Position: Robust AI Personalization Will Require a Human Context Protocol

Anand V. Shah, Tobin South, Talfan Evans, Hannah Rose Kirk, Jiaxin Pei, Andrew Trask, E. Glen Weyl, Michiel A. Bakker

TL;DR: This paper argues for portable, user-mediated infrastructure for AI personalization motivated by concerns over user lock-in and disempowerment, and discusses system design and tradeoffs to provoke debate.

Abstract: Personalization underpins the modern digital economy. Today, personalization is largely implemented through provider-managed infrastructure that infers user preferences from behavioral data, with limited portability or user control. However, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used to perform tasks on users' behalf. The age of LLMs for the first time provides a path to a more controllable and interpretable personalization paradigm, grounded in user-expressed natural language preferences and context. In this position paper, we argue that to provide robust and user-centric personalization, we need a new Human Context Protocol (HCP) to represent and share personal preferences across AI systems. HCP treats preferences as a portable, user-governed layer in the personalization stack, enabling interoperability, scoped access, and revocation. Along with a working prototype to ground discussion, we consider counterarguments along adoption dynamics and market incentives, high-stakes use cases, and outline novel paths via the HCP towards trustworthy personalization in the human-AI economy.

Lay Summary: Personalization underpins the modern digital economy. Today, personalization is largely implemented through provider-managed infrastructure that infers user preferences from behavioral data, with limited portability or user control. However, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used to perform tasks on users' behalf. The age of LLMs for the first time provides a path to a more controllable and interpretable personalization paradigm, grounded in user-expressed natural language preferences and context. In this position paper, we argue that to provide robust and user-centric personalization, we need a new Human Context Protocol (HCP) to represent and share personal preferences across AI systems. HCP treats preferences as a portable, user-governed layer in the personalization stack, enabling interoperability, scoped access, and revocation. Along with a working prototype to ground discussion, we consider counterarguments along adoption dynamics and market incentives, high-stakes use cases, and outline novel paths via the HCP towards trustworthy personalization in the human-AI economy.

Link To Code: https://github.com/avshah1/hcp-demo

Primary Area: System Risks, Safety, and Government Policy

Keywords: personalization, infrastructure design, data property rights, market design

Submission Number: 462