On the Limitation of Diffusion Models for Synthesizing Training Datasets

Published: 30 Oct 2023, Last Modified: 30 Nov 2023SyntheticData4ML 2023 PosterEveryoneRevisionsBibTeX
Keywords: synthetic data for machine learning, generative models, diffusion models, empirical analysis
TL;DR: We empirically found that modern diffusion models could not perfectly replicate training dataset due to its sampling process.
Abstract: Synthetic samples from diffusion models are promising for leveraging in training discriminative models as replications of real training datasets. However, we found that the synthetic datasets degrade classification performance over real datasets even when using state-of-the-art diffusion models. This means that modern diffusion models do not perfectly represent the data distribution for the purpose of replicating datasets for training discriminative tasks. This paper investigates the gap between synthetic and real samples by analyzing the synthetic samples reconstructed from real samples through the diffusion and reverse process. By varying the time steps starting the reverse process in the reconstruction, we can control the trade-off between the information in the original real data and the information added by diffusion models. Through assessing the reconstructed samples and trained models, we found that the synthetic data are concentrated in modes of the training data distribution as the reverse step increases, and thus, they are difficult to cover the outer edges of the distribution. Our findings imply that modern diffusion models are insufficient to replicate training data distribution perfectly, and there is room for the improvement of generative modeling in the replication of training datasets.
Submission Number: 11