Impossible Shaded Images.

Berthold K. P. Horn, Richard Szeliski, Alan L. Yuille

Abstract: It is shown that shaded images that cannot have originated from a uniformly illuminated, smooth continuous surface with uniform albedo exist. The typical condition where this occurs is when a dark area (corresponding to a region of high gradient) is surrounded by a lighter region (with low gradient). For this to correspond to a real surface, it must be established that there is a local extremum or area of lower gradient inside the dark region. This, in turn, will show up as either a light area in the image or an orientation discontinuity in the surface (thus violating either intensity or smoothness constraints). The impossibility of a shaded image can be established by counting the number of extrema inside a region corresponding to an isolated surface patch.<