                 initial model &                        dataset &                    gemma-7b-it &            Llama-2-13b-chat-hf &            Llama-2-70b-chat-hf &     Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1 &               Qwen1.5-14B-Chat &               Qwen1.5-72B-Chat &             gpt-3.5-turbo-0125 &             gemini-1.0-pro-001 &         claude-3-opus-20240229 &                     gpt-4-0613 &             gpt-4-0125-preview &                         random &                          human  \\
                               &     \scalebox{0.9}[1]{MathGen} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{50.0} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} &                           62.1 &                           60.7 &                           66.4 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} &                           63.6 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{46.4} &                           60.7 &                  \textbf{72.1} &                           72.1 &                           50.5 &                           88.2  \\
                               &     \scalebox{0.9}[1]{FgFactV} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{48.6} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{42.9} &                           55.7 &                  \textbf{60.0} &                           55.0 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{47.9} &                           50.7 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{47.9} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} &                           50.7 &                           94.3  \\
                               &      \scalebox{0.9}[1]{AnsCls} &                           53.6 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{50.0} &                           53.6 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} &                  \textbf{56.4} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{44.3} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{47.1} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{50.7} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{50.0} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{49.3} &                           51.2 &                           82.9  \\
                               &     \scalebox{0.9}[1]{MathGen} &                           66.2 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{31.2} &                           78.1 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{59.4} &                           68.8 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{40.6} &                           73.1 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{43.1} &                           73.8 &                  \textbf{84.4} &                           83.1 &                           62.5 &                           97.1  \\
                               &     \scalebox{0.9}[1]{FgFactV} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{60.6} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{54.4} &                           70.6 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{51.9} &                  \textbf{78.8} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{29.4} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{35.6} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{29.4} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{34.4} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{46.2} &                           68.8 &                           66.5 &                          100.0  \\
                               &      \scalebox{0.9}[1]{AnsCls} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{37.5} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{45.0} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{35.0} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{34.4} &                           66.9 & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{23.1} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{23.8} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{24.4} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{33.1} & \cellcolor[RGB]{211,211,211}{60.0} &                  \textbf{75.0} &                           65.1 &                           97.1  \\
