Efficient Lower Bounding of Single Transferable Vote Election Margins

Michelle L. Blom, Alexander Ek, Peter J. Stuckey, Vanessa Teague, Damjan Vukcevic

Abstract: The single transferable vote (STV) is a system of preferential proportional voting employed in multi-seat elections. Each ballot cast by a voter is a (potentially partial) ranking over a set of candidates. The margin of victory, or simply margin, is the smallest number of ballots that, if manipulated (e.g., their rankings changed, or ballots being deleted or added), can alter the set of winners. Knowledge of the margin of an election gives greater insight into both how much time and money should be spent on auditing the election, and whether uncovered mistakes (such as ballot box losses) throw the election result into doubt -- requiring a costly repeat election -- or can be safely ignored. Lower bounds on the margin can also be used for this purpose, in cases where exact margins are difficult to compute. There is one existing approach to computing lower bounds on the margin of STV elections, while there are multiple approaches to finding upper bounds. In this paper, we present improvements to this existing lower bound computation method for STV margins. In many cases the improvements compute tighter (higher) lower bounds as well as making the computation of lower bounds more computationally efficient. For small elections, in conjunction with existing upper bounding approaches, the new algorithms are able to compute exact margins of victory.