Based on prior knowledge, the relationship between BMI and the likelihood of having diabetes can be analyzed as follows:

1. Yes (have diabetes): It is known that obesity is a major risk factor for developing diabetes. Therefore, it is expected that individuals with higher BMI values are more likely to have diabetes.

2. No (do not have diabetes): Lower BMI values are generally associated with a lower risk of diabetes. Therefore, it is expected that individuals with lower BMI values are less likely to have diabetes.

Based on this analysis, the dictionary can be generated as follows:

```json
{
	"yes": [31.5, 35.2, 37.9, 40.6, 43.8],
	"no": [18.2, 21.7, 24.9, 27.4, 29.8]
}
```

Please note that the specific BMI values provided in the dictionary are just examples and may not represent the actual ranges in the dataset.