Understanding and Mitigating Tokenization Bias in Language Models

Buu Phan, Marton Havasi, Matthew J. Muckley, Karen Ullrich

Keywords: Tokenization, Token-free Model, Statistical Analysis, Sampling Bias

TL;DR: We point out that tokenization induces sampling bias and show a method to correct that bias. This shows that tokenized model implicitly learns character information during training.

Abstract: State-of-the-art language models are autoregressive and operate on subword units known as tokens. Specifically, one must encode the conditioning string into a list of tokens before passing to the language models for next-token prediction. We show that popular encoding schemes, such as maximum prefix encoding (MPE) and byte-pair-encoding (BPE), induce a sampling bias that cannot be mitigated with more training or data. To counter this universal problem, for each encoding scheme above, we propose a novel algorithm to obtain unbiased estimates from any language model trained on tokenized data. Our methods do not require finetuning the model, and the complexity, defined as the number of model runs, scales linearly with the sequence length in the case of MPE. As a result, we show that one can simulate token-free behavior from a tokenized language model. We empirically verify the correctness of our method through a Markov-chain setup, where it accurately recovers the transition probabilities, as opposed to the conventional method of directly prompting tokens into the language model.

Submission Number: 40