the vase but merely asks for a discount without offering any additional incentives. Therefore, this customer seems less valuable to you, unless they demonstrate a willingness to buy more goods or become a repeat customer in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill is expressing her desire and interest in purchasing the flower vase but also hinting on a possible negotiation for the price. The difference between the two situations is the potential long term value the customer can bring.\\n\\nScenario 1 paints a picture of not only an appreciative customer who might ultimately buy the vase today, but also a repeat customer who can provide future income. She might also bring friends, family, or others who see her purchased vase to my store. She's implicitly providing a verbal commitment to come back for more purchases. It's essential for any business, including artisans, to encourage and facilitate repeat customers as they bring much consistent value long term.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 talks about a one-time customer who merely appreciates the work and is looking for a price cut. While this customer is likely to purchase, there is no express indicator that she will return or has plans to buy more in the future.\\n\\nTherefore, I would be more likely to negotiate the price with Jill in the first scenario due to the anticipated future income she could provide in comparison to the second scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is not only interested in purchasing the vase, but she also expresses interest in buying additional items and shows a future intent to keep coming back and make more purchases. This suggests a potential for increased patronage and sales, which is advantageous for my business in the long run. She is also appreciative of the work of local artisans, showing respect and understanding for the craft. This could build a stronger relationship with the customer.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill appreciates the craftsmanship and shows interest in purchasing the vase, her request for a discount seems more due to personal budget constraints rather than an intent to contribute more to my business in return for the price reduction.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 65 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "0_3, generation 1, score 5\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios presented by Jill indicate her interest in the vase, they suggest different ways of negotiation. In Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the work on the vase and also offers to promote the artisan's store on her social media. This approach might be more enticing because it promises potential exposure and future sales, which is beneficial for any business. It is a mutually beneficial proposition and can create a stronger bond between the artisan and the customer.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill does compliment the craftsmanship and expresses her interest but doesn't suggest any alternative way to make up for the proposed discount. It's a simple negotiation based only on immediate self-interest. While there's nothing inherently wrong with this scenario, it might not be as beneficial to the artisan compared to the former.\\n\\nWith these considerations, I would opt for the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and even visualizes its placement in her home indicating a strong interest and attachment. Moreover, she proposes a barter arrangement where she is willing to advertise your store on her social media. Considering today's digital age, this kind of promotion could potentially bring more clientele to your local market stall. That's invaluable, especially if Jill has a considerable following.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also appreciates the vase but her language is a bit more reserved and unsure. She doesn't offer the same level of enthusiasm as in scenario 1 or offer any additional incentives to lower the price.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the potential gain from a non-cash benefit (free advertisement) and Jill's strong interest and appreciation in Scenario 1, I am more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in this scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses her interest in buying it. However, the difference lies in how she is proposing the negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only asks for a price reduction but also adds value to her request by offering to share pictures and tag the store on her social media. This could potentially increase the visibility of my work and potentially bring in more customers, which is a great benefit. This is a form of bartering, where both parties could win - Jill gets a discounted price while I get free publicity potentially leading to increased sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill appreciates the work and expresses interest but only requests a discount. While her genuine interest is appreciated, this scenario lacks the added value presented in scenario 1.\\n\\nMy reasoning leads me to the conclusion that scenario 1 presents a better negotiation situation for me, as the artisan.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 82 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 5\n",
      "0_2, generation 1, score 10\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning Text:\\n\\nIn both scenarios, the customer Jill has expressed admiration for the craftwork and has shown interest in returning to purchase more crafts in the future. In each case, she politely inquires about price negotiation and potential discounts, possibly for multiple purchases or for repeat business. This indicates that she values the work, which is positive. Both inquiries would typically lead to a price negotiation depending on the seller's policy. \\n\\nHowever, in scenario 1, Jill pushed a little bit further in her negotiation plea. She mentioned the possibility of buying multiple items, which may benefit the seller in terms of sales volume. This proposition would usually incentivize a seller to consider a discount, making this scenario slightly more compelling for price negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses appreciation for the artisan's work. However, Scenario 1 reads as more sincere and builds a foundation for long-term customer loyalty. Jill expresses interest in making multiple purchases and becoming a returning customer. These words give impression that Jill values the artisan's work and is not only interested in getting a discount, but also in supporting the artisan's craft in the long run. This mutual respect is likely to open the artisan to the idea of giving a discount. In Scenario 2, although Jill also mentions supporting the artisan's work in future, it is less specific than in Scenario 1. The lack of interest in buying multiple items also makes Scenario 2 less compelling.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning: In scenario 1, Jill interprets the craftsmanship and gives praise to the artisan, indicating that she understands and appreciates the value of handcrafted work. She also engages in respectful negotiation, asking delicately about the possibility of a lower price or multiple purchase discounts. Plus, she intends on being a repeat customer, showing loyalty to your craftsmanship that might be rewarded with a small discount. In comparison, Scenario 2 is similar, but lacks the same level of appreciation and promise of repeat business. While she admires the craft, the language used is less engaging.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as an appreciator of artisan work who sees value in the vase but is hoping for a discount. However, the key deciding factor between these two scenarios is the additional benefit the artisan could secure beyond the sale of the vase. In Scenario 1, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work on her social media platforms, which could potentially attract more buyers and increase business in the long run. This kind of promotion can work as free advertising, reaching an audience that the artisan might not have access to. Therefore, the potential long term financial benefit is something to bear in mind.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, the compliment from Jill acknowledges the work and craftsmanship that has gone into the vase, but she offers no additional benefit that would compensate for the reduction in price. Her statements only express readiness to negotiate, but she doesn't bring something extra on the table as Scenario 1 does.\\n\\nOn the basis of the above reasoning, I would be more likely to negotiate with Jill in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nI'm more likely to negotiate the price in Scenario 1 and this is mainly due to a few reasons. \\n\\nFirstly, Jill is offering me something in return for the discount – publicity on her social media platforms. This can be a great way to reach a wider audience and potentially attract more customers. As an artisan, exposure can be crucial in expanding my customer base.\\n\\nSecondly, Jill flatters my workmanship generously, acknowledging my talent and the uniqueness of the locally made product. She also manifests appreciation for local artisans and the worth of supporting them. Her admiration builds up a rapport and creates a positive line of communication.\\n\\nAlthough this could potentially reduce my revenue initially, Scenario 1 proposes a specific exchange: some loss now, but potentially gain later with the advertisement. However, in Scenario 2, Jill only compliments the vase and asks for a price cut, without offering anything in return. While her interest and compliments are appreciated, they don’t clearly benefit my business outside of this one sale.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nLooking at both scenarios, it appears that Jill is truly interested in the vase in both situations. However, the key elements in both scenarios differ.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill commends the quality of the vase and expresses interest, but only asks for a discount without offering anything in return.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 1 not only has Jill appreciating the craftsmanship, but she also proposes an exchange of sorts. While she asks for a price reduction, she also offers to share the works on her social media profile, which could potentially mean more exposure and therefore, potential clients for me.\\n\\nThough I value my work and the listed price of the vase, the prospect of more visibility and potential customers might lead me to negotiate in this case. Therefore, Scenario 1 seems to present the best case for negotiation to happen.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1.']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 2, score 6\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is suggesting a collaboration of sorts - she's offering to promote our crafts through her social media platforms. This could be beneficial to us in the long run as it might attract new potential customers. However, it is difficult to measure the true potential of her proposal. She might have many followers, but will her sharing translate to actual sales for us?\\n\\nScenario 2 also mentions Jill's interest in making future purchases. This is more direct and something that could be immediately beneficial. While a discount may lower the profit for this particular sale, knowing that Jill is planning to return in the future for more purchases makes this an easier decision to make. \\n\\nSo, while both scenarios offer potential benefits, Scenario 2 is more within our control and offers a more immediate and tangible benefit. Therefore, it would more likely encourage us to negotiate on the price of the vase.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2 \\n\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios have their merits and differences. \\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill is offering to advertise my work on her social media platform in exchange for a discount. This could potentially introduce my work to a broader range of customers who may not be currently aware of it. However, the reach and impact of the proposed advertisement isn't assured. I have no information on the demographic and buying habits of Jill's followers. Additionally, there's a risk in this scenario since I can't control the quality and veracity of the promotion.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill expresses interest in the vase but also hints at the possibility of future purchases. This signals that she might become a repeat customer, which is beneficial for a sustainable business. Even though there's no particular promise, there's still potential for more business down the line, which could be a more secure form of gaining profits. Finally, there isn't the uncertainty of social media exposure as in the first scenario. \\n\\nBased on these deliberations, I would, on balance, be more willing to negotiate in Scenario 2. The prospects of a returning, loyal customer and potential for future purchases provides a more tangible business prospect. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 1. In this situation, Jill not only expresses admiration for my work but also presents a potential opportunity for free advertisement and possibly more clients through her social media following of people who share her interest in handcrafted items. \\n\\nWhile it's true that offering the discount reduces the initial profit from selling the vase, the potential gain in terms of customer reach, increased visibility, and potential new clients outweighs this small loss. In addition, it builds good customer relations and encourages people to support local artisans. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, Jill also shows interest in the product and suggests the potential of future purchases which is a good prospect. However, without any solid commitment of repeat business, it's a less appealing proposition compared to Scenario 1. Offering a discount based on a promise of future purchases which may or may not happen is riskier. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a well-spoken and appreciative customer, which is great for any artisan at a local market. In Scenario 1, customer Jill not only shows admiration for the vase but also offers reciprocal value. She proposes to share the work on her social media platforms, which can potentially give the artisan a reach to a larger audience - an effective form of free marketing. It is also a form of investment, which may yield higher returns in the future.\\n\\nScenario 2 is a straightforward appreciation and request for a discount due to personal budget constraints. While this scenario is still polite and respectful, it doesn't offer a form of reciprocal value beyond the purchase of one piece.\\n\\nThus, considering value exchange and potential future gains, scenario 1 carries a little more weight.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a situation where Jill, the customer, initiates a negotiation for the price of a handcrafted flower vase. Understanding the premise, however, offers insight into why or why not I might prefer and be more willing to consider one scenario over the other.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only appreciates the artisan work but also provides an additional value proposition. She offers to promote the work on her social media, potentially driving more customers to the business. This suggests that the personalized craftsmanship is not only valued by her, but likely to be appreciated by a broader audience, validating the work. If her following is sizable and if such free promotion might attract more customers, then losing a small amount on an individual item could be advantageous over a broader scale.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also expresses admiration for the artisan craft and desire to support local businesses. However, she appears only to be seeking a discount based on her budget without offering any additional value for the business. It might be a simple, straightforward sale.\\n\\nWhile the genuine appreciation expressed in both scenarios is a positive, the added value in Scenario 1 offers a potentially greater business benefit. The promise of exposure to a wider customer base may more than offset a small discount provided to this individual customer and thus yield a long-term gain.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nThe decision between the two scenarios has to be made based on the perceived value of the proposed transactions and Jill's approach. In both cases, Jill is appreciative of the work and finds the vase appealing. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, she doesn't directly mention about what kind of discount she wants, but she proposes to help advertise the product on her social media platform, which could lead to increased exposure and possibly more sales. This is a valuable proposition as it might help in growing the business.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2, she only says she can't stretch her budget to the price but she doesn't give any specific reasons nor does she offer anything else in return, although she still shows appreciation for the work.\\n\\nGiven the additional potential value offered in Scenario 1, I'd be more likely to negotiate the vase's price with Jill in that context.\\n \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"In response to Scenario 1:\\nJill is offering something beyond more money as a part of her negotiation. Her offer to share the work on her social media platforms could result in increased exposure and potentially more customers in the future. This free advertising is valuable and could result in a greater increase in revenue over time than the immediate sale of the vase. \\n\\nIn response to Scenario 2:\\nIn this scenario, Jill is asking for a discount based on her intention to purchase multiple items or become a returning customer. While this does offer potential for additional sales in the future, it doesn't guarantee future purchases and doesn't offer any immediate, additional value as Scenario 1 does.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Although the benefits from both scenarios are theoretical, the guaranteed exposure from the social media promotion in Scenario 1 has a more direct and measurable potential for driving revenue in the short and medium term than a promise of future purchases in Scenario 2. This makes Scenario 1 a more desirable strategy from a business perspective.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: Jill's proposition in Scenario 1 not only appeals to a short-term benefit (the immediate sale) but also to long-term advantages (potential increase in visibility, customer base, and future sales). If Jill has a sizable social media following that aligns with potential customer demographics, offering a discount could ultimately pay off more than the price cut. Additionally, from the description Jill provides, she seems genuinely enthusiastic, supportive, and appreciative of the artisan's work, highlighting a potential for a longer-term customer relationship and possible referrals. Also, Jill talks about promoting the artist's work, which could lead to a rise in business visibility.\\n\\nWhile the potential of selling more than one vase in Scenario 2 is also appealing, there seems to be less guarantee of continued benefit as compared to the prospect of more visibility for future customers generated from Jill's social media promotion in Scenario 1. The discount proposal in scenario 2 also seems to be mainly centered around the buyer's benefit rather than a mutual benefit, as compared to scenario 1.\", \"Answer: Scenario 1\\n\\nReasoning: In both scenarios, Jill approaches me politely and appreciatively, showing interest and admiration for my craftsmanship. However, what makes scenario 1 more appealing, despite seemingly similar notions, is the mention of potential exposure through her social media platforms.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill offers not only a purchase but also an exchange where the value goes beyond just the sale of the vase. She's providing a form of compensation in addition to paying for the vase. Jill's offer to promote my work on her social media where she has a considerable following could potentially increase my customer base which could lead to greater sales in the long run. This form of advertisement is an added value and a bartering chip that makes me more likely to negotiate the price and offer a discount.\\n\\nOn the other hand, in Scenario 2 Jill asks for discounts on potential future purchases. While this might suggest a long-term customer relationship, it's much more speculative and uncertain compared to the immediate and definite offer of advertising present in Scenario 1. Also, offering a discount in anticipation of future purchases might set a precedent for discounted prices in the long run which may not be sustainable for my business.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "1_3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios offer compelling cases for offering a discount, but I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1. Here's why:\\n\\nFirstly, Jill not only acknowledges the craftsmanship in my work but also offers a form of reciprocation, something that isn't present in Scenario 2. She proposes to promote my work on her social media platforms, which has the potential to greatly increase the visibility of my products to a wider audience. This can be an effective way of acquiring new customers, especially if Jill indeed has a good number of followers.\\n\\nFurthermore, her proposition suggests she's interested in building a relationship beyond a simple transaction, which is beneficial from a customer loyalty perspective. It shows she values the work and is likely to come back for future purchases or refer others.\\n\\nWhile the customer in scenario 2 also praises the work and shows interest in supporting local artisans, she does not offer anything in return for the asking of a discount. Therefore, scenario 1 is more persuasive.\\n \\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill not only recognizes the value of the item she wants to buy but also offers something in return for a discount. Aside from showing appreciation for the local crafts, she wants to help advertise my business on her social platforms. Not only will this bring more visibility to my work, it could potentially bring in new customers. This is a form of barter system where I would be trading a product for a service.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also values and appreciates the craftsmanship of the vase, she only asks for a lower price, without proposing a possible benefit for me in return. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1, because Jill both appreciates my work and offers a way to promote it, can be seen as a win-win situation, as I could gain more customers and visibility in addition to making a sale. This could be more beneficial for my business in the long run compared to Scenario 2.', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present a customer who appreciates the workmanship of the vase and is open about the budget constraints they currently face. Jill's proposed deal in Scenario 1, however, offers something more substantial than just praise for the work: the prospect of marketing and reaching a wider customer base through her social media platforms.\\n\\nSuch a prospect could potentially result in increased sales and exposure for the artisan's work, and that could prove to be more valuable in the long run compared to the loss of a few dollars on the vase. Moreover, Jill's approach of appreciating the art and offering something in return gives a fair ground for negotiation.\\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 provides a similar appreciation for the work but does not offer anything else other than the plea for a discount. While it's often respectful and polite to engage a customer in price negotiations, this approach may not be as compelling as the first scenario where Jill offered something in return.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "0_2, generation 2, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\n\\nEach scenario offers compelling reasons for me as the artisan to potentially negotiate the price of the vase. In the first scenario, Jill acknowledges the quality and craftsmanship of the vase while expressing her interest in it. She politely asks for a potential discount, showing she appreciates the work that went into creating the vase.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill adopts a similar approach. She praises the craftsmanship and expresses a clear interest in the vase. But uniquely in this scenario, she also indicates her intention to be a returning customer, suggesting she could bring more business my way in the future.\\n\\nGiven these considerations, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 2 for a few key reasons. First, Jill not only appreciates my work but also suggests the potential for future purchases. This could mean a steady stream of business from her and perhaps her recommendations to others. Additionally, by offering a small discount, I could ensure her loyalty and possible word-of-mouth advertising, which could attract even more customers. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nI see two key differences between the two scenarios that could influence the likelihood of negotiating the price. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill opens the conversation with a compliment for the craftsmanship of the vase and is explicit about both her interest and her desire for a discount. This direct approach can be seen as honest and straightforward, which might encourage me to grant her a discount purely as a sign of good faith and to encourage a pleasant interaction. \\n\\nHowever, in Scenario 2, Jill not only compliments my work but also hints at the potential for future business and repeat visits. The prospect of a returning customer, especially one who appreciates the craftsmanship at work, is quite appealing as an artisan. This potential for an ongoing relationship might make me more inclined to negotiate a discount not just to make a sale now, but to encourage her to return in future.\\n\\nTherefore, taking into consideration the prospect of continuing business relationship, the potential for multiple purchases, and the overall attitude, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill makes a respectful request for price negotiation. She shows an appreciation for the craftsmanship of the piece, which recognizes the effort and skill the craftsman has put into it, and she expresses a genuine interest in purchasing the item. However, in scenario 2, Jill not only expresses her interest in the round vase but also speaks about future purchases. Her indication of frequenting the market and potentially making multiple purchases in the future adds more value for the artisan. Being appreciated as a skillful artisan and assured of possible future business would create a more meaningful relationship and might promote a willingness to negotiate the price. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios present Jill as a respectful and appreciative customer who values the work and craftsmanship that has gone into the flower vase. However, some differences could potentially impact my decision to negotiate.\\n\\nIn scenario 1, Jill's approach is more straightforward. She admires the vase and directly expresses her interest in a possible discount or negotiation. While this approach is clear and might lead to a negotiation, it doesn't provide additional benefits to me as the seller. \\n\\nOn the other hand, in scenario 2, Jill not only admires my craftsmanship but also mentions her intention of purchasing multiple items and becoming a returning customer. This implies potential for more sales now and in future, which may make offering her a small discount on the vase more advantageous in the long run.\\n\\nAs a seller, while I want to value my work appropriately, customer loyalty and the opportunity for repeat business is a significant factor to consider. Therefore, while both scenarios could lead to negotiation, Jill’s long-term customer potential in scenario 2 might make me more likely to negotiate.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", 'Reasoning: The decision to negotiate the price of the vase would certainly depend on several factors, but based on the given scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate in Scenario 2. Although both individuals are expressing their interest in the item, the customer in Scenario 2 is not only expressing a strong interest in that one item but also hinting at the potential for future purchases. Offering a discount to this customer could not only secure the immediate sale but also garner a repeat customer who may make additional purchases. Moreover, she also expressed interest in buying multiple items which could potentially lead to a bigger sale. Therefore, it would make more sense to negotiate with the customer in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2', \"Reasoning: The customer in both scenarios is polite and shows genuine appreciation for the artisan's work, which can make the artisan more disposed to negotiate. However, in scenario 2, Jill proposes buying multiple items, not just the vase, which could potentially be a more profitable transaction. Moreover, she mentions being a returning customer, suggesting a potentially long-term relationship which might be valuable for the artisan. Therefore, the artisan may be more inclined to consider negotiation in scenario 2 in the hopes of securing a higher total sale and possibly a regular customer.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFirstly, negotiation is essential in business, and as a local artisan, I may be more inclined to negotiate price based on certain advantageous factors or incentives. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill provides multiple potential benefits for giving her a discount. She mentions the possibility of being a returning customer, which means more potential sales in the future. She also offers to promote my work on her social media in exchange for a discount. This endorsement could help me reach a bigger audience and ultimately increase my customer base. Both of these factors make offer from Jill in Scenario 1 a profitable trade-off for a reduced price.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase and expresses interest in buying it, she doesn't offer any specific reasons or incentives for a discount beyond simply asking if it's possible. Her negotiation does not extend beyond the immediate sale, which, while certainly not negative, doesn't bring the same potential long-term benefits as Jill's proposal in Scenario 1.\\n\\nHence, considering these points, negotiation would be more beneficial for me in Scenario 1 as it potentially gives me subsequent sales and a wider market reach.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"The likelihood of offering a negotiation strongly depends on the individual seller's perspective. However, in terms of potential benefits to the business, I would be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 1.\\n\\nReasoning:\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is offering several compelling reasons for a potential discount. Firstly, she expresses an intention to become a repeat customer which could mean consistent business in the future. Secondly, she shows interest in buying multiple items at once which often warrants a small reduction in price. Lastly, she offers to endorse the products on social media. As someone with a few thousand followers, this could provide some valuable marketing exposure, resulting in increased sales.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill does compliment the craftsmanship and indicates interest in purchasing the vase, she doesn't offer any extra incentive that would directly benefit your business in terms of future sales or marketing exposure.\\n\\nHowever, taking the negotiation decision should not only base on this single interaction, as Scenario 2 might lead to a stronger bond of trust with the customer, leading to potential word-of-mouth advertising and possibly returning business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning: \\n\\nFrom a business standpoint, both scenarios provide incentives to consider a negotiation. However, they present different opportunities, and the best scenario depends on what I, as an artisan, value more. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows interest in being a repeat customer and speaks about the possibility of promoting my work on her social media. This could potentially provide some free marketing and bring in new customers. Continual business and broad exposure to a new customer base can be very beneficial, especially if Jill's followers are within my target demographic. The discount could be seen as a marketing cost.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill compliments the craftsmanship but doesn't necessarily offer any additional value, like the promise of repeat business or exposure in Scenario 1. Nonetheless, her appreciation for the product is genuine, and as an artisan, I may feel satisfied knowing my work is being valued. \\n\\nThe decision depends on crafting satisfaction vs. potential business growth. \\n\\nAnswer: Essentially, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase in Scenario 1 due to the potential long term benefits for my business.\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "0_2, generation 2, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill approaches me politely and demonstrates a great appreciation for handcrafted items, highlighting the uniqueness of my work. This as a positive start for any negotiation. \\n\\nHowever, in the first scenario, Jill not only shows interest in the round flower vase, but she also mentions her intention to come back again and possibly buy more items. This can be interpreted as Jill possibly being a repeat customer which could potentially generate more sales in the future. To establish good rapport and incentivize her to come back, I would be more inclined to give a discount.\\n\\nIn the second scenario, Jill also appreciates the vase but expresses in her statement that 30 dollars is slightly stretching her budget. While this is a legitimate reason to give a discount, it's only a single sale with no indication of future purchases. \\n\\nIn summary, while both scenarios present good reasons to offer a discount, the prospect of securing a repeat customer in scenario 1 would likely be more beneficial for my business in the long run. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBetween the two scenarios, Jill uses different tactics to try to get a discounted price on the vase. My decision to negotiate or not would largely depend on her approach and her intention.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the quality of my work, expressing genuine interest in my products. She also indicates that she's considering making multiple purchases and becoming a returning customer, both of which would be beneficial to my business in the long run. Negotiating a price with her could foster a good relationship and encourage future purchases. Knocking off a few dollars might be a good investment here.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also compliments my work, her approach to potentially lowering the price is based solely on her personal budget constraints. While it's possible that offering her a discount would make her happy and potentially turn her into a return customer, it's less clear whether this would be a long-term benefit for me — especially if she's likely to ask for discounts in the future as well.\\n\\nSo, based on the reasoning above, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in...\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios introduced by Jill present valid arguments for possible negotiation, however, there are some distinctions between the two. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only compliments the craftsmanship of the vase but also expresses the intention of returning to make additional purchases. The prospect of a returning customer may lead to a larger overall profit, making it more appealing for me, the artisan,  to negotiate the price for the current item.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill again praises the work and even identifies herself as a supporter of local artisans. However, she only expresses financial constraints for purchasing the vase without mentioning any potential return or future purchases. \\n\\nGiven these considerations, the decision on whether or not to negotiate does not only consider the immediate sale but potential future business opportunities as well.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\\n']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "0_2, generation 2, score 0\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "['[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill admirably appreciates the craftsmanship and expresses a strong interest in the round flower vase. She skillfully introduces the idea of potential purchases in the future and hints at becoming a returning customer. These elements in negotiation can be persuasive, benefiting both the customer and me as an artisan. It promotes my work and ensures returning business, which is certainly good for any artisan.\\n\\nNevertheless, there is a subtle difference between the two scenarios. In Scenario 1, Jill not only shows interest in the vase but also expresses concrete plans on coming back to the market in the future. While in Scenario 2, Jill \"plans\" to come back and \"possibly\" buy more. The former shows more certainty on the part of Jill and seems more promising in terms of future business. Therefore, a little negotiation on the price, in this case, appears to be more justified. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth customers presented their interest in the product effectively and showed respect for the craftsman's work. However, Jill in Scenario 1 was slightly more strategic in her request for a discount. She not only balanced her request for a price reduction with genuine appreciation for the work, but also indicated a longer-term potential benefit for the artisan, in that she is planning on being a return customer. This gives an impression that she values the work and is interested in forming a business relationship rather than just seeking a one-off deal.\\n\\nJill in Scenario 2 followed a similar approach but did not clearly express her intention of being a return customer or the possibility of buying more products in the future, which could be a positive factor for small entrepreneurs like artisans.\\n\\nTherefore, considering the prospect of future business and showing respect for my work, I'd be more encouraged to negotiate on the price in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nBoth scenarios are quite similar with Jill expressing interest in the vase, admiring the craftsmanship, asking about negotiations on the price, and mentioning the prospect of future purchases. She is respectful and complimetary in both scenarios. \\n\\nOne slight difference is found in the way the question about price negotiation is phrased. In Scenario 1, she is wondering if there \"is any room for bargaining?\" while in Scenario 2, she asks if there is \"any room for a slight negotiation?\". The phrasing in Scenario 2 implies she is asking for a minor adjustment which could suggest a less aggressive negotiation from her side, while in Scenario 1 it\\'s not specified to what extent she is looking to bargain. \\n\\nFurthermore, in Scenario 2, Jill reinforces her interest in your work by directly saying your work stands out in the market, which might imply a higher value attached to your work.\\n\\nGiven these nuances, it seems that you might be more inclined to negotiate in Scenario 2. Jill\\'s request appears to be more reasonable, respectful and less assertive making you more likely to engage in a friendly negotiation.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "0_2, generation 2, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\nUpon examining Jill's approach in both scenarios, both are polite and appreciative, commending the artistry and uniqueness of the items. However, in Scenario 1, Jill not only does she express her interest in the item but also shows genuine intentions of becoming a repeat customer and making more purchases in the future. That hints of a potential for future sales, which could offset providing a discount at this moment. Furthermore, encouraging multiple purchases can boost overall sales and customer loyalty. An investment of a small discount now could result in a loyal customer whose purchases will cover and exceed the initial discount.\\n\\nTherefore, taking these factors into consideration, I would be more likely to negotiate the price of the vase in Scenario 1 as Jill showed her interest to be a loyal customer and hinted at buying more in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\nI am an artisan who takes great pride in the work and effort put into creating unique pieces. Both Jill's scenarios are flattering and encouraging, showing that she appreciates the value and quality of handicrafts. This is very important for an artisan, as it validates the effort that goes into every piece. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill shows a keen interest in the vase and also expresses her intention to return to the market for more purchases. This suggests not only a one-time sale but potentially more business in the future which is always appealing to a seller. This would make me more likely to consider a discount, if it could ensure future transactions. Jill also praises the work and craftsmanship, which reassures me that she truly values the product. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill values and appreciates the craftsmanship, she mentions financial constraints. This portrays the situation as a desire to own the product rather than a detailed interest and future engagement as suggested in Scenario 1. \\n\\nSo while both scenarios indicate appreciation of my work and intent to buy, it is Scenario 1 that holds the promise of future business.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nWhile both scenarios propose a situation where the customer shows interest in my work and implies a desire for a price reduction, my decision would factor toward the motivation behind the negotiation, the potential for future business, and the overall benefit to my trade.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill expresses her admiration for my craftsmanship, which is always reassuring as a local artisan. But what stands out more in this scenario is that she intends to be a returning customer and anticipates making multiple purchases in the impending visits. This could translate into steady business and, potentially, increased sales volume.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, while Jill also appreciates my work, she is asking for a discount primarily due to her budget constraints. While I empathize with her situation, there is no guarantee of future business as compared to Scenario 1.  \\n\\nGiven these reasons, I would be more inclined to offer a discount in the first scenario. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her appreciation for the artisan's work and shows interest in buying the vase. However, the situations differ significantly when it comes to their potential for future business.\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill not only wants to purchase the vase but also hints at buying multiple items and even becoming a recurring customer. This has potential to increase my revenue in the long run, even if I have to reduce the price somewhat for this initial purchase. She also shows sincere appreciation in my craft, which is a form of respect for what I do, setting quite a conducive environment for negotiation.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill is also complimentary of my work, but mentions that the marked price is a stretch for her budget, implying that she might not purchase if there's no room for negotiation. While this scenario brings the sympathy factor into play, it may result in a one-time sale only without hinting at any future business or multiple item purchases.\\n\\nTherefore, based on potential for future business and considering this as a long term relationship, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price in Scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn my evaluation, both scenarios have Jill expressing sincere admiration for the vase and for my craftsmanship. However, Jill's approach in Scenario 1 includes elements that make me more inclined to negotiate the price with her. Firstly, she expresses interest in buying multiple items, not just the vase. This represents a bigger sale for me, making me more likely to consider a discount on the vase. Secondly, Jill suggests she will be a returning customer. This means that offering her a discount now could lead to further sales in the future, establishing a loyal customer who appreciates my work. While Jill in Scenario 2 also appears genuine in her interest and praise, her approach simply focuses on a discount without offering a clear future benefit to me as the artisan. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Given the two scenarios, I would be more inclined to negotiate the price of the flower vase in Scenario 2. \\n\\nJill, in scenario 1, shows admiration and interest in my craft and proposes future purchases but doesn\\'t state any particular reason to really need a discount. Despite the fact that she implies she will be a returning customer, this isn\\'t a guarantee. However, a future discount for repeat business could potentially be negotiated as it fosters a returning customer relationship.\\n\\nIn scenario 2, Jill gives a specific reason - \"30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment\". This shows an immediate need for a discount and she is clearly expressing her interest in the piece but showing restraint due to her current financial situation. This consideration and honesty are compelling reasons for a price negotiation, along with the fact that she also appreciates local artisans, means she may more likely recommend my products to others, indirectly helping me sell more.\\n\\nObviously, the implication of a repeat customer in scenario 1 is very enticing, but the immediate sale under sincere circumstances as expressed in scenario 2 is a safer bet.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 0, score 0\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"[reasoning text]\\n\\nFrom a negotiation standpoint, both scenarios present compelling cases for a price adjustment. However, several key factors lead me to favor one scenario over the other. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill compliments the craftsmanship of the vase, showing her acknowledgment of the effort and time put into creating it. She also states her support for local artisans which implies she values the work involved. Jill then expresses her desire for the vase and notes that the price is a bit out of her current budget. Here, Jill is quite honest about her financial situation, which adds credibility to her request for a price adjustment. She is not asking for a considerable discount, just a 'little wiggle room', which suggests she respects the artisan's work and is not trying to undervalue their effort. \\n\\nOn the other hand, Scenario 2 involves Jill asking for potential discounts for multiple purchases or for returning customers. While these propositions may seem appealing, they put the artisan in a spot where they're committing to future discounts without any concrete commitment from Jill apart from her 'plan' of regular visits. The social media aspect she introduces could give the artisan exposure, but it's not guaranteed to translate into sales. It could also set a precedence for the artisan, where they might be expected to offer discounts to anyone promising to promote them on social media.\\n\\nTherefore, based on the above reasoning, I would be more inclined to negotiate with Jill in:\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", \"Reasoning Text:\\nIn both scenarios, Jill has approached the situation by complimenting the item and acknowledging the work that has gone into it, which is a good starting point for any negotiation. However, her methods of justifying her request for a discount vary quite significantly. \\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill is open about the fact that the price is slightly out of her budget, hinting at the fact that she might not be able to buy the item unless the price is reduced. This may work in her favor as, being a local artisan, I may be more interested in selling my items to people who genuinely appreciate them and will give them a good home, rather than just making a profit.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill offers two reasons for a potential discount: the possibility of purchasing multiple items and her potential to promote the items on her social media platform. While the promise of future purchases might be appealing, it's not guaranteed. The social media promotion, however, could potentially reach a large audience and attract new customers to the stall, which could generate more sales in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\\n\\nHaving considered both scenarios, I would be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill in Scenario 2. Her suggestion of promoting my items on her social media platform could be more beneficial to me in the long term, despite being an undefined return. While Scenario 1 is more immediately sympathetic, as a business, potential brand exposure offers greater future opportunity.\", '[reasoning text]\\n\\nThere seems to be a greater willingness to compromise price in Scenario 2. Even though they both show interest, Jill from Scenario 2 is giving more reasons and bargaining chips for you to consider lowering your price. She is discussing not only just getting the vase, but also potential repeated business, as she plans to come back to the market often. Moreover, she could potentially help expand your customer base with her social media following, which is an aspect in favor of giving her a discount. In Scenario 1, while Jill shows admiration for your work, she only uses her current budget constraint as an argument, and she does not mention anything about promoting your work, repeat business, or buying multiple items. \\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "0_2, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: True\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [1, 1, 1]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning text: \\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill shows a deep appreciation of my craftsmanship which is always welcome. However, in the first scenario, Jill mentions that she might purchase multiple items and is also thinking about becoming a returning customer. This could potentially lead to further sales, which would benefit my business in the long run and makes it more attractive to clients. Providing a discount to encourage a larger purchase or reward customer loyalty is a common business practice. \\n\\nThough Jill is also appreciative in the second scenario, she only expresses interest in the single vase, and mentions her budget constraints. While it's understandable for customers to have budget limitations, this situation doesn't present the same opportunity for ongoing or expanded sales as in the first scenario.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1\", 'Reasoning:\\nJill approaches the negotiation differently in both scenarios, but the key point here is her intention of potentially buying more items or returning as a recurring customer. In both scenarios, she compliments the work and shows genuine interest, validating the quality of the craft which can also be an essential element in negotiations. However, scenario 1 could have a larger overall selling potential, as she expresses interest in purchasing multiple items and promises revisit in the future. The promise to become a returning customer insinuates a developing business relationship that could be more profitable in the long run.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1', '[reasoning text]\\n\\nIn both scenarios, Jill expresses her admiration for your work. However, in the first scenario, she is more invested in your craft as she proposes buying multiple products and returning in the future. This suggests a valuable potential customer who is likely to bring more business to you. In economic terms, giving her a discount might result in a greater long-term profit due to an increase in her customer loyalty. Therefore, it would make more business sense to negotiate with Jill in scenario 1.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 1']\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "participant 86 has a large difference:\n",
      "0_1, generation 1, score 0\n",
      "2_3, generation 0, score 6\n",
      "Evaluator: artisan:\n",
      "Flipped: False\n",
      "Scenarios: Scenario 1:\n",
      "\"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "\n",
      "Scenario 2:\n",
      "Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "\n",
      "In which scenario would you be more likely to negotiate on the price of the vase with Jill? \n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): [0, 0, 0]\n",
      "\n",
      "Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \n",
      "[\"Reasoning:\\nIn any negotiation, the key to making a deal is effectively communicating mutual benefits. Looking at the scenarios, Jill in Scenario 1 compliments the work and recognizes the value of supporting local artisans but mentions her budget constraints. A good negotiator might choose to impact her positively, encouraging her to keep supporting local artisans in the future by offering a discount. However, she only shows interest in one item and doesn't offer any concrete benefit or bargaining tool, instead, hints at her financial constraint as a need for lowering the price.\\n\\nMeanwhile, Jill in Scenario 2 offers a more compelling case for a discount. Not only does she express interest in the vase, but she also hints at the possibility of purchasing more than one item - which could mean more revenue. In addition, she offers to promote the artisan's items to a considerable following on social media, potentially driving more clients to the artisan's business. This sort of promotion could be very valuable, especially if her followers are locals and/or people likely to appreciate handmade crafts. Furthermore, she indicates that she is a returning customer, suggesting she will continue to support the business in the future.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\", \"Reasoning:\\n\\nIn Scenario 1, Jill complements the originality of the artisan's work, showing a deep appreciation for the uniqueness and attention to detail. This is flattering for the artisan and suggests that Jill understands the value of unique, handcrafted goods. She also mentions that she is budget-constrained, implying that she may not be able to buy more items in the future if she pays the full price now.\\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill also shows appreciation for the vase and interest in buying other items from the same artisan, indicating the possibility of a long-term customer relationship. More importantly, Jill offers to promote the artisan's work on social media, offering potential exposure to thousands of people who might be interested in similar items. This could significantly boost the artisan's business.\\n\\nBased on these considerations, Jill appears to be offering more value to the artisan in Scenario 2. Therefore, the artisan might be more inclined to negotiate the price with Jill in Scenario 2.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2.\", \"Reasoning Text\\n\\nIt's quite difficult to make a definitive choice - both scenarios present valid reasons for discount consideration. In Scenario 1, Jill compliments our work, which is always nice to hear as an artisan, and presents her issue with budget constraints. However, offering discounts based on a customer's budget could set a tricky precedent for future sales. \\n\\nIn Scenario 2, Jill not only expresses interest in the vase but indicates she plans on buying multiple items and becoming a returning customer. She also proposes a promotional exchange: a discount in return for social media exposure. This could potentially result in new customer acquisition through her followers. Offering a discount to returning customers or those purchasing in bulk is a common business practice, and the prospect of gaining additional exposure through her social media influence is a worthwhile consideration.\\n\\nAnswer: Scenario 2\"]\n",
      "\n",
      "\n",
      "\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "df_tmp = df[df[\"participant_id\"].isin(competent_participants)]\n",
    "get_large_differences(df_tmp)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 52,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "dict_keys(['0', '0_1', '0_2', '0_3', '1', '1_2', '1_3', '2', '2_3', '3', '[]'])\n",
      "1 piece 7.110912343470483 559\n",
      "2 pieces 6.95230998509687 671\n"
     ]
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "text/plain": [
       "{'whiskers': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4a9dc0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4b90a0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4b9af0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4b9d90>],\n",
       " 'caps': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4b9340>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea3fe100>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4e9070>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4e9310>],\n",
       " 'boxes': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4a9b20>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4b9850>],\n",
       " 'medians': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea411760>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4e95b0>],\n",
       " 'fliers': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4b95b0>,\n",
       "  <matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fc7ea4e9850>],\n",
       " 'means': []}"
      ]
     },
     "execution_count": 52,
     "metadata": {},
     "output_type": "execute_result"
    },
    {
     "data": {
      "image/png": "[encoded data, 4788 characters]",
      "text/plain": [
       "<Figure size 432x288 with 1 Axes>"
      ]
     },
     "metadata": {
      "needs_background": "light"
     },
     "output_type": "display_data"
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# AVERAGE SCORES FOR NUMBER OF ADVICE INDICES\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] != 'baseline_ask']\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] != 'baseline_ask_with_reasoning']\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby(['advice_indices'])['answer']\n",
    "print(grouped.groups.keys())\n",
    "\n",
    "# zero_pieces = grouped.get_group(\"nan\")\n",
    "one_piece = pd.concat([grouped.get_group(\"0\"), grouped.get_group(\"1\"), grouped.get_group(\"2\"), grouped.get_group(\"3\")])\n",
    "two_pieces = pd.concat([grouped.get_group(\"0_1\"), grouped.get_group(\"0_2\"), grouped.get_group(\"1_2\"), grouped.get_group(\"0_3\"), grouped.get_group(\"1_3\"), grouped.get_group(\"2_3\")])\n",
    "\n",
    "# print(\"0 pieces\", zero_pieces.mean(), len(zero_pieces))\n",
    "print(\"1 piece\", one_piece.mean(), len(one_piece))\n",
    "print(\"2 pieces\", two_pieces.mean(), len(two_pieces))\n",
    "\n",
    "plt.boxplot([one_piece, two_pieces], labels=[\"1 piece\", \"2 pieces\"])"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 250,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "ties: 35\n",
      "total: 2556\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# NUMBER OF TIES FOR AVERAGE SCORES FOR EACH GENERATION\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby('origin_id')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "ties = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "for origin_id, score in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "    for origin_id2, score2 in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "        if score == score2 and origin_id != origin_id2:\n",
    "            ties += 1\n",
    "            # print(origin_id, origin_id2, score)\n",
    "\n",
    "ties = ties // 2\n",
    "print(\"ties:\", ties)\n",
    "print(\"total:\", len(grouped) * (len(grouped) - 1) // 2)"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 251,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "6 30 baseline_ask_with_reasoning baseline_neutral_advice [] 1\n",
      "6 71 baseline_ask_with_reasoning unorthodox_advice [] 2_3\n",
      "8 42 baseline_irrelevant_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0 1_2\n",
      "9 23 baseline_irrelevant_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 0 1_2\n",
      "9 33 baseline_irrelevant_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0 0_1\n",
      "10 50 baseline_irrelevant_advice unorthodox_advice 1 0_1\n",
      "16 69 baseline_irrelevant_advice unorthodox_advice 2 1_3\n",
      "22 25 baseline_irrelevant_advice baseline_neutral_advice 1_2 0\n",
      "23 9 baseline_irrelevant_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 1_2 0\n",
      "23 33 baseline_irrelevant_advice baseline_neutral_advice 1_2 0_1\n",
      "25 22 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 0 1_2\n",
      "26 51 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0 0_1\n",
      "26 60 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0 1_2\n",
      "26 72 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0 2_3\n",
      "27 38 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0 0_2\n",
      "27 68 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0 1_3\n",
      "30 6 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_ask_with_reasoning 1 []\n",
      "30 71 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 1 2_3\n",
      "31 45 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0_1 0\n",
      "32 48 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0_1 1\n",
      "33 9 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 0_1 0\n",
      "33 23 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 0_1 1_2\n",
      "35 53 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 2 2\n",
      "36 37 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_neutral_advice 2 0_2\n",
      "36 44 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 2 0\n",
      "37 36 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0_2 2\n",
      "37 44 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0_2 0\n",
      "38 27 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0_2 0\n",
      "38 68 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0_2 1_3\n",
      "39 52 baseline_neutral_advice unorthodox_advice 0_2 2\n",
      "42 8 baseline_neutral_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 1_2 0\n",
      "43 55 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0 0_2\n",
      "43 65 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0 0_3\n",
      "44 36 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0 2\n",
      "44 37 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0 0_2\n",
      "45 31 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0 0_1\n",
      "46 54 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 1 2\n",
      "46 64 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 1 0_3\n",
      "48 32 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 1 0_1\n",
      "50 10 unorthodox_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 0_1 1\n",
      "51 26 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 0_1 0\n",
      "51 60 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_1 1_2\n",
      "51 72 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_1 2_3\n",
      "52 39 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 2 0_2\n",
      "53 35 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 2 2\n",
      "54 46 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 2 1\n",
      "54 64 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 2 0_3\n",
      "55 43 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_2 0\n",
      "55 65 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_2 0_3\n",
      "60 26 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 1_2 0\n",
      "60 51 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 1_2 0_1\n",
      "60 72 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 1_2 2_3\n",
      "61 63 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 3 3\n",
      "SAME ADVICE SET\n",
      "62 70 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 3 2_3\n",
      "63 61 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 3 3\n",
      "SAME ADVICE SET\n",
      "64 46 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_3 1\n",
      "64 54 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_3 2\n",
      "65 43 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_3 0\n",
      "65 55 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_3 0_2\n",
      "66 67 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 0_3 1_3\n",
      "67 66 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 1_3 0_3\n",
      "68 27 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 1_3 0\n",
      "68 38 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 1_3 0_2\n",
      "69 16 unorthodox_advice baseline_irrelevant_advice 1_3 2\n",
      "70 62 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 2_3 3\n",
      "71 6 unorthodox_advice baseline_ask_with_reasoning 2_3 []\n",
      "71 30 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 2_3 1\n",
      "72 26 unorthodox_advice baseline_neutral_advice 2_3 0\n",
      "72 51 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 2_3 0_1\n",
      "72 60 unorthodox_advice unorthodox_advice 2_3 1_2\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# How many of the ties are from the same advice set?\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby('origin_id')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "ties = []\n",
    "\n",
    "for origin_id, score in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "    for origin_id2, score2 in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "        if score == score2 and origin_id != origin_id2:\n",
    "            ties.append((origin_id, origin_id2))\n",
    "\n",
    "grouped2 = df.groupby('origin_id')[['advice_type', 'advice_indices']]\n",
    "for (origin_id, origin_id2) in ties:\n",
    "    advice_type = grouped2.get_group(origin_id)['advice_type'].unique()[0]\n",
    "    advice_type2 = grouped2.get_group(origin_id2)['advice_type'].unique()[0]\n",
    "    advice_indices = grouped2.get_group(origin_id)['advice_indices'].unique()[0]\n",
    "    advice_indices2 = grouped2.get_group(origin_id2)['advice_indices'].unique()[0]\n",
    "    print(origin_id, origin_id2, advice_type, advice_type2, advice_indices, advice_indices2)\n",
    "    if advice_type == advice_type2 and advice_indices == advice_indices2:\n",
    "        print(\"SAME ADVICE SET\")\n",
    "\n",
    "# ONLY 1 TIE IS FROM THE SAME ADVICE SET"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 252,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "# what about ties between advice sets (instead of generations?)\n",
    "grouped = df.groupby(['advice_type', 'advice_indices'])['answer'].mean()\n",
    "ties = 0\n",
    "\n",
    "for (advice_type, advice_indices), score in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "    for (advice_type2, advice_indices2), score2 in grouped.iteritems():\n",
    "        if score == score2 and (advice_type != advice_type2 or advice_indices != advice_indices2):\n",
    "            ties += 1\n",
    "            print(advice_type, advice_type2, advice_indices, advice_indices2, score)\n",
    "# NO TIES BETWEEN PIECES OF ADVICE"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 290,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "5.85\n",
      "5.946666666666666\n",
      "0.544079946796192\n",
      "-0.17766996787124562\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# ABLATION AGAINST AVERAGE GENERATION SCORES -- RESPONSE\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] == best_generation_advice]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['generation_index'] == best_generation_index]\n",
    "grouped_best = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(grouped_best.mean())\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all generations\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "print(df_tmp['answer'].mean())\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(np.std(grouped, ddof=1))\n",
    "\n",
    "# num std devs higher\n",
    "print((grouped_best.mean() - grouped.mean())/np.std(grouped, ddof=1))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 292,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "6.6\n",
      "6.2027777777777775\n",
      "0.45064405616792186\n",
      "0.8814544800613231\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# ABLATION AGAINST AVERAGE GENERATION SCORES -- RESPONSE WITHOUT SOCIAL MEDIA\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] == \"1_2\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['generation_index'] == 0]\n",
    "grouped_best = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(grouped_best.mean())\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all generations\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '0_3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '1_3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '2_3']\n",
    "print(df_tmp['answer'].mean())\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(np.std(grouped, ddof=1))\n",
    "\n",
    "# num std devs higher\n",
    "print((grouped_best.mean() - grouped.mean())/np.std(grouped, ddof=1))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 293,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "7.2 \"Hi there, I just want to say I really love this flower vase. The craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. I'm really keen to support local artisans like yourself and I'm definitely planning to come back to shop in the future. I was wondering, though, are there any discounts for people buying multiple items or for future returning customers? This piece is really lovely, but my budget is a bit tight at the moment.\"\n",
      "6.85 \"Hello, this is such a beautiful vase! The design is truly unique. You've done an incredible job crafting it. I'm a great supporter of local artisans and I love adding these kinds of pieces to my home. However, I wonder if there might be a little wiggle room on the price? 30 dollars is just a slight stretch for my budget at the moment. Is there a possibility we could negotiate a little?\"\n",
      "6.8 \"Hi there! This vase is absolutely stunning - your craftsmanship truly shines. I'm really interested in making a purchase, but I was wondering if there might be a little wiggle room with the price? Also, do you offer any deals for repeat customers? I would love to keep supporting your work when I return to the market.\"\n",
      "6.6 \"Hello, I must say, I absolutely love your work. Your craftsmanship is remarkable and I truly believe in supporting our local artisans. This round flower vase has caught my eye, it’s so beautiful. Though, I've to confess the price is slightly more than I had budgeted for today. I plan to come back to the market in the future. Do you offer discounts for multiple item purchases or for returning customers? I'd love to be a regular patron and support your craft while also keeping a tab on my expenses.\"\n",
      "6.55 \"Hello, I must say, I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship of this beautiful flower vase. Your work truly stands out in the market. I'm drawn to this round vase, it's priced at 30 dollars, right? I am quite interested but I was wondering if there might be any room for a slight negotiation? Also, I'm planning to come back to the market again and possibly buy more. Do you offer any discounts for returning customers or if I make multiple purchases?\"\n",
      "6.3 \"Hi there, I'm really interested in purchasing this lovely vase, but I was also wondering, do you offer any discounts for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I really enjoy your work and I plan to visit the market again in the future.\"\n",
      "6.25 \"Hello! I must say, your work is absolutely exquisite. The attention to detail in this round vase is something I can't find elsewhere... you truly have a gift. I am always eager to support our local artisans. However, I'm slightly constrained by my budget. Would there be any chance for a little flexibility on the price?\"\n",
      "6.2 \"Hello, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate this beautiful round flower vase. Your craftsmanship truly stands out. I'm actually very interested in purchasing it. I was just wondering, is there is any room for bargaining? Also, would there possibilities for discounts if I were to purchase multiple items, or perhaps for returning customers? I admire your craft very much and I plan on coming back to this market in the near future.\"\n",
      "6.2 \"Hello! I must say, this round flower vase is absolutely gorgeous. The craftsmanship is truly exceptional. I'm really considering buying it, but I was wondering if there might be a possibility for some kind of discount or negotiation on the price? I truly appreciate the work that's gone into this and I'm really interested in it.\"\n",
      "6.2 \"Hi there! I have to say, I absolutely adore this round flower vase. The craftsmanship is truly outstanding. I can see myself placing this vase in my living room, it would surely enhance its beauty. I was wondering, though, is there any possibility we could discuss the price a bit? Maybe there's some room for a slight reduction? I'd also be more than happy to share some pictures of this beautiful piece on my social media and tag your store. How does that sound?\"\n",
      "6.15 Hello! I've been admiring your work. This flower vase is absolutely stunning. I'm really passionate about supporting local artisans like yourself, and I love that I can buy something handcrafted instead of something factory-made. \n",
      "\n",
      "However, I'm on a tighter budget than I had hoped for. Do you think we might be able to work something out? Perhaps I could help promote your work on my social media or anything else that might be beneficial for your business in exchange for a slight discount on this vase?\n",
      "6.1 \"Hello, this is a beautiful piece. You truly have incredible talent. I'm interested in purchasing it, and while I appreciate the craftsmanship and the price, I was wondering if there might be any flexibility there? Also, I'd love to help others discover your work. If you're open to a little discount, I could feature this vase and your entire shop on my social media. What do you think?\"\n",
      "6.1 \"Hello, I was really drawn to this beautiful flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly exquisite. I'm a big supporter of local artisans and I love to have items like this in my home. However, as much as I love this vase, the price is a tiny bit over my budget. Is there by any chance you could give me a small discount?\"\n",
      "6.1 \"Hi there! This vase is indeed captivating. I'm planning on being a regular visitor here in the future and I'm also interested in multiple purchases. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts for returning customers or for purchases of more than one item?\"\n",
      "6.0 \"Hello there! I absolutely love this vase; it's so beautiful. I can see the quality of your work and I truly admire it. As a big supporter of local artisans, I’m thrilled to contribute to the community, but I'm on a bit of a budget. So, I was wondering if there's any possibility of a slight reduction in price?\"\n",
      "5.9 Hello, I am really interested in this beautiful flower vase. It's exactly the kind of craftsmanship I've been looking for! I notice the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair given the quality, however, I was wondering if you offer any discounts on purchases? For example, I plan on returning to this market regularly and buying more items, would that potentially qualify me for a discount? \n",
      "\n",
      "Additionally, I have quite a large following on my social media channels where I share all things home décor and DIY. I would be more than happy to feature any piece I buy from your stall and share your artisan shop's information with my followers. That way, it could help bring more attention to your work. Would that perhaps encourage a discount on this vase?\n",
      "5.9 \"Hello, first let me say - your work is outstanding. I can see the passion and effort you've put into crafting this vase. It's exactly what I've been looking for and I really want to support local artisans like yourself. But, I am a bit constrained by my budget. Is there any chance for a small discount, perhaps?\"\n",
      "5.9 \"Hi there, I absolutely love this round flower vase. I'm always looking to support local artisans like you and add unique pieces like this to my collection. I notice it's marked at $30, though, which is a little more than I was hoping to spend today. Do you offer any discounts for buying multiple items or for customers who will be returning to the market in the future? I definitely see myself coming back to shop here again.\"\n",
      "5.85 Hello, I'm very interested in this lovely round flower vase. It's perfectly suited for my home. I'm definitely on board with supporting local artisans, and I noticed that you have so many other high-quality products here. I was wondering, do you offer any discounts if I purchase multiple items or even as a returning customer? I come to the market often and would love to keep supporting your work.\n",
      "\n",
      "Also, I have a substantial following on my social media platforms, and I would be thrilled to share your work with my audience to help promote your business. Would it be possible to consider an equivalent exchange like that for a discount on this vase?\n",
      "5.8 \"Hi there, I must say, this vase is beautifully crafted! Your talent is truly extraordinary. Just out of curiosity, would there be any room for a slight price negotiation on this piece?\"\n",
      "5.7 \"Hello, I've been admiring this beautiful flower vase. I really love supporting local artisans like you, and your work truly is unique. I must mention, though, I'm trying to stretch my budget a bit, so I was hoping we could possibly discuss the price a bit?\"\n",
      "5.65 Hi there, I'm really interested in this lovely round flower vase. Its craftsmanship is indeed impressive. I'm thinking about purchasing it, but I wonder if you might offer any discounts for buying multiple items? Also, I plan to be a returning customer, as I'm a big supporter of local artisans like yourself. Would there possibly be any special deals for loyal customers like me?\n",
      "5.55 \"Hello, this vase is wonderfully made, your craftsmanship is truly impressive. I am very interested in purchasing it, but I was wondering if there's any room for bargaining on the price?\"\n",
      "5.35 \"Hello! I noticed this beautiful round flower vase and I'm really interested in buying it. Your work is exceptional and I'd love to support you by promoting your talent to my network. I have a decent amount of followers on social media who would love your work. Do you think we could come to an arrangement where I promote your work in exchange for a small discount on the vase?\"\n",
      "5.35 Hi there, I absolutely love your work! This round flower vase has particularly caught my eye, it's really beautiful. I noticed the price is 30 dollars, which is fair for the quality, but I was wondering if there's any chance we could arrange a little discount? I'm active on my social media where I post often about local art and artisans. I'd be more than happy to feature your work and this beautiful vase on my Instagram and Facebook which could help in promoting your craft. What do you think?\n",
      "5.3 Hi there! I'm absolutely enchanted by this beautiful round vase you've created. The craftsmanship truly reflects the talent we have here locally. I'm a big fan of supporting our local artisans. But you know, my budget is a little tight at the moment. \n",
      "\n",
      "I wondered if you might consider offering me a small discount? To show my gratitude, I would love to share your work on my social media platforms. I have a good number of followers who share my passion for artisan pieces. I think they would adore your work and it could potentially draw more clients to your business. How does that sound to you?\n",
      "5.3 Hi there! I must say, I'm absolutely smitten with this round flower vase. The design and craftsmanship are simply exquisite. I can tell a lot of time and effort went into creating this beautiful piece. \n",
      "\n",
      "I was just wondering, is there any room for negotiation with the price? I'm willing to pay the full price, but as an admirer of local artisans, I always try to get good value whenever possible. \n",
      "\n",
      "Actually, I have quite a following on social media. If possible, I'd love to post this vase and highlight your fantastic work in exchange for a small discount. What do you think about that?\n",
      "5.15 Hello! I really love this flower vase. It's perfectly round and well-crafted, just what I've been looking for. I was wondering if there might be any discounts available, perhaps for purchasing multiple items or for returning customers? I do plan on coming back to this market regularly. Also, I have a few thousand followers on social media and would be more than happy to share how much I love my finds from your stall, if that could potentially earn me a small discount on this vase. What do you think?\n",
      "5.15 \"Hi there. I absolutely love this flower vase. Your craftsmanship is truly unique! I noticed the marked price is 30 dollars, which I think is fair considering the quality. However, I was wondering if you might consider offering a discount? I have a considerable following on my social media platforms and would be more than happy to share a post about this beautiful vase and your other works, directing people to your stall. This could potentially bring your craft to a wider audience. What do you think?\"\n",
      "4.95 Hello there! I absolutely love your work, it's clear you're very talented. I've been searching for a unique, locally made piece of art and your vase really caught my eye. As someone who really values supporting our local artisans, I would be so happy to take this vase home. \n",
      "\n",
      "I have to admit though, the price is a little higher than I was hoping to spend today. However, I really do not want to pass up on owning such an exquisite item. I have quite a large following on my social media platforms and I'd love to post a photo of your beautiful vase and share your name/brand. Maybe we could work out a deal where I help promote your work in exchange for a bit of a discount on the vase? What do you think?\n",
      "30\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# print where it is in the non-3 (4th best)\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('origin_id')\n",
    "\n",
    "scores = []\n",
    "texts = []\n",
    "for origin_id in grouped.groups.keys():\n",
    "    df_tmp2 = grouped.get_group(origin_id)\n",
    "    scores.append(df_tmp2['answer'].mean())\n",
    "    texts.append(df_tmp2.iloc[0]['text'])\n",
    "\n",
    "order = np.argsort(scores)[::-1]\n",
    "for i in order:\n",
    "    print(scores[i], texts[i])\n",
    "print(len(order))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 295,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "5.633333333333333\n",
      "5.946666666666666\n",
      "0.4279436907691662\n",
      "-0.7321835561360015\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# ABLATION AGAINST AVERAGE GENERATION SCORES -- ADVICE\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] == best_advice_index]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(grouped.mean())\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all advice\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "grouped_advice = df_tmp.groupby('advice_indices')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(grouped_advice.mean())\n",
    "print(np.std(grouped_advice, ddof=1))\n",
    "\n",
    "# num std devs higher\n",
    "print((grouped.mean() - grouped_advice.mean()) / np.std(grouped_advice, ddof=1))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 298,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "6.566666666666666\n",
      "6.202777777777778\n",
      "0.3097340555786289\n",
      "1.174843005910635\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# ABLATION AGAINST AVERAGE GENERATION SCORES -- ADVICE WITHOUT SOCIAL MEDIA\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] == \"1_2\"]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(grouped.mean())\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all advice\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '0_3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '1_3']\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] != '2_3']\n",
    "grouped_advice = df_tmp.groupby('advice_indices')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(grouped_advice.mean())\n",
    "print(np.std(grouped_advice, ddof=1))\n",
    "\n",
    "# num std devs higher\n",
    "print((grouped.mean() - grouped_advice.mean()) / np.std(grouped_advice, ddof=1))"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 297,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [
    {
     "name": "stdout",
     "output_type": "stream",
     "text": [
      "mean scores for best framework response 5.85\n",
      "mean scores for baseline_ask 4.683333333333334\n",
      "mean scores for baseline_ask_with_reasoning 5.983333333333333\n",
      "mean scores for baseline_neutral_advice 5.002777777777778\n",
      "todo: run the framework on this\n",
      "mean scores for baseline_irrelevant_advice 3.980555555555555\n",
      "todo: run the framework on this\n"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "source": [
    "# COMPARISONS AGAINST BASELINES\n",
    "\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"unorthodox_advice\"]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['advice_indices'] == best_generation_advice]\n",
    "df_tmp = df_tmp[df_tmp['generation_index'] == best_generation_index]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(\"mean scores for best framework response\", grouped.mean())\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all baseline_ask\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"baseline_ask\"]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(\"mean scores for baseline_ask\", grouped.mean())\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all baseline_ask_with_reasoning\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"baseline_ask_with_reasoning\"]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(\"mean scores for baseline_ask_with_reasoning\", grouped.mean())\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all baseline_neutral_advice\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"baseline_neutral_advice\"]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(\"mean scores for baseline_neutral_advice\", grouped.mean())\n",
    "print(\"todo: run the framework on this\")\n",
    "\n",
    "# average of all baseline_irrelevant_advice\n",
    "df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == \"baseline_irrelevant_advice\"]\n",
    "grouped = df_tmp.groupby('text')['answer'].mean()\n",
    "print(\"mean scores for baseline_irrelevant_advice\", grouped.mean())\n",
    "print(\"todo: run the framework on this\")\n"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 110,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "from utils import remap\n",
    "\n",
    "remap(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/artisan/mappings\")\n",
    "with open(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/artisan/mappings_remapped.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "    remapping = json.load(f)[0]"
   ]
  },
  {
   "cell_type": "code",
   "execution_count": 111,
   "metadata": {},
   "outputs": [],
   "source": [
    "# A. analysis on large differences\n",
    "import os\n",
    "import re\n",
    "import random\n",
    "\n",
    "def get_large_differences(df):\n",
    "    \n",
    "    evaluator = \"artisan\"\n",
    "    with open(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}/mappings_remapped.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "        remapping = json.load(f)[0]\n",
    "\n",
    "    diff_threshold = 5\n",
    "    df_tmp = df[df['advice_type'] == 'unorthodox_advice']\n",
    "    grouped = df_tmp.groupby('participant_id')[['answer', 'advice_indices', 'generation_index']]\n",
    "    participant_ids = sorted(list(grouped.groups.keys()))\n",
    "    l = []\n",
    "\n",
    "    for i in range(len(grouped)):\n",
    "        participant_id = participant_ids[i]\n",
    "        participant_df = grouped.get_group(participant_id)\n",
    "\n",
    "        for j in range(len(participant_df)):\n",
    "            score = participant_df.iloc[j]['answer']\n",
    "\n",
    "            for k in range(j+1, len(participant_df)):\n",
    "                score2 = participant_df.iloc[k]['answer']\n",
    "\n",
    "                if abs(score - score2) >= diff_threshold:\n",
    "                    advice_indices1 = participant_df.iloc[j]['advice_indices']\n",
    "                    advice_indices2 = participant_df.iloc[k]['advice_indices']\n",
    "                    generation_index1 = int(participant_df.iloc[j]['generation_index'])\n",
    "                    generation_index2 = int(participant_df.iloc[k]['generation_index'])\n",
    "\n",
    "                    if advice_indices1 == \"nan\" or advice_indices2 == \"nan\":\n",
    "                        continue\n",
    "\n",
    "                    compare_index1 = int(remapping[f\"{advice_indices1}.json\"])\n",
    "                    compare_index2 = int(remapping[f\"{advice_indices2}.json\"])\n",
    "\n",
    "                    # print(f\"{advice_indices1}, generation {generation_index1}, score {score}\")\n",
    "                    # print(f\"{advice_indices2}, generation {generation_index2}, score {score2}\")\n",
    "\n",
    "                    if compare_index1 > compare_index2 or (compare_index1 == compare_index2 and generation_index1 > generation_index2):\n",
    "                        compare_index1, compare_index2 = compare_index2, compare_index1\n",
    "                        advice_indices1, advice_indices2 = advice_indices2, advice_indices1\n",
    "                        generation_index1, generation_index2 = generation_index2, generation_index1\n",
    "                        score, score2 = score2, score\n",
    "\n",
    "                    print(f\"participant {participant_id} has a large difference:\")\n",
    "                    print(f\"{advice_indices1}, generation {generation_index1}, score {score}\")\n",
    "                    print(f\"{advice_indices2}, generation {generation_index2}, score {score2}\")\n",
    "\n",
    "                    d = {}\n",
    "                    d[\"participant_id\"] = participant_id\n",
    "                    d[\"advice_indices1\"] = advice_indices1\n",
    "                    d[\"advice_indices2\"] = advice_indices2\n",
    "                    d[\"generation_index1\"] = generation_index1\n",
    "                    d[\"generation_index2\"] = generation_index2\n",
    "                    d[\"score1\"] = score\n",
    "                    d[\"score2\"] = score2\n",
    "\n",
    "                    for evaluator in os.listdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators\"):\n",
    "                        if os.path.isdir(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}\"):\n",
    "                            with open(f\"{scenario}/evaluators/{evaluator}/compare_results/{compare_index1}_{compare_index2}_{generation_index1}_{generation_index2}.json\", \"r\") as f:\n",
    "                                compare_result = json.load(f)\n",
    "                            \n",
    "                            scenario_options_text = compare_result[\"user_prompt\"][\"content\"]\n",
    "                            scenario_options_text = re.sub(r'Please think step by step and explain your reasoning.*', '', scenario_options_text, flags=re.DOTALL)\n",
    "                            scores = compare_result[\"parsed_answers\"]\n",
    "                            reasoning_text = compare_result[\"responses\"]\n",
    "\n",
    "                            if \"evaluator\" in d:\n",
    "                                d[\"evaluator\"] += [evaluator]\n",
    "                                d[\"flipped\"] += [compare_result[\"flipped\"]]\n",
    "                                d[\"scenario_options_text_2\"] = scenario_options_text\n",
    "                                d[\"scores\"] += [scores]\n",
    "                                d[\"reasoning_text_4\"] = reasoning_text[0]\n",
    "                                d[\"reasoning_text_5\"] = reasoning_text[1]\n",
    "                                d[\"reasoning_text_6\"] = reasoning_text[2]\n",
    "                            else:\n",
    "                                d[\"evaluator\"] = [evaluator]\n",
    "                                d[\"flipped\"] = [compare_result[\"flipped\"]]\n",
    "                                d[\"scenario_options_text_1\"] = scenario_options_text\n",
    "                                d[\"scores\"] = [scores]\n",
    "                                d[\"reasoning_text_1\"] = reasoning_text[0]\n",
    "                                d[\"reasoning_text_2\"] = reasoning_text[1]\n",
    "                                d[\"reasoning_text_3\"] = reasoning_text[2]\n",
    "                            \n",
    "\n",
    "                            print(f\"Evaluator: {evaluator}:\")\n",
    "                            print(f\"Flipped: {compare_result['flipped']}\")\n",
    "                            print(f\"Scenarios: {scenario_options_text}\\n\\n\")\n",
    "                            print(f\"SCORES: 1 -> first one better, 0 -> second one better (these are affected by flipped): {scores}\\n\")\n",
    "                            print(f\"Model Reasoning (these are also affected by flipped): \\n{reasoning_text}\\n\\n\\n\")\n",
    "\n",
    "                    l.append(d)\n",
    "\n",
    "    random.seed(0)\n",
    "    random_selection = random.sample(l, 10)\n",
    "    # save as csv\n",
    "    import csv\n",
    "    with open(f\"{scenario}/large_differences.csv\", \"w\") as f:\n",
    "        writer = csv.DictWriter(f, fieldnames= \\\n",
    "                                [\"participant_id\", \"advice_indices1\", \"advice_indices2\", \"generation_index1\", \"generation_index2\", \\\n",
    "                                \"score1\", \"score2\", \"evaluator\", \"flipped\", \"scenario_options_text_1\", \"scenario_options_text_2\", \\\n",
    "                                \"scores\", \"reasoning_text_1\", \"reasoning_text_2\", \"reasoning_text_3\", \"reasoning_text_4\", \"reasoning_text_5\", \"reasoning_text_6\"])\n",
    "        writer.writeheader()\n",
    "        for d in random_selection:\n",
    "            writer.writerow(d)\n"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "metadata": {
  "kernelspec": {
   "display_name": "Python 3 (ipykernel)",
   "language": "python",
   "name": "python3"
  },
  "language_info": {
   "codemirror_mode": {
    "name": "ipython",
    "version": 3
   },
   "file_extension": ".py",
   "mimetype": "text/x-python",
   "name": "python",
   "nbconvert_exporter": "python",
   "pygments_lexer": "ipython3",
   "version": "3.9.4"
  },
  "orig_nbformat": 4
 },
 "nbformat": 4,
 "nbformat_minor": 2
}
