Evaluation of Defogging: A Real-World Benchmark Dataset, A New Criterion and Baselines

Shiyu Zhao, Lin Zhang, Shuaiyi Huang, Ying Shen, Shengjie Zhao, Yukai Yang

Abstract: Modern defogging methods are able to achieve very comparable results whose differences are too subtle for people to qualitatively judge. On the other hand, existing quantitative evaluation methods are also not convincing due to a lack of proper datasets. In this work, we attempt to address these issues and establish a long-term lacking benchmark dataset, namely BeDDE (BEnchmark Dataset for Defogging Evaluation), for evaluating the performance of defogging algorithms. To our knowledge, BeDDE is the first real-world dataset comprising foggy images with their registered clear counterparts. Using BeDDE, we set up a new criterion for evaluating defogging methods where VSI, a full reference image quality assessment metric, is calculated and averaged on registered ROIs of all image pairs. The evaluation results of the proposed criterion correlate well with human judgements. 10 state-of-the-art defogging methods are evaluated as baselines on BeDDE. BeDDE is available online.