Fine-Tuning can Distort Pretrained Features and Underperform Out-of-DistributionDownload PDF

29 Sept 2021, 00:33 (edited 16 Mar 2022)ICLR 2022 OralReaders: Everyone
  • Keywords: fine-tuning theory, transfer learning theory, fine-tuning, distribution shift, implicit regularization
  • Abstract: When transferring a pretrained model to a downstream task, two popular methods are full fine-tuning (updating all the model parameters) and linear probing (updating only the last linear layer---the "head"). It is well known that fine-tuning leads to better accuracy in-distribution (ID). However, in this paper, we find that fine-tuning can achieve worse accuracy than linear probing out-of-distribution (OOD) when the pretrained features are good and the distribution shift is large. On 10 distribution shift datasets (BREEDS-Living17, BREEDS-Entity30, DomainNet, CIFAR $\to$ STL, CIFAR-10.1, FMoW, ImageNetV2, ImageNet-R, ImageNet-A, ImageNet-Sketch), fine-tuning obtains on average 2% higher accuracy ID but 7% lower accuracy OOD than linear probing. We show theoretically that this tradeoff between ID and OOD accuracy arises even in a simple setting: fine-tuning overparameterized two-layer linear networks. We prove that the OOD error of fine-tuning is high when we initialize with a fixed or random head---this is because while fine-tuning learns the head, the lower layers of the neural network change simultaneously and distort the pretrained features. Our analysis suggests that the easy two-step strategy of linear probing then full fine-tuning (LP-FT), sometimes used as a fine-tuning heuristic, combines the benefits of both fine-tuning and linear probing. Empirically, LP-FT outperforms both fine-tuning and linear probing on the above datasets (1% better ID, 10% better OOD than full fine-tuning).
  • One-sentence Summary: Fine-tuning does better than linear probing (training a linear classifier on pretrained features) in-distribution, but worse out-of-distribution (OOD)---we analyze why this happens and propose a way to get the benefits of both.
  • Supplementary Material: zip
21 Replies

Loading