Same Cause; Different Effects in the Brain

Mariya Toneva, Jennifer Williams, Anand Bollu, Christoph Dann, Leila Wehbe

Keywords: encoding models, interpretability, neuroscience, fMRI, regression, neurolinguistics

TL;DR: Encoding models are a popular tool that reveals which brain zones are affected by the properties of a stimulus, but are these zones affected in the same way?

Abstract:

To study information processing in the brain, neuroscientists manipulate experimental stimuli while recording participant brain activity. They can then use encoding models to find out which brain "zone" (e.g. which region of interest, volume pixel or electrophysiology sensor) is predicted from the stimulus properties. Given the assumptions underlying this setup, when stimulus properties are predictive of the activity in a zone, these properties are understood to cause activity in that zone.

In recent years, researchers have used neural networks to construct representations that capture the diverse properties of complex stimuli, such as natural language or natural images. Encoding models built using these high-dimensional representations are often able to significantly predict the activity in large swathes of cortex, suggesting that the activity in all these brain zones is caused by stimulus properties captured in the representation. It is then natural to ask: "Is the activity in these different brain zones caused by the stimulus properties in the same way?" In neuroscientific terms, this corresponds to asking if these different zones process the stimulus properties in the same way.

Here, we propose a new framework that enables researchers to ask if the properties of a stimulus affect two brain zones in the same way. We use simulated data and two real fMRI datasets with complex naturalistic stimuli to show that our framework enables us to make such inferences. Our inferences are strikingly consistent between the two datasets, indicating that the proposed framework is a promising new tool for neuroscientists to understand how information is processed in the brain.

Community Implementations: [ 1 code implementation](https://www.catalyzex.com/paper/same-cause-different-effects-in-the-brain/code)