Evaluation of Architectures for Mobile Robotics

Anders Orebäck, Henrik I. Christensen

Abstract: In this paper we make a comparative study of some successful software architectures for mobile robot systems. The objective is to gather experience for the future design of a new robot architecture. Three architectures are studied more closely, Saphira, TeamBots and BERRA. Qualities such as portability, ease of use, software characteristics, programming and run-time efficiency are evaluated. In order to get a true hands-on evaluation, all the architectures are implemented on a common hardware robot platform. A simple reference application is made with each of these systems. All the steps necessary to achieve this are discussed and compared. Run-time data are also gathered. Conclusions regarding the results are made, and a sketch for a new architecture is made based on these results.