ImageNet suffers from dichotomous data difficultyDownload PDF

Sep 28, 2021 (edited Nov 21, 2021)NeurIPS 2021 Workshop ImageNet PPF Blind SubmissionReaders: Everyone
  • Keywords: ImageNet, CNNs, Cognitive Science, Vision Science, Psychophysics, Neuroscience, Visual perception, Inductive bias, CIFAR, Representation similarity analysis, Error consistency, Datasets
  • TL;DR: All CNNs make similar decisions, since data difficulty is dichotomous
  • Abstract: "The power of a generalization system follows directly from its biases" (Mitchell 1980). Today, CNNs are incredibly powerful generalisation systems---but to what degree have we understood how their inductive bias influences model decisions? We here attempt to disentangle the various aspects that determine how a model decides. In particular, we ask: what makes one model decide differently from another? In a meticulously controlled setting, we find that (1.) irrespective of the network architecture or objective (e.g. self-supervised, semi-supervised, vision transformers, recurrent models) all models end up with a similar decision boundary. (2.) To understand these findings, we analysed model decisions on the ImageNet validation set from epoch to epoch and image by image. We find that the ImageNet validation set suffers from dichotomous data difficulty (DDD): For the range of investigated models and their accuracies, it is dominated by 46.3% "trivial" and 11.3% "impossible" images. Only 42.4% of the images are responsible for the differences between two models' decision boundaries. The impossible images are not driven by label errors. (3.) Finally, humans are highly accurate at predicting which images are "trivial" and "impossible" for CNNs (81.4%). Taken together, it appears that ImageNet suffers from dichotomous data difficulty. This implies that in future comparisons of brains, machines and behaviour, much may be gained from investigating the decisive role of images and the distribution of their difficulties.
  • Submission Track: Main track, 5 pages max
  • Supplementary Materials: zip
  • Poster: pdf
1 Reply