IsnadGuard: Detecting Fabricated Chains of Narration in Hadith Transmission Networks

Ghaleb Aldoboni, Mohammed Talha Alam, Lobna Nassar, Fakhri Karray

Keywords: Hadith authentication, Isnad analysis, Graph machine learning, Anomaly detection, Multiple-instance learning

Abstract: The isnad is the ordered chain of narrators through whom a hadith is transmitted. Hadith science has robust methodologies for evaluating reports based on narrator reliability and chain continuity. However, computational work has largely treated authenticity assessment as text classification over the report content, or matn. We study a focused task: detecting and localizing fabricated chains from narrator-transmission structure alone. Using Sanadset 650K, we construct a directed narrator graph and generate corruptions grounded in classical defect typologies: narrator substitution (tas-heef fi al-isnad) and chain splicing (idraj al-sanad). We propose IsnadGuard, a multiple-instance graph model that scores each transition using local statistics and narrator embeddings, aggregates transition scores with noisy-OR, and is trained jointly for chain classification, contrastive ranking, and edge localization. On 43,539 held-out chains, IsnadGuard improves AUROC from 0.727 to 0.836 and Hit@2 from 0.838 to 0.916 over an edge-frequency baseline.

Track: Track 1: ML Research Addressing Challenges Faced by Muslim Communities

Email Sharing: We authorize the sharing of all author emails with Program Chairs.

Data Release: We authorize the release of our submission and author names to the public in the event of acceptance.

Non Archival Confirmation: I understand that submissions to MusIML are non-archival and can be submitted to other venues.

Submission Number: 42