Program Integration for Languages with Procedure Calls

David W. Binkley, Susan Horwitz, Thomas W. Reps

Abstract: Given a program Base and two variants, A and B, each created by modifying separate copies of Base, the goal of program integration is to determine whether the modifications interfere, and if they do not, to create an integrated program that incorporates both sets of changes as well as the portions of Base preserved in both variants. Text-based integration techniques, such as the one used by the Unix diff3 utility, are obviously unsatisfactory because one has no guarantees about how the execution behavior of the integrated program relates to the behaviors of Base, A, and B. The first program integration algorithm to provide such guarantees was developed by Horwitz, Prins, and Reps. However, a limitation of that algorithm is that it only applied to programs written in a restricted language—in particular, the algorithm does not handle programs with procedures. This article describes a generalization of the Horwitz-Prins-Reps algorithm that handles programs that consist of multiple (and possibly mutually recursive) procedures. We show that two straightforward generalizations of the Horwitz-Prins-Reps algorithm yield unsatisfactory results. The key issue in developing a satisfactory algorithm is how to take into account different calling contexts when determining what has changed in the variants A and B. Our solution to this problem involves identifying two different kinds of affected components of A and B: those affected regardless of how the procedure is called, and those affected by a changed or new calling context. The algorithm makes use of interprocedural program slicing to identify these components, as well as components in Base, A, and B with the same behavior.