Deconfounding Scores and Representation Learning for Causal Effect Estimation with Weak Overlap

Oscar Clivio, Alexander Nicholas D'Amour, Alexander Franks, David Bruns-Smith, Christopher C. Holmes, Avi Feller

Abstract: Overlap, also known as positivity, is a key condition for causal treatment effect estimation. Many popular estimators suffer from high variance and become brittle when features differ strongly across treatment groups. This is especially challenging in high dimensions: the curse of dimensionality can make overlap implausible. To address this, we propose a class of feature representations called deconfounding scores, which preserve both identification and the target of estimation; the classical propensity and prognostic scores are two special cases. We characterize the problem of finding a representation with better overlap as minimizing an overlap divergence under a deconfounding score constraint. We then derive closed-form expressions for a class of deconfounding scores under a broad family of generalized linear models with Gaussian features and show that prognostic scores are overlap-optimal within this class. We conduct extensive experiments to assess this behavior empirically.

Code Dataset Promise: Yes

Code Dataset Url: https://github.com/oscarclivio/deconfounding_scores_paper

Format Confirmation: I agree that I have read and followed the formatting instructions for the camera ready version.

Submission Number: 578