Learning Decouples Accuracy and Reaction Time for Rapid Decisions in a Transitive Inference Task

Fabian Munoz Silva, Greg Jensen, Maxim Shinn, Yelda Alkan, John D Murray, Herbert S. Terrace, Vincent P. Ferrera

Abstract: Transitive inference (TI) is a cognitive process in which decisions are guided by internal representations of abstract relationships. Although the mechanisms underlying transitive learning have been well studied, the dynamics of the decision-making process during learning and inference remain less clearly understood. In this study, we investigated whether a modeling framework traditionally applied to perceptual decision-making—the drift diffusion model (DDM)—can account for performance in a TI transfer task involving rapid decisions that deviate from standard accuracy and response time (RT) patterns. We trained six macaque monkeys on a TI transfer task, in which they learned the implied order of a novel list of seven images in each behavioral session, indicating their decisions with saccadic eye movements or reaching movements. Consistent learning of the list structure was achieved within 200–300 trials per session. Behavioral performance exhibited a symbolic distance effect, with accuracy increasing as the ordinal distance between items grew. Notably, RTs remained relatively stable across learning, despite improvements in accuracy. We applied a generalized DDM implementation (PyDDM) [Shinn, M., Lam, N. H., & Murray, J. D. A flexible framework for simulating and fitting generalized drift-diffusion models. eLife, 9, e56938, 2020] to jointly fit accuracy and RT data. Model fits were achieved by incorporating both an increasing evidence accumulation rate and a collapsing decision bound, successfully capturing the RT distribution shapes observed during learning. Learning and transfer were fit by varying drift rate with little change in other parameters. Eye and reaching movements showed similar dynamics, with the difference in RT accounted for mainly by nondecision time. Our results highlight a distinct dynamical regime of the DDM framework, extending its applicability to cognitive domains involving symbolic reasoning and serial relational learning.