How to Fix a Broken Confidence Estimator: Evaluating Post-hoc Methods for Selective Classification with Deep Neural Networks

Luís Felipe Prates Cattelan, Danilo Silva

Keywords: Selective classification, deep learning, uncertainty estimation, failure prediction, misclassification detection, reject option, neural networks, distribution shift

TL;DR: For many neural network classifiers, the softmax response exhibits poor performance at selective classification, but simple post-hoc methods can fix this issue.

Abstract: This paper addresses the problem of selective classification for deep neural networks, where a model is allowed to abstain from low-confidence predictions to avoid potential errors. We focus on so-called post-hoc methods, which replace the confidence estimator of a given classifier without modifying or retraining it, thus being practically appealing. Considering neural networks with softmax outputs, our goal is to identify the best confidence estimator that can be computed directly from the unnormalized logits. This problem is motivated by the intriguing observation in recent work that many classifiers appear to have a ``broken'' confidence estimator, in the sense that their selective classification performance is much worse than what could be expected by their corresponding accuracies. We perform an extensive experimental study of many existing and proposed confidence estimators applied to 84 pretrained ImageNet classifiers available from popular repositories. Our results show that a simple $p$-norm normalization of the logits, followed by taking the maximum logit as the confidence estimator, can lead to considerable gains in selective classification performance, completely fixing the pathological behavior observed in many classifiers. As a consequence, the selective classification performance of any classifier becomes almost entirely determined by its corresponding accuracy. Moreover, these results are shown to be consistent under distribution shift.

List Of Authors: Cattelan, Luis Felipe and Silva, Danilo

Code Url: https://github.com/lfpc/FixSelectiveClassification

Submission Number: 184