Subspace Exploration: Bounds on Projected Frequency Estimation

Graham Cormode, Charlie Dickens, David P. Woodruff

Abstract: Given an $n \times d$ dimensional dataset A, a projection query specifies a subset $C \subseteq [d]$ of columns which yields a new $n \times |C|$ array. We study the space complexity of computing data analysis functions over such subspaces, including heavy hitters and norms, when the subspaces are revealed only after observing the data. We show that this important class of problems is typically hard: for many problems, we show $2^Ømega(d) $ lower bounds. However, we present upper bounds which demonstrate space dependency better than $2^d$. That is, for $c,c' \in (0,1)$ and a parameter $N=2^d$ an $N^c$-approximation can be obtained in space $\min(N^c', n)$, showing that it is possible to improve on the naï ve approach of keeping information for all $2^d$ subsets of d columns. Our results are based on careful constructions of instances using coding theory and novel combinatorial reductions that exhibit such space-approximation tradeoffs.