What Matters for Model Merging at Scale?

TMLR Paper4194 Authors

Abstract: Model merging aims to combine multiple expert models into a more capable single model, offering benefits such as reduced storage and serving costs, improved generalization, and support for decentralized model development. Despite its promise, previous studies have primarily focused on merging a few small models. This leaves many unanswered questions about the effect of scaling model size and how it interplays with other key factors—like the base model quality and number of expert models—, to affect the merged model’s performance. This work systematically evaluates the utility of model merging at scale, examining the impact of these different factors. We experiment with merging fully fine-tuned models using four popular merging methods—Averaging, Task Arithmetic, Dare-TIES, and TIESMerging across model sizes ranging from 1B to 64B parameters and merging up to 8 different expert models. We evaluate the merged models on both held-in tasks, i.e., the expert’s training tasks, and zero-shot generalization to unseen held-out tasks. Our wide range of experiments provide several new insights about model merging at scale and the interplay between different factors. First, we find that merging is more effective when experts are created from strong base models, i.e., models with good zero-shot performance, compared to pre-trained ones. Second, larger models facilitate easier merging. Third merging consistently improves generalization capabilities. Notably, when merging eight large expert models, the merged models often generalize better compared to the multitask trained models. Fourth, we can better merge more expert models when working with larger models. Fifth, different merging methods behave very similarly at larger scales. Overall, our findings shed light on some interesting properties of model merging while also highlighting some limitations. We hope that this study will serve as a reference point on large-scale merging.

Submission Length: Regular submission (no more than 12 pages of main content)

Assigned Action Editor: Yen-Chang Hsu

Submission Number: 4194