Toward Democracy Levels for AI

Published: 10 Oct 2024, Last Modified: 15 Nov 2024Pluralistic-Alignment 2024EveryoneRevisionsBibTeXCC BY 4.0
Keywords: democratic AI, pluralistic AI, public AI, collective alignment, pluralistic alignment
TL;DR: A framework for evaluating the degree to which decisions about the development, alignment and governance of AI are made democratically.
Abstract: There is increasing concern about the unilateral power of the organizations involved in the development, alignment, and governance of AI. Recent pilots — such as Meta’s *Community Forums* and Anthropic’s *Collective Constitutional AI* — have illustrated a promising direction, where democratic processes might be used to meaningfully improve public involvement and trust in critical decisions. However, there is no standard framework for evaluating such processes. In this paper, building on insights from the theory and practice of deliberative democracy, we provide a “Democracy Levels” framework for evaluating the degree to which decisions in a given domain are made democratically. The framework can be used (i) to define milestones in a roadmap for the democratic AI, pluralistic AI, and public AI ecosystems, (ii) to guide organizations that need to increase the legitimacy of their decisions on difficult AI governance questions, and (iii) as a rubric by those aiming to evaluate AI organizations and keep them accountable.
Submission Number: 41
Loading