Gatekeeper: Improving Model Cascades Through Confidence Tuning

Stephan Rabanser, Nathalie Rauschmayr, Achin Kulshrestha, Petra Poklukar, Wittawat Jitkrittum, Sean Augenstein, Congchao Wang, Federico Tombari

Keywords: cascading, deferral, selective prediction, confidence tuning

TL;DR: We introduce Gatekeeper, a novel loss function that calibrates smaller models in cascade setups to confidently handle easy tasks while deferring complex ones, significantly improving deferral performance across diverse architectures and tasks.

Abstract: Large-scale machine learning models deliver strong performance across a wide range of tasks but come with significant computational and resource constraints. To mitigate these challenges, local smaller models are often deployed alongside larger models, relying on routing and deferral mechanisms to offload complex tasks. However, existing approaches inadequately balance the capabilities of these models, often resulting in unnecessary deferrals or sub-optimal resource usage. In this work, we introduce a novel loss function called Gatekeeper for calibrating smaller models in cascade setups. Our approach fine-tunes the smaller model to confidently handle tasks it can perform correctly while deferring complex tasks to the larger model. Moreover, it incorporates a mechanism for managing the trade-off between model performance and deferral accuracy and is broadly applicable across various tasks and domains without any architectural changes. We evaluated our method on encoder-only, decoder-only, and encoder-decoder architectures. Experiments across image classification, language modeling, and vision-language tasks show that our approach substantially improves deferral performance.

Submission Number: 3